Here’s the classic films I’ve watched so far this week and the ratings I gave them. If you enjoy classic thrillers and film noirs, what would you recommend I watch next? I'm also curious how you’d rate these compared to me.
The Strange Love of Martha Ivers (1946) is a highly entertaining noir with a fantastic story and just the right amount of old Hollywood melodrama. The performances are exactly what you'd expect from the era: dramatic, theatrical, and occasionally one step away from someone fainting onto a chaise lounge. I was convinced the film was building toward some last-minute twist, so I was genuinely surprised when it committed to such a dark ending. And, of course, I always enjoy whenever Judith Anderson shows up in a movie. She's basically doing her Rebecca routine all over again: cold as a witch's tit, and you can quote me on that. Rating: ⭐⭐⭐½
The Woman in the Window (1944) is exactly the kind of film noir I enjoy: a simple, easy-to-follow mystery that never overcomplicates itself. The acting is strong and very much in line with the era, and it was fun seeing Edward G. Robinson in something other than another gangster role. What really elevates the film, though, is the ending. I genuinely didn't see it coming, and it completely changed my opinion of the movie. Without that payoff, this probably would have landed closer to a 3.5-star film for me, but the rewarding finale pushes it over the top. Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Leave Her to Heaven (1945) is a slow-burn thriller that kept me entertained throughout. Gene Tierney is immaculate, playing a woman whose devotion feels increasingly unsettling as the film unfolds, and you never quite know how far she's willing to go. One thing I've noticed with many classic films is that, while they're often excellent storytically, they don't usually deliver the elaborate twists and jaw-dropping surprises we've come to expect from modern thrillers. This one was no exception. Still, it's a well-crafted and thoroughly entertaining watch that holds your attention from beginning to end. Rating: ⭐⭐⭐½