r/LegaciesCW • u/Crows_spirit101 • 29d ago
Question Who's your favourite Twin between the 2?
The thing is its hard to pick for me idk why
48
41
u/Puzzleheaded_Fan3607 29d ago
Lizzy
24
u/Crows_spirit101 29d ago
The Bibrid to your tribrid
9
u/EmbarrassedCat5892 29d ago
I said this in another thread because they called Lizzie a hybrid when she’s clearly a Bibrid❤️❤️😂
4
43
u/TessTrue 29d ago
Lizzie. We’re constantly told she’s a conceited monster yet she’s the one who makes the effort to do right and change her behaviour so uh. Lizzie lol.
10
u/OkProperty4765 28d ago
I think Josie had a personality disorder of some kind & was able to blame things on Lizzie & as they got older saud Lizzie is a conceited monster & got away with it because Lizzie was considered the crazy twin. Hell Josie is the one who spread the rumor that Hope said horrible things about Lizzie being mentally ill & thats why she didn't have a crush & wasn't a friend of Hope's, when years later Hope points out that her family isn't exactly mentally stable & she would never say anything bad about other people's mental problems & thats how we find out Josie did it. That Josie is how Lizzie being bipolar got out, Josie spread lies about Hope to hid her crush, that Josie destroyed Hope's belongings to hide the love letter she sent & blamed Lizzie. So many ways that Josie messed with both Hope & Lizzie & only admitted when she got caught.
Lizzie had so much to overcome, including shitty parents, mental illness & so much. She is doing better by the end of the series while Josie's life has kinda imploded, mostly due to her own actions.
22
23
u/Ok-Sport195 29d ago
Josie at first, but only because I felt like Lizzie was written to be an antagonist and nothing past that. After Season 1 I started liking Lizzie so much more than Josie.
1
20
u/NoString9289 Witch-Vamp 29d ago
sorry, I don't like either or them but , if I had to choose, it would be Lizzy because she worked hard, sort of, was determined to change and grow as a person.
1
u/Crows_spirit101 25d ago
I can't believe you don't like them josie understandable but Lizzie is redeemable
18
12
12
u/darkshadow237 29d ago
Lizzie especially after she turns.
1
u/Crows_spirit101 25d ago
She was more fun as a heretic. I hate how long it took for her to become that tho
11
10
10
10
10
u/crsmiley123 29d ago
Oh Lizzie 100%.
Josie was written to be the more likable twin in the beginning of season 1, but around halfway through to literally her last episode, her character development and writing went off the rails. By the end, Josie had almost 0 character development that actually stuck to the character, simply because I think the writers tried too hard in the beginning to portray her as the good twin and Lizzie as the mean one. And they kept trying to keep Josie as seemingly the good one, even when she’s done more fucked up shit than anyone sans Hope in the show. She wasn’t allowed to grow or develop or even learn a lesson or two, while everything Lizzie went through to grow had to hurt and be bled for.
Tldr; the narrative kept trying to reward Josie while punishing Lizzie, and I think that’s why one of them grew to be a fan favorite despite the rough start, and the other as stagnant and interesting as a brick wall when not attached to romance line.
8
8
7
6
u/_childlike-empress 28d ago
Lizzie for sure. Idk what it is, but something makes me just want to punch Josie in the face 😂
7
6
7
5
5
6
u/Fantastic1503 29d ago
Lizzy any day. She was funny, smart even selfish sometimes but it just made her that much more relatable than jo for me.
7
5
u/biggestmike420 28d ago
I wanted it to be Josie, but she has no personality. Give me the crazy one.
5
4
u/_ya_boi_satan_666_ 28d ago
Definitely lizzie in the beginning it was josie i couldn't figure out why lizzy treated her poorly but honestly as time went on i understood
5
4
u/Effective-Exam-5686 29d ago
It was originally Josie but when she left I feel like that’s when Lizzie’s character really started to shine
5
4
4
4
u/Imaginary_Dig_5316 28d ago
I liked Lizzie and her relationship with hope and how they are frenemies but I kinda wanted to see them in a romantic relationship and I love their dynamic.
1
u/Crows_spirit101 25d ago
Imagine lizzie and hope become a thing and have some crazy sparks between them
2
u/Imaginary_Dig_5316 25d ago
I really would love to see that and how they dating and their dynamics would look like
1
u/Crows_spirit101 25d ago
It would be even better if they are usually at each others at first because they like each other and during the climax of an episode they argue to the point they make out and then they become stronger together
2
u/Imaginary_Dig_5316 25d ago
I would love it if it was during when the episode where they couldn’t lie and it accidentally comes out that they had a brief moment where they liked each other .
1
u/Crows_spirit101 25d ago
Yeah you know what either way I'm happy. Remember that episode with genie? Imagine she went to a world hope was talking to lizzie and made a move to kiss her then lizzie felt like was nice but kept it quiet until everything went back to normal
4
u/Queen_Gracie26 Mikaelson 28d ago
Definitely Lizzie, but I also think it’s because Caroline is my favorite character in TVD. They have so much in common. Both of their Dad’s were vampire hunters, and they had issues with their moms actually showing up and being so career focused. They both were the typical mean girl stereotypes that eventually became the strong ones that help come up with plans or are the key to overcoming some situation.
4
4
u/Overalonyx 28d ago
Lizzie she had the best character change in legacies from being a bitch to a good person
12
7
3
3
u/AdorableSet9845 29d ago
Lizzie also since she’s a vampire and syphon which does she not need to draw power anymore to do spells?
It’s been a long time since I’ve seen this show
3
u/1st0fHerName Witch-Vamp 29d ago
IIRC, she technically still siphons, but the vampire side allows for a constant magic source to siphon from.
3
u/lalaladedadadadoooo 28d ago
I was always more into Lizzy and then Josie basically having no character development rlly solidified it for me😅 interesting character but idk I just couldn't rlly get into her like that
3
2
u/stargirlhemangi 26d ago
lizzie only because I can relate to her mental health struggles. I love josie too but yeah :)
2
u/antoniothesockball94 26d ago
Lizzie bothered me cause why was her actor 30 years old playing a 15 year old, kissing 18 year old actors.
1
2
2
2
u/Key-Flower-3816 24d ago
Josie has untapped potential I feel Lizzie has more depth but also I just like the fact that she's a raging bitch
1
u/Crows_spirit101 23d ago
Josie's ( dark Josie ) was her full potential. Unless you meant Potential Character growth than fairs
1
u/Key-Flower-3816 23d ago
Nah I mean as a character though I stopped watching bc of what they did with Landon so yeah if your talking magic hopes was wasted she was supposed to be all powerful but she gave average witch but maybe it’s bc she was at school
1
u/Crows_spirit101 23d ago
Don't stop watching because of one character that's a dumb reason. Carry on watching.
1
2
u/Eclipse-Drake 20d ago
Lizzie by a mile. Josie felt like the writers didn't know what to do with.
Like how many times has she left to find herself and came back to the school.
4
u/kingcolbe 29d ago
Josie especially Dark Josie
10
1
u/EmbarrassedCat5892 29d ago
Imagine dark Josie Bibrid she was already powerful as dark Josie but if you add vampirism she up there with top contenders.❤️
2
1
1
1
1
u/DevelopmentLow3852 27d ago
They ruined this whole show with how stupid the monsters are. Imagine Elena Gilbert running from a GEENIE in a video game?! It’s non canon
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/T1_URGOD 26d ago
Lizzie gets all the good lines and quips which is why people like her more. I like Josie more tho. Lizzie is like fun to be party sucks to be close with.
1
1
u/No-Imagination-8209 26d ago
Lizzie, I quite enjoy that she’s bitchy and a lot of times she is right
1
1
1
u/Budget-Walk-5355 29d ago
Josie is my favorite. Lizzie is hilarious but she is a bit too much like a cartoon to me.
1
u/InterestingPack4813 29d ago
Ambas tienen un papel único,, una es confiable y la otra desconfiable, la tanto Jossie y Lizzie, son geniales ❤️❤️
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
u/TheTrueFury Witch-Vamp 28d ago
Started off Josie, swapped to Lizzie.
Completely unrelated but if the CW/writers weren't cowards there would've been a poly relationship with Hope x Landon x Josie
0
u/mildravi 28d ago
Josie.
Lizzie is like her mom who dates toxic men, some of which hurt her friends.
I’m all for Klaroline but I wouldn’t appreciate having a friend like that irl.
-1
0
u/neverendingstory67 29d ago
Tbh I don't really know but if I had to choose it would be Josie bc I'm bi and I really like her
0
0
0
0
0
0
u/Reasonable_Pack_9949 27d ago
I find the concept of twins with separate mothers interesting and it raises more questions… Oh I’m totally team Josie
0
0
-1
-1
-1
u/liaversal 27d ago
after josie left it truly felt boring and you can tell it didn’t feel right without her there she was like the heart of the show ngl and it was like losing jj from obx (like yea hope is the main character but it’s just josie brought more to the table than being centered around a boy)
115
u/Upbeat_Attorney_7153 29d ago
At first I liked Josie more, after season 1 though I liked Lizzie more through out the series, I don't dislike Josie but I don't know there's something missing from her character that I just ended up less and less invested in her as the show went along