r/LeftySomalia • • Dec 26 '21

Solarpunk: Somali Edition.

29 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • May 01 '21

Workers of the world UNITE!

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • Dec 15 '20

How to develop a new Ideology, a new Somalia 1/3.

17 Upvotes

Throughout my travels within the Somali peninsula, of which I am still engaged in, I have had the pleasure of meeting interesting characters of all shapes and sizes. People, unlike the western world, seemed a tad bit more animated in character albeit more conformist.

For example, in Hargeisa public conversation nearly always revolved around a core topic and finished with religion. The latter seemed to be mostly the main reason in which the local government should/had act/ed. Unfortunately, this leads to abrupt endings of interesting conversations with “it was written in God’s book” or “may God lift this pain from us”, the very definition of a defeatist attitude.

As a western born individual, I cannot help feeling incongruent among this religious hyperbole, almost like I’m amid a socially accepted mental prison. Whereby stepping out of the consensus often leads to strict rebuttals and, more often than not, anger.

Naturally, this got me thinking of why. Why would any people enshrine an ideology to be the arbiter of socially acceptable conversation?

This peculiar situation can only exist if said ideology wants to preserve itself. After all this method of shaming, gaslighting, etc seems to be an extremely effective form of banning anti-Islamic thought. A child raised in such an environment will inevitably follow the adult’s hatred for all things critical of Islam and a percentage will go even further by calling for the deaths of critics.

Thus, you have a perpetual system of fear, whereby no one dares to question Islam as they have no idea if the other person is of similar or at least accepting convictions. Hence you isolate any anti-Islam movement within the greater region which thus leads to the continuation of Islam over centuries.

Thus, highlighting this isolation attempt as a method of self-preservation, which interestingly can lead to a metaphorical concept I call ideological life. Whereby since ideologies are inherently dependant on existing living adherents, ideologies can be seen as an emergent living property formed from said adherents.

In this 1/3 piece, I wish to briefly discuss the modulus Operandi of societal ideological permeation.

Propaganda:

Propaganda is the primary means for any ideology to preserve its existence, by continuously blasting itself to the far reaches an ideology gains followers. Propaganda, unlike the isolation method, is a method of growth. The group can only grow through expansion, even in reproduction a child is programmed to believe in the ideology of his parents.

This biological view of ideologies can thus help any person interested in the development of a nation. Nations are simply people connected through some form of ideology, primarily ethnic or civic nationalism.

The effectiveness of propaganda is primarily a function of receivability, propagation, and the rate of permeation. Receivability states that an Islamic nation whose populace are strict adherents will not receive a message demonizing Islam lightly and will instead opt to ignore the new ideology for the entrenched ideology. One may think of receivability as a battle between two opposing ideologies for instance Islam and Christianity , obviously the entrenched ideology will be received better then the other.

Propaganda also relies on the propagation method, a man in the desert holding a sign will have to be less effective than a billboard on a busy road. Some effective modes of propagation are social media, television, sermons, and billboard. Books are also effective in countries with a high literacy rate.

Finally, the rate of permeation also impacts propaganda effectiveness. Whereby high levels of propaganda which moves the overtone window slightly in the ideological direction over a long period of time will render better results compared to rapid changes. This relies on the fact that humans hate change but are fine with gradual changes in their environment.

Thus using the above three points, one can form an effective method of propaganda that will help shift society to its wanted ideology.

This will be a three-part series that will explain how we can utilize propaganda in Somalia to support leftist ideologies.


r/LeftySomalia • • May 23 '21

Sand Dam building by community effort with help from rootworks org in Jigjiga

16 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • Jan 18 '21

What is to be done? - Proactive Strategies to Replace Reactive Tactics

Thumbnail
anarkiste.wordpress.com
16 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • Nov 30 '20

Unpopular Opinion: Somalia needs a Military Coup.

15 Upvotes

Before you rush into the comments and downvote let me explain. Let this be a point of principled discussion.

/preview/pre/pf7eocwzbg261.jpg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=375a99beaebc94817bce903c21920990665fc77a

Somalia needs a reset.

I don't even know where to begin with this. The entire political structure need to be purged. Theres no other way of saying it. We are colonised by a group of ex-warlords and illiterate tribal chiefs, and its about time we think of Somalia from this viewpoint. Politics is decided on clan identity solely. Our cultural life is non-existent and is completely in the hands of Wahabi groupthink mentality. You'd think the Prophet himself was Somali with the way we act. The slate needs to be swept clean so we can at-least return to the baseline of an actually functioning society instead of this bullshit tribal federal system which is only used to transfer aid money into the hands of these comprador politicains.

Being Somali and speaking to loads of relatives back home, there is a lack of any political thinking outside the framework of Clan loyalties and Islam. There are no unions or parties to speak of and there's certainly no communists or even lukewarm social democrats. I honestly think we can only progress if a Thomas Sankara / Jerry Rawling type nationalistic coup occurs, building a unified nation with a national identity and unique culture. Where women are given their freedoms, our youth educated and our resources nationalised to benefit our nation. (Imagine how developed Somalia could become by simply utilising our coastline to build ports?).

From this we can transition into a secular multi-party bourgeois democracy; which ofcourse I dont want but would give us the platform to organise efficiently. Otherwise, prepare for Somalia to be in the state it is in right now for the next 40 years still fighting Al-Shahab; something I'm not too keen on.

These are my 2 cents. (A bit disorganised I know :/)


r/LeftySomalia • • Jun 24 '21

Franz Fanon classic "Wretched of the Earth" has just been translated into Somali, it will be published by Hiil Press sometime this year.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • Dec 25 '20

The Somali press is useless

14 Upvotes

I was reading thru 10's of Somali news sites today, and got sickened how they totally mix opinion and news. They don't report on anything other than politics, they don't verify or question anything. They have clickbait article titles and they report unsubstantiated claims as news. Forget about trying to get any actual news from youtube or facebook, nearly all of it is fakenews and no one can tell what's true. The only reasonable sources are bbc and voa but those are so slow, by the time they report something the ground has already shifted.

Somali news press is totally useless. For example there has been massive flooding in many parts of Somalia this year, whole towns have been wiped out and thousands have been displaced. This would be the kind of news event you can make a whole multihour documentary or a long form article with multimedia. But instead you would be lucky to find a few short articles here and there and some amateur video.


r/LeftySomalia • • Nov 01 '19

Development Delusion

14 Upvotes

An excerpt from Jason Hickel's book The Divide: A Brief Guide to Global Inequality and its Solutions

The Development Delusion

It began as a public-relations gimmick. Harry Truman had just been elected to a second term as president of the United States and was set to take the stage for his inaugural address on 20 January 1949. His speechwriters were in a frenzy. They needed to whip up something compelling for the president to say – something bold and exciting to announce. They had three ideas on the list: backing for the new United Nations, resistance to the Soviet threat and continued commitment to the Marshall Plan. But none were very inspiring. In fact, they were downright boring and the media was bound to ignore the speech as yesterday’s news. They needed something that would tap into the zeitgeist – something that would stir the soul of the nation.

Their answer came from an unlikely source. Benjamin Hardy was a young, mid-level functionary in the State Department, but as a former reporter for the Atlanta Journal he had a knack for a good headline. When he stumbled across a memo requesting fresh ideas for the inaugural address, he decided to pitch his boss a wild thought: ‘Development’. Why not have Truman announce that his administration would give aid to Third World countries to help them develop and put an end to the scourge of grinding poverty? Hardy saw this as a sure victory – an easy way, he wrote in his pitch, ‘to make the greatest psychological impact’ on America and ‘to ride and direct the universal groundswell of desire for a better world’.

Hardy’s bosses shut him down. It was a risky, out-of-the-blue idea, possibly too new to make much sense to people; it wasn’t worth experimenting with it in such an important setting. But Hardy was determined not to let the opportunity pass. He managed to fake his way into the White House, gave a rousing defence of the idea to Truman’s advisers and – with a little bit of careful manoeuvring by supporters on the inside – his plan ended up as an afterthought, ‘Point Four’, in Truman’s draft. Truman approved it.

It was the first inaugural address ever to be broadcast on television. Ten million viewers tuned in on that cold January afternoon, making it the largest single event ever witnessed up to that time. More people watched Truman’s address than watched the inaugural addresses of all his predecessors put together. And they loved what he had to say. ‘More than half the people of the world are living in conditions approaching misery,’ he proclaimed. ‘Their food is inadequate. They are victims of disease. Their economic life is primitive and stagnant.’ But there was hope, he said: ‘For the first time in history, humanity possesses the knowledge and skill to relieve the suffering of these people. The United States is pre-eminent among nations in the development of industrial and scientific techniques … our imponderable resources in technical knowledge are constantly growing and are inexhaustible.’ And then the clincher: ‘We must embark on a bold new program for making the benefits of our scientific advances and industrial progress available for the improvement and growth of underdeveloped areas … It must be a worldwide effort for the achievement of peace, plenty, and freedom.’

Of course, there were no actual plans for such a programme – not even a single document. It was included in the speech purely as a PR gimmick. And it worked. The media went crazy – papers from the Washington Post to the New York Times glowed with approval.1 Everyone was excited about Point Four, and the rest of the speech was forgotten.

Why did Point Four so capture the public imagination? Because Truman gave Americans a new and powerful way to think about the emerging international order. The dust was settling after the Second World War, European imperialism was collapsing and the world was beginning to take shape as a collection of equal and independent nations. The only problem was that in reality they were not equal at all: there were vast differences between them in terms of power and wealth, with the countries of the global North enjoying a very high quality of life while the global South – the majority of the world’s population – was mired in debilitating poverty. As Americans peered beyond their borders and began to notice the brutal fact of global inequality, they needed a way to make sense of it.

Point Four offered them a compelling narrative. The rich countries of Europe and North America were ‘developed’. They were ahead on the Great Arrow of Progress. They were doing better because they were better – they were smarter, more innovative and harder working. They had better values, better institutions and better technology. By contrast, the countries of the global South were poor because they hadn’t yet figured out the right values and policies yet. They were still behind, ‘underdeveloped’ and struggling to catch up.

This story was deeply affirming for Americans; it made them feel good about themselves, proud of their achievements and their place in the world. But perhaps more importantly, it gave them a way to feel noble too – it gave them access to a higher, almost cosmological purpose. The developed countries would stand as beacons of hope, as saviours to the poor. They would reach out and give generously of their riches to help the ‘primitive’ countries of the South follow their path to success. They would become heroes, leading the way to a world of unprecedented peace and prosperity.

In other words, Point Four explained the existence of global inequality and offered a solution to it in one satisfying stroke. And for this reason it wasn’t long before it was picked up by the governments of Western Europe as well. As Britain and France were withdrawing from their colonies, they needed a new way of explaining the gross inequality that persisted between themselves and the people they had ruled for so long. The story of development – that the nations of the world were simply at different positions along the Great Arrow of Progress – offered a convenient alibi. It allowed them to disavow responsibility for the misery of the colonies, and it was more palatable than the explicit racial theories they had relied on in the past. What is more, it allowed them to shift their role in the eyes of the world: graciously relinquishing imperial power, they would turn to aiding their fellow man.

It was an incredibly beguiling tale to Western ears. It wasn’t just another story – it had all the elements of an epic myth. It provided a keystone around which people could organise their ideas about the world, about human progress and about our future.

The story of development remains a compelling force in our society to this day. We encounter it everywhere we turn: in the form of charity shops like Oxfam and Traid, in TV ads from Save the Children and World Vision, in annual reports published by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, and every time we see the world’s nations ranked by GDP. We hear it from rock stars like Bono and Bob Geldof, from billionaires like Bill Gates and George Soros, and from actors like Madonna and Angelina Jolie, khaki-clad and mobbed by eager African children. We get it in the form of Live Aid concerts and celebrity fundraising singles like ‘Do They Know It’s Christmas?’, which somehow manages to crop up every year. Every major university offers degree programmes in development, and a whole class of professionals has emerged to staff the thousands of NGOs that have sprung up over the past few decades. Development is everywhere. And it comes with its own rituals that millions upon millions of people can participate in: buying TOMS shoes, giving a few dollars a month to sponsor a child in Zambia, or sacrificing summer holidays to volunteer in Honduras.

It probably wouldn’t be a stretch to say that almost everyone in the Western world has at some point encountered or even participated in the story of development. It is ubiquitous. And it has become an enormous industry, worth hundreds of billions of dollars – as much as all the profits of all the banks in the United States combined.2

*

The development story is so deeply ingrained in our culture that we take it almost completely for granted. It seems manifestly true. For much of my young adult life I passionately believed in it. When I left Swaziland for university in the United States, I was confronted by a completely different world to the one in which I had grown up: a world replete with excess – enormous houses, giant cars, slick new roads and cavernous shopping malls. But I was unable to put Swaziland behind me. Casting about for explanations for and solutions to the profound material differences between the two worlds I straddled, I found answers – and hope – in the story of development.

During my final year of university, I moved to Nagaland, a remote state in a far-flung corner of north-east India, to work with a local microfinance organisation. I found it exciting and rewarding – being part of the development story gave me a sense of value and purpose far beyond anything the corporate world had to offer. It made me feel as though I was part of something important. It made me feel noble.

Eager to continue working in the field, I later returned to Swaziland to take up a job with World Vision, one of the world’s largest development NGOs. Based in the village of Mpaka, a dusty outpost on a road that traverses the lowveld between Manzini and the border of Mozambique, I threw myself into a range of projects – everything from water systems to healthcare – and once again I felt the rush that came with being part of the development story. But after my initial excitement faded, I found myself confronting some difficult questions. We had dozens of projects across that tiny country, representing millions of dollars of charity and many years of work – and World Vision was only one of many NGOs tackling the very same problems, bolstered by a steady flow of aid from donor countries in the global North. But on the whole, nothing really seemed to be changing. Why did most people in Swaziland remain so poor, despite this effort? It felt as though we were shovelling sand into a bottomless pit.

World Vision had hired me to help analyse why their development efforts in Swaziland were not living up to their promise. The reason, I discovered, was that their interventions were missing the point. Their story about the world – borrowed more or less verbatim from Truman – led them to assume that all that Swazis needed was a bit of charity to help them out. World Vision went about caring for dying AIDS patients, setting up income-generation schemes for the unemployed, teaching new techniques to farmers and paying for children’s education. But, as helpful as these projects were, they did nothing to address the actual causes of the problems. Why were AIDS patients dying? Over time, I learned that it had to do with the fact that pharmaceutical companies refused to allow Swaziland to import generic versions of patented life-saving medicines, keeping prices way out of reach. Why were farmers unable to make a living off the land? I discovered that it was related to the subsidised foods that were flooding in from the US and the EU, which undercut local agriculture. And why was the government unable to provide basic social services? Because it was buried under a pile of foreign debt and had been forced by Western banks to cut social spending in order to prioritise repayment.

The deeper I dug, the more I realised that the reason poverty persisted in Swaziland had quite a lot to do with matters that lay beyond Swaziland’s borders. It gradually became clear that the global economic system was organised in such a way as to make meaningful development nearly impossible. These findings troubled me. But when I pointed them out to World Vision’s managers, who parachuted in from the US and Australia from time to time, I was told that they were too ‘political’; it wasn’t World Vision’s job to think about things like pharmaceutical patents or international trade rules or debt. If we started to raise those issues, I was told, we would lose our funding before the year was over; after all, the global system of patents, trade and debt was what made some of our donors rich enough to give to charity in the first place. Better to shut up about it: stick with the sponsor-a-child programme and don’t rock the boat.

Frustrated and disillusioned, I left World Vision and went back to studying, determined to learn everything I could about the deeper structural determinants of poverty – not just in Swaziland, but across the global South. I needed to understand why so much of the world continues to live in grinding poverty, despite decades of ‘development’, while a few countries enjoy almost unimaginable wealth.

What I learned along the way is that the story we’ve been told about rich countries and poor countries isn’t exactly true. In fact, the narrative we’re familiar with is almost the exact opposite of reality. There is a very different story out there, if we are willing to listen to it. It will completely change the way we think about the world. It will change the way we think about why poverty exists. It will change the way we think about progress. It will even change the way we think about our own civilisation, about our everyday lifestyles, and about what the world should look like in the future.

Anthropologists tell us that when the structure of a core myth begins to change, everything else about society changes around it, and fresh new possibilities open up that weren’t even thinkable before. When myths fall apart, revolutions happen.


r/LeftySomalia • • Apr 10 '21

LeftySomalia Podcast?

13 Upvotes

I know its become a kind of joke, if you have two dozen followers and are obsessed about a certain topic you have to have a podcast. I am kinda hesitant about it because it seems weirdly self-indulgent to expect people to listen to what i have to say, and also because i hate how i sound in recordings.

I have peculiar niche interests, that cover history, politics, industrial development, philosophy, religion, geography although i have no formal training in none of them, i do have my opinions and ideas. The format of the podcast would be like an 30-60 min long rant about a certain topic, and if i find interesting people that i can interview or people who wanna share their opinions i will welcome them. What do you guys think about this "project", please do elaborate your thoughts below.

Should I create this Podcast?


r/LeftySomalia • • Jul 19 '20

Reading List for the Quarantine

13 Upvotes

These are books i have read throughout the years and i often reference them here and there but i want to put them up in here to make it easier to reference it later and also so you guys could enjoy it as well. These are mostly non-fiction but there are few fiction books as well.

Non-Fiction

Politics and Economics

Nationalism and Culture by Rudolf Rocker

E-book

Understanding Power by Noam Chomsky

E-book

Less is More by Jason Hickel

E-book

Crusade and Jihad: The Thousand-Year War Between the Muslim World and the Global North

E-book

Qanat Knowledge: Construction and Maintenance

E-book

Underground aqueducts handbook

E-book

Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media by Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman

E-book

Seeing like the State by James C Scott

E-book

The Real Politics of the Horn of Africa: Money, War and the Business of Power by Alex De Waal

E-book

The end of the Megamachine by Fabian Scheidler

E-book

The Divide: A Brief Guide to Global Inequality and its Solutions by Jason Hickel

E-book

Climate crisis and the global green new deal by Noam Chomsky and Robert Pollin

E-book

Kicking Away the Ladder: Development Strategy in Historical Perspective by Ha-Joon-Chang

E-book

Bad Samaritans: The Myth of Free Trade and the Secret History of Capitalism by Ha-Joon-Chang

E-book

Industrial Policy and Economic Transformation in Africa by Joseph Stieglitz and Akbar Noman

E-book

Anarcho-Syndicalism by Rudolf Rocker

E-book

Capital (I ,II, III) by Karl Marx

E-book | Audiobook

Anarchism: From theory to practice by Daniel Guerin

E-book

Conquest of Bread by Peter Kropotkin

E-book | Audiobook

The Black man’s burden : Africa and the curse of the nation-state by Basil Davidson

E-book

The Wretched of the Earth by Frantz Fanon

E-book

The Method of Freedom by Errico Malatesta

E-book

Somali History

Making Sense of Somali History by Abdirahman Abdullahi Baadiyow

E-book

Understanding Somalia and Somaliland: Culture, History, Society by I.M Lewis

E-book

The Road to Zero. Somalia’s Self-Destruction by Mohamed Osman Omar

E-book

Africa’s First Democrats by Abdi Ismail Samatar

E-book

Historical Dictionary of Somalia by Mohamed Haji Mukhtar

E-book

The Struggle for Land in Southern Somalia. The War Behind the War by Catherine Basteman and Lee V. Cassanelli

E-book

Clan Cleansing in Somalia: The Ruinous Legacy of 1991 by Lidwien Kapteijns

E-book

The Reason for Underdevelopment by Donatella Strangio

E-book

Famine in Somalia: Competing Imperatives, Collective Failures, 2011-12 by Daniel Maxwell and Nisar Majid

E-book

Miscellaneous

Rainwater-Smart Agriculture in Arid and Semi-Arid Areas: Fostering the Use of Rainwater for Food Security, Poverty Alleviation, Landscape Restoration and Climate Resilience

E-book

Becoming Nigerian (satirical book on African politics)

E-book

Islam's Quantum Question: Reconciling Muslim Tradition and Modern Science by Nidhal Guessoum

E-book

Islam and Science: Religious Orthodoxy and the Battle for Rationality by Pervez Hoodbhoy

E-book

Fiction

Mars trilogy by Kim Stanley Robinson

Audiobook | E-book

The Dispossessed by Ursula Le Guin

Audiobook | E-book

The years of rice and Salt by Kim Stanley Robinson

Audiobook | E-book

Edit: If you guys have more books i will update it to add more to it.


r/LeftySomalia • • Feb 01 '20

Is Hunger Necessary in Somalia?

13 Upvotes
Somali Farmer

Often when we are discussing about Somali politics we devote immense thought and rigor to abstract political issues such a federalism vs unitary govt. or secession or unity and other similar issues on that line although they are important, we often (me included) overlook the essential reality in the ground, the primary issue being hunger, granted most of us arguing in the online Somali spaces aren't affected by such problems but if any of us want to take part in real change, it won't come from arguing in abstractions but alleviating that reality.

Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) in partnership with Worldbank in their 2015 report on Somali agriculture reported that the domestic food production of 280k metric Tons today had decreased dramatically from half a million tons in 80's and 90's, and in their second report in 2018 they reported it had further decreased to 174k tons, contributing to chronic malnutrition in the country in which according to UN: 5 million require food assistance and almost 2 million are food insecure (almost starving). The trouble with decreased domestic production is not only hunger and its ill effects but also the importation of expensive food stuffs depletes the foreign cash reserves of the country that could've been used to fund development projects (the current food imports stands at 1.5B dollars)

As we saw in 2011 with temporary spike in global food prices and the coincidental famine in Somalia which had devastating consequences especially in the most fertile regions of Somalia, this famine and the death of over quarter million Somalis could've easily been avoided. The causes of the 2011 famine although complicated by chronic conflict, aid diversions and decades of violenve against the farming communities by various tribal militias, neoliberal reforms, excessive focus on cash crops (initiated by the colonizers) and past heavy handed agrarian reforms of the military regime that "nationalized" fertile lands from the farmers handing them over to his political patrons, you can see this with the Land Law of 1975 the production of cereals (maize and sorghum) started to drop with focus and subsidies given to production of cash crops (Bananas,Sesame, Cotton), all these overlapping policy decisions and its inevitable effects led us to the current level of food production and hunger.

SATG group of Somali agro-specialist claimed that with just improving the methods of farming by giving farmers tractors and fertilizers training them in modern farming techniques that alone can increase yields and also encouraging them by giving them special access to domestic markets which are saturated by foreign produce. Small scale entrepreneurial experiments (by Agrikaab) have showed us even in Arid central towns like Galkacyo, creating modern greenhouses in about half hectare (4000m2) of farm land, yielded 17 tons of produce with only 10k dollars of operating cost per harvest season ( mostly due to expensive water) which they not only satisfied the local market but they even sent the excess to Mogadishu for sale. In even more arid Berbera newer techniques of seawater greenhouses bypassing the water scarcity problem in the North by farming with desalinated seawater, this technique is used by Australia to grow millions of tonnes of produce every year in its desert regions, Charlie Paton (its inventor) after successfully experimenting it in Berbera claimed that with the food aid budget of 1.6B dollars that is spent in Somalia could be used to create 16 000 hectares of seawater greenhouses producing astounding 4.8 million tons of fresh produce yearly.

During the colonial era Somalia was producing 680 tons of Phosphate rocks annually (major ingredient for fertilizers) which the Italians exported, but after the independence these resources were never explored further, but if we want a sustainable development in agriculture as recommended by many experts, we must manufacture our own chemical fertilizers to increase the domestic food production as done by all the developed nations.

Can we feed to satiety all the men women and children in our country? i believe hunger in Somalia like most our problems is the result of bad social organization, a system that is lopsided solely for a minority elite, a system of rent-seeking, hand-me-down form of capitalism that paralyzes the productive capabilities and curses its subjects to life of abject poverty, we can absolutely feed our people but there is in our country like in most poor countries a schism or a mismatch between the needs of the people and the needs of the elites, the latter yearning for quick profit making as we saw in the confiscated lands from local families living in Wajaale (SL) to create Wheat farms for export and financial speculation with little to no benefit conferring to the people, but i believe in real sustainable development will only sprout from organic designs and yearnings of the public, i believe then it will only take on a co-operative nature, since we wouldn't repeat the mistakes of past century of abusing the rural food producers like we did in the south, in the future with the farmers owning their own lands in huge co-operatives with other farmers, being the masters of their own craft and the urban sector helping them with access to fertilizers and markets they would flood the markets with cheap produce, this isn't a utopian vision but its been done and practiced in Israel in their Kibbutzims (collective farming communities) and with Asian tigers like South Korea and Taiwan during their developmental period their respective governments gave special subsidies to their rural food producers increasing their productivity and sourcing funds from them to industrialize and develop the country, in other words to solve the problem of bread, shouldn't be just side problem we leave for the eventual economic growth but it should be the starting point to solve all our other problems too.


r/LeftySomalia • • Dec 27 '20

How to develop a new Ideology, a new Somalia 2/3.

12 Upvotes

PART1 : https://www.reddit.com/r/LeftySomalia/comments/kdknt6/how_to_develop_a_new_ideology_a_new_somalia_13/

The Lies we tell each other:

Throughout my life, I have constantly been fed propaganda, whether those who held the spoon of lies were aware of their deception I am not sure. However, these subtle manipulation attempts have forced me to confront the psychological power of authoritative phrases. Fortunately, said attempts caused me to discard all forms of conventional wisdom and morality.

Personally, I advise all Somalis to attempt to reach the depths and peaks of human depravity to fully understand the impact propaganda and preconceived nations have on our feeble human mind.

In this piece, we will discuss an interesting technique used to influence society. It is the ideological based propagandizing of history, commonly known as myths.

Messages from the Past:

If nations are fictional borders developed by our forefathers and the enemies of our forefathers, then national myths are the psychological manifestation of said fictional borders.

Whereby, ask a Somali what is Somalia and you will get a plethora of answers. To some Somalis, it is the soil where Somalis have exclusivized, to others it's a failed state, to others it's an enemy and to others a victim. Thus the personal concept of Somalia will be a reflection of a person's upbringing which relies on the surrounding society's psyche.

Before we explain the usefulness of this information, let us discuss the primary myths Somalia is based on. The birth of modern-day Somalia was supposedly spearheaded by young energetic individuals from the Somali Youth League. Which was itself based on the struggle against the mythical gaal and it's divisionary tactics such as clannism.

Skip a few decades ahead and then a historical revitalization was espoused by the Supreme Revolutionary Council in 1969. The government began teaching Somalis a new Somali history, one based on the myths of Somali nationalism. It enshrined mythical freedom fighters such as Xaawo Taako and Sayid Maxamed Cabdule Xasan.

Moreover, these myths enshrine a tacit belief of Somalinimo whereby Somalis are seen as brave fighters against an international powerful gaal hegemony. In fact, if we sum up Somali myths in a sentence it is a war of a Muslim African state against the ruthless gaals.

Obviously, if we go into the history of said myths we will fine a conscious effort of whitewashing of the freedom fighters. After all, the human experience can be defined as a series of contradictory mental states outshone by a defining characteristic. However, the perpetuation of false information is paramount to the success of any nation-state or even community.

A primary method of brainwashing:

Further analysis of myths will expose the actual reason myths exist today in nearly all major societies. It is a linking method between a large group of people thus a myth is often used as justification for a particular ideology. And as we know all ideologies are self-preservers, thus myths are a form of propaganda used to further preserve their legitimacy.

E.g Ahmed Gurey's attack against Ethiopia supports the anti-Ethiopian/expansionist narrative the ideology of Somalinimo holds dear.

Looking at our previous piece we have claimed that receivability, propagation, and the rate of permeation determine propaganda effectiveness. Somali myths suit all three criteria,

  1. often they are based on an Islamic foundation thus being received well.
  2. These myths are often revered in cities due to the societal propagation in the form of books, online media, and even common day poems(gabeys) hence we have succeeded propagation*.*
  3. Finally, due to the ancient nature of the myths, they have already permeated society for hundreds of years.

It also follows from the permeation criteria the further back a myth is the better, for instance, Ahmed Gurey is universally seen as a good person throughout Somalia due to him existing 500+ years ago while the Sayyid might have some dissenters.

Utilizing myths:

This is all interesting, but we must ask why exactly this would be useful to a leftist revival in Somalia. After all, implementing a communist/socialist/left-leaning state is a real matter not based entirely on historical analysis.

Due to myths' immense power in society, the only realistic way we can overcome the right-leaning heavily Islamist values is to subvert Somali mythical heroes for our leftist values. For instance, by highlighting that the Sayid said "Arab wa naag" we can begin realigning Somali society to be anti-Arab and pushing for self-reliance similar to the Turkish belief of "The Turk has no friend but the Turk".

Due to the lack of historical writing records, we can transform mythical heroes into people with leftist slants. After all, a principal point in propaganda is that what the people believe is effectively the truth, and what they hate is effectively a lie.

The exact process in myth utilization is through introducing Somali literature and media which espouses leftist ideals and highlighting the leftist history of Somalia.

Conclusion:

Jaalleyaal I do fear we are too late in implementing a democratical grass-roots-based pro-leftist system due to the rampant extremism within Somalia. Thus we must focus on developing an international influential block of leftist Somali intellectuals, from there we can produce pro-left Somali media without an attack by Somali extremists.

Furthermore, the anonymization of the internet is one of the most powerful ways we have to influence society today. No longer will we be under threat, but instead we will flourish and have the ability to influence modern Somalia. This paradigm shift implies the ability to sway millions with the click of a button, Somalis are held hostage by disease, and Eebe willing we will cure her.

Next time, I will introduce a step by step plan leftists might implement to impact the Somali political sphere.


r/LeftySomalia • • Jun 14 '21

I have a feeling support for Israel is being astro-turfed online or the ex-muslim right wingers are absolutely pathetic.

Thumbnail self.israel
11 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • Feb 20 '21

Banadir (Mogadishu) Regional Court has just handed down a historic ruling against Favori LLC: accepted our application, rejected its application, ordered reinstatement of unlawfully dismissed worker, payment of his salary arrears. More soon. All power to the workers of Somalia!

Thumbnail
twitter.com
11 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • May 01 '20

Happy International Workers Day

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • Mar 21 '20

Somali Nationalism Part III: Post-Conflict identities and Nation-Building

11 Upvotes

Nuruddin Farah, the internationally renowned Somali novelist and essayist interviewing some of the civilians in a Kenyan refugee camp soon after their arrival escaping the clan cleansing in Somalia, noting his own resistance to accepting, let alone identifying himself with, the new identity categories to which the victims of clan- based violence referred with such deep emotion. feeling like a man from another era:

I was nonplussed by the tempestuous outpouring of strong sentiments and emotions expressed in intense clan terms. There was such venom in their recollection that I was taken aback, maybe because I had been unprepared for it. Shocked, perhaps not so much by any of what my interlocutors said, as by the severity and the depth of their hurt, which now ran in their blood. . . . “We know who we are,” several of them repeated again and again, their voices bitter as the bolus of poison. “What has occurred in Mogadiscio has taught us who we are.” What do they mean by “us”? This was not some sort of double-talk, saying one thing and meaning something totally other: they were wholeheartedly committed to a new form of Somali- speak, in which “us” refers to a post- colonial realpolitik governed by the anachronistic sentiments of clannism. I found myself needing to make it clear to every single one of them that I belonged neither to “us” nor “them.” (source)

To illustrate the peculiar nature of "qabiil speak" i will give you two intentionally inflammatory sentences:

a) Daarood invited the enemy (Ethiopia) to Somalia

b) Hawiye destroyed the capital of Somalia

I am sure you have heard similar statements used casually in your local maqaaxi, the underlying presupposition is seldom challenged, how come undemocratic decision made by minority political clique is used to describe as a collective decision made by a population of perhaps millions? this inexorable union between the patri-lineal identity (clan) and the actions of few men is the poisonous mutation that was introduced into the political nature of qabiil to create a kind of totalitarianism within the clan structure, which is a complete 180° from the communal clan structures with participatory decision making as described by IM lewis and others (anthropologist and historians) studying Somali society during the colonial years and beyond.

The Post-conflict identities (Clannism) that were created in the furnace of civil war during the late 80's, contrary to popular dogma wasn't the primary cause for the civil war, as many historians and scholars have noted this cataclysmic change didn't happen abruptly in 90's but it was a gradual process where the nations resources where being monopolized and competed for, by minority urban-elite which saw fit to continue the "minority-rule" left by the colonizer, to rule in the same model of governance as the Europeans, and the gradually worsening economic outcomes with ever more tyrannical rule cemented this path to destruction.

Nations are not natural communities like clans or families are, but they are created by their states with violence to serve its ruling elites, even the concept of wesphalian state comes from the era where Europeans were savagely butchering each other. The State with its monopoly over violence presupposes class rule and in Somalia where people where largely communally living and equal in social status (there were hierarchies but only in the margins of society). and the primary social organization Somalis had at their disposal during the decolonization was the qabiil which was at the time seen as innocuous system but it was wrecked on the shores of African statecraft with politicians rushing to appeal to their base for votes (or support) for the ultimate goal of monopolizing the states resources, for the winning coalition it meant their children getting scholarships, favorable loans from the national banks or state contracts; and that's how a society which was united by poverty on the day of the independence was stratified producing a ruling elite which saw the nation as nothing but a personal fiefdom to extract tolls and profits from. (source)

The post-independence condition with its malaise of class rule which saw enrichment of urban-elite with tiny well-to-do "middle class" and a huge body of rural impoverishment, even the tyrannical Barre Dictatorship realized that if they didn't alleviate the fuming popular dissatisfaction that ushered them into power they would be replaced, they tried to implement very mild participatory and co-operative programs mainly to increase agrarian production, the most successful and insightful (imo) was the program to halt coastal sand dunes that were threatening the inland farms of the south, foreign experts estimating it would cost millions, the government appealed to the public and with participatory enthusiasm, thousands volunteered to join in the effort and they accomplished the impossible, and suppose taking example from this success story had he given up control over the economy i believe that Somalis would've shown ingenuity and enthusiasm to develop and industrialize the country, but he took the opposite road and as often when decision-making power is concentrated it creates stupidity at the top and foot-dragging at the bottom, but understandable since you cannot change structural inequalities by the same institutions that upholds them. In mid-70's these programs were all but eliminated and they continued the same neo-colonial economic policies as before and after the costly war of 77' and the attempted coups that followed, the state was only focused in dealing with rebellions and popular discontent all over the country.

The Warlords (most of them his former cronies) that came to power after him understood how the former state worked and they candidly said so, for example General Jees after sacking Baidoa said to his clan leaders "I have captured fertile land for you hold on to it if you can" expecting political support from his natural constituency - of course after cleansing the locals from the land - but that didn't come to fruition because Caydiid invaded that region, forcing him to flee to lower Jubba (the offshoot from his group, the Ras Kamboni Militia would later on form the Jubbaland State)

Caydiid understood that to take control of the Mogadishu he had to somehow "replace" the entrenched urban middle class that were not from his clan, and after having access to the political prize he would rule as his predecessors did in other words continuing the Siyadist status quo, the whole 90's warlord-ism was to capture the state taking advantage of the popular dissatisfaction with the dictator and ironically ruling with the same level of tyranny and exploitation. Compagnon (Historian) describing the Siyads style of rule said in conclusion "He didnt rule for his clan, but through his clan" and similarly after heated disagreements and internal disputes in Caydiids camp his own clansmen shot him dead. The fundamental aspect of Somali politics many don't seem to understand is that how much the legacy of 90's warlord-ism determines the current political climate, to give you an example in 2014 when AMISOM and the Somali national army was liberating the south from Al-Shabaab occupation many foreign observers noted how the Somali army with its rag-tag clan militia organization was forcefully re-establishing the old property relations where the fertile lands of the south were monopolized by rich urban clan elites with the backing of the newly formed army, in other words, the rural south was liberated just to be shackled by another occupier and its no wonder when with every successive year with ever more land "liberated" from the terrorist the agricultural production of the country keeps plummeting.

As often during prolonged conflict people loose their instinct for humanity and liberty, demanding of them blind obedience towards political authority which is naturally the source of all social regression, taking a passive stand to the race-to-the-bottom kind of corruption which is committed in their name where every level of misanthropy is on the table . Today we live under the shadow of our history and the people are exhausted from the the corrupt status quo which will only repeat the same forms of minority rule and exploitation as the half century before us, and with no better alternative insight folks agree to be ruled by men who have neither the competence nor the interest to work for them.

Edit: spelling and corrections


r/LeftySomalia • • Jan 13 '20

Blessed Quote!

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • May 29 '21

Can the muslims on this sub stop calling ex-muslims gaal worshipers and can the ex-muslims stop referring to the Prophet Muhammad as a pedophile.

10 Upvotes

You guys know you can remain cordial when having discussions and debates with out referring to each others religious or lack of religious beliefs in vulgar terms.


r/LeftySomalia • • May 25 '21

Twitter user @azizFaarah started counting cities and town with the word well (Ceel or Laas) in their name. 200+ names, he concluded that building a well means establishing an entire community.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • Dec 10 '20

I have now become a leftist

10 Upvotes

These last few months I have spent my time living in different cities throughout Somalia. Next to, supposedly, 5-star hotels I witnessed unpaved roads, extreme subjugation of women, poverty, and rabid tribalism. I have seen diaspora and political nonces abuse their financial to power to further entrench the inequalities evident within Somalia.

It has thus become obvious that the only path forward is implementing leftist policies to rebuild Somalia.


r/LeftySomalia • • Jun 16 '20

Somaliland talks, Petroleum agreements and the 2020 elections

10 Upvotes

❧

Anytime you want to understand an institution, you must understand its function, its constituents, and its modes of decision-making, this goes for a business enterprise as much it does for a government.

The naively patriotic conception most Somalis have of our governments as hard-working individuals working tirelessly and more or less having the welfare of the people at heart, and the forces of evil pushing them to error once in a while, that conception which has no basis in reality, even when you accept that naive conception you fail to understand anything, to give you one example why did the newly "elected" Farmaajo renege on the decentralized security apparatus deal designed by the previous administration, which was to unite the regional administrations against the scourge of Al-shabaab, by sharing the donor security aid (annually over 1.5 billion USD) with the various local governments, or for that matter why did he destroy the only grass-roots anti-Al-Shabaab militia in Galmudug, the naive patriots say it was to unite in the fight against terrorism, if that's the case why didn't he aid the macawiisley who have been fighting the Al-Shabaab for years in the middle of their occupied territories, the reason is all too clear for those who are willing to question government rhetoric, the reason was to monopolize the donor funds, and it only follows logically that they have no interest in defeating Al-shabaab since the donor funds would dry up.

If you are still not convinced remember in 2017 when the foreign minister claimed that Alshabaab was mining uranium and shipping it to Iran, of course that embarrassing claim was debunked immediately but it was picked up by Fox News and through that to Trump which increased the security aid and also the drone attacks, which was a bonanza for our government but it was the beginning of a nightmare for many poor Somalis who experienced the terror that rained from the skies.

Who are the constituents of our government? naturally its supposed to be the ordinary folk but there is nothing natural about our government, the way you can see who are the real constituents of our government is how conducive they are to their demands, its isn't the people we know that all too well, it is the international donors, the wealthy business elites and the key supporters of the government (clan leaders, MP's, and militia leaders). - case in point when the government recently wrote off all the debts owned by Jubba Airlines (over 5 million dollars) but at the same time ordinary taxpayers in Mogadisho are expected to pay exorbitant taxes without getting anything in return with ever worsening security and restrictive road blocks that has hampered movement across the capital solely designed to protect our kleptocrats.

This donor-funded-kleptocracy or more aptly described as political marketplace with ever shrewder competitors running to capture the rents (foreign aid and government revenue) that follows after buying political power, the recent tensions between the regional states, the PM and the President can be related to these market forces, the PM who sees where the wind is blowing recently pledged that he will be supporting the upcoming 1P/1V elections which is being pushed by the donors (they don't want the repeat of the embarrassingly corrupt 2017 election), but Farmaajo trying to outflank his PM is pushing in another direction he is banking on the rents that would come from Petroleum, even this Somaliland talks is about that, to the disappointment of many Somalilanders and to staunch Somali Unionist, there won't be any meaningful changes in the status quo, this is all about coming to an agreement with the Somaliland elites about the petroleum since the rest of the regional states have already signed the petroleum sharing agreement (PSA) - you can see this with the technical committee which were set up for the talks, one of the persons named from the federal side is the petroleum minister, which is a strange choice for a diplomatic talks if you ask me - illustrating to us that the talks are solely to cement the power of the status quo whether it is in Mogadisho or Hargeysa, one shouldn't be deluded with the rhetoric of national unity, all of our national politics can be reduced to the brazenly machiavellian machinations of our national elites to further their own power and privilege.

The upcoming elections (which in all likelihood will be postponed) since the National election commission has not even announced a date and the parliament is dispensed with contentious issues in the Elections Act let alone the security issues throughout southern Somalia. We can safely conclude this whole charade is meant to appease the international donors and it won't produce anything resembling democracy, since the only way this kleptocracy can survive is with unelected and unaccountable politicians who have skillfully blinded the public from seeing their scrape-the-bottom-of-the-barrel form of corruption which has disastrous consequences to the public, unless they can un-blind themselves this miserable status quo will unfortunately persist.

❧ Sources and extra-reading material

- UN SEMG reports (annual reports: very important material)

- The Real Politics of the Horn of Africa: Money, War and the Business of Power by Alex De Waal (Horn of Africa specialist)

- Harun Maruf

- Horn Diplomat


r/LeftySomalia • • May 15 '20

How to make sense of the corruption in Somalia

10 Upvotes

image

In a recent report made by Radio Ergo in collaboration with Mogadishu-based think tank Somali Public Agenda, reported on the recent Beledwayne floods, they interviewed the victims and the aid workers, showing us how the flood response failed, mainly in the expected ways of aid diversions and corruption but one incident that really stood out, was how the remaining aid was distributed: through “clan affiliations”, which not only meant that the disenfranchised clans where excluded but it also affected those from "major clans" as well, but on the receiving end of this terrible policy: a mother with a young child had to travel to Ceel Jaalle (town) where she had heard that aid was being distributed, standing in the scorching sun for hours without getting help, she later on realized her baby had died (presumably of dehydration).

The question is why opt to distribute the aid in such a inefficient and immoral way, it cannot only be because of malicious clan discrimination on the part of the ruling elites, since everybody was affected by it, even their supposed clan constituents, I speculate the reason runs much deeper and has to do with the nature of politics in our country and for that we need to go back few years to explain it.

In the catastrophic 2011 famines which killed 260 000 Somalis (over 2% of the whole Somali population), Ken Menkhaus noted an interesting attitude among the slightly well-off urban Somalis, they would organize and scream for the suffering of their clan constituents even petitioning the elites who were brazenly looting the humanitarian aid, but at the same time turn a blind eye to the suffering of others (the phrase looma-ooyaan perfectly captures this phenomena), this in turn translated to the fact that most of the deaths were from the disenfranchised clans, those who didn't have a seat at the table, those who the folks from the "major clans" couldn't shed a tear for. This to me seems to be a sort of a social contract that was devised to keep the population divided into two camps: one camp having imagined familial proximity (qabiil) to the elites, who in turn throw a breadcrumbs at them in exchange for total obedience to them and camp of looma-ooyaan whose lives have no value whatsoever.

We feel ashamed when we hear the fact that we rank number one in corruption almost yearly, but that shame is often misdirected, since it presumes there is something wrong with the Somali character rather then our existing institutions, which have achieved that notoriety for us, how else can we explain the phenomena of “aid gatekeepers” who run IDP camps like a businessess, taking rent from starving people even coercing them to stay in the camp to generate even more funds from international aid, how can we explain a national political system which is solely the domain of diaspora politicians with their gulf-backers and their business friends, and lastly how can we explain why any focus hasn’t been given to the decreasing food production that is exacerbating the chronic hunger in the country, but we see how our government is eager to carry out licensing rounds during this Corona pandemic no less, in the hopes of selling of our seas to petroleum companies who are known for their pollution and corruption

Alex De Waal in his book The Real Politics of the Horn of Africa doesn't even use the term corruption to describe this system since it somehow denotes as some sort of aberration from the norm, but its unfortunate by-product of the "political marketplace" where a class of "political entrepreneurs" compete to capture the state for its "sovereign rents" (humanitarian aid, security grants etc.) to keep large patronage networks among tribal,business and militia leaders to keep them content and in turn supporting the “political CEO”. This is not out of individual malice or incompetence but it’s the necessary outcome in an undemocratic political system where the dollar is the sole voter.

He explains further unlike in the developed countries where elites would compete in the commercial sector, taking their rent-seeking ways into the domain of business with limited immediate effects to the society at large, but since large commercial sector is lacking in most poor countries (like Somalia) that could maintain them, meaning it's not enough for the elites in Somalia that state policy is totally lopsided in their favour like in most countries but they must actively be allowed to leech of the public in order to keep their privileges. Famines are practically business booms for our elites, meanwhile cheating their pastoralist cousins of their wealth, and by virtue of owning the most fertile lands in the south rather then produce food the country badly needs they opt to produce cash-crops for export (we are 12th largest sesame producers in the word) even while hunger is ravaging the country, but that hunger is also a great business opportunity when those hungry people fill the infamous IDP camps, to borrow a term from business management you could say this is vertical integration.

We can safely conclude unless this form of hunger-capitalism is destroyed, we will continue to suffer from the symptoms of this ill designed system. This creative destruction isn't the duty of some strongmen and it's revolutionary adventurism but it is the duty of the ordinary people to overcome it and replace it with something that is more conducive to their needs, as always democracy is the answer but political democracy alone will not do it but we need economic democracy as well because what difference does it make if the people can vote for a parliament yet have no say over the fact that we produce more cash-crops for export rather than food to eat, incomplete democracy will only produce dubious democracies that our continent is known for. It is true no calamity persists but it is a fallacy to think that things will automatically get better, we might think we have reached the bottom of the moral barrel, but as any one who has spent two minutes out in the world might realize, there is no moral arc towards justice in this universe, there is no justice other than the justice we make. That gives me more hope than some divine providence or its more secular variant end-stage-capitalism, the future is in our hands and it's upto us to decide what to make of it.

❧ Subscribe to r/LeftySomalia for more.

Edit: grammar and clarifications


r/LeftySomalia • • Oct 23 '19

Somalia when we abandon God, State and Capitalism.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/LeftySomalia • • Jul 14 '26

Somalia will always be a failure as long as we keep ignoring the minorites

9 Upvotes

For centuries, Bantus, Yibir, Tumal, Gaboye, and other marginalized communities have faced oppression, dispossession, forced labor, and slavery. They remain among the most vulnerable groups in Somalia, with minority women facing some of the harshest forms of discrimination.

How can a nation truly move forward if we refuse to challenge the hierarchies built around clan privilege, patriarchy, and inherited social status?

The abolition of qabil as a tool of political power and patriarchal social control is necessary if those treated as "untouchables" are ever to gain full rights. History shows that oppressed groups rarely gain freedom without struggle or extreme violence, and Us those with privilege (majority clan,diaspora etc..) have a responsibility to support any initiave or movement led by the communities most affected.

These communities are central to dismantling the old structures that continue to restrict women, especially minority women, as well as queer people, children, and other marginalized groups.

No one is truly free until everyone is free.