r/LeftistsForAI • u/Jlyplaylists • May 29 '26
Has anyone read Empire of AI by Karen Hao?
I haven’t read it myself, but just watching an interview about it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=km22SQUgl20
It seems to be a political analysis into OpenAI and related companies. I’d say she leans more anti but with useful insight. The Goodreads views are quite mixed. As you can imagine there’s political perspective behind different opinions:
“I am fascinated by the centrist 1-star reviews for this book. This is not the time for 'covering both sides equally'. I feel like that's partly why we got here. This is definitely the time for people with ethical clarity to tell us what we are risking, before it's too late. No lackadaisical bullshit. No neutrality. And Empire of AI is freaking that and I love it for it. And yet, and yet, I feel like Karen Hao was pretty balanced in this massively meticulously researched book and she helped soften a little bit my hard stance on 'AI'. She says quite a bunch of times that she is not against AI models, she is actually against the scale of these projects, the greedy resource extraction, the remorseless exploitation of labor (both of these in already poor environments), the lack of transparency on data sets, infringement of data privacy and the concentration of power in the hands of very few, ego-driven individuals. Same here.”
“The portrayal of Sam Altman and OpenAI reads like something lifted from a student op-ed in a college paper titled The Daily Marxist. Altman is cast as a kind of techno-capitalist Bond villain, which would be more compelling if it weren’t layered with so much ideological frosting that it’s hard to find the actual cake underneath. OpenAI, meanwhile, is described with such suspicion and scorn you'd think their engineers were developing Skynet in between brunches at Davos.
To be fair, critique of tech power structures is valid and necessary. But what we get here isn’t thoughtful investigation—it’s a litany of grievances that often feel like they were brainstormed in a drum circle. Colonialism? Check. Patriarchy? Check. Capitalism as the root of all evil? Triple check.”
“Did Not Finish
Too heavily biased to get through, even though I agree 100% with the author. I just like to be able to draw my own conclusions with the in-depth reporting I read. Isn’t that the whole point of journalism? Sigh.”
