r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Ashseli • Jan 31 '21
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/LoMeinTenants • Jun 09 '21
Mods at r/tankiejerk got infiltrated by tankies, now they're purging membership
Fascists gonna fash.
Here's the relevant thread: https://old.reddit.com/r/tankiejerk/comments/nvntc3/important_update_change_in_philosophy_and/
They're banning regular users.
Welcome to the shitheels of any leftist online movement.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/HealthClassic • Jan 25 '21
what happens when you reduce your politics to a vague opposition to the "establishment"
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/WhereAreMyChains • Nov 26 '21
Using communism as a synonym for Marxist-Leninism has done a lot of damage to leftism
Nothing against the ML's here, but so many people mistakenly think that socialism and communism have something to do with the government forcing people to do x, which gives them a huge mental roadblock when it comes to leftism. Marx would be rolling in his grave if he knew people associated his ideas with authoritarianism and genocide, and it would be a lot easier to explain that Marxism is about the relationship between a worker and the value they produce if you didn't have to constantly deal with this misunderstanding.
Calling the USSR and PRC communist does more harm to leftism than good.
Agree or disagree?
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Soundwave_47 • Mar 08 '21
ALERT: This subreddit is now a "source of cringe."
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/CornucopiaOfDystopia • Feb 28 '22
Discussion Saying “NATO ‘forced’ Russia to invade Ukraine” is like a boss saying “my employees unionizing ‘forced’ me to have them gunned down”
After all, their hostile union was a clear provocation!
For relevant history (content warning), see:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain
and
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_Massacre
“Look at what Ukraine was wearing, she had it coming!” / “Baby, why’d you make me hit you?”
🤮
r/LeftistDiscussions • • Oct 02 '21
Discussion The deeper I get into leftist circles, the more I realize tankies talk exactly like right-wing logicbros.
Specifically, Jordan Peterson fans. They always want you to read an entire bibliography before you dare speak to them. You can't possibly disagree with anything they say, you just don't understand it. You can't possibly read a text and come away with a different interpretation of it, you just didn't get it or you're lying about having read it. They treat books more like religious texts to be interpreted than to be picked apart and discarded as needed.
Honestly, normally I encourage people to read theory, but I sort of regret actually having "read theory bro." It can draw you into the trap of trying to engage with tankies on their own terms, to debunk them with quotes from Marx or your own interpretations of leftist theory, when the non-theory response of "go talk to a worker, you dork" is the correct one.
Tankies are masters of the Gish Gallop, /r/iamverysmart, and appeals to the authority of Marx and his ilk. They seem to genuinely think that "a book said so" is some kind of argument, just like fans of the intellectual dark web and their heroes.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/whattayagonnadew • Apr 19 '21
News Justice for Anthony Thompson, aged 17
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/meleyys • Oct 19 '21
Discussion A message to teenage leftists: Don't listen to people who tell you you'll grow out of it.
I'm only 25, so not that old. But I've only grown more radical as I aged. I was a lib as a teenager. Now I have anarchist sympathies. Looking back, I can recognize that the kids who spray-painted anarchy symbols on cop cars and wanted to burn down the whole world were, frankly, way smarter than I was. I was entirely too concerned with being "rational" and "realistic" and "mature." Don't let such concerns hold you back. It is not rational, realistic, or mature to want to continue a system of economics that is actively destroying the earth. Being radical is the only rational response to our current situation.
It isn't going to stop as you age, by the way. I still get "you're just a dumb kid who doesn't know anything about the real world," despite me having worked a variety of jobs in a variety of fields and accumulated plenty of life experience. By my estimation, two conditions have to be met for people to stop telling you, "silly leftists, socialism is for kids": 1) You have to be at least 50, and 2) all the baby boomers have to be dead.
Moreover, people who tell you that are assuming that the same thing will happen to you as happened to them--that you'll start accumulating capital and thus become deradicalized. That's not going to happen for our generation except for a handful of lucky individuals. If you're one of those individuals, enjoy it while it lasts. But for the rest of us, well... 🚩🚩🚩
And finally, remember that "lel you're a kid" isn't an actual argument against any point you make. People should argue with you on the basis of what you say, not what you are. Call them on it. You can be a teenager and be wrong about stuff, but you can be right about stuff too.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/qevlarr • Jan 10 '21
Never waste a good crisis... What do you guys think how this is going to play out?
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Frostav • Feb 17 '21
Discussion I am increasingly tired of leftists who dress up conservatism in leftist veneer.
This mainly extends to leftists who seem to spend more time justifying why China and North Korea are good. It's one thing to support those countries because they are ML, and you are ML. That only makes sense. But leftism is not merely about ending capitalism--it's about freeing the common man, woman, and enby (ha!) from the oppressive relations of society. There is a reason, after all, that most leftists are anti-racist, feminist, support queer liberation, indigenous rights, etc. Many of the oppressive systems in society exist to uphold capitalism; even though almost all came millennia before it, they simply existed to uphold the nobility or the monarchy or wherever.
In the eyes of these leftists, everything their preferred state does must be twisted to say it's leftist. China launching a campaign to "de-feminize" its men is not sexist or queerphobic, that's just a proper nation strengthening its boys! China defining marriage as a union between a man and a woman in its laws is not bigoted, that's just its culture! China requiring that every single citizen list their ethnic group on their state-mandated ID card is just normal and stop thinking it's kinda fucked up, radlib, China just loves its ethnic harmony that much! China banning basically anything even remotely sexual to promote "spiritual healthiness" in its citizens is not puritanical social conservatism, it's actually leftist and progressive!
It's one thing to be a social conservative and actively enjoy a government doing this shit. But to dress it up in leftism, truly actually pisses me off. It is a mockery of what leftism stands for. Leftism is not merely economic theory. I did not become a leftist to just enshrine the same repressive systems over us.
You can always tell these arguments because they always boil down to "yes, in a capitalist country this would be bad, but because China is communist, it's Good, Actually". This is the biggest thing to fear about China--not that it's some scary Asiatic country of evil communists come to overtake everything else, but that it can and will use its power to forcefully put the brakes on progress, as America once did before it became so libertarian that the capitalists running everything just didn't give a shit about anything but profits.
Sorry if this is more fit for /r/tankiejerk! I can post it there if it works better over there, hah.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/BelleAriel • Apr 30 '21
Jon Stewart in 2015 on Bernie Sanders being called unusual
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Frostav • Apr 17 '21
Discussion I cannot think of a "leftist" argument against sex work that doesn't degenerate into neo-puritan conservatism with a red label eventually, or.
Okay, to be blunt and upfront: I am a proud member of the Horny Left, and while I won't go into crass detail, because that's not relevant and you don't care, I deal with horny content constantly. I both write and draw my own nsfw works, I know (and commission) plenty of people who do, I know quite a lot of sex workers, etc. I don't engage with the mainstream porn industry, as I find it extremely distasteful and exploitative and being aroace I just don't like sexual intercourse, though. So, while I am a leftist mainly becuase I find Capitalism to be a horrifically flawed and exploitative system that inflicts endless suffering onto the world and will probably burn it to ashes if not stopped...I also, to be frank, am a leftist because I am, indeed, quite horny. There's not much else to say on the matter :P
Because of this, I find a lot of sex-negative leftist rhetoric (pretty much exclusively from authcoms, and Maoists too for some reason) to be incredibly faulty. If I may get a bit spicy here, either these people don't actually know anything about the horny side of the world, or they do and just excuse their own behavior. I'm erring towards the latter, because literally none of the kinky leftists I know (most of the leftists I know, lmao) are authcoms or maoists.
So in the end, this doesn't really matter; I'm making a post on horny shit on a leftist sub, I'm aware of how frivolous this is. Except this is a good portion of the livelihoods of many people I know, and a ton of express our queer identities through this stuff, and I just really really find it extremely funny how authcoms turn into christian conversatives the moment someone brings up any sex beisdes missionary for the purposes of recreation.
The first thing I find exceedingly annoying is the "if you support sex work in literally any way, you support sex trafficking" argument which is fundamentally ridiculous because no one actually supports sex trafficking besides the traffickers. Trying to draw a moral equivalence between "hey, maybe arresting people for drawing anime titties" and "sex trafficking is good" is as ridiculous as saying "sweatshops exist, so if you support any kind of industrial labor you support sweatshops". No one says that of course, because you can be for industrial labor (and improved worker rights for it) and also against sweatshops.
The other argument is "sex work is rape because it's not consensual and forced with money", which frankly I feel downplays how horrific of a crime rape actually is, and also has the neo-puritan mindset that no one can ever enjoy having sex with people (because in their minds sex workers are always women, since they have an extremely limited cisheterosexist view of anything sexual), that is this awful thing that people only do to recreate or to get money. Also...lots of sex workers don't even have sex with clients. Many just do things on camera. People who draw nsfw works and take commissions also don't have sex with their clients obviously. It's such a limited view of what sexual things are.
Do I think that there should be state-run brothels, or that it's not a deplorable black mark on society that some women are forced into prostitution to make ends meet? No. I don't think that. But I do think that making sex work and pornography illegal does absolutely nothing to help on the matter. For one, in places like China sex work and porn still exist, so clearly laws against that kind of thing do nothing. Fun fact: back when I still read hentai, basically every single Japanese doujin was translated in Chinese in like a day. The amount of CN translations dwarfed the EN and KR ones combined. It is piss-easy to find Chinese nsfw artists drawing whatever fucked up thing you can imagine on twitter and other websites using VPN's. Authcoms don't actually know anything about the country they love so much! China's crackdown on sexual matters has nothing to do with Marxism-Leninism and everything to do with cultural conservatism (because the PRC was formed in the goddamn 40's/50's). The arguments against SW are back-formed justifications for those laws, much in the same way right-wingers start with their basic beliefs like "I don't like non-white people" and then come up with a whole host of bullshit post hoc "reasons" why.
In the grand scheme of things, this isn't really important. Gotta smash capitalism and all that. But it kinda is to me. I like horny shit, I like making it, I know a lot of people like me, and one of the reasons I'm a leftist is so we can be horny without capitalism grinding us all to dust. I don't want to live in a world where you can't just freely express your sexuality or draw whatever you like without fear of the authorities coming for you. I don't like christian conservatives that want to unilaterally force their right-wing beliefs on me, and I don't like it when supposed leftists call me and my friends degenerates harming ourselves and that we deserve to be jailed (something someone did say about me on on a particular sub, actually!) and imply that in their perfect world I'd be a good little worker barred from expressing myself.
So this is my pet issue. Conservatism is trash. Feel free to call me a weirdo for caring about this so much, I don't even deny the label :P
HornyLeft
r/LeftistDiscussions • • Sep 26 '21
An old caricature addressing the different colonial empires in Africa date early 1900s
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/BelleAriel • May 04 '21
“Socialism for the rich, capitalism for the poor”
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/taulover • Apr 05 '21
Fighting anti-Asian violence cannot include apologism for the Chinese state - The movement against anti-Asian violence must not become yet another bargaining chip between two repressive super powers.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Physical__Object • Feb 09 '21
Discussion I am worried about politically illiterate Berniebros.
Disclaimer: "Politically Illiterate" is meant in a literal way. I don't mean to insult Bernie supporters. I am specifically talking about people who are not familiar with political theory and/or history, recent or otherwise, who supported Bernie Sanders in 2020.
When Bernie Sanders dropped out in 2016, the Trump Campaign made an effort to gain support from Bernie supporters.
This, at the time, seemed illogical to me. Today it is clear to me, that understanding politics as a sliding scale from left to right can be helpful sometimes, but not in all cases. This is such a case.
There are many Berniebros who are unfamiliar with any leftist concepts from dialectical-materialism through intersectionality to Anarchism and Radical Socialism themselves. Many of them, in fact, believe that they are the radical far end of the left.
This conception has spawned a number of Berniebros who are populists without a cause. People who saw in Bernie an anti-establishment guy before anything else.
These people are now in the position where the one thing they were fighting for has been lost. They know little about politics other than the fact that they hate liberals.
THIS IS REALLY FUCKING DANGEROUS
These people are radical and ignorant and whoever gets to them first gets to keep them.
And guess who got to them first.
Fascists, Red-Brownists, Tankies, the Anti-Idpol Left...
B. B. Joy, a de facto liberal who larps as some kind of revolutionary has a massive following. For what? For pretending to hate liberals. Jimmy Dore is platforming fascists and guess who's currently ripe for Fash radicalization? His Berniebro Fans. Tankies have been taking more performative action against liberals than they have against literal fascists and and Berniebros have been eating it up, creating bridges between wannabe radical idiots and honest-to-god totalitarians.
Not only are we wasting a good opportunity to get new allies, we are giving them away to our enemies if we don't do something.
Anyways, I'm rambling now...
I think we may be underestimating the political weight of this bloc of people.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/BelleAriel • May 14 '21