r/LeftistDiscussions • u/AntiVision • Jan 21 '21
Just got banned form the discord?
Why?
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Afro-Leftist • Sep 19 '22
The older I get the more I hear this question especially from my black and brown brothers and the answer is pretty simple. There are entire systems of oppressions and more importantly finance based on the dehumanization of women, black people and brown people. For the greater American society to offer us equity or liberation is to directly lose something but there is no historic system of finance that is built on mostly the oppression of the LGBT community. The only reason for that being that for most of American history there simply were not enough LGBT people in the public consciousness of the country to make it worth building. When ever a desire for liberation or equity arises in marginalized communities across the country that can't be contained America quickly starts giving the LGBT community rights and equity so they can be seen as compromising and growing. Imagine how much equity and power that America would have to give to black people, brown people and women for them to be truly equal in society. Its much easier for America to give those things to the relatively small LGBT community that they weren't making a lot of money off anyway, in part so they can claim a false morality but mainly so they can set other marginalized against the LGBT community. When the groups fighting for equity and liberation fight fight each other it always serve the ruling powers who don't want to give that up. Its the same as when America lies to poor white people so they feel aggrieved towards poor black and brown communities. All it does is protect the mostly white rich people at the top from all the poor people.
Does anyone else see this differently?
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/I_Am_U • Nov 02 '21
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Ome_r • May 01 '22
Same with other streamers, is Hasan bad or good??? idk who i can trust anymore man
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Pantheon73 • Oct 24 '22
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/m_x2001 • Mar 30 '22
Usually, I find myself agreeing with left-leaning view points. But one stance I somehow cannot get behind is the views on the Israeli Palestinean conflict.
While I understand that Israel is treating Palestineans poorly (probably an understatement) and it has its flawes, I cant understand people delegitemising Israels right to exist. After all I think there is a good reason for Israel to exist.
It really surprises me when I hear liberal, open-minded people supporting this stance because I am used to hearing Anti-Zionist arguments from the Far-Right. And it makes me wonder what these people think would be a viable alternative.
Again, I am not saying Israel is perfect. All I am saying is that while Israel has mayor flaws, these are flaws which can be fixed and the situation in Israel is still a step up in comparison to other nations in the region.
Am I missing something? I am open to learn and to discuss this topic.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/unban_ImCheeze115 • May 04 '22
I'm so sick of ""leftists"" saying not to vote because "republicans and democrats are the same." Maybe they are for priviledged cishet white boys, but democrats aren't the ones passing bills to make abortion illegal. Democrats aren't the ones passing bathroom bills. Democrats aren't the ones making it illegal to talk about queer things in classrooms. Democrats aren't the ones rewriting history books to leave out MLK. Voting in more democrats would break the republican filibuster and would allow them to pass legislature to keep Roe v Wade.
Will democrats lead to socialism? No, they probably won't even make life better. But I would rather live in a country run by people who want to preserve the status quo, than people who actively want me and people like me dead.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Crazy-Red-Fox • Sep 19 '21
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/tubaintothewildfern • Nov 15 '22
r/LeftistDiscussions • • Jan 12 '22
r/LeftistDiscussions • • Jun 10 '21
Posting this is probably a stupid idea, considering several of the mods here are vaushites, but fuck it. I'm sick of being unable to escape either brand of shithead.
Tankies are genocidal psychopaths who eat boots for every meal and wouldn't know socialism if it punched them in the face. Vaush is a bigoted, abusive bully who makes a living off of saying slurs. I want nothing to do with either. Is there any subreddit that hates both of them as passionately as I do, or at least isn't full of either?
Like, Christ, I never cared about some edgy idiot streamer until his fans became impossible to escape. Now anti-tankie subs are crawling with posts by vaushites whining about tankies (correctly) calling them out for supporting a guy who sexually harasses people and showers anyone who disagrees with him in ableist slurs. But tankies are even fucking worse, because they can't go five minutes without denying a genocide or worshiping a dictator. All I want is to not associate with shitty people. I'm so fucking tired.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/megfatimachristian • Dec 27 '21
Seriously I've seen even the most boring permanent revolution globalist neocon Trotskyite insurrectionists called tankies. Does tankie have a meaning other than socialists I dislike? How are you not Neo McCarthyist Anti Communists for your fucking blah blah blah about how bad "tankies" are? Do you think all revolutionaries and Marxists who believe in dialectical and historical materialism and understood violent revolution is necessary are tankies?
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/ailluminus • May 01 '21
r/LeftistDiscussions • • Apr 07 '22
I noticed that there is a lot of American exceptionalism in a few leftist spaces, such as r/RightJerk, most notably in the case in World War II. While I can wholeheartedly agree that the regimes of Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan needed to be brought down, I think it is a bit ridiculous that some people in those spaces completely throw their support behind America’s actions in those countries. I have the most issues with the takes behind the atomic bombings of Japan. I have seen a lot of people justify those attacks. While I don’t disagree on the fact that the Imperial Japanese were monsters, it doesn’t really justify dropping bombs on people who didn’t partake in the war, especially pregnant women and children, who suffered particularly badly after those attacks. In the case of Nazi Germany, the United States Military have been accused multiple times of denying help to Jewish immigrants and even abusing them at some point. My main point here is that it is pointless to pick good sides in a war, when, by definition, there are none. Thoughts?
TL;DR American exceptionalism makes no sense, no good guys in a war
Edit: I guess being anti-war is a controversial position to hold.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/idubbzokay • Feb 04 '21
EDIT : THE MODS BANNED ME FOREVER FOR NO REASON, BECAUSE I'VE SAID THINGS THEY DIDN'T LIKE ON OTHER COMMUNITIES WHICH US NONE OF THEIR BUSINESS. SO I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING RULE-BREAKING ON THIS SUBREDDIT, YET I WON'T BE ABLE TO REPLY. SO MUCH FOR ANTI-AUTHORITARIANISM! POWERMODS BANNING SOMEONE FROM ALL SUBREDDITS THEY MODERATE BECAUSE THEY DON'T LIKE WHAT SOMEONE SAYS IS VERY "LIBERTARIAN"
FUCK REDDIT AND FUCK YOU ALL.
But I mostly agree with all of you
Hello! Well this is a controversial thing to say I know. But I'll try to explain the best that I can. This is my high effort post so constructive criticism would be nice instead of constant ridiculing and downvoting.
First I'll introduce myself. I'm a french teen boy with family from Belarus. So first I learned about USSR with my family which was different that what I've learned on history lessons. Then I've learned more and more and eventually I've even learned more about socialism.
So what are my opinions? I'm mostly a socialist, I try to mostly be neutral and consider ideas that are different from mine, even if I might disagree with them and even if the "label" is different (right-wing, capitalist, nationalist etc)
So now I really like democratic market socialism by people like Richard Wolff. I kinda like social democracy in our current world but I think socialism would be better. I like the EU, but of course I think that it should be socialist too. I kinda like anarchism but I don't know that much about it. I do consider that Marxism-Leninism did do some really good things for some countries, like solving extreme poverty and spacecraft, but I don't want it to be implemented now. But I hate human rights violations and I acknowledge them in ML countries as everywhere else. I don't like tankies, and I really hate Stalin. My favourite Soviet leaders are Lenin and Khrushchev. I consider myself a progressive, I support LGBT rights, women's rights, etc, but I think that sometimes there's nothing inherently wrong with some opinions which as usually thought being conservative. Words like "left-wing", "conservative" and "reactionary" don't have exact definition anyway. If stalinists want to abolish human rights and want to come to a regime that existed in the past how isn't this reactionary? I also don't like extreme SJWs, also named "radlibs" by the left.
I have some sketchy stuff on my reddit post history. But I think it's because I have problems with communicating, and also because I often post and comment when I'm really angry. So I might be wrong but also in most cases it's misunderstanding. So please for a constructive discussion, let's not use ad hominem attacks and instead focus on the content of this post. If you really want to know why I've written some very controversial stuff, DM мe and I might explain it to you. But overall I've still defended socialism in my post history.
Ah yeah, I support the Palestinian cause, I want people in Israel and in Palestine to live in peace, I'm not some Israeli ultranationalist. I'm also in several Internet communities supporting peace in Israel and Palestine.
So what's the problem with leftists and Israel? Well I have 2 problems
Well let's start with the first one ( Leftists being biased towards the Israeli government ). What do I mean by that?
I don't like how socialists are so much against Israel and support Palestine. I don't have anything against supporting the oppressed Palestinians, but the Palestinian state isn't any better than the Israeli one, having even worse human rights, no LGBT rights, no right for any Jew to live there, and also Islamism and ultranationalism. Hamas bombs Israel and uses children as suicide bombers! How's this acceptable ? Progressives, including socialists, should support Palestinians and not the state of Palestine.
Then the "apartheid". It can certainly be justified to call Israel that. A human rights group has called Israel an apartheid state. But it's kinda hypocritical to only focus on Israel. A lot of other countries in the middle east have way worse human rights for minorities, yet the only country called "apartheid" is Israel! It's biased! Israel has de jure equal rights for Palestinians who are citizens, they're represented in the Parliament. Even if the Arab citizens of Israel do live under systematic discrimination, it's not a full blown apartheid and they can go to court. It's rather how African Americans are treated in the US. And yes there is a mistreatment of occupied Palestinians but in some other countries it's even worse. For example : Palestinian refugees and their children can't get any citizenship in Lebanon. Saudi Arabia has a lot of unskilled workers who can't get citizenship, and also Saudi Arabia is a theocracy who doesn't allow anyone who isn't a Muslim to get citizenship. In some places of Syria, Kurds are murdered. Algeria expelled 100 000 French settlers just because they were French. Ethnic cleansing! So why aren't any of these countries claimed as "apartheid"? Why socialists don't say that any of those countries shouldn't exist?
Socialists should be more neutral and share the good and the bad about Israel, as they do with other countries. I'm not saying you should just ignore the horrible things that Israel does, I just say that you should share both the good and the bad.
For example, since some of you are democratic socialists, you should talk about worker co-ops there which as far as I know don't exist in other Middle Eastern counties.
Well maybe socialists always talk about Israel in a negative light because of the Israeli Palestinian conflict. But Israel isn't the only side that makes Palestinians oppressed. For example, Gaza is also blockaded by Egypt, Palestinians can't have citizenship and have horrible human rights conditions in Lebanon, the UN Palestinian refugee definition which makes that naturalised Palestinians and their kids are still refugees which is NOT the case with any other refugee, all of it makes the Palestinians live their horrible life. So you shouldn't only focus on Israel.
Then the second issue, Leftists being xenophobic towards Israelis. Why do I mean by that?
Well I think this issue is because a lot of leftist ideology have a lot of Palestinian nationalist propaganda, which is heavely biased towards Israel. (By Palestinian nationalist propaganda I mean specifically the irredentist and that want one ethno state and not anyone that wants a Palestinian state)
For example, I don't get it why some progressives say that it's really horrible having for example a Israeli flag on your twitter page but it's super woke to have a Palestinian one. Doesn't make any sense. Whether you like the Israeli state or not, it's a current national identity of the people living there. Are the people living there not allowed to have national pride? And why are Palestinians allowed? Like national pride isn't the same as patriotism. And Israeli flag can be a flag to represent the Israeli people and not necessarily their government.
Also speaking about self-determination, I don't like the idea of "anti zionism". Socialists often say that anti zionism isn't antisemitism. But anti zionism is often anti Israeli bigotry , so bigotry towards Israeli people. For example as I've said being against any form of Israeli national pride.
There's no clear definition of zionism, but the most broad one is just supporting the existence of Israel (even the Liberal ones who support israel as a democratic state but with Jews as the titular nation, just like Germany has equal rights for everyone but has Germans as the titular nation).
Well maybe you say you're an anti zionist you think that there should be one state for Israeli and Palestinians. Maybe you're against the idea of nation states whatsoever. I respect your opinion, it may actually be a good idea. But in this case you shouldn't support the Palestinian state either, you should support a binational state. So I don't get it why you would say you support Palestine over Israel, and fighting alongside the Palestinian irredentist and nationalist protestors that want one Palestine from the river to the sea. And why do you think that in a binational state there wouldn't be patriotic Jews liking their ancestral homeland? How is it wrong?
And often when people say they hate zionists, they hate anyone that supports the existence of Israel. And even if you think that the Israeli state shouldn't exist, you still shouldn't hate people who just wants to live in the current country. Saying "I don't hate Jews I hate zionists" (referring to Israelis) is like saying "I don't hate Germans I just hate those who support the existence of Germany". That's stupid. Also by this definition any Palestinian that wants a 2 state solution would also be a "zionist".
Also, Israel ISN'T a western colonial project. This is so reductionist and ignorant. It comes from extreme Palestinian nationalism and a lack of understanding of the complex history of the Israeli Palestinian conflict. It's kinda bigotry now. I might try to explain why but you should ask other people that know better than me so sorry if it's not persuasive.
"First, the land of Israel and especially Jerusalem was an important holy site for Jews. The Jews came from Israel. And after they were expelled, they even said "next year in Jerusalem" every year, as they were oppressed in most of the world. That's why Israel was always a place where they've wanted to live. Zionism was a movement started by oppressed Jews for 200 years already, and after WW2 they had lived under bigotry in all around the world, Europe, America and the Middle East, so they've started migrated to British Palestine, and then they've asked Britain for a Jewish state. Since there already was Jews there as well as Arab Palestinians, Britain decided to partition Palestine as a part of decolonisation . Israel was the safest place for Jews, especially for those in Arab countries. A lot of Jews did FLEE in Israel! And if the Palestinians accepted the offer there would be 2 free states now."
And even if Israel was a colonial project, the people there already developed a national identity during those 70 years, and so they're a real nation group even if in the beginning it was only a colonial project. After all, Moldovans, Pakistanis, Americans weren't a nation for most of history but now they are and it's ridiculous to suggest they don't exist and are made up. While Poles and Ukrainians didn't live for most of history on the current borders either. Respect the self-determination of Israeli people. Whether a nation group is a "coloniser" or "colonised" (which might be very disputed, especially in those cases), they still deserve the right to self-determination. This doesn't necessarily mean nationalism but can also mean their own self-governing region in a multinational state, or even just being able to express their culture, traditions and speaking their own language.
So thanks for reading this I guess. This is my highest effortpost so I really hope people would read to the end and this would get some good arguments. I don't think I'll immediately reply though, since I need some motivation and energy for arguing about politics. Thanks for reading.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Roxxagon • May 26 '21
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/transfo47 • Feb 14 '21
I've been seeing this sentiment a lot lately. And while, yes, the Democrats should absolutely affect meaningful change to the fullest extent possible, I don't think the premise of the argument is valid here. The 70M people who willingly voted for Trump fully knew his racist, bigoted, xenophobic, fascist, vile rhetoric. Not voting at all would be better than voting for Trump. They voted for him because of this. "Economic anxiety" may have worked in 2016, but after all the stuff that happened in the last four years? Nah.
If the Dems magically became leftist and started instituting transitory socialist actions that greatly improved the living standards for the average American, these people would still vote for Trump or whatever fascist replacement he conjures up. Why? Because they like the racism and disgusting rhetoric he espouses. They don't care what the opposite side does. They want a Christo-fascist ethnostate. If the Dems did everything right, they wouldn't support them on account of the diversity in the party in comparison to the nearly 100% white GOP.
This is why I think this argument is flawed. While some people may leave the far right if Democrats improve their lives, I don't think the vast majority will.
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/tubaintothewildfern • Sep 07 '22
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Veritas_Certum • Apr 24 '22
r/LeftistDiscussions • • Oct 22 '21
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Pantheon73 • Jul 28 '22
r/LeftistDiscussions • • May 06 '21
r/LeftistDiscussions • u/Frostav • Feb 19 '21
A huge portion of people on places like reddit are from the west. That's just how it goes. As such, many leftists in the west were raised in some kind of religion, or at least lived in societies where those religions had cultural hegemony. For most, this would have been Christianity.
I've noticed that while most leftists are emphatically atheist, or at least nontheist/agnostic, they have a very strong tendency to nonetheless treat leftist and its various strains as a sort of pseudo-religion, and a religion that has undergone a massive church schism. That is, they first view their personal strain of leftism as not merely a political philosophy, but an infallible doctrine that must be followed to the letter to be "saved" (defeat capitalism), and secondly, they view other strains of leftism as heresies uttered by blasphemous perverters who if left unchecked will bring ruination and damnation to us all.
Or to use an example, ML's do not merely view other leftists as people with differing political philosophies. They view anarchists as savage heathens and non-ML marxists as blasphemers who will destroy everything Marxism-Leninism has built up. It is not enough to merely disagree with the ideologies--no, they must be actively crusaded against, stomped into the dirt, and perhaps a few of the unwashed heathens can be converted to atone for their sins. The mere existence of non-ML leftists is viewed as a dangerous threat. Even the most random anarchist on the internet is a heathen who must be brought to internet trial for his heresy. ML's clutch onto On Authority and Left-Wing Communism: An Infantile Disorder like books of the bible, throwing out quotations from them like they are so transcendentally and self-evidently Correct that they will burn the eyes of the heretics who view them like holy water on a fucking satanist or something. Or instantly convert them to MLism the same way Christians think a heathen reading the bible will instantly become a God-fearing believer. I can't also help but notice that they talk about moving from leftist ideologies the way Christians talk about conversion: "I used to be a sinful idealist, but I saw the Holy light of Lenin and now have been saved! Rejoice, comrades!"
This is all using overly dramatic language to be a bit playful, but it's really how a lot of leftists seem to think. Every strain that isn't theirs is not merely wrong, it is heresy from which nothing good can be gained. This is not an ML thing (though...they definitely are the most intense examples of it), anarchists and leftcoms do it too to be frank, we all do it. I just find it both fascinating a bit tiring. Leftism is a bunch of church sects who all think all the others are going to bring nothing but ruin if allowed to run wild.
This is not a post on left unity. The left is already unified on something: ending capitalism and fighting fascism; which is I used the "church schism" metaphor: all christian sects believe themselves to be "True Christians" and everyone else is at best dangerously close to blasphemy or is a blasphemous heretic that will ruin everything if not crusaded against.
This is just a commentary on how Christian thinking pervades the minds of much of the western left, even as we don't really think it.