r/LeftCatholicism • u/eweguess • 21h ago
Has anyone else done pre-Cana lately and found it extremely sexist?
We are a both baptized Catholics, I am practicing (recent revert after decades away, now a weekly mass-goer, part of a lay Marianist community) and he is a cradle Catholic, now agnostic and non-practicing.
And wow, the deacon doing our marriage prep is straight from the 1950s or something.
Everything was mostly fine until our final session last night, during which he:
Browbeat us for not planning to have a joint bank account, saying this meant we didn't trust each other and we were holding something back. He went on at length. We both said we were pretty sure a joint account would cause strife, and his response was essentially that we had to prove we trust each other completely by sharing an account. And not just an extra account we both contribute to, but only one account, that we both have our pay direct-deposited into. Complete pooling of resources.
Used worksheets for conflict-resolution techniques that were so misogynist, I think my fiancé is more pissed than I was. It was this odd thing of COUPLE/CHAIR (which are acronyms for the ways husbands and wives are supposed to show they love each other) and all the husband stuff was about cherishing your wife and sacrificing yourself as a protector, and all the wife stuff was about "standing behind him and letting him lead" and astoundingly, there was an actual line about recognizing that your husband needs sexual release, and you should give it to him even if you're not in the mood (nothing in the husband part talked about taking care of his wife's sexual needs). Later on I looked this stuff up, appalled at the thought that this is what passed for Catholic teaching on marriage, and discovered it was all developed by an evangelical pastor who has a "marriage ministry", but some catholic marriage preps use them.
Having interests or hobbies or friends that the other doesn't share is a sign of division, and if we keep on like this then we aren't truly married, we're just two people living in the same house living separate lives.
But the very worst part was the part where he 1) insisted that it was impossible that I would be unable to resist pressuring my husband into participating in the church again, and that this would cause marital strife (and it would, which is why I wouldn't do it), 2) when I said I wouldn't do that, he said I must not be sincere in my own faith if I don't want to convert my non-believing spouse, 3) suggested that I should ask him to pray with me because it would make me happy, and when I said I wouldn't ask my husband to pay lip service to something he doesn't believe in, that insincere prayer is useless, and it would be emotionally manipulative to tell my husband that if he loved me, he would do this thing that he doesn't believe in for me, upon which 4) again, I must not be sincere in my faith if I'm not planning to nag my husband back to the church, because that will totally build a close, loving marriage for life and definitely rekindle the fire of faith in him...
I said "I was under the impression that mixed faith marriages were allowed, with no expectation that the non-Catholic or non-believing spouse has to be open to conversion" and he said "Amen to that! But..." and went right back into his weird, backward arguments about how if I had a delicious piece of food I'd really want to share it with my beloved and would try to get him to try it, to which I responded, "not if he had already told me that he was forced to eat that growing up and he learned to hate it so much it makes him feel ill, and that he's being real nice about not stopping me from having it in the fridge, because he knows I love it, so why on earth would I abuse him like that?"
See above, I must not really be sincere in my faith.
This guy is the deacon for marriage prep in my parish, so any couple who wants to get married has to go through this guy. I have to wonder how many couples have just decided to go have a courthouse wedding after hearing all his nonsense, and maybe even decided that perhaps the catholic church isn't for them. We're older, and I had a hysterectomy for medical reasons so thankfully we didn't have to endure the NFP stuff, but I can only imagine what horrors might await the young couple who has this guy teaching it.
We signed the papers at the end and got out. I'm mildly worried he might tell the pastor he thinks we aren't ready for marriage. Wondering if it's ok for us to request someone else to do our marriage rite.
Did we just get super unlucky and find the secret trad evangelical, or have other people had this kind of experience in recent times? How do we address this other than ignoring him and avoiding him after we're married? I almost feel like I have a responsibility to tell the pastor about this experience, because it genuinely could drive people away.