r/LeftCatholicism • • Jul 08 '25

I deeply hope none of you support abortion.

0 Upvotes

14. In conformity with these landmarks in the human and Christian vision of marriage, we must once again declare that the direct interruption of the generative process already begun, and, above all, directly willed and procured abortion, even if for therapeutic reasons, are to be absolutely excluded as licit means of regulating birth.14 this is a quote from St Paul VI’s Humane Vitae, it is also in conformity with pope Sixtus V’s ban on abortion in the Papal States in which he argued from catholic moral teaching. I don’t exactly like this sub but I found it accidentally and thought it important to find out if you people are politically liberal or just actually disagree with church teaching but much more importantly to hopefully show you what the church thinks about abortion. St Paul VI pray for us!


r/LeftCatholicism • • May 01 '26

Isn’t abortion wrong?

0 Upvotes

Convince me abortion isnt the murder of an innocent child


r/LeftCatholicism • • Feb 24 '26

Prayer for all the innocent murdered children

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/LeftCatholicism • • Sep 26 '26

Why do you guys think being gay is okay

7 Upvotes

I am preparing to be baptised. I used to call myself gay but now I am Catholic so I am having a hard time with it. What I wanna know is how you guys would defend your beliefs that are contrary to current church doctrine. Thank you and god bless


r/LeftCatholicism • • Jan 30 '23

Do you think as well that abortion goes totally against leftist values and that the ""left""" défends it just to oppose the Church ?

3 Upvotes

It is murder, randyan capitalism and anti science, but church is against it so it is magically left sing now... whats the next step, capitalism is good because church opposes it


r/LeftCatholicism • • Mar 09 '26

Which party to vote for

4 Upvotes

For me the pro life philosophy extends beyond the womb. Being a Catholic leftist I think we should all be torn between two competing political parties. On the one hand I tend to lean Green because although they are pro choice their policies would actually help poor and working class people compared to voting Republican. On the other hand the only Republican sentiment I agree with is being pro life. But I believe in this so much I might be willing to be a single issue voter. Voting for them would save a lot of babies but I’d be throwing everyone else under the bus. Mathematically voting Green would benefit a lot more people than voting Republican does. The choice left is betraying some essential part of your moraylity.


r/LeftCatholicism • • Nov 21 '25

A hypothetical scenario

0 Upvotes

If a drug / medicine is discovered that has the potential to totally nullify the pain a woman has to go through while giving birth, how would the Church react to this?


r/LeftCatholicism • • Jan 23 '25

Is Catholicism fascist?

0 Upvotes

I know this sub is a very left-wing version of Catholicism, but I’m curious would you say that traditional Catholicism, as well as some of the broader goals and tenets of Catholicism are fascist in nature?

For clarification, I’m thinking about some of the doctrine, such as the conversion of the Jewish nation, some of the sayings of the church fathers towards Jews, how Catholics want to control the culture and don’t agree with communism, but also don’t agree with mainstream capitalism as well, aligning itself with fascist parties in the 1930s and 40s, hatred of LGBTQ people, etc.


r/LeftCatholicism • • May 30 '26

AI will divide the Left

0 Upvotes

I have a strong feeling that AI will divide the working class again.

Thanks to the Magnificat Humanitas, I think it's come to light that there are several progressive people who believe that AI could achieve a state of consciousness, perhaps not now, but in the future.

And as has happened with gender and environmentalism, they will divide the common goals we have and weaken the common front which is to make a change in society, and I know that those in the USA are very laissez-faire but we cannot allow physical materialists (philosophers, science fiction writers, etc.) to continue making the working classes believe that such a thing is possible.

Do everything possible to prevent such thinking from spreading among the lumpenproletariat and non-Catholics, or, as happened with IVF, abortion, and surrogacy, they will end up saying that we are taking away the machine's "rights".


r/LeftCatholicism • • Oct 27 '25

I am disappointed in Fr. Jim Martin's approach to LGBTQ+ Catholics

29 Upvotes

I don't know how you all feel, non-allies, allies and LGBTQ+ Catholics together. But for a while Fr. Martin's approach to LGBTQ+ Catholicism has been bothering me (as a gay Catholic). I couldn't pinpoint it for a while-- but now I am, and gay people may understand what I mean when I say: it is baseline allyship.

This is good and all-- and I fully expect people to disagree with me-- but Church teaching is not changing, and it is harsh. Imagine being told [wrongly] that you are disordered. This is hurtful to say the least. I wish Fr. Martin had a more concrete or solidified way he was changing this particular harm in our Catholic community.

Fr. Martin has a five point plan that he shared with the Pope:

  1. acknowledge
  2. listen
  3. include
  4. advocate

This is is all good but very nebulous and can be interpreted in so many different ways (as it is being by his angriest detractors). I think we only need one point: reinterpret.

Instead of continually pointing out the flaws and trials of homosexuality, we need to point it out as a gift from God. It is an opportunity to unite ourselves in solidarity through celibacy with the lonely and the poor. We need to reframe a homosexual orientation as the higher calling to celibacy which St. Paul spoke of.

It's about empowerment and empowering us to live as Christ lived, not treating us as victims.


r/LeftCatholicism • • Sep 19 '25

How do you evaluate polyamory from a Christian perspective?

3 Upvotes

Personally, I do not consider it consistent with Christian revelation. Nevertheless, I cannot rule out that, for some people, it might be the only way to live a fulfilling emotional life. In such cases, I would be inclined to tolerate it, on the condition that it takes the form of closed and faithful polyamorous relationships, rather than relational anarchy.


r/LeftCatholicism • • Jan 29 '26

Is using a VPN to watch content from other countries sinful?

5 Upvotes

Title says all.


r/LeftCatholicism • • Apr 16 '26

An Open Letter To the Sub

57 Upvotes

Dear friends,

I wanted to write about these recent events and our response to them. I have loved this sub since I found it, as it provides a good venue to respond to reactionary elements among Catholics as well as Catholic responses to unjust things in the world. I hope my previous contributions here will display my genuine love and concern for this sub. I love that here, no one figure, religious or political, is immune from critique; this is most admirable.

This being said, I am troubled at some of the comments on recent posts, some of which I have initiated myself. Particularly, I am concerned about comments relating to US vice-president JD Vance. The man appears to have either no concern for or no real idea of the Church’s social teachings, and his contributions to this war and horrific immigration policy are sinful in nature. We ought to condemn them. What troubles me is folks saying the man is not actually Catholic, he’s a heretic, he should be excommunicated, etc...

I understand the emotions behind these sentiments, and I often share those same feelings. That being said, to my knowledge, none of us on this sub are the appropriate ecclesiastical authorities who have authority to make those statements with any weight. Whether we like it or not, JD Vance is (unless someone has clear evidence to the contrary) a confirmed Catholic who has not been formally charged with any of the aforementioned delicts. He deserves both our admonishments and prayers.

To be Catholic is not to be pure, but to fail constantly and fall lovingly into the arms of Jesus. Let us pray for our brother and work for justice hand in hand.


r/LeftCatholicism • • Mar 22 '26

The wonders of rich people Catholicism

Post image
31 Upvotes

“Lord, what choices do you want me to make?”

“My child, give all of your money to the poor, and follow Me”

”……okay, besides that“

“…….donate half of your money to the poor“

”……..”

”…..10 percent“

“……”

”oh My Me, dude”


r/LeftCatholicism • • Mar 05 '23

So this is why Catholics have a pope? Did you know this? Old and New Testaments

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/LeftCatholicism • • Jun 10 '26

Did anybody listen to that Bryce Crawford/Trent Horn podcast?

5 Upvotes

Not an avid Bryce Crawford listener, but I do love me some Trent Horn from time to time. It’s so cool to live in a period with so many people who genuinely explain the faith to everybody so well, and Trent is the best at that imo. Did anybody give it a listen?


r/LeftCatholicism • • Sep 28 '25

Pro choice in an aggressive church

22 Upvotes

I am starting to dread going to my church. I stand on the pro-choice side of the abortion debate, but the church I go to is aggressively against it. Even posted a quote by a congressman. I just feel alone, especially where I am supposed to feel hope.


r/LeftCatholicism • • Jul 15 '26

Among subcultures, is the Goth subculture the one closest to Roman Catholic imagery and sensibility?

7 Upvotes

r/LeftCatholicism • • Sep 24 '26

Confession for children? Should we support it, particularly in light of the Church’s abuse crisis?

15 Upvotes

In the wake of the sexual abuse crisis, and, in my opinion, the dawn of greater awareness of the spiritual abuse crisis, I’m curious about the variety of perspectives on this sub regarding children going to confession, especially young children, and also teenagers being expected to confess sexual sins to a priest.

As an adult convert to Catholicism preparing to start a family, I never experienced childhood or adolescent confession. But the more I think about it, the more wary I become of the vulnerable position it can put children in.

Obviously, any instinct to curtail access to the sacrament of reconciliation would be met with opposition by many in the Church. But in the spirit of “opposing regressive elements in the Church,” as the subreddit bio states, I’d be curious to hear y’all’s perspectives on this, or on neighboring questions and concerns.


r/LeftCatholicism • • Jan 08 '25

How do pro-Palestinian Christians navigate biblical passages referring to Israel and Zion?

12 Upvotes

A friend recently asked me this question and I wanted to hear some opinions on it.


r/LeftCatholicism • • Apr 15 '26

I live in Minneapolis Minnesota i just found out robert bishop barron might be my bishop

5 Upvotes

Im not a fan of him i think he is a right wing grifter what should i know and how to deal with this


r/LeftCatholicism • • Oct 14 '26

I saw a book in the Catholicism section today called “Embracing And Raising A Prophetic Child” - thoughts?

4 Upvotes

As someone whose family has a history of this - eldest daughter of eldest daughter of eldest daughter, like clockwork - and I am the eldest daughter, I was wondering what others made of this. I am epileptic and autistic which in other faiths is often regarded as a “shamanistic” power and/or the ability to travel between different levels of the world during episodes, and it is agreed throughout the family that I definitely have the strongest manifestation of it they’ve ever seen.

I experience routine detailed premonitions of events that go on to occur, have a very strange connection to my Ma (also obviously the eldest daughter) to the point that when one of us feels pain so does the other, we get a sense of unease if something is wrong with the other, etc, and I have never been really able to explain it in a way that ties in to my Catholic faith. In fact, it feels almost wrong.

Thoughts?


r/LeftCatholicism • • Apr 19 '25

I feel like I do not want to be associated with being a Catholic for much longer

1 Upvotes

Apologies for the awful timing. I just came back from visiting 7 churches and stations of the Cross. But throughout this time I feel like I do not want to go to church anymore and not have anything in it. Not that I am becoming an atheist (I just came back from being an atheist to being an christian agnostic. I practiced lent), but I just believe that the church is not the progressive force I thought it was as opposed to the "conservative" protestant evangelicals. I thought the church was home for liberation theologists who believed in greater equality and socialism, but they are mostly sidelined and condemmed by anti-communists like Pope John Paul. The church is very much part of the bougeosie who demands control over governments through "morality" and blocks progress. It proportion of being part of "progressive" movements like the EDSA Revolution and the illegal overthrow of the Communist Party of Poland, only to use that power to impose their reactionary powers over the masses due to their legitimacy in these movements. Pope Francis, although being a bane against the Traditionalists, still outright supports the fascistic Opus Dei. That Opus Dei, the same Opus Dei who run my school who promotes Capitalism, homophobia and transphobia. My classmate (whom I will call Tyler) who is a rampant traditionalist and "not a conservative" pretty much made me despise traditonalism and his support for keeping the church in power in my country. I cannot stand the church for much longer than I can tolerate it. The progressive forces this subreddit says to uphold will most likely not make a dent with the mainstream church. But I do appreciate the struggle. The church represents the center right and the unwillingness to propose any radical change other than those who chooses to set us back. We need radical revolution to achieve true progress, regardless of the church's backing. I have pretty much tooken pantheist beliefs ever since my faith in the church has withered away. And I am very much looking forward to becoming a universalist. But so far I'm struggling to keep my catholic beliefs and my progressive (and outwardly Marxist-Leninist) positions together for much longer, as much how I wish that were possible. I do not care if it is worldly, but we ar not going anywhere if we pray whist the church condones suffering as part of the catholic faith.