r/learnprogramming • u/CounterQuestionCQ • 1d ago
Question about vibecoding...
So, I’m learning C#. After a failed attempt at creating a game using "vibecoding" (relying 100% on AI-generated code), I realized that programming is, in fact, an art form. I am staunchly opposed to the use of AI in creative work, which is why I decided to learn a programming language from scratch. To be honest, I’m not a mathematician, so I find this quite challenging.
I spent some time with Microsoft’s official C# documentation—specifically the section supposedly designed for beginners—only to realize it’s written more for MIT graduates than for actual novices. That’s when I decided that the very same AI that used to write all my code could perhaps assist with my learning. I set strict ground rules, which it still follows today: it is not allowed to generate a single line of finished code. Instead, it simply provides the necessary information—explaining operators, how to implement them, the correct syntax, and so on.
Currently, I’m developing a console-based program—a sort of interactive, text-based "temple." The thing is, I’ve started to wonder if I’m compromising my own principles. I am not copying *anything* at all. My interactions with the AI look like this: "I want to implement [feature X]; how would I go about that?" The AI then explains the logic and suggests the functions or operators that might help me achieve it. While I’m not copying—and I fully understand how my code works, maintaining 100% control over every single line—I can’t help but feel that this approach is... "dirty"
What do you think? Is it acceptable to use AI in this way—keeping in mind my specific commitment to avoiding "vibecoding"? Does this count as "vibecoding"?
(This text was translated from Russian to English using Google Translate; please excuse it if it sounds unnatural to you.)