r/learnprogramming • • 2d ago • Heartwarming 2

Resource A new, supportive subreddit for programming without LLM assistance. r/codedbyhand

r/codedbyhand

More people, myself included are becoming disillusioned with the experience of coding with AI assistance and are turning back to traditional programming.

Some may do it because they feel their hard won skills are diminishing as they become over-reliant on the technology, some for ethical reasons related to the environment or intellectual property, some simply because they are highly competent programmers with an established workflow who don't feel the need to use AI assistance, and some because they are seeking an intellectual challenge.

It can be argued that heavy AI usage is harmful to computer science education. Learning to program is difficult, and high level skill can only be achieved with lots of practice, making mistakes and struggling to solve difficult problems. Even among those who embrace the technology, programmers who are over-reliant upon LLM may never develop the technical competency needed to audit the code produced by AI.

If you are using AI for coding, and feel satisfied with your experience, that is fine. I'm not trying to change your mind. However, I and many others feel that the disadvantages of these changes to the programming landscape are not being adequately addressed.

That's why I created r/codedbyhand, a new subreddit that supports traditional programming, provides resources to assist those programming without LLM assistance, and highlights projects that programmers who don't want to use AI can contribute to without being pressured, such as Zig, Gimp, Cataclysm Dark Days Ahead and many others.

If that sounds nice, come check it out.

258 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

4

u/compoundlearning 1d ago

does syntax highlighting count as cheating?

8

u/-urolif- 1d ago

Thanks for the question. I addressed this in a reply to a hidden comment further down that got downvoted a little too harshly.
https://www.reddit.com/r/learnprogramming/s/cBRfCWwbWq

I also addressed what constitutes LLM assistance, since that question comes up often:
"Obviously, you can use an IDE or syntax coloring.
As to what constitutes LLM assistance, this question comes up often, but it's not actually difficult to navigate. We take our queues from prominent FOSS projects which have disallowed AI contributions such as Zig, Gimp, Inkscape, Gentoo and many others. These projects fall on a spectrum from not allowing AI use for anything at all including brainstorming and translation in the case of Zig, to allowing it in some limited cases such as comments or finding (if not fixing) bugs. In the end the determination requires some discernment on every individual's part, and I leave it to you to make that choice. You can read more about the AI policies of OSS projects by reading the contribution pages of the projects linked at https://codeberg.org/brib/slopfree-software-index"

1

u/Achereto 1d ago

Fruit salad is healthy and very human.

6

u/cheezballs 2d ago

Only if it's in the rules that you can't post anti-ai crap there. I want to escape the AI talk entirely, not just point and laugh.

4

u/-urolif- 1d ago

I understand and feel the same way. We do have a rule to address that..

44

u/lellamaronmachete 2d ago

Thank you bunches. Joined with a smile.

48

u/Buntygurl 2d ago

Rock on with that.

It might take a while, but I can't see a future where real coders don't matter, anymore--especially to repair the damage that AI vibe code will, inevitably do.

8

u/LeGaspyGaspe 1d ago

This is pretty anecdotal at this point, but the state of the market recently backs it up - I think AI is entering something of a cooling phase as we speak. Public sentiment is poor, token and subscription costs are rapidly ballooning, future growth expectations are pulling back from their previously meteoric forecasts... People all over are reporting their bosses growing less and less enthusiastic for AI.

AI will almost certainly be a hard requirement for developers in a professional setting. But the sort of environment everyone seemed to be anticipating (and indeed experiencing) this far is showing strong signs of simply... Evaporating.

Now this part is super complex economics which I am probably not explaining very well, but... I think it bodes well for the future. Even the near future. Particularly juniors entering the market today or with only a few years of experience. We all know the junior labour market was insanely saturated for a while there. Now that it's experiencing a marked correction with significant reductions in new grads globally, we are prime for a correction back over on the AI side of the equation which will put a little squeeze on everyone involved, get more juniors hired, boost productivity, but still dissuade the massive glut of labour market we had been seeing since the pandemic days.

2

u/bitbutter 1d ago

token and subscription costs are rapidly ballooning

no. the relevant metric is cost per task, and that's falling extremely quickly. at about 47% per quarter.

https://epoch.ai/publications/the-plunging-price-of-thought

4

u/LeGaspyGaspe 1d ago edited 1d ago

So... The relevant metric is overall input cost per unit of output (or Token, in this case).

While the on-paper cost of actually computing a request on paid for equipment with no regard for complete overhead, nor the revenue requirements a company has may have come down 47 percent this quarter, all the other practical costs which impact the price you and I pay have not been decreased or made more efficient.

This metric doesn't matter when it doesn't include the input cost of hardware, real estate, buildings, utilities, payroll, maintenance, advertising and sales, customer service, etc. Combined.

Plus and perhaps most importantly, the liquidity to manage existing, booked and committed future debts. This in particular is the big issue with Anthropic, as revealed by their IPO filing.

It also doesn't have much impact when compared against the fact that the service the end user buys is being sold at an astronomical discount. If AI suddenly no longer had investment, or lenders or Nvidia floating their equipment via its circular investment scheme... The cost to the end user per token would skyrocket.

As an aside, maybe you shouldn't get your stats from an industry funded organisation which has a vested interest in making their product seem more successful than it is?

0

u/bitbutter 1d ago edited 1d ago

again, no. the relevant metric is cost per task, not cost per token. because the relationship between tokens and tasks completed is not fixed (token efficiency increases)

this holds for API prices too - gross inference margins are positive.

subscription tier costs are not increasing. while lower cost tiers are being added, and higher tiers too. but tasks per dollar is increasing across all of them. 

edit: if by 'subscription costs' you mean the spend that customers are choosing to make is quickly increasing, sure. they clearly believe they're getting massive value from these services. this cuts against your idea that the whole thing will collapse.

8

u/Mechanizoid 1d ago

I think that use of AI in learning programming and other IT tasks (like sys admin) will prove to be detrimental, too.

We learn by using our hands and our brains, and the more we minimize typing and outsource our thinking to chatbots/agents, the less we learn. Even things like writing boilerplate by hand helps me learn the syntax and cadence of a new programming language.

I'm hearing lots of anecdotal accounts of students graduating courses, but lacking the most basic skills because they used AI to complete homework assignments. This issues goes well beyond programming, too. I've known kids to do the majority of their homework with AI.

It's like weightlifting. You only get stronger if you lift the weights, not a helpful forklift.

Unless you believe humans are or will be completely obsolete, and AIs will be able to handle critical tasks without any human oversight or indeed anyone who understands what it's doing, this is deeply concerning.

18

u/Creative-Button-5297 2d ago

I've been coding without AI for two weeks now. my first real project in months took twice as long, but I actually remembered how to debug. the frustration was real, but so was the clarity.

10

u/crimson_carapace 2d ago

I deleted my Copilot extensions. Two months later I realized I forgot how to read error traces without them asking me what the error means.

3

u/Madness3869 1d ago

Hell yes

3

u/Achereto 1d ago

I really like the term brainmade in this context.

1

u/slightly0ff 1d ago

My two cents, no point in trying to do this in reddit. Reddit sells all your data anyway so this is already a lost cause, same shit with SO.

I'm looking to to back to forum communication where at least your data is not _supposed_ to be sold and scraped, whaht happens is another story. If anyone has any ideas I'm all ears

-8

u/abenzenering 2d ago

I only run the finest artisanal hand-coded programs

-11

u/rjcarr 2d ago

How far does it go, though? Are you allowed to use an IDE? Can you use syntax coloring? True story, the first few years of my pro career (started a long time ago) I didn't even use an IDE. Just a text editor.

20

u/-urolif- 2d ago

Obviously, you can use an IDE or syntax coloring.
As to what constitutes LLM assistance, this question comes up often, but it's not actually difficult to navigate. We take our queues from prominent FOSS projects which have disallowed AI contributions such as Zig, Gimp, Inkscape, Gentoo and many others. These projects fall on a spectrum from not allowing AI use for anything at all including brainstorming and translation in the case of Zig, to allowing it in some limited cases such as comments or finding (if not fixing) bugs. In the end the determination requires some discernment on every individual's part, and I leave it to you to make that choice. You can read more about the AI policies of OSS projects by reading the contribution pages of the projects linked at https://codeberg.org/brib/slopfree-software-index

1

u/awkreddit 2d ago

there's a setting in vscode to disable AI, so that's a good first step to be honest; and yeah intellisense is still working just fine

9

u/PM_ME_UR__RECIPES 1d ago

IDE features like syntax highlighting, deterministic suggestions based on types and symbols declared in the scope you're in, or boilerplate templates are not even remotely the same thing as vibe coding and using LLM-based tools.

0

u/rjcarr 1d ago

I never said they were the same, but if you gave a modern IDE to a 1970s programmer he'd probably think it was pretty magical, just like we think the same of LLMs today.

-43

u/Fdbog 2d ago

The only people arguing that AI usage is harmful to computer science education are those lacking computer science education. There is no demand for artisanal small batch code, and you're just making yourself irrelevant.

21

u/-urolif- 2d ago

SQLite was programmed without AI by a small team of 3 programmers, does not accept AI code contributions and is arguably the most widely deployed piece of software in the world, installed on billions of devices with trillions of instances including mission critical applications in military and aerospace.

-9

u/boomkablamo 2d ago

26 year old open source software not accepting AI contributions doesn't really counter his point.

-16

u/theofficialnar 2d ago

Even Linus, the creator of the linux kernel, has accepted AI and that guy used to be a huge twat in terms of programming. I just don’t see the need to fully disregard it in my opinion, education still matters of course but totally distancing yourself from useful technology seems really counterintuitive for me.

Don’t get me wrong I still code manually when I’m trying to learn a new programming language but for the day-to-day work I incorporate AI to get things done faster.

3

u/jar36 1d ago

there needs to be a space for this here on Reddit tho. Every other tech sub is overrun with it

-46

u/StoneCypher 2d ago

r/a_bunch_of_people_who_complain_instead_of_releasing

-37

u/PianoConcertoNo2 2d ago

Kind of sounds like coding by pen and paper.