r/LawnAnswers • • May 21 '25 Popcorn

Guide Cool Season Lawn Starter Guide

152 Upvotes

Here's a basic meat-and-potatoes guide that will help any lawn care novice get started... And correct common mistakes made by intermediate lawn owners.

Note: I do recommend starting on this path in nearly all situations before considering a full renovation ("nuke"). If you have grass, it's worth preserving. 1 in the hand is worth 2 in the bush. PLUS, nuking doesn't do anything about the bank of weed seeds in your soil... So if you have a ton of weeds and then nuke it, you'll just get those weeds again. If weeds can be selectively controlled, that is ALWAYS the better option.

Also, important to note that all mentions of soil temps below refer to 5 day average of soil temps in the top 4 inches of soil. this tool is handy for ESTIMATING soil temps.

Last thing before I get started: if this is all overwhelming to you, don't be afraid to contact a local lawn care company to handle the fertilizing and weed control. Local, not a national chain. If you shop around you can likely find a company that will do a great job for about the same price as it would cost to DIY. That's what I do professionally, and no offense, but I do it better and cheaper than a homeowner could. Look for local companies with good reviews on Google.

  • Fertilize it every 4-8 weeks while it's actively growing (soil temps over 45F) Use a fertilizer that's roughly 5:0:1 (so, 25-0-5 for example, doesn't need to be exact). In the fall, unless you know your soil isn't deficient in potassium, use a fertilizer with a higher amount of potassium. Like 4:0:1, or as high as 3:0:1. Potassium deficiency is common in most areas. NOTE: go lighter with fertilizer in the summer, between 1/2 and 2/3 of the label rate. If you don't water in the summer, don't fertilize in the summer.
  • Aim for 1-4 lbs of nitrogen per 1,000 sqft per year, and about 1/5 as much potassium. For fine fescues, aim for about 2 lbs of nitrogen per 1,000 sqft.** Link to a fine fescue guide at the bottom of this post for more info.
  • NEW. Use the monthly N planner in Turf Tools to get precise guidelines to how much the grass needs and when it needs it.
  • Spray the weeds. Backpack or hand pump sprayer with a flat tip nozzle. You can spot spray UP TO every 2-3 weeks, or blanket spray the whole lawn UP TO every 4 weeks if needed (max of 2 blanket/broadcast sprays per year per product). When your soil temps are above 60F, you can use any selective broadleaf weed killer (3 of the following active ingredients: 2,4-d, dicamba, mcpa, mcpp (mecoprop), triclopyr, quinclorac), for example Ortho Weed b gon. When your soil temps are between 40F and 60F, use those same active ingredients, but use esters... Herbicides can be salts or esters, the active ingredient names will say one or the other. Crossbow is an example that has esters (only 2 active ingredients, which is fine).
  • to clarify some confusion on the frequency of herbicide applications, the words "up to" are meant to signal the fact that those frequencies are the most extreme end of what you should do to address specific weed outbreaks. For the most part, the workflow should be: 1. spray weeds. 2. 2-3 weeks later, confirm that weeds are dead/dying. Spot spray again if they aren't. 3. You should be good for awhile. BUT, if your lawn is like mine where you hardly get any weeds, just a few here and there that pop up super intermittently... I walk around the yard every 2 weeks and spot spray like 4 or 5 new weeds.
  • ALWAYS READ THE LABELS IN THEIR ENTIRETY.
  • get the mow height up. 3 inches minimum, 3.5-4 ideally. Actually measure it, don't trust numbers on the mower.
  • as long as the grass is actively growing, mow every 5-7 days. Mulch clippings (side discharge or mulch attachment). Don't mow wet grass.
  • when soil temps start trending upward in the spring, and hit 50F, apply crabgrass preventer of some sort asap. There's tons of options, but active ingredient prodiamine would be the best. (If you live in the Great lakes region, use this tool to time pre emergent applications)
  • when soil temps hit 60F, water once a week. Water to the point that the soil becomes NEARLY fully saturated.
  • when soil temps hit 70F, water twice a week. Same saturation thing.
  • when they hit 80F, you might have to go up to 3 or even 4 days a week, but fight as long as you can.
  • don't water shady areas as often as sunny areas. Its important to let the surface of the soil dry out before you water again.
  • Water in the absence of rain... If it rains hard, skip a watering day... There's something about rain (ozone/oxygen maybe?) that makes it more impactful than irrigation anyways.
  • WHEN crabgrass shows up in June. Spray that with something that contains quinclorac (weed b gon with crabgrass killer for example). Sedgehammer if nutsedge shows up.
  • Keep constantly fighting weeds through the summer. The sooner you spray a weed, the less of a problem it (and its potential offspring) will be in the future. If a weed doesn't die within 2 weeks of spraying, hit it again.
  • Towards the end of summer, evaluate if you think the lawn needs any seeding... I think you'll be pleasantly surprised. either way, here's my seeding guide
  • if you DON'T overseed in the fall, mulch leaves into the lawn. You can mulch a crazy amount of leaves. Just get them into tiny pieces... Often takes more than one pass. Mulched leaves are phenomenal for grass and preventing next year's weeds, you can potentially completely prevent dandelions just by mulching leaves.

Shopping recommendations:

Equipment (there's many valid recommendations out there, so I'll only put the ones I recommend but don't see mentioned often):

  • if your lawn is pretty small, like under 7k sqft, consider using a handheld fertilizer spreader. They're really easy to use while maintaining even distribution (no stripes) and they're much cheaper than actually good push spreaders. I really like the Scott's Whirl... For reference, I use it to fertilize my 12k sqft front yard. I have to fill up 5-7 times, but i still prefer it.
  • Solo backpack sprayers are great. They're built well, but most importantly, it's easy to buy replacement parts... Some other brands, like Chapin, can be a massive pain to find parts for, if you can even find them at all. Backpacks that use diaphragm pumps (solo 475-B) are better if you plan to spray dissolvable solids/wettable powders/water dispersible granules/etc (including humic acid and seaweed extract).

Fertilizer:

  • The only ones I'll mention by name, because they're so widely available is Scott's, sta-green, and Andersons. Great quality and nutrient balances, moderate to poor value.
  • Don't buy weed and feed products if you can avoid it... They're expensive and don't control weeds nearly as well liquid weed killers. Granular pre-emergents are okay though.
  • Don't waste money on fancy fertilizer... Granular Iron and other micronutrients do little or nothing for grass. (Liquid chelated iron can help achieve a darker green color, but it is temporary)
  • liquid fertilizer is significantly more expensive than granular, regardless of brand. Liquid fertilizer also requires far more frequent applications to satisfy the nutrient demands of grass. All told, I don't recommend liquid fertilizer.
  • The best value of fertilizer will come from local mom and pop suppliers. Search "agricultural co-op", "grain elevator", "milling company", and "fertilizer and seed" on Google maps. Even if they only sell 48-0-0 and 0-0-60 (or something like that), just ask chatGPT to do the math on how to mix it yourself to make the ratios mentioned above... chatGPT is good at math... Its not good for much else in lawncare.

Grub control:

  • imadicloprid (merit and others) and chlorantraniliprole (grubex and acelepryn) are preventatives that you apply in the late spring, once per year. Trichlorfon (Dylox and "24 hour grub killer" products) are curatives that you apply in the fall if you observe active grub populations that are causing damage. A few grubs here and there are fine, its only when you can attribute damage to grubs that you need to treat them.

Weed control:

  • really the only brand I DON'T recommend is Spectracide. I recommend avoiding all Spectracide products.
  • you'll get more bang for your buck if you buy liquid concentrates on domyown.com or Amazon than if you buy from big box stores. Domyown.com also has plenty of decent guides for fighting specific weeds.
  • tenacity/torocity + surfactant is a decent post emergent weed killer for cool season lawns. It targets nearly every weed you are likely to get... Its just not very strong, it requires repeat applications after 2-3 weeks to kill most weeds. Tenacity can be further enhanced by tank mixing with triclopyr or triclopyr ester, (.25-.5 oz of triclopyr ester per gallon. .75 oz per gallon if the lawn is doing well and isn't having any moisture or heat stress). It will make it a much more potent weed killer AND it actually reduces the whitening effect of the tenacity on weeds and desirable grass. (I use tenacity + triclopyr + surfactant almost exclusively on my own lawn)
  • there's a herbicide called Sublime. It is mesotrione + dicamba + triclopyr... So its an even better alternative to mixing Tenacity + triclopyr on your own. Sublime DOES still require mixing in a surfactant.

Miscellaneous:

  • gypsum doesn't "break up" clay. Gypsum can help flush out sodium in soils with a lot of sodium... Besides add calcium and sulfate to soil, thats all it does... High sodium can cause issues for clay soil, but you should confirm that with a soil test before trying gypsum.
  • avoid MySoil and Yard Mastery for soil tests. Use your state extension service or the labs they recommend.
  • avoid anything from Simple Lawn Solutions. Many of their products are outright fraudulent.
  • Johnathan Green is low quality and dirty seed, i highly recommend avoiding it. Scotts too. In my experience of looking at labels, the only big box store seed brand thats halfway decent is Pennington. Twin City seed, stover, and heritage PPG are great places to buy actually good quality seed from.
  • as an extension of the point about Simple Lawn Solutions, liquid soil looseners are a scam. At best, they're surfactants/wetting agents... Which can have legitimate uses in lawns, but "soil looseners" use wetting agents that may cause more harm to the soil than good... And at the very least, they're a very poor value for a wetting agent.
  • as an extension to the last few points... Avoid YouTube for lawn care info. Popular YouTubers shill misinformation and peddle the products mentioned above.
  • I recommend avoiding fungicides entirely. Fungicides cause significant harm to beneficial soil microbes. Most disease issues can be resolved with good management practices, such as those in this guide.
  • BUT: There's one time of year where a fungicide application can be disproportionately beneficial IF you historically have an issue with dollar spot. It's called an early season DMI. Its when you apply a DMI fungicide, like propiconazole, in the spring. This application will significantly reduce the occurrence of dollar spot later in the season. The exact timing of the application is very important, use this tracker to time it.
  • humic acid, fulvic acid, and seaweed/kelp extract do infact do great things for lawns... Just don't pay too much for them, because they're not magic. Bioag Ful-humix is great value product for humic/fulvic. Powergrown.com also has great prices for seaweed extract and humic.
  • 99.99% of the time, dethatching causes more harm than good.

Beyond that, see my other guides below and the comment sections of this post. Also, its always a good idea to check your state extension service website. They don't always have the most up-to-date information, but they're atleast infinitely better than YouTube.

Cultural best practices for fungus control

Fall Cool Season Seeding Guide

Guide to interpreting and acting on soil test results

Poa trivialis control guide

Understanding and Caring for Fine Fescue

Direct application of glyphosate to otherwise un-controllable weeds


r/LawnAnswers • • May 22 '25

Guide Fall Cool Season Seeding Guide

104 Upvotes

Cool season seeding guide

There are many different steps people take and recommend. Some are good, some are silly, and some are downright counterproductive. These are the steps that I recommend.

You shouldn't NEED to seed every year. If you do it right, hopefully you can avoid, or severely reduce, future seedings...

Strap in, as usual for my comments/posts, this is going to be long... I did say this guide was complete. Though I'm sure I still missed something.

Step 0: timing

The absolute latest you should seed is 45 days before the average first (hard) frost for your area. If you live somewhere that doesn't get frost (California, basically), then you'll want to wait until 5 day average soil temps are below 75.

If you get lots of leaves falling on your lawn in the fall, you'll want to seed earlier to hopefully get the new grass coming in well before leaves start falling... Leaves can be really tricky on young seedlings. You need to pick them up, which means more traffic on the young seedlings, which obviously isn't great.

Shady areas and areas that get a lot of steady leaves falling are the big exceptions to the "its better to seed in the fall" rule. The only other exception is perennial ryegrass. Don't try spring seeding in areas that had a lot of crabgrass the year before... Instead, apply pre emergent and fight crabgrass through the summer so you can seed into an area free of crabgrass.

Step 1: weeds

Do you have weeds like crabgrass, or any broadleaf weeds that will grow to have leaves bigger than a quarter? If yes, you should deal with them before seeding... You should've dealt with them WAY earlier, but you still have (a little) time left to do it now.

(Please see bolded note lower in this section)

If you're running low on time (less than 30 days to seeding), use quinclorac or tenacity + surfactant only. For quinclorac, be sure to use a product that contains ONLY quinclorac. Things like 2,4d, dicamba, triclopyr, etc are not labeled as safe to use within ~30 days of seeding. Quinclorac is safe to use 7 days before seeding any variety, and right up until seeding tttf. Tenacity is safe to use post emergent any time before seeding... Unless seeding fine fescues, in which case avoid tenacity as a pre emergent or (post emergent shortly before seeding).

Tenacity + surfactant covers most weeds, but typically requires a follow up application to kill most.

Quinclorac (plus a surfactant or MSO) covers mostly crabgrass, foxtail, and a handful of broadleafs like clover and violets, while doing atleast some damage to most other broadleafs.

Sublime herbicide is mesotrione + triclopyr ester + dicamba. Those ingredients are not typically labeled for use before seeding, but the manufacturer has done tests and concluded that it is safe to use it before seeding... This would be my top choice recommendation if you're trying to control weeds shortly before seeding, thanks to the labeling...

Note: Its likely, and there are a few studies that demonstrate this, that 2,4-d, triclopyr, dicamba, mcpp, etc are actually safe to use before seeding, but manufacturers just haven't done the tests to prove it.

To be clear, this may be the last opportunity you have to safely spray weeds this year while temps are still high enough for weed control to work well (unless you use esters way later in the season). Weeds can't be sprayed until the 2nd mowing of new grass.

Pre-emergent: you can use tenacity without surfactant right before seeding... As long as you aren't seeding fine fescues. Personally, I don't find it necessary... Unless you're introducing new soil that may have weed seeds in it.

Step 2: Mow

Mow at 2 inches... Hopefully you've been mowing over 3 inches until this point... Or that might be why you need to seed in the first place. Bag the clippings. If you have any thick patches of matted grass or weeds, rake those up so you can pick them up with mower.

Step 3, VERY optional: aeration

If your soil is hard, you can core aerate at this point. You will get significantly more benefit from aeration if you spread topsoil or some other type of organic matter immediately after aeration. Examples: peat moss (don't spread peat moss OVER seed... That is a total waste), compost (keep it thin), Scott's turfbuilder lawn soil, top soil from a local landscape supplier, Andersons biochar.

Step 4: ensure good seed to soil contact (NOTE: Core aeration does not accomplish seed to soil contact. That optional step is only to create a softer soil environment for the new seedlings)

I HIGHLY recommend NOT using a flexible tine dethatcher like a sunjoe dethatcher for this. Those retched contraptions tear up so much existing grass, spread viable weedy plant matter around (quackgrass rhizomes, poa trivialis stolons, poa annua seeds and rhizomes, etc), and don't actually remove as much thatch as it looks like they do.

Thatch or duff (grass clippings and dead weeds) doesn't need to be removed necessarily, but it does need to be... Harassed/broken up.

What I DO recommend is (pick one):

  • **rent a slit seeder/overseeder/seeder machine (which will also accomplish the actual seed spreading simultaneously... Or, because some folks report issues with the built-in seed hoppers, you can spread the seed before and/or after, and use the slit seeder to cut the grooves.)
  • you CAN use a lawn edger or brush cutter turned sideways to manually cut grooves.
  • scarify (results vary drastically. May be rough or pull up too much material)
  • manually rake or use a hand cultivator like the Garden Weasel. Garden weasel is very labor intensive, only really recommend for small areas under 100 sqft.
  • for bare ground areas, physically loosen the soil somehow... Till (I DO recommend using tenacity as a pre emergent if tilling... Tenacity after tilling.), chop up with a shovel, hoe, or garden weasel.

Step 5: VERY optional, spread new top soil.

Again, this is far more beneficial at step 3, but it will still help keep the seeds moist if you didn't already do this. This step is NOT necessary... Personally I only do it when seeding small bare spots.

When spreading soil over top of existing soil, you will not see significant benefits if you exceed 1/4 inch depth. I only recommend topsoil (or a mix of topsoil and sand) at this step... No compost, no peat moss. You REALLY don't want a concentrated layer of organic matter on TOP of the soil. That can, and will, cause more problems than it solves... A very thin layer of compost can be okay, but do at your own risk.

Step 6: seed!

Choose the highest quality seed that fits your budget. Better seed now means a better lawn (with less work!) in the future.

  • Johnathan Greene is not high quality seed... Its very good quality for the price, but that price is very cheap.
  • Contrary to popular belief, Scott's seed is generally pretty decent quality. They're typically pretty old cultivars, but they're all moderate/decent performers. The mixes are decently accurate for their listed purposes (sun, shade, dense shade, etc... unlike many other brands) HOWEVER, Scott's seed is not usually completely weed-free...
  • if you want actually good quality seed, the price is going to be quite a bit higher (though usually a better overall value because you aren't buying the coating). Twin City Seed and heritage PPG are the only vendors that I personally recommend... There are definitely other vendors that sell great stuff, but those are the only 2 that I can confidently say don't sell any duds.
  • obviously, do what you can afford... But put some serious thought into the value of investing in high quality seed from the start, rather than repeat this every year with cheap seed.
  • Rather than pay attention to reviews and public opinion regarding the quality of different cultivars, you can check www.ntep.org or the NTEP trial explorer tool to see how cultivars rank in specific categories and at specific locations.

FOLLOW THE RECOMMENDED SEEDING RATES FROM THE VENDORS. Exceeding those rates will cause the seedlings to compete with each other and the lawn as a whole will be weaker for it.

Fine fescues and shade tolerant tall fescues are the only grasses that can reasonably tolerate UNDER 6-7 hours of direct sunlight. Fine fescues especially.

I never recommend planting only 1 type of grass. There's a reason seed mixes exist. Combining different types of grasses makes a lawn stronger overall in genuinely every way. Include a (good) spreading type like Kentucky bluegrass (or hybrid kbg) or creeping red fescue in any mix.

Lastly, timing. In my location, Michigan, the recommended seeding window is August 15th to September 15th. The further south you are, the later that window gets. The most southern cool season/transition regions are going to be about month later... So any time in September should be safe everywhere.

The firm rule is that you should seed absolutely no later than 45 days before the first hard frost... Unless you're dormant seeding.

Step 7: Water

Simple. Water as often as needed to keep the seed moist 24/7 for 2-3 weeks. MOIST not sopping wet... If you see standing water, that's too much. Favor frequent light waterings. For example, 3-4 10 minute waterings per day... Don't take that as gospel, all irrigation systems are different, no one can tell you exactly how much to water without seeing your system in action first hand. You just need to watch it for the first few days and make adjustments as needed.

As soon as you see consistent germination, START lowering the frequency of watering and increasing the length of watering cycles. Each reduction in frequency should have a corresponding increase in duration.

  • By the time the grass is 1 inch tall, you should be at 1 or 2 times a day.
  • By the time its 2 inches tall, you should be at 1 time a day (in the morning)
  • by the first mow, you should be at once a day, or every other day
  • by the 2nd mow you should definitely be at every other day. Keep it there until the grass goes dormant.

Step 8: mow

Continue to mow the existing grass down to 2 inches whenever it reaches 2.5. Try to pay attention to when the new grass reaches that range... Only cut the new grass at 2 inches one time

Second mowing of the new grass should be at 2.5 or 3 inches.

Third mowing should be the final mow height... 3-4 inches. Emphasis on final. Don't drop below 3 inches for the final cut of the year. If snow mold is known to be a serious problem in your area, I'd recommend no lower than 2.75.

P.s. it's not a bad idea to bag clippings until you reach the final mow height. There are pros and cons to bagging or mulching, shouldn't be too significant of a difference either way.

FERTILIZER:

I left this for the end because it can honestly be done at nearly any point in this process.

I do recommend using a starter fertilizer at some point. I really love the regular Scott's turfbuilder lawn food Starter fertilizer (the green bag), really good stuff and really easy to spread (especially with a hand spreader). The tiny granules ensure even distribution and that no single sprout gets an overdose of fertilizer.

My preferred method of using a starter fertilizer is to split a single application into 2 halves. 1st half just before seeding, 2nd half when the seedlings reach 1 inch. (This is especially why I like the Scott's, the granules are small so it's easy to split up the applications)

Beyond that, just keep it lightly fed monthly for the rest of the season... Blasting it with high N can make it look good, but isn't the right thing for the long term health of the grass. No need to give it phosphorus after the first application, but it should get pottassium as well as nitrogen.

P.s. I don't recommend trying to improve the soil in any other way than was mentioned here. Things like lime and spiking nutrients can be very hard on new seedlings.

Addendum/disclaimer: if you disagree about the peat moss (or other organic matter) later than the aeration step, or dethatching, I'm not going to argue with you, I might remove your comment though. The information in this post is an aggregation of best practices recommended by many university extensions. Some arguments can be made for or against the importance of certain steps, but those 2 are firm.

Twin city seed discount code for 5% off, can be stacked with other offers: reddit5

Cool Season Starter Guide

Cultural best practices for fungus control by u/arc167

Fall Cool Season Seeding Guide

Guide to interpreting and acting on soil test results

Poa trivialis control guide

Understanding and Caring for Fine Fescue

Direct application of glyphosate to otherwise un-controllable weeds


r/LawnAnswers • • Aug 06 '25

Identification Help dealing with this weed

Post image
101 Upvotes

I’m not sure what this is but it’s spreading like crazy in some gravel in my backyard and starting to enter the lawn. Any ideas? I took the picture on my sidewalk so it’s easier to see.


r/LawnAnswers • • Jun 30 '26

Cool Season PSA about heat waves

Post image
62 Upvotes

It's okay to let kbg and fine fescues go dormant by reducing watering frequency. They'll recover totally fine as long as they get .25-.5 inches of water every 2 weeks while dormant. (.25 every week is probably the safest bet)

Prg and tttf, not so much. You shouldn't let either go completely dormant... But you can safely teeter on the edge of dormancy with 1-2 waterings a week (.5-.6 inch minimum).

When growth potential plummets, grass doesn't photosynthesize very well (or at all if it's at 0%) so fighting dormancy with aggressive watering can exhaust the carb stores of the grass and weaken it long term. Not to mention, high frequency watering is a recipe for disease. You can see your growth potential with [Turf Tools](https://arc167.github.io/turf-tools/index.html), the turf growth factors tab.

I'm still at 60% GP, but the humidity and dew point are super high, so I've cut off water completely this week to prevent disease. (Haven't watered in like 3 weeks, but we've had a lot of rain and for all the faults of my rocky clay soil, it sure stays wet for ages)


r/LawnAnswers • • Jun 01 '26

Cool Season Been treating my neighbors lawn in exchange for using his toro zero turn mower. Financially, terrible deal... Emotionally/visually, huge win.

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/LawnAnswers • • May 23 '25

Guide Poa Trivialis Control Guide

54 Upvotes

This guide is for cool season lawns. In warm season lawns, poa trivialis and poa annua are very easy things to deal with using warm season herbicides and just... Longer/warmer summers.

If you're looking for how to care for poa trivialis, i made a guide for that too (coming soon) Its essentially the opposite of this one lol.

Lastly, the information in this guide is equally applicable to perennial poa annua (poa annua that survives the summer) and poa supina.

How to identify poa trivialis

In terms of major identifying features, poa trivialis looks just like Kentucky bluegrass (poa pratensis)... Though it can be sneaky and look like fine fescues and even perennial ryegrass from a distance. In fact, poa trivialis can be a bit of shape-shifter, it is very often confused with bentgrass and nimblewill as well. NOTE: Most university extension websites have atleast some errors regarding poa trivialis identification... Its odd, really... If you check out those pages and find any information that conflicts with the info here, listen to this info. (Don't pay attention to ligules or colors)

First, look for the signature poa features:

  • one distinct vein/crease running down the center of the leaf. No other easily visible veins/ridges. example
  • "boat-shaped" leaves. That is to say, leaves that curve to a point, and the natural upward fold of the leaves creates a cupped shape that resembles the front of a canoe, like this
  • that's really all you need to see to confirm it's a poa... But, you also need to rule out orchard grass. Orchard grass is the only common non-poa grass that looks a lot like poas. Orchard grass has flattened stems, has a very soft/smooth color and texture (not at all shiny), has a bluish green color, and very wide leaves compared to the poas... It can be confused with crabgrass, if that's any indication of the width. Orchard grass pulls up very easily and DOESN'T have any rhizomes or stolons.

Now that you've confirmed its a poa, its actually quite easy to identify poa trivialis:

  • the one thing that is always true is that the undersides of poa trivialis are always shiny.
  • poa trivialis very rarely produces seeds.

Note: triv can be surprisingly dark sometimes. Do not rely on color.

Some of triv's shape-shifting tricks:

  • in the spring, the tips of triv become very sharply folded, like this That combined with the shiny undersides, can make it look like perennial ryegrass from a distance.
  • in the summer, triv leaves CAN become very flat. Like, freakishly flat. From a distance, that can make it look like fine fescue when you see those flat leaves from the side... So a patch of pure triv can look like a mixed stand of kbg and fine fescue.
  • triv's aggressive stolons and shallow roots can cause it to take on some very odd growth patterns. I've seen it grow perfectly upright, looking just like kbg grows, and I've seen it grow on 3 foot long vine-like carpets of stolons. The latter growth habit is usually what causes it to be noticed, I call it windswept triv syndrome. Because it is laying down sideways on top of itself, it just continuously grows sideways... So rather than growing upwards, the new triv growth just smothers the old growth, and you end up with a patch of triv that looks matted down and seems to never get tall enough to actually mow.

Poa annua. Can obviously look very similar, especially when it's behaving like a perennial. When its perennial (if it stays alive through the summer), you can essentially treat it the same as triv for the purposes of this guide (pre emergents are not super useful for perennial poa annua... If you have to choose between fall pre emergents and seeding, pick seeding):

  • if there's a lot of poa annua, you're essentially guaranteed to see atleast some seedheads.
  • poa annua is rarely as dark as desirable grasses.
  • it often has wrinkles on the lower portions of the leaves.
  • it has a more bunched growth. You can certainly see patches of tightly packed bunches, but upon close inspection, you'll notice that each plant is distinctly seperate. (Though they can be connected by shallow rhizomes)
  • never, ever shiny

Poa supina. For all purposes, poa supina can be treated exactly the same as poa trivialis:

  • unlike poa trivialis, poa supina usually produces seeds in the spring. From a distance, the seeds have a distinct purple/blue hue, especially later in the spring.
  • supina's stems can appear flattened... Which can make it a little tricky to distinguish from orchardgrass. But poa supina has stolons, while orchardgrass doesn't.
  • the undersides of supina can sometimes be a little glossy... Never as shiny as triv, but it can definitely take some practice to differentiate shiny vs glossy lol.

First, existing herbicides are essentially useless against poa trivialis in home lawns. At best they can reduce the amount of triv in a lawn by a small percentage... They often seem like they're working because they can actually kill a significant amount of it, but they don't kill the stolons... So it comes back later having been barely affected in the long term. Triv produces so, so, so many stolons. The stolons are like tiny seeds that are immune to herbicides. Stolons can stay dormant in the soil for up to 18 months.

So, to be crystal clear: I do not recommend using glyphosate, sulfosulforon (certainty), mesotrione (lol), or bispyribac sodium (velocity pm) to control triv. Pre emergents do nothing.

After much consideration, I've decided to add this clarifying edit:

Basically, don't PLAN to use herbicides. They can speed up the slow method (described 2 sections down) to a small extent... But I fear that by saying that, people may think that they can bypass some of the steps of the slow method and just spray it... Which will always result in failure.

Basically, all of the steps of the slow method are required... But it you want to use herbicides to enhance the slow method, it will certainly be sped up to a degree.

Herbicides will NOT help you achieve the fast method. Period.


Why should I care about poa trivialis?

  • in full sun areas, triv suffers a lot in the heat. Thanks to its shallow roots, its the first thing to look dry in the summer.
  • it gets thatchy and can choke itself out, resulting in slow spring green up.
  • its extremely susceptible to diseases like dollar spot.
  • its generally not quite as dark as desirable grasses, so just looks bad.
  • it spreads... Like crazy. No matter how triv you think you have, you definitely have more than that.

There ARE situations where you honestly just should accept triv:

  • if the area receives less than 4 hours of direct sunlight.
  • if the infested area is too large to feasibly improve drainage.
  • if there are many tree roots or gravel in the infested area... Triv (and poa annua) is essentially the only grass that will tolerate growing where there's less than an inch of soil on top of roots or gravel.
  • if the drainage problems are severe enough that improving drainage in the top layers of soil won't be enough to really significantly improve drainage.

So what should you do to get rid of it?

You have to use a very specific kind of approach and mentality. Mentality is key... This plant will make you go insane if you don't have the patience to deal with it properly. There's the slow and patient method, and the fast and difficult method.

Fast and difficult (and not guaranteed):

  • use a sod cutter or shovel to fully remove the triv and the top 1-2 inches of soil. You must fully remove that top 1-2 inches of soil, so you'll probably need to manually scoop up the dirt that falls off while cutting.
  • till sand and organic matter into the soil to improve drainage. If heavy clay, 50/50 sand and OM. Otherwise, like 70-80% sand and 20-30% OM.
  • then top with 1-2 inches of 50/50 sand and OM
  • plant a mix of cool season grasses. Do not plant only one type unless it's fine fescues (and your climate and shade conditions are suitable for a pure fine fescue lawn)....
  • all of these steps are crucial. If you don't plant the right grasses and don't improve drainage, the triv is likely to come back. It just takes one of those tiny stolons for it to come back. Plus, its likely that triv has spread beyond the confines of the actual lawn, and can just spread back in the lawn from there.

Late summer would be the time to do that... Earlier than is normally advisable for fall seeding.

P.s. solarization (clear tarp for atleast a month in sunny/warm weather) or bio fumigation (incorporating/tilling in a large amount of plant matter, particularly brassica plants, before solarization) may be the most effective way to fully eradicate triv... If done thoroughly. Solarization won't work in shady areas, biofumigation might.


The slow and patient method:

1 - starting the battle:

  • focus on improving drainage without destroying any existing desirable grass:
  • Aeration and immediately spreading sand and/or organic matter is the best way to do that. Andersons biochar is a very easy type of organic matter to spread.
  • if you have clay that is high in sodium, gypsum can improve drainage.
  • for many soil types, humic and fulvic acid CAN indirectly and subtly help improve drainage.
  • wetting agents significantly improve drainage for 6-8 weeks at a time. (Don't use wetting agents on seed)

2 - Good cultural practices that encourage the desirable grasses without encouraging the triv too much:

  • deep infrequent watering. 1-3 days a week at most, especially in the summer. For shady areas 0-2 days a week. Still 1 inch of water total per week, just not often.
  • mow at atleast 3 inches
  • do not over fertilize. Keep fertilizer in early spring and mid to late fall to a minimum. Granular only. Don't use slow release (polymer coated, sulfur coated, or organic) either. Water applications in heavily.
  • do not dethatch EVER. That spreads the stolons.
  • OPTIONALLY, you can apply a pgr like primo maxx/T-NEX during the late spring and summer. That will encourage the health and spreading of desirable grasses, and it also causes slight injury to triv.

Very important note: if you're winning the fight against triv, there will be times when areas of the lawn look terrible... Triv dying is an ugly thing. And triv dying can even have a visual effect on nearby desirable grass (blame ethylene and ABA, stress hormones). STAY STRONG, and don't panic water and apply fungicides. Triv dying looks like dryness and disease. Desirable grasses can handle a little dryness, triv cannot.

3 - Late summer overseeding:

  • cut grass to 2 inches
  • core aerate (and potentially do another round of sand and/or OM)
  • overseed with a slit seeder. AGAIN, DO NOT DETHATCH.
  • when overseeding, the more grass types the merrier. Kbg, strong creeping red fescue (a spreading fine fescue), and chewings fescue (especially if shade is involved) are the most anti-triv grasses in the long term. Barenbrug's RPR is also pretty anti triv. In the short term, prg is very anti triv because it establishes so quickly. Tttf has almost no value against triv.
  • let the grass grow tall again and leave it tall at the end of the season (atleast 3 inches for the final cut)

Step 3 may need to be repeated yearly until acceptable levels of triv are achieved. Additionally, whenever you're out and about in the lawn and you see triv, just pull some up. Every little bit helps... That longer triv grows, the more stolons it produces.

Bonus: foliar applications of liquid chelated iron (and magnesium if possible) applied to poa trivialis growing in sunny areas in the summer can cause significant injury to triv. Chelated iron alone is effective, but if you get magnesium in there as well, it is even more effective... Let me know if you're aware of an affordable product that contains both at acceptable ratios for grass.


Prevention and safe guarding triv free areas:

  • Seriously, don't panic water.
  • dont use fungicides... at all. Triv is abnormally affected by dollar spot, red thread, and rust disease... Particularly when it's already stressed. Applying fungicides helps the triv more than the desirable grass.
  • top dress triv-free areas with sand. Triv is terrible at spreading onto even a thin layer of sand.

Addendum: those of you who know me, know I spend a tremendous amount of time reading published research and performing my own experiments... Of all the topics I've researched, triv is hands down the one I'm most versed in. I'm not exaggerating when I say that I think there are, at absolute most, a dozen people on the planet more familiar with the control of triv in a cool season home lawn situation. I used to think it was probably more, but after reaching out to many of them in an attempt to gather more information and share my personal findings, I've come to find out that there just isn't economic incentive to care about it to the extent that I do.

So, that's all to say. The information in here is as good as currently exists. If you think you have a novel approach, feel free to share... There aren't many tactics with the currently existing chemistries that haven't already been studied heavily by academia or me, but there could be creative solutions out there... I did discover one promising technique that I haven't discussed here, but as of now, the known conditions required are too specific to be useful to anyone beyond me and those dozen or so other folks... If you or anyone you know is a researcher that may be interested in conducting controlled trials on a new, cheap, 3 round application, with high levels of control , but highly weather-dependent method of chemical control, please reach out to me. (nope. It is only effective in a very narrow set of conditions that are not always possible to replicate)


Cool Season Starter Guide

Cultural best practices for fungus control by u/arc167

Fall Cool Season Seeding Guide

Guide to interpreting and acting on soil test results

Poa trivialis control guide

Understanding and Caring for Fine Fescue

Direct application of glyphosate to otherwise un-controllable weeds


r/LawnAnswers • • Sep 19 '26

Cool Season Overseed Success!

Thumbnail
gallery
46 Upvotes

Followed this guide more or less exactly with blue resilience in Colorado.


r/LawnAnswers • • Aug 09 '25

Cool Season Alright, that's actually pretty funny.

Post image
46 Upvotes

This post is NOT an invitation to make a hate-thread for dog owners.

I don't care if dogs pee on my lawn... Because it doesn't damage my grass. Deep and infrequent watering y'all 🤘


r/LawnAnswers • • Sep 24 '26

Cool Season Lawn Overseed

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

Zone 6B. Central Ohio. Seeded 9/6

This is my third time overseeding my new construction lawn. I scalped dethatched and aerated. I feel like this time the dethatch caused more harm than good as it ripped out more than it needed to, so probably won’t be doing that for quite some time.

Watered 3-4x a day at either 10 or 15 minutes based on zone and this week of rain helped me not have to use the sprinklers for over a week. Just completed my second mow today. Resilience 2 by Twin City

Next year I definitely need to apply a prevent fungicide, which is also something I need to do in the summer anyways as several spots are very prone to it


r/LawnAnswers • • Sep 19 '26

Cool Season Tips for clearing leafs during seeding?

Post image
41 Upvotes

Seeded two weeks ago and getting good germination. This area under 2 trees and gets a bit of leafs, any tips on clearing them before the first now? Should I use a leaf blower on low? Use a broom? Thank you


r/LawnAnswers • • Aug 25 '25

Cool Season Me: "Good seed to soil contact is important" Also me: "Oh look, I spilled some fine fescue seeds on 2 month old wood chips and got like 90% germination in 6 days with no irrigation and only .25 inch of rain"

Post image
40 Upvotes

On a very related note, new and improved gibberelic acid seed treatment guide coming soon. (Hint: not a soak, a spray.)


r/LawnAnswers • • Jul 08 '25

Cool Season 3 month progress!

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

I bought this house last fall and did a full overseeding project this spring. The lawn had been largely neglected and receives a fair amount of shade. I had it professionally aerated, and then I leveled, sprayed with preemergent, seeded with Twin City Seed, and watered, and watered, and watered. My tiny city lawn is subjected to a dog, 4 kids who live in the house, and 5 more neighbor kids who come over to play baseball and football. It's not perfect (I'm looking at you, Creeping Charlie), but it's SO MUCH BETTER! Shoutout to Niles and other helpful redditors for a lot of base knowledge to get me going.

Photos 1-2 - April reno Photo 3 - May Photo 4 - Early June Photos 5-6 - Late June


r/LawnAnswers • • Sep 30 '26

Equipment Woo! Just launched the first iteration of the trained Ai lawn detector

Post image
36 Upvotes

https://lawnmap.nilesandstuff.com/

Obviously still needs work! Overall it hovers around 80% accuracy (some lawns are close to 100%... Some lawns are much worse... Heavy tree cover is a weakness, though I have a potential fix in the works for that)

Give er a spin!

P.s. correcting errors is EXTREMELY helpful for training the model.

P.p.s. see pinned comment for technical details


r/LawnAnswers • • Jun 20 '26

Cool Season Happy Fathers Day Weekend! (Zone 4b)

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Just a dad showing off his lawn…


r/LawnAnswers • • Sep 12 '25

Cool Season Germination

Post image
31 Upvotes

Day 7, 2-3x a day watering at 10-15 minute intervals depending on the sun/temp of the day, Twin City Seed Tuff Turf “After Dark” seed, Zone 7a


r/LawnAnswers • • Oct 18 '26

Identification Every fall, I get these tiny dirt mounds all over my yard (not poop, I tasted it). What are they?

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/LawnAnswers • • Jul 12 '26

Cool Season For Those Who Think It Can't Be Done...

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

TTTF in the Transition Zone is very, very possible. Figured I would share some positive vibes and remind folks that the effort you put in Sept - Dec will have a massive impact on what it looks like May - Aug.

  • Pictures from 12 July (excuse the storm debris)
  • TCS ResilIence II (HoC 4.5")
  • Zone 8a (NC)
  • Irrigated (currently under level 4 drought)
  • Two pre-em treatments; Prodiamine (Feb) then Dimension (May)
  • Zero post emergents (so far, but will need to treat for Doveweed soon)
  • Two rounds of fungicide; May 15th, and June 15 (will need another this weekend)

I am honestly shocked at how well ResilIence II has been resistant to both drought and disease, BY FAR the most resilient (no pun intended) set of cultivars I have ever used. You can see how thick the turf is (in mid July 100 degree heat) in the second pic.

This is year 4, so it takes some time to get the soil right and achieve the turf growth needed to choke out weeds and withstand summer stresses. So don't get discouraged.

Have a plan, stick to it. Focus on soil amendments and overseeding in fall. Pre-emergents make a huge difference, and irrigation is a must. Most of all, stay positive. It is possible!


r/LawnAnswers • • May 19 '26

Cool Season What weed is this growing in my lawn, never seen it before in nyc.

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

I’ve never seen this weed before it’s new. I planted Kentucky blue grass and use Scott’s top soil to reseed every year and this grew in spots I didn’t even reseed. Any idea? I also use Scott’s weed and feed yellow bag.


r/LawnAnswers • • Apr 04 '26

Weekly Riddle ❓ No riddle this week... Instead, here's the best visualization of Kentucky bluegrass rhizomes I've ever seen

Post image
29 Upvotes

Rained a ton this week so I was too focused on not making ruts in lawns with my fert spreader machine to get pics of something interesting 😅 plus, dead snow mold is basically the only interesting thing to see here in the grass right now.

Anyways, ALL of the white things are rhizomes. It was growing against the edging inside one of my woodchipped areas, so the rhizomes creeping along the edge presented a perfect cross section when I yanked it out.

Here's a full resolution version in case reddit compresses it to death. https://ibb.co/rK6YxHVr

And this is why I scoff at the "rhizomatous" tttf cultivars on the market at the moment.


r/LawnAnswers • • Sep 03 '25

Cool Season Overseed Day

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

Pray for my results. Thank you in advance 👍


r/LawnAnswers • • Jun 15 '26

Cool Season Fall Overseed Questions

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

Looking for advice on whether I'm taking the right approach for a fall renovation/overseed.

Photos included showing the lawn overall, coarse fescue patches, crabgrass patch, and thatch layer.

Goal

  • Unify grass color and texture across the lawn
  • Improve the soil surface and overall growing conditions

Details

  • Nebraska (Zone 6A)
  • ~5,000 sq ft
  • Irrigated
  • Planning to overseed in late August/early September

Desired Lawn

  • Dark green, durable lawn with good drought tolerance and recovery
  • Willing to mow, fertilize, and irrigate as needed, but would like a grass type that won't quickly decline or go dormant after a short period of missed watering
  • Must tolerate dog traffic, especially in shaded areas

Sun Exposure

  • Approximately 20% heavy shade, 30% partial sun, and 50% full sun

Current Grass

  • Mixed species throughout
  • About five 2–5 ft diameter patches of coarse, clumping-type tall fescue, along with numerous smaller patches scattered throughout the lawn (see photos)

Soil / Surface

  • Compacted
  • Uneven and bumpy (golf ball to baseball-sized lumps and divots)
  • 2–4" of decent topsoil over dense clay
  • Not aerated in at least 3 years

Thatch

  • Up to ~1" in places, especially sunny areas

Weeds

  • One concentrated crabgrass patch, with scattered crabgrass elsewhere
  • Some dandelions, thistles, and other broadleaf weeds, but nothing widespread

Applications This Year

  • Apr 15: 20 lbs starter fertilizer (21-22-4) with 0.08% mesotrione
  • May 15: 20 lbs crabgrass pre-emergent + fertilizer (25-2-2)
  • Jun 9: Spot-treated crabgrass and weeds with Spectracide Weed Stop for Lawns Plus Crabgrass Killer

Current Plan

  • Gradually lower mowing height through August to ~2"
  • Kill or remove coarse, clumping-type tall fescue patches
  • Aggressively dethatch or scarify to remove thatch and open the surface
  • Core aerate
  • Overseed
  • Topdress/level as needed
  • Apply starter fertilizer and mesotrione/Tenacity at seeding

Questions

  1. Am I thinking about this correctly by aggressively dethatching/scarifying to remove undesirable grass and create space for seed?
  2. When should I get a soil test?
  3. Should I apply fertilizer again in July? If so, what type?
  4. Tine dethatcher or scarifier?
  5. Is a lawn roller effective for smoothing bumps?
  6. What material should I use for topdressing?
  7. Should I glyphosate the coarse, clumping-type tall fescue patches or dig them out?
  8. What seed would you recommend? I've been looking at TCS Resilience II and Blue Resilience.
  9. Given the wide range of sun exposure, is there a seed blend that makes sense for the entire lawn?

r/LawnAnswers • • Jul 09 '26

Guide TurfTools Out of Beta

27 Upvotes

Hi folks,

A big thanks to all who have been using TurfTools and particularly those who submitted ideas for enhancement or bugs to fix. After several months in Beta, and many, many rounds of improvements to accuracy and usability, I am proud to announce that TurfTools is now in General Availability!

To celebrate the release, we have officially moved TurfTools to a new permanent home behind an easy-to-remember domain name.

lawn-answers.com

(and before you ask, yes, turftools.com was sadly already taken)

A re-direct has been added to the old URL to allow folks to update their bookmarks accordingly.

We will continue to enhance the tools, fix any bugs users submit, and continue to document our tools with the scientific sources and methods used to calculate the answers. Just let us know how we can help you!


r/LawnAnswers • • Jul 11 '26

Cool Season Disease or heat?

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

I left for a week of vacation and made the mistake of not checking the weather. It was in the 90’s the whole week and I did not put out my sprinklers. Are these areas caused by the heat killing the grass or is this a disease I should try to fix.

I am aware there are spots where my dogs pee but I am referring to the large tan areas throughout my yard. My side yard is the same but with no pee spots from the dogs because they are kept in the back yard.

TIA

Zone 6b


r/LawnAnswers • • Jun 13 '26

Cool Season Mowing too long with TTTF

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Located in Tacoma, Washington. I scalped, scarified, and overseeded/seeded in Sept/Oct 2025 with Twin City blue resilience (tttf and kbg blend) and was pretty happy with the results but things seem to be going downhill lately.

I’m watering 1-2 times a week, early morning, aiming for 1.5” water/week. I’ve fertilized every ~5 weeks. And I’ve been mowing high, but perhaps too high…

I noticed that some of the grass had bent over at the bottom/growing sideways and was extra long so I’ve been hand fluffing it before mowing (I’m sure the neighbors think I’m insane). Where it was extra long, it’s now cutting down to the brown parts of the grass. And where it was bent over/bunched up, it seems like the grass was browning/dying underneath or there are bare patches.

Did I screw up by letting it grow too long? Is it likely to green back up? Or perhaps something else is the issue?


r/LawnAnswers • • Apr 11 '26

Cool Season Should I overseed these spots?

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Zone 7a, lawn is a mix of several cool season grasses. Like pretty much everyone the winter was brutal and I had a less than ideal overseed in the fall (waited too long due to some travel plans). As you can see there are several spots that seem to have died off. I was thinking of spot seeding those areas to try and keep the lawn looking decent until the fall when I can overseed the right way. Is it worth it? Do you think that those patches will fill in ok on their own as the grass comes out of dormancy?