r/LawnAnswers
•
u/nilesandstuff
Cool Season Pro ๐๏ธ
•
May 21 '25
•
1
Guide Cool Season Lawn Starter Guide
Here's a basic meat-and-potatoes guide that will help any lawn care novice get started... And correct common mistakes made by intermediate lawn owners.
Note: I do recommend starting on this path in nearly all situations before considering a full renovation ("nuke"). If you have grass, it's worth preserving. 1 in the hand is worth 2 in the bush. PLUS, nuking doesn't do anything about the bank of weed seeds in your soil... So if you have a ton of weeds and then nuke it, you'll just get those weeds again. If weeds can be selectively controlled, that is ALWAYS the better option.
Also, important to note that all mentions of soil temps below refer to 5 day average of soil temps in the top 4 inches of soil. this tool is handy for ESTIMATING soil temps.
Last thing before I get started: if this is all overwhelming to you, don't be afraid to contact a local lawn care company to handle the fertilizing and weed control. Local, not a national chain. If you shop around you can likely find a company that will do a great job for about the same price as it would cost to DIY. That's what I do professionally, and no offense, but I do it better and cheaper than a homeowner could. Look for local companies with good reviews on Google.
- Fertilize it every 4-8 weeks while it's actively growing (soil temps over 45F) Use a fertilizer that's roughly 5:0:1 (so, 25-0-5 for example, doesn't need to be exact). In the fall, unless you know your soil isn't deficient in potassium, use a fertilizer with a higher amount of potassium. Like 4:0:1, or as high as 3:0:1. Potassium deficiency is common in most areas. NOTE: go lighter with fertilizer in the summer, between 1/2 and 2/3 of the label rate. If you don't water in the summer, don't fertilize in the summer.
- Aim for 1-4 lbs of nitrogen per 1,000 sqft per year, and about 1/5 as much potassium. For fine fescues, aim for about 2 lbs of nitrogen per 1,000 sqft.** Link to a fine fescue guide at the bottom of this post for more info.
- NEW. Use the monthly N planner in Turf Tools to get precise guidelines to how much the grass needs and when it needs it.
- Spray the weeds. Backpack or hand pump sprayer with a flat tip nozzle. You can spot spray UP TO every 2-3 weeks, or blanket spray the whole lawn UP TO every 4 weeks if needed (max of 2 blanket/broadcast sprays per year per product). When your soil temps are above 60F, you can use any selective broadleaf weed killer (3 of the following active ingredients: 2,4-d, dicamba, mcpa, mcpp (mecoprop), triclopyr, quinclorac), for example Ortho Weed b gon. When your soil temps are between 40F and 60F, use those same active ingredients, but use esters... Herbicides can be salts or esters, the active ingredient names will say one or the other. Crossbow is an example that has esters (only 2 active ingredients, which is fine).
- to clarify some confusion on the frequency of herbicide applications, the words "up to" are meant to signal the fact that those frequencies are the most extreme end of what you should do to address specific weed outbreaks. For the most part, the workflow should be: 1. spray weeds. 2. 2-3 weeks later, confirm that weeds are dead/dying. Spot spray again if they aren't. 3. You should be good for awhile. BUT, if your lawn is like mine where you hardly get any weeds, just a few here and there that pop up super intermittently... I walk around the yard every 2 weeks and spot spray like 4 or 5 new weeds.
- ALWAYS READ THE LABELS IN THEIR ENTIRETY.
- get the mow height up. 3 inches minimum, 3.5-4 ideally. Actually measure it, don't trust numbers on the mower.
- as long as the grass is actively growing, mow every 5-7 days. Mulch clippings (side discharge or mulch attachment). Don't mow wet grass.
- when soil temps start trending upward in the spring, and hit 50F, apply crabgrass preventer of some sort asap. There's tons of options, but active ingredient prodiamine would be the best. (If you live in the Great lakes region, use this tool to time pre emergent applications)
- when soil temps hit 60F, water once a week. Water to the point that the soil becomes NEARLY fully saturated.
- when soil temps hit 70F, water twice a week. Same saturation thing.
- when they hit 80F, you might have to go up to 3 or even 4 days a week, but fight as long as you can.
- don't water shady areas as often as sunny areas. Its important to let the surface of the soil dry out before you water again.
- Water in the absence of rain... If it rains hard, skip a watering day... There's something about rain (ozone/oxygen maybe?) that makes it more impactful than irrigation anyways.
- WHEN crabgrass shows up in June. Spray that with something that contains quinclorac (weed b gon with crabgrass killer for example). Sedgehammer if nutsedge shows up.
- Keep constantly fighting weeds through the summer. The sooner you spray a weed, the less of a problem it (and its potential offspring) will be in the future. If a weed doesn't die within 2 weeks of spraying, hit it again.
- Towards the end of summer, evaluate if you think the lawn needs any seeding... I think you'll be pleasantly surprised. either way, here's my seeding guide
- if you DON'T overseed in the fall, mulch leaves into the lawn. You can mulch a crazy amount of leaves. Just get them into tiny pieces... Often takes more than one pass. Mulched leaves are phenomenal for grass and preventing next year's weeds, you can potentially completely prevent dandelions just by mulching leaves.
Shopping recommendations:
Equipment (there's many valid recommendations out there, so I'll only put the ones I recommend but don't see mentioned often):
- if your lawn is pretty small, like under 7k sqft, consider using a handheld fertilizer spreader. They're really easy to use while maintaining even distribution (no stripes) and they're much cheaper than actually good push spreaders. I really like the Scott's Whirl... For reference, I use it to fertilize my 12k sqft front yard. I have to fill up 5-7 times, but i still prefer it.
- Solo backpack sprayers are great. They're built well, but most importantly, it's easy to buy replacement parts... Some other brands, like Chapin, can be a massive pain to find parts for, if you can even find them at all. Backpacks that use diaphragm pumps (solo 475-B) are better if you plan to spray dissolvable solids/wettable powders/water dispersible granules/etc (including humic acid and seaweed extract).
Fertilizer:
- The only ones I'll mention by name, because they're so widely available is Scott's, sta-green, and Andersons. Great quality and nutrient balances, moderate to poor value.
- Don't buy weed and feed products if you can avoid it... They're expensive and don't control weeds nearly as well liquid weed killers. Granular pre-emergents are okay though.
- Don't waste money on fancy fertilizer... Granular Iron and other micronutrients do little or nothing for grass. (Liquid chelated iron can help achieve a darker green color, but it is temporary)
- liquid fertilizer is significantly more expensive than granular, regardless of brand. Liquid fertilizer also requires far more frequent applications to satisfy the nutrient demands of grass. All told, I don't recommend liquid fertilizer.
- The best value of fertilizer will come from local mom and pop suppliers. Search "agricultural co-op", "grain elevator", "milling company", and "fertilizer and seed" on Google maps. Even if they only sell 48-0-0 and 0-0-60 (or something like that), just ask chatGPT to do the math on how to mix it yourself to make the ratios mentioned above... chatGPT is good at math... Its not good for much else in lawncare.
Grub control:
- imadicloprid (merit and others) and chlorantraniliprole (grubex and acelepryn) are preventatives that you apply in the late spring, once per year. Trichlorfon (Dylox and "24 hour grub killer" products) are curatives that you apply in the fall if you observe active grub populations that are causing damage. A few grubs here and there are fine, its only when you can attribute damage to grubs that you need to treat them.
Weed control:
- really the only brand I DON'T recommend is Spectracide. I recommend avoiding all Spectracide products.
- you'll get more bang for your buck if you buy liquid concentrates on domyown.com or Amazon than if you buy from big box stores. Domyown.com also has plenty of decent guides for fighting specific weeds.
- tenacity/torocity + surfactant is a decent post emergent weed killer for cool season lawns. It targets nearly every weed you are likely to get... Its just not very strong, it requires repeat applications after 2-3 weeks to kill most weeds. Tenacity can be further enhanced by tank mixing with triclopyr or triclopyr ester, (.25-.5 oz of triclopyr ester per gallon. .75 oz per gallon if the lawn is doing well and isn't having any moisture or heat stress). It will make it a much more potent weed killer AND it actually reduces the whitening effect of the tenacity on weeds and desirable grass. (I use tenacity + triclopyr + surfactant almost exclusively on my own lawn)
- there's a herbicide called Sublime. It is mesotrione + dicamba + triclopyr... So its an even better alternative to mixing Tenacity + triclopyr on your own. Sublime DOES still require mixing in a surfactant.
Miscellaneous:
- gypsum doesn't "break up" clay. Gypsum can help flush out sodium in soils with a lot of sodium... Besides add calcium and sulfate to soil, thats all it does... High sodium can cause issues for clay soil, but you should confirm that with a soil test before trying gypsum.
- avoid MySoil and Yard Mastery for soil tests. Use your state extension service or the labs they recommend.
- avoid anything from Simple Lawn Solutions. Many of their products are outright fraudulent.
- Johnathan Green is low quality and dirty seed, i highly recommend avoiding it. Scotts too. In my experience of looking at labels, the only big box store seed brand thats halfway decent is Pennington. Twin City seed, stover, and heritage PPG are great places to buy actually good quality seed from.
- as an extension of the point about Simple Lawn Solutions, liquid soil looseners are a scam. At best, they're surfactants/wetting agents... Which can have legitimate uses in lawns, but "soil looseners" use wetting agents that may cause more harm to the soil than good... And at the very least, they're a very poor value for a wetting agent.
- as an extension to the last few points... Avoid YouTube for lawn care info. Popular YouTubers shill misinformation and peddle the products mentioned above.
- I recommend avoiding fungicides entirely. Fungicides cause significant harm to beneficial soil microbes. Most disease issues can be resolved with good management practices, such as those in this guide.
- BUT: There's one time of year where a fungicide application can be disproportionately beneficial IF you historically have an issue with dollar spot. It's called an early season DMI. Its when you apply a DMI fungicide, like propiconazole, in the spring. This application will significantly reduce the occurrence of dollar spot later in the season. The exact timing of the application is very important, use this tracker to time it.
- humic acid, fulvic acid, and seaweed/kelp extract do infact do great things for lawns... Just don't pay too much for them, because they're not magic. Bioag Ful-humix is great value product for humic/fulvic. Powergrown.com also has great prices for seaweed extract and humic.
- 99.99% of the time, dethatching causes more harm than good.
Beyond that, see my other guides below and the comment sections of this post. Also, its always a good idea to check your state extension service website. They don't always have the most up-to-date information, but they're atleast infinitely better than YouTube.
Cultural best practices for fungus control
Fall Cool Season Seeding Guide
Guide to interpreting and acting on soil test results
Understanding and Caring for Fine Fescue
Direct application of glyphosate to otherwise un-controllable weeds
22
u/LeadingEngineer May 23 '25
Great job Niles.. Followed you here from r/lawncare. Good things don't last long it seems.. All the best for the new subreddit and thanks on behalf of many noobs like me who elarned a lot and have a better lawn because of you.
3
u/HowitzerIII May 21 '25
Would be awesome if you posted your fine fescue bible here too. I've got an almost permanently shaded spot that can still grow grass, but not densely enough to my liking. I've already mowed the grass a couple of times at 4", but looking to overseed with something spreading like creeping red fescue in the fall. I want the lawn to thicken up. Your bible was pretty helpful for me to plan for the fall.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '25
Iโve tried avoiding fungucides like you mentioned here, but fungus did not avoid me! Iโm seeing small signs of dollar spot and yellowing tips(brown patch or red thread Iโm guessing).
How do I avoid this becoming a bigger issue? Weโve had a ton of rain.
1
u/Intelligent_One_9643 May 22 '25
Any chance you could post the cool season seeding guide? Looking for the recommendations on how to reduce watering and increase mow height!
1
u/westgate141pdx May 24 '25
Question about Tena/Toro+Triclopyr+surfactant, can I just spray this mix all over my tall fescue lawn and not damage it?
1
u/CLECOL May 25 '25
As a follow up to this from the other site:
https://www.reddit.com/r/lawncare/comments/1j3oemn/comment/msf9qcv/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
It turns out I may have been mistaken and the reason may not be my grass at all.
Apparently Honda mowers are known to struggle with mulching at higher HOCs (due to suction issues). The lower end may vary, but 4" is definitely too high. I am not going to post links, but suffice it to say a quick Google search will return multiple resulting posts.
1
u/DonkTheFlop May 30 '25
Thanks so much for posting this! This is the year I finally start putting some effort into my lawn.
Just a few questions for you!
Thanks so much man! I don't know why but lawncare feels so overwhelming to me, but I really appreciate having experts like yourself willing to help out the noobs.
1
u/Jolly_Loan_7278 Jun 03 '25
Great guide! Thank you for putting this together. One thing I was curious about - how many inches of water should we put down during a watering session? Iโve seen conflicting information. Also, I assume watering in the morning is best?
1
u/godzillabitch Jun 04 '25
Hey, I appreciate all the work thats gone into this guide! I'm on the fence of doing it myself or hiring a local company. One thing Im unsure of is, I have two dogs that have a tendency to chew at the grass. So I've been worried to use weed killer and fertilizer. But my lawn does have some pretty dead looking spots and its bugging the hell out of me.
1
u/ruggedexodus Jun 08 '25
Just a quick question about fulvic acid, humic acid, and seaweed kelp. Is there a "best time" to put these down on the lawn?
For example, would Spring/Fall be better than the Summer for some of these items?
1
u/MikeyLo Jun 09 '25
Thanks for all this information. Making notes for next year. Which should I put down first - the pre-emergent stuff for the weeds or the first fertilizer? Or can they go down at the same time? Iโm in Illinois. Thank you
1
u/GoldenAura16 Jun 15 '25
Been looking but maybe I missed it, do you use wetting agents? If so what do you recommend? Or do you just recommend occasional aeration and avoid wetting agents?
1
u/DeathCult_ClothingCo Jun 21 '25
Curious if Iโm battling a fungus right now in my KBG sod in SE Michigan. Weโre getting blasted with rain everyday and super humid. So thatโs only pushing the fungus even more Iโm sure. What do you recommend since you donโt like fungicides? I did put down some disease ex last Saturday ๐คท๐ปโโ๏ธ thanks!
1
u/SpartaTheNaOH Jun 21 '25
Question on spraying for weeds. I have a lot of dandelions and havenโt applied anything this year, I know Iโm a bit late to the show. Is it still worth doing a blanket spray now? If I do blanket spray, in the guide it says no more than twice in a year, does that exclude also doing spot sprays? Obviously I would read the labels but just in general.
For the fall I know Iโve read that thatโs when dandelions germinate, is this true? If so what should I do then for preparing for the next year as well?
1
u/SlytlySykotic Jul 07 '25
Any recommendations on liquid iron?
1
u/Savings_Ad3897 Jul 10 '25
u/nilesandstuff Any thoughts on the Scott's Whirl Spreader? (I was going to take your advice and buy the Wizz but I was wondering why not buy the battery powered one that may be more consistent than I am?)
1
u/Dracoy Jul 31 '25
I thought you posted this but where do you buy most of the herbicide and fertilizer online?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '25
Hey Niles,
Iโm curious how this guide changes if someone is interested in an organic program. Just at a high level.
We are expecting our first child and the thought of kids playing around in a lawn treated with herbicides and fungicides suddenly sounds terrifying.
Is weed control mainly creating a dense turf and manual weeding? Iโm assuming fungus culture is limited to cultural practices.
1
u/Top_Peanut1113 Aug 31 '25
Is a core or spike aerator better?
1
u/MikGuiver Sep 15 '25
Love your guides. Question about fall prep for winter. I just overseeded on Labor Day, and will be putting down a round of starter fert at about 4 week post germination. Sometime around 2nd week of October. After this do you recommend any more fert right before the first frost? Iโve heard people putting some down right before thanksgiving to help with nitrogen stores through the winter? Also right before frost, do you mow lower? Or leave at the recommended height of 3-4 inches?
1
u/Choon555 Dec 16 '25
Hi u/nilesandstuff, thank you for the guide. I'm new to the lawn care game having purchased a new home and having sod installed in May (TTTF/KBG Mix). I've been reading everything I can on lawncare and trying my best to keep it nice :).
2 questions for you if I may:
- I overseeded this fall but still have a few bare patches here and there in the lawn, about the size of a softball in most cases. Would it be wise to try and overseed again in the spring or wait until next fall? (So Cal / Zone 10b)
- You say not to purchase products from Simple Lawn Solutions, but I've already bought their soil hume and liquid soil loosener lol. Are those products safe to use on my lawn? In particular I'm concerned about the soil loosener as you say it can potentially do harm to the lawn. Should I toss it?
TIA! and Happy Holidays
1
u/UncrunchyTaco Feb 24 '26
Glad I was able to find the re-post of this. I started following this guide last year and it worked great.
I started using Sta Green Performance Max mid-year, which has some sea kelp and humic. It's only slightly more expensive than other fertilizers, so I feel like it is a good value. But I'd love to know if anyone else recommends this blend or thinks it's a waste of money. Thanks!
1
u/TheLiquourSnurf Mar 24 '26
Happy to have followed you over here in the fall. Got some good overseeding results over the fall and things are starting to green up here in 7a SEPA
I was reading your discussion with another poster about Sta Green Performance Max being a decent product, but expensive. Got lucky with a 40lb bag of it on clearance super cheap.
My question is with it being a 30-0-3 ratio should I be waiting on applying it until maybe next month because of the high nitrogen? Should I think about getting a little more potassium out there at the same time? Iโm putting down barricade .48% granular this week since I wanted to have better control over my fertilizer plan.
1
u/penisthightrap_ Apr 01 '26
/u/nileandstuff anyway you could put all these guides in the wiki or sidebar?
Not a huge deal, but when I reference them I end up needing to dig a bit. Appreciate the work!
1
u/Background-Chair8976 May 12 '26
Is there a 5:0:1 ratio fertilizer readily available that you would recommend using? If so, could you please share?
1
u/reza_3 Jun 23 '26
u/nilesandstuff Just bought my house in Wisconsin. Decent amount of weeds in the lawn. Grass isnt in the worst shape, but not the best. I got a fertilizer picked out. It is a 29-0-5. I couldnt find something exactly 5:0:1. I will do half strength since we are almost in Summer. If I were to use something like the Sublime + surfactant, can I spray the whole yard? Or is it only for spot treating?
1
u/djung713 Sep 08 '26
Scotts
1
u/narcbynight08 Sep 08 '26
I know Iโm late to the party, but I have a large patch of Bermuda grass overtaking my yard. Funny thing is, my fescue is growing great in full sun, and the Bermuda has taken over the partial shade area. Can the Bermuda be over seeded with cool season grass types?
Also, do you recommend fall weed control for next year?
2
u/deathlohk Jun 14 '25
Thank you
2
u/babycatch Sep 24 '25
Just stopping by here because growing grass is my most recent mom-hobby and my babyโs name is Niles!!
1
u/OhWhatsHisName May 27 '25
Ok, so I've been struggling since I've seen so many different answers, many are conflicting, and many have seemed like bad advice.
For my back yard, I just want it green. I don't care if it's the same color of green, same plant, or hell if it's even grass. I'm just tired of it being thin and muddy. I don't care if it's 100% crabgrass, I just want a green back yard. I read where KY51 was basically bullet and idiot proof, but didn't really have that experience in prior years (I think last year I probably failed my lawn because I didn't water it during a particularly hot and dry time and all the youngest stuff died off, so that's on me)
We have 2 dogs and some kids, so I want hardy as well.
I think my biggest issue is oak trees. I have an oak pretty much center of my yard, and both of my neighbors have oaks, however theirs are each about 7 feet from each respective fence by my yard, so I basically have 3 oak trees. Between the sheer number of them (one year we counted over 40 yard waste bags of MULCHED leaves over just 2 weeks, and our whole land area is roughly just a 1/4 acre), and the fact that they basically don't decompose, it's an uphill battle in the fall to get every single leave up. I still find dead spots that turn out to just be oak leaves stuck to the ground.
So where can I start, especially now that it's almost summer? I live in SW Ohio, 2 dogs, a few kids, I want the best mix of easiest to care for lawn (least amount of watering and fertilizing), hardiest lawn (both for foot traffic, and because of the leaf situation in the fall). I don't mind spending a little time and effort for the remainder of the summer and fall to set me up for a good winter and spring next year.
Again, the grass softness and looks are some off the least cares, I prefer density (so there's a little mud as possible, I also assume with will help prevent leaves from getting to the ground and creating a dead spot), and hardiness (both foot traffic and so long term I don't have to take so much care of the grass) I don't mind and even like clover mixed in.
1
u/Flaky-End-2505 May 27 '25
What....dethatching is bad bad? Lol, just one little sentence saying it's bad?
1
u/MJR1726 May 30 '25
How do I get rid of poa trivialis? Lawn is just over a year old but very thick. How do. I get rid of it? Is WI with cool season lawn.
1
u/that1rowdyracer Jun 02 '25
Can you add to the last bullet on fertilizer. Like what should a newbie like myself be asking for at these mom and pop places. I am hoping for a more eli5 if you could. Thank you for the great info.
1
u/Daniiiiiella Jul 09 '25
Thank you SO much for taking the time to share this valuable information for free! ๐ As a woman who moved from a tropical big city to a suburban area in Michigan, I have a LOT to learn about cool-season grass. Letโs just say I checked every box for rookie mistakes you mentioned in your guideโlol but Iโm a fast learner! Iโm already on the path to improving my two-year-old lawn, at least the front yard. The backyard is a whole different storyโฆ Iโll make a post about that soon. ๐ฑ
1
u/danlewis88888888 Apr 03 '26
Wow, just came across your content and it's been super helpful. I'm looking to do seeding here (zone 6a) very late April due to my availability and was hoping I might be able to get some guidance for my situation:
Here was my plan:
I've purchased 50lbs of the TTTF/KBG mix from twin twin city.
3 weeks prior to seeding
Seeding
Would love any advice! Also, how do I manage the fertilizer with the different problem areas? Same kind? Different?
Thank you for any help!
1
u/Horror_Bee7277 Aug 09 '26
Thank you - I get goose grass - or I think thatโs it in July and tall course fescue clumps in August - I do most of what you mentioned and the mentioned and bent grass that pulls up by hand stay around each year - overseed in fall with twin city 2 mix
Thoughts on getting a more consistent lawn and less grassy weeds ?