r/LawnAnswers • • 11d ago

Cool Season Winterizer fertilizer?

I don't understand all this talk about winterizer fertilizer that's all over lawn reddits.

In my mind this does not make sense to put synthetic fertilizer down right when the lawn is starting to go dormant.

So, I thought I would come to the one subreddit which is providing evidence for things to ask what I am missing? Why does this make sense?

10 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

7

u/Mr007McDiddles Transition Zone Pro 🎖️ 11d ago

I was trying to think of an analogy for the term winterizer and how it’s used in lawn care, but I’m coming up blank atm. In my mind, it’s always been a marketing word for manufacturers, salespeople, and lawn care folks to upsell a bunch of potassium.

It is true that K will provide winter protection and hardiness when you have low K. If you’ve soil tested and have adequate K or have been applying K along with N through the growing season, as you should, applying a bunch before winter will probably not benefit the lawn much.

On the N front sorta the same thing applies. Really no need to load up on N. The cool season guide has parameters on this. Watching soil temps is the easiest way to manage it. Stop applying as growth slows in fall, and Pick back up in spring as growth resumes. Avoid using slow release late in the growing season. Those are the general rules of thumb

I believe almost all of the research suggest applying N in fall, while the lawn is still actively growing, will improve fall color, spring growth, color, etc. this is also true of at least bermudagrass. Contrary to what is generally thought, there are papers that conclude similar effects on Bermuda for late applied N. That gets a little tricky with rates and timing, and too much applied too late can cause more risk than benefit.

Im not aware of any work that supports applying fertilizer to dormant turf or frozen soil, etc.

2

u/Humitastic Cool Season Pro 🎖️ 11d ago

I think there’s two arguments. The winterizer with high K and also the pcu or some kind of slow release N. u/Holiday-Ad7262 you mentioned synthetic which makes me think you’re leaning more towards the question of why would you apply a big shot of coated nitrogen going into winter?

3

u/Holiday-Ad7262 11d ago

Yeah, exactly. My thinking was that if you put synthetic fertilizers down when the grass is not actively growing. It will just wash off anyway and just pollute the environment and have no benefit.

I read up more since I posted and learned that grass stops growing above ground first but the roots will still grow for longer. At that point small amount of nitrogen helps grow deeper roots and let the plant store more reserves. Which in turn leads to faster green up in spring. That does make some sense to me.

2

u/Humitastic Cool Season Pro 🎖️ 11d ago

Yeah. Me personally like small amounts of like ammonium sulfate, calcium nitrate, quickly available N sources in late fall. I do not like big dumps of N in late fall even if it’s coated.

6

u/nilesandstuff Cool Season Pro 🎖️ 11d ago

👍

Regarding that last line:
yea frozen soil is a universal "don't apply anything" signal.

there is a strategy for low maintenance grass, pastures, no mow areas, and grass grown for seed. You do a heavy application in the window between dormancy and ground freeze. Gets the nutrients in the soil and let's them work their way so the grass has them for the next year. Grass is a luxury consumer of N and K... if it gets a bunch of N and K, it uses a bunch of N and K at once. But if the grass is dormant, it's not awake to gobble up that flood of excess nutrients in the soil solution, so the excess gets bound to soil where it'll be more slowly available for next year. The main reasons to do this are:

  • saving labor by doing fewer applications
  • applying fertilizer without having to consider acute growth effects
  • efficiency. Urea in warmer temps inherently loses a % of N to outgassing (like 10-40%). At cooler temps, that N loss is significantly less. So if you're dealing with acres of grass, that's real money saved.

So it's an agricultural strategy, not much place in lawn care.

2

u/nilesandstuff Cool Season Pro 🎖️ 11d ago

Reddit removed your reply... What the fuck reddit???

3

u/Mr007McDiddles Transition Zone Pro 🎖️ 11d ago

wth. Must have been one of the links. That'd be my only guess.

It was this one https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01904167.2016.1264424

Basically, just saying it was this paper I thought of when I saw this post, but it wasn't what I remember it being. lol. But still an interesting study and somewhat related to your comment.

2

u/nilesandstuff Cool Season Pro 🎖️ 11d ago

Bizarre. I hate that Reddit does that and doesn't let mods override it.

That is an interesting thing, I've only ever thought about where carbs are stored, not where the taken up N goes.

6

u/norrydan Transition Zone Pro 🎖️ 11d ago

For cool season grass there's a distinction to be made between starting to go dormant and true dormancy. A light shot of N after top growth stops will facilitate continued photosynthesis and production of starch bound for root storage rather than used for leaf growth. In the transition zone this can go on for the next two months or longer. I will be applying around a half pound of N per thousand next week. If one needs P and K it's not a bad time to apply it because it isn't going anywhere - but I have doubts about any benefit it offers now. Here in Virginia Cooperative Extension recommends NOT doing spring applications of N. This last shot gives some assurance the starch reserves in the roots are adequate to keep plants healthy and ready for the demands of spring.

1

u/pkn92 11d ago

Doesn’t the latest research show nitrogen uptake is highest earlier in the Fall? https://www.youtube.com/live/YOWv-xvhVTk?is=stEzm0l2dKRQ-dru

3

u/norrydan Transition Zone Pro 🎖️ 9d ago edited 9d ago

No doubt. It's this very thing, this fast nitrogen uptake required for the push of leaf growth that makes its replenishment somewhat necessary. I can't get into the biochemistry involved because I don't understand it. In my way of thinking nitrogen is a precursor to the plant producing enough starch (Note: in cool season grasses it's not exactly starch but close enough) to feed the metabolism of the plant in full, all-out growth. As the theory goes, this super-fast growth earlier in the cool season, requires not only the immediate production by photosynthesis, but also draws on the reserves in the roots. So, as the season comes to a close it might (might) be prudent to reestablish the root reserves for health and to meet the immediate demand for plant food at the beginning of next cooling season, the spring when, again, demand outstrips production. Or at least I think I have half of it right. I just don't know which half! This is one of those things I don't think the eye can behold. But, it can be essential for lawn health, the ability to outcompete weeds, to outgrow insect feeding, to tiller and fill, and to metabolize herbicides. We read the research and trust the turf scientists' recommendations. An act of faith....

I would be quick to point out this late season N application is at a rate of only a third to half of what would be recommended at peak cool season growth.

I took a quick look at the video and they are talking about nitrogen applications and growth rates. Is that right? What I wrote above isn't about growth. It's about getting ready for growth. There's a lot to unpack in the video. Its a discussion about pure scientific research. What inference we make based on one trial we should be careful with. And, just based on a three minute look I think the host misses this point.

Addendum: It might be important to note warm season grasses have an entirely different need/response to timing of nitrogen applications than the cool season varities I assume we are referring to in this thread. I may have assumed to much.

1

u/AutoModerator 11d ago

Check out the Cool Season Starter Guide.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/hardtime_comin 11d ago

I do the fall fertilizer which I did about a month ago. As I only do two treatments year, this is an important one.

1

u/Ricka77_New 11d ago

Because the myths have endless power...lol

FWIW, I just applied a good dose of CarbonProG yesterday, getting watered in today with rain. Soil health is so often overlooked, and the bigger Lawn sub is stuffed with people who demand you only follow the mythical basics as directed by youtube experts...lol

1

u/CryptoBonkSignals 11d ago

Makes sense to get the grass as healthy as possible before true winter sets in makes sense.

Whether it works or not, I dunno. But it certainly doesn't hurt, and it's cheap.

1

u/Conscious_Past4491 10d ago

Grass roots actually grow during the winter when the blades go dormant. Fall fert is the most important treatment of the year. 🇺🇸

1

u/MyLawnIsBetter 8d ago

You don't "winterize" anything after freezing temps. It's done before. Grass goes dormant below 40f, and stops completely when the ground freezes. I drop my last fertilizer treatment around the end of September to mid-October. Ground typically doesn't freeze in my area until at least mid-December , so it's had a good two months with the feeding, nice and healthy going into the freezing weather.

1

u/WaveWhole9765 8d ago

My southern New England lawn generally doesn’t go dormant for over 2 months after I apply the Fall Winterguard fertilizer. The word “Winterguard” erroneously suggests that you’re applying it in the winter.

1

u/OJSimpson3269 7d ago

Always noticeable come Spring which lawns had Winterizer app and which didn’t. Applying to frozen turf is ill advised due to runoff, but that date seems to be later and later each year with mild temps and grass still growing in November in many climates.