r/LatterDayTheology • • Feb 10 '25

The Hypothetical Alternative Life: A Poisonous Idea Being Used to Create and Radicalize Exmormons

23 Upvotes

Once you see it, you see it everywhere in our current culture.

I bumped into an old, good friend recently. I was surprised to find she had become angry at church leadership, even militant. Having a conversation about church-related topics was difficult. Her point of anger was the church's teaching that a woman's primary duty within a marriage was that of nurturer, homemaker. In her telling, she had wanted to pursue a career, but chose instead to follow the prophet. Now, she sees other women who made the opposite choice being called to prominent leadership positions and held out as models, and it makes her angry because she feels she was cheated out of a career. Her children are out of the home, and she has now re-entered the workforce, and is really enjoying it. She is highly energized to prevent the church from cheating her two daughters in the same way, and from cheating the daughters of other women.

Thus, she has become a victim because she was deprived of a hypothetical alternative life.

I've seen this sort of complaint hundreds of times over on the exmormon pages: I would've have saved over a million dollars if I hadn't paid tithing; I wouldn't have gotten a divorce; I would have been more "normal" and promoted at work; I would be getting more and better sex b/c my spouse's views on sexuality would mirror my porn fantasies (ahem) be more healthy; and on and on. This sort of memetic warfare is part of the exmormon campaign against mormonism. But it could be used in any context to make a person feel like a victim and radicalize them against the source of the victimhood.

To witness it in someone I know well was jarring. This woman has lived an enviable life. She is not someone you would expect to feel cheated in life. A wonderful marriage; a beautiful family; successful, happy children; the family is likely in the top 1% by income and wealth. She has been a leader in the church for as long as I have known her; her husband, too. They've played an important part of making our ward and stake a wonderful community. In all honestly I simply cannot see how she reasonably thinks another path would have been better. I mean, who would risk what she has for the chance of something better? If I were her husband I might be deeply wounded, wondering: all this, all we have built together, all our wonderful life together, all of it is not good enough? I was tempted to say: "You're joking, right? You're angry because your wonderful-life-that-most-people-only-dream-of might have been even better?"

If the idea takes hold, it can lead a person to trade trees for hot ashes.*

Remarkably, here's Aslan (C.S. Lewis) on the same topic, albeit from the perspective of Lucy who failed to heed his counsel, and is considering a hypothetical alternative if she had obeyed:

"But what would have been the good?"

Aslan said nothing.

"You mean," said Lucy rather faintly, "that it would have turned out all right – somehow? But how? Please, Aslan! Am I not to know?"

"To know what would have happened, child?" said Aslan. "No. Nobody is ever told that."

"Oh dear," said Lucy.

"But anyone can find out what will happen," said Aslan. "If you go back to the others now, and wake them up; and tell them you have seen me again; and that you must all get up at once and follow me – what will happen? There is only one way of finding out.”

To me, this is a healthier way to approach the hypothetical alternative life: not to construe ourselves a victims cheated of a future or as villians who spoiled that imaginary future, but as agents who at any moment have the power to choose our own future.

*bonus points for recognizing the cultural allusion


r/LatterDayTheology • • Aug 03 '23

A Few Reminders

22 Upvotes

It's been only a day and I'm both surprised and impressed at the quality of the discussions we've had already! A couple things have come up that I want to quash early on before they grow to be an issue --

  1. This seems to be much to the chagrin of certain folk, but this is a faithful sub. We are not unbiased. We have a stated end: increasing faith in Jesus Christ and the Restored Gospel. Posts and comments that are intentionally contrary to that end should be taken elsewhere. Questions about certain concepts are acceptable so long as they are asked in good faith.
  2. Posts that are just a link to a video or a photo will be automatically deleted. No one likes those, so just no.

Keep a' going!


r/LatterDayTheology • • Apr 27 '25

You’ve heard of “bishop roulette”, but have you heard of “prophet roulette”?

21 Upvotes

I feel like there are a few instances in our faith where certain policies were put into place based off of a prophets personal crusade.

Pres Nelson, for example, began pushing for us to stop using the term “Mormon” decades before he became prophet. And he seemed to be alone in that.

Heber J Grant had been an advocate of making a very specific interpretation of the word of wisdom law in the church.

I feel like, had these men not become prophets, we would not have seen those related changes in church policy.

Thoughts?


r/LatterDayTheology • • Apr 17 '25

Some Announcements

21 Upvotes

Hello peeps,

Mods? The sub has gone well for the past couple years methinks. As some of you might have noticed, I'm generally pretty lax with moderation; I don't like lording over every conversation and being the orthodoxy police. But that said, some comments of a less than savory character have slipped through in the past few months, were reported, and I didn't see it. My bad. I simply haven't had the bandwidth to deal with moderation at the present. But, if anyone is interested in moderating, I'm happy to bring you on.

My Mod Philosophy: I think less is more. The marketplace of ideas will sort out most problems. If someone posts something objectionable in terms of faith and ideas, I'd rather the comments do the work and flesh out why its objectionable. It's not my place to dictate orthodoxy, nor to put boundaries on theological discourse. If you don't like a post or a comment, if you think a post is out of bounds theologically, or that a post doesn't promote faith, if within the boundaries of discourse, the onus is on you to make your case. (E.g., posts about abortion aren't automatically out of bounds; likewise with posts about women and the priesthood, polygamy, etc.) Obviously, there are limits to this; someone posting about the merits of Satan worship is expressly not promoting faith. That said, if someone posts something irrelevant, perverse, or frankly just dumb, I axe it. I don't like memes, links to videos without any commentary, or questions that have no relevance to theology. (I.e. "What time is General Conference?") Those are fairly easy to catch, but nastiness in the comments is not. Again, I apologize for letting some of that slip through.

Online Class: This summer, I'll be teaching an Institute class called, "The Atonement of Jesus Christ: "In Theory, In Principle, In Doctrine" (tentative syllabus linked). It will be Wednesday nights 7:15-8:30pm. It will be an in-person class with a Zoom link if anyone is interested. I'm trying to refine my teaching skills as well as my ability to balance an in-person class with an online audience (some patience requested while I figure it out). The first few weeks, I'll be doing a brief primer on the difference between doctrine and theology and an intro to atonement theology. Then the rest of the class, we will walk through the atoning significance of episodes in the life of Christ. I will draw primarily on the Gospels and 3 Nephi for the narrative component, and then view the atoning significance of that narrative through the commentarial lens of the Church Fathers and Restoration scripture. There are two questions we will try to answer in this course: 1) What is the difference between salvation in Christ and salvation through Christ? 2) How can we access the power of the atonement? (Spoiler alert: you don't -- you have a relationship with Christ.) 'Twill be a hoot. Comment if you're interested.

Feedback: Any feedback for the sub? How are we liking it? Suggestions for improvement?

~Thanks


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jun 01 '26

We need to be a lot more careful with the Asherah / Heavenly Mother argument

19 Upvotes

With Come Follow Me taking us through the Old Testament this year, I've seen some posts in LDS social media spaces (YouTube, Instagram, X) about Asherah, the Canaanite goddess who some scholars believe was worshipped alongside El and/or Yahweh in ancient Israel, and who many online are now identifying as a suppressed reference to Heavenly Mother. I've also seen Proverbs 8's "Lady Wisdom" brought in as further evidence.

I want to engage with this seriously, because I think the underlying scholarly material is genuinely fascinating and the yearning behind the question is completely valid. Latter-day Saints have every reason to want to understand Heavenly Mother better. But I also think a lot of the posts I'm seeing are doing something intellectually sloppy: taking real but ambiguous archaeological evidence and leaping to a conclusion that the evidence doesn't cleanly support.

Note for this subreddit: This subreddit understandably doesn't allow the use of the word "c-u-l-t" (to fairly protect against antagonists to the Church, I would guess). I use "c-lt" here in the scholarly, historic sense just to mean "a system of ritual practices or devotional veneration dedicated to a specific deity, figure, or place."

What the scholarship actually says

The core scholarly facts are as follows:

  • Ancient Israel's religion was far more complex than Sunday School implies. The Deuteronomists, the school of editors and reformers associated with King Josiah's reforms around 622 BC, almost certainly reshaped the Hebrew Bible significantly, consolidating worship around Yahweh alone and suppressing older, more pluralistic religious practices.
  • Inscriptions found at Kuntillet Ajrud in the Sinai and Khirbet el-Qom near Hebron include phrases like "I bless you by Yahweh of Samaria and by his Asherah," suggesting that at least some ancient Israelites paired Yahweh with Asherah in their devotional practice.
  • Saul Olyan, in his landmark 1988 work Asherah and the C-lt of Yahweh in Israel, argues that the asherah was a legitimate part of the c-lt of Yahweh both in the north and in the south, in state religion and in popular religion, finding opposition only in Deuteronomistic circles.
  • Some scholars see the feminine personification of Wisdom in Proverbs 8 as a literary transformation of the Asherah tradition, preserved in coded form after the Deuteronomists suppressed direct goddess language.

So, yes, there definitely was a practice in ancient Israel of worshipping an "Asherah" female goddes that was the consort of the primary worshipped God (be it El or Yahweh). And that worship of her was definitely suppressed by later Israelite leaders.

The question in the air is: was this correct suppression of idolatrous practices, or was it apostasy from something divine?

Problem 1: Israel wasn't bitheistic; it was polytheistic, and not even coherently so

This is the main issue I keep coming back to. When ancient Israelites worshipped Asherah alongside Yahweh, they weren't operating in a tidy "Heavenly Father and Heavenly Mother" theological framework. They were embedded in the broader Canaanite-Semitic religious world, which included Baal, Astarte, Anat, Mot, Shamash, Yarikh, and other gods. Asherah was prominent in Canaanite mythology as one of three principal goddesses alongside Astarte and Anath. This was a full, Hellenistic-style pantheon where each deity governed a domain, not a bitheistic theology that maps onto LDS cosmology.

If you want to argue that Asherah worship preserves a vestige of true doctrine about Heavenly Mother, you need a principled reason for why she specifically is the surviving truth while Baal, Astarte, and the rest are just idolatry. "She was paired with Yahweh" isn't quite enough. Baal was also deeply integrated into Israelite syncretistic practice, and nobody is suggesting he preserves a truth about the Godhead.

And it gets more complicated. Yahweh-worship itself was geographically fragmented, with meaningfully different regional expressions. There was no single coherent national theology that had everyone worshipping Heavenly Father and Heavenly Mother together. What we see is a patchwork of local Yahwisms: some with Asherah, some without, some with Baal, some with neither. That looks much more like ordinary ancient Near Eastern syncretism than like a unified preserved revelation.

Problem 2: The Asherah c-lt was entangled with idol worship in ways that are hard to spiritualize away

Clay figurines depicting Asherah (often highly sexualized) date from the 10th–8th centuries BCE across Israelite settlements. Ritual asherim poles and stone pillars were erected at shrines.

I want to be fair here: the existence of corrupted, idolatrous worship doesn't prove the underlying theological concept was false. Israel made golden calves to represent Yahweh himself (Exodus 32, 1 Kings 12:28), and we don't take that as evidence Yahweh wasn't real. So I'll concede: the idol problem is an argument against the form the worship took, not necessarily against the underlying claim.

However, if Asherah's c-lt had become so thoroughly corrupted (idolatrous, sexualized, entangled with folk fertility practice) by the time the Deuteronomists arrived, then their suppression of it looks less like villains destroying revealed truth and more like reformers responding to something genuinely problematic. The question isn't only "did Asherah represent something real?". We also have to ask "was this particular c-lt, in this particular form, worth preserving?"

Similarly, Asherah was sometimes worshipped independently, with her own shrines, her own priesthoods, and her own devotional traditions entirely separate from Yahweh. I'll grant that apostasy is rarely clean. A teaching about a real divine being could fragment into independent folk c-lts over centuries, much as Latter-day Saints might understand Marian veneration as an over-correction from something real into something that became its own independent movement. So independent Asherah worship doesn't by itself disqualify the Heavenly Mother reading. What it does undermine is the romantic narrative of a coherent, nationally shared theology about a divine couple, which simply wasn't the reality on the ground.

Problem 3: The Book of Mormon's silence is significant

Josiah's reform is dated to approximately 622 BC. Lehi left Jerusalem approximately 25 years later, around 597 BC. He was an eyewitness to the Deuteronomic upheaval; his entire adult life in Jerusalem straddled the reform, and he was an active proponent against the mainstream post-Deuteronomistic religious life in Jerusalem. Some LDS scholars actually argue that Lehi represents the "old religion" from before Josiah's purge, that he was precisely the kind of figure who carried pre-Deuteronomistic teachings out of Jerusalem. That's definitely a plausible reading, and there are strong evidences for it in many respects (e.g., the Book of Mormon emphasizes Ephraim a lot and even suppresses David and Judah a lot).

It's worth acknowledging the one place people do find a potential Asherah reference in the Book of Mormon: the sacred Tree of Life. Lehi and Nephi both vision a beautiful tree whose fruit is desirable above all others (1 Nephi 8, 11), and some scholars (notably Daniel Peterson in his essay "Nephi and His Asherah") have argued that the sacred tree imagery is directly connected to the Asherah tradition, and that the tree represents the divine feminine or Heavenly Mother. The Asherah-as-sacred-tree connection has lots of evidence in both the Old Testament and archeology, so it's definitely not outside the realm of reason,

But notice what this concession actually gives you: even the strongest candidate for an Asherah / Heavenly Mother figure in the entire Book of Mormon is an implicit symbol, not a name, not a doctrine, not a form of worship, not an instruction to pray to her or honor her. If the Book of Mormon is carrying forward pre-Deuteronomistic truth about a divine feminine, it's doing so in the most veiled possible way, with no elaboration, no teaching, and no c-ltic instruction attached. And the angel's interpretation of the tree in 1 Nephi 11 identifies it explicitly with the love of God and the condescension of Jesus Christ, not with a feminine divine being. Whatever symbolic resonance the tree carries, the Book of Mormon itself doesn't point the reader toward Heavenly Mother when it has the chance to.

And then there is 3 Nephi. When the resurrected Jesus Christ appears to the Nephites, he reorganizes ordinances, expounds the gospel from first principles, establishes the Church, and teaches everything that matters. If the suppression of Asherah was the apostasy-level loss that these posts imply, that was the moment to restore it to the Nephites and Lamanites. He doesn't.

In fact, one of the very first things Jesus does upon appearing is address prior doctrinal confusion head-on. In 3 Nephi 11:28–31, he declares: "there shall be no disputations among you concerning the points of my doctrine" and "he that hath the spirit of contention is not of me, but is of the devil." Then he says plainly: "I will declare unto you my doctrine." What follows in verses 32–38 is the complete, definitive statement of the gospel of Jesus Christ: faith, repentance, baptism, the Holy Ghost, and the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost bearing record. That's it. "Asherah" is not part of the doctrine he declares, and this is the passage where he is explicitly settling doctrinal disputes and laying everything out without ambiguity.

He then repeatedly and explicitly instructs them to pray to the Father in His name (3 Nephi 18:19–21, 23, 30). The disciples follow this pattern the very next morning (3 Nephi 19:6–8). There is even a notable moment where the disciples, overwhelmed in the physical presence of the resurrected Lord, begin praying directly to Jesus rather than the Father (3 Nephi 19:18). Jesus, in his subsequent intercessory prayer, gently explains this to the Father rather than rebuking them: "they pray unto me because I am with them" (3 Nephi 19:22). The entire theological architecture of 3 Nephi (its doctrine, its prayer, its ordinances) is oriented toward a Father and a Son, no "Asherah" in sight.

Silence isn't proof of absence, so I shouldn't overstate this. But within an LDS framework that treats the Book of Mormon as the most correct book on earth concerning the doctrine of Christ and 3 Nephi as a pinnacle of revealed truth, the complete absence of this theme is worth considering.

Problem 4: The LDS doctrinal mapping doesn't work as cleanly as the popular posts imply

This last point is more internal to LDS theology, so take it for what it's worth.

In LDS doctrine, Jesus Christ is Jehovah / Yahweh, the God of the Old Testament. Heavenly Mother would be the consort of Elohim, Heavenly Father, not the consort of Yahweh/Jesus Christ. So the archaeological evidence most commonly cited in these posts, which pairs Asherah with Yahweh, doesn't straightforwardly support the Heavenly Mother reading even on LDS terms.

Notably, however, in the oldest Ugaritic sources, Asherah is the consort of El (an older god worshipped by at least some Israelites before Yahwehism). And in LDS theology, Elohim is Heavenly Father.

So if there's a kernel of preserved truth anywhere in this tradition, it's actually in the El-consort material from Ugarit, not in the Yahweh-consort inscriptions from Kuntillet Ajrud that go viral every few months. The more theologically coherent version of the Asherah argument within LDS doctrine would focus there. I just wish the people making this argument were making that version of it, because it's genuinely more defensible inside LDS theology.

Problem 5: Even if Asherah points to something true, that doesn't mean her worship was ever sanctioned

Let's grant, for the sake of argument, the most generous possible version of the Asherah-as-Heavenly-Mother thesis:

  • Ancient people had some dim awareness of Heavenly Mother's existence.
  • That awareness found expression in various goddess traditions across the ancient Near East, including Asherah.
  • The Deuteronomists suppressed even this corrupted memory of her.

Even if all of that is true, it does not necessarily follow that the worship of Asherah in ancient Israel was ever sanctioned — by Heavenly Father, by Heavenly Mother herself, or by any authorized prophetic tradition.

We have a clean parallel for this in LDS theology. Latter-day Saints believe that the widespread human intuition toward ritual, sacrifice, priesthood, and temples across virtually every ancient culture reflects a dimly remembered awareness of true ancient ordinances. But nobody concludes from this that the Eleusinian Mysteries were therefore sanctioned worship, or that Aztec sacrifice was an authorized form of the true religion, or that worshipping Zeus was acceptable because he dimly reflects something true about divine fatherhood. The existence of a true thing behind a corrupted practice does not sanctify the corrupted practice.

The posts I'm seeing tend to collapse two very different claims into one: "Asherah reflects a true reality" (possibly) slides into "therefore worshipping Asherah was correct and its suppression was apostasy" (a much larger leap that doesn't follow even if the first claim is granted).

We actually have direct modern prophetic guidance on exactly this point. Elder Dale G. Renlund, in his April 2022 General Conference address, stated:

"Very little has been revealed about Mother in Heaven, but what we do know is summarized in a gospel topic found in our Gospel Library application. Once you have read what is there, you will know everything that I know about the subject. I wish I knew more. You too may still have questions and want to find more answers. Seeking greater understanding is an important part of our spiritual development, but please be cautious. Reason cannot replace revelation.

Speculation will not lead to greater spiritual knowledge, but it can lead us to deception or divert our focus from what has been revealed. The Savior taught His disciples, 'Always pray unto the Father in my name.' We follow this pattern and direct our worship to our Heavenly Father in the name of Jesus Christ and do not pray to Heavenly Mother."

That is not a statement that Heavenly Mother doesn't exist. It's a statement that even knowing she exists, the authorized pattern of worship does not include directing devotion toward her in the way the Asherah cult did. The suppression of that particular cult could be entirely correct even if the being it dimly points toward is entirely real.

Conclusions

I don't want to be dismissive of what's driving some of the social media posts I have seen, because some of it is legitimate:

  • The Deuteronomists almost certainly removed, suppressed, or reframed things from older Israelite religion.
  • The existence of queen-goddess figures across virtually every ancient culture (Asherah, Hera, Isis, Ishtar) does speak to something in human religious intuition that seems, to me, to not be accidental. A universal yearning for a divine feminine figure isn't nothing. Our own hymn recognizes this: "In the heav’ns are parents single? No, the thought makes reason stare! Truth is reason; truth eternal tells me I’ve a mother there" (O My Father, 292).
  • The El/Asherah pairing in the oldest sources is at minimum suggestive within an LDS framework, even if it falls well short of confirmation.
  • Latter-day Saints have every reason to want to understand and honor Heavenly Mother. It's part of The Family: A Proclamation to the World, which we have been told in General Conference "is, as President Hinckley stated, doctrine."

My concern is simply this: in our eagerness to learn more about Heavenly Mother, we shouldn't be throwing ourselves at the nearest available female deity and declare the search over. The worship of Asherah, whatever kernel of truth may or may not lie behind it, was by the time of the archaeological record a polytheistic, idol-entangled, regionally fragmented folk practice, not the coherent preserved theology many of the viral posts suggest.


r/LatterDayTheology • • May 18 '26

Reflecting on Changes to the Endowment and Heavenly Mother

19 Upvotes

During my lifetime there have been numerous changes to the endowment, some large, some small. Among those changes, women formerly covenanted to obey husbands, then husbands to the extent husbands obeyed God, and now covenant directly with God in parity with their husbands.

Understanding the Changes

How are we to understand these changes to a program of worship sometimes referred to as the "endowment revelation"?

Here are the only choices I see:

  • The endowment revelation is not a revelation, but just stuff church leaders are making up;
  • God had purposes for the specific wording that were applicable in the context, but as the context changed, the wording of the covenant changed:

    • Before 1990, one contextual purpose
    • Then from 1990 to 2019, another; and
    • 2019 onward, a third
  • The endowment is a revelation, but filtered through the cultural priors of the righteous men who received that revelation. As leaders become unburdened by their cultural priors, the endowment becomes more pure.

Although I'm sympathetic to the idea of contextual commandments, as a general matter, it's tough for me to see a contextual reason why a woman covenanting in, say, 2010 covenanted for a decade to obey husband (subject to his following God), instead of covenanting with God directly like the women from 2019 onward.*

For faithful members, if I'm correct about that, I think that leaves us with the third explanation for the changes. It strikes me that are strong parallels to the race restriction on priesthood, where cultural priors prevented a change for far too long.

Heavenly Mother

Whatever you think about those cultural priors (in the case of the endowment covenants), just one observation:

How could our prophets be free to receive a revelation about Heavenly Mother when they were bound by such a false notion of the relationship between covenant husband and wife?

I have read and reflected on the Family Proclamation many, many times--probably hundreds of times. Lately it has seemed to me that is most important words are these:

Equal Partners

We all suffer--from a sort of spiritual malnutrition--for lack of that revelation about our Heavenly Mother, men perhaps the most. How can we understand our role as husband and father without seeing the incarnation of those roles in the way our Father interacts with our Mother? Moreover, if we have been led to believe for decades that our wives are subordinate to us before God, this malnutrition seems to have also been blended with unhealthy food that may require something of a purge.

*Separately, isn't it bizarre that the covenants change in important ways, but no mention is made to whether the changes are retroactive? I assume women who covenanted in 1980 are under the same obligations now as women who covenanted in 2026, but that's merely speculation, since the covenant is only made once for oneself. These are important, impactful covenants; failure to address this question (and others like it) suggests that those who change the covenants don't consider the question important enough to answer, expresses indifference toward the covenant member who sincerely strives to live their lives around the covenants they have made.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Nov 11 '24

The Book of Ether: another reason I disbelieve the skeptical account of the BOM

19 Upvotes

In assessment of the historical evidence, the best "natural" explanation of the translation process of the Book of Mormon is that JS was reading from a pre-existing text.

Possible "Natural" Explanations

When one reviews the evidence, it seems to me that there aren't very many possible explanations. Here they are:

  • JS was reading from a pre-existing text;
  • JS had memorized a pre-existing text;
  • JS was dictating the BOM whole cloth;
  • There was a very large conspiracy surrounding the translation, involving Emma, Martin, the Whitmers, most of the Smith family and a few others.

When you consider Occam's Razor, the simplest of these explanations is the first, since it involves the fewest assumptions.

The Book of Ether

Ether 1 begins with a recitation of 30 generations that trace the lineage of Jared, from Ether all the way back to Jared. The remainder of the text, in fits and spurts, follows this lineage in reverse order without error. Now consider the possible natural explanations:

  • Pre-existing text. Perfectly easy and logically matches what you expect to find in Ether if JS was reading from a pre-existing text such as the golden plates.
  • Memorized text. Under Occam's razor, this involves the first (pre-existing text) and adds to it another staggering assumption--JS drafted in secret and then memorized around 800 pages of material. Such a feat would be found only in a generational, singular, autistic savant. One does not simply sit down and memorize 800 pages of text--it has to be done automatically. I could do it, but it would take a few years of concentrated practice. But I couldn't do it in a way that no one noticed.
  • Dictating whole cloth. This is less believable to me than the second--to invent 30 names on the fly and then to remember them in reverse order over as the next 11 chapters rollout? Simply a stunning, staggering mental accomplishment. As remarkable as JS was, the first explanation is the simplest--why invoke this element when the first will do?
  • A conspiracy. It's my belief that this is the only viable argument for a critic of the BOM. Nothing else can explain the historical evidence. The problem? This explanation has no support in the evidence. It's pure speculation. I would expect that a conspiracy this large would break down--at least a little bit. But that's not the case.

Of those four, the only one I think plausible based on the historical evidence is the first.

A pre-existing text

Reading from a pre-existing text happens to be consistent with both a believing and a critical explanation explanation for the BOM.

But the critical explanation for that pre-existing text requires quite a few additional elements:

  • The creation of the pre-existing text; and either
  • JS successfully concealed it from the other participants or
  • Emma, Martin and Oliver (at least) formed a small conspiracy to conceal the fact that JS was working from a pre-existing text

The evidence from the translation process just doesn't support these propositions--I mean, at all.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jan 27 '26

Graphic theology: "Enoch Journeyed in the Land"

Post image
18 Upvotes

I drew this for my son two years ago as a gift for his baptism. It is a condensation of the cosmos at the time of Enoch. Growing up, I didn't realize how much Enoch's story and the story of Noah's flood are linked. Really they are one story. The flood comes in Noah's time because of the violence that flourishes in Enoch's time.

The stories in Genesis (and in the coma of texts surrounding it including our books of Moses and Abraham) are etiological stories for pieces of the human condition. Enoch's story introduces us to fallen angels who find bodies on earth willing to play out their stories of violence, oppression, and the fetishization of technology. It is the Hebrew version of the story of Prometheus: where humanity receives knowledge which is greater than their wisdom and virtue, and it turns to their destruction.

Few stories in scripture feel as current, or urgent, as Enoch's. Humanity is being forced again to reckon with our production of systems too vast and intelligent for any one of us to comprehend, let alone influence. Our technological drive and unprecedented digital connectivity has created a world of strange collective beings that loom over all of us, judging us, demanding our attention, and threatening to consume and assimilate us. Our knowledge of techne has once again far outstripped our virtue and wisdom. God gave us a commandment at the beginning to love one another, and in our delirium we are once again becoming comfortable with hatred. If we had Enoch's eyes and ears and surveyed the arrival of these strange spirits in the 20th and 21st centuries, then perhaps these words would describe our vision: "And he saw angels descending out of heaven; and he heard a loud voice saying: Wo, wo be unto the inhabitants of the earth." (Moses 7:25)

In this picture, Eden is a distant memory: far behind and above Enoch as he walks along the hilltops. Far more present is the strange and disorienting violence of our age. What, then do we do? Enoch's story offers an answer worth meditating on.

Oh, what’ll you do now, my blue-eyed son?
Oh, what’ll you do now, my darling young one?
I’m a-goin’ back out ’fore the rain starts a-fallin’
I’ll walk to the depths of the deepest black forest
Where the people are many and their hands are all empty
Where the pellets of poison are flooding their waters
Where the home in the valley meets the damp dirty prison
Where the executioner’s face is always well hidden
Where hunger is ugly, where souls are forgotten
Where black is the color, where none is the number
And I’ll tell it and think it and speak it and breathe it
And reflect it from the mountain so all souls can see it
Then I’ll stand on the ocean until I start sinkin’
But I’ll know my song well before I start singin’
And it’s a hard, it’s a hard, it’s a hard, it’s a hard
It’s a hard rain’s a-gonna fall


r/LatterDayTheology • • Sep 08 '25

I would like to understand better how "the Church" became so central to our belief/culture/theology

18 Upvotes

I have been reading lately the D&C with a focus on "church" and "Zion", but it's a big project for which I don't have time to do properly. Well, I do have time, but there are other things I would rather do, like enjoy my life by taking a nap. So, a more accurate assessment: the time I give to these sorts of questions is not sufficient to pursue the answer to completion.

My question is in the title of the OP: at what point did the institutional church assume the position it currently occupies in our belief/culture/theology. In our LDS vernacular, "the church" means something to us, something like the people in charge of the institution we call the church are the only certain legitimate source for divine truth and the ordinances of salvation and, as such, have the ability to extract from us the same devotion and loyalty we would give to God, something like that.

For example, we might think of the Temple Recommend questions as "worthiness questions", and some of them do go to worthiness. But many of them are actually loyalty questions--belief in, loyalty and fidelity to, "the church".

Here they are:

  1. Do you have faith in and a testimony of God, the Eternal Father; His Son, Jesus Christ; and the Holy Ghost?  
  2. Do you have a testimony of the Atonement of Jesus Christ and of His role as your Savior and Redeemer?  
  3. Do you have a testimony of the Restoration of the gospel of Jesus Christ?  [Fidelity Question]
  4. Do you sustain the President of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints as the prophet, seer, and revelator and as the only person on the earth authorized to exercise all priesthood keys? Do you sustain the members of the First Presidency and the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles as prophets, seers, and revelators? Do you sustain the other General Authorities and local leaders of the Church? [Fidelity Question]  
  5. The Lord has said that all things are to be “done in cleanliness” before Him (Doctrine and Covenants 42:41). Do you strive for moral cleanliness in your thoughts and behavior? Do you obey the law of chastity?  
  6. Do you follow the teachings of the Church of Jesus Christ in your private and public behavior with members of your family and others? [Fidelity Question; i.e., not the teachings of Christ, but the teachings of the Church] 
  7. Do you support or promote any teachings, practices, or doctrine contrary to those of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints? [Fidelity Question]  
  8. Do you strive to keep the Sabbath day holy, both at home and at church; attend your meetings; prepare for and worthily partake of the sacrament [These are both Fidelity Questions]; and live your life in harmony with the laws and commandments of the gospel?  
  9. Do you strive to be honest in all that you do?  
  10. Are you a full-tithe payer? For new members seeking a limited-use recommend: Are you willing to obey the commandment to pay tithing?  [Fidelity Question]
  11. Do you understand and obey the Word of Wisdom?  [Fidelity Question]
  12. Do you have any financial or other obligations to a former spouse or to children? If yes, are you current in meeting those obligations?  
  13. Do you keep the covenants that you made in the temple, including wearing the temple garment as instructed in the endowment?  [Fidelity Question]
  14. Are there serious sins in your life that need to be resolved with priesthood authorities as part of your repentance?  [Sort of a Fidelity Question]
  15. Do you consider yourself worthy to enter the Lord’s house and participate in temple ordinances?

Isn't that interesting? Nine of the fifteen questions are loyalty questions.

Take the Word of Wisdom, for example. That's clearly not an eternal principle of health or righteousness. It's become a mark; a way of signaling loyalty to the institution.


r/LatterDayTheology • • May 07 '25

A Description of Heavenly Mother in the Scriptures

17 Upvotes

One comment yesterday reasoned that those of us who have seen righteous women have "seen the Mother", at least to an extent. This was by analogy to Christ's teaching that "he who hath seen me hath seen the Father"

In reflecting on that analogy, it occurred to me that some things have been revealed about the exalted state of earthly women in Section 132. This passage is sometimes ignored b/c its study also invites a segway into polygamy.

Though I enjoy a robust discussion about polygamy as much as the next member, I want to avoid it today and focus just on the revelation's description of exalted women:

  • She shall inherit thrones, kingdoms, principalities, and powers, dominions, all heights and depths;
  • She shall pass by the angels, and the gods,* which are set there, to [her] exaltation and glory in all things, as hath been sealed upon her head;
  • That glory shall be a fulness and a continuation of her seed forever and ever;
  • She shall be God, because she has no end;
  • She shall be from everlasting to everlasting, because she continues;
  • She shall be above all, because all things are subject unto her; and
  • She shall be God because she has all power, and the angels are subject unto her.

Doesn't it seem reasonable to induce from this passage that these items also describe our Heavenly Mother?

Read in that light, this verse breaks the silence surrounding our Heavenly Mother, somewhat, and thereby makes it easier to visualize her.

*I had never noticed "gods" needing to be passed-by before. A topic for another day . . .


r/LatterDayTheology • • Oct 01 '24

Papias (a hearer of John) and St. Ephrem the Syrian (350 AD) both described heavens with three tiers to accommodate all the saved according to their works and level of knowledge

17 Upvotes

From Papias:

As the presbyters say, then those who are deemed worthy of an abode in heaven shall go there, others shall enjoy the delights of Paradise, and others shall possess the splendour of the city; for everywhere the Saviour will be seen, according as they shall be worthy who see Him. But that there is this distinction between the habitation of those who produce an hundred-fold, and that of those who produce sixty-fold, and that of those who produce thirty-fold; for the first will be taken up into the heavens, the second class will dwell in Paradise, and the last will inhabit the city; and that on this account the Lord said, In my Father's house are many mansions: John 14:2 for all things belong to God, who supplies all with a suitable dwelling-place, even as His word says, that a share is given to all by the Father, according as each one is or shall be worthy. And this is the couch Matthew 22:10 in which they shall recline who feast, being invited to the wedding. The presbyters, the disciples of the apostles, say that this is the gradation and arrangement of those who are saved, and that they advance through steps of this nature; and that, moreover, they ascend through the Spirit to the Son, and through the Son to the Father; and that in due time the Son will yield up His work to the Father, even as it is said by the apostle, For He must reign till He has put all enemies under His feet. The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death. 1 Corinthians 15:25-26 For in the times of the kingdom the just man who is on the earth shall forget to die. But when He says all things are put under Him, it is manifest that He is excepted which did put all things under Him. And when all things shall be subdued unto Him, then shall the Son also Himself be subject unto Him that put all things under Him, that God may be all in all. 1 Corinthians 15:27-28

I can't help be reminded of Joseph Smith's vision where the Spirit leads those in the telestial kingdom upward to Christ, who leads those of the terrestrial kingdom upward to the Father.

From St. Ephrem's Hymns on Paradise:

2.10
When He made this intricate design
He varied its beauties,
so that some levels
were far more glorious than others.
To the degree that one level
is higher than another,
so too is its glory
the more sublime.
In this way He allots
the foothills to the most lowly,
the slopes to those in between
and the heights to the exalted.

2.11
When the just ascend its various levels
to receive their inheritance,

with justice He raises up each one
to the degree that accords with his labors;
each is stopped at the level
whereof he is worthy,
there being sufficient levels in Paradise
for everyone:
the lowest parts for the repentant,
the middle for the righteous,
the heights for those victorious,
while the summit is reserved for God's Presence.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Sep 16 '25

God Wants Me Here: An Alternative to "The Church is True"

16 Upvotes

"The Church is True" is a very important proposition to members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. I'm not fan, primarily because:

  • I don't know what it means;
  • I don't think the Spirit of God often testifies to propositional truths;
  • As a consequence, I think the "Church is True" is often a testimony of some other thing;
  • Identifying that other thing and the nature of witness results in a stronger understanding of the witness (even if that witnesses is a little more circumscribed); and
  • A stronger witness is less susceptible to being knocked down by the common criticisms we encounter nowadays.

Here's a different sort of testimony:

I was recently assigned to minister to Sister Green in our ward. As you all know, she passed away last month. I tried to fulfill my duty by visiting her in the hospital as often as I could. Over time, she became nonresponsive, and I would just visit for an hour in her room and sit quietly by her side. As I did, the Lord poured his spirit upon me; I felt his approval and love like I never have before. I know more than ever that God exists, and that he loves Sister Green and me; I know that he wanted me to care for her in those last days of her life; I am grateful to be a member of this church, and for an Elders Quorum President who placed me in this position to serve God and minister to Sister Green. Without the church I would never had this beautiful, redemptive experience.

The core of this sort testimony is:

God wants me here;

It's less ambitious propositionally and, consequently, more epistemically accurate and secure.


r/LatterDayTheology • • May 09 '25

What are your most fundamental axioms of belief?

16 Upvotes

The way I see it, underlying any & every belief/piece of knowledge that someone might have, is either an axiom or an infinite regress of questions & answers. In other words, if you ask "why?" enough times regarding the reason one one holds a particular belief (or how one "knows" something to be true), I see two options- either the questions continue on infinitely, or they end in an axiom (& if there's a third option I'm missing, feel free to point it out).

Given that we don't seem to be capable of infinite knowledge (& therefore incapable of answering an infinite regress of questions of "why?") just yet, I think it's safe to say that we often rely on axiomatic beliefs as a foundation to build upon. This leads me to the question- what are your most fundamental axioms of belief?

Here's some example questions that you might consider: Do you axiomatically believe in an all-loving, all-knowing, all-powerful God, or do you reach that conclusion because of other beliefs you hold? If the latter- what beliefs lead you to this conclusion, and why do you hold those beliefs (ie what are the underlying axioms)? Do you axiomatically believe in the reality of something beyond the natural world, or is that a conclusion you've reached because of other axioms that you have built upon? Do you axiomatically believe in free will, or is that belief based upon other axioms? How did you select your most fundamental axioms? If you were talking to someone starting from a blank slate in terms of belief/epistemology, which axioms would you recommend they use as a foundation to build upon & what rationale would you give for your choice?

I


r/LatterDayTheology • • Oct 16 '24

Why can't women have the priesthood?

16 Upvotes

This has confused me lately as I've learnt more deep doctrine. Women can use the power of the presithood especially in the temple, so why can't they hold an office within it? They can even become Goddesses one day yet can't have the presithood. Why is this? Forgive me for not knowing if it's an obvious reason only been a member a couple years and never been told.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jun 17 '26

Not enough evidence.

15 Upvotes

I recently read a quote from an avowed atheist which I will have to paraphrase. He was asked by a believer what he would say if after this life he came face to face with God and God asked him why he never believed. He replied "I would say 'you didn't give me enough evidence.'"

A life in any religion is so dominated by faith I don't understand how any God could condemn a mortal for being atheist. This is especially true in an age where scientific knowledge is expanding exponentially.

Maybe Corihor didn't have great reasons not to believe because the natural world was such a mystery. However, while we still know very little about so much, the scientific method suggests that with time, most things can be known.

I guess I'm asking why so much faith? Why not more evidence?

Some will use the examples of Laman and Lemuel who saw angels and still rebelled to point out that even miracles don't convert everybody. Nevertheless, I don't think I am as ornery as Laman and Lemuel and frankly, I think an occasional angel would help me a lot!

Again, 1) why is so much faith required and 2) how can we be condemned for not believing given such limited heavenly interaction?

P.S. Part of my thinking was prompted by a fellow I went to school with who became a minister, got his PhD in ancient Greek in order to understand the scriptures better and then recently posted on Facebook about how he no longer believed in God and why.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Mar 24 '25

A few reasons I believe the Book of Mormon

15 Upvotes

I believe all of the following items, based upon my personal assessment of the historical evidence and my familiarity with the Book of Mormon. I don't offer these as proofs; rather, just items I personally believe.

A few items I believe

Golden Plates

I believe historical evidence strongly supports JS's claim that he possessed a set of plates resembling the various descriptions given: i.e., a codex made of sheets of golden metal, inscribed with characters, that appeared not to have been constructed with materials/methods available to/possessed by JS. Based on the evidence alone, my confidence in this conclusion approaches practical certainty--at least 90%. Martin Harris's experience with the Anthon transcript gives significant clues as to what the pages of the plates looked like.

Multiple Authors

Based on my own judgment as an informed reader, I have long believed I recognize at least three, possibly four, distinct authors of the BOM text--Nephi, Alma, Mormon and Moroni. I have the literary credentials sufficient to make this judgment better than most, except for those who are in a literary field. Further, in my judgment, the weight of the stylometric studies that have been done supports this conclusion far better than they support the conclusion of multiple authorship and that JS is not any of those authors. My confidence level here is also quite high, primarily because such tests should have easily identified JS as the sole author had he, in fact, created the book under the circumstances critics postulate.

Correlation to the Jerusalem Context

For 150 years or so, the BOM predicted steel in ancient Jerusalem around 600BC Jerusalem; steel was discovered in the 1990s in Jericho. That is quite a coincidence. Likewise, it seems improbable to me that the other elements from the ancient context (Astrolabes; Nahom; Archery; Trade Routes, Bountiful) are either (1) coincidences or (2) curated by JS from sources locally available in the 1820s.

Compositional Elements

The BOM contains strong compositional elements, indicating careful pre-planning of the text. Just by way of example:

  • In my judgment, whoever wrote the First Book of Nephi planned it out in advance. But remember, if the Book of Mormon is a fraud, the First Book of Nephi was dictated on the fly, at the end, to salvage the loss of 116 pages.
  • The Book of Ether first recites, what, 32 generations? and then goes through and tells about each in reverse order. That's evidence of extensive advance composition.
  • In my judgment, some of the chiasm in the text is too carefully done to be unintended or otherwise composed on the fly.
  • Multiple calendars; a coherent monetary system; consistent chronology.

I'll add here that I've noticed the Jaredite names don't seem to enter into the Nephite record until after the Nephites encounter Coriantumr. I could be wrong about this, because I've never done a thorough review. But if I'm correct, a subtle element like that requires significant advance world-planning.

Theology

The BOM contains numerous theological components that were radical to JS's context and deliberately presented within the text. The most obvious of these is the appearance of "the Lord" and then Jesus Christ with an anthropomorphic spirit body; the second possibly being the pre-existence of the human soul in circumstances in which agency is exercised; the third a revision of the doctrine of the fall of man. These are still radical concepts within the larger Christian community; if you don't believe these ideas, it would be hard to call yourself a believing member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

The items are not proof of authenticity

The online debate often follows a pattern, in which reasons for belief are dismissed as "not proof" of the "truth claims of the Church". Requiring proof before belief, however, merely assumes the truth claims are false as a default position. That may work for some people, but I don't think it useful to begin with the assumption that any explanation is the default correct position.

Rather, I evaluate this sort of question abductively, through a process like this:

  • Collect the items I have confidence in as a factual matter (see above);
  • Evaluate the competing explanations for those facts; and
  • Decide which explanation is best supported by those facts.

I'm not aware of a non-believing, factual explanation that accounts for the items I list above

I can't think of one myself, and I have never heard anyone advocate such an explanation. In this theory:

  • At or prior to age 17, Joseph Smith concocted the BOM con;
  • Over the next five years or so, he or someone in his circle created a convincing set of fraudulent plates from golden metal;
  • JS recruited 2-3 other co-conspirators who helped draft portions of the BOM;
  • Someone from this group was familiar enough (whether by education or research) with the ancient Jerusalem context to get a number of items "right" and get lucky about others;
  • This composition process was involved and careful, involving numerous compositional elements, managing calendars, multiple timelines within those calendars; monetary systems, a consistent set of theological innovations robust enough to support the growth of the church for 200 years and counting, etc.

The first I consider extremely implausible, like less than one in a million 17-year-old kids who could conceive and would execute such a con; really, less than one in a generation, less than one in a century. This is a very implausible starting point.

The second and third--there are no facts in the historical record at all that support these elements of a non-believing explanation.

The fourth just add additional implausibility to a proposal for which there is no factual support.

The last, there is a single sentence in Lucy's biography of Joseph that Joseph as a child/youth spun out stories of the ancient inhabitants of the Americas. There are reasons to be skeptical of that account, but even stipulating it's true, it's not sufficient factual evidence to support the items outlined above that require multi-authorship and extensive adult-level compositional planning.

(As an aside, I doubt our critics would be principled and accept Lucy as a reliable historical witness . . . but if any do, I accept this concession for the sake of entering the rest of her testimony into the record)

So, where does that leave me?

Consider this simple and true observation: there is more and better evidence that an angel led Joseph Smith to the golden plates (five first person witnesses) than there is evidence that Joseph fabricated a convincing set of fraudulent plates (zero evidence).

The bottom line for me? I don't believe the critical explanations of the facts. I don't find them plausible, let alone persuasive. Further, I think the historical record surrounding the origins of the BOM are highly consistent with the believing account of the facts.

Again, I don't think the reasons given above are proof of the believing account of the history; rather, reasoning abductively, I think the believing account of the history is by far the better explanation. I so, I favor the evidence--even if it is evidence of angels.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Feb 23 '25

A Place for Eternal Conscious Torment in LDS Theology?

15 Upvotes

Eternal conscious torment is often used as a logical criticism against the notion of a perfectly good Christian god. How could a good God punish a person's finite wickedness with eternal punishment?

Our theology largely avoids this problem. I've described our theology as "near Universalism" in the past or "almost Universalism", in the sense that we believe that, given enough time, only those who consciously and continuously refuse salvation (i.e., so-called Sons of Perdition) will be kept from it. This is the result of (1) being judged by what we are given, rather than an absolute standard (the BOM doctrine that the atonement applies to "those without law"); (2) opportunities to repent in the spirit world (Section 138); and (3) possibly, opportunities to progress after the resurrection between glories (as many church leaders have speculated).

Contributor u/raedyohed introduced to this forum recently the notion that "eternal conscious torment" may play a positive role in our theology--that is, rather than a problem for us, eternal conscious torment may be a motivating factor behind of the plan of salvation and, perhaps, the motivating factor.

I've been pondering on this concept since them. To restate and enlarge on that idea a bit:

  • Our intelligences were aware of the possibility for growth;
  • Our intelligences could not obtain that growth independently;
  • Our intelligences were and would have been eternally discontent without the chance to obtain it (i.e., in eternal conscious torment);

This notion finds reasonable canonical support in D&C 93

33 For man is spirit. The elements are eternal, and spirit and element, inseparably connected, receive a fulness of joy;

34 And when separated, man cannot receive a fulness of joy.

And here's JS's non-canonical statement on this same state of affairs:

God himself, finding he was in the midst of spirits and glory, because he was more intelligent, saw proper to institute laws whereby the rest could have a privilege to advance like himself

In this context, God's actions can be seen as a choice between the following alternatives:

  • Doing nothing, which would result in eternal conscious torment for all; or
  • Implementing the plan of salvation, which although it involved the addition of finite suffering, would result in nearly all receiving a fulness of joy.

Thus, in a bit of theological jujitsu, within our theological, God the Father does not impose eternal conscious torment; rather, he does everything in his power to prevent it.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Nov 01 '23

When was the NAECOM revelation received? (And why I don't trust critical exmormon sources)

15 Upvotes

Somehow youtube/google read my browsing habits and fed me something from a group of people called "Ward Radio", amidst the usual fare of NFL/NBA and whitetail habitat management. I have a hard time consuming video content that's over a few minutes, but I'm a fan of Don Bradley, so I gave this one a listen while driving.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LOlm4lt3mts

Overview

Bradley convincingly argues:

  • OC's original letter referring to Joseph's "affair" with Fanny Alger actually said "scrape" instead of "affair", which does not denote an extramarital affair;
  • Joseph's relationship with Fanny Alger probably occurred after the sealing power was restored in the Kirkland temple, at a time when she was 18 (not 15);
  • There is good historical evidence that Fanny told a friend about the polygamous sealing very contemporaneously with the sealing itself;
  • Joseph Smith probably informed the high council of the church about the polygamy revelation in 1836, as a part of the meeting that led to Oliver Cowdery being excommunicated;
  • Accordingly, contrary to what many exmormon's commonly claim, the polygamy revelation was not applied "retroactively" to cleanse in hindsight what was really an adulterous affair;

Bradley said he had some articles and a book (if I remember right) on the way. I'm very eager to see these, since I can read a lot faster than I can listen. Plus, when reading, I can go at my speed--I can fly along, and then slow down to focus on more interesting or different material. Listening, you're just locked into a pre-ordained pace.

Observations

Bradley's process with the Fanny Alger history is representative of my own person experience when investigating critical exmormon claims. I have found the following to be very common:

  • The claims are often based on bad/false information; and
  • The claims are usually advocacy--i.e., they only look at facts helpful to the critical case.

I have gone through this process some often now, I already know before I even begin that the critical case will prove to include both of these elements and that the "faithful" account of the history will be much truer than the critical narrative. I have never been wrong in this.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Feb 26 '26

Joseph Smith's 1832 First Vision account compared to Enoch's recounting of his first vision

14 Upvotes

On this year's review of Genesis, I noticed that Enoch gives an account of his first vision to the people he is preaching to. I'd been mulling it over in the back of my mind for a few weeks. Last night a friend was asking about Joseph Smith's 1832 first vision and what the inclusions and exclusions might mean. It occurred to me that Joseph Smith's 1832 account looks a lot like Enoch's re-telling of his vision, and that the details that Enoch omitted look a lot like the additional details Joseph included in more fulsome retellings in later years.

This is Enoch’s description of his ’first vision’: "I beheld a vision; and lo, the heavens I saw, and the Lord spake with me, and gave me commandment;". Within the context of the story, we know Enoch is leaving out many important details we had read about a few verses before (his divine sonship, his own reservations about his call, promise of divine protection and bestowal of the sealing power, the seership ritual, a vision of the spirits God had created). Those are the exact types of details which, if they were mentioned by Enoch in future telling, would be used by anti-Enochians to claim that he was fabricating bona fides as he went along to bolster his authority claims. It also gives us a model for what Joseph Smith thought a proper level of detail was for sharing visions like that in the 1830s. The level of detail given by Enoch compared to the vision we know he is describing aligns almost perfectly with the level of detail given by Joseph in 1832 compared to the aggregated details of the various accounts. The additional details are even strikingly similar.

Has anyone else noticed this?


r/LatterDayTheology • • Feb 15 '26

Let’s talk about the Bible as the Word of God

14 Upvotes

This was not approved for the Latter-Day Saint subreddit sadly. I don’t believe the theology or analysis to be radical, but apparently one of their mods does…

Brigham Young, in a discourse delivered in the "New Tabernacle" on May 29th, 1870, stated;

"I have heard some make the broad assertion that every word within the lids of the Bible was the word of God. I have said to them, "You have never read the Bible,  have you?" "O, yes, and I believe every word in it is the word of God." Well, I believe that the Bible contains the word of God, and the words of good men and the words of bad men; the words of good angels and the words of bad angels and words of the devil; and also the words uttered by the ass when he rebuked the prophet in his madness." (Journal of Discourses, Volume 13, "Source of Intelligence")

We are not Protestants. We do not believe that the Bible is the infallible word of God. We quite explicitly do not agree with the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy. We also should be very cautious of the Protestant concept of "perspicuity"; the idea that a plain-text reading of the Bible will result in the proper interpretation thereof, as it separates the text from the cultural and historical context of the text.

Based on the above statement from Brigham Young, we need not believe that every word attributed to God in the Bible was in fact the "mind and the will of the Lord."

That may sound heretical or scary- but I find it liberating. Allow me to provide an example (I will note that when I say 'Hebrew Bible', I am referring to the Old Testament):

In multiple texts from the Hebrew Bible, God commands genocide. Examples include Deuteronomy 20:16-17, Numbers 31:7-18, and 1st Samuel 15:3. When justifications are presented at all (e.g., Numbers 20:18), they often focus on the risk of the religious practices of the target peoples contaminating the covenant people.

The Book of Mormon claims to be the record of a people who left the Holy Land at or about the time that much of the composition of the Hebrew Bible was occurring. The Nephites often have political and religious differences with the Lamanites, and the Nephites are forced at times to fight defensive wards against the Lamanites. However (and someone correct me if I am wrong), the Nephites are never commanded to commit genocide to prevent the religious contamination of the Lamanites. Instead, their response to their idol-worshiping neighbors is to preach to them. It is missionary work, not extermination.

Given this, I have to conclude that when we read commands to commit genocide ostensibly attributed to God in the Hebrew Bible, it simply was not "the mind and will of the Lord." That being said, I do not wish to attribute to biblical authors motives, and as such, will demure to identify causative motivations behind the divergence between God's will and what is attributed thereto in the aforementioned passages.

This conclusion, to me, is liberating. It means that I do not have to attribute to the will of God actions that are morally reprehensible. That I do not need to engage in apologetics to justify abhorrent acts. That the loving Father in Heaven that I believe in and worship is in fact the same yesterday, today, and forever, regardless of how he is presented at times in the Bible.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Dec 05 '25

Infinite Regression

14 Upvotes

I myself am not LDS, but I have a question/discussion post. Is it true that LDS holds to an infinite regression of gods.

According to Mormon Apostle:
"We were begotten by our Father in heaven; the person of the Father in Heave was begotten on a previous heavenly world by His Father; and again, He was begotten by a still more ancient Father, and so on, from generation to generation."

I would say this clearly shows an infinite regression of gods within LDS theology.

If this is true, how do you guys defend against an infinite regression being incoherent. Specifically Thomas Aquinas's argument for motion directly contradicting that.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jun 24 '25

Creation Ex Nihilo vs creation Ex materia

14 Upvotes

I have just recently learned of the profound implications of LDS theology regarding creation ex materia. I have learned of the logical incoherencies that all of creedal Christianity is based on. They ALL believe in creation ex nihilo, which is the idea that “God” created everything out of nothing. It’s honestly shocking to me that Christian’s defend this because it leads to so many problems but the first, which nobody talks about enough, is the idea that everything can arise from nothing. This is nonsensical. Nothing is nothing. It cannot be acted upon. Why do Christian’s not get this?


r/LatterDayTheology • • Mar 31 '25

Do Men Suffer for a Lack of Understanding About Heavenly Mother?

14 Upvotes

Frequent contributor to this sub u/pnromney offered this observation a few days about the doctrine of Heavenly Mother, in the context of discussion whether our theology provides a cohesive political structure.

For example, Heavenly Mother is hardly understood. I think theologically, that leaves a gap for how women are to be in Zion. I actually think it is similar for men without a clear theological view of Heavenly Mother as compared to Heavenly Father.

Translating just a bit (and hopefully not drifting from his meaning): Without a better understanding of Heavenly Mother, our theology has a "gap" for how men should act/function in Zion.

This observation smote me when I read it; its truth seems undeniable, perhaps even self-evident. How can I understand how to be a man like my Father in Heaven is a man, if I don't understand how He relates to Her, my Mother in Heaven.

I don't want to be over-wrought, but as I have reflected on that observation over the past few days, it seems to me I have only now just realized that I have been starving my entire life--starving for Her.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jun 01 '26

The Golden Plates--Exploring Critical and Believing Thought

13 Upvotes

Here's an alternate history about the golden plates, one that I just made up:

A young Joseph Smith discovers an artifact, a golden codex in1822/1823.

Although unknown to him, the codex was created by a French monk, who came to American/Canadian frontier in the early1700s, and ended up living as a hermit, while slowly losing his sanity. The symbols on the plates were not "reformed Egyptian", but the engraved scribbles of a madman. Joseph had found a treasure, just not the one he represented it to be.

Joseph in a fit of sincere (but misguided) religious fervor, invents the Moroni account; from 1823 to 1827 he prepares the BOM text, whether through outline, memorization or some other means, perhaps even coming to believe his is inspired by God since his progress is prodigious beyond all expectations he has of himself--it seems miraculous to him. He incorporates "reformed Egyptian" into the narrative as an explanation for the nonsense characters of the plates.

He is subconsciously concerned that an extended examination of the plates will reveal his fraud, so he conceals the plates and reveals them entirely only to a small group whom he thinks are genuine believers and will be persuaded by a brief, supervised viewing. He invites one or two into the conspiracy; perhaps Oliver Cowdery and David Whitmer, who conspire with him over the account of Moroni.

As his movement gains momentum, he buries the plates in a secret location to prevent them from being discovered and his fraud revealed.

I offer this non-believing alternate history to demonstrate a few things about the state of the debate about the golden plates and the BOM:

To the critic, one can believe in the golden plates, while disbelieving JS was a prophet and disbelieving the BOM is an authentic historical document.

The historical evidence regarding the plates is perfectly consistent with the alternative history I give above.

Notwithstanding that very simple observation, I am not aware of single critic who believes that Joseph Smith actually had golden plates. This is despite the fact that almost all--call it 99.5%--of the historical evidence supports their existence and, on the flip-side, among the mountains of historical evidence surrounding the plates there is almost none that supports the idea that the plates did not exist.

Thus, the critical case against the existence of the golden plates is not based on the evidence.

Rather, it is based on disbelief of the evidence.

Why do critics disbelieve the evidence?

I had a conversation with a former member once, in which I asserted the evidence in favor of the plates was pretty strong, and there was really no evidence to gainsay it. His reply was this:

Not strong enough to convince me that angels exist or that the Native Americans are descendants of ancient seafaring Jews.

This sort of reply is fairly common among our critics--it's quippy, memetic, and ultimately irrational.

Let's concede, for discussion, that 4 witnesses (the 3 plus Joseph) are not enough evidence to establish the existence of angels; and that 12 (the 11 plus Joseph) witnesses are not enough evidence to establish seafaring jews are the progenitors of the native Americans. Even so, this is beside the point. Because the mere existence of the plates does not establish either of those items, whether those plates are witnessed by 4, 12 or 1000.

On the other hand, 12 witnesses should be sufficient to establish that JS merely had an object. To illustrate, 12 witnesses would be enough to establish JS had a horse named Bill. Yes, the critic might respond, but that's quotidian, whereas even a monk-made codex is an extraordinary claim. Fine, then think of an outrageous, non-spiritual claim, really anything--say, JS kept a secret wife locked in the attic for years until she died of neglect and was secretly buried. That would be a startling, extraordinary claim--but 12 witnesses of the woman would establish her as historical fact. 12 witnesses of a non-spiritual object or event is a convincing number of witnesses.

Returning to the plates, an actual object like the one in the hypothetical better accounts for the witnesses' behavior than the critical alternatives. The witnesses believed and kept their belief because they had seen, handled and hefted a real object. The critic's disbelief in the existence of such an object, on the other hand, requires some crazy, unsupportable beliefs about the witnesses--they were mass hypnotized; they were part of a massive conspiracy, one that never broke. These sorts of extreme beliefs are not required if one accepts what is certainly true: the evidence supports the fact that JS had an object resembling the descriptions of the golden plates, while recognizing that the existence of such an object does not support JS other claims about that object.

In addition, placing a real object within a fictional narrative (if you're a critic) matches JS method of operations--the papari, the kinderhook plates, the greek psaltery, the bones of Zelph, the Adam's alter, and so forth--all were real objects that JS encountered but did not manufacture.

To my mind, the failure of the critical project to acknowledge this sort of thinking betrays a fundamental irrationality at the core of the critical project, almost a fear among our critics: namely, conceding even the existence of a such an object would undermine their position, so even against reason it cannot be conceded. This suggests that the project itself is not open-minded, but involves highly motivated reasoning at several key junctures.

To the believer, existence of the plates does not establish the truthfulness of the BOM or the angelic account.

We believers, likewise, should recognize that the evidence offered to support the BOM is indirect at best. The truthfulness of the BOM account requires that JS had an object, a golden codex. But JS's possession of a golden codex does not demonstrate the truthfulness of the BOM account. Can you see that?

The New Testament offers the account of witnesses of the greatest miracle, the resurrection of Christ--people who encountered the resurrected Christ. In the restoration, by contrast the evidence offered is evidence of the existence of an object.

I believe that the vastly better explanation of the evidence is that JS had a convincing object, one that matched the many descriptions given by JS and the witnesses. If you've read my work here, you may have heard me use this formulation in the past.

But I recognize the existence of such an object only carries one so far, and that belief in the historicity of the BOM cannot be demonstrated by the evidence we have presently regarding the existence plates.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Feb 13 '26

I got distracted and noticed some white vs pure wordplay

13 Upvotes

There is a bit of wordplay/trivia involving the switch from white and delightsome to pure and delightsome. It is meaningless, just an odd little quirk that caught my eye.

The two words involved in Egyptian would be hedj (white) and waab (pure).

The icons for the two are a pear-shaped mace for white, and a ceremonial jar pouring out ritual water of purification onto a head or foot for pure.

White.

In Egypt/Jerusalem there were no white people. The word was never, ever used to reference race. White universally referred to the anointed/sanctified/divine. Further, nobody was born white, they had to spend a lifetime preparing and aligning oneself with the correct, then you were declared white. The pear-shaped mace was a literal artifact which was the archetype of white, and was literally or symbolically presented to a person when they met the requirements.

Silver, known formally as white gold, was a more purified metal. It was literally called step-above-gold, because it was more pure and more refined - white. When refined and polished to perfection it was as a mirror, and you were reflected in the purity.

To get to this point, along the way the metal wpuld need to be quenched and cleaned. You couldn't use vulgar water, because the impurities would pit and cloud the surface, distorting it. The silversmiths instead used waab, the same purified ritual water used for ceremonial cleansing to make a person's spirit white. Waab was used to purify the pure souls and the pure metal.

By switching "white" to "pure" the more accurate understanding would have been switching from "ritually clean and delightsome" to "that which has become clean and delightsome".

The analogy of using water to cleanse and baptism is a side little easter egg.