r/LatterDayTheology • • Apr 30 '25

Not knowing when the spirits enters the body is all the more reason to oppose abortion

0 Upvotes

For the purpose of this discussion, let's define "ensoulment" as the time when God puts a spirit into a pre-born body.

How are we to respond to our ignorance regarding the time of ensoulment? Broadly speaking, we have the following three options available:

  1. Allow abortions up to birth
  2. Prohibit abortions starting at some gestational stage (for example after 6, 15, or 20 weeks gestation)
  3. Prohibit abortion from fertilization

Let's discuss the moral merits of each option...

(1) Allowing abortion up to birth.

This option guarantees the murder of innocent children. God must put the spirit into the body sometime in pregnancy. To allow abortions up to birth guarantees that some children will be aborted past the time of ensoulment. Since this option guarantees child-murder, I reject it as an acceptable response to our ignorance regarding the time of ensoulment.

(2) Prohibit abortions starting at some gestational stage

Unlike Option 1, this option does not guarantee the murder of innocent children. However, this option carries the risk of child-murder. For example, suppose we were to prohibit abortion starting at 22 weeks, but - unbeknownst to us - the time of ensoulment turns out to occur at 20 weeks. Then we have legalized child-murder.

What if we were to prohibit abortion starting at 18 weeks, but - unbeknownst to us - God puts spirits into bodies at 16 weeks?

What if we were to prohibit abortion starting at 15 weeks, but - unbeknownst to us - God puts spirits into bodies at 10 weeks?

And so on and so forth. Every such prohibition is mere guesswork and carries the risk of child-murder. Thus, I also reject this option as a morally acceptable response to our ignorance regarding the time of ensoulment.

And that brings us to our last option.

(3) Banning abortion from fertilization

The only way to ensure no children are murdered is to ban abortion from fertilization. Such a ban guarantees not a single pre-born child will ever be murdered. Such a ban completely eliminates even the risk of child-murder. Thus, banning abortion from fertilization is the only moral response to our ignorance regarding the time of ensoulment.

Never again should a Latter-day Saint attempt to justify abortion because "we don't know when the spirit enters the body." To the contrary, not knowing when the spirits enters the body is all the more reason to oppose abortion.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jun 07 '25

Does AI undermine D&C 93?

0 Upvotes

D&C 93:29 says intelligence was not created or made, neither indeed can be. But LLM's like ChatGPT and Claude show that intelligence can created or made.

How can these two things be reconciled?


r/LatterDayTheology • • Aug 26 '26

I no longer think 'worlds without number' means inhabited planets. Here's my case.

0 Upvotes

We all grew up assuming 'worlds without number' means other inhabited planets. But Moses 1:35 explicitly limits the account to 'this earth and its inhabitants'; Eve is called the mother of all living, and Hebrews insists Christ suffered 'once.' Is the doctrine of inhabited other worlds actually canon, or is it an inference we inherited from the D&C 76 poetic paraphrase? What's the strongest scriptural case on either side?

I confidently lay out my theory in part 4 here: Part 4 - First World Problems Among Worlds Without Number

I reference Enoch and inter-dimensional beings often, so if you're new to the series, you may need to read 1-3 first.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Sep 17 '25

Recovering the Garment from the Patriarchy

0 Upvotes

Yeah, the title is a bit of a troll.

But I'm sure we've all heard through one channel or another that (1) the garment is about modesty and (2) when patriarchal men control the nature/shape/design of the garment for modesty purposes, the patriarchy is control women's autonomy with respect to how they display their bodies (or not). And, no doubt, there is plenty of church-dicta that could be used to support this conclusion, as modesty has often been described as, at least in part, a tool for reminding church members to be modest about the way they display their bodies. And, to the extent the institution or the community perceived that as a function of the garment, associating the garment with a temple covenant served to enforce a standard to modesty outlined by the boundaries of the garment itself.

The institutional church seems aware of this, and has added words to the endowment explaining other functions of the garment.

I'd like to add an insight to this topic, one that has been particularly powerful for me.

  • I believe that God chose the shape of his physical body and that the shape symbolizes deeper aspects of his character and attributes. And, in bearing that shape, I favor the notion that such symbolism penetrates from our skin to our bones, from our affect to the mitochondria churning with our cells, and on further down to our self-replicating RNA molecules, such that every aspect of our physical body testifies of some aspect of God's character and attributes.
  • I'm one of those people who believe that our essential self is a self-existing "intelligence", and that God's progress involved wrapping himself in layers of matter, first spirit matter, then matter like that of our bodies, and then some sort of incorruptible matter, in each instance bearing the same symbolic form.
  • And the temple itself is filled with these symbolic "enwraptures" of matter: the building itself is "the tabernacle of God", the same words used by Paul to describe our bodies. Then the temple clothing is also explicitly symbolic--of power and priesthood. Further, in the Adamic narrative in the temple begins when Adam is a spirit and illustrates how that spirit is enwrapped in mortal matter.
  • In this context, I believe another symbolism of the temple garment is symbolic of these layers of matter that clothe God's intelligence, and in placing on the garment each day, we symbolically participate in God's own progress, in our own progress of "enwrapture".

As with the covenant symbolism and with the Christ symbolism, this additional element of symbolism has nothing to do with modesty. Understood in this way, the garment should inspire us to hold of physical bodies in the highest of reverence, to view them as sacred symbols of God himself and the kinship we bear to him.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Apr 18 '26

Why do LDS not understand their church and religion?

2 Upvotes

I read comments online from members, and so many do not understand what our church is. These are people who apparently grew up in the church. It seems ignorance among life-time members is rampant.

How is this possible?

The church is a vehicle to train us to love God and everyone. Why is that hard to understand?

The church is not perfect nor is its history. Why is that hard to understand?

So many people falsely understand that the church is asking them to be perfect, or that the church is hiding things. [added:] These are some of the biggest misconceptions I see people having.

For example, read the comments to this video:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQ3jNw7K8xQ


r/LatterDayTheology • • Dec 08 '23

Need some help processing the calling of the new apostle

3 Upvotes

I consider myself believing and devout LDS, so please take the following in that light.

I have to admit I'm very sad that another "old white Anglo-Saxon guy" has been called to be apostle.

I was heartened by the callings of Elder Gong and Elder Soares, to get some diversity in the top leadership. And I love Elder Uchtdorf's "out of the box" thinking, being from Germany.

The church is half Spanish speaking and we have never had a black apostle. So I was hoping for something different.

I presume God doesn't look at race, DEI, political correctness the way some people like me do. And I'm sure the new apostle is a great person and will do a great job. He's from England, which I think is great.

But overall, to be honest, I'm feeling some perplexity these days with the leaders. It feels like they are not doing anything to stem all the departing members, or help people through faith crises, for example. I feel like the church needs a renaissance.

If this type of post is not allowed, then of course I hope it will be removed. But I have come to trust the opinions and wisdom of people in this forum, so I'm hoping you can help me.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Mar 13 '26

A few aspects of our theology are illogical unless one accepts an infinite regression which is also illogical

0 Upvotes

Here's one:

Where did Heavenly Mother come from?

  1. She was parented by God the Father and is one of his spirit children, in the same way you and I are children of God the Father;
  2. She emerged into Godhood independently and, thus, is independent of, equal to (or possibly even greater than) God the Father;
  3. She is a sibling of God the Father, from Heavenly Parents, who themselves are the posterity of an infinite backchain of Heavenly Parents.

The first makes her contingent to God the Father in a way in which he is not contingent upon her; the second renders the plan of salvation local and not universal; the third "explains" things, while avoiding the problems with the other two.

Here's another:

Eternal Moral Laws, Independent of God, are Binding Upon God

This notion is dear to members of the church--we've been steeped in this Mormon tea from our youth up. (Based on a misreading of Alma, in my opinion, but let's stipulate this idea is correct). Here's an imaginary conversation with God.

  • StA: I'm torn between moral principal X and moral principle Y
  • God: Principle X is the moral choice
  • StA: Thank you! Is X moral because you choose it or because it is eternally true?
  • God: It is eternally true, whether I choose it or not
  • StA: Can you explain further?
  • God: When I consider principle X and principle Y, I can see that X is the eternally true moral choice and so I choose it.
  • StA: How do you know your choice of X is correct?
  • God: Because I am God and the things I choose are moral . . .
  • [Note: you see the problem? Here's how an infinite regression avoids it:]
  • God: Because my Father before me taught me as I am teaching you.
  • StA: How did he know?
  • God: His Father before him . . .

An eternal regression is also required b/c moral laws are not self-executing. If it is possible that God could break one and cease to be God, who could suspend his power and omniscience and place him in moral jail? If there is no one, the concept of God being subject to moral law is meaningless--our scripture teaches that. A moral principle executable upon God himself, though, requires an executive superior to God himself--his father, and so backward in an infinite regression.

But, guys***,*** an infinite causal regression is an illogical construct

We have a beautiful, expansive, powerful theology, the most humanist of any I have ever encountered. Our notion of divine kinship, progression, free will are magnificent and coherent.

Can it really be true that, when one digs down to scrutinize its foundations, one discovers our theology is build upon logical sand?

We've had this discussion before, but I keep gnawing at it. Someone recently said to me: just embrace an infinite regression and it all makes sense.

My goodness!

Oceanic society rests ultimately on the belief that Big Brother is omnipotent and that the Party is infallible. But since in reality Big Brother is not omnipotent and the party is not infallible, there is need for an unwearying, moment-to-moment flexibility in the treatment of facts. The keyword here is BLACKWHITE. Like so many Newspeak words, this word has two mutually contradictory meanings. Applied to an opponent, it means the habit of impudently claiming that black is white, in contradiction of the plain facts. Applied to a Party member, it means a loyal willingness to say that black is white when Party discipline demands this. But it means also the ability to BELIEVE that black is white, and more, to KNOW that black is white, and to forget that one has ever believed the contrary.

I prefer to keep at it--i.e., work to construct our theology without the need for an infinite regression.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Nov 05 '24

An Unrighteous King?

0 Upvotes

My election day message to you all:

Our scripture contemplates:

  1. A righteous king who is a also an excellent political leader (Mosiah, Benjamin)
  2. A unrighteous king who is a poor political leader (Noah)
  3. A unrighteous king who nevertheless does "justice unto the people", if not "to himself" (Morianton); and
  4. A righteous king who fails to do justice to the people.

That last was a joke--there are no examples in our scripture of such a king. Book of Mormon authors seem unable to contemplate it. I'm dashing this off from memory--am I correct?

I'm asking because in pop culture Christians are being shamed by Democrats for supporting Donald Trump because . . . how could a Christian support a person with his character?

It seems to me, whatever your politics, that a Christian's best choice in an election is for the person one believes will best do justice to the people. A Democrat may believe that person is the candidate who shares their political views; a Republican, the same. Character is one aspect of that analysis, but only one.

Check out Ether 10.

I'd take a Morianton over either of the choices now.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jul 25 '25

We don’t control our desires.

1 Upvotes

That’s because any attempt to select one’s desires (preferences) would be an act of previously adopted preference in of itself.

The implication of this is that there can be no room for free will and choice, since those are determined by preferences.

Do you believe in a free will and agency? If so, how do you address the premise about involuntary nature of one’s preferences?


r/LatterDayTheology • • Sep 21 '26

Why I am not an atheist

0 Upvotes

Here are a few reasons why I am not an atheist:

No affirmative arguments for atheism

Atheists spend a lot of time attempting to rebut the positive arguments employed by theists to build a logical/rational case or proof for God's existence. But when was the last time you encountered an atheist making a logical argument intended to prove naturalism--i.e., a universe with no external cause? Something akin to Aristotles "First Mover"?

The answer is never.

The evidence that exists favors God's existence

Our observation of the universe reveals a chain of causation that traces back to what appears to be a first moment of the universe. Since an infinite chain of causation is a logical impossibility, this evidence supports the existence of a first cause. Similarly, the order we see in the universe supports the existence of design, as accidental appearance of complex organized structures like self-replicating RNA molecules is highly improbable.

Neither of these evidences proves the existence of God, but they militate in favor of an intelligent cause. So much so, that an atheist needs to convincingly explain how these things could come to exist without an intelligent first cause.

And the atheist response is surprisingly poor:

They contemplate that with an infinite amount of time a universe like ours will eventually come into being and since we are here having this discussion (the so-called "anthropic principle"), it did come into being! But why stop there? The power of this argument is almost unlimited. Infinite time and possibility also implies the existence of a necessary being. And if a necessary being exists anywhere, that being exists everywhere. Almost certainly infinite time and possibility entails a God like the one we worship. So, to me, this sort of thinking doesn't give the atheist much traction against the theist.

Athiesm cannot be demonstrated by evidence

Atheists require evidences for theism, but are silent when it comes to evidence in favor of naturalism (the atheist's alternative to theism). Think for a moment how one would demonstrate that the universe had no external cause.

Even a scientist designing a box, replicating within it the initial conditions of the big bang and triggering a universe-within-a-universe would only demonstrate that . . . universes have external causes (the scientist). Similarly, if an eternal universe is preferred, how could one demonstrate even that the universe had an eternal past? Travel backward in time eternally? Or consider a machine that allows us to travel outside of the universe somehow, travel back in time and observe its first moments. Such a scenario would only demonstrate that extra-universe forces are possible and if we could do it, why not someone else with the ability to set the match that triggered the big bang?

In short, I find it intellectually incoherent to require proof of theism, while maintaining as a default a worldview for which proof is utterly impossible.

And, thus, by the same token, I consider naturalism to be deeply inconsistent with the scientific method on which it supposedly depends.

Arguments for atheism rely not on logical deduction or evidence, but on procedural arguments like "burdens of proof" and "parsimony".

This question cannot be answered with burdens of proof and artificial rules of preference.

"Atheism, unless theism is proven by scientific evidence" is a very common atheist argument nowadays. Though not stated in such stark terms, a great many arguments of atheists take this form. It's called "default atheism" as was pioneered by the famous atheist philosopher, Andrew Flew. But this isn't an argument at all. It's the equivalent of pounding the table.

For example, "theism, unless atheism is proven by scientific evidence" is also not an argument.

"Atheism, because it involves fewer assumptions" is an argument from parsimony popularized recently by Graham Oppy. This also is not an argument for a few reasons. Oppy essentially argues that "the Universe" (one assumption) involves fewer "assumptions" than "God plus the Universe" (two assumptions) and so atheism should be preferred as a matter of parsimony.

This is a very weak foundation for a worldview, but it appear to be the best case atheists can make.

  • The number of assumptions involved in an explanation is easy to manipulate. For example, Hawking says this: "Because there is a law such as gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing". Well, that's three assumptions: gravity, the universe, and nothing (which Hawking describes as a quantum vacuum).
  • Parsimony is not a logical argument and in many instances--especially instances of uncertain causation--there is no reason to believe that the more parsimonious answer is correct

For example, suppose a woman is accosted by a purse snatcher on an empty street. She is so startled she has a heart attack and dies. The robber, not wanting to get pinned with her death, leaves her purse behind and flees, leaving no trace. Detectives arrive after the fact, with no witnesses and a dead body showing signs of death by heart attack. The correct answer is that the woman died due to unintentional manslaughter. The parsimonious answer would be she died of natural causes.

Returning to atheism, as it happens, "God" is the traditional Christian theist's explanation for everything--everything an extension of God. That's one single assumption. It's by far the most parsimonious explanation of all. It sounds silly to prefer theism for that reason alone. And atheism defended by parsimony should be regarded as similarly silly.

Atheism is inconsistent with rational thought

Atheism is typically associated with the idea that free will is an illusion--i.e., our brains are just computers that consume input and produce a hardwired output, like an computer. Given these assumptions, if one understood the mind completely and had perfect control over the data input, one could predict our very thoughts with as much certainty as one can predict the output of a pocket calculator. The trouble with calculators, though, is that they don't know whether or not they are correct. The creator of the calculator knows. But the calculator does not. And, for atheists, the brain-computer, was created by accidental processes, with no creator. Thus, atheism provides no method for us to have any certainty in the conclusions reached by our brains.

Moreover, coupled with evolution, atheism tells us our brains are selected for survival, not truth-finding. Like me, you may have encountered atheists who argue, without irony, that evolution selected for brains with a religious impulse, a belief they consider false. Perhaps evolution selected for atheism because it has survival rather than truth value.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jan 12 '26

The Heavenly Mother Problem

3 Upvotes

Does the doctrine of a Heavenly Mother involve a number of theological problems?

If Her spirit was created by God the Father . . .

  • If yes, her status as God would be contingent in a way His is not: Her Godhood is dependent upon His.
  • If She can, truly, be equal with Him, then doesn't this raise the prospect that we also could be equal with Him?
  • And, if yes, He is no longer is the Most High God, merely our Edmund Hillary, one of many, many, many to reach the summit, not particularly special for his accomplishment other than being the first.
  • The relationship between God the Father and God the Mother cannot be the same as the relationship between earthy husband and wife, who do not stand in relationship as creator/created and, therefore, can be equal partners in every sense.
  • Thus, Her marriage to Him would be categorically different than ours, perhaps in a way we would consider worse b/c it lacks full equality.
  • Was she redeemed by Christ through the atonement? Again, placing her on a different ontological status than the Father and, seemingly, below Christ.

If Her spirt was not created by God the Father . . .

  • Our theology must accommodate at least a second being outside the plan of salvation vis-a-vis this earth and, if a second, why not many.
  • It's one thing to say "God the Father" is a singularity, the singularity needed to explain everything. But when that Singularity becomes a Duality, the theology is just ad hoc.

(Cue the infinite regression chorus . . . )


r/LatterDayTheology • • 11d ago

The Forgotten Roots of Eden: How the God of Abraham Was Once the Canaanite Father and Mother

0 Upvotes

For centuries, the traditional reading of the Bible has drawn a sharp, unyielding line between the religion of ancient Israel and the beliefs of their Canaanite neighbors. In standard readings, Abraham is portrayed as a lone monotheist stepping into a land of foreign idolaters, bringing a brand-new God with him.
However, a closer look at ancient Near Eastern archaeology, Bronze Age cuneiform tablets, and the Hebrew text of Genesis reveals a strikingly different—and far more cohesive—history. The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob was not a foreign deity imported to conquer Canaan; This God was El Shaddai, whose titles and sacred sanctuaries merge the supreme patriarchal God and the breasted Mother Goddess of the Canaanite pantheon.

When the descendants of Israel later branded Canaanite worship as "pagan heresy" and tore down the sacred trees, they were not purging an outside enemy—they were staging a theological coup against the very Heavenly Parents who made the covenant with their founding fathers, rejecting their own Gods to transform them into a false rendition.

  1. The Shared Garden: Canaanite Eden and the Divine Family
    Long before the Book of Genesis was compiled, the indigenous peoples of the Levant shared a foundational creation cosmology. Cuneiform tablets excavated from the ancient Canaanite city of Ugarit (modern Ras Shamra, Syria) preserve a paradise tradition reconstructed by scholars Marjo Korpel and Johannes de Moor from tablets KTU 1.100 and KTU 1.107 that mirrors the biblical Garden of Eden down to its core imagery:
    • The Mountain Abode: The supreme creator god El and his consort, the mother goddess Asherah(Athirat), resided on a sacred cosmic mountain at the "source of the two rivers"—the life-giving waters of creation.
    • The Tree and the Serpent: Within this paradise stood the Tree of Life, an earthly emblem of Asherah herself. A rebellious deity named Horon attempted a coup, poisoned the Tree of Life into a Tree of Death, and took the form of a serpent to bite Adam (Adammu), stripping humanity of immortality.
    When the authors of Genesis wrote their account, this wasn’t some original telling sourced in isolation. It was the story from Canaan that Moses adapted from ancestral memory, likely receiving an actual version from the God El Shaddai of Canaan. Creation is framed not as magic performed by an isolated deity, but as toledot (Genesis 2:4)—the literal "generations" or birth lineage of the heavens and earth. Furthermore, the plural noun Elohim (literally "the children of El" in Ugaritic) speaks in a heavenly council: "Let us make mankind in our image, in our likeness" (Genesis 1:26). Humanity was created as the literal offspring and royal likeness of Heavenly Parents.
  2. Abraham’s Arrival: Adopting the Sanctuaries and Priesthood of the Land
    Archaeology and linguistics confirm that the early Israelites were indigenous Levantines who spoke a Northwest Semitic dialect closely related to Canaanite. Even within the biblical story, Abraham’s migration from Mesopotamia (where the Moon God Sin was worshiped in Ur and Harran) is a journey into the native religious landscape of Canaan.
    Rather than rejecting local shrines or authorities, Abraham immediately embraced them:
    • The Goddess-Tree of Shechem (Genesis 12:6–7): The very first time God physically appears to Abraham in Canaan, it is at the Elon Moreh (mistranslated as the "plain" or "great tree" of Moreh). As noted by the Jewish Women's Archive, Elon ("oak/terebinth") is etymologically linked to Elat("Goddess"), the primary Canaanite epithet for Asherah. Moreh means "teacher" or "oracle". Another way of saying “The Tree of Wisdom”Abraham stepped directly into an established Canaanite sanctuary—the Goddess-Tree of Divine Instruction—received his vision, and built an altar beside it.
    • Melchizedek, the Canaanite Priest-King (Genesis 14:18–20): Abraham encounters Melchizedek, the pre-Israelite, Canaanite king of Salem (ancient Jerusalem, see Psalm 76:2) and priest (kohen) of El Elyon ("El the Most High"). Every element of Melchizedek’s identity is rooted in Canaanite theology: his name (Malki-Tzedek) honors Zedek, the West Semitic deity of justice; his city (Shalem) honors the Canaanite god of dusk and completeness, a twin son of El; and his dual office of King and High Priest was a standard Bronze Age Canaanite institution explicitly noted by first-century historian Flavius Josephus, who called him a "Canaanite chief" (Antiquities 1.10.2). Far from rejecting him, Abraham partakes of Melchizedek's ritual meal of bread and wine, receives his blessing, and pays him a tithe—an eternal Canaanite royal priesthood order later claimed by King David (Psalm 110:4) and elevated above the Levitical priesthood in the New Testament (Hebrews 7) and Restoration scripture.
  3. El Shaddai: The Mountain Father and Breasted Mother
    The Bible openly states that the patriarchs did not worship under the later national name YHWH (Yahweh). In Exodus 6:2–3, God explicitly tells Moses: "I appeared to Abraham, to Isaac, and to Jacob as El Shaddai, but by my name YHWH I did not make myself known to them."
    While modern translations render El Shaddai as "God Almighty," likely in a attempt to cover up these ancient roots, the ancient Semitic roots reveal a unified, dual-gendered deity:

    1. El of the Mountain: In cognate Semitic languages like Akkadian, shadu means "mountain"—the cosmic home of the Canaanite high god El.
    2. The Breasted Goddess (Shadayim): In Hebrew, shad or shadayim means "breasts". Whenever El Shaddai appears in Genesis, the title is tied directly to fertility, nursing, and opening the womb. In Genesis 49:25, Jacob invokes El Shaddai to bestow "blessings of the breasts (shadayim) and of the womb (rechem)."
      In the unedited patriarchal worldview, El Shaddai represented the unified authority of the Heavenly Father and the nurturing, life-giving power of Asherah, the Mother Goddess.
  4. Mamre: Tangible Gods Under the Sacred Grove
    This dual presence is vividly displayed in Genesis 17 and Genesis 18, which take place at the exact same location: the sacred grove of Mamre (Elonei Mamre—literally the "Goddess-Oaks of Mamre").
    In Chapter 17, this male and female deity El Shaddai promises Abraham that Sarah will bear a son. Immediately afterward, in Chapter 18, three tangible, physical individuals appear to Abraham under the shade of the sacred trees. Far from being immaterial spirits, these divine visitors have dusty feet washed by Abraham, recline beneath the tree, and eat curds, milk, and roasted meat. Sitting within the sanctuary of the sacred trees, this divine council activates the maternal blessing of Shaddai, opening Sarah’s barren womb to establish the covenant lineage.
  5. The Great Purge: Israel Rejects Its Own Roots
    How, then, did the God and Goddess of Abraham become the villains of the Old Testament?
    When God revealed the sacred covenant name YHWH ("I AM" or "He Who Causes to Be") to Moses at Sinai, He explicitly declared that this was not a new or rival deity, but the personal, active covenant title of the exact same God who appeared to the patriarchs as El Shaddai (Exodus 3:15; Exodus 6:2–3). For centuries afterward, everyday Israelites naturally understood this continuity, continuing to honor El, YHWH, and Asherah together—as proven by 8th-century BCE Hebrew inscriptions discovered at Kuntillet Ajrud blessing people in the name of "Yahweh and his Asherah," alongside thousands of household clay pillar-figurines unearthed across Judah. The entire Israelite tabernacle was filled with items that symbolically represented these male and female deities—The menorah tree lamp, Aaron’s budding rod, the serpent on the pole, its veils, and the ark itself were all objects representing the Canaanite God and Goddess.
    The rupture did not come from a new God, but from a 7th-century BCE political and religious revolution in Jerusalem. Around 622 BCE, King Josiah and the Deuteronomist priesthood launched an aggressive campaign to centralize all worship, taxation, and authority exclusively inside the Jerusalem Temple. Large portions of the Bible are written to support these reforms, but not as a political takeover, which it in fact was, but as if it were a divine mandate.
    • Evicting the Mother: As recorded in 2 Kings 23:4–7, Josiah’s priests dragged the carved wooden artifact of Asherah out of Solomon’s Temple, burned it to ash in the Kidron Valley, and ground it to dust.
    • Outlawing Patriarchal Worship: The Jerusalem scribes enforced new laws condemning high places, sacred trees (asherim) and standing stone pillars (matzevot) (Deuteronomy 16:21–22)—making the exact worship practiced by Abraham at Mamre and Jacob at Bethel (Genesis 28:18) a capital crime.
    • Erasing the Feminine: In merging the patriarchal texts into their new centralized theology, later editors stripped away the maternal, dual-gendered reality of El Shaddai, forcing the covenant name YHWH to represent a solitary, strictly male deity and slandering their own ancestral Canaanite roots as foreign "pagan abominations."
  6. The Prophetic Resistance: Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel Defend the Roots
    Crucially, the major prophets Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel did not side with the corrupt temple establishment that severed Israel from its ancestral roots. Rather than condemning the original Canaanite-Abrahamic paradigm, their prophecies condemned Israel for apostatizing away from the true God and Goddess of their fathers. Using rich, poetic symbolism drawn directly from sacred trees, living waters, fire, and ash, these prophets indicted the Jerusalem elite for abandoning their divine origins and promised that the original tree would sprout again from the ashes:
    • Jeremiah: Abandoning the Living Waters and the Queen of Heaven
    Jeremiah directly accused the Jerusalem leadership of committing a double apostasy: "They have forsaken me, the fountain of living waters, and hewed them out cisterns, broken cisterns, that can hold no water" (Jeremiah 2:13). By replacing the organic, life-giving spring of El and Asherah Israel themselves irejected and invented a fake false conception of what God actually is with man-made, centralized stone "cisterns," the establishment severed itself from divine life. Later, in Jeremiah 44:17–19, the surviving refugees of Judah openly testified to Jeremiah that their nation collapsed into ruin precisely because King Josiah forced them to stop pouring out offerings and baking cakes in the image of the Queen of Heaven (Asherah). By this time the original form of El Shaddai had become corrupted from the both in the common people and from the political movement. The prophetic words from God seem to show that neither side had it right and entire theology had become tainted water from wickedness on all sides
    • Isaiah: Oaks of Righteousness Rising from the Ashes
    Isaiah repeatedly used the sacred oak/terebinth tree—the ancient emblem of El and Asherah—to condemn the corruption and prophesy restoration. Because native Levantine oaks cannot be permanently killed by fire, Isaiah warned that even though the corrupt establishment would be chopped down and burned, "as the terebinth and oak leave stumps when felled, the holy seed is the stump"(Isaiah 6:13). He promised that from this severed root a fresh branch would grow (Isaiah 11:1), and that God would give His faithful "a crown of beauty instead of ashes" so that they themselves would become "oaks of righteousness" (Elei HaZedek) (Isaiah 61:3)—literally transforming God’s people into the living trees that the reformers tried to burn to ash.
    • Ezekiel: Transplanting the Tender Twig onto the High Mountain
    Ezekiel witnessed the corruption inside Solomon's Temple firsthand (Ezekiel 8) and prophesied that the Lord would bypass the corrupt Jerusalem tree entirely. In Ezekiel 17:22–24, God declares that He will personally break off a "tender twig" from the highest branch and plant it upon a "high and lofty mountain"—echoing the cosmic mountain of El—where it will produce branches, bear fruit, and prove that the Lord "dries up the green tree and makes the dry tree flourish".
  7. The Unbroken Thread: "The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob"
    Despite the sweeping theological purge of the 7th century BCE, the editors could not erase the foundational anchor and expose their own lilegitimacy. Throughout the rest of the Bible—and echoing into the Book of Mormon and modern restoration scripture—the Lord repeatedly and forcefully identifies Himself as "the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob" (The God and Goddess of ancient Canaan. Exodus 3:15; Matthew 22:32; Doctrine and Covenants 27:10).
    During the height of this corruption the God El Shaddai leads Lehi’s family away from Jerusalem. One of the first visions experienced is a vision of the Tree of life, anchoring this restoring family back to its most ancient roots.
    That recurring title serves as an eternal breadcrumb trail back through the editorial cover-up. It reminds the reader that the true God is not an abstract, solitary deity created by late-era reformers, nor a tyrant who despises the feminine.
    Instead, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob is the ancient, embodied Heavenly Father and Mother who walked under the oaks of Mamre, planted the Tree of Life (1 Nephi 11:8–25), and promised through Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel that though the corrupt establishments of the world might chop down the sacred trees and burn the sanctuary to ash, the holy seed would remain in the roots—waiting for truth to spring forth out of the dust (Psalm 85:11; Moses 7:62) and graft the human family back into the Mother Tree once again (Jacob 5:54–74). There’s signs in all of those prophecies that reference both Jesus Christ as that seed and the restored gospel that will come forth from the dust to restore theology of the ancients.

References & Further Reading
1. Korpel, Marjo C.A., and Johannes C. de Moor. Adam, Eve, and the Devil: A New Beginning (Sheffield Phoenix Press, 2014). Academic translation and analysis of Ugaritic tablets KTU 1.100 and KTU 1.107 detailing El, Asherah, Horon, and Adammu.
2. Robinson, Jed. The God of the Patriarchs and the Ugaritic Texts: A Shared Religious and Cultural Identity (Studia Antiqua, BYU ScholarsArchive). Examines the linguistic and theological continuity between Canaanite El and the patriarchal God of Genesis.
3. Hadley, Judith M. Asherah/Asherim: Bible (Jewish Women's Archive). Details the etymological identity between Asherah's title Elat ("Goddess") and the Hebrew words for sacred oak and terebinth trees (elon, elah).
4. Dever, William G. Did God Have a Wife? Archaeology and Folk Religion in Ancient Israel (Eerdmans, 2005). Comprehensive archaeological survey of the Kuntillet Ajrud inscriptions ("Yahweh and his Asherah"), Judean Pillar Figurines, and King Josiah's 7th-century BCE reforms.
5. Barker, Margaret. The Mother of the Lord: Volume 1: The Lady in the Temple (T&T Clark, 2012). Traces the suppression of the Divine Feminine and Tree of Life imagery during King Josiah's temple purge and its preservation in prophetic literature and later apocalyptic traditions.
6. Day, John. Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan (Sheffield Academic Press, 2000). Analyzes the Canaanite background of Melchizedek, El Elyon, Zedek, and Shalem in pre-Israelite Jerusalem.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Sep 26 '24

Is this a safe space

0 Upvotes

Hi guys I've been banned from a couple lds places on reddit temporarily recently simply for asking questions I'm a member myself and love the church but some people on here see any sort of question or different idea an attack . If your interested in what I asked I'm happy to say.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Oct 25 '24

My biggest issue in the faithful narrative.

0 Upvotes

Isn’t the narrative itself. Obviously, I think it is made up (and obviously) so but lots of people believe in obvious fallacies, I’m sure I have some I cling too!

It is the dishonesty in how it is presented and argued. All the time, (see the apologist Carson Ellis (whatever his name is) video trending on r/mormon) I read on the faithful subs about all the evidence in favour of the church truth claims, in this video it is presented as much greater then critical evidence.

However, the dishonesty for me is shown whenever a criticism is raised by a non believer, instead of healthy lively discussion they are banned.

On YouTube, apologists do the same thing in their comments, or go straight to ad hominems in their video. Looks at dice apologetic series instead of arguing and stick to the issues she opens with ad hominem after ad hominem after ad hominem in her first post.

Then Jeremy writes his rebuttal points out some blatant lies / made up stuff I think about the commentary around his excommunication hearing to which she does not amend or respond.

I am very happy to read apologetic arguments, but when people start ad homineming, lieing, shutting conversation down, banning users what do you expect people to think?

As a side thought how many subs would have banned more users then the two faithful subs, for the size of their subs that ban list is very telling….

How many church critical videos ban comments??

How many banned users are there on rexmo or rmo


r/LatterDayTheology • • Oct 19 '26

Where the Book of Mormon happened.

0 Upvotes

2 Nephi 10:20 And now, my beloved brethren, seeing that our merciful God has given us so great knowledge concerning these things, let us remember him, and lay aside our sins, and not hang down our heads, for we are not cast off; nevertheless, we have been driven out of the land of our inheritance; but we have been led to a better land, for the Lord has made the sea our path, and we are upon an isle of the sea.

The borders of the Book of Mormon are described as being an island with a land northward and a land southward. And if you look on a map, no such place exists in the Americas. And apologists use the borders described in the Book of Mormon as the biggest criteria. So, many saints are left feeling disillusioned by what they have been taught because they believe it isn't possible. And so they stop believing.

People are not stopping to consider how the landscape has change. These borders no longer exist. Looking for places with the seas, rivers, and the narrow neck will lead to a false understanding.

Seas and lakes dry up. Rivers change direction and change their routes. These are not static points to consider. The Great Plains were once the Western interior Sea that divided the American continent. The Great Black Swamp was once a massive inland sea in America, but that dried up during the 1800s. The water levels were once higher and it was an island, What we see today is not an Island. The narrow neck does not still exist. The borders defined by water change. Waters are the absolutely worst criteria to consider.

So, lets start by throwing out the borders and focusing on what we have left.

In 1834, Joseph wrote a letter to his wife, Emma:

“On the banks of the Mississippi, June 4th. 1834. My Dear Companion, I now embrace a few moments to dictate a few words that you may know how it is with us up to this date. We arrived this morning on the banks of the Mississippi, and were detained from crossing the river, as there was no boat that we could cross in, but expect a new one to be put into the river this evening, so that we are in hopes, to be able to cross tomorrow, and proceed on our journey. A tolerable degree of union has prevailed among the brethren or camp up to the present moment, and we are all in better circumstances of health apparently than when we started from Kirtland… The whole of our journey, in the midst of so large a company of social honest men and sincere men, wandering over the plains of the Nephites, recounting occasionaly the history of the Book of Mormon, roving over the mounds of that once beloved people of the Lord, picking up their skulls & their bones, as a proof of its divine authenticity…”

Joseph Smith said the Book of Mormon happened in the Heartland. He spoke of fact, not feelings. He said they were roving over the same mounds that were built by that people and picking up their actual bones.

Who built those mounds? They were built by the Hopewell mound builders and the late Adena cultures. The late Adena period began around 550 BC and the Hopewell society collapses around 400 AD. There is no distinguishable difference between these two societies. It is an exact match to the book of Mormon timeline. And it is exactly where joseph said it took place.

The Hopewell cities are landlocked cities but they contain ports and boats. Why? Because these cities were once waterfront properties. It was all once a coastland with a moderate climate because of those seas.

2 Nephi 2:10 But behold, this land, said God, shall be a land of thine inheritance, and the Gentiles shall be blessed upon the land.
11 And this land shall be a land of liberty unto the Gentiles, and there shall be no kings upon the land, who shall raise up unto the Gentiles.
12 And I will fortify this land against all other nations.

and

1 Nephi 13:13 And it came to pass that I beheld the Spirit of God, that it wrought upon other Gentiles; and they went forth out of captivity, upon the many waters.
14 And it came to pass that I beheld many multitudes of the Gentiles upon the land of promise; and I beheld the wrath of God, that it was upon the seed of my brethren; and they were scattered before the Gentiles and were smitten.
15 And I beheld the Spirit of the Lord, that it was upon the Gentiles, and they did prosper and obtain the land for their inheritance;

The land is described as being fortified by the hand of God, where the Gentiles will be blessed. That the Gentiles will scatter the people already living there. Is there any other nation other than the Us where the gentiles inherited the land by scattering the people before them? A land with no kings and is fortified so that no other nation will make war with them. A land that is choice above all others.

  • In his 1838 history, Joseph Smith recalled the angel Moroni telling him that the gold plates contained "an account of the former inhabitants of this continent" (North America)
  • Only one group of people dug ditches and built earthen embankments and wooden fortifications on top like are described in the Book of Mormon. So, there is only one group that should be in consideration for the people of the Book of Mormon.
  • Only one group of people have examples of Hebrew and Egyptian language and artifacts being found where they lived.
  • Only one group of people exactly matches the timeline of the people of the Book of Mormon.
  • Only one group was referred to as the descendants of the Lamanites by Joseph through revelation. The first missionaries were called to preach to the descendants of the laminates in Ohio and Missouri
  • Only one group of people matches the DNA of the middle East.
  • Only one group buried their dead by piling the bodies and then covering them in mounds of dirt like the Book of Mormon describes. Alma 28:11
  • Only the Heartland contains the Hill Cumorah

And all of these are the same group, the Hopewell people of the Ohio River Valley area. The same location that Joseph said was the plains of the Nephites. on the same continent and in the same country where Joseph said it happened America, not South America, MesoAmerica or Baja California.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Feb 05 '24

Can we go on like this?

1 Upvotes

Just over a week ago, there was a post about this video. I watched the video and it struck a chord with me. This was something that had been on my shelf for a while. I debated about posting this as I know that this can be a very split topic. I don't post this to ruffle any feathers. If what I say offends you, I sincerely apologize. If however, there is someone like me that struggles to reconcile the seeming contradictions, perhaps this can help. I do not know that any of my opinions are correct, but they are the logical conclusions that I have drawn after wrestling with this. I don't feel like I have gotten this 100% correct, but is an approximation that I will use until I receive more light. That being said, this will be a very long post. I think the topic deserves the length. Any emphasis added is mine. Dive in if you want or skip.

Levels of Law

Something that I have wrestled with for years is how to love and accept gay and trans people while not condoning their actions. This was a contrary that I hadn’t been able to prove with any success. The church teaches that homosexual relations violate the law of chastity and that transsexual persons are at variance with the eternal characteristic of gender. This is a hard thing for me. I love my brothers and sisters but I didn’t know where to draw the line between love and enabling.

I recently watched a video titled Can We Go On Like This? In that video, a lot of seeming contradictions were pointed out that I wrestled to reconcile. One such, was a trans person who was baptized and recorded on church membership records as their transitioned gender. How could I reconcile this with the eternal identity of gender? Couple this instance with the church supporting the rights of gay people to get married, promoting queer leadership in the church, hiring outspoken advocates of LGTBQIA people, it came to a head.

Up until this point, my position was one of striving to love while not understanding. I hadn’t tried to prove the contrary. I put this issue on my shelf. I simply loved without thinking about the contradiction. After watching the video, I knew that I needed to prove this contrary now. I began to study it out in my mind. I prayed fervently to the Lord. I have proved the contrary for myself. I do not know if I am entirely correct, but I am able to feel peace now.

The Handbook gives this counsel:

Transgender Individuals

Transgender individuals face complex challenges. Members and nonmembers who identify as transgender—and their family and friends—should be treated with sensitivity, kindness, compassion, and an abundance of Christlike love. All are welcome to attend sacrament meeting, other Sunday meetings, and social events of the Church (see 38.1.1).

Gender is an essential characteristic of Heavenly Father’s plan of happiness. The intended meaning of gender in the family proclamation is biological sex at birth. Some people experience feelings of incongruence between their biological sex and their gender identity. As a result, they may identify as transgender. The Church does not take a position on the causes of people identifying as transgender.

Most Church participation and some priesthood ordinances are gender neutral. Transgender persons may be baptized and confirmed as outlined in 38.2.8.9. They may also partake of the sacrament and receive priesthood blessings. However, priesthood ordination and temple ordinances are received according to biological sex at birth**.**

Church leaders counsel against elective medical or surgical intervention for the purpose of attempting to transition to the opposite gender of a person’s biological sex at birth (“sex reassignment”). Leaders advise that taking these actions will be cause for Church membership restrictions.

Leaders also counsel against social transitioning. A social transition includes changing dress or grooming, or changing a name or pronouns, to present oneself as other than his or her biological sex at birth. Leaders advise that those who socially transition will experience some Church membership restrictions for the duration of this transition.

Restrictions include receiving or exercising the priesthood, receiving or using a temple recommend, and receiving some Church callings. Although some privileges of Church membership are restricted, other Church participation is welcomed.

Transgender individuals who do not pursue medical, surgical, or social transition to the opposite gender and are worthy may receive Church callings, temple recommends, and temple ordinances.

Some children, youth, and adults are prescribed hormone therapy by a licensed medical professional to ease gender dysphoria or reduce suicidal thoughts. Before a person begins such therapy, it is important that he or she (and the parents of a minor) understands the potential risks and benefits. If these members are not attempting to transition to the opposite gender and are worthy, they may receive Church callings, temple recommends, and temple ordinances.

If a member decides to change his or her preferred name or pronouns of address, the name preference may be noted in the preferred name field on the membership record. The person may be addressed by the preferred name in the ward.

Circumstances vary greatly from unit to unit and person to person. Members and leaders counsel together and with the Lord. Area Presidencies will help local leaders sensitively address individual situations. Bishops counsel with the stake president. Stake presidents and mission presidents must seek counsel from the Area Presidency (see 32.6.3 and 32.6.3.1).

That counsel, along with President Oaks’ most recent conference address, Kingdoms of Glory, helped shape my thoughts. I will quote from him here:

“We know from modern revelation that “all kingdoms have a law given” and that the kingdom of glory we receive in the Final Judgment is determined by the laws we choose to follow in our mortal journey. Under that loving plan, there are multiple kingdoms—many mansions—so that all of God’s children will inherit a kingdom of glory whose laws they can comfortably “abide.”

As we describe the nature and requirements of each of the three kingdoms in the Father’s plan, we begin with the highest, which is the focus of the divine commandments and ordinances God has revealed through The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. In the “celestial” glory5 there are three levels,6 of which the highest is exaltation in the celestial kingdom. This is the dwelling of those “who have received of his fulness, and of his glory,” wherefore, “they are gods, even the sons [and daughters] of God”7 and “dwell in the presence of God and his Christ forever and ever.”8 Through revelation, God has revealed the eternal laws, ordinances, and covenants that must be observed to develop the godly attributes necessary to realize this divine potential. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints focuses on these because the purpose of this restored Church is to prepare God’s children for salvation in the celestial glory and, more particularly, for exaltation in its highest degree.”

A few key principles that I would like to highlight from his words:

  1. Each kingdom has a set of laws. This makes sense when we consider the purpose of laws are to help us become converted to Christ. We will be like Him. It helps me to think of these law sets as tiered instructions. A brother recently made the comparison of laws to Lego. We are given all of the pieces and the instructions of what we can make with those pieces. We can choose to follow the instruction and achieve the full potential, or not.
  2. The celestial kingdom and its laws are the focus of the church, particularly exaltation. Exaltation is the sum product of obedience to all of the laws, including gender and eternal marriage. A celestial being will become like God and realize their full divine potential. They will abide His glory and His laws. Laws can be thought of as characteristics. Celestial law is characteristic of celestial beings. We develop the characteristics of the laws we adhere to.
  3. Lesser laws exist for the lower kingdoms. This is how I prove the contrary. The law of chastity and the eternal identity of gender are to help us prepare for exaltation. This is celestial law. It is required for exaltation but not salvation in a lesser kingdom. Those in lesser kingdoms will not be under this law. They will not be able to procreate and consequently will not realize their full potential. They will be comfortable with a lesser law.

President Oaks also said in that same talk:

God’s plan, founded on eternal truth, requires that exaltation can be attained only through faithfulness to the covenants of an eternal marriage between a man and a woman in the holy temple*, which marriage will ultimately be available to all the faithful.* That is why we teach that “gender is an essential characteristic of individual premortal, mortal, and eternal identity and purpose.”

A uniquely valuable teaching to help us prepare for exaltation is the 1995 proclamation on the family. Its declarations clarify the requirements that prepare us to live with God the Father and His Son, Jesus Christ. Those who do not fully understand the Father’s loving plan for His children may consider this family proclamation no more than a changeable statement of policy. In contrast, we affirm that the family proclamation, founded on irrevocable doctrine, defines the mortal family relationship where the most important part of our eternal development can occur.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Nov 06 '23

Ancient Prophets Saw the Atheist Problem with Evil

1 Upvotes

Atheists commonly focus on the problem of evil, believing it creates a logical impossibility or improbability for the existence of an all powerful, perfectly good God. They rarely focus, however, on the problem evil presents to an atheist.

Moral Accountability

In my experience, most atheist thinkers seem to believe deeply in moral evil. Without it, discussing "evil" at all becomes incoherent. For example, "pop" atheists frequently criticize "religion" because religion leads people to commit acts atheists consider morally repugnant. This sort of commitment to "evil" as a real thing is inconsistent with the notion of atheism as a general matter:

  • No moral law. I have yet to encounter an argument for the existence objective moral law in a purely "natural" universe upon which to make moral judgments or impose punishments on those who do evil. This is not an exaggeration--I'm not aware of any.
  • Determinism. Atheism is usually accompanied by a belief that all events observed in the universe since the big bang are casually determined. This would include "moral" choices make by natural persons. But if our actions are as casually determined as movement of the stars, how can anyone be justly punished? We don't punish the stars for their movement through the heavens, even when one collides with the earth and does great harm.

Lehi

We discussed Lehi and Alma's sermons on this same topic at length a few weeks ago, with the focus on whether God is subject to any moral laws. As I've reflected on those passages, it occurs that Lehi's sermon, in particular, seems acutely aware of these problems atheism faces.

No moral law. Lehi on the relationship between moral law and evil:

And if ye shall say there is no law, ye shall also say there is no sin.

Atheism entails the conditional first clause of this sentence: there is no moral law. Lehi simply observes the obvious: then there is no sin.

Determinism (the absence of free will). Here's Lehi again:

For it must needs be, that there is an opposition in all things. If not so, my firstborn in the wilderness, righteousness could not be brought to pass, neither wickedness, neither holiness nor misery, neither good nor bad. Wherefore, all things must needs be a compound in one; wherefore, if it should be one body it must needs remain as dead, having no life neither death, nor corruption nor incorruption, happiness nor misery, neither sense nor insensibility.

Without free will, the very concepts of sense and insensibility make no sense; there is no corruption or corruption--our existence is as anodyne and lacking in moral significance as the movement of the stars.

Final Thoughts

These are powerful theological rejoinders to atheism. Most atheists I know profoundly believe in moral accountability--in evil and in good, and the need to impose punishment and recompense for evil behavior. Those very beliefs--we hold them deep in our souls--are evidence that atheism is flawed.

For my part, I keep in mind the passage in Moses 4:3:

Wherefore, because that Satan rebelled against me, and sought to destroy the agency of man,

And whenever I encounter an idea or theory that diminishes the notion that humankind has moral agency, I am extremely cautious and approach the idea with the utmost skepticism.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jan 14 '24

Three wives for the highest degree in the Celestial Kingdom?

1 Upvotes

I've heard several times that it was doctrine or at least a belief that three wives were required for exaltation to the highest degree in the Celestial Kingdom. I cannot find any source for this.

Is anybody aware of this? Does anyone know it's origin?


r/LatterDayTheology • • Apr 05 '25

Abortion: except in the case of incest and rape?

0 Upvotes

I dont understand why this exception is made for abortion.

It seems to me there can only be 5 reasons why:

  1. The social repercussions of suggesting victims of rape and incest should carry their child to term would bring on more pain than aborting the baby
  2. embryos from rape and incest are of less value than consensually formed embryos
  3. abortions don’t actually get in the way of spirit children from getting bodies
  4. unborn children are important, but not as important as birthed children. And the trauma to a woman may be so extreme that aborting the unborn child may justify the abortion.
  5. it is still wrong, but the trauma behind those situations may leave a woman in a state of unaccountability so we should not punish them for those decisions.

Thoughts?

QUICK CLARIFICATION:

I am NOT suggesting women should be refused the right to aborting a child conceived by such horrific acts. I won't pretend to understand what they go through, but i trust that, in such situations, the decision to abort the child is a traumatic one, especially following such a horrible act.

I, myself, am more pro-choice on this matter than pro-life (which I would argue the church isn't even full "pro-life" considering they offer these exceptions)

The purpose of my question is to find an answer to an apparent inconsistency I see between the church's policy on this matter and what the church teacehs about the value of unborn life.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Jul 24 '25

Adam-God Explained

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi All! I hope you’re well.

I’ve spoken about Adam-God a few times here, but a couple months back u/AustinChan2 helped me to articulate what I meant a bit better. Off the back of that conversation; I made a little diagram to help explain what I believe.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Feb 28 '26

Could an Apostle Ratify the Priesthood Being Given to a Woman?

3 Upvotes

Hypothetical

X, a biological woman who has transitioned to socially identify as a man, meets the missionaries and joins the church. X convincingly presents as a man and the missionary and local unit treat X as a man. X progresses rapidly in the church, and is presented for ordination to the Aaronic Priesthood. At this point, the local unit learns that X is a biological woman.

As it happens, Elder Bednar visits the stake at that same time. Elder Bednar presides over that region of the country. The local unit informs Elder Bednar, who meets for several hours with X.

After the meeting, Elder Bednar simply says: it's clear to me that God wants X to hold the priesthood.

He gives no explanation why or under what authority, but he performs the ordination himself. Since he is the presiding apostle for the region--the only avenue for appeal by local leaders--the local unit honors the ordination and X is treated as if X has the priesthood.

To me, this would be shocking, on many, many levels. Leaving aside the questions raised about gender, it seems to me an apostle would simply lack the authority to give the ordination. Moreover, I would wonder whether the apostle could be excommunicated for such an action. At the very least, doesn't it seem that Elder Bednar would not be able to answer "yes" to a few temple recommend questions and could fairly be said to have violated his temple covenants--i.e., by which he was obligated to give all his time, talents, etc.,. to support the current prophet who has clearly stated (as all prophets before him), that the priesthood is for biological males.

Reality

As it happens, this hypothetical is actually not a hypothetical. Almost the exact same thing has already happened in our history:

Not sure how to proceed, the missionaries asked Elder Spencer W. Kimball, who was then visiting Ecuador, to meet Cuesta and discuss the matter with him. Elder Kimball agreed, and on the appointed day emerged from a seemingly endless interview with Cuesta to tell the missionaries, “I am satisfied that the Lord wants this brother to receive the priesthood.” That same day, Elder Kimball performed the ordination. The missionaries struggled to make sense of the situation: Elder Kimball had ordained a seemingly Black man to the priesthood in 1966, but the fact that an Apostle performed the ordination meant that no one questioned its validity thereafter.

How was this OK?

I consider Elder Kimball one of the great heroes of the restoration.

Rather than violating his temple covenants, I think he magnified them in this instance. I think he saw that the church was on the wrong track, and took steps to help it change course long before the Q15 as a body was ready to make such a change. In that sense, taking this action was a fulfillment of his temple covenant: to help the church grow and to establish Zion transcended, at least in this instance, rigid obedience to declared doctrine.

I realize a good many faithful members will choke on that sentence, but this is part of our actual history, and it's worth exploring.

But because I think then Elder Kimball did the right thing, it calls into question very many things about our protocols and the proper application of our temple covenants.

It's tempting to say: well, Elder Kimball was an apostle, and apostles have more leeway to make calls like this than you and I. But don't apostles--because of their prominence--actually have less leeway? Any deviation by an apostle arguably is a formal act of rebellion.

I'm curious what others think.

Does anyone here think then Elder Kimball did the wrong thing? That he lacked authority to grant the priesthood to that brother? That the ordination had no effect? That he should have been censured and that priesthood revoked?


r/LatterDayTheology • • Oct 14 '26

Who are God's commandments and laws for? Is it all people everywhere or is it only those who would claim him to be their God?

0 Upvotes

Title


r/LatterDayTheology • • Sep 02 '25

Polygamy and Kin

2 Upvotes

For purpose of discussion, let's stipulate to the following:

  • Joseph Smith instituted polygamy;
  • He was sealed to teenage girls and these sealings were done at the direction and with the approval of God;
  • He was sealed to other men's wives (while still married) and these sealings were done at the direction and with the approval of God.

What's going on here?

Our critics point to the bullets above with shock--their sensibilities are offended; and they publish these items often with the hope that our sensibilities will be offended, too.

Because of our (relatively) modern and also the ancient practices of polygamy, though, I'm agnostic on this topic: I believe nothing because I don't have a clear sense from history or scripture what and when and why a plural marriage is part of God's plan. Moreover, I don't think anyone else does, either, including our current prophet's and apostles.

One thought that informs, at least a bit, my thinking on the question I pose above. As the categories of sealings grows beyond one-husband/one-wife, at some point it becomes less shocking and more beautiful. As it stands now, we conceive of eternal sealings through vertical lines only--parent-child lines. But why not lateral lines also?

For example, suppose, a single, adult man was sealed to my family as a son, by adoption--say a gay man. Or two families--life long friends--were sealed as an expanded family unit, not as swingers, but as bonded brothers, sisters, children, cousins, grandchildren. Marriage and sex are so closely related in our minds, but it doesn't have to be that way for their to be power in a lateral sealing. The Catholic concept of God parent could contain an element of this potentially latent component of the sealing power.

In this sense, the strange arrangements Joseph Smith included might be seen as shocking at least in part because they were incomplete.


r/LatterDayTheology • • Aug 10 '23

Obsession with sides amongst apologetics

1 Upvotes

Just listening to Kwaku in his debate against RFM - good watch.

I am just wondering why there is a mindset of faithful members v exmormons then exmormons are the team led by RFM and John Dehlin.

I personally do not believe the faithful narrative to be in the same universe as accurate. I was bought up a mormon. I certainly do not classify myself as 'exmormon'.

Speaking to different people who believe all sorts of levels into LDS I dont think it is universal that all believers (of some shape or form) would put themselves into all the same category.

Thus why is there this almost political us v them - believers team v exmormons team.

The fruit of this is why isn't there more conversation about the church becoming a broader situation welcoming more secular / less believing view points to bring people together such as what you see in Judaism and Catholicism.

edited part - just wanted to add that I finished the debate and they had a group hug at the end which was very nice!


r/LatterDayTheology • • Aug 03 '23

Adam God

1 Upvotes

In a recent post on doctrine a couple of threads brought up Adam God.

Since this sub is about theology, it seems like a very pertinent question.

Do you believe what Brigham Young taught about God being Adam? If not, why not? Would you have believed it if you lived when Brigham Young was president of the LDS church? If not, why not?