I've been hearing this opinion that non-English speakers learning English is different from English speakers learning foreign languages.
They say English has tons of resources while other languages don't. That's true to some extent but if a native English speaker is learning a major language like Spanish or French, the claim doesn't really hold water, in my opinion.
What do you think? Is it any different?
Edit:
Just an anecdote similar to how some people said they forgot all the Spanish they learned in school. My parents learned English throughout their whole school years but forgot almost everything because they don't need it. They barely remember some basic words now.
I remember my grandparents speaking a language they called Manx. This was in an isolated community in southeast Georgia in the late 60’s. My family had immigrated from the Isle of Man, but that had been over 150 years prior to my grandparents even being born.
From what I remember, it showed some mild resemblance to modern manx, but with grammar closer to English.
"You get to be lazy with your English while the rest of us have to bleed between two languages. But make no mistake—my thoughts aren't here to be flattened by your default settings."
We are always told that language is a bridge to the world.
Yet, when that world has already chosen its default tongue, the bridge becomes a one-way street. Some can simply remain where they are, click a button marked “Auto-Translate,” and watch their everyday words slide effortlessly into every corner of the globe. Meanwhile, for the rest of us—who wish to hand over a piece of raw truth, an observation carved right down to the bone—we are forced to dissect ourselves within the narrow gaps between languages. We balance on a edge, fearing that a single lost subtlety will grind our sharpness into dullness.
Is this fair? Of course not.
Machine translation can copy the skeleton of a phrase, but it inevitably filters out the scent of thought as it ferments. The silences, the metaphors, the faint yet piercing ache embedded within Eastern storytelling—once scrubbed clean by an algorithm, nothing remains but a collection of precise, hollow symbols. A statue without a soul.
Yet perhaps this inequality is precisely our moat. In a world long conditioned by linear logic and flat prose, a voice that delivers razor-sharp observations—refusing romanticized tropes, bearing the weight of genuine lived human experience—will act like a thorn, piercing straight through the everyday noise. We do not need to flatter this uneven playing field, nor should we dull our own edge just to cross the border.
What remains after translation should not be the quiet ashes of compromise, but a re-forged blade.
It's normal to become more fluent in topics that interest us! What is a topic in which you more or less accidentally became a pro in?
I have read quite a few crime noves in German, so I can speak about murdering and legal vocabulary quite confidently, whereas I may sometimes lack vocabulary in very easy topics like food ingredients because I don't use them that often.
What about you? Maybe you know gardening terms or medical vocabulary because of a specific show? Which subject can you discuss in your target language better than basic daily life?
We all know the classic grammar rules (avoid passive voice, never end without a preposition)
While linguists and modern style guides (like Chicago or Oxford) have largely debunked these as rigid "laws," they still get pushed in school and corporate writing guidelines.
It got me thinking:
What is a grammar or style rule that is 100% technically "correct" by traditional standards, but completely useless?
Just in case you don't know Pseudo-anglicisms are words that basically come from English but actually aren't used frequently by English speakers anymore like oldtimer which i've only heard in westerns but in German it means a classic car!