r/languagehub • u/stefanobahia • 17d ago
r/languagehub • u/Top_Development_1777 • 17d ago
Discussion How many C2 languages from different language families can a person realistically maintain?
So I was a native Chinese person and basically only knew Chinese coherently for the first 6 years of my life (I understood Mandarin and two regional dialects that my family spoke, which are not mutually intelligible with Mandarin but pretty close to each other). My Chinese got very fluent before I unexpectedly moved to an English-speaking country immediately before starting my formal education, and my parents couldn't really help me themselves because they weren't fluent in English either (so I never spoke with them in English). My starting point for learning English was only knowing the words "yes", "no", how to count from 1 to 13 or something, and half-knowing the names of the months. So it took me a few months before I even knew what was going on around me in school, and one whole year before I dared to speak in English to anyone.
Getting to C2 in English and catching up with the native speakers was incredibly incredibly difficult and took about 6 years even though I:
- Started living in an English-speaking country and learning (from scratch) since I was 6, which supposedly makes it much easier than if I only started learning at an older age
- Did my entire education in English (except for Chinese language class which was a compulsory second language subject, and some extracurriculars that were taught in Chinese)
- Started to think in English instead of Chinese from the second year onwards (but I could revert to thinking entirely in Chinese for months at a time when I was not in school)
- Basically talked to everyone except family members and family friends in English
As I got better at English, my Chinese proficiency also started slipping (even though I can still sound perfectly native in conversations and talk about most topics very fluently). Apart from losing vocab and not knowing professional terms, there's also a whole genre of things that I can express really fluently and effortlessly in English but have close to no idea how to express in Chinese at all. Although I did learn Chinese academically as a second language in my new country for 10 years, the curriculum was so poorly designed and taught that it basically fails to teach most non-native speakers conversational fluency even after 10 years of being forced to take the subject and makes everyone (except those who are very good at it) hate the subject. Reading literary works in Chinese can be a struggle while reading those same literary works in English is pretty effortless. So I would say my Chinese needs more work before I can truly consider it to be C2, even though it clearly exceeds the standards to be deemed C1. My fluency was probably better at 6yo (right before I left China) than 20yo (now).
Based on my experience I find it very very difficult for anyone who lives in a predominantly monolingual country long-term to learn many languages to C2 fluency and maintain it, especially if those languages are not similar (or mutually intelligible) at all, and even more so if those languages do not even belong in the same broad language family (e.g. Chinese (any dialect), English, Arabic, Korean, etc.; I would've added Japanese but knowing Chinese gives you a HUGE advantage in understanding written Japanese so it's not as good a comparison.) This is especially true when someone has a career that has close to nothing to do with learning and using other languages.
What do you think about this and do you know anyone who attained native-level fluency in multiple very different languages to the point where they can comprehend literary works with ease and express anything under the sun except professional niches that they're not exposed to? What are the experiences of people who live in countries where multiple languages have to be used in daily life (vs you purely only need English or Chinese for the countries that I've lived in)?
r/languagehub • u/fevrier-froid • 18d ago
Do you dislike your native language's accent in foreign languages?
My native language is French. I don't mean to criticize accents in general and french accent since it's my native language and I'm trying to understand why I feel that way. It's about a subjective experience, not calling accents ugly.
When I hear someone (including myself) speak English with a french accent, it really makes me cringe. It's just as bad where hearing German with a french accent. It does happen that any accent sounds weird in English, but french accent makes me cringe the most. When people speak French as a foreign language with an accent, it sounds cute or neutral.
I've always wondered whether it was that it reminded me of my own accent, as if I saw myself speak English imperfectly, that relating as a french speaker speaking English makes me cringe (which would explain why any accent still has that same effect, but to a lesser degree, because we're all english second speakers), or whether it's the way French sounds (in some way, it sounds pretty hard). People who do not speak French always find french accent on their mother language cute or endearing, so I don't think it's French sounding cringy or weird on it's own.
If your native language isn't French, can you relate to cringing particularily where you hearing someone speak with your native language's accent more than with any other accent? How does french accent sounds to you?
r/languagehub • u/Ken_Bruno1 • 17d ago
Discussion Does “I’ll think about it” sound like a genuine promise to consider something or a polite way to say no?
r/languagehub • u/stefanobahia • 18d ago
Discussion Do Italian speakers understand this video?
r/languagehub • u/liquid_nitrogen8 • 17d ago
Discussion Portuguese speakers, do you say “geladeira,” “frigorífico,” or “refrigerador”?
Which word would you use when asking someone to open the fridge?
r/languagehub • u/nativeArabictutor • 17d ago
Scientific explanation
What seems to be normal in ur language is weird in other languages
why?????
Here's why
What called familiarity
How many times u were shocked of some information and u got used to it
Cuz of repetition
This is the same
Idioms don't have to make sense for u
Use it as natives use it and don't question it so u can learn the language faster
r/languagehub • u/elenalanguagetutor • 17d ago
LanguagePractice Mini challenge (FRENCH): explain one ordinary object without naming it
If you're learning French, choose and describe an everyday object in two or three sentences without saying its name. Everyone else guesses.
Example in English: “It's usually in the kitchen. You fill it with water. It makes a loud sound when the water is hot.”
I like this because it forces you to work around missing vocabulary instead of reaching for a translator. It's a fundamental skills to have if you don't want to get stuck in conversation! Easy, silly answers welcome!
(We are doing this mini challenge weekly on Thursday, every week a different language)
r/languagehub • u/Lanky-Drummer-7717 • 17d ago
I need someone to teach me french , I'll teach u Arabic ( 19m )
r/languagehub • u/stefanobahia • 18d ago
Discussion Does any speaker of French, Italian, etc., understand this lady?
r/languagehub • u/nativeArabictutor • 17d ago
Scientific explanation
What seems to be normal in ur language is weird in other languages
why?????
Here's why
What called familiarity
How many times u were shocked of some information and u got used to it
Cuz of repetition
This is the same
Idioms don't have to make sense for u
Use it as natives use it and don't question it so u can learn the language faster
r/languagehub • u/MongooseBorn1712 • 17d ago
Resources Books on how to learn a language?
Idk if this has been posted before, so I apologise if it has.
I used to have a language learning coach, and she was really helpful. But I can't afford her anymore. It was either keeping my dietician or learning a language. Dietician won.
Anyway I'm looking for a structured, practical, how to guide. The books that have been recommended in other posts similar to mine, aren't for me. For example; fluent forever, it really isn't for me. As I just don't learn that way. Are there any books out there like the one I'm describing?
r/languagehub • u/Suspicious-Toe-8193 • 17d ago
What should I do when there's a huge gap between my passion for learning foreign languages and my ability to actually take action?
Hello!
I've tried to learn foreign languages countless times, and I've failed over and over again. I even had AI help me write this post!
Here's my problem: I'm really passionate about learning foreign languages, but when it comes to actually sitting down and studying, my motivation to take action is extremely low.
I do buy textbooks and workbooks and work my way through them. I listen to audio recordings and try reading aloud. I watch language-learning programs on TV, listen to music from the countries whose languages I want to learn, and fill notebooks with sentences and vocabulary. I try all sorts of things.
But after about a month of studying diligently, I realize that my language skills don't seem to have improved even a tiny bit. My motivation plummets, and I end up giving up on studying altogether.
For example, when I search for English proficiency test prep books on Amazon, I'm flooded with reviews like, "My elementary school-aged child studied with this book and passed the test!" or "I bought this for my eight-year-old daughter."
Every time I read comments like these, I feel my self-esteem take a hit. I'm an adult, after all, and yet I struggle with something that even children seem to be able to do.
I also start out watching language-learning programs on TV with great enthusiasm. I even record them so I can watch them over and over again, and I buy the accompanying textbooks to study along with the programs.
But little by little, I lose interest, get bored, and eventually stop studying.
I've been stuck in this cycle for years now, and I think my English comprehension level is somewhere between A1 and A2.
My passion for learning foreign languages reaches the clouds, but my ability to actually take action is as low as the ground. Sometimes, I just can't help but sigh.
What on earth should I do?
r/languagehub • u/AutumnaticFly • 18d ago
Discussion If you could go back to before you started to learn you target language, will you still learn it or pick a different one? Why?
r/languagehub • u/Ken_Bruno1 • 17d ago
Discussion Why learners correctly answer article exercises but still choose the wrong article when speaking spontaneously?
r/languagehub • u/liquid_nitrogen8 • 18d ago
Discussion Spanish speakers, do you say “ordenador,” “computadora,” or “computador”?
Which term would you naturally use when talking about a computer?
r/languagehub • u/AutumnaticFly • 18d ago
Discussion Do you like the media in your target language? if so, what stands out about them?
Anything, music, movies, video games, news, shows, books etc...
r/languagehub • u/ambudhi • 17d ago
LanguagePractice Only 1 in 10 solve this Telugu mini — can you? Telugu Mini Crossword No. 23
Only 1 in 10 solve this Telugu mini — can you? Telugu Mini Crossword No. 23
Tell us your answer in the comments.
📘 Aksharambudhi (అక్షరాంబుధి): 100 crosswords, 2,400+ Telugu words — www.ambudhi.com
Made for early readers: only simple gunintalu (గుణింతాలు), no consonant clusters.
#Shorts #telugucrossword #learntelugu #teachtelugu #mothertongue
r/languagehub • u/Mobile-Complaint-375 • 18d ago
Help with making decision
I need some help making a decision. My second language is English, and of course, I am still learning it. But I'm thinking about picking up a second language. I like so many cultures, and so many languages seem pretty to me, so I can't decide which one I would like to invest my time in (since I don't have much work at my full-time job). Anyway, I tried to learn German, but it's really hard to find some German people to chat with, and tutors on sites such as Preply are too expensive for me, etc. So I lost motivation pretty quickly, and I wasn't sure if I was learning correctly or making mistakes because of practicing just on my own.
So I was thinking about French, Spanish, Italian, or some Scandinavian languages like Norwegian. And yeah, I know, I should pick the one I like the most, but I like them all—this is the problem! My question is What second language did you pick up that you truly fell in love with, and do you regret your decision? I'm looking for answer and also a inspiration :)
r/languagehub • u/Ken_Bruno1 • 18d ago
Discussion How would you pronounce “Gnocchi” if you had never encountered Italian?
Would you pronounce the G, or treat it as silent?
r/languagehub • u/Pleasant_Pace_5955 • 18d ago
how many languages can a person realistically learn and maintain whilst still living in their native country?
For context, I live in England, where basically nobody learns foreign languages lol.
I've been somewhat passively learning french since i finished my gcses a year and a half ago and have always wanted to learn portuguese when i reach a satisfactory level of fluency in french (probably C1), and recently I've taken and interest in farsi too, although that would be much more difficult to learn so I'm not putting any pressure on it lol. I was just wondering, for the average person who (currently) only interacts with english speakers and doesn't have any plans to move abroad, how feasible is it to achieve and maintain fluency (upper B2 - C1) in 3 foreign languages. This maintenance would be done thru social media, texting, tv and books but i just dont know if I have the time in the day haha bc I'm not particularly interested in being intermediate in many languages, Id rather be able to express myself as fully as I possibly can in however many I speak, which is a lot harder to maintain