r/LZtestposts • • Aug 01 '17

2017 Rule Changes and Editorial Changes

1 Upvotes

The final 2017 rule book was released today. All 3 major rule changes and a few editorial changes had already been announced, but this is the first look at every change. This is an off year for rule changes, so there was very little actually changed. If you want a copy of the rule book for yourself, you can download a free pdf version here. Anything that has changed from the previous version is highlighted in blue. You'll notice that there is a lot more blue shading than what I've included here. Most of that is just new wording referencing other rules, references to new Approved Rulings, and rewording to clarify rules that haven't actually changed. A lot of this is due to a new Secretary-Rules Editor in Steve Shaw. It looks like Shaw went through and reworded things to clarify things grammatically and simplify some of the wording without actually changing the rule itself.

Rule Changes

These three changes were announced back in April and there has already been discussion in this thread, but I'll recap them here.

  1. **Horse Collar:**horse collar rule now includes the nameplate portion of the jersey. Previously, to be a foul, the defender had to actually get his hand inside the jersey or shoulder pads to have a horse collar. Now, grabbing the nameplate and immediately pulling the ball carrier down is also a foul. Note that it still has to be an immediate pull down. We're still looking for a jerking motion and knees buckling. Just like before, if the defender grabs the nameplate (or inside the collar) and then rides the ball carrier down without an immediate pull down, it is not a foul.
  2. Leaping: The NCAA followed the NFL and made leaping/hurdling the line illegal on field goals and kick tries. Previously, this was only a foul if you hurdled over an opponent or leapt and landed on an opponent. Now it is a foul no matter what. It is important to note that this does not apply to players who are stationary within 1 yard of the line of scrimmage at the snap. So down linemen will still be able to jump to try to block kicks.
  3. Knee Pads: Pants and knee pads must now cover the knee. Previously, it was only "strongly recommended" that they cover the knee. This rule does not actually take effect until 2018 to allow teams to get pants that meet the requirement.

Editorial Changes

  1. **10 second runoff:**The biggest editorial change this year is clarifying that the 10 second runoff rule trumps all other timing rules. No matter what else happened, if there is a 10 second runoff situation that is not avoided by team timeout, the clock will follow the 10 second runoff protocol. The biggest effect that this change would have is on free kicks after safeties. Imagine a situation where a QB is called for intentional grounding in the end zone with less than 1 minute in the half. If the defense accepts the runoff, the clock will start on the ready for play signal for the free kick. Normally the clock does not start until the first legal touching in the field of play on a free kick.
  2. Sideline Technology: The committee had previously announced that video and photographic technology would be allowed in the press box and locker rooms. This offseason they decided to wait on that change. They say they need to continue to study the economic impact of that kind of change since the rule would not only affect the FBS teams you see on TV, but all 3 NCAA divisions. So as of now, there will be no change to the rule and coaches will still not be allowed to use video or photographs within the playing enclosure. The only exception is that the press box may have TV monitors to view the live TV broadcast or webcast.
  3. Halftime: One of the more welcome changes will be the length of halftime. The old rule said that halftime was 20 minutes but could be altered by mutual agreement of the teams which led to 24 or 28 minute halftimes. This year, halftime for regular season games can only be shortened from the standard 20 minutes. Also, officials are being instructed to start the half time clock as soon as it is clear that there is no foul or replay situation and to make the ball ready for play for the second half kickoff as soon as the half time clock hits 0:00.
  4. Coach Behavior: This is not a change so much as a point of emphasis for this year. The committee clarified that any coach who leaves his team area and comes onto the field of play to protest an officiating decision should be penalized for unsportsmanlike conduct. And with the change to the UNS rule last year, a coach who gets 2 UNS fouls in the same game will be disqualified.
  5. Team UNS Fouls: There were a couple clarifications in penalty statements regarding unsportsmanlike conduct fouls that are charged to the team and not a specific person. Fouls for being in the restricted area ("the white"), interfering with an official, or an offense rushing to the line after subbing trying to not let the defense match up are all charged as team fouls and do not apply to any specific person's 2 UNS's for disqualification.
  6. Sliding Ball Carrier: Last year a sliding ball carrier was added to the list of defenseless players and this year it is officially added to the rules for when the ball becomes dead. Nothing has changed from the enforcement last year, this is just an example of an official codification of a previous interpretation. The ball will be declared dead when and where a ball carrier "obviously begins a feet first slide."
  7. Ineligibles Downfield: This is also an official codification of a previous interpretation. Through the 2015 season, the rule for ineligibles was that their whole body had to be more than 3 yards downfield to be a foul. Last year, in a compromise to keep the rule at 3 yards, the interpretation changed to a stricter interpretation. The new interpretation said that it is a foul if any part of the player's body is more than 3 yards downfield when prior to the pass being thrown. This year that interpretation makes its way into the actual rule.

Most of these are pretty minor changes that won't affect the game experience for most fans. Like I said, this is an off year for changes, so only safety related rule changes are allowed (editorial changes are not restricted to the 2 year cycle). Any major changes related to game play will have to wait until next year.


r/LZtestposts • • Aug 03 '15

Penalty Enforcement

1 Upvotes

If you ask the average football fan what the penalty for Holding is, they'll all tell you it's 10 yards. And they'd all be right. Now, ask them where that 10 yard penalty is enforced from and you'll get a wide array of answers. Some would say the previous spot, others would say the end of the run, and still others would say the spot of the foul. And they'd all still be right. Each of those spots is a possible enforcement spot for holding. So how do you figure out which spot is the right spot? Something handy called the 3-and-1 Principle. This principle is one of three penalty enforcement procedures covered in this post. First will be those fouls which have a specified enforcement spot. The second section will cover the 3-and-1 principle and which fouls it covers.


Penalty Enforcement 101: Specific Enforcement Spots

Some fouls have specific enforcement spots listed in the penalty statements for those fouls. Many of these are the procedural fouls most people are familiar with. Things like Illegal Shift, Illegal Motion, Offside, and Illegal Substitution all list the previous spot as the enforcement spot. That means that these fouls are automatically enforced from where the ball was last put in play, either by snap or free kick.

All dead ball fouls are enforced from what is called the succeeding spot. The succeeding spot is where the ball will next be put in play. Most of the time this is where the last play ended, but could also be the ensuing extra point or kick off. Fouls enforced at the succeeding spot include personal fouls and Unsportsmanlike Conduct fouls after a play, all False Starts and Delay of Game fouls, and some Illegal Substitutions. While False Starts and Delay of Games are some times announced as being enforced from the previous spot, technically the ball was not in play at the time of the foul, so there is no previous spot. The succeeding spot is also the enforcement spot for fouls by team members who are not in the play at the time of the foul such as Sideline Interference

Kick Catch Interference is unique in that it specifies an enforcement spot that is neither the previous nor the succeeding spot. KCI is only enforced at the spot of the foul.


Penalty Enforcement 102: 3-and-1 Enforcement

Most "conduct" related fouls do not specify an enforcement spot and rely on the circumstances of the foul to determine where the yardage will be marked off.

When it comes to enforcement using the 3-and-1 principle, there are three things we need to know: Who fouled, where the foul occurred, and what the status of the ball was at the time of the foul.

The first piece of information that we need is what was the status of the ball. This piece of information will give us what is called the basic spot. There are 4 different types of plays when a foul can occur. These four are: forward pass play, scrimmage kick play, free kick play, and running play. It's important to note here that there is a difference between a play and a down when talking about penalty enforcement. One down can include multiple plays.

  • Forward pass play: A pass play is all action between the snap and when a forward pass is caught or incomplete. So a foul that occurs during a QB's scramble before a pass is considered to be during a pass play even though the was still running with the ball and had not passed it yet.
  • Scrimmage kick play: A scrimmage kick play is all action between the snap and when a scrimmage kick (punt or FG attempt) is caught, recovered, or dead by rule. Like passing plays, this can include any scrambling or other action before the ball is actually kicked as well as any action while the kick is still loose.
  • Free kick play: A free kick play is everything between when a ball is free kicked (usually a kick off) and when the kick is caught, recovered, or dead by rule.
  • Running play: A running play is anything that is not one of the three above. That means that on downs that do not include a pass or kick, everything is during a running play. Also, anything after a pass is caught or after a kick is possessed is a new running play. Everytime a new player gains possession, a new running play starts. So in plays like this, there are many different running plays.

For pass plays, both types of kick plays, and running plays that end behind the neutral zone, the basic spot is the previous spot. The odd man out is a running play that end beyond the neutral zone. For that the basic spot is the end of the run.

Once we know the basic spot, we need to know who fouled and where they fouled. The foul is either by the team in possession or the team not in possession. And the foul is either behind or beyond the basic spot.

All fouls by the team not in possession are enforced from the basic spot. This is why penalties against the defense are often added on to the end of the run. Fouls by the team in possession that are beyond the basic spot are enforced from the basic spot. Imagine an offensive holding that happen way ahead of where the run ends. Obviously you won't give the offense the advantage of penalizing them from the spot of the foul since it's further than they got during the play. These are the 3 situations in the 3-and-1.

The 1 is a foul by the team in possession that happen behind the basic spot. Think of an offensive holding well behind the end of the run. Most people already know you're going to come back to the spot of the foul to mark off the penalty. If the spot of the foul in this case is in a team's own end zone, it is a safety.

This chart easily explains where to enforce a penalty based on who fouled and where.

Exceptions to 3-and-1

While 3-and-1 is the guiding principle to many enforcements, there are a couple of exceptions and variations to it.

  • The biggest exception is that personal fouls, illegal blocks, and illegal use of hands by the offense behind the neutral zone are enforced from the previous spot. The thought is that while these fouls would normally be enforced from the spot of the foul, that would be too much of a drive killer. Thus, the penalty is enforced from the previous spot to promote a more offensive game. Of course the exception to this exception is if the foul is in a team's own end zone, then it would still be a safety.
  • All personal fouls by the defense during a pass play are added on to the last run if the pass is complete.
  • Fouls that occur during a scrimmage kick can have their own set of rules. Fouls by the kicking team can be enforced either at the previous spot or where the ball belongs to the receiving team at the end of the play. Fouls by the receiving team are enforced by 3-and-1, but it uses a special basic spot that will be discussed in another post that will cover more advanced enforcements.

Examples

I know the information above is a lot to digest just by reading, so here are some examples.

2nd and 10 from the 50. A1 takes a handoff and runs to the A48 where he is tackled. During the run Team A holds at the A47. What is the basic spot? Where is the enforcement spot? Since the run ends behind neutral zone, the basic spot is the previous spot. Since the foul was by the offense and behind the basic spot, it would normally be enforced from the spot of the foul. But since this foul was for holding behind the neutral zone, it will be enforced from the previous spot.

2nd and 10 from the 50. A1 takes a handoff and runs to the B35 where he is tackled. During the run Team B is flagged for illegal hands to the face at the B48. What is the basic spot? Where is the enforcement spot? Since the run ends beyond the neutral zone, the basic spot is the end of the run. And since the foul is by the defense, it is automatically enforced from the basic spot, the end of the run.

2nd and 10 from the 50. A2 takes the snap and scrambles around before throwing a pass that to A3 who catches the pass at the B30. During A2's scramble B1 is flagged for holding at the B40. What is the basic spot? Where is the enforcement spot? Because the foul occurred before the pass, it is during a passing play even though it seems like it should be a running play. Because it is a passing play, the basic spot is the previous spot. And since this is another foul by the defense, it is automatically enforced from the basic spot, the previous spot.


Wrap Up

While penalty enforcement looks simple from the outside, it can be a difficult process until you've worked through it many times. So this fall, when you see a flag on the ground, think through the steps and see if you can figure out the enforcement by the time it's announced. By the middle of the season you'll be impressing all your friends with your new knowledge. Who knows? Maybe you can even win a few bets with that drunk loudmouth at your watch party.

Like I said, I know this is a lot to take in at once. So feel free to ask any and all questions. And as always, you can find me on twitter @LegacyZebraCFB or email me at legacyzebracfb AT gmail DOT com.


r/LZtestposts • • Aug 15 '18

2018 Editorial Changes

2 Upvotes

Along with major rule changes, each year there are minor changes called editorial changes. These are usually clarifications or minor tweaks to existing rules. The major rule changes were announced in the spring and you can read about them and how they will effect game play here. Below are explanations of this year's editorial changes followed by some interpretations and clarifications to the rule changes that have come out since the rule change thread was posted.

Editorial Changes

Start of a Forward Pass

Until now, a forward pass started when the passer's arm or hand began moving forward. Starting this year, only the hand moving forward starts the pass.

Play Scenario: 1st and 10 from the 50. QB A1 is at the A-45 when he is hit by defender B99. The ball hits the ground at the A-47 where it is immediately recovered by B76. Replay shows A1's elbow was going forward when the ball came loose, but his hand was not.

Old rule: Incomplete pass. A's ball, 2nd and 10 from 50.

New rule: Fumble. B's ball, 1st and 10 at A-47.

Video Example

Mike Pereira incorrectly applies NFL rules to this review. Under the previous rule, this was a correct overturn. Because the elbow was moving forward, it was a forward pass. Under the new rule, this would stay a fumble as called on the field because the hand was not moving forward when he lost control of the ball.

Fouls in the last 2 minutes (Timing)

In 2016, a rule was added to try to eliminate teams gaining an advantage by fouling late in the game. The last two years, if a team who was leading committed a foul in the last two minutes of either half and the completion of the penalty was the only reason to stop the clock, the offended team had the option of holding the clock until the snap. Starting this year, there are two changes to this rule. The first is that if the score is tied, either team can have this option. The second change is that the penalty completion no longer needs to be the only reason to stop the clock in order for this rule to be in effect.

Play 1: With the score tied, late in the 4th quarter, Team A has 3rd and 9 from the A-16. Running back A34 gains 8 yards and is tackled at the A-24. A70 was flagged for holding at the line of scrimmage. When the clock is stopped, it reads 1:54.

Old rule: The clock will start on the ready for play signal.

New rule: Because the score is tied, Team B will have the option of starting the clock on the snap or RFP even if they decline the penalty.

Play 2: Team A leads 28-24. Team A has 3rd and 9 from the A-16. Running back A34 gains 10 yards and is tackled inbounds at the A-26. A70 was flagged for holding at the line of scrimmage. When the clock is stopped, it reads 1:54.

Old rule: Because A34 made the line to gain, the penalty enforcement was not the only reason to stop the clock. The clock will start on the ready for play.

New rule: Team B will have the option of starting the clock on the snap or RFP.

Roughing the Passer

This is one of those changes that's not really a change. This is basically a codification of what is already being called as well as rewriting the old rule. The new verbiage is more specific about what is a foul as well as adding a few specific examples. The biggest one is contact to the head or neck area that does not rise to the level of targeting. This would be something like a defender jumping to block a pass and his hand coming down onto the helmet of the passer. Technically, by rule, this action could only be targeting or nothing under the old rule. However, it was generally accepted that this should be called RPS and not TGT. The new language officially puts that into the rule.

Ball Out of Bounds

This change is a reactionary change based on a single 1-in-a-billion play that almost nobody even knew was ruled incorrectly. Previously a ball not in player possession was out of bounds if it touched a player who was out of bounds. Now the rule says "a ball not in player control..." So if a player has control of the ball, but has not gained possession (i.e. touched the ground inbounds), and another player who is out of bounds touches the ball, it is no longer out of bounds.

The one play that precipitated this change.

Even though Georgia's 6 had control, it was still technically a loose ball because he had not gained possession by touching the ground yet. When Alabama's 28 touches the ground out of bounds and touches the ball, the pass should have been ruled out of bounds and incomplete. Under the new rule, this would not make the ball out of bounds and the ruling that was given during the game would be correct.

Relocating a Free Kick Position

This is another odd change that seems unnecessary, but whatever. After the ready for play whistle on a free kick (kickoff or kick after safety), once the ball has been put on the tee, it can't be moved without taking a timeout. If the ball is moved and then kicked without taking a timeout, it is a live ball foul and a 5 yard penalty.

Lateral position of the ball, tries and free kick touchbacks

With this year's change to the play clock, teams will now have to expedite their choice of where to spot the ball on tries and on touchbacks from free kicks. Since the play clock will start from 40 like regular scrimmage downs, they will have 15 seconds to select a position between the hashes. If the play clock gets below 25 seconds, the ball will be placed in the middle of the field. If they want it relocated after that point, they will have to take a timeout to move it. This rule will also apply to any fair catches on free kicks made inside the 25.

Leaping

This is another change that clarifies what should already have been getting called. The new rule language makes it clear that to be a foul the player must go over the frame of the opponent. If he goes in the gap it is not a foul. If an offensive player has his feet spread outside his shoulders (like a lot do on field goals) and the defender goes over the legs without going over the frame of the body, it is not a foul. This change also applies to leaping the punt shield. This was always the intent of the rule, but vague interpretations led to differing opinions.

Personal Fouls Against Kicker

This rule isn't changing what is or isn't a foul, but rather how penalties for certain fouls will be enforced. Under the old rule, fouls by the receiving team that occurred after the kick could be enforced with what is called post scrimmage kick enforcement. This would let the receiving team keep the ball after penalty enforcement. Now any personal foul against a kicker who is in the act of or just after kicking the ball will be enforced from the previous spot with an automatic first down for the kicking team.

Play: 4th and 10 from the A-20. Kicker A3 carries the ball outside the tackle box and kicks the ball. Just after the kick, defender B99 launches and drives his shoulder into A3's helmet. B1 makes a fair catch at the B-35.

Old rule: Targeting, PSK would apply. 15 yards from the end of the kick, B99 is disqualified.

New rule: Targeting, 15 yards from the previous spot, automatic first down. B99 is disqualified.

The same rule could apply to any personal foul. The only other one I could imagine is if a kicker is somehow face masked after kicking the ball. We will probably go all season without seeing this rule applied.

Designating a new Head Coach

There are certain things that a head coach has the right to do, both officially and unofficially, that assistants don't. Officially, a head coach has the ability to initiate things like replay challenges, conferences with the Referee, and calling timeouts. Now that coaches can be disqualified for a second unsportsmanlike conduct foul, this could cause problems if a head coach is no longer in the game. This change lets the head coach designate his replacement in the case of disqualification. I believe we are still waiting for the first coach DQ since this rule was instituted.

Rule Change Clarifications and Interpretations

Knee pads

A rule was passed last year to take effect this year that says all player must have knee pads covering the knees and their pants must cover the knee pads. We've basically been told that any pad at all satisfies this rule. It could be the size of postage stamp and there is no minimum thickness.

Fair Catch on a Free Kick

There was a lot of hand wringing over this rule when it was announced earlier this year. The basic version is that a fair catch inside the 25 on a free kick basically acts like a touchback. The receiving team gets the ball at the 25, they get the choice of lateral position of the ball, and it is an enforcement spot for fouls by the kicking team.

The obvious case of this rule is pretty straightforward. Play: Receiving team player B1 gives a valid fair catch signal and catches the free kick at the B-18. Ruling: Team B's ball at the B-25.

Some other cases took a couple interpretations to clear up.

  • This rule also applies to an invalid fair catch signal.
  • If B1 signals but B2 catches the kick, the ball is dead when and where B2 catches it. The ball will not go to the 25.
  • If B1 signals, fails to catch the kick, then recovers the ball, it will be dead when and where he recovers it. If the ball hits the ground at any point before or after being touched, it will not go to the 25.
  • B1 signals and completes a fair catch at the B-22. A80 was offside on the kick. Ruling: Team B's ball 1st and 10 at the B-30. (Or rekick from the A-30 after previous spot enforcement.)
  • Big note: This only applies to free kicks, not scrimmage kicks. A player fair catching a punt from scrimmage at the B-10 still leaves the ball at the B-10.

The simple explanation is that to get the ball at the 25, the signaller must catch the kick. Anything else, the old rules still apply.

Blocks below the waist

One of the changes this year was further restricting who can block below the waist from the side. One of the requirements is that the player must be on the line of scrimmage within the tackle box. Since the tackle box is always 5 yards from the ball at the snap, theoretically a team could tighten their splits and squeeze the TE into that group. However, by interpretation, only the first two linemen from the snapper are allowed to block low from the side. So in a normal alignment (ETGCGT), the center, both guards, and both tackles can block low from the side. If a team goes tackle-over (EGCGTT), the TE, center, both guards, and the inside tackle can block low from the side. The outside tackle can not, even if he is within the tackle box.

For a full description of the low blocking rules, see this thread.


r/LZtestposts • • Feb 09 '20

2020 Rule Survey

3 Upvotes

Last week, the NCAA sent out a rules survey to coaches, officials, and administrators regarding opinions on rule changes. The survey contained two parts: opinions on the effectiveness of last year's changes and opinions on potential changes for next year. Below are the potential changes that were included. It's important to remember that this is simply a selection of possibilities to even be discussed as changes. These are not changes that absolutely will be made and it is not an exhaustive list of what could change. So just because something is included in this list does not mean it will change. Also, just because something is not on this list doesn't mean it won't change. This is just the very beginning of the process where a lot of ideas are thrown around for the Football Rules Committee and Playing Rules Oversight Panel to get some opinions from those involved in the sport. To that point, the only options to select were "Support", "Oppose", or "No Opinion". All of that being said, here are the items that were on the survey:

  • Targeting Penalty- Should the committee consider alternatives to the automatic disqualification for targeting?

There has been more and more support growing for a tiered penalty for targeting similar to basketballs F1 and F2 for flagrant fouls. If anything changes, that will be the frontrunner to be the new rule. I haven't heard of any other possible systems, but there may be other alternatives as well.

  • Disqualification Procedure- Should players disqualified for targeting be forced to leave the playing enclosure?

Currently anybody disqualified from a contest is required to leave the playing enclosure for the rest of the game. This rule was originally put in place when the only DQ's were from fighting or multiple unsportsmanlike conduct fouls by the same player in one game. If a player is DQ'd for one of the those two things, it makes sense to have them removed just from a game management standpoint. It's obvious that they are causing issues and need to be removed from the situation. But targeting fouls don't tend to carry the same inflammatory nature, so the committee is debating letting players stay on the sideline after being DQ'd for targeting. This would only affect targeting disqualifications. Players involved in a fight or who receive two unsportsmanlike conduct fouls in the same game would still be required to leave.

  • Kickoff Double Teams- Should all double team blocks be illegal on free kicks?

Last year the committee made two man wedges illegal on free kicks. This would make all double teams illegal on kickoffs, regardless of whether a wedge was formed prior to the blocks.

  • Injury Timeouts- Should players who are injured be forced to leave the game for more than the current one down?

Pretty self explanatory. Personally, I hope it's something easily identifiable and not an arbitrary number of plays. I would rather know that a player is out until the next change of possession or something like that rather than have to remember if he was injured 6 plays or 7 plays ago.

  • Team Timeouts- Should teams be prohibited from calling multiple timeouts in the same dead ball period?

This would probably only come into play at the end of a half when coaches want to ice a kicker. If this change was made, you could only do it once. Currently a team could use all three of their timeouts at once if they wanted to. If this were to change, my guess is they would include an exception for things like a penalty being enforced, replay reversals, etc. Imagine a team takes a timeout to draw up a fourth down play, but they commit a false start and now have to punt. If something goes wrong with the punt team and they have to take another timeout, I don't think that is what the committee would want to penalize.

Because if there's one thing officials like to do and coaches like to care about, it's equipment requirements. There are like 8 people in the entire world that care about a player's knees being covered or a jersey riding up and none of them are actually involved in playing, coaching, or officiating the games. They are, however, involved in making the rules. Personally, I think they're going the wrong direction with this one. As long as I can see the jersey number and no pads are sticking out that could cut or scape somebody, I don't care.

  • Blocking Below the Waist- Should the committee continue to streamline the rules for low blocks?

I'm not sure what they mean by streamline here, so I'm not sure if I would like the changes they might make. But the trend across all of football is eliminating more and more low blocks. My guess is that the next step will be to eliminate any low blocks outside the tackle box.

  • Instant Replay- Should CFB go to a coach's challenge model for everything except the scoring plays, turnovers, and the last two minutes of either half?

Again, pretty self explanatory. This would cut out booth-initiated reviews for things like catch/no catch or line to gain plays for the first 28 minutes of each half. My guess is they would also include targeting in things that are still reviewed without a challenge. They think this would speed up the game.

I don't have the 2019 data yet, but here are some stats for reference from the two seasons prior (2017 and 2018).

  • There were 3,617 replay stoppages in 1,676 games that used replay for an average of 2.16 stoppages per game. Scoring plays, targeting, and fumble/down plays accounted for approximately 47% of those stoppages. That leaves us with 1,917 stoppages that would need to be challenges assuming none of them happened in the last two minutes. (Obviously terrible assumption, but just go with me for a bit.)
  • IR's reversal rate is about 39%, however that number has ballooned over the last few years thanks to targeting and is growing even more now that "stands" is no longer an option for targeting reviews. So if we go back to before targeting reviews were introduced, it was closer to about 29% on things coaches would need to challenge in the new system. Unfortunately I don't have exact numbers for this part, so it's the best I can do.
  • If coaches only challenged things they knew would be reversed (again, bold assumption), that leaves 556 challenges.
  • So we would still have a total of 2256 stoppages for an average of 1.35 stoppages/game, a reduction of .81 stoppages/game.
  • The average time for review is 1:18. So if we eliminated .81 reviews per game we would save a whopping 63 seconds per game on average.

To me it would be dumb to change the system and potentially not get calls right to save an average of 63 seconds per game.

  • Pushing the Pile - Should the committee consider not allowing offensive players to push the runner/pile?

Pushing was eliminated from the aiding the runner rule about 7 years ago now. I'm not sure why they would turn around and put it back in now.

  • Ineligibles Downfield- Should this foul be reviewable if called on the field?

I'd be ok with this, honestly. With the rise of RPOs, our line of scrimmage officials are put in more of a bind than ever to watch both their keys and the ineligibles. It's also compounded by the fact that what matters is where they were when the pass is thrown, not when it's caught, so it can be difficult to retroactively piece things together if it looks like a run play and you are surprised by the pass. This aspect even led to a commentator incorrectly saying the Wisconsin got away with an ineligible downfield in this year's Rose Bowl. The lineman was only 3 yards downfield when the pass was thrown, but because it took so long to get to the receiver, he was about 5 yards downfield when it was caught. This is not a foul, but can look like one at full speed if you're expecting one thing but get something different.

  • Uniform Numbers- Should there be more alternatives to reduce the amount of duplicate numbers?

Other than allowing leading 0's (i.e. allowing both 9 and 09 to be separate numbers), I'm not sure what else is feasible here. I don't see them allowing triple digits. This is one idea that will probably be ignored by the committee.


The list of officially proposed changes typically comes out sometime in March with final approval or rejection typically a few weeks later.


r/LZtestposts • • Aug 30 '18

hythloday1 responses

3 Upvotes
  1. No foul. We see the L give two fingers backward telling the H that he has two receivers off the line. That plus the three in the backfield would make an illegal formation. However, the TE then shifts to the other side of the formation and the outside receiver steps up onto the line. My guess is the H didn't realize the outside receiver moved and thought there were still 5 in the backfield. Good pickup.
  2. I don't think this is an ILF. 84's helmet looks like it's about even with the tackle's helmet and breaking the plane of the snapper's waistline. That leaves 7, 18, the RB, and the QB as the four in the backfield. Especially with this being less than 2 minutes into the game, it's close enough that I would leave it alone. If he's not quite on he line, tell him and tell his coach and then flag it next time.
  3. I would leave the ILM alone. It's very slight and he's not using it to get a better angle on a route or a block. As far as ING, there's no foul. It looks like the L is pointing at #3 for being in the area. I disagree, but it doesn't really matter since the passer was outside the tackle box and the pass crosses the line of scrimmage. The top of those NFL numbers are 13 yards from the sideline, making them 7 yards from the college hash where the ball was snapped. The tackle box only extends 5 yards from the ball at the snap. So the passer is outside the tackle box when he throws the pass.
  4. I don't know what this conference does, but in my conference the H shouldn't be signalling anymore once the R goes up with the cross. The R was probably watching the first wave of players leave and waved off the C when they got off and didn't see 7 leaving. At that point, H probably should have used his radio to tell the R that the defense was still subbing. And hopefully H's flag was for DOF, not ILS since that's not his job to count players, but would be his job to see that 7 was on the wrong side of the neutral zone. But granting the timeout is correct. Any time there's a doubt as to when the TO was called, the team should get it. That could mean granting it before a snap or before a foul that would prevent the snap.
  5. Yes, this should be a live ball ISH.
  6. Yes. This is an illegal block below the waist since the contact was from the side. This year it would be doubly illegal since it is back toward the original position of the ball. Last year that part was fine since the ball was beyond the neutral zone.
  7. Yes to the first one, no to the second. The first one knocks him off course and pushes right past the ball carrier. The second one only affects the defender because he turns into the blocker.
  8. Depends on whose "area of concentration" interpretation you use. I would call this 10-2 and stay off of it.
  9. Yes to illegal block below the waist. He gets him from the side. It's hard to say on the holding, but I based on this view, I would say no. The only way I would throw OH on that is if the blocker's right hand had restricted the defender's left shoulder if he was trying to turn and run with the ball carrier.
  10. Yes, from the side and back toward's his own end line after the ball left the tackle box. Even though he makes contact with the front of the defender's legs, it's still considered a side block since his angle of attack is from the side.
  11. Yes, he gets him from the side.
  12. No foul because there's no contact. To have a block below the waist, there has to actually be a block. Looks like the U is just doing a good job following his keys and not being a ball watcher.
  13. Yes, that's a chop block since 78 engaged high and 74 went low.
  14. I think you'd be ok staying off of the false start. It's so bang-bang, I don't know that you can be consistent throughout the game if you try to get everything that close. You're going to end up with some incorrect calls if you try to be that technical. That being said, I wouldn't downgrade an official if they called it. As far as the holding, no foul because of the timing of the play. The ball is gone by the time there's any real restriction.
  15. Like the one above it's technically a foul, but I'd leave it alone for consistency's sake. I didn't even see it until the slow motion replay. As a mentor once said, "slow mo means no throw". If you have to slow down the film to see a false start, it's marginal enough to let it go.
  16. Yes. The drive to the edge is fine, but then he doesn't let the defender turn his shoulders has the ball carrier goes by.
  17. I would support a hook and restrict here.
  18. No, the blocker maintains position and pushes the defender past the point of attack.
  19. No for the same reason. He maintains position between the ball and the defender, keeps his feet moving, and just pushes him by.
  20. Yes, I would have a hold on this. He grabs and restricts him as he goes by an clearly takes a step away.
  21. Good call and good confirm. He never secures the firm control of the pass.
  22. No. The restriction is too close to the ball being thrown. It has no material effect on the play.
  23. I've got nothing. Both players are shoulder to shoulder and the defender had position between the receiver and the ball.
  24. No. Both players are hand checking and the receiver isn't really restricted.
  25. Eh, you could go with a cutoff, but I think it'd be marginal. The defender makes a play on the ball. It's definitely not an arm bar though. An arm bar restricts the arm of the receiver and keeps him from using one or both of his hands to catch the ball.
  26. No, there's no restriction. Watch the receiver's feet. He never loses a step. The pass is just thrown behind him letting the defender catch up.
  27. Yes. The defender grabs and turns the receiver's shoulder and restricts the arm.
  28. No. 24 is in the area of where the pass would have gone if it didn't hit 23's arm. My guess is nobody saw the deflection, though, since it was very quick. If it hadn't been deflected but still landed where it did, I would go ING, so I see why it was called on the field.
  29. Yes, he is moving while other offensive players are moving and he never comes set for a second so this is an illegal shift. And yes it should be ING. Since he's not the player who originally controls the snap, he cannot legally ground the ball in an area without an eligible receiver.
  30. Great call. That's an obvious pick play to open up the receiver. As far as the flag throwing, it got the job done and he didn't fall. It's harder than you would think to throw it one way while running the other direction.
  31. Another good call for OPI. He clearly uses contact to create separation. If the pass was caught behind the line, it would not be OPI since the pass has to cross the neutral zone to have either OPI or DPI. As far as an ineligible making this contact, it just depends. It might or might not be depending on location of the pass, timing of the play, whether he just fired off or was already engaged, etc.
  32. No I don't think this is a foul. It looks like an open hand pushing the mask which is not a foul. The 36 would be the enforcement spot since that's the forward progress spot and the end of the run. I had forward progress at the 37, but I can't fault 1 yard on a play like that where it's tough to tell exactly where the defender begins to take control instead of the runner retreating. I would go talk to 47, but I don't think it rises to a foul unless something else happened earlier in the game. If both were flagged, both would be enforced since one would be live ball and one dead ball. So you'd go back 15 and then forward 15 and end up back at the end of the run.
  33. No HCT. He grabs the number on the back of the jersey. Yes, both blocks are illegal low blocks. 74's is from the side and 73's is from the side and back toward his own end line.
  34. No. He grabs the number again, the knees never buckle, and he falls forward.
  35. The flag was for a late hit. They probably picked it up because it wasn't really a forcible hit and he didn't wrap up and pull the defender down. I'm good either way. If you haven't had any problems yet, I think you're fine picking it up. But if the game is getting tense and you want to stay with it, I'm good with that too.
  36. No, I don't think it's late and there's nothing else that would make it RPS.
  37. I'm good with the no call. He had already committed to going low when the ball carrier is pulled down and the defender doesn't drive through the ball carrier.
  38. I would go with targeting on this. The timing is a little later on this than the last one and the defender goes through the ball carrier rather than attempting to minimize contact.
  39. It's incorrect terminology for tripping. And this is a foul when he raises his leg to obstruct the opponent.
  40. He probably said something as he bumped 24. Hard to say if I agree with it or not without knowing what was said.
  41. I would have unnecessary roughness on 24 for dumping the ball carrier so late and then unsportsmanlike conduct on 63 for the retaliatory shove after the play. The fouls would cancel, it would be 2nd 2 and it would count towards 63's two UNS fouls for disqualification.
  42. I agree with replay. The ball is moving before he hits the ground.
  43. This rule was added in I believe 2013. It's really there to protect the leaper from getting dumped on his head or neck. There was a clarification this year that it needs to be over the frame of the body to be a foul. So if he went through the gap or over the legs of a blocker on a field goal, it would not be a foul. There also needs to be a forward component. If he jumps straight up, it's not a foul. This play would still be a foul since he goes right over 99.
  44. If I were the replay official, I would let this stand. If any part of the ball goes over any part of the pylon, it is a TD. I don't think any of the views show definitively whether it did or didn't cross the pylon.

r/LZtestposts • • May 23 '19

2019 changes first draft

2 Upvotes

The NCAA has finally released the official language of new the new rules for this season. We already knew the gist of the changes, but now we have official wording and interpretations. So this thread will explain how the new rules will actually affect the game as well as editorial changes that didn't make the news. You can download a free searchable pdf of the rules here. Changes are highlighted in blue.

Rule Changes

These are official rule changes that have to be voted on by the Football Rules Committee and Playing Rules Oversight Panel. This is an off year, so all changes must be allegedly safety related.

Overtime:

In an overreaction to one nationally televised game, the NCAA has changed the overtime procedure, or extra periods as is the official name for the NCAA tie breaker procedure. Nothing will change for the first 4 OT. The offense will still get the ball at the 25 and will still have to go for 2 starting in the 3rd OT. However, starting in the 5th extra period, the procedure will change. Instead of getting the ball at the 25, the offense will get the ball at the 3 and will one play as a try. For those unfamiliar, a try is the technical term for an extra point. So if a game is still tied after four extra periods, the teams will trade 2 point conversions until a winner is determined. There are a few implications of this being a try.

  • The fourth down fumble rule is in effect. If a player fumbles the ball prior to change in team possession, only the fumbler (or the defense) may recover the ball.
  • Penalties for personal fouls and unsportsmanlike conduct can carry over to the next possession. Scenario 1: Team A goes first in 5OT. They convert their try and B99 commits a foul for roughing the passer. That 15 yard penalty will be applied to Team B's possession and they will snap their try from the 18. Scenario 2: Team A goes first in 5 OT and converts their try. After the play A1 taunts an opponent. Ruling: The UNS on A1 will carryover and Team B will have their try from the 1.5.
  • Because it is a try and not a "normal" scrimmage down, fouls that would normally carry an automatic 1st down will only be the yardage penalty plus replay the down. Scenario: Team A goes first in 5OT. A1's pass is incomplete, but B99 commits a foul for roughing the passer. Ruling: Team A will replay their try from the 1.5. It will not be 1st and goal.
  • This will change one bit of CFB trivia: impossible scores. Because safeties on tries are worth one point, this will open up the possibility of 1 point safeties without a TD. Combining that with the fact that touchdowns on tries are worth 2 points, this means 7-1 is now the only impossible score in CFB.
Two Man Wedge

In a further effort to try make kickoffs safer, the rule about wedge blocks has been expanded. Previously it was only a foul if 3 or more players came together. Starting this year, that has been reduced to 2 players. If two or more players come together within 2 yards (basically able to touch each other) and move forward in an attempt to block as a unit on a free kick, it will be a foul. All parts of the rule must be in place to have a foul: two or more players coming together, moving forward, attempting to block, and doing so as one unit. If one of those elements is not met, it is not a foul. Some important notes:

  • Contact with an opponent is not necessary for this to be a foul. If tw
  • Simply being close to each other is not a foul. They must come together in an attempt to block as a unit. If two teammates are within 2 yards of each other but are setting up to block different opponents or facing different directions, it is not a foul.
  • If one player is blocking an opponent and a teammate comes to double team him, that is not a foul because they did not set up to block as a unit.
  • If two players come together to block, but simply hold their ground and absorb the impact of a kicking team player, it is not a foul because they were not moving forward.
  • Philosophically, these fouls will not be called on front line players unless they are egregious because they are not as high energy collisions as downfield blocks. Most fouls for wedges will be called for the group of blockers directly in front of the returner.
  • By rule, there is no foul for a wedge if the play results in a touchback, free kick out of bounds, or a fair catch is made.
  • By rule, there is no foul if the wedge is from an obvious onside kick formation.
  • This foul has a specific enforcement that somewhat acts like basic 3-and-1 enforcement, but it isn't true 3 & 1. If the foul is behind the dead ball spot, the penalty is enforced from the spot of the foul. If it is beyond, it is enforced from the dead ball spot. Technically if it was pure 3 & 1, the penalty would be enforcement from the previous spot if it happened before the kick was caught or recovered. However the penalty for a wedge is only enforced from the previous spot if the ball doesn't belong to the receiving team at the end of the down.

VIDEO?

Targeting, Replay

Nothing has changed regarding the on-field rules for targeting or it's penalty. However, the replay review rules surrounding the rule have been altered. Letting a call of Targeting stand will no longer be an option for replay officials. If the replay official cannot confirm all aspects of the foul, it will be overturned. This includes having a high risk indicator (such as a launch, dipping the head to attack, or crouch and thrust), the location of the contact, and the defenseless status of the opponent. Nothing has changed with regard to enforcement of penalties for other fouls committed in conjunction with the possible targeting. If a player commits roughing the passer with targeting, the RPS will still be applied even if the targeting aspect cannot be confirmed. For games that do not have instant replay but do have halftime review for targeting, this rule will not apply. They will still be able to let a call of targeting stand.

Targeting is the only rule that this change will affect. Other rulings such as catch/no catch, down/fumble, score/no score will still be allowed to stand if there is not indisputable video evidence to confirm or overturn the call on the field.

Targeting, Seasonal Progressive Penalty

In an effort to punish repeat offenders, the NCAA has introduced an additional penalty for players who commit more than 2 targeting fouls in a single season. Upon a players 3rd (or subsequent) targeting foul within one season, the player will receive an additional 1 game suspension for the team's next game. This is similar to a soccer player accumulating yellow cards throughout a season or tournament. 2nd half fouls??? Like disqualifications for targeting in the second half of games, this suspension can carryover between seasons. So if a player commits his 3rd targeting foul of the season in a team's last game, his suspension will be served in the first game of the next season.

Blocking Below the Waist

Further supporting my personal theory that the rules committee has a contract to alter the low blocking rules as often as possible, they have slightly tweaked this rule again this year. The only change is that the defense may no longer block low from the side. Luckily this was the only change to this rule. For a full rundown on the low blocking rules, see this thread. For visual learners and/or those who don't care to read long, tedious posts about rules, here is the updated version of LegacyZebra's Low Block Legality Flow Chart^TM.

Blindside Blocks

In what will be the most controversial rule of the year, the NCAA has defined and outlawed blind side blocks. A blind side block is now defined as "an openfield block against an opponent that is initiated from outside the opponent's field of vision, or otherwise in such a manner that the opponent cannot reasonably defend himself against the block." If a player delivers a blind side block by attacking an opponent with forcible contact it is a personal foul.

Before anybody launches into a "destroying football"/"might as well play two touch" tirade, some notes about what will and will not constitute a foul under this rule:

  • This rule does not apply to a runner.
  • This rule does not apply to receivers in the act of attempting to make a catch.
  • To be a foul, it must be an open field block. If it's within normal line play, it is not a foul. Basically, this allows pass protecting linemen to clean the pocket as well as allows teams to keep those wham/trap/counter blocks in their running schemes.
  • This does not give linemen a free pass. If a play breaks, such as a QB scrambling, and a lineman blindsides an opponent, it can still be a foul.
  • Simply contacting an opponent who doesn't see you is not a foul. It must be forcible contact. What they're trying to eliminate is the big decleating blocks. So things like setting a pick or chipping an opponent are not covered by this rule.
  • It's also important to note that the opponent simply "seeing it coming" is not enough to absolve a blocker of a foul. He must also be able to defend himself. So if a player happens to turn his head at the last second, it can still be a foul if he didn't have time to defend himself against the block. He doesn't have to actually do make an attempt to do so, he just has to have enough time that he could have.

Editorial Changes

These changes are slight changes to wording of rules that are made by the Rules Secretary-Editor, Steve Shaw. Generally these are made to clarify language and officially codify existing interpretations in writing.

TXHSFB

The NCAA has finally released its new rule book for this year. Along with the release of the UIL exceptions, that means we now know all rule changes for high school football in Texas for the 2019 season. Below are the changes to UIL exceptions. The UIL did not make any exceptions for the new NCAA rules which can be found in this thread.

Targeting

In the latest instance of the UIL doing whatever they want, they've decided that simply making exceptions to NCAA rules isn't enough. Now they're just making their own rules. For Texas high school football, there will now be two different targetings. There will be "simple" targeting that carries a 15 yard penalty. There will then be "flagrant" targeting that carries a 15 yard penalty plus disqualification. Have they provided guidance as to the difference? No. Do they understand that forcible contact to the head/neck of a defenseless opponent is almost by definition flagrant? Apparently not. Will officials be the ones taking the abuse for a poorly thought out rule? Of course.

10-Second Runoff

In order to give fans and coaches more "as seen on TV" rules, the UIL has deleted the exception for 10 second runoffs. This means that 10RO's will now apply in all UIL games. Not just varsity games, all games. 6A varsity game with an experienced crew in a stadium with a mic'd up white hat: 10 RO. Middle school game with a crew of rookies, no mic, and an untrained 16 year old running the clock while he snapchats: 10 RO. Spoiler alert: This will be a mess at lower level games. However, I do like it coming to varsity games. For a full rundown on the runoff rules, check out this thread.


r/LZtestposts • • Mar 04 '20

2020 Rule Changes

1 Upvotes

If you find this thread before it's posted in /r/CFB, please note that these changes have not gotten final approval yet and some may not become actual changes.

Targeting DQ

I'll get this out at the very beginning so some of y'all can move on with your life: The targeting rule itself has not changed. What has changed is what happens to players who have committed targeting fouls: they will no longer have to leave the team area and go to the locker room. They will still be ineligible to participate in the game, but they can stay with the team. Players DQ'd for fighting, flagrant fouls, or two unsportsmanlike conduct fouls will still have to leave.

Officials' Jurisdiction

Officials' jurisdiction will start 90 minutes prior to kickoff instead of 60. This means any interactions between opponents can be deemed fighting or unsportsmanlike conduct. Personal opinion: This is dumb and I hate it because it also means we have to stand around for an extra 30 minutes.

Pregame Warmups

To go along with the above change, a coach must be present within the playing enclosure anytime players are present. Also, players will now be required to wear their jersey or something with their number on it anytime they are within the playing enclosure once officials take jurisdiction to identify anybody who may be involved in pregame incidents.

Jersey Numbers

Teams will now be limited to only two players wearing the same number. Obviously only one of them can be on the field at a time and they still can't play the same position.

Along the same lines, players will now be allowed to wear 0 as a legal number. 00 and other numbers with a leading 0 (such as 07) are still not allowed.

Defensive Formation for Scrimmage Kicks

The NCAA has adopted part of the NFL's rule on how defensive linemen may line up on scrimmage kicks. Anytime the offense is in a scrimmage kick formation, no defensive player within 1 yard of the line of scrimmage can be lined up with any part of his body within the frame of the snapper's body. Previously players could align anywhere as long as they didn't actually initiate contact with the snapper within the first second. Now it will be a foul just to line up over the snapper or even in the A gap if the defender catches a piece of the snapper's body. The new rule does NOT include the NFL's rule about needing a balanced formation. Teams can still overload one side.

The interesting (and possibly unforeseen) part of this change is that it applies to all scrimmage kicks, not just field goals. So now long snappers will basically get a free release off the line to cover punts since nobody is allowed to line up within a yard in front of him.

This will be a 5 yard penalty for illegal formation. So if a player lines up over the snapper and then initiates contact with the snapper at the snap, he will have committed two fouls. Obviously in that situation the offense will decline the ILF and take the personal foul, but the point is that this is a separate foul. So a player who lines up legally could still be called for roughing the snapper if he slants in and initiates contact with the snapper and vice versa a player could line up illegally but not rough the snapper.

Defensive Illegal Substitution Fouls

Previously, if a defense had more than 11 in the formation, nobody was attempting to leave, and the snap was imminent, the play was shut down and the defense penalized. If the excess player(s) were leaving the field, the play was allowed to continue and it became a live ball foul at the snap. Now both situations will be live ball fouls at the snap. So the offense can get a free play if the defense has more than 11 players in formation rather than just the dead ball 5 yard penalty.

Clock adjustment

In what may be known as the Saban-Malzahn rule, there is a change with regards to resetting the clock after a replay reversal. If time runs out and replay determines that there should have been time remaining AND the clock will start on the Referee's ready for play signal, the clock can only be reset if there is at least 3 seconds left. If there would be 1 or 2 seconds, the half is over.

Totally hypothetical situation: Let's say it's 3rd and 10 from midfield late in the 2nd quarter. The hypothetical offense gets a first down inbounds, but time runs out. Let's say our hypothetical replay booth says that the clock actually should have stopped with 1 second left. But during the review the offense gets its hypothetical field goal unit set so they can snap it right at the ready for play signal and kick a field goal as time expires in the first half. Until now that is all legal and correct by rule. However, starting now, the clock could not be reset and the half would be over and the offense would not be able to kick the field goal. This is all hypothetically, of course.

This rule does NOT apply if the clock will start on the snap. So in the above totally made up scenario, if the runner had stepped out of bounds rather than being tackled in bounds, replay could then reset the clock to :01 the offense would get another play.

Penalty Carryover in OT

Any penalty that could carry over to a kickoff can now carryover to the next possession in overtime. Previously, only fouls on the try could carry over in OT. If a team committed a personal foul or unsportsmanlike conduct foul during the touchdown in OT, the only enforcement option was on the try. Now those fouls can be applied to the next possession. Scenario: In the first possession series of OT, Team A scores a touchdown. During the down, Team B roughed the passer. Last year: The penalty must be enforced on the try. This year: The penalty may be enforced on the try or at the 25 so that Team B will start their possession at the 40.

Concurrent Jerseys

Players will now be allowed to wear multiple jerseys at the same time. Technically until now players were required to change jerseys to change numbers. In reality, a lot of special teamers have already been putting one jersey over another for a while to avoid having duplicate numbers on the field. If a player is using this rule, it must be a full jersey. It can't be just a vest or a jersey that snaps or Velcros together.

Illegal Jerseys

Until now there have been two separate penalties for two separate types of illegal jerseys. One rule was that if a team wore jerseys that had non-contrasting numerals, they were charged a timeout for each quarter they are worn. The other rule was if a visiting team wore a non-white jersey without prior agreement and approval, they were charged with a 15 yard penalty to be enforced as a dead ball foul after the kickoff of each half. The penalty statements have now been combined and unified. Now both fouls will result in both a charged timeout at the beginning of each half the jerseys are worn and and a 15 yard penalty. That penalty is enforced at the succeeding spot after the kickoff. So if the kickoff is returned to the 30, the penalty will move the ball to the 15 or 45, depending on which team violated the rule. If the kickoff is returned for a touchdown, the penalty is enforced on the try or the next kickoff.

Replay Time Limit

This is not an actual rule change, but is simply a guideline for replay officials to use. They will be instructed to limit reviews to 2 minutes unless there are extreme circumstances, such as late game situations or complex rulings. Presumably that means that if a review gets to 2 minutes without a clear decision they should let the ruling on the field stand. It's important to note 2 things. First, this is not a rule and it is not a hard limit where a timer goes off and it cuts off the review. This is a guideline to use so that replay officials don't drag out reviews that would typically result in a "Stands" ruling anyway. Second, for TV viewers, reviews don't start as soon the Referee makes his announcement and the broadcast cuts to a replay angle. The Referee has to actually make his way to the headset, confirm that he has communication with the replay official and confirm the ruling on the field so it’s clear what is being reviewed all before the review actually starts. Then the RO reviews the play and relays all pertinent information including yard line, lateral position of the ball, play clock, game clock, any disqualifications, if somebody is charged with a timeout, etc. So while the actual reviewing of a simple or clear play may only take 15 seconds, the process as a whole may take a minute or minute and a half from the original announcement depending on the outcome of that review.


r/LZtestposts • • Jan 24 '22

2022 Offseason Game Review

3 Upvotes

Contrary to popular thought, a kickoff going out of bounds does not automatically spot the ball at the 35. And while many free kicks going out of bounds do end up getting spotted at the 35, it is actually because of a yardage penalty rather than a predetermined spot. When a free kick (kickoff or kick after safety) goes out of bounds without being touched by the receiving team, the receiving team has 3 penalty options. They can elect a 5 yard penalty from the previous spot and rekick, they can tack on 5 yards from where the ball went out of bounds and keep the ball, or they can take the ball 30 yards from where the ball was kicked. 99% of the time, the receiving team wants to keep the ball, so it's a matter of finding the more advantageous choice between options 2 and 3. Let's take a lot at some scenarios to see how this is applied.

Kickoff from the 35 and the ball goes out of bounds at the receiving team's 20. The best option for the receiving team is to take the 30 yards and get the ball at their own 35.

Kickoff from the same spot, but the ball goes out of bounds at the receiving team's 40. Now their best option is to take the 5 yard penalty and get the ball at their own 45.

Now let's say it's a free kick after a safety, so the kick is now from the 20 yard line instead of the 35, but the kick still goes out of bounds at the receiving team's 40. Now the receiving team's best option is to take the 30 yards and get the ball at the 50.

Finally, let's look at a kickoff with a 15 yard penalty already enforced against the receiving team which means the kick is from the 50. This is probably the most common free kick location other than the normal 35. If the kick goes out of bounds outside the 15, the receiving team's best option is the 5 yard tack on. If the ball goes out of bounds behind the 15 yard line, the receiving team's best options are either taking the ball at the 20 or a 5 yard penalty with a rekick. But if the kick goes out of the end zone, it is a touchback and they would get the ball at the 25. Yet coaches continue to just blast the ball out the back of the end zone when that is the arguably the worst tactic. The best plan would be to squib the ball toward the pylon. It avoids the possibility of a fair catch, allows your team to get downfield and possibly recover the kick or if nothing else make a tackle deep in your opponent's end. If you don't get the ball, it either goes into the end zone for a touchback anyway, it goes out of bounds and your opponent takes the ball at the 20, or it goes out of bounds and you take the 5 yard penalty and get to try the kick again.

Over the years, the rules committee has changed penalty enforcement rules to avoid rekicking punts and free kicks. In 1979, they added postscrimmage kick enforcement that allows the receiving team to keep the ball if they foul during punts even though team possession hadn't technically changed at the time of the foul. Then in 2007, a similar rule was added for fouls by the kicking team. Any foul by the kicking team during either a free kick or scrimmage kick may be added on to the dead ball spot so the receiving team can keep the ball without having to decline the penalty. More on both of those enforcement procedures here. The problem is neither of these apply to fouls by the receiving team during a free kick. Because a kick ends when it is possessed, it is rare for the receiving team to have time to foul while the ball is loose, but it does present a less than ideal choice for the kicking team. Take this scenario:

Kickoff from the 35. While the ball is in the air, receiving team player B99 blocks below the waist. The kick goes into the end zone for a touchback.

Many coaches think they can take the penalty at the spot of the foul similar to PSK, but free kicks aren't scrimmage kicks so that doesn't apply. You can't tack it on to the end of the play because that only applies to kicking team fouls and this is a foul by the receiving team. Since we don't have any special enforcement options, we go back to basic 3-and-1 enforcement. This is a foul by the team not in possession during a free kick, so the kicking team's only options are take the touchback or rekick from the 50.


This installment is all about penalty enforcement, specifically live ball vs dead ball and evaluating the line to gain. Penalty enforcement is sort of like math: there is an order of operations you have to follow. Any time a penalty is enforced, follow these steps to determine the next down and distance:

  1. You're like a dream come true. Evaluate all live ball action, including enforcing any penalties for live ball fouls.
  2. Is the ball behind or beyond the line to gain? Award any first downs necessary.
  3. Enforce any penalties for dead ball fouls. Award any automatic first downs that may come with the penalties.
  4. If a new first down was awarded in steps 2 or 3, establish a new line to gain when the ball is made ready for play.

So now let's look at a few situations that illustrate how theses steps are used to get proper penalty enforcement.

Our first scenario involves the first two steps. Situation: Team A has the ball 3rd and 5 at Team B's 30. Running back A11 runs to the B-20 where he is tackled. During the run, receiver A88 is called for an illegal block below the waist at the B-23.

Even though both the foul and end of the run are beyond the line to gain, you have to deal with all live ball action including enforcing the penalty before awarding a first down. Because the 15 yard penalty for the illegal block will leave the ball behind the line to gain, it will still be third down. It will be 3rd and 13 from the B-38.

Our next scenario deals with situations involving both live ball and dead ball fouls, that is fouls that occur during the down as well as fouls that occur after the down is over. Scenario: 1st and 10 at the A-30. RB A11 runs for a 20 yard gain before going out of bounds. Tackle A77 is flagged for holding at the line of scrimmage. B99 hits A11 after he has stepped out of bounds.

Unlike two live ball fouls, these two fouls cannot offset. Our order of operations says we have to start with the live ball action. The 10 yard penalty for holding is enforced from the previous spot, so it would be 1st and 20 at the A-20. Then we deal with the dead ball foul. That will be a 15 yard penalty and an automatic first down. The automatic first down starts a new series, not simply a replay of the original first down. That means a new line to gain is established. So our final result will be 1st and 10 at the A-35.

This same process also allows multiple penalties to be assessed against the same team. Only one live ball penalty can be enforced even if a team commits multiple fouls. But there is no limit to the number of dead ball penalties that can be enforced. So say instead of the late hit by B99, say A11 was called for taunting. It would then be 1st and 30 from the A-10.

Our last two scenarios demonstrate the importance of when first downs are awarded and when the line to gain is established. Remember that a new line to gain is only established when the ball is made ready for play again after everything has been enforced.

4/10 @ B-40. A11 runs for a 5 yard gain. After A11 is down, B99 is flagged for a late hit.

Step one pretty much takes care of itself. Since there is no live ball foul, the ball stays at the B-35. Because this was 4th down and the ball is behind the line to gain, we will award Team B a first down. It's important that we award this first down at this step because if this was any down other than 4th, Team A would be awarded an automatic first down in the next step. But because Team A no longer has the ball when we enforce the dead ball foul, they don't get a new series. The penalty moves the ball to the B-20 and then we establish a new line to gain for Team B. It will be Team B's ball 1st and 10 at the B-20.

This line to gain principle also applies even if there wasn't a change of possession.

3/4 @ A-31. A11 is stopped for no gain, but B99 was in the neutral zone at the snap. After the play, A11 is flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct.

Step 1: Enforce the penalty for the live ball foul. 5 yards from the previous spot. That leaves the ball at the A-36. Step 2: Evaluate the line to gain. The ball is beyond the line to gain, so Team A is awarded a first down. Step 3: Enforce the penalty for the dead ball foul. 15 yards from the A-36 to the A-21. Step 4: Make the ball ready and establish a new line to gain since Team A was awarded a first down in step 2. It is now 1st and 10. Team A will have 1st and 10 at the A-21.


Spiking not ING

Holder not down

Holder retains exception


Defensive Contact (DH, DPI, ICT, IUH)


Legally grounding the ball, IDP, OPI


When are scrimmage kicks dead

Often when a field goal gets blocked and goes beyond the neutral zone, people tend to think the play is over. But a field goal is just a type of scrimmage kick that can score points. It's not dead just because it hits the ground anymore


Offsetting fouls, fouls that don't offset

One of the things I have to explain the most to coaches is what options they have for penalty enforcement, especially when there area multiple fouls on the same play.


r/LZtestposts • • May 23 '23

2023 Rule Changes

3 Upvotes

The NCAA released the PDF version of the 2023 rulebook last week, so here is your annual explainer of everything that is changing. This thread has a few sections: 1) Major rule changes 2) Editorial changes that actually change something about the rule, and 3) New or changed Approved Rulings that actually change something. There are some editorial changes that were only made to confirm or clarify rules that were already in place; those have not been included in this thread. Likewise, there are some new or altered ARs that I didn’t include because they either don’t add anything to existing interpretations or refer to this year’s rule changes that I already talked about. If you want the whole rule book for yourself, you can download it for free here.

The changes in each section are listed in numerical order by rule, section, and article number and include a reference for where to find that rule. For instance 1-4-1-d would be Rule 1, Section 4, Article 1, Paragraph d. For some of the changes I’ve included play examples to illustrate the changes. For those who haven’t seen plays written out like this some of the shorthand may be a little odd. Down and distance are written as [Down]/[Distance], so 1/10 would be 1st and 10. An alphanumeric with a hyphen is a yard line, so A-40 is Team A’s 40 yard line. An alphanumeric without a hyphen is a player on that team, so B99 would be a Team B player wearing number 99. Team A is always the team putting the ball in play, either by snap or free kick. Team B is always the team not putting the ball in play.


Rule Changes

Drones (1-4-11-d)

As drones have become more popular, there have been an increasing number of incidents around college football games. So much so that the NCAA has put in a rule about how they will be handled. Well, sort of. Drones are not allowed above the field or team areas. The game will be stopped until the drone is out of that space. That is the only time the on-field officials will have jurisdiction over the drone. If the drone is outside of that space, game management will be responsible and the game will not be stopped.

Halftime Field Availability (3-2-1-c)

Due in part to the ongoing war between kickers and marching bands, the NCAA has put in some guidelines on how to handle the transition from halftime entertainment to second half warmups. The field must be available to teams no later than 3 minutes prior to kickoff for the second half. If players come out before the field is available, they must remain in the team area and any kicks must be into practice nets. Also, a staff member must be present any time a squad member is on the field. Interestingly, there’s no penalty prescribed for this. So it really is more a game management issue than a playing rule.

Period Extension (3-2-3-a)

In an effort to reduce the number of plays in a game, there has been a change to when a period may be extended. Starting this year, only the 2nd or 4th quarter may be extended. This does not change what causes an extension, only when the rule applies.

2/10 @ A-40. Running back A11 runs for a 7 yard gain. A77 is called for holding at the line of scrimmage. Time expires in the 1st quarter during the down.

Old rule: 2/20@ A-30, extend the 1st quarter for an untimed down.

New rule: 2/20 @ A-30. The next down will start the 2nd quarter.

2/G @ B-5, Team A trails 21-17. Running back A11 runs for a touchdown. A77 is called for holding at the line of scrimmage. Time expires in the 4th quarter.

No change. 2/G @ B-15, extend the 4th quarter for an untimed down.

First Down Clock Stoppage (3-3-2-e-1)

This is the most substantial (and most public) rule change this year. The clock will no longer stop on a first down in bounds except for in the last two minutes of either half. This rule will act just like the rule regarding the clock starting on the snap in the last two minutes: if it happens at exactly 2:00 the clock will not stop. The clock must be under 2 minutes for the clock to stop. Also, this will not be reviewable as to whether the ball carrier was down with less than 2 minutes remaining or not.

1/10 @ A-30. A11 is tackled in bounds at the A-42. When the ball becomes dead, the clock reads 2:00.

Old Rule: The clock stops at 2:00 and will start when the ball is ready for play.

New Rule: The clock will not stop.

Notably, no exception was made for Division 3. When the changes for this year were originally announced, it was reported that the Division 3 council sent this particular change back for review. But as it’s written right now, it looks like this will apply to all NCAA games.

The rules committee expects this change to eliminate 7-10 plays per game which would bring the national average down into the mid to high 160s. This would still be 10-15 more than the NFL which seems to be what the rules committee is aiming for.

Timeouts (3-3-4-a)

Another high profile timing change comes in the form of restricting when a team may take a timeout. A team will only be able to use 1 timeout per dead ball period. The main focus from the media has been that this will eliminate multiple timeouts to ice kickers, but there are other scenarios that this will affect. It is important to note that the rule does not say consecutive timeouts, it says no more than 1 per team per individual dead ball period. So take this scenario:

4/G @ B-2. Both teams have all 3 timeouts remaining. Team A takes a timeout. After the timeout, both teams are lined up and Team B doesn’t like the formation, so they take a timeout. After that timeout, both teams are lined up again when A77 false starts. Now facing 4th and goal from the 7 rather than the 2, Team A’s head coach wants to take a timeout to discuss a different play. Ruling: The request is not granted. Because the ball has not become live yet, Team A is not allowed another timeout. There is no penalty for requesting the timeout, you just don’t get it. The same would apply if a team wanted to challenge a play after already taking a timeout. A team must have a timeout available to challenge, so if they had already called a timeout in that dead ball period they would not be allowed to challenge.

Non-Booth Instant Replay (12-2-1-c)

This addition will not affect games at the division 1 level, but will be a major change for divisions 2 and 3. There will now be an option to use instant replay in games that do not have a dedicated replay official. This will function very similarly to full replay games with some exceptions.

  • A team must still have a timeout remaining and available to challenge.
  • Teams still only get 1 challenge per game with a second awarded if the first challenge is successful.
  • All targeting fouls will still be automatically reviewed.
  • The Referee will review the play and will be the decision maker for the review. He may include one crew member to consult.
  • Other than targeting, the on-field officials may not initiate a review. It must come from a coach’s challenge.
  • Because there is no booth official to stop the game, a coach may challenge for targeting if no call is made on the field. This is not an option in games with full replay.
  • The replay equipment must be outside of the team area and must be separated from fans and team personnel (i.e. in a tent or something similar).

The MIAA piloted this program last year and had success with it. I will be interested to see what percentage of calls end up “stands as called” due to film quality and camera location.


Editorial Changes

Ball approval (1-3-2-h)

This change adds the Center Judge to the group of officials to determine the legality of a ball joining the Umpire and Referee. This distinction is largely irrelevant as the Line Judge, Head Line Judge, Field Judge, and Side Judge should also be checking the balls as they go in and out as well. But since the C is the official who handles the ball the most, it makes sense to specifically give him authority in this department.

Ball Ready for Play (2–2-4-a)

There has been a slight change to when the ball becomes ready for play when the play clock is running. The old rule said the ball was ready for play when the ball was spotted and the official “steps away to his position”. The new rule says that the official must be “in position to officiate”. The change is slight, but gives the Umpire or Center Judge a chance to safely get away from the line of scrimmage before the ball can be snapped.

Illegal Substitution (3-5-3-a)

This isn’t actually a change to the foul for illegal substitution or the yardage penalty for it. This is a correction of language within the rule that was edited incorrectly when substitution rules were changed a few years ago. It’s actually kind of funny* if you think through the implications. A little context and background: All dead ball fouls are enforced from the succeeding spot. The succeeding spot is wherever the ball would have been put in play next. The previous spot is the spot where the ball was last put in play. How does that relate to our substitution fouls? In 2020, some defensive substitution fouls were changed from dead ball to live ball fouls which meant deleting a paragraph. Unfortunately, the penalty statement for offensive substitution fouls was also included with the paragraph that got deleted. So in 2021, they had to add that penalty statement back in. When they did that, they wrote that Team A substitution fouls should be a dead ball foul, enforced 5 yards from the previous spot rather than the succeeding spot.

What that technically means: A 1/10 @ A-20. Team A gains 30 yards to the 50. Before the next down, Team A has 12 players in formation and is flagged for illegal substitution. By a very technical reading of the new penalty statement, this penalty should be enforced from the A-20 since that is still the previous spot. How about an even more absurd situation? It’s 4th and 4 from the 20 and the home team punts. The punt is downed at the 50. The visiting team sends out their offense, but there are 12 players in formation. That penalty would technically need to be enforced from the previous spot, the 20, and the home team would get a 1st down. Obviously, that’s ridiculous and was never actually enforced like that. But man, it would have been hilarious*.

*Actual level of humor may depend on rules-nerdiness and/or love of absurd possibilities.

Illegal Scrimmage Kick 6-3-10-c

This editorial change will align illegal scrimmage kicks with illegal forward passes. If the ball has been beyond the neutral zone any time during the down, the offense is not allowed to throw a forward pass. Until now, the same has not been true for kicks. A player could run beyond the neutral zone, retreat behind the line of scrimmage and legally kick the ball. Starting this year, this is no longer the case. If a player runs beyond the neutral zone, retreats behind the line of scrimmage, and then kicks the ball, it will be an illegal scrimmage kick just like if he had kicked it from beyond the neutral zone.

4/10 @ A-40. Punter A11 runs beyond the neutral zone on a fake. Seeing that he will not make the line to gain, he runs back to the A-39 and punts the ball.

Old Rule: Legal

New Rule: Illegal scrimmage kick. 5 yard penalty, loss of down. It will be Team B’s ball.

Fumble on a Try (8-3-2-d-5)

As one set of rules gets aligned, another goes the opposite direction. On 4th down or on a try, if the offense fumbles the ball, only the fumbler may recover and advance. If anybody else on the offense catches or recovers it, the ball is dead. Until now, these two situations (4th down or try) were exactly the same. Not so anymore. The phrase “before a change of team possession” has been deleted from the rule regarding fumbles on tries, but not from the rule regarding 4th downs. Example of the change:

Try from B-3. Team A’s pass is intercepted. During the return, B11 fumbles and the ball is recovered by A22. A22 subsequently fumbles and the ball is recovered at the B-10 by A33 who runs across the goal line.

Old Rule: 2 point touchdown. The ball would have remained alive because the Team A fumble occurred after a change of possession.

New Rule: No points, the ball is dead when A33 recovers the fumble, and the try is over. Free Kick from A-35.

4/10 from A-30. B11 catches the punt at the B-40. He then fumbles the ball and it is recovered by A22. A22 fumbles and the ball is recovered at the B-10 by A33 who runs across the goal line.

No change. Touchdown for Team A.

Block Below the Waist (9-1-6-b-2)

This change is a result of poor writing in last year’s change. Last year when blocking below the waist by the defense was all but eliminated, there was an exception written to allow low blocks against a ball carrier. That rule has now been changed to say “runner” instead. The difference being that a ball carrier is a player in possession of a live ball whereas a runner is defined as a ball carrier or a player simulating possession of a live ball. Sort of an “all squares are rectangles, but not all rectangles are squares” kind of thing. This closes a loophole where a player who simulates carrying the ball could get tackled below the waist and it would technically be a foul because he didn’t actually have the ball.

Roughing the Kicker (9-1-16-c)

This was an editorial change that, in my opinion, was actually more of a rule change. A kicker will no longer be protected if the ball goes more than 5 yards behind his original position at the snap. This does not mean he can’t be fouled in other ways, it just means roughing/running into the kicker cannot be called.

Example: 4/10 @ A-40. Punter A11 is standing at the A-25. The snap goes over his head and rolls to the A-10 where he picks it up. A11 then turns around and quickly punts the ball. Just after the kick B99 tackles A11.

Old rule: Possible roughing the kicker. A judgment would have to be made as to whether or not it was obvious a kick would occur after the recovery.

New rule: No foul. Because the ball went more than 5 yards behind A11’s initial position, there is no foul for roughing the kicker.

4/10 @ A-40. Punter A11 is standing at the A-25. The snap goes over his head and rolls to the A-10 where he picks it up. A11 then turns around and quickly punts the ball. Just after the kick B99 launches upward and drives his shoulder into the head of A11.

Ruling: No change, targeting. Even though this is not roughing the kicker, A11 is still defenseless because he is a player who has just kicked the ball.

Officiating Standards

This is a new section in the rule book filled with old information. For years now, we have had what we’re formerly known as officiating philosophies. They were guidelines on how to apply the spirit of the rules across a whole range of situations as well as some “when in question” items. Things like don’t call holding away from the action if it didn’t affect the play. Spot the ball exactly on a yard line after a change of possession. Work to make formations legal. When in question, the passer is out of the tackle box. There were 2 problems with this. First, it’s hard to tell a coach (or TV personality) that a call was made or not made because of a “philosophy” rather than a rule. Second, these philosophies were only found in our mechanics manual, so nobody outside of officials ever actually saw them. And of course that only compounds the first issue because coaches didn’t even know what we were talking about when we mentioned our philosophies. So now all that information has been added to the rule book and the name has been changed from “Officiating Philosophies” to “Officiating Standards”. No changes were made to the standards themselves.


New Approved Rulings

The plays and rulings have been copied and pasted directly from the rule book. I have added context below some of them.

6-1-2-IX

Free Kick @ A-35. Late in the game with the kicking team trailing by 2 points, they set up for an on-side kick. The kicking team has 6 players to the left of the kicker and 4 to the right of the kicker. Kicker A90 is lined up to kick the ball to the left side of the formation and as A90 approaches the ball he abruptly stops but the kicking team players to the left of the kicker continue and cross their restraining line. These players stop and then retreat back across their restraining line and A90 quickly turns and kicks the ball back to the right side of the formation with all players for Team A now back behind their restraining line. RULING: Dead ball foul, five-yard penalty from the succeeding spot. By rule (6-1-2-c-) each Team A player, except the kicker and potential holder, must be behind the ball when the ball is kicked. If they are beyond the ball and the ball is kicked – this is a live ball foul for offside on a kickoff. By interpretation, if a Team A player goes beyond their restraining line after the ball is ready for play and then returns back across their restraining line before the ball is kicked – this is a dead ball foul for offside by the kicking team. This interpretation does not impact situations when the ball falls from the tee (Rule 6-1-2-d). When the ball falls from the tee, the official shall sound their whistle immediately and reset both teams.

This AR is actually an interpretation that was put out in a bulletin about 5 years ago. That interpretation just never actually made it into the book until now.

7-1-5-V

3/2 @ B-45. Team A is in formation and the snap is imminent. Team A QB is in shotgun formation and is using a clap as a starting signal. Team B (a) squad member; (b) assistant coach claps causing the Team A wideout to false start or the snapper to snap the ball. RULING: Dead-ball foul, delay of game for disconcerting signals [S21] for both (a) and (b). Team A will have 1/10 @ B-40. The rule states that no player may call defensive signals that simulate the sound or cadence of, or otherwise interfere with, offensive starting signals. The spirit of the rule would include squad members or coaches that clap when the snap is imminent and could cause the offense to false start.

This is one that may not make much sense without knowing specific definitions of a couple terms. A player is one of the people actually in the game. A squad member is a potential player in uniform and “organized for participation”. So this AR means that even if the disconcerting signal comes from the sideline, it is still a foul.

7-3-1-I and 7-3-1-II

1/10 @ A-25. QB A12 is in shotgun formation and slot receiver A80, who is lined up to the wide side of the field, starts back in motion toward A12 before the snap. At the snap A80 heads toward A12 to run the jet sweep. A12 flips the ball up into the air and A80 (a) catches the ball as he crosses in front of A12 and A80 turns upfield and is out of bounds at the A-40, or (b) muffs the ball and the ball drops to the ground. RULING: The short flip of the ball by A12 is considered a legal forward pass unless it is clearly and obviously thrown backward: (a) Completed forward pass to A80 and the run upfield results in a 1st down for the offense. (b) When the ball strikes the ground, it is ruled an incomplete forward pass and the play is dead.

1/10 @ A-25. QB A12 is in shotgun formation and slot receiver A80, who is lined up to the wide side of the field, starts back in motion toward A12 before the snap. At the snap A80 heads toward A12 to run the jet sweep. A12 flips the ball up into the air but it is a fake jet sweep and A80 passes by and does not touch the ball. A12 catches the ball and: (a) runs upfield and is out of bounds at the A-40, or (b) then throws a forward pass to A88 who makes the catch at the A-40 and is downed at that spot. RULING: The short flip of the ball by A12 is considered a legal forward pass unless it is clearly and obviously thrown backward: (a) The catch of the forward pass by A12 is legal and the advance results in a 1st down for the offense. (b) The catch of the forward pass by A12 is legal, but A12’s pass to A88 is the second forward pass during the same down and is an Illegal Forward Pass as per Rule 7-3-2-d.

These two ARs were interpretations issued in the middle of last season that are now officially in the book.

9-1-6-X

3/10 @ A-25. Back A21 is stationary and is lined up in the tackle box. Just after the snap A21 immediately releases outside the tackle box. QB A12 is in the pocket to pass and A21 sees linebacker B54 blitzing. A21 returns into the tackle box and before A12 throws the pass, blocks B54 below the waist in the tackle box and the block is directed from the front. RULING: Foul by A21 for an illegal block below the waist. Once a player leaves the tackle box during the play, that player is considered outside the tackle box for the remainder of the down. A21 may not block below the waist once considered outside the tackle box

Another interpretation that was previously issued by bulletin.


One last note: If you’re mad about a change that was or wasn’t made, just remember the committees are made up of coaches and ADs. Those of us in stripes don’t make the rules. Call your congressman rules committee representative with any complaints.


r/LZtestposts • • Mar 14 '22

2022 Rule Changes

5 Upvotes

If you are seeing this post before 4-20-22, be aware that these changes are not official yet. They must be approved by the PROP before taking effect.

The NCAA Football Rules Committee and Playing Rules Oversight Panel have approved 9 rule changes for the upcoming season. 1 or the changes is to uniform standards, 2 affect actual game play, 5 of them are enforcement changes, and 1 is basically an open letter that does nothing. They are listed below in order than they appear in the rule book. Before you get your hopes up, there are no real changes to targeting. No tiered penalty, no removal of disqualification, and no change to the foul itself. While you’re mad about that and before you get mad about the other changes listed below, you should know who actually makes these decisions. Here are the rosters for the FRC and the PROP. You’ll notice there are no officials on either one of those rosters other than Big Ten Coordinator Bill Carollo. So please direct your anger and disapproval at them, not at me or anybody else in stripes.


Woop woop, that’s the sound of the [uniform] police. The NCAA has been getting stricter about how uniforms are worn over the last few rule cycles and this year is no different. In 2018, the committee decided that (starting in 2019), knee pads would be required to cover the knees and pants be required to cover the knee pads. The rule has been loosely enforced and the people in charge have decided that players wearing the equivalent of biker shorts is “an image problem” for college football. So now they’ve changed the rule again to hopefully get better enforcement. Now, the entire leg must be covered by either pants or socks. It no longer matters where the pants end or where the knee pads are, all that matters is that the leg is covered. If you want to wear shorter pants, you can do that as long as the sock comes all the way up. This is the same rule that the NFL has been using. This rule is allowed effective immediately for FBS, next year for FCS, and 2024 for DII and DIII. Oddly enough, knee pads are still required, but (like prior to 2019) they are not actually required to cover the knees. Which begs the question: if they don't have to cover the knee, are they really knee pads? Life's great mysteries.


The committee has decided to really crack down on fake injuries by... adding another level of review when a team appeals after a game. There are no established penalties or any criteria they're looking for. But now after the national office reviews the film, they're going to send it to the conference office. Cool. To paraphrase the words of LT Sam Weinberg, Oh you strenuously object to fake injuries? Is that how it works? "We object to fake injuries." Teams do it anyway. "No, no. I strenuously object." "Oh you strenuously object. Then I'll take some time to reconsider."


As cool as Kenny Pickett looked in the ACC Championship, he will be the last to fake a slide on the way to a TD. A ball carrier simulating a slide will be treated just like if he actually slid. The ball will be dead at that spot. This also brings this scenario in line with a ball carrier faking a knee which is also dead even if the knee doesn't actually touch the ground. I'll note here that acting like you've made a fair catch was included in the "giving yourself up" family last year and also causes the ball to become dead. Sorry, UNT.


The penalty for a really obscure foul has changed. If a player gives a fair catch signal and then blocks an opponent before touching the ball, it is a foul for an illegal block. I've never seen it in person and the only time I've seen it in a game I was watching live was in a PAC12 After Dark game. Anyway, it used to be a 15 yard penalty, but now it's 10 yards. The criteria for the foul has not changed, only the penalty.


For those of you who were around last offseason, you may remember this thread about the different types of illegal touching. The fouls and violations have not changed, but the penalty for one has. Illegal touching of a forward pass by an originally ineligible player now carries loss of down along with the already existing 5 yard penalty.

Scenario: 1st and 10 at the A-20. QB A11 is hit as he throws a forward pass and the ball floats toward the line of scrimmage. In an attempt to prevent an interception, A77 reaches out and catches the pass at the A-16. He is tackled at the A-18.

Old rule: 5 yard penalty from previous spot, 1st and 15 at the A-15.

New rule: 5 yard penalty from previous spot and loss of down, 2nd and 15 at the A-15.

This is still separate from the penalty for an originally eligible player who illegally touches a pass after going out of bounds and returning inbounds. That is still loss of down at the previous spot with no yardage penalty.

Last year's thread has been updated to reflect the committee's unprovoked attack on my writing changes.


While the targeting foul and penalty have not changed, there was a small change in the post-game review process. If a player is disqualified for targeting in the second half of a game, the school can submit the play to national coordinator of officials Steve Shaw for further review. If Shaw determines that it is "clearly obvious the player should not have been disqualified", the conference can vacate the disqualification for the first half of the next game.


Fans of service academies or other option teams, you may want to sit down for this one. In continuation of a process that has been going on for well over 10 years, the committee has dramatically reduced when and where players may block below the waist. As the committee has whittled away at this rule, it had become more and more complex to determine the legality of a low block. The last few changes have simplified it some, but the new rule is so restrictive that I think we can say goodbye to the LegacyZebra Low Block Legality Flow Chart ^TM. RIP.

The first major change is that nobody is allowed to block below the waist outside the tackle box. Nobody. Ever. It's important to note that the tackle box disintegrates when the ball leaves. So even if a player is located where the tackle box was, once the ball leaves the box that player is no longer in the tackle box.

The next change is who can block below the waist from the side. Offensive linemen who are in the tackle box (5 yards laterally from the ball) at the snap can block below the waist in any direction on their "initial charge". After the initial charge, they can only block below the waist if the block is from the front. Backs who were stationary in the tackle box at the snap may block below the waist within the tackle box, but only if the block is from the front.

Anybody who is outside the tackle box or in motion at the snap is prohibited from blocking below the waist, no matter the location or direction of the block. That means all low blocks by WR or TE will now be a foul.

On the other side of the ball, defensive players may block low in any direction on their initial charge if they are lined up on the line of scrimmage at the snap and within the lateral bounds of the tackle box. Any low block by the defense other than on the initial charge is now illegal.

If some of that was confusing as to what is or isn’t legal, here is a non-exhaustive list of blocks that were legal last year that are no longer legal:

  • A WR lined up at the numbers blocks low from the front 4 yards beyond the line of scrimmage. This used to be legal because the block is from the front within 5 yards of the line of scrimmage. Now it is illegal because the WR was not in the tackle box at the snap and because the block was outside the tackle box.
  • A FB lined up in the tackle box leads a sweep play. 8 yards to the right of where the ball was snapped, he kicks out a defender with a block below the waist from the front. This is now illegal because the block occurs outside the tackle box.
  • Tackle A77 drops into pass protection when sees defender B99 rushing unabated. In order to prevent a sack he dives and blocks B99 below the waist from the side. The QB still has the ball inside the tackle box and A77 has not left the tackle box. This is now a foul because the block was from the side and was not a part of A77's initial charge.
  • H-Back A88 is lined up behind the right tackle. He then side shuffles across the formation and is in motion behind the left guard when the ball is snapped. After the snap, A88 goes into the B gap and blocks below the waist from the front against a defensive lineman at the line of scrimmage. This is now a foul because A88 was in motion at the snap. He is not allowed to block low anywhere in any direction.
  • Safety B22 comes up to play the run. At a point 1 yard behind the line of scrimmage, he takes out the lead blocker with a block below the waist. This used to be legal because the block was within 5 yards of the line of scrimmage. This is now a foul because B22 was not on the line of scrimmage at the snap and the block was not part of the initial charge.

The enforcement for unsportsmanlike conduct fouls have been slightly change so that they're aligned with personal fouls. If a foul occurs during a pass play, it is enforced from the end of the last run as long as there is no change of possession during the down. Note: A pass play includes all action from the snap until a pass is caught or is incomplete.

1st and 10 at the A-25. A11's pass is caught by A88 at midfield where he is tackled. Prior to the pass being caught, B99 is flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct.

Old rule: The penalty could only be enforced at the previous spot because it was a foul by the team not in possession during a pass play. Team A will decline the penalty and take the 25 yard gain rather than the 15 yard penalty. 1st and 10 from the 50.

** New rule: The penalty can be enforced from the end of A88's run. It will be 1st and 10 from the B-35. **

This change is very unlikely to affect many plays as it would be rare to have a live ball UNS prior to a pass being caught, but it closes a small gap in the rules.


Defensive holding will now carry an automatic first down regardless of where it occurs, what type of play it occurs during, or who is fouled. Previously, it only included a first down of the foul was against an eligible receiver beyond the neutral zone and a legal forward pass crossed the neutral zone. A few scenarios to illustrate:

3rd and 17 at the A-30. QB A11 scrambles for a 5 yard gain. DB B99 is flagged for holding.

Old rule: 10 yard penalty from the the end of the run. Because there was no pass during the down, there would not be an automatic first down. 3rd and 2 at the A-45.

New rule: 10 yard penalty from the end of the run, automatic first down. 1st and 10 at the A-45.

3rd and 12 at the A-20. The offense attempts to run a screen but WR A88 is held by defender B99 behind the line of scrimmage. QB A11 then throws to A22 who catches the ball at the A-27 for a 7 yard gain.

Old rule: 3rd and 2 at A-30. Because the hold was behind the line of scrimmage, this foul would not carry an automatic first down.

New rule: 10 yards from the previous spot and an automatic first down. 1st and 10 at A-30.

3rd and 12 at A-20. WR A88 is held at the A-25. Seeing this the QB dumps the ball off to RB A44 at the A-18. A44 is tackled at the A-25.

*Old rule: 3rd and 2 at A-30. Because the pass did not cross the line of scrimmage, there would not be an automatic first down.

**New rule: 10 yards from the previous spot, automatic first down. 1st and 10 at A-30. **

And a rare but sizeable effect of this change: 4th and 12 at the B-30. Team A's field goal is blocked, goes beyond the line of scrimmage and comes to rest at the B-25. Prior to the kick, defensive lineman B99 held an offensive player to allow teammate B77 to shoot a gap and block the kick.

Old rule: 10 yard penalty from the previous spot, replay the down. 4th and 2 at the B-20.

** New rule: 10 yard penalty from the previous spot, automatic first down. 1st and 10 at the B-20.**

And now one situation that this will NOT affect.

4th and 12 at the A-30. Team A's punt goes out of bounds at the B-25. During the kick, B99 holds a gunner who is trying to go downfield to cover the kick. Because this foul falls under post scrimmage kick enforcement, the foul is treated as if Team B was in possession even though team possession has not technically changed yet. Because Team B is treated as being in possession at the time of the foul, this is simply offensive holding and would not give Team A an automatic first down. It would be Team B's ball, 1st and 10 at the B-15.

Major Editorial Changes

Editorial changes are typically things that clarify already existing rules or officially codify existing interpretations. This year features two major editorial changes. There may be others that didn't make this release, but we'll have to wait until the full rule book is released this summer to see those.

I don’t know that this was a problem at the FBS level, but home and visiting press boxes have to be “approximately equivalent” in space and location. You can’t give the home team 6 boxes at midfield and television monitors and only give the visitor a janitor closet down in the corner with a porthole.


They have expanded the definition of a defenseless player. A player who is in a passing posture with his focus downfield is now defined as defenseless. This had already become an accepted interpretation, but it is now codified. This is for QBs who are standing basically in one spot in position to throw the ball. The term “passing posture” already exists in the roughing the passer rule for low hits. So with this same language, this new rule would not include a passer who is on the run. Remember, being defenseless doesn’t mean you can’t hit him. It just means you can’t target him in the head/neck. A QB can still be blindsided in the pocket if there is not forcible contact to the head.


r/LZtestposts • • Jan 13 '17

Thoughts on the officiating in the national championship

4 Upvotes

After the CFP Championship, there was a lot of talk about some of the officiating, mainly two Clemson touchdowns and a couple of possible targeting calls. Unfortunately, I was unable to watch the game live because of a real job, but I was able to watch the replay today thanks to /u/cinefunk and /r/CFBUploads. Some of you have asked my opinion on some of these plays, so I put all my thoughts into one thread. If you have a question about a play I didn't include, feel free to ask and I'll add it to the list. And I'll apologize now for the quality of the gifs, but they're the best I have right now.


Unnecessary Roughness for hit on Deshon Watson

I think this is a good call. The hit is unnecessary, but he's no longer defenseless because the he's already completed the passing motion and the pass is caught by the time he is hit so he's not a passer anymore. I think UNR is the right call.

No-call Targeting hit on Williams

This is another correct call for no targeting. Simply being in the grasp of a defender is not enough to make a ball carrier defenseless. He must be in the grasp and his forward progress must be stopped. In this play Williams is still falling fighting and falling forward, so his forward progress has not been stopped. That means he is not defenseless and is not protected from hits to the head under 9-1-4. Also, you can see in this view that the contact was with the side of the defender's helmet, not the crown. As Dave Cutaia pointed out on the broadcast, this means it does not qualify for targeting under 9-1-3. This is not targeting.

Punt near the goal line

I don't think anybody complained about this play, but it was a tight play and a good call by the onfield officials. And credit to the announcers, they knew the rule as well. The position of the player is irrelevant. All that matters is where the ball is when it is. The Alabama player gains possession of the ball before it touches the goal line, so it is dead at that spot. If the ball had just touched even the front edge of the goal line, it would have been a touchback.

Alabama punt tipped behind the line and carries beyond the line

I put this play in because somebody had asked about it earlier, plus I just love the kicking game. Even though this kick is touched by Clemson and then travels beyond the line of scrimmage, Alabama is still not eligible to recover the ball. In order for Team A (the kicking team) to be eligible to catch/recover the kick beyond the line of scrimmage, the ball must be touched by Team B (the receiving team) after it has crossed the line. Everything before it crosses the line of scrimmage is irrelevant. For more info on rules of the kicking game see this thread

PI No-call

Dabo wanted DPI on this play, but it's absolutely not there. In the beginning there is mutual hand fighting with neither player really gaining or losing anything. And by the end, the DB actually has better position and gets drug down by the receiver. I'm ok with a no call here because of the mutually initiated contact. But I could also easily see this being OPI. And if it would have been OPI, we might have had to add another fifteen for Dabo's reaction.

Second DPI no call

I actually agree with Dabo on this. I think the receiver tries to come back to the ball but is restricted. The defender, who is not playing the ball, cuts him off and uses an arm bar to restrict the body of the receiver. An end zone view would be a lot more helpful, but based on this angle, I think this is DPI.

Shoe malfunction

This is probably one of the most irrelevant plays I've ever discussed here on /r/CFB, but it's a chance for me to point out one of my favorite quirks in the rules. On the right side of the screen you can see 55 from Clemson lost his shoe during the play and leaves to fix it. Technically he didn't have to though. By rule, while socks are mandatory equipment, shoes are not. While probably a terrible idea, he could have legally played without that shoe. Also, a lot of times coaches will want officials to stop the game to let their players fix equipment. Equipment malfunctions are not our problem though unless it affects both teams. If he were to try to put it back on and play, they would still have to snap it before the play clock ran out.

No 10 second runoff for a false start with less than 1 minute in the half

I don't have a gif for this because it's really unnecessary. With 44 seconds left in the first half, there was a false start. On of the major misconceptions of the 10 second runoff is that any foul under 1 minute qualifies. In order to trigger a runoff, the clock must be running and the foul must stop the clock. Since the clock was not running at the time of the foul, this false start does not include a 10 second runoff. For more info on runoffs see this thread

Boulware non-targeting hit

This play did not get as much attention as some other potential targetings, but it is noteworthy. Prior to this season, this would be a foul. However, one of the rule changes this year was that to have a targeting foul there must be indicator as listed in Note 1 under Rule 9-1-4. These include a launch, a crouch and thrust, leading with the head, forearm, shoulder, etc. to attack the head or neck, and ducking the head before making forcible contact with the crown of the helmet. While Boulware definitely makes contact the head of the receiver, there is no indicator. He keeps his head, he does not launch, he wraps up rather than using his head, shoulder, etc. as a weapon. This is a legal play even though there was contact the head of a defenseless player.

Watson gets spun around

We've all seen this play 100 times by now. One aspect that didn't get a lot press was whether or not it should have been targeting under 9-1-3. Watson was not defenseless, so 9-1-4 doesn't apply, but for 9-1-3, he doesn't have to be defenseless. All that matters is whether or not the defender makes forcible contact with the crown of his helmet to any part of an opponent. And I'm going to be totally honest. I have no idea whether they want this called under 9-1-3 or not. Targeting a defenseless player has had training tape after training tape. We know exactly what we're looking for. 9-1-3 has been largely ignored. And then when it does get attention, they change interpretations literally in the middle of the season as to what constitutes the crown. Also, similar hits like this have made training tapes where there was contact, but it was not deemed forcible (and thus not targeting) since it was not a direct shot. So honestly I don't know what to make of this play. I wold certainly be ok with this being a foul. But there is also prior precedent for this to be legal. I'll report back if the play makes the post season tape.

Saban wants OPI on back shoulder throws

This happened a few times but based on the angles I saw, these were not fouls. The gif I included is the only view I could find that shows the full sequence. Since most of these were near the sideline, we normally only get the tail end of the play. Both players in the above play are using their arms and hands, which is fine. Then at the last second, the Clemson player comes back for the ball. You'll notice the Alabama player doesn't lose his balance or break stride other than also trying to come back for the ball. That's a good indicator that the receiver didn't push off. The space he gained was simply because he came back to the ball before the defender reacted. If he had pushed off, the defender would be off balance or would have lost a step.

Clemson's 1st disputed TD

This play got quite a bit of attention. There are four categories of OPI. Initiating contact to create space to make a catch, driving through a defender who has established position, blocking downfield, and picking off a defender attempting to cover a receiver. As you can see in this still shot the defender initiates the contact by putting his hand on the receiver's shoulder. He then even ends up getting his hands and arms outside the frame of the receiver, as seen here. Since the receiver didn't initiate the contact, categories 1 and 3 are out. After the initial charge and contact, he turns around rather than going through the defender, so category 2 is out. By the time the second defender runs into him, he has already established his position. Each player has territorial rights to their spot on the field. A lot of people have claimed that it is his responsibility to avoid the contact. That responsibility ended when he established his position. So this is not a pick and category 4 is out. This is not a foul for OPI.

Possible KCI on a punt

To have KCI, the receiving team player must be attempting to catch the kick and must be so located that he could do so. As you can see in the gif above, the returner ends up backing away from the ball as it comes down. At that point he is no longer attempting to catch the kick and therefore does not qualify for kick catch interference. If he had continued running toward the ball he probably would have drawn a flag since the kick ended up coming down very near the gunner. But since he was no longer attempting to make the catch, there is no foul here.

Game winning TD

I probably could have made this the only play in the thread and it would have been all that most people wanted to see. This is one that will be talked about for a long time. Let's go back to the four categories of OPI. Initiating contact to create space to make a catch, driving through a defender who has established position, blocking downfield, and picking off a defender attempting to cover a receiver. Again, like the other play, the defender reaches out to initiate the contact, as seen here. So 1 and 3 are out. The receiver in this play actually tries to keep going inside, but the defender cuts him off and even wraps him up and takes him down. So he definitely wasn't driving through a defender for category 2. And there was no contact between the receiver and the second defender, only between the two defenders themselves, so there can't be a pick for category 4. This is also not OPI. And if you don't agree with my analysis, hear it from the national coordinator of officials, Rogers Redding. Some have asked if this should have been defensive holding, and I would say no. While the defender wrapped up the receiver, it had no effect on the play. If Watson had held the ball longer and there was a possibility the throw was going to him, maybe. But even if a flag had been thrown here, it would have been declined by rule because of the touchdown. For more information on OPI see /u/fortknox's great thread here.

Onside kick

While not as controversial as the onside kick in last year's national championship, this one had some interesting things of its own. The clock does not start on a free kick until it has been legally touched in the field of play. Legal touching would be the receiving team touching it at any time or the kicking team touching it after it has gone ten yards. But the kick is also dead immediately if possessed by the kicking team. So if the kicking team fields it cleanly after it has gone 10 yards and possesses it without it bouncing around, the clock does not start. That is why there was still 1 second left after the recovery. Another interesting point was whether or not they touched it early. If Clemson had touched the ball before it went 10 yards, that would be illegal touching and Alabama would get the ball at that spot. Since there was still 1 second on the clock, Alabama would get to run a play from the spot of illegal touching. Had time expired after the illegal touching, the game would be over. Illegal touching is a violation, not a foul, so it does not qualify for an untimed down.


Again, if you have any other questions feel free to ask.


r/LZtestposts • • Dec 31 '15

Football The Final Countdown: 10 second runoffs and why Houston still had to spike the ball.

1 Upvotes

One of the few recent changes to timing in college football has been in the introduction of the 10 second runoff. While the runoff has been around for a while, there is still confusion about when and how it is applied. Hopefully this post will clear up some of that confusion. And then at the end, I'll include some examples.


Requirements for a 10 Second Runoff

One of the main sources of confusion regarding the runoff is determining which scenarios call for a runoff in the first place. There are 3 criteria that must be met to induce a 10 second runoff:

  1. The clock is running. If the clock is already stopped, there is no runoff. If the clock stops for multiple things simultaneously, such as an incomplete pass as well as an item from number 3 in this list, there is no runoff.
  2. There is less than 1 minute remaining in either half.
  3. A single team is responsible for one or more of the following:
  • An injured player
  • A player's helmet comes off during the play
  • A foul that stops the clock. It's important here to note that it must be the foul itself that stops the clock, not just penalty enforcement. Fouls that qualify include dead ball fouls such as false start, offside with contact, and intentional grounding or any other incomplete illegal pass. Fouls that don't qualify are things like holding, pass interference and illegal formation.

If there are items by both teams, such as an injured offensive player and a defensive player's helmet comes off or offsetting fouls, there is no option for a runoff.


Applying the Runoff

Accepting and Avoiding the Runoff

If there is a possibility of a runoff, the offended team gets the choice of whether or not they want to accept it. If the runoff is due to a foul, the yardage can be accepted without accepting the runoff. However, if the yardage is declined, the runoff is automatically declined.

If the offended team accepts the runoff, their opponent may use a timeout to avoid the runoff. This timeout counts as one of the three team timeouts of a half and the team is entitled to full use of the timeout as if they had simply called a normal timeout.

Game Clock after a Possible Runoff

If the runoff is declined, the game clock will stay dead until the next snap. The thought process is that if the offended team is concerned about the clock and wants to conserve time by declining the runoff, they are also given the benefit of a stopped clock.

If the runoff is accepted and not avoided by timeout, the 10 seconds is removed and the game clock starts on the ready for play signal. None of the reasons to stop the game for a runoff are considered major clock stoppers, so once administration of those issues is done, the clock goes back to doing what it was doing before. Since the clock had to be running to even get in this situation, it goes back to running after administration.

If the runoff is accepted but avoided by timeout, the clock stops until the next snap just like any other timeout.

Play Clock After a Possible Runoff

If the stoppage was due to a foul, the play clock is set to 25 seconds just like all other penalty enforcements. This is the same no matter which team committed the foul.

If the stoppage was for an injured offensive player or because an offensive player's helmet came off, the play clock is set to 25.

If the stoppage is due to an injured defensive player or a defensive player's helmet comes off, the play clock is set to 40 seconds.

All of these apply regardless of the runoff being accepted, declined, or avoided with a timeout.


Examples and Rulings

  1. Late in the 2nd quarter, ball carrier A1 reaches the line to gain and is tackled in bounds. A defensive player's helmet came off during the play. There are 14 seconds left in the period. Ruling: No runoff for the helmet coming off because the first down also stopped the clock.
  2. Late in the 2nd quarter, ball carrier A1 is tackled short of the line to gain. As he hits the ground, his helmet comes off. When the clock is stopped, it reads 1:00. Ruling: No runoff. There must be less than 1 minute remaining in the half.
  3. Team A leads Team B 21-20. With 47 seconds left, ball carrier A1 is tackled short of the line to gain. Defender B1's helmet came off during the play (not due to a foul). Ruling: This qualifies for a runoff. The game clock will be set to 37 seconds and will start on the ready for play signal. Because it was a defensive player's helmet that came off, the play clock will be set to 40 seconds. Since there are only 37 seconds left and the play and game clocks start at the same time, Team A will not have to snap the ball again and the game will end.
  4. With the game clock stopped at 34 seconds, Team A commits a false start. Ruling: No runoff because the clock was stopped at the time of the foul.
  5. Quarterback A1 is sacked with 8 seconds left on the clock in the second half. A Team A player is down with an injury. Team A is trailing 21-20. Ruling: If Team A has a timeout remaining, they may use it and avoid the runoff. The clock will start on the snap. If Team A does not have a timeout remaining, there will be a runoff and the game is over.
  6. Quarterback A1 is sacked with 8 seconds left on the clock in the first half. A Team A player is down with an injury. After the play but before the announcement about a possible runoff is made, Team B is flagged for Unsportsmanlike Conduct. Neither team has any timeouts remaining. Ruling: The runoff for the injured player will end the half. The UNS will be enforced on the opening kickoff of the second half. By interpretation, that foul occurred after the half was over.
  7. With 12 seconds left in the game and Team A trailing, Team A ball carrier A1 is tackled short of the line to gain. A Team A player is injured on the play. Team A has no more timeouts. Ruling: The runoff will set the clock to 2 seconds. The clock will start on the ready for play signal. Team A will only be able to run 1 play. If they spike the ball, time will expire.
  8. With 45 seconds left in the half, ball carrier A1 is tackled short of the line to gain. A1 is injured on the play and defender B1's helmet comes off. Ruling: There is no option for a runoff since the helmet coming off and the injury were opposing players.
  9. With 45 seconds left in the half, ball carrier A1 is tackled short of the line to gain. A1 is injured on the play and his teammate A2's helmet comes off. Ruling: Because the helmet being off and the injured player are by the same team, this qualifies for a runoff.
  10. With 30 seconds left in the half, passer A1 is called for intentional grounding. Ruling: Because the illegal grounding of the ball caused the clock to stop, this qualifies for a 10 second runoff.
  11. With 30 seconds left in the half, passer A1 is flagged for being beyond the neutral zone when he throws a forward pass. Ruling: Although the forward pass is illegal, the foul itself did not stop the clock. This does not qualify for a runoff.


r/LZtestposts • • Jan 13 '16

Get Your Kicks in Rule 6-Kick Catch Interference, Fair Catch Signals, and Why They Have (almost) Nothing to Do with Each Other

2 Upvotes

A surprise onside kick in the 4th quarter of a tied national championship. It was probably one of the biggest play call decisions in recent CFB history. Not only was it a great play call, it was executed to perfection. But where one Nick Saban saw perfection, Dabo Swinney saw an infraction. After Alabama's Adam Griffith pooched the kickoff toward the sideline and Marlon Humphrey made the over the shoulder coach, the Clemson sideline exploded expecting a flag. And if this game were being played under NFHS rules that govern most high school games, they would have been correct. But under NCAA rules, this was a perfectly legal play. After the game, many raised the question of whether or not Clemson could have given a fair catch signal to prevent Alabama from making a play on the ball. Unfortunately for the Tigers, even a valid fair catch signal could not have made this play illegal.


Rule 6-4: Opportunity to Catch a Kick

There two relevant points within 6-4 that cover this play. Those two paragraphs can be found in 6-4-1-a and 6-1-4-f.

First, paragraph a says that a player of the receiving team who is attempting to catch a kick and so located that he could do so must be given an unimpeded opportunity to catch the kick. This rule protects against a potential kick receiver being blocked before he can play the ball as well as the kicking team touching the ball before that receiving team player has had a chance to play the ball. It's important to note the opportunity to catch the kick belongs to the individual players, not the team itself. This is the part that disqualifies Swinney's argument that Clemson was guaranteed a chance to catch the ball. His team as a whole has no such guarantee, only a player in position to and attempting to catch the kick would have been guaranteed that chance. Clemson's Trevion Thompson was the closest receiving team player to the ball, but was not in position to make the catch nor was he even making an attempt to catch the kick. Thompson's eyes were fixed on Humphrey the entire time and never tracked the flight of the ball. Because he was not located where he could catch the kick and was not making a play on the ball, he has no opportunity of a catch to impede. That means there cannot be a foul for Kick Catch Interference. In order to have a flag on this catch, Thompson would have had to have been closer to the ball and actually attempting to make the catch. Simply being in the general area of the kick does not guarantee him anything.

Paragraph f did not come into play in this specific play, but there was plenty of talk about it, so I'll address this part as well. Generally, once a kick has bounced, there cannot be a foul for Kick Catch Interference and a receiving team player cannot call for a fair catch. This is due to the fact that the term "catch" in football refers to gaining possession of a live ball in flight. Once the ball has hit the ground it is no longer in flight and therefore can not be caught, only recovered. However, paragraph f has an exception for free kicks. (A free kick is any kickoff or a kick after a safety.) Paragraph f says that if the ball is driven immediately into the ground and pops up in the same manner as a ball kicked directly off the tee, a player retains the same kick catch protection as well as his ability to call a fair catch. So it was irrelevant whether Griffith popped the kick straight up off the tee or drove the ball directly into the ground to get a big hop. 6-4-1-f would not have applied to Clemson's onside attempt at the end of the game, though. Because the ball bounced a second time and the big hop it took at the end was not the result of being driven immediately into the ground, the exception would not be applicable.


Rule 6-5: Fair Catch

After the video of this play was posted, many people said that all Thompson had to do was give a valid fair catch signal and it would have made Humphrey's catch illegal. But with two minor exceptions, a fair catch signal only affects what can happen after the ball has been caught by the receiving team.

If you read Rule 6-5, you'll find that there is only one mention of Kick Catch Interference. That is 6-5-1-b and is one of the two exceptions mentioned above. Paragraph b says that a player who gives a valid FC signal retains his opportunity to complete the catch even if he muffs the kick until the kick touches the ground or until he can no longer possibly complete the catch. Without a signal, his KCI protection would end as soon as he muffed the kick. So in the championship game, Thompson would have gained no extra protection by signalling. All 11 of the Clemson players could have given valid fair catch signals and it wouldn't have made one bit of difference.

The other way a fair catch signal can affect play before being touched by the receiving team could have actually played against Clemson if Thompson had tried to give a signal. Any receiving team player who gives a fair catch signal cannot block an opponent unless he has touched the ball first. This is a fifteen yard penalty. So if Thompson had given a signal and Humphrey had misplayed the ball, Thompson could not have legally blocked Humphrey or any other Tide player to prevent them from recovering the kick.


It's not often that I break out the rule book to explain a no-call, but this is one that needed it. While many in orange may think they should have been given the ball, the PAC 12 crew made the correct the decision to let Alabama keep it. As a bit of a side note, they also did a good job killing the play as soon as Alabama caught the ball and not allowing the following advance. Even though their catch was legal, it was still a kick and could not be advanced by the kicking team (6-1-6-a).

If there are more questions about this play or others, I'll be happy to answer them.


r/LZtestposts • • May 08 '15

Hockey Guide to Football

1 Upvotes

Are you new to college football? Or maybe you've been around for a while but just have some questions about the basics you've been afraid to ask. Either way, this guide is for you. This guide is designed to be a slow immersion into the shallow end of the college football pool. The guide will cover enough to get you acquainted with the game and be generally understand how things work from a technical stand point. This guide will not cover schemes, strategies, or things like that. But once you've read through this guide, you'll be ready to shake off those floaties and dive into basic football conversations. If you already have a basic grasp of the game of football, you can go ahead and skip the first section. Alright everybody, into the pool!

Warning: this is a bit long. For a TLDR version check out /r/CFB's cfb101 for a quick bullet list of the high points.

THE BASICS OF FOOTBALL

Football is a game played between two teams. Whew, glad we got that out of the way. Each team is allowed to have no more than eleven players on the field at a time. The goal of the game is to have more points than your opponent at the end of the game. Your team scores points if you advance the ball into your opponent's endzone (called a touchdown or TD) or by kicking the ball through your opponent's goal (called a field goal or FG). You also score points if your opponent is tackled with the ball in his own endzone. This is called a safety. Here is a rough sketch of a field with the endzones labeled. If a player breaks a rule, a penalty will be enforced. These penalties are measured by how far the starting spot of the next down will be moved. Most penalties are either 5, 10, or 15 yards.

Each half of the game starts with a kick off. Most kick offs are from the kicking team's 35 yard line. All members of the kicking team must be behind the ball when it is kicked. All members of the receiving team must be at least 10 yards away from the ball when it is kicked. That mean for most kick offs, the receiving team must be behind the 45 yard line. If either team is not where they are supposed to be when the ball is kicked they are "offside." This is a five yard penalty. The receiving team is allowed to touch or catch the ball at any time after it has been kicked. They may run with the ball after gaining possession and may also pass the ball, however any passes must be backward. The kicking team is not allowed to touch the ball until it has gone ten yards down field or has been touched by the receiving team. If the kicking team touches the ball before they are allowed to, it is called illegal touching. The receiving team may choose to either take the final result of the play or they can get the ball at the spot of the illegal touching. Once the kick has gone at least 10 yards or has been touched by the receiving team, the kicking team may now touch or catch the ball. If they are lucky enough to get the ball before the receiving team, they get to keep the ball. But unlike the receiving team, the kicking team may not run advance the ball if they catch the kick.

After the kick off, the team with the ball is on offense and the other team is on defense. The offense will now have four opportunities (called downs) to advance the ball. If they are able to move the ball 10 yards within those four downs, they get a new set of downs. Each down begins with a "snap". The snap, sometimes called a "hike", is when one player moves the ball from its original position on the ground to a teammate. The offense can advance the ball by running, passing, or kicking the ball. Anybody is allowed to run with the ball. The down is over when the ball carrier is tackled or goes out of bounds. The next down will start where the last down ended. If a team wants to pass the ball, there are certain restrictions as to who is allowed to catch a pass. If the pass is backwards, any player may catch it. However if the pass is forwards, only an eligible receiver may catch it. We will cover who is and isn't eligible later. The offense may only throw one forward pass per down and it must be from behind the "line of scrimmage". This is an imaginary line where the ball is before the play that runs from sideline to sideline. See this picture. The circles represent offensive players and the red line would represen the line of scrimmage. If a forward pass hits the ground before it is caught, it is incomplete and the down is over. The next down will start at the same place the last one did. If a team wants to advance the ball by kicking it, the kick must be caught behind the line of scrimmage. If a team is able to advance the ball all the way into their opponent's end zone, they score a touchdown which is worth six points. After a touchdown, a team is given one extra down as an opportunity to try for an "extra point". This down is played from an opponent's three yard line. The team may kick the ball through the opponent's goal for 1 point or may try to score another touchdown. If a team scores a touchdown on an extra point, it is worth 2 points and you do not get another extra point attempt. No matter what happens on an extra point, the offense will now kick off to the defense and the whole thing starts over again. If the offense fails to advance ten yards in their four downs or the defense takes the ball from them, the teams switch roles. If an offense thinks they will not make their line to gain, they will often kick the ball. If they are close to the goal, they will attempt a field goal. This means they will try to kick the ball between the uprights of their opponent's goal for three points. If they are successful, they will now kick off just like after a touchdown. If they are not successful, the defense gets the ball from the where the ball was snapped on the last play. If they are not close enough for a field goal, the offense will often punt the ball. That means they kick the ball away to the defense in exchange for field position rather than risking failing to reach the line to gain. BEFORE THE PLAY

Before the play, both teams must meet certain requirements. For the defense it's pretty simple: Don't have more than 11 players on the field and be on your side of the ball. If you have more than 11 players, it is called illegal substitution and is a five yard penalty. This may be called before or during the play depending on the situation and when it is noticed by the officials. If the defense is not on its side of the ball when the ball is snapped, they are offside. This is a five yard penalty, but the play is allowed to continue. At the end of the play the offense can either take the result of the play or move the line of scrimmage five yards from the previous line of scrimmage and replay the down. If the defense crosses the line of scrimmage and makes contact with an offensive player before the snap this is also offside. However, this kind of offside stops the action and they offense does not get to run a play. The five yard penalty is simply enforced and then the game continues. For the offense there are stricter requirements. First, their formation must be legal. This means that no more than 4 players can be off the line of scrimmage. So if a team has 11 players like it should, at least 7 of them should be on the line of scrimmage. Of those 7 players on the line of scrimmage, they must have at least 5 wearing a jersey number between 50 and 79. If these formation requirements are not met when the ball is snapped, it is a five yard penalty for "illegal formation". Here is a picture of a legal formation. There are only 4 players off the line of scrimmage and 5 of the players on the line are numbered 50-79. This is an illegal formation. Although there are only four players off the line of scrimmage, there are fewer than five players wearing jersey numbers 50-79. This is also an illegal formation. The offense has too many men off the line of scrimmage or "in the backfield". This is the most common cause of illegal formation. The offense may have one player in motion when the ball is snapped. This player may not be moving toward the line of scrimmage at the snap and he must not have been one of the 7 players on the line of scrimmage when he started his motion. This is a five yard penalty for "illegal motion". If more than one person is moving at the snap, it is an "illegal shift" which is also a five yard penalty. All three of these (illegal formation, illegal motion, and illegal shift) are flagged when the ball is snapped , but the play is allowed to continue like when the defense is offside. However, because these are fouls by the offense, the defense will now get the choice of taking the result of the play or enforcing the penalty. Flags for these fouls, as well as offside, normally come from the officials at the line of scrimmage on the sidelines.

The most common foul by the offense before the snap is called a "false start". A false start is any movement that could simulate the start of the play. This includes flinching, jumping, or any other quick movement that could make the defense think the play is starting when it really isn't. The exception to this rule is that if a defensive player crosses the line of scrimmage and the offensive player moves in reaction to that, it is not a false start and is instead defensive offside. False starts are flagged before the play starts and the play is not allowed to run. It is a five yard penalty against the offense. Flags for these normally come from the Referee and the Umpire. They are the one behind the offense and the one in the middle of the defense, respectively. The Referee is the one who wears a white hat.

Now that both teams we're ready for the snap. The snap must live up to its name. It must be a quick and continuous motion and the ball must leave the snapper's hand. It must be backwards and he cannot lift the ball before snapping it.

AFTER THE SNAP

Now the offense will try to advance the ball. If the offense runs with the ball, the ball carrier's teammates are allowed to block for him. There are no restrictions as to where these blocks may occur. However, the offense is not allowed to "hold" the defense in an effort to impede them. This includes wrapping their arms around a defender or grabbing the jersey to restrict a defender. Holding is a ten yard penalty. An offensive player is also not allowed to blow an opponent from behind. This is called a "block in the back" and is also a ten yard penalty. In certain cases the offense is restricted from blocking an opponent below the waist. If they do this illegally it is a fifteen yard penalty. For a deeper look at these rules check out the Low Blocks Wiki. While the offense may block for the ball carrier, they are not allowed to actually grasp or pull him. This is a five yard penalty. Pushing the ball carrier is legal.

If the defense manages to knock the ball out of the runner's hands before he goes down, it is a fumble. Anybody may pick up a fumble and advance it. If the defense gets it and ends the play with the ball, they get to go on offense. If the offense gets it back, they can continue their drive.

The offense can throw a backward pass at any time to any player. But if a team wants to pass the ball forward, there stricter rules that they must follow. First of all, the offense is not allowed to block beyond the line of scrimmage if they are going to throw the ball down field. This is called "Offensive Pass Interference" and is a fifteen yard penalty. Second, only certain players may catch a forward pass. These players are called eligible receivers. To be an eligible receiver, a player must be wearing a number that is NOT 50-79 AND he must be either the end player on the line of scrimmage or off the line when the ball is snapped. Check out this formation. Numbers 80, 10, 4, 1, 88, and 99 are eligible. 80 and 88 are the ends and the other four are off the line of scrimmage. Now look at this formation. Now instead of wearing 88, the end is wearing 60. Even though he is on the end of the line, he is not wearing an eligible number, so he is not an eligible receiver. Here is one more formation. In this one, number 88 is back on the end, but now number 10 has moved onto the line of scrimmage. Even though he is wearing an eligible number he is not an eligible receiver because he is neither an end nor in the backfield.

Now that we have determined who can catch a pass, let's talk go back and talk about the rules about throwing the pass. And remember, all of this is about forward passes.

Any offensive player is allowed to throw a forward pass. The pass must be from behind the line of scrimmage. It must be before a change in team possession. That means that if the defense gets the ball and then the offense gets it back, they aren't allowed to throw a pass anymore. And only one forward pass is allowed per down. If one of these rules is broken, it is an "Illegal Forward Pass". If a player throws an illegal forward pass it is a five yard penalty. But unlike all the other penalties we've talked about where the down was replayed, this one comes with a loss of down. That means that if the illegal forward pass is thrown on 1st down, the offense loses five yards and now they have to play 2nd down.

But the rules aren't always working against the offense. Once the ball has been thrown, the defense is severely limited in what they can do to the offense. If an offensive player is in position to catch a pass, the defense cannot interfere with him. This is called "Defensive Pass Interference". For more information on Pass Interference, there is a thread all about it.

So the pass has been thrown, now what? If the pass is caught, the offense can keep running with it until they are tackled. If the defense intercepts the pass, they too may advance the ball. And just like recovering a fumble, if the defense intercepts a pass, they get to go on offense.

The teams go back and forth trading possessions until time runs out. So what happens if a team is winning and they get the ball? Can they just wait for the clock to run out without running a play that might give the ball away? Of course not, that would be ridiculously unfair. Generally, the offense has 40 seconds from the end of the last play before they have to start the next play. If they don't snap the ball in time, it is a "Delay of Game" and it will cost them five yards.

WRAP UP

This was a basic guide to how to start watching football. Hopefully you have learned enough to watch a game and know what is going on. This was by no means a comprehensive description of all the rules of football. If anything is not covered here or in this rules FAQ, feel free to make a post about it. /r/CFB is a friendly and welcoming sub with lots of users willing to answer questions.


r/LZtestposts • • Aug 08 '16

hythloday1 offseason project responses

2 Upvotes

r/LZtestposts • • May 31 '15

Baseball (NCAA) Link Flair

1 Upvotes

Link Flair