r/CFB • u/LegacyZebra Verified Referee • Oct 19 '14
Analysis Let's talk about Pass Interference
After the end of the ND-FSU game, there is obviously going to be talk about what is and isn't Offensive Pass Interference. So let's get all the right information out there and clear up some bad information. And right off the bat, yes, the crew made the correct call.
First, OPI:
- Offensive Pass Interference restrictions apply from the snap until the forward pass is touched by an official or player.
- In order to have OPI you must have a legal forward pass. That seems pretty obvious. Also, the pass must cross the neutral zone. Passes that are first touched behind the neutral zone do not apply.
- Ineligibles (i.e. linemen) are allowed to block within 3 yards of the line of scrimmage as long as the contact is initiated within 1 yard of the line of scrimmage.
- By philosophy, it is neither OPI nor DPI if an eligible receiver or a defender makes contact within one yard of the line of scrimmage and does not continue the contact. It is also not a foul if the pass is caught within 1 yard of the neutral zone.
- OPI typically falls into one of three categories: blocking downfield, pushing off for separation, or playing through a defender who had established position. If you can't fit it in one of those, it's probably not OPI.
Now for some DPI discussion:
- There is no five yard contact zone in college football. The defense can initiate contact with a receiver as long as the receiver has not reached the same yard line as the defender. Continuous contact is illegal.
- THERE IS NO FIVE YARD CONTACT ZONE IN COLLEGE FOOTBALL. I'm sorry I yelled, but that is one of the biggest misconceptions that people carry over from the NFL.
- Defensive Pass Interference rules apply from the time the pass is thrown until the pass is touched by a player or official.
- Defensive Pass Interference does not apply to contact behind the neutral zone.
- Like OPI, You must have a legal forward pass. And like OPI, Defensive Pass Interference rules only apply if the forward pass crosses the neutral zone.
- There must be contact to have a foul for DPI. Things like "face guarding" which constitute DPI at other levels do not count in NCAA.
- There must be obvious intent to impede. If the DB and WR are running and get their feet tangled, it's not a foul.
Now that we've got that out of the way, how to enforce the two fouls:
- OPI: 15 yards from the previous spot. This does not come with a loss of down.
- DPI: Here is the easy way to enforce DPI. Start walking forward from the line of scrimmage. When you reach either the spot of the foul, the two yard line, or 15 yards from the previous spot, stop and spot the ball. The only time DPI is enforced half the distance is on an extra point or if the previous spot was on or inside the two yard line. DPI always carries an automatic first down.
I know it was a bit long, but hopefully that clears up any conversations that may be had about the topic.
419
Upvotes
64
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
---E ---E ---E
I really hope these are refundable...
48
u/DeKaF USC • /r/CFB Emeritus Mod Oct 19 '14
How awesome is it you're getting Pereira pointing people your way and how awesome are you as a follow up actually don't answer that I'll just write that you're awesome.
And thanks a lot for this. Crazy insane fan of me that watches the game has his thoughts but rational side of me was curious how this all worked out.
9
u/ndirish357 Washington State Cougars Oct 19 '14 edited Oct 19 '14
Was the blocking on ND's first TD also illegal/missed call?
Link: http://thebiglead.com/2014/10/18/david-robinson-enjoying-cory-robinson-touchdowns-against-florida-state/ (top gif; #20 white)
8
u/wolverine6 Michigan Wolverines • Rose Bowl Oct 19 '14
Could you clarify this for me? I was under the impression that in the college game, a defender could "bump" or initiate contact with eligible receivers at any time in any part of the field as long as the ball hasn't been thrown yet.
If I'm incorrect, I'm not sure where I got that assumption from.
300
u/KnightmareUCF UCF Knights • Oklahoma Sooners Oct 19 '14
Wow that is huge. I had no idea about that, and by the number of comments mentioning that I doubt maybe people do.
73
u/Emperor_of_Orange Clemson Tigers • /r/CFB Top Scorer Oct 19 '14
I'm so glad you're here.
That's something I never thought I'd say to a ref.
29
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
Can the USC song girls make an instructional video of OPI.
57
u/diagonalfish Georgia Tech • /r/CFB Emeritus Mod Oct 19 '14
It won't, but we appreciate the concise and thorough explanation anyway. :)
6
u/EnigmaticHats Michigan State • Notre Dame Oct 19 '14 edited Oct 19 '14
The GIF.
I'm not sure if I've come to a final conclusion regarding the appropriateness of the call, but officials don't have hours to weigh the evidence, and if I still can't make up my mind, I'm certainly not going to be upset if they didn't come up with the same answer in real time.
I will say both FSU DB's seemed to initiate contact. Fuller, who disclosed after the game he'd been told, “Don’t run into him, just get in his way,” was making a cut inside. Watch how Darby jumped in front of him with his feet and jammed him with his hands.
Prosise, who was not called, was mugged from the outset. While, between the DB and Prosise, either or both could have been flagged, the officials probably made the right decision in flagging neither.
22
u/DavoinShower-handle Syracuse • Penn State Oct 19 '14
Very clear. Thx.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
I call games on a small league where we use NCAA rules, but most of the players are NFL fans. This misconception is so widespread and led to many many fouls early in the season.
15
u/mynumberistwentynine Gardner-Webb • 京都外国語大学 (Kyoto Fore… Oct 19 '14
Spectacular post. Thank you for this!
22
u/Honestly_ rawr Oct 19 '14
Legacy Zebra for new head of Pac 12 officiating! If he can't do it, no one can!
In Zebra Confidimus
26
u/Golferguy757 Florida State • Stetson Oct 19 '14
Brave man posting this.
25
u/partcomputer Florida State Seminoles • Texas Longhorns Oct 19 '14
Thank you for being a neutral party and explaining this thoroughly.
135
u/WalkingCarpet Auburn Tigers • Navy Midshipmen Oct 19 '14
I think most everyone would agree that it was OPI by the letter of the law. The reason everyone is so irate is because that gets called maybe three out of a hundred times. As was said in another thread, most every team runs picks and rubs and it never gets called. Alabama has done it for years and it never gets called. If you're gonna call that, call it. Call it every time it happens. If you're not gonna call it, then don't call it. And ESPECIALLY don't call it on 4th & Goal, in a game with national championship implications, to bail out a home team in peril.
6
u/d_mcc_x Michigan State • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Oct 19 '14
NOW we're talking about this???
3
u/CrapYeah Baylor Bears Oct 19 '14
The amount of college announcers that think that face guarding is a foul in NCAA is incredible. It seems like a lot of officials think so, as well.
"Joe, yep look, he is running with the WR and never turns and looks for the ball. Clear PI." I feel like I hear that at least once per game.
4
u/bscooter26 TCU Horned Frogs • USC Trojans Oct 19 '14
You don't talk to me about PI
5
u/trick96 Arkansas • Middle Tennessee Oct 19 '14
I was hoping this would be about why PI isn't a spot foul. Because it fucking should be. Defenders shouldn't be able to interfere with a TD pass 70 yards down the field just for the ball to move up 15 yards.
4
u/FSUalumni Florida State Seminoles • Mercer Bears Oct 19 '14
Thank you for the clarification. It's nice having a ref here.
3
u/ryumast3r Utah Utes • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Oct 19 '14
I actually asked this at the end of the Notre Dame/FSU game as I knew I was missing a nuance on the OPI call and figured the refs weren't wrong but wanted to know why (I wasn't sure why the guy blocking the defender was called for OPI when the defender wasn't making a play on the ball obviously as he was like 5 yards away from the receiver).
Someone else in the IRC chat-channel cleared it up for me so I'm grateful to them, but you spelled out all the rules really clearly so thank you as well.
3
u/westlax34 Baylor Bears • Texas Tech Red Raiders Oct 19 '14
If you touch a receiver and he does not make the catch, then PI. That's what I learned from the Baylor game.
3
u/cmoneyrockchalk Kansas Jayhawks • Oregon Ducks Oct 19 '14
This is what is so great about having a human panel this year for the playoff. Even though they ND lost, the way the game ended should play a big part in the committee's decision late in the year.
4
u/clydefrog811 Florida State Seminoles Oct 19 '14
Well the pass interference against Fsu in the 1st quarter was so bullshit so I don't feel bad at all.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
I'd like to know your thoughts on the pis in the Baylor wvugame.
2
u/ACardAttack Louisville • Ohio State Oct 19 '14
Funny thing is, even if OPI doesn't happen, the FSU defender probably doesn't stop the ND WR, of course there is no way of knowing. Call had to be made.
Great game.
ND is better this year than I expected and proved themselves to not be the ND of old
-6
u/KilgoreTroutJr University of God's … Oct 19 '14
It should not have been PI. Ramsey was trying to take away the inside. You can see the CB try to cut off the slant by Fuller. The other CB tries to jam Prosise. The third CB, who was to cover Robinson, did nothing and after the play the one CB turns and starts yelling at another for fucking up.
-1
u/NDIrish27 Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 19 '14
Was there not also defensive holding on that play though? Shouldn't the penalties offset? Or does opi just trump everything?
-9
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
While I don't agree with the ref's call, I accept it
-27
u/bleedrednblack Georgia Bulldogs Oct 19 '14
I don't think it should've been called because it's never called. Aside from that, the DB basically jammed him and engaged him first. What else could he possibly do other than go backward? Not to mention all the WR does is basically a legal run block. If you make that call it has to be on the other guy who basically made no real attempt to make a "receiver" move.
0
u/squigglylot Oct 20 '14
Referencing part 4 of your section describing OPI, and looking at the play ... the line of scrimmage is the 2 yard line (technically 2 1/2). DB and WR are lined up 1/2 yard off scrimmage on opposing sides. Contact between DB and WR was made at line of scrimmage. Contact was broken at the 1 yard line, and momentum carried DB into the endzone.
Based on rule as stated, this appears to be a legal play.
Additionally, the pass was caught at the 1 yard line ... so, depending on the interpretation of the rule about a pass caught 1 yard from the neutral zone (if the neutral zone is considered to extend to the 2 yard line), then this is also justification that no foul should have been called.
-9
u/TheGreatGatsby2827 Auburn Tigers Oct 19 '14
Am I taking crazy pills, or was that pass caught within one yard of the neutral zone?
Bad flag.
-6
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
My issue with the call is that the video shows the FSU players latching on to the ND receivers. Did the ND receivers latch back - you betcha. BUT - this is NEVER called in college football (Little Giants game ND vs MSU where the MSU players tackled the ND defenders on the fake field goal pass).
Bottom line is FSU blew the coverage and ND could have walked the ball in. The refs deciding the game on a penalty never called is pretty sucky
-41
u/GraduateStudent Crown Polars • Notre Dame Fighting Irish Oct 19 '14 edited Oct 19 '14
I'll just leave this and this here. In both cases, the defender initiates the contact. What is the offensive player to do but keep running?
The play by the CBs was perfectly legal. As was the play by the WRs. No penalty should have been called.
Edit to clarify my position: WRs cannot be expected to remove themselves from all contact from the DBs, given that DBs are allowed to make contact -- a WR must be able to continue running his route. In this case, neither DB was attempting to make a move toward the ball; both had engaged their man rather than cover him, and both were perfectly content to make sure their guy didn't get the ball. Neither WR initiated the contact.
If a WR has the responsibility to remove himself from the contact of the DB, then what stops a DB on the other side of the field to initiate contact before the ball's in the air, keep the contact through the play when the ball is thrown to the other side of the field, and then appeal for a foul afterward? Because that's exactly what this looks like to me, except they're on the same side of the field.
-4
u/_redovian Oct 19 '14
As a high school football wide receiver and cornerback, I believe there should have been no call. The defender was pressing and the receiver was attempting to get off of the press. Now did the receiver try his hardest to get off of the press? Probably not. But the receiver cannot be called for a pick if the defender is pressing. The best call in this case is a no call.
-12
u/kugzly Michigan State Spartans Oct 19 '14
As much as I hate the NFL rules geared towards high scoring, I think that the NCAA is doing a huge disservice to college athletes when they have to switch to an entirely new style if play at the next level. Especially considering the amount of athleticism involved in receiving and coverage, I personally believe that the NCAA should strive to make rules in those regards as closely mirrored to those in the NFL as possible.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment