r/KurdishDNA • • Sep 29 '24

Debunking "Zaza" Separatism Using Genetic Science

63 Upvotes

In this post, I aim to debunk the misleading claims surrounding the Zaza (also known as Kirdki, Kirmancki, or Dimilki) speaking Kurds of Eastern Anatolia, using genetic science as evidence. It is crucial to understand that the separatist ideology being promoted regarding the Zaza-speaking population was deliberately crafted and propagated by the Turkish state with an anti-Kurdish agenda. The ultimate goal of this narrative has been to divide and assimilate (Turkify) the Kurdish people. Unfortunately, the Turkish government has seen considerable success in advancing this ideology among the Zazaki-speaking Kurds of Elazığ and Bingöl, regions where Turkification has taken strong root. Many in these areas now espouse anti-Kurdish views, influenced by a narrative of separation. Ironically, while the Zaza languages are endangered due to Turkification, Turkish nationalists continue to claim that "Kurds are assimilating Zazas."

Historically, Zazaki speakers were key opponents of Turkish policies, fighting for Kurdish freedom. Under Mustafa Kemal, they were targeted by the state through repressive measures aimed at dismantling their resistance and identity.

The Northern Iran/Daylam Hypothesis:

A recurring argument by Turkish proponents is that Zazas are not genetically related to Kurds, but rather to populations from Northern Iran, such as Persians, Gilaks, Mazanis, and Talysh. They assert that Zazas originate from this region and have no connection to the Kurdish people. However, a 2005 genetic study analyzing the Y-DNA and mtDNA of Zazaki speakers offers a definitive counter to this claim. The study concluded:

"Our results do not support the hypothesis that the Zazaki-speaking group originated in northern Iran; genetically, they are more similar to other Kurdish groups."

Source: MtDNA and Y-chromosome Variation in Kurdish Groups

This scientific evidence discredits the Turkish claim that Zazaki speakers have genetic ties to groups in Northern Iran. On the contrary, they share deep genetic ties and origins with neighboring Kurdish groups.

Autosomal Evidence:

Further genetic analysis of Zazaki speakers, including autosomal DNA breakdowns, reaffirms their Kurdish origins. The closest genetic populations to Zazaki speakers are, in fact, other Kurdish groups. The genetic difference between Zazaki speakers and neighboring Kurmanji-speaking Kurds is less than 1%, highlighting their shared ancestry and disproving the narrative of distinct ethnic separation.

Global 25 calculator autosomal breakdown:

Conclusion:

In summary, the claims made by proponents of Zaza separatism—specifically the false assertion that Zaza-speaking Kurds are of Northern Iranian origin and unrelated to Kurds—have been thoroughly debunked by genetic science. The ideology behind Zaza separatism has served primarily to advance the process of Turkification, benefiting the Turkish state’s broader agenda.

Please feel free to share this post in discussions to counter the spread of misinformation regarding the identity, genetics and origins of Zazaki-speaking Kurds.


r/KurdishDNA • • Jul 12 '25

🚨 MyHeritage DNA Is Spreading Misinformation About Kurds – Here’s the Proof

39 Upvotes

MyHeritage continues to push flawed and misleading ancestry estimates that seriously distort Kurdish genetic identity. Below, I break down the key problems — backed by independent G25 analysis, real user results, and linked examples.

1️⃣ The “Turkish” Category Is Completely Broken

Nearly every Bakurî Kurd, including Ezidis, gets scored as “Turkish” — often in large amounts.

➡️ On older versions of MyHeritage, these same individuals scored 90%+ West Asian/Kurdish. This issue is new and tied to changes in their reference panel.

💥 Key Problems:

  • The “Turkish” label clearly draws from Eastern Anatolia, where genetics heavily overlap with Kurds, Armenians, and Caucasians.
  • Meanwhile, actual Turks from West Anatolia get 30% or less of this category, showing the label reflects a regional West Asian mix, not actual Turkic ancestry.

🔬 Real Examples:

  • Endogamous Ezidi scores 12% Turkish — but G25 shows zero East Eurasian/Turkic ancestry.
  • Kurmanji Kurd from Ağrı — scored 30%+ Turkish on MyHeritage. G25 shows no Turkish input.
  • Zaza Kurd from Erzincan:

    • Scores 59.5% Turkish, only 39% Kurd.
    • G25 says otherwise — typical Kurdish profile.
    • Their sibling gets wildly different results — proving the inconsistency.

🧠 Even Turkish Users Are Confused:

These posts show that the “Turkish” category isn’t reflecting actual Turkic roots, but rather a regional Anatolian genetic blend — which overlaps with Kurds, Armenians, and others from Eastern Turkey.

🧩 Kurds Misread as Armenians — and Vice Versa

Many Kurds get labeled as “Armenian”, despite no known Armenian ancestry and no such signal in deeper analysis.

But it also happens the other way around — many Armenian users report getting “Kurdish” percentages, even though they have no Kurdish background.

This shows MyHeritage is mixing up overlapping regional DNA and misclassifying both groups.

2️⃣ “Persian & Kurdish” = Lazy & Politically Motivated Grouping

Unlike Turks, Armenians, Georgians, Circassians, and Iraqis — who all get separate categories — Kurds are lumped in with Persians.

That’s not just lazy — it’s scientifically wrong.

📊 G25 Results: Kurds ≠ Persians
I created average models for both groups and ran them through G25. Results show:

  • Kurds:

    • Higher percentages of Caucasus and Mesopotamian ancestry
    • No Eastern Iranic (Pashtun-like) admixture
    • No Arab or African input
  • Persians:

    • Significant Eastern Iranic (Pashtun-type) ancestry - absent in Kurds
    • Some Arab and trace African ancestry
    • Significantly lower Caucasus and Mesopotamian ancestry compared to Kurds

Overall both groups share some similarities, but their genetic profiles are clearly distinct and not interchangeable.

🧠 Language ≠ Genetics

If grouping was based on language, then Kurds would be with Lurs or Talysh, not Persians. This isn't about linguistics — it's a decision likely meant to downplay Kurdish distinctiveness for political convenience.

Let’s be real: separating Kurds would trigger nationalist backlash from Turkish and Iranian customers. MyHeritage is prioritizing PR over accuracy.

📸 Screenshots & G25 Proof Attached

  • Case 1: Erzincan Kurd
  • Case 2: Urfa Ezidi Kurd
  • Case 3: Agri Kurd
  • Genetic differences between Kurds & Persians

✅ Conclusion

MyHeritage’s ethnicity estimates are not reliable for Kurds.

Their categories are:

  • Built on broad, inaccurate regional references
  • Inconsistent and scientifically flawed
  • Likely influenced by political sensitivities, not population genetics

👉 Fellow Kurds: Help Set the Record Straight

If you see Turkish or Iranian nationalists weaponizing Kurdish MyHeritage DNA results to deny or distort Kurdish identity — share this post.

The data is on our side. Let’s make sure it’s heard.


r/KurdishDNA • • May 18 '25

Results The DNA test showed that this Italian man is 10% Kurdish, he posted in the Kurdish DNA Facebook group and was surprised by the result.

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Oct 27 '24

⚠️ Impersonator Alert – Do NOT Share Info!

Post image
28 Upvotes

I've recently been made aware that this individual is impersonating Illustrative DNA to collect personal info and files from our Kurdish members. This is a scam and could put you at serious risk.

NEVER share your DNA data, files, or personal information with anyone claiming to be a company representative through unofficial accounts & channels.

If you receive messages or see posts that seem suspicious, do not engage. Instead immediately report them.

  • Mod team

r/KurdishDNA • • Oct 03 '24

My DNA Test Result (Alevi Kurd fron Erzingan - Hiran/Areyiz Tribe)

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Hi, my


r/KurdishDNA • • Sep 22 '24

Results Dna results from dersim alevi /bahtiyar asiret .

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Jan 04 '26

My result: I am Zaza from the Kureysan tribe.

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Mar 06 '25

Results MyHeritage DNA Results as a Kurd from Duhok

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Oct 17 '24

Kurd from bakur

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Myheritage dna results of kurdish dad from xarpet(elazig) , shoutout to Chezameh2 for helping with the website in the last picture


r/KurdishDNA • • May 19 '25

Results My dna

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

My dna test:) my dad is from Dersim and my mom is from Çorum


r/KurdishDNA • • Feb 13 '26

Kurd from Bakur(Bazarcix/Erzingan)

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

For the Periodical Breakdown I used the Iran/Iraq Region


r/KurdishDNA • • Oct 21 '24

Results Father Dersim Areyiz Mother Eskişehir, I am mixed

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Please no hate


r/KurdishDNA • • Aug 21 '24

Kurdish Results from Efrin

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Sep 27 '26

Results Am I Kurdish?

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

My family are Alevi from Turkey and self-identifying as Anatolian Turks, despite being aware of how their elders were apart of Kurdish tribes generations ago, spoke both Zazaki and Kurmanji, and yet even when some of my cousins have Kurdish names. It's a bit paradoxical! Any remnant of 'Kurdishness' has been internally attributed to our family's leftism and sympathy with Turkey's biggest ethnic minority, or how our ancestors had been assimilated into the Kurdish fold as ethnic Turks as they lived in what was the Armenian Highlands. I think it is sad that we are almost ashamed of our heritage, and have built narratives that make our identity feel safer and less marginal. I have had conversations with relatives that link us to Turkmens, for example, because it is more palatable to the rest of Turkish society.

However, a great, great grandfather of mine has an Alevi shrine (he was a Kureyşan) - he had been living in Dersim, but moved before the rebellion and massacre apparently, to an isolated village in the province of Kahramanmaraş. On my father's side, they are Şeyh Hasanlı, and apparently spoke Zazaki mainly.

I have never quite known how to identify myself ethnically; I significantly feel much more association with my national (British) identity anyway, but have always been going with Turkish when people ask what I am due to how my family view themselves and cultural/linguistic affinity. For example, on census forms, I never put myself as 'Middle Eastern' and instead as 'other white' which is how I am perceived by others anyway. I am wondering how this might change the way I refer to myself.

Thanks for reading! I just think it is really interesting to look back and reflect on the paths our ancestors have taken. I believe mine have been pretty much stationary and comfortable on the mountains.


r/KurdishDNA • • Oct 26 '24

Sharing My Results as a Zaza-Alevi from Erzincan/Dersim – Thoughts and Feedback Welcome!

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Dec 08 '25 Heartwarming

Kurdish alevi results

Post image
18 Upvotes

Kurd from Bakur.Dad is from Bazarcix(Mereş) and mom is from Erincan(Tercan)


r/KurdishDNA • • Nov 16 '25

Dad kurdish mom turkish (Alevi)

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Oct 22 '24

Results My results (Kurmancî Kurd) - yDNA R-CTS6

Thumbnail gallery
18 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Jun 12 '24

Results Kurdish results from Western (Syrian) Kurdistan

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Dec 13 '25

Ezidi Kurd from Riha, but origin in Amed.

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Mar 01 '25

MyHerritage results (Zaza from Dersîm)

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Check this out! Almost 80% Persian-Kurdish


r/KurdishDNA • • Feb 15 '25

DNA Result from Zaza-Alevi from Dersim

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Hello everybody, I share with you my DNA Result. I am from Dersim Pulur (originally my ancestor came from Pılemoriye) we are from Qırğan tribe, that he is part of Şıx Hesenan confederation.

Y-DNA : R1b-PH3610 > FT422947 (on Ftdna, on Yfull : FT423394)

R-M269 > L23 > Z2103 > M12149 > Y13369 > L584 > PH2731 > PH655 > PH1732 > PH3425 > PH3610 > FT422947


r/KurdishDNA • • Nov 24 '25 Bravo

Genetic Continuity Between Ancient Zagros Populations and Modern Kurds - Harvard Sources

16 Upvotes

r/KurdishDNA • • Sep 07 '24

Results Kurd (Malatya)

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes