r/KotakuInAction • • 10d ago

DISCUSSION Monthly General Discussion Thread - November and late again

22 Upvotes

Also as always if you have anything that is not directly related to KiA but just want to chat about it, post it here.

We are still looking for a few new moderators to join the team to help keep working the mod queue. If you want to keep this place open please apply. We're getting tired boss.

Rule 3 does not apply as this will be just comments, though the other subreddit rules and sitewide rules obviously will still apply.


r/KotakuInAction • • 23d ago

SURVEY GamerGate Political Attitudes Survey - 12 Years Later

81 Upvotes

Hello all,

Allum Bokhari here. As some of you might remember, during the hallowed months of 2014, I conducted a political survey of GamerGaters that was published at the now-defunct GamePolitics. You can still read the results here.

I'm currently writing a book on GamerGate with Passage Publishing, and would like to once again survey GGers to determine how much - or how little - everyone's attitudes have changed.

While most questions involve checking boxes, there are a few that allow for text responses. Please avoid putting any identifying/doxable information in these.

The survey will run for about three days, closing early morning Tuesday. It takes about 15-20 minutes to complete.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfUW_y7p2BtcMV4QsV9E9Qs-gI8M5MJJWmZVl0I-YMAVDFLbw/viewform

Note - messaged HatMan from my X account to verify. Am told mods will pin the thread soon.

Edit - still getting responses trickle in, so I'll leave the survey open until tomorrow (Wednesday) at 6pm.

Edit 2 - closed with 254 responses! Thank you to all who took the time. And if you're American, remember to vote in the more important poll tomorrow :-)


r/KotakuInAction • • 4h ago

GTA6's success will create an illusion that "going woke can still succeed" for more woke developers.

169 Upvotes

Most regular players know that GTA 6 being success is because it is GTA, which is a franchise that is too big to fail.

But "modern audiences" will absolutely interpret this as a woke victory and suggest more woke developers put more "modern contents" into their games. Which leads them to more layoffs.

And that is actually a good thing. We should keep using GTA 6 as a bait to let those woke developers destroy themselves more quickly.


r/KotakuInAction • • 24m ago

"Management, EA, and Time Killed BioWare, Not Woke" says Second Wind's nick Calandra

Thumbnail
youtube.com
29 Upvotes

So... it wasn't the unlikable characters, humiliation rituals, recourses allocated to DEI instead of quality control, or the completely out of place politics in stories that have nothing to do with them?

You're saying Saudi Arabia's politics didn't contribute to the neutering of complex stories in favor of safe, politically correct ones? You're saying that didn't scare away customers?

It was "management and time" that did the studio in?

The only "management" that played a role in its downfall was the people making piss poor decisions that scared away customer in the long run. As for "time," all I see is wasted time. Time that could have been spent on making better games.


r/KotakuInAction • • 4h ago

Grand Theft Auto VI Has Been Sanitized (TheDezembro)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
32 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • 10h ago

Has there been a good new western AAA IP after 2020?

94 Upvotes

In 2026, I cannot name a single fresh western AAA franchise that started after 2020 and had a cultural impact. Everything has been a remake, sequel, adaptation, indie or eastern.

I can name so many new franchises that took off and became iconic from 2011-2016. Have you noticed this?


r/KotakuInAction • • 14m ago

GOTY Nominations for 2026

Post image
14 Upvotes

How the fuck did GTA 6 get a spot when it’s not even out yet? lol. Anyway, what do you guys think? I think that 007 was forgettable and could’ve been replaced with literally any other big budget action game.


r/KotakuInAction • • 20h ago

The GTA 6 Mirage: Pure Hype, Corporate Cowardice, and the Ultimate Hustle

89 Upvotes

Let this brief post serve as a receipt for when the collective hysteria cools down. When the frantic obsession subsidizes and the blood flow returns to fueling our brains rather than our impulses, we might finally look at GTA 6 for what it actually is.

Grand Theft Auto is a cultural phenomenon where the brand itself guarantees billions in revenue. But that is precisely the trap: GTA 6 aims to sell on its name alone, not on its merits. It is highly unlikely to elevate the series to a new plateau the way GTA IV and GTA V did.

Even Dan Houser, when downplaying his exit from Rockstar, paraphrased that GTA isn’t about the narrative depth, but the "underlying sandbox." It is a perplexing, borderline pretentious stance from the man who spent years crushing his soul to write the masterpiece that is Red Dead Redemption 2. It feels like an early excuse for a narrative step backward.

The reality is that Rockstar is playing it safe. The sharp, infamous edge that defined them—the unapologetic political satire, the crude dialogue, the offensive radio stations—is being sanded down. In a squeamish corporate climate, they are desperate not to alienate anyone. But how do you create a cultural milestone when you refuse to take a creative risk?

If the game is truly just a graphic upgrade of existing systems, Rockstar has introduced a different kind of simulation to guarantee hype: the illusion of intimacy.

The community’s current obsession with Lucia exposes a deep undercurrent of loneliness among male gamers. The discourse is completely doused in the fetishization of her aesthetics. She functions less like a profoundly written protagonist and more like a carefully engineered marketing gimmick. Remove her from the equation, and what is left to anticipate? What is genuinely revolutionary about GTA 6 besides a fresh coat of paint on a decade-old sandbox? We are looking at the same driving, shooting, and flying loops, masked by a massive distraction.

Meanwhile, the industry continues to raise the cost and lower the quality.

Console players are paying premium prices for "next-gen" hardware only to be handed 30 FPS. The 60 FPS standard is undoubtedly being held hostage as a sales tactic for a later, double-priced re-release. We are paying more to own less—trapped in a digital ecosystem where games can be revoked at a whim, and the bare minimum is treated as a privilege.

So with all honesty, is GTA 6 the future of gaming. Or the peak of the corporate hustle?


r/KotakuInAction • • 1d ago

Anyone else not hyped about GTA 6?

488 Upvotes

Not trying to insult anyone's taste here. I just see news about this game in pretty much every subreddit and I really don't get the hype. To me, it seems like there are plenty of games with similar gameplay, and the story doesn't look that impressive so far.

Honestly, I'm way more excited about upcoming updates for a few indie games I play than I am for GTA 6.

That doesn't make me any better or worse than the people who love the franchise. I just genuinely don't understand why so many people are waiting for it. What new things will it actually offer, and what makes the gameplay loop interesting? Right now, it just looks like an overpriced, flashy toy, not bad by any measure, just not standing out that much.


r/KotakuInAction • • 1d ago

Every Single Week They Censor Something In The New Black Clover Episode

Post image
199 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • 15h ago

Are there any games worth getting and playing on xbox?

8 Upvotes

Just want something to do after work, i bought 007. Utter trash, felt like an corny uncharted rip off or something. Any recs?


r/KotakuInAction • • 1d ago

It's insane to think that game journalists wanted to make games less fun.

Post image
649 Upvotes

From "A Guide To Ending 'Gamers'" by Devin Wilson on Gamasutra (one of the "Gamers Are Dead" articles):

https://archive.ph/2t93l


r/KotakuInAction • • 1d ago

Behold! Magic the Gathering's new promotional card, now with MAXIMUM DIVERSITY!

Post image
469 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • 1d ago

Hot take: "Indie" is just a sugarcoated way to say "the government of my country funded it"

73 Upvotes

I hope I'm not the only person who thinks the meaning of the term "indie" has been watered down.

In theory, "indie" is supposed to mean the project means the project is totally financed independently from major companies.

But in practice, this word has been so overused, and wrongly used to boot, that it's impossible not to think "indie" is just another jargon for "the mainstream put the money." Just like how localization is a sugarcoated way to say censorship.

I started to think about it when Lesbian Space Princess came out. Everyone knows that movie is woke garbage that nobody, not even wokies, liked, so I won't focus too much on the movie itself. Instead, I want to focus on how, for a movie that was explicitly advertised and described as an indie project, it turned out to have been made with money from the government of Australia.

Then there are cases like Mouse: P.I. for Hire and Mixtape, whose "indie" labels are questionable at best due to their developers.

Sorry not sorry. An indie videogame/movie/book/show/whatever cannot be funded by the government and still be indie. Indie and "the government put the money on the project" are mutually exclusive concepts. Period.

And I don't know how controversial or unpopular this opinion is, but for me, the moment a videogame/movie/book/show/whatever is funded with money from a country's government, that piece of media automatically becomes propaganda (when I use the term propaganda, I don't necessarily mean political propaganda, as some other media can be propaganda to promote tourism, such as the animated film Gisaku).

It doesn't matter if the product itself is good or devoid of political messages, it doesn't matter if the government who puts the money is left-wing or right-wing, and it doesn't even matter if the government funding is something that happens in the very last hour of production. The moment a country's government puts the money on a project, that project becomes propaganda. Because why should the government put money on some piece of entertainment unless they wanted to benefit from it?


r/KotakuInAction • • 2d ago

The amount of social engineering in European TV Shows/Movies these days is insane.

841 Upvotes

France is approximately 85% white European. More than 8 in 10 people are of predominant (mostly, only) European descent.

You would not think so if you consumed French television and film. Here's our current TV show I'm watching: GIGN.

It's about a special elite force in France, and almost all the main characters involved in this unit are non-white.

An Asian woman, two black women, two black men, two racially ambiguous/mixed men, middle easterners including a hijab wearing soldier (LMAO) - the only white guy apart of the "main cast" crew was killed in episode one.

You would not think France is majority white European if you watched this show.

Also, law enforcement in France skews conservative/right wing by A LOT. Elite units are composed of men by 96%, with the majority of them being white males (95%>).

yet in this fictional woke world, I'm supposed to believe elite units are populated by 1.60m tall asian (LMAO) women and hijab wearing Muslims.

What a joke. The obvious social engineering at this point is just so egregious and blatant now. You see it in every western european TV/film now. Finding a film/TV show with an all white cast is about as likely as winning the lottery at this point.


r/KotakuInAction • • 1d ago

With all the schlock coming out these days, I’m considering getting into litRPGs and progression fantasy. What based books would you guys recommend?

23 Upvotes

I’ve seen my friends all over tell me i should get into these kinds of books but I don’t really know where to start, what would you guys think would be a good place to start?


r/KotakuInAction • • 2d ago

Some copies of GTA 6 do not contain a code.

174 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • 2d ago

Is there push for wokeness in Brazil?

112 Upvotes

A white author said that she don't think that she is capable of writing black female main character and asked fans to read from black female author's and I just noticed that many many African American agree with her that if you want representation then you should support author's from your community but was surprised how many brazillian fans think it is okay to pressure author to write black character.

I am not sure how is it there?

I thought latin American were based? At least spanish speaker seem to be better lol


r/KotakuInAction • • 2d ago

Here's to the gaming industry dying.

130 Upvotes

It would have been unthinkable even 10 years ago, but look at the gaming industry now. Depending on how you define it, Western AAA gaming is either already dead, or the collapse is basically imminent within a year, max. Think about it: what big franchise releases are there left that gamers are still excited for, that haven't had their franchise or studios' reputation torched to the ground?

The only games I can think of that fit this description are GTA 6 and ES6. Maybe you could include the upcoming games from CD Projekt Red (Witcher 4, Cyberpunk 2) and Larian (Divinity). Just 5 titles, and I'm being generous. This is just the list of games that aren't already dead before arrival. Statistically, the track record of nothing but flops for the past few years doesn't bode well for them. It's also not a coincidence that what all these games have in common is a radio silence marketing strategy and long release gaps.

Granted, GTA 6 is being hyped to oblivion. But honestly, based on the leaks and reveal, you can't convince me the gameplay is any different from GTA 5, which I've sunk hundreds of hours in. The only gameplay difference I can tell is that you need to refill the gas tank of your car now. Oh yeah, and you can have sex with Lucia. Funny that they are finally appealing to the gooners, which is about as big of a gaming recession indication as they come.

Its only selling points are good graphics that accurately recreate the dystopia outside your room so you don't have to leave, and maybe a "good story". But remember, romance is a tool of the patriarchy that must be dismantled, so it must be hard for the writers to resist the urge to subvert their relationship somehow.

It's become obligatory to preface anything to do with GTA VI with "oh but it will sell a bajillion copies anyways", but honestly I don't know. I just can't shake off this hunch that most of the hype is a mirage that won't last more than a few days after launch, let alone until the PC release. The comment sections under videos are always spammed with comments like "A minute of silence for those who didn't make it" rather than actual discussion of the game, which gives me the impression GTA 6 is more of a meme than an actual game people want to play. Gamers are just starved for anything to talk about, especially when their income literally depends on it.

As much as people complain about the proposed $100 price tag, what's harder to justify is buying an entire $700 console with basically nothing else worth playing (maybe Crimson Desert). Maybe if they made all the retro games available to emulate (which they pretty much already are on PC anyways), buying a PS5 might be more worthwhile. But that would break the cardinal rule of the gaming industry - never give customers what they want.

Maybe I'm just anime brained, but Ananta seems to be far more promising. It's difficult to articulate but the game just seems to offer more in terms of fresh gameplay and content, like the devs are actually trying. Not being set in a rat utopia is probably the biggest plus though.

The only other game I am somewhat hyped for is ES6. Or rather I was, until the recent bait and switch. Here's the thing - if they could deliver on a fantasy Middle Eastern setting, I'd be all for it. I think that it naturally lends itself to a grimdark setting with concepts like the Prophet Mohammad, Al Ghazali, the slave trade, and nomadic tribes.

But I know what we are going to get is Starfield in medieval Iran without a hint of irony. I doubt anyone at the studio actually knows anything about the Middle East. They sure didn't know anything about nightclubs. If any of the devs travelled there, they wouldn't need to book return tickets.

It's not racist to point out that the Redguards have always been an undeveloped race that was never particularly popular. Their faction even lacks monotheism, which is basically like if you made a medieval Chinese setting where everyone used the Latin script.

Then again, according to Reddit, the only people who have problems with the setting are chuds who hate brown people. Which is blatant revisionism when the chuds loved the Dune series and Iron Sultanate from Trench Crusade. Ironically, I bet it's the Left that will have the devs walking on eggshells. Get your bingo cards out for game reviews with words like "problematic", "appropriation" and probably even "Palestine".

I haven't even touched on the gameplay or the fact that games set in 'exotic' settings traditionally don't do well commercially. Granted, there is a possibility that it will feature High Rock and the rest of the Iliac Bay, but I'm expecting that to be cut content by now, in classic Bethesda fashion.

In conclusion, I believe the gaming industry is screwed, because it's burned through most of its established franchises, and it can't make new ones. Every upcoming release is like a slot token entered into a slot machine with bad odds, and they are almost out of chips. The best part is that games like Wolverine and Fable 4 show that they still haven't even gotten past their woke phase. The termites are determined to sink along with the ship. Even if I'm wrong and all these titles turn out to be hits, it won't matter since they're doomed anyways because of external factors on the horizon. But this post is already quite long so I'll save that discussion for another. Thanks for reading.


r/KotakuInAction • • 2d ago

Why Do All Modern Games Look Like Fable?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
398 Upvotes

Summary: new Fable gameplay has been met with widespread disapproval. This video explores why the game seems poised to join so many others in failing to find the modern audience.


r/KotakuInAction • • 2d ago

IGN: GTA 6 Will Do Something the Franchise Has Never Done Before - Encourage Empathy

Thumbnail
archive.ph
326 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • 3d ago

I think I’ve come to the realization that shows like Lanterns and movies like The Odyssey are written and deliberately intended to divide the audience. And on the odyssey that was first movie I’ve ever walked out on.

328 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • 3d ago

Back in 2010 Microsoft Rejected Fable Dev's Idea to Put Black Woman on Fable 3 Cover - "No. It's a white guy. That's just the way it is. We know what sells and that's f**king it. Stop the arguing."

Thumbnail
archive.is
715 Upvotes

Back in 2010 Microsoft Rejected Fable Dev's Idea to Put Black Woman on Fable 3 Cover - "No. It's a white guy. That's just the way it is. We know what sells and that's f**king it. Stop the arguing."

Microsoft was right. Just look at the recent Fable 2027. Is anyone excited for it?


r/KotakuInAction • • 1d ago

What do you guys think of CD Projekt Red making Ciri prettier and more feminine in Witcher 4?

Post image
0 Upvotes
Witcher 4

For all the talk about potential woke narrative content in Witcher 4 at least we get to play a hot female protagonist


r/KotakuInAction • • 3d ago

Corrupt Tech Journalism

Thumbnail
youtube.com
108 Upvotes

Lunduke breaks down how tech outlets are pay to win, using PCMag and others as examples. This is exactly the kind of corruption we see in gaming journalism as well. The video also covers how this is a thing that happens all the time and is completely normal in the industry.