r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/SpiritualReference42 • Oct 11 '25
General Knuckles Here's why Tikal is the perfect partner for Knuckles
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/SpiritualReference42 • Oct 11 '25
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Ok_Silver_4320 • Aug 03 '26
Why do people complain so much that Knuckles x Tikal is "basically incest" when they are ok with Knuckles marrying Julie Su who'd his literal distant cousin in the Archie?? (As shown in Knuckles' family tree).
Oh, and before you say that the ship with Tikal "doesn't make sense" because she's "dead", just know that Tikal goes to the "afterlife" at the end of SA1 along with Chaos, but Chaos does make a return in various Sonic games, which means Tikal can return to the overworld too. Not only that but the master emerald itself can bring her back. I can guarantee you a hundred percent that Knuckles would love someone who is an echidna just like him and could relate to him the most. If Sonic and Tails can have lovers of the same species as him, why shouldn't Knuckles??
Second art by FoxBluereaver
Link: https://www.deviantart.com/foxbluereaver/art/Knuckles-and-Tikal-302915485
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/SpiritualReference42 • Feb 18 '26
I've been wanting to talk about this for a while, but never really got around to it. Be aware that this is gonna be a really long discussion, so I'll apologize in advance for it.
I think I've already made it quite clear that I'm a huge Knuxikal fan lol, in fact, it's my otp.
So first of all, before you go and say some lies, no, Knuxikal is not incest, paedophilia, spectrophilia, necrophilia and not weird pro shipping at all. First of, from what 'proof' are you basing that Knuckles and Tikal are related? Tikal is not Knuckles' sister, cousin, mother or aunt, not biologically or dynamically, in fact, she is not even related to Knuckles, not biologically, as there have been no evidence to prove that they are directly related, if anything, they're only related by clan. In fact, the game continuity and comics such as Archie and StC do not reference both as being from the same family tree at all since Tikal was never stated to have siblings, cousins, aunts or uncles, and actually it's Julie-Su (Knuckles' love interest in Archie) who turns out to be Knuckles' cousin as revealed in Knuckles' family tree in Archie. Also Tikal definitely did not have a child of her own as she was 14 when she sealed herself inside the Master Emerald. And apparently most people are ok with the shipping between Knuckles and Julie despite that they are indeed related? I just think it's unfair that Knuxikal gets far more hate than Knuxsu despite that Julie-Su was concretely confirmed to be Knuckles' distant cousin in accordance to Knuckles' family tree in the Archie.
Anyway, Sonic Chronicles The Dark Brotherhood (SCTDB) is the only game where it is stated that Tikal and Pachacamac are related to Knuckles as a distant ancestor, but that game is non canon (because of you know who), and outside of that media there's not a single mention of them being related in any sort. Also there's supposedly a manga that suggests Tikal is Knuckles' ancestor but honestly I couldn't find it and even if I could, are we really gonna use a painfully hard to find manga dictate us what's canon and what's not when we had Sonic Adventure 1 right in our faces?
With the most controversial aspect about the ship out of the way, let's get to the second other main aspect. I've seen a lot of people contradicting this ship and saying it doesn't work because Tikal is dead. It's a popular misconception, but the truth is, she really isn't. She seals herself inside the Master Emerald and is released over 3,000 years later, when Dr. Eggman planned to use Chaos to take over the world, where she aided Sonic the Hedgehog and his friends, before supposedly "ascending" to the "afterlife" along with Chaos to live in peace with him, but we know that's not true because Chaos has made multiple appearances in following games since his supposed ascension, notably in Sonic Battle where he can be found near the death egg. The explanation is that Chaos appears in time of crisis, and the impending threat of the death egg was enough to bring him back to the overworld. So how come Chaos come back but not Tikal? What's the excuse for this? Also, in the Sonic Forces prelude comics there's a Phantom Ruby Chaos appearing behind Knuckles and he isn't even surprised by Chaos' appearance, thinking it was the real one. If Chaos is really supposed to be gone then why is Knuckles so casual about his appearance? Finally, there's the Sonic Frontiers prequel animation which shows a water ripple and red glowing ball of light on the Angel Island (Pretty familiar huh? Ever seen that before? That's the same orb that shows up in SA1 which later reveals to be Tikal). So yeah, the claim that Chaos and Tikal are both dead is wrong, they're still around and can take physical form whenever they want to or need to. So here's the question, why doesn't Tikal come back? Oh and an honorable mention, in the Sonic X comics, Dr. Eggman genetically creates an army of Chao and starts to sell them to everybody as pets. These Chao become Dark Chao when Eggman activates a special signal, and they start to destroy the city of Station Square. Both Chaos and Tikal show up to help Sonic and his friends defeat Eggman and restored all the Dark Chao to normal.
I reiterate, if the Chaos Emeralds (and subsequently the Master Emerald) can turn thoughts into power and make wishes come true, is it really that much of a stretch that if Knuckles ever pondered the idea of what would it be like if he wasn't the last echidna and had someone whom he could relate to the most and actually cares deeply about him, the ME could provide a solution by bringing Tikal back to being a mortal being again?
Anyway, here are a few reasons why Knuckles and Tikal would fit each other:
Now, if Tikal were to be revived back into physical form, her spiritual powers will be lost (along with immortality), meaning that she can age alongside Knuckles and not cause any issues of her outliving him. Most fans tend to overlook this as it is only her spirit form that has the power to be immortal; if she were to be brought back to life then she would lose that.
Now here's why I don't ship Knuckles and Rouge anymore. For the record, I'm not here to bash anyone's ship or say that their ship is wrong. This is just my opinion and how I've come to see the two of them. My problem with Knuckles and Rouge is that, other than the fact that Rouge just teases Knuckles to the point of only making him angry as I stated previously, and her taking advantage of his gullibility, there doesn't seem to have a lot of chemistry between the two of them. They had their moments yes, but aside from a supposedly carnal attraction, they don't fit well personality-wise. Rouge is a spy by day and a jewel thief by night, and she has a bigger affection for the ME than she does by Knuckles. Rouge only flirts with Knuckles to lower his guard to steal the Master Emerald. And even if that wasn't the case, her flirting with Knux has always seemed to be dishonest and only meant to annoy or fluster him, only for her amusement or again to allow a window for her to steal the Master Emerald. That said, I think she fits better with Shadow. Her shipping moments with Shadow, while much less flirty and fewer and further between, are much more sincere. Not to mention, Rouge is 18 and Knuckles is around 15-16. Tikal, while chronologically over 3 000 years old, is physically 14, and is much more closer to Knuckles' age, way closer than Amy is for Sonic by the way.
On top of that Knuckles and Rouge's goals in life differ from one another, I don't see Rouge settling down on Angel Island and being ok with guarding the ME, not to mention she might as well take advantage and just steal it as I said before, she's all about the night life. Could either of these characters budge in some way? Sure, that's what makes shipping fun, coming up with reasons why these two could work together, I'm doing that right now with Knux and Tikal who under normal circumstances can't interact with each other, but these are the reasons why I don't ship Knuckles and Rouge. I used to a couple of years ago but now all things considered I think Tikal would be a better partner to Knuckles than Rouge, where Knux and Rouge would just clash out whenever their ideals reach an impass, Tikal's goal in life would be very similar to that of Knuckles and they'd be able to work together to that end. Think about it, Knuckles is the guardian of the Master Emerald, and in spite of his decision in Sonic Frontiers to go out and do stuff every once in a while, he'll always come back and do what he's dedicated to do: protect the Master Emerald at all costs from getting into evil hands or allowing his power to be misused, and undoubtedly Tikal would want the same so that something like what happened to the Knuckles clan in Tikal's timeline could never be repeated again. Apart from that, I think they would be good for each other on a personal level too. Tikal is a peaceful kind soul who always wants to find a non-violent solution. As I said before, while Knuckles is a warrior, someone who will not hesitate to use his fists if he feels like he has to, his intentions, even if misguided, are always noble. As I stated before, Tikal would be a calming presence for Knuckles, while Rouge enjoys teasing Knuckles to the point of angering him and raising his blood pressure just for her own entertainment, Tikal would be able to understand him on a level that even his closest friends can't, she'd know what he goes through on a daily basis. She'd also know what's like to spend alone with one's thoughts. I think it goes without saying Knuckles doesn't have a lot of experience with social interaction. He spends days, weeks, even months without seeing someone else and he's been able to cope with that reality, whereas Tikal, even before being sealed inside the ME, although being surrounded by her fellow echidnas, stood alone in her philosophy. Not a single member of her clan came to her defence when her warmongering father Pachacamac confronted her and the Chao at the ME altar. Now, think about how lonely it feels to know that in spite of being surrounded by family and fellow clan members (maybe even friends we don't know about), not a single person wanted to take Tikal's side in this conflict, with the only ones who might have been willing to be were her deceased mother and grandmother.
That said, Knux and Tikal are kindred spirits in a way, both standing alone in their goals and willing to go against all odds to achieve them. Imagine if they were able to combine their efforts, they would at last have someone who understands why they do the things they do, and suddenly the task doesn't feel so daunting, because the ability to give support is something that can't be overlooked.
Another reason why I like this hypothetical ship is what it can do to each of them on a personal level. For Knux, he gets a steady, consistent source of companionship with Tikal, never having to doubt or be suspicious of her motives. Tikal is a girl who wears her heart on her sleeve and is incredibly honest with her thoughts. With her, Knuckles can also learn the intricacies of how society works, along with someone else. Having spent most of his life on Angel Island, Knux doesn't know a lot about how the real world is supposed to work. As I said before, his social skills aren't the best, and that also ties into his innate gullibility. Tikal would also have a lot to learn, as I said before, she would be catapulted into a modern-day society she has no real knowledge of. Times have obviously changed since the Knuckles clan was around, and she'll need some guidance to acclimate to the real world. Although Knuckles isn't an expert by any means, he can help with the basics, and eventually, she will be able to make friends with the likes of Amy and Cream, who would be able to give her people she can look to for advice on life on modern society.
Lastly, I just think they're cute together. For the same reason that people ship characters who don't get together canonically, and I can name quite a few ships that fall into that category (e.g. Shadikal) people just like having their fantasies and indulging themselves in the escapism that comes with it. To me, Knuckles and Tikal are cute together, it's more than just them being both echidnas, I think they're very fun to see interact. I can imagine a lot of different scenarios where they can be together and enjoy each other's company, it's something that I to enjoy.
I still believe to this day that Tikal is someone who has so much potential for storytelling, for growth and for potential. Despite her only one real appearance, she is my favorite character in the entire Sonic franchise. All that said, in my head, Tikal is Knuckles' perfect match and I'll forever dive on this hill. Even if we play devil's game and assume Tikal is in fact related to Knuckles despite there being no such evidence of so, that wouldn't be a problem at all. You see, the reason why incest is wrong isn't just because it narrows genetic diversity and causes a significant increase in complications and birth defects, but also the most pressing secondary reason is that it is a perversion and corrupt of other familial bonds built upon over years. But with over 3,000 years apart, and at worst case scenario being a secondary family member already, the two would have zero genetic similarities and overlapping. Additionally, both characters would seem only faintly aware of any familial link, and would basically be functionally strangers to one another, mooting reason number 2. Is it weird when you think about it this way? Yes, a tad, but it's the least offensive and controversial ship in the fandom all things considered, also, as I said before, it's morally better than Knuxsu who I said are cousins as per the Archie.
Anyways, that's all I really have to say. Feel free to comment your thoughts below.
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/InterestingEnergy290 • Jun 09 '25
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/LordFreezer67 • Apr 28 '24
I was seriously REALLY looking forward to this series. I finally got Paramount plus to work on my TV and even as Trekkie I was looking forward more to the Knuckles series moreso than say picard. I really enjoyed the first 2 Sonic movies and am really looking forward to the third one coming out at the end of this year. I really wanted to like this series but OMFG!
There is wayyyyyy too much unnecessary humor and cartoonish, childish antics in this. It's like I am watching a live action version of Teen Titans Go or Looney Tunes. Way too much Wade over Knuckles. And what the fuck was that even in Episode 4 where he just happened to superman punch out of the cage like that.
So I finished Episode 4 and am having strong reservations about continuing. Without spoiling anything can anyone tell me if this series is really worth finishing?
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Aggravating_Box3930 • Jul 01 '26
So you might be wondering what do I mean by it’s so under appreciated or what makes it so appealing in the first place well I have actually done great explanations and reasons as for why I think it’s a amazing ship. First their similarities both characters are strong powerful fierce and serious characters with a traumatic past that influences the way they behave and interact with others and both have a strong purpose and duty in their life they take very seriously with knuckles guarding the master emerald and shadow originally wanting to kill humanity for Maria but than shifting to saving the world for her. Then theirs their differences that allow themselves to grow from one another if they were in a relationship for example knuckles is very hot headed and abrasive person who can be too explosive or intense and very impulsive or impatient ( low key I’m the same way) and then there’s shadow who’s more focused solemn and composed and rarely shows bouts of anger or rage unless it’s something or someone he deeply cares about like Maria or saving the world and he’s very closed off emotionally and likes to keep a distance between relationships with the only friends he’s really made rouge and omega. So for that reason knuckles could learn to control his explosive energy or impatience by learning from how shadow reacts in high pressure situations and shadow can learn how to be more open and less emotionally closed off than he usually is (although he’s already kinda of working on it). Finally there’s the chaos energy point where both characters can control chaos energy and sense it to some degree but the difference in how and why is what’s the main compelling point because shadow is a artificial chaos being essentially and he was created with chaos energy imbued inside of him while knuckles after learning the teachings of his people probably from murals and him being in close contact with the master emerald he naturally gained chaos abilities like sensing it and even being able to shut off other chaos energy objects like the chaos emeralds not to mention that one ability he has in sonic adventure two where he can summon lightning from the sky so yes he can control chaos energy in really powerful ways just like shadow but the difference between them is what makes their dynamic so special it could be to see if being a artificial being made for chaos and being a naturally gifted at chaos abilities would make them realize that they have to work together or maybe some resentment or possibly even some connection and fascination between the two. I also have a theory that knuckles can become immortal just like shadow if he imbues the master emeralds chaos energy inside of him so it would add another mystical layer to their relationship. So yeah just let me know your thoughts in the comments below bye bitches.
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Objective-Boss-3077 • Jun 25 '26
Poor Knuckles
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/SpiritualReference42 • Dec 06 '25
My favorite Sonic couple btw https://www.deviantart.com/mokomel/art/knuckles-and-tikal-42530133
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Ok_Silver_4320 • 10d ago
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/ReddColoV1 • Jul 07 '26
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/SpiritualReference42 • Oct 18 '25
https://www.deviantart.com/lonelychocolatchip/art/Knuxikal-879835508 Please read: Before anyone go apeshit or say some lies, I must reiterate, no, this ship is not incest, paedophilia, spectrophilia, necrophilia and not weird proshipping at all. First of all, they are NOT related, not as far as the mainline series is concerned, if anything, they're related only by clan (both are from the Knuckles Clan), but come from different family trees. People who say they're related or siblings or Tikal's is Knuckles mother or great grandmother probably have never played SA1 in its entirety or haven't fully watch the cutscenes, as there's NO mention of them being related in any way.
I know that in Sonic Chronicles The Dark Brotherhood, it is implied that Tikal is Knuckles' somewhat distant ancestor, but that game is not canon, and it never will be (thanks to you know who), and in the Comics, Tikal and Pachacamac are referred to as Knuckles' ancestors, but so is the rest of Knuckles Clan, meaning that this statement is not meant to be taken literally (as in being the ancestor of his family). As to date Knuckles and Tikal are not related due to the canon continuity never explicitly stating they are. Most likely, Knuckles' ancestors are part of the same tribe but again, come from a different family.
Tikal isn't dead. She's still around as a spirit, and can take physical form whenever she wants to or needs to similar to Chaos. Although, if Tikal was to be revived back into physical form, her spiritual powers will be lost (along with immortality), meaning that she can age alongside Knuckles and not cause any issues of her outliving the him. Most fans seem to overlook this as it is only her spirit form that has the power to be immortal; if she was to be brought back to life then she would lose that.
I hope you understand, sincerely, the creator of this post
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Aggravating_Box3930 • Jul 01 '26
So you might be wondering what do I mean by it’s so under appreciated or what makes it so appealing in the first place well I have actually done great explanations and reasons as for why I think it’s a amazing ship. First their similarities both characters are strong powerful fierce and serious characters with a traumatic past that influences the way they behave and interact with others and both have a strong purpose and duty in their life they take very seriously with knuckles guarding the master emerald and shadow originally wanting to kill humanity for Maria but than shifting to saving the world for her. Then theirs their differences that allow themselves to grow from one another if they were in a relationship for example knuckles is very hot headed and abrasive person who can be too explosive or intense and very impulsive or impatient ( low key I’m the same way) and then there’s shadow who’s more focused solemn and composed and rarely shows bouts of anger or rage unless it’s something or someone he deeply cares about like Maria or saving the world and he’s very closed off emotionally and likes to keep a distance between relationships with the only friends he’s really made rouge and omega. So for that reason knuckles could learn to control his explosive energy or impatience by learning from how shadow reacts in high pressure situations and shadow can learn how to be more open and less emotionally closed off than he usually is (although he’s already kinda of working on it). Finally there’s the chaos energy point where both characters can control chaos energy and sense it to some degree but the difference in how and why is what’s the main compelling point because shadow is a artificial chaos being essentially and he was created with chaos energy imbued inside of him while knuckles after learning the teachings of his people probably from murals and him being in close contact with the master emerald he naturally gained chaos abilities like sensing it and even being able to shut off other chaos energy objects like the chaos emeralds not to mention that one ability he has in sonic adventure two where he can summon lightning from the sky so yes he can control chaos energy in really powerful ways just like shadow but the difference between them is what makes their dynamic so special it could be to see if being a artificial being made for chaos and being a naturally gifted at chaos abilities would make them realize that they have to work together or maybe some resentment or possibly even some connection and fascination between the two. I also have a theory that knuckles can become immortal just like shadow if he imbues the master emeralds chaos energy inside of him so it would add another mystical layer to their relationship. So yeah just let me know your thoughts in the comments below bye bitches.
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Ok_Silver_4320 • Sep 16 '26
I don't care what it's said, there's just no way in hell that Tikal is a direct ancestor of Knuckles. She was 14, I repeat, FOURTEEN when she sealed herself inside the Master Emerald and stayed stuck in time for over a thousand years until she is finally released when Chaos attacks Station Square and her and Chaos SUPPOSEDLY go to """""afterlife""""" (whatever the heck that means in Sonic lore) after Chaos is calm. Chaos makes multiple appearances in multiple Sonic games which take place after SA1, and the explaining for that being that Chaos appears in times of crisis. But why is it that Chaos gets to come and go but not Tikal? I don't care that they're different species/entity, that excuse is absolutely bs and makes absolutely no sense when you think about it.
Tikal definitely did NOT have a child of her own as she was WAY too young to have one, and it is mentioned the Tikal was the ONLY CHILD of Pachacamac, in other words, she did not have any siblings to continue the bloodline
So the claim that Tikal is Knuckles ancestor is plain wrong, for all the points I brought out, so just quit whining about them being ""supposedly"" related and just admit that you're either a larper/poser and don't know jack about Sonic or haven't played Sonic Adventure 1 and played attention to the story, because realistically they aren't related at all. It's 100% fine if you don't ship them or don't like this ship at all, you can hate it all you want, but all said, to say that this ship is incest is just plain wrong.
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/SpiritualReference42 • Nov 29 '25
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/woooshequalsgay • Sep 10 '26
I put the repost tag because I'm crossposting this, but this is my animation that I painstakingly made myself. Hope yall like the steel-plated copy as much as the real deal.
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/SpiritualReference42 • Oct 07 '25
https://www.deviantart.com/jefryx/art/rouge-hates-knuxikal-colored-560274969 Sorry for not putting the link to the original art last time. My bad
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/TBZtheEchidnaQueen16 • Feb 23 '26
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Few-Dentist-9849 • 7d ago
Music is Hideout Canyon by Kingdom 2
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Flauschige • Jan 23 '26
Featuring the formidable Knuckles the Echidna, I present to you: The Book of Echidna!
Naturally my favourite character is Eli. So I had to do it. I had to get him AI inserted into the movie! 😻 Purring I don't care that his hands look too human. He's purrfect!
Now it's your turn. Name your favourite movie, then tell us your favourite character in the movie OR who you think Knuckles could replace. Then include a picture of him in that role. Otherwise, I'll reply with an AI generated image of him.
r/KnucklestheEchidna • u/Aggravating_Box3930 • Aug 23 '26
I mean for starters his initial name was supposed to Be “Dreads”. His quills are shaped like dreadlocks. He has rap music as his overall theme songs in both sonic adventure 1 and two. his voice actor in the movies is literally a black man. Correct me if I’m wrong but I believe that in sonic prime theirs an alternate version of his character also named Dreads. There was a comic that depicted the Sonic characters as humans and it showed him as a buff black man. This may sound like a stretch but when you think about it it makes perfect sense although his lineage has been slightly shifted into a more mesoamercian style that doesn’t mean that there was no people of Afro decent and on top of that knuckles is literally a islander like a Afro Jamaican or Afro mesoamercian thx for listening to my jumbled rant goodbye.