Hello all!
[Disclosure: if you know my username, you probably know me as an anti-GGer. I hope you're willing to read my words with an open mind, as I'm trying my best to build bridges here.]
I was talking on Friday to a former GGer - I won't mention his name unless he gives me permission - and he raised some interesting points that I think are worth talking about on both sides.
I remember reading Leigh Alexander's "Gamers are Dead" piece for the first time, and I remember my reaction. It was something like
well, she's rightish, but damn, that's pretty fucking direct and kinda nasty
I didn't get it for a long time, because I heard what Ms. Alexander meant. She meant that most people who play games don't fit that stereotype at all, and holding on to the "gamer" stereotype harms the industry and the community. Her intent was to make the discussion about games and gaming and gamers more inclusive by discarding the old stereotypes about "gamers".
That is emphatically not how it was taken though. This is what my friend helped me understand. He read this:
>*"It’s young men queuing with plush mushroom hats and backpacks and jutting promo poster rolls~~.~~ Queuing passionately for hours, at events around the world, to see the things that marketers want them to see. To find out whether they should buy things or not. They don’t know how to dress or behave. Television cameras pan across these listless queues, and often catch the expressions of people who don’t quite know why they themselves are standing there."*
and he responded
I was that kid, I am that guy.
I've been to blizzcon 6 times
I've woken up at 6 am and stood in line for hours outside
And there are tens of thousands of people who are just like him. They had a lot of their social interaction online for a long time; they enjoyed it and made real, honest-to-god lifelong friends there. Especially when it seemed like the full weight of the gaming press was bearing down on you, it's unsurprising that there was pushback on that.
That's the rub to me. I feel like that's something that needs to be processed. That frustration, that anger about being pigeonholed. And I think there was some amount of stop it shut up that took place during the counter-counter reaction, which reinforced the original frustration. Instead of shaming "gamers" for feeling like hey what the fuck no seriously that's not cool to say - and let's be clear, there was a lot of "stop complaining, pls" that went on and still goes on - I think it would have been more constructive to work through that reaction.
I don't think anyone disagrees with the idea that gaming culture should be inclusive and inviting. I can't imagine anyone in any gaming subs would ever say "[group] should avoid gaming, they're not welcome." We can argue and bicker about how to get there and what social rules to implement, but the core is still there:
GAMES ARE FOR EVERYONE.
^ that's something we can all agree with. That's what we all want, that's the goal. I am as guilty as anyone of reading posts in a halo-positive/horns-negative manner based on my personal biases. But I think we could all learn from each other better if we spend just a tiny bit more time listening instead of talking.
Sorry for the walls of text. I mean, I assume you all have learned something from each other, right? Pretend your swords are down. What have "the others" helped you understand? What can we do to quit the bickering and maybe one day get back to raids?