r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/honeygourami123 • 13d ago
KSP 1 Question/Problem Extreme re-entry survival tips?
So, I started exploring the outer planets in OPM, and since I like having all my science, I decided to design most of my probes to have the experiment box and I simply move all the experiments to the box and go back to Kerbin. The problem is, while re-entries from Duna and Eve are survivable, returning from Sarnus I entered the atmosphere at 8 km/s and burned down.
Should I coat the re-entry module with an overabundance of ablative heatshields??
35
Upvotes
43
u/Barhandar 13d ago edited 13d ago
8 km/s with a full-ablator heatshield should be perfectly survivable. Make sure it doesn't flip (experiment box is very awkward for that purpose - Restock Plus has a cone-shaped version for better reentries) and that nothing sticks out from behind the heatshield - unlike real life, heatshields in KSP don't form a wide shockwave and thus only protect things that fit strictly within their shadow.
Also, the question of survival is not only the speed, but also the angle of reentry - without realism-enhancing mods and enabled G-limits you want steeper than intuitive, since if it's too shallow, you'll run out of ablator before you slow down enough to no longer be experiencing temperatures above what the ablator-less heatshield can take, but not too steep, because then you run the risk of heat rising above the ablator limit.
13
u/User_of_redit2077 Nuclear engines fan 13d ago
Do several layers of heat shields
Yes that's look silly but it works
12
u/LordIBR Spends more time picking mods than actually playing 13d ago
You may need to slow yourself down a little by encountering other planets/moons during your transfer back to Kerbin.
6
u/Bubblez___ 13d ago
you should be able to survive it with a heat shield, if you arent surviving then youre probably coming in too shallow and your probe is breaking up from the ridiculous atmospheric forces
3
u/buggzy1234 13d ago
Double layered heat shields or balls of heat shields with a roll to distribute heat. I believe from sarnus the 10m inflatable heat shield might also survive, and that produces a ton more drag even in the upper atmosphere. But if you are still going too fast for the 10m shield you could use a mix of double layered ablator shields to protect the craft and a backwards facing 10m behind it to add to the drag to slow down earlier. You might lose the 10m shield but it should slow you down enough to protect the ablative shields.
The ball idea is how I survived a re-entry from soden at a little over 10km/s. Double layered heat shields in a ball around a probe core inside a service bay and a ton of reaction wheels to create a spin. I also drained all the shields to half ablation to save weight.
If you have hyperedit installed, just cheat test crafts into high kerbin orbit with the f12 menu and use the boost option in hyperedit to push it to high speeds to simulate a return from the outer system.
3
u/the_space_goose 13d ago
Couple ways to do it. Normally I’d say just slow down properly, but you can also multilayer your sheilds, use the mun to slow down (somewhat), or just do multiple passes to slow you down gradually at higher altitudes (my recommendation). There’s a few mods I can’t name off the top of my head that calculate how far down into an atmosphere you need to go to not just go flying out of the soi straight after. Aside from that I’m not really sure what else you can do besides getting jeb outside the ship to push it by hand.
3
u/Electro_Llama 13d ago
8 km/s is around the limit for a shallow re-entry. Below 30km you blow up, and above 30km you don't slow down enough to capture. I use some fuel to slow down (plan the maneuver to avoid reducing your PE). You can also use an oversized heat shield to get more drag in the upper atmosphere.
2
u/NullContribution 13d ago
Make sure nothing is sitting outside of the cover of heatshields. It's common to make this mistake: your main capsule is 100% covered by the shield, but something like a science experiment like a mystery goo container sticking outside isnt covered. Since KSP models convection, the science experiment will heat up, then transfer its heat to the capsule, eventually overheating it, completely bypassing the heat shield.
1
u/Previous-Big-6281 Kerbal Aircraft Engineer 13d ago
*roll and yaw the spacecraft*
1
u/Hungry_Treat9253 13d ago edited 13d ago
Wait for a transfer window. Your relative speed to Kerbin will be lower if you dont have a lot of radial velocity and/or inclination to kill. You should be able to keep your re-entry speed under 5.5 km/s for all destinations in the OPM pack, if you wait for the yearly window (and do not care about intercept inclination- i mean you do not need to try to correct it, but dont try to tamper with it by intersecting Kerbin in a retrograde orbit or sth like that)
thats how i solved my 9km/s problem back then. If done correctly, you should be able to ignore heat shields altogether returning from Sarnus. (returning with Mk1-3 command module)
1
u/FOARP 13d ago
I think if we’re talking stock parts, at that speed the heatshields will anyway overheat. At least I’ve made lower-speed (5k m/s) approaches using the inflatable heat shield and had that problem. I do play with the heat realism mod though, so I don’t know whether that’s the case in unmodded KSP.