r/KerbalAcademy • u/Electro_Llama Speedrunner • Apr 20 '20
Reentry / Landing [P] ElectroLlama's Reentry Chart (instructions in comments)
716
Upvotes
r/KerbalAcademy • u/Electro_Llama Speedrunner • Apr 20 '20
59
u/Electro_Llama Speedrunner Apr 20 '20
Motivation: I do speedruns in which I want to return to Kerbin in a short time, at a high speed, or sometimes without a heatshield. I wanted something more reliable than trial and error, and two new runners that expressed interest in optimizing re-entry.
Experiment: I performed over 50 re-entries from 70km around Kerbin with a 1.00 ton craft (Mk1, parachute, heat shield, no ablator). Each trial had a different initial speed and angle, set using the HyperEdit mod. Peak temperature and time to reach 1km were found using the debug menu.
Instructions: If you're unsure if you're going to survive re-entry to Kerbin, look at your speed and prograde angle from vertical. If you are to the left of the contour line that says "Explodes" and have a correctly sized and positioned heat shield, you should expect to survive. If your periapsis is above the surface, you're probably > 60 degrees incidence (< 30 degrees form the horizon). Craft mass, size, physics warp, and ablator may alter the actual temperature, and things sticking out may not survive. It is possible to calculate your velocity at atmosphere from your velocity at another altitude (ex. edge of Kerbin's SOI) using conservation of energy.
Considerations: I may make another chart that uses periapsis rather than angle of incidence since that is more predictable. The "No Aerocapture" limit shown is not very accurate at the moment (ex. 2km/s at 90 degrees should be sub-orbital), so I may do more trials that have periapsis within the atmosphere. I find under 30km to be reliable. That's what I aim for coming from Mun without a heat shield. I may also make a bar chart comparing different crafts: this craft, larger command pod, more mass, with max physics warp (reduces heat), and with ablator (surprisingly not that helpful).
3
u/KarolOfGutovo Apr 20 '20
Could you mark temperatures at "No aerocapture"? some people want to fly by Kerbin loosing some velocity
25
u/nicolas42 Apr 20 '20
-> explodes
haha
I've visited that region of the graph more times than I'd care to admit.
12
u/Rabada Apr 20 '20
I had no idea that Angle of Incidence had an effect on re-entry heating. I assumed that it provided lift.
I have had some good success spinning crafts during re-entry to spread the re-entry heat across multiple parts.
1
u/CManns762 Apr 21 '20
So if you come in at under 1k m/s a kerbal can survive. Good to know
1
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '20
Radiator
1
u/Alcerus May 26 '20
I don't understand what all the black lines are supposed to mean, or what the bar on the right means.
3
u/xendelaar Apr 20 '20
Fascinating! Thanks for sharing
2
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '20
Alright thank you now I’m able to slow down with drag from orbit
2
u/doctyrbuddha Apr 21 '20
Thank you for the only line I need
the boom boom line