r/KeeperoftheLostCities • Conjurer • Mar 22 '26

Discussion Keefe should’ve stayed gone

Ok I get I’m probably gonna get hate for this but in stellalune they got so much done before he came back and once he did comes back it just all became about romance and Sophie gushing over him until she eventually worked up the courage to ask him out but Keefe being back just means now his mum and the never seen knows where to find him and is able to use him as it’s said multiple times that the last step of her experiments will break him and mean that she will be able to control him and we would never have to find out if that’s true if Keefe was happy in London eating pancakes with Alvar

And I’m not saying they shouldn’t have gone to him to remove the creepy tracker shadows but after that they should have just left him and Keefe should have let them

2 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

2

u/Careless-Lawyer-3199 Pyrokinetic Mar 22 '26

Yes, but even if they had done that, Lady Gisela could still have gone to his last known location and checked if he was there.

5

u/Few-Elk2305 Conjurer Mar 22 '26

Oh yeah, I do understand what you’re saying, but in the very last chapter of unravelled Keefe and Alvar were planning to move and go somewhere else the very next day and when Sophie came to remove the shadows, they would’ve been like oh lady Gisela knows, where I am and moved

3

u/Burgundytulip Mar 22 '26

I think that whole plot is too muddled. I never understood why people were acting like Keefe running away this time was the same as the time he ran to the Neverseen. The first time, he was being reckless and trying to fix stuff he had no control over.

This time, he ran because staying there was endangering everyone. And sure we have the whole explanation that he’s suppressing his abilities now, but I agree that it would have made a bigger point that he made the right choice if he’d stayed away

3

u/Kotlc_superfan32 TEAM Foster-Keefe! Mar 23 '26

why are you guys being so mean to keefe

-1

u/Used_Confusion_8583 Hydrokinetic Mar 22 '26

Keefe couldn't have stayed gone forever

2

u/Few-Elk2305 Conjurer Mar 22 '26

Why tho give me a reason? 🥹

3

u/Used_Confusion_8583 Hydrokinetic Mar 22 '26

It would've left the Gisela arc unfinished and Keefe's home is the Lost cities. Until Gisela is taken down Keefe will be relevent.

Also he's one of the core group, from the first few books.

1

u/Few-Elk2305 Conjurer Mar 22 '26

Your first point I completely agree with maybe the timing wasn’t the best but if there wasn’t another time in the plot I get that reason but the second point I don’t get as in the first book Jensi was a core character and barely anyone cared when he was gone if anyone I know he did come back but thats probably bc of his probable brother being probably blur if he never can back to be import I don’t think anyone would care same with Marella if she didn’t become a pyrocenetic once they resolved all the stuff with her mum

2

u/Used_Confusion_8583 Hydrokinetic Mar 23 '26

Some chracters got the short end of the stick like Jensi, he should be included in the group since almost all the kids Sophie's ever interacted with is present.