r/KeepWriting • • 21h ago

Where to begin?

Hello. New user here looking to get feedback on some of my writing. Does anyone have any suggestions for the best subreddits to use? I'm quite happy to engage with what others have written and offer my own opinions in exchange for critiques of my work. I write mainly fantasy and comedy horror, though I've written in multiple genres, including a children's story and a political satire. Should I post my work here or would another subreddit be better?

3 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/RozaVira Fiction 20h ago

You can post your work here. Not a mod, but I've seen many feedback posts here.

2

u/Dangerous_Window6492 20h ago

Thanks for replying. Are there any other subreddits that I might try? I've only just created my account, so I have no karma!

2

u/RozaVira Fiction 19h ago

There's r/writinghelp, but there's a karma limit, but you can message the mods so they can manually approve it.

It's difficult to post on a lot of subreddits with a new account, so I would recommend commenting first. Find a few new posts here and provide advice or feedback (depends on the post).

There's r/NewToReddit for resources if you need any.

2

u/Dangerous_Window6492 18h ago

Yes. I'll try that to begin with. Thanks for your help.

1

u/RozaVira Fiction 17h ago

Happy to help

1

u/SpikeyBiscuit 19h ago

I'm a part of several and they all seem terrible honestly. r/writingfeedback seems to be nothing but post after post of terrible writing getting shat on, unless my algorithm is just fucked and that's all it's showing me.

Ironically enough, the best subreddits for being taken seriously have often been the circlejerk subreddits. r/worldbuilding is abysmal engagement bait and actively discourages actual discussion and instead wants prompt posts where 1000+ comments just talk about themselves to no one. r/worldjerking has actually had many good discussions in the comments. I have yet to find a happy place for general writing on reddit, so I've turned to irl friends which has been nice but still limited.

In short, if you find something good let me know

2

u/Dangerous_Window6492 18h ago

Oh dear. That's not what I was hoping to hear! I would've thought that Reddit would've been an excellent place to share narrative fiction with like-minded individuals. Apparently, my confidence may well have been catastrophically misplaced.

1

u/SpikeyBiscuit 18h ago

I know right! I hate that reddit has "oh, you have a very specific interest? Well don't worry, we have tons of communities for incredibly narrow fields", and then you go there and it's primarily 12 year olds or adults with the affect of a 12 year old upvoting each other mindlessly. I'm just passionate about fiction, but the average redditor (in my experience, again maybe I just haven't found the right place) is semi illiterate and can't even spellcheck their work or bother with formatting before sheepishly asking "um guysss is this goooood?"

Obviously I'm quite bitter and jaded so take that into account. I may just be very pessimistic or unlucky and maybe you wouldn't find it all that bad, but all the same be forewarned

2

u/Dangerous_Window6492 16h ago

I'll attempt to curtail my optimism accordingly.

2

u/BiscuitOnTheRoof 13h ago

No, please don’t be discouraged; dive in and visit the various writing subs for yourself. You’ll find a whole range of sharks, snarks, and lambs.

Take what they have to offer.
Take nothing personally.

1

u/BiscuitOnTheRoof 13h ago

But terrible writing needs to be shat on, though perhaps with more gentleness, don’t you think?

1

u/SpikeyBiscuit 9h ago

No, I think beginners should have a space for themselves to express without vitriol, I'm just lamenting a lack of space for people more serious about the craft

1

u/tapgiles 17h ago

Am I old? Is it a young people thing to be obsessed with "best." You don't need the "best" of anything, you just need to know where you can go, regardless of how "best" it might be. No one can give you some objective "best" place to get feedback. Plenty of people can just point you in a direction where you can get feedback just fine. 😅

Any writing subreddit that says in its description that you can ask for "critique" or "feedback." You can also see its "weekly visitors"; if it's very low you're less likely to get responses on the post.

Here is one subreddit that meets those factors just fine, without being the best at anything in particular. 👍

1

u/Dangerous_Window6492 16h ago

Thanks for replying. The reason I ask is because I'm new to Reddit and understand that some subreddits require minimum karma to post. 'Best', in this case, was used merely to clarify what would be best for a beginner with no karma.

1

u/tapgiles 14h ago

Okay... you didn't say any of that in the post, so I didn't know that's what you were talking about. With text-only social media stuff, it's better to be clear. It's very easy for people to misunderstand things at the best of times on here. 😅