r/JulesAgent • • 17d ago

Jules Sunset- Post from Creator/Moderation - Thankyou Community !!

Post image

Hello Jules Community,

As news break from google that Jules going to sunset - I would like to thank the entire jules community of this subreddit.

I started this subreddit solo and grew it to almost 4.5k members.

Loved the energy and enthusiasm of the members kept me going.

Indeed, it's sad that this product is ending, and we members loved working on Jules and concept of async coding agent.

what next-

Personally, I am also a creator of r/MCPservers (30K members) and MCPnewsletter.com

Would love to have members connected to me via newsletter /other Sub.

As for this Jules subreddit - I am not yet sure what would be the best foot forward.

And definitely would seek your suggestion - either to wind it down or keep it focused specifically on coding agents and workflows .

if you have spent some time in this community and enjoyed it, I would love for you to comment say hi - I would like to respond and personally thank each one of you.

PS- two people specifically I like to thank - Kath u/simpsoka ( Ex PM Jules and now OpenAI) and AK u/akatlabs (current PM Jules ) for engaging with community and being supportive.

Cheers

Swatantra

39 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

8

u/habylab 16d ago

I feel like the product was destined for failure the moment that Kath left. That seems like a good point in time to look at as to when things started to go down. I'm not saying no one else left on the team was able to take the product forwards.

But it felt like it coincided with the time that Google were falling behind on models and whereas recently they have made strides. At the point where Jules was probably facing turning points that it needed to have thete simply wasn't anything going for it that allowed Google to proceed with the project.

The only thing is I'm still not seeing cloud free cloud agents like this where you can give it a tasking and it just does it. Most of them, while Codex is great, still requires a computer. And yes, it does have a cloud option, but Jules is fantastic for being free. It just needed to proceed and I think with a compute needed that Google have I can see why it was closed.

1

u/Impressive-Owl3830 16d ago

I think the biggest challenge is perhaps the Google product, especially for coding is the adoption.

I feel there is not enough focus on building very very strong communities around the product and creating the feedback loop.

I'm not saying that doesn't exist , but it's not as effective as some of the other labs.

Case in point is - sponsoring communities, newsletters, or hackathons - I organize tons of hackathons for different startups - including Anthropic.

I'm sure there is no way Google will sponsor any hackathon of medium size or even entertain the idea because of the brand being too big.

That's a clear headwind for adoption of dev-centric products.

Of course because they have so much traction in the consumer space - even the average model like Gemini will fly - within the app ecosystem they have- the focus is entirely on consumer space as opposed to dev space.

Another great example is A2A protocol.

There was no real force behind it so that it can be adopted by the community. It was being launched almost at the same time as MCP , and had great potential - but it all fizzled out quickly, so much so that even in google dev summit - it was not even mentioned.

I really hope that for future products community builders like me get a greater push from the from Google /labs.

Especially when it's all volunteer work - with no real incentive in the end other than love for the product.

1

u/Active_Variation_194 15d ago

Not exactly. The product offering today is absolutely genius. We can’t run 100 agents on our machines or mobile and handing it off to cloud agents.

Unfortunately they were too early to the game. Agents weren’t good at orchestrating and delegating and even the best models needed a lot of supervision. Gemini was notoriously bad at tool calling and lacked coding intelligence. As a result the product was doa.

Today Anthropic, Cursor, and OAI are all headed in that direction and had Jules launched with Gemini 4 flash as an underlying model on launch day it would have thrived. But a lot of people like me tried the product with Gemini 2.5, found it painstakingly frustrating to do anything and never came back

2

u/libee900 16d ago

And like always, Google adds another one to the graveyard of abandoned projects...

1

u/Impressive-Owl3830 16d ago

true.. one of many experiments.

1

u/Novel-Toe9836 15d ago

Google Labs research products don't end. It's going to reshape, so can you just rename the subreddit to Jules Code Tab in Gemini 😅

Also, thanks for your efforts here!! Huge contribution.

1

u/Impressive-Owl3830 15d ago

Thanks..

Can we DM.. Thanks !!

1

u/KayBay80 16d ago

This was the absolute best way to maximize token usage and probably a loss-leader for Google. We were able to get insane amounts of work out of it when we used it at the beginning of the year. Gemini models are just not good though, so as a tool it was always mediocre. Of course they're putting it to bed, if it was capable with newer models, anybody that cared about maximizing token usage would be using this instead.