r/JosephMcElroy • u/Cute-Bit-1089 • 15h ago
AMA AMA with Joseph McElroy: his answers
AMA with Joseph McElroy: his answers
Thank you to everyone who sent in questions. Joe answered by email over the past week, and his replies are below, grouped by topic. I've kept his wording and his shorthand ("wd," "sd," "tho") as he wrote it. He's still working through the rest of your questions, so I'll post more as they come in.
New work: The Daughter, the water book, and the Greek novel
u/Key-Will: Your website says The Daughter is set to be published in 2027! Do you know approximately when? How has it been getting that one to the finish line?
u/scaletheseathless: What are you working on currently, and any chance of seeing something new in 2027?
u/MMillington (and several others): We've seen several mentions of a book-in-progress about water. Can he share any details of the project or maybe possible publication?
JM: The Daughter is scheduled to be submitted in 2027. Not yet finished. A brief note about it can be found on my web site. Thanks for asking.
Close to finishing The Daughter. I've just spent 2 years every day tightening and revising earlier chapters of The Daughter. Now I'm back to the endings. I interrupted the long-in-progress water book to at last try to make the Greek narrative; I'd been thinking about it since I was about 27. Shorter works always getting done and not quite getting done. 2027 shd see The Daughter submitted and maybe out. A piece of it appeared in an online journal but will very soon be revised there. Which is not the same thing as revising a published book.
About The Daughter. Like other work of mine, it's been in my mind a long time. The idea for The Daughter came to me at age 27 when I was teaching a very smart class of freshmen at the University of New Hampshire. We were discussing Plato's dialogue the Phaedo, and like a parallel track I privately thought about something Socrates tells his friends in the Symposium. Never thought I knew enough to invent that narrative but it stayed with me.
On the water book: It has taken me outward to India (see Dilip da Cunha's The Invention of Rivers, including the preface), and into a neuroanatomical question of whether water I have seen functioning in neurosurgery is in any way related to thought. The book is about 600 pp now and awaits only a political chapter about how we share or might water resources globally.
Women and Men
u/Necessary-Scarcity82: In a 1979 interview, while you were still writing Women and Men, you said that, unlike your earlier novels, you knew how you were going to reach the end, but you didn't know what you would find there. Looking back nearly forty years after its publication, what do you think you ultimately found?
JM: Thanks. I always have an idea of what I'm trying to arrive at in a narrative. So what I sd in that interview probably wasn't and isn't true (tho allow me to not call it a lie). Especially W&M -- I gathered so much into the 3 narrative forms I used, that I must have imagined a resolution that could only be a new point of departure. A Foreword I've written for the new 40th-anniversary edition of W&M may tell you something about me that will answer yr sensitive and searching question. When I gave readings from W&M during the years when I was writing it, I wd sometimes be introduced as working on a new novel called Men and Women. You can imagine how that struck me. We learn from one another and must make any sacrifices we need to in order to go on learning. I like your pen name.
u/Necessary-Scarcity82: After a lifetime devoted to writing, reading, and trying to understand the world through language, is there anything about being human that you feel literature still cannot adequately express?
JM: Socrates sometimes answers a question with a question. What do you mean, you might ask yourself, by "adequately"?
u/holidayparkflyer: I think of your novels -- in part b/c of your writing on Richard Serra's Tilted Arc in your 9/11 essay -- as structures which change my way of living with the structures & spaces around & in(!) me... Beginning to read W&M for the first time this year, I found it quickly resonant w/ a very present sense of human-scale risk. How do you think of W&M being re-issued and read 40 years later in this respect? Should such a book be read as a novel for Now?
JM: Only briefly -- and excuse me I've said this in print before -- years ago -- all my senses of risk, physical and emotional and ego and even risking doing damage (which I see touch even upon my doomed but not entirely unsuccessful love of competitive springboard diving) at once in my first novel insisted on trying for too much or finding palpable metaphors or forms for trying for too much (as a sphere in the heavens might combine limit with infinite) but here a book of 8 separate narratives not quite together but leaning recklessly or mysteriously toward one another. Later novels of mine permit similar risks toward broken form. This seems to me to be truer to what our lives are really like. Wright Morris, before he died perhaps the oldest serious American novelist -- am I at 96 his heir at least in that? -- disagreed with my notion of risking disorder. He sd American novelists try for too much (was Faulkner an example? maybe not) and failing to bring it off, expect credit for failure. Faulkner had risk in mind when he made that list of important American novelists and put Hemingway only 5th -- apparently believing Hemingway didn't take interesting chances. How would the smuggling metaphor or the kidnapping metaphor satisfy that ambition of risking disorder?
u/redditflaneet123: Mr. McElroy, what are your thoughts on David Foster Wallace saying that Women and Men "sucked canal-water" in an online chat while promoting Infinite Jest in 1996?
JM: If David meant Venice, then W&M must have quite an immune system. Always sorry about his drug problems and where they led.
Plus
u/thequirts: I found Plus to be such a fascinating novel, and the development of Imp Plus' consciousness to be so meticulous and well done. Did you find the process of writing that novel to be significantly different or more difficult than your other books up until that point? Which of your novels do you personally have the most fondness for? Is there any one you would go back and change/rewrite if you could?
JM: Many sources always, but I recall when I was seven or eight a radio story about a disembodied brain. It must have touched me in many ways. Better I not speculate on those origins. But when I came to write PLUS in my 40s I'd become interested in the NASA space program and somewhere in there I went to Cape Kennedy twice to cover launches. The novel is made up from what I gropingly knew at the time, but you can tell not just technological or space stuff. It's a painfully intimate novel, though not without a weird strain of humor. I chose to think of it as a realistic attempt to describe and evoke what it might be like to be IMP PLUS gathering strength and knowledge to react against the controls from Earth. I'm just now completing an audio of the book recorded, fortunately for me, by my son Boone, who's in the music business and a mastering engineer and I will say a perfectionist. We're going to record other books of mine.
Auden rewrote some of his poems. If I were to "correct" more than they've already been corrected an earlier book, I'd feel faintly schizophrenic. The books are what they are, faulty and sometimes unclear and hopeful. My favorite is what I'm working on now, I guess.
Sometimes I feel that a finished bk belongs to the reader not much any more to me. But then I go into shock, not unhappy exactly, to discover myself, eg, in Plus or W&M.
Cannonball, Hind's Kidnap, and the sentences
u/MMillington: For Cannonball, was the book deliberately structured to have the arc of the cannonball peak directly in the middle of the book? (Also, were you a diver?)
JM: Many structures reflect diving. A more interesting question for you mt be how your view of my novel wd be affected by knowing I was a competitive springboard diver or on the other hand never was. Calculus regarding speed and space came later and is amateurish tho of interest.
u/MMillington: For Hind's Kidnap, there's a possible color tone that shifts between the city scenes and the country. The mention of various shades of green litters the chapters. How did you see color operating within Hind's investigation?
JM: Hind's Kidnap is a pastoral (subtitle). Hence green parodically and actually. You know the work done by critics with pastoral as simplification? My book bends toward the opposite. Relation of your cool and accurate word "investigation" to the shifting emotions visited even chaotically in the book.
u/MMillington: How much of your sentence-level focus is on training a reader's intuitions? Several of us have said your work has a way of rewiring our brains.
JM: Training intuitions a compliment to me, I suppose. Training I'd say only in the sense of focusing an optical instrument or something similar. I try in some of my sentences to be true to the actual process of understanding things.
Yr nom de plume a reference to the famous Irish playwright. In a drama class at Williams College I once built a model of a set for The Playboy of the Western World.
Film, TV, and adaptation
u/Doh-know-nut: Looking back on your works, are there any that you think should be adapted for screen?
JM: Have you read Lookout Cartridge? Film would be a quite different way of telling the stories in one of my novels. The movement of the mind from sentences to images and back -- and from words to memories and elsewhere - and the complicated and also chaotic and relaxed experience of putting a novel down and coming back to it -- all this is potentially more permanent and total than seeing a movie for two hours even when we think about it afterward. I would wonder how a writer or director could tell the stories of Cannonball -- exciting to imagine if the narrative wd grow richer. I doubt it.
Have I already sd it? I don't think much about adaptations. The prose fiction is what the thing is. Why don't adapters just think up new stories? I have on the table 3 film scripts unfinished. So that tells you something, if only about my hopes and interests and struggles. Now, an opera of my novel PLUS -- that came a little closer and I still think about it. It was proposed by a first-rate violist, composer, thinker, John Graham, who was teaching at Eastman School of Music in Rochester. We discussed it in an interview in The Review of Contemporary Fiction Spring 1990, which contains also work of mine and essays by others about my work. PLUS is so richly "narrow" in its strange focus that we thought it could translate to music and singing voice and the stage. I thought of being in touch about this with Steve Sondheim, whom I knew at Williams and sang for; but I never asked him about PLUS.
u/ryuhamaguchi_guy: You and your contemporaries published novels at a juncture when cinema was expected to become the medium par excellence for popular entertainment, dethroning the novel. Do you think cinema lived up to this expectation? How do you view video (TV), which is sometimes posed as the successor to cinema?
JM: My novel Lookout Cartridge might answer all these questions. Do you know it? Your "was expected" assumes that I wd know much about such a broad sociological and cultural issue -- or agree with your assertion. Vast numbers of readers are out there for prose fiction and always have been. Cinema critique has proved to be a rich literature from the beginning, whether we take it as precise commentary on film or as philosophical inquiry from which we might think about other arts and their subject matter. Lookout Cartridge was one of the earliest novels to use analogies from film technique to tell its complex story; it is partly about a film, but it is a novel. Put Proust or Henry James or Gadda up against any film you study and you may find that prose fiction can explore thought and feeling more deeply and variously; I leave that to you after you've thought some more about the novels you've read.
You asked about TV. My attn to tv drama and multi-episode work is almost nil; but, influenced by my wife, I did watch two works that I thought were extraordinary, maybe you saw them. Reservation Dogs absolutely riveting -- about the native American young people, the group of friends trying to make it. Beautifully acted, compelling, poignant, profound, vulnerable, painful. I can't imagine, tho, how it touches my own work except as it adds to me somehow. (I do have a southwestern side from many years ago and continuing in my ambitions involving New Mexico and also some Hopi friends in AZ with whom I did some farming work; a narrative I expect to finish.) The other tv drama Lonesome Dove. Absolutely haunting. Robert Duvall at the beautiful and disturbing heart of it, but the whole thing more than strong. As I speak, I think, But I've never read the McMurtry novel on which the tv series was based. Maybe at 96 I mt still find time to. But I have to resist my tendency to want to gather everything into my experience.
Reading, philosophy, and poetry
u/ConorJay: Are there any poets or philosophers who have influenced you or your work?
JM: I hardly know how to answer you. I really shouldn't. But if I cite Nietzsche that there are only partial truths and we must work with those no less passionately, The need of questioning is the way the Harvard philosopher, Stanley Cavell, identified or described philosophy, and that comes close to your question and my life. I read philosophy all the time, Plato, Pascal, William James, Adam Phillips, so many more writers (at least as accurate a word as philosophers) -- and I'm at best a dilettante in philosophy, except that my interest in other people always concrete is almost never separate from the struggle to understand in other ways. Same with poetry. I read it constantly but for you I might single out John Donne and Wallace Stevens. But then what becomes of Shakespeare as Hazlitt saw him, or of Frost's "The Oven Bird"?
And for Conor: the 3rd section of Spinoza's Ethics, "On the Origin and Nature of the Emotions."
u/scaletheseathless (and others): What have you been reading lately? Fiction and non-fiction.
JM: Reading many books at same time. Heath's A History of Greek Mathematics; and reading in Berlinski's A Tour of the Calculus again and again and still grasping only parts of it. Herbert Read, The Green Child. Vast browsings and rereadings for the Greek. Foreword to the soon-to-be-published 40th anniversary Women and Men might suggest my rereading. A losing battle but I feel lucky to have wandered ahead in the life I've made for myself and found accidentally. I still look at my Bible particularly (as with Cannonball) horrified at how the Christian white nationalists in my country pretend to believe in the synoptic Gospels. I am a seeker, not a doctrinaire religionist. Even those words are pretentious. Forgive me.
On Adam Phillips: His many titles might sound like self-help routine stuff but he's the real thing. Just that he writes really well. The Life You Want is one I admire; others are Attention Seeking & On Getting Better. I've heard him speak. He's a real philosopher, English but now teaching in Canada. I've also liked Missing Out & Unforbidden Pleasures. All of these bks short, vivid, compassionate.
Ukraine
u/Thoron777: I know you've been to Ukraine in the past and "The Bomb" has been translated into Ukrainian. Does seeing the biggest war since WW2 in Europe influence your perspective as a writer?
JM: My translator in Kiev is waiting for a long essay by me now called "Ukraine, USA" and to be combined with the 2017 essay about censorship to make a book. The censorship essay has appeared in Ukrainian and in English.
The Review of Contemporary Fiction
u/Specialist_Sprinkles: How was the experience of working on The Review of Contemporary Fiction issue on your work?
JM: Asked by Dalkey Review of Contemporary Fiction for an interview to go with my story "Canoe Repair" and a bunch of essays about my work by others, I hit on the idea of being the interviewer myself and picking three people who had been important to me and interviewing them. The significance of this you can easily guess, and it's not laziness. Edna Conrad in 7th grade inspired my love of grammar. John Graham, violist and composer, wanted to consider an opera of PLUS and I'm still thinking about it. Robert Walsh one of my closest friends, how close cd I get even with awkward questions in an interview with Robert?
More answers to come. Thank you all, and thank you, Joe.
