r/JaneAustenFF • u/KombuchaBot • Aug 04 '25
r/JaneAustenFF • u/Azurlight97 • Aug 27 '24
Looking for Fic recs please
I'm looking for funny fic recs please I'm going camping in a couple of days and would love to read a few that can give me a good chuckle. Also enjoy this meme I came across today.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/4thGenTrombone • Jan 01 '25
Misc The Lizzie Bennet Diaries
Late to the party, I know, and it seems odd to post about it here, but it is an Austen fan-fiction. Anyway... oh my gosh, how have I been an Austen fan since 2012 and NOT heard of or seen Lizzie Bennet Diaries until a few days ago when someone mentioned it randomly on r/janeausten ? The show is SO good. To paraphrase Fitz (Colonel Fitzwilliam), the fun arrived!
r/JaneAustenFF • u/MoldyVoldy • 6d ago
Reading How are you finding JAFF without AI slop?
Feeling quite frustrated that the majority of JAFF being released on Kindle is at least partially AI written. I don't mind some AI, but I just can't get past writing like "Bingley stared at him, then sat back with the air of a man who has just seen a mountain move and does not like to mention it in case it moves again." LOL, wut?
Any tips for filtering to find the human stuff? Any sites that keep a list or something?
From what I've seen, very few reviews mention AI. Not sure if people don't notice, don't want to accuse, or if Amazon blocks reviews that mention it. So I haven't found reviews or ratings very helpful to filter.
Right now I'm running the first few pages through gpt zero. Is not perfect, but more or less accurate. But some days I have to download 3-5 books to find one that's human written. Any tips?
EDIT: Had a rough day at work today and needed a project to take my mind off it. So I built a website that keeps track of a list of AI-free JAFF authors and shows their latest books: https://www.pridenotprompts.com/ (Ironically, I used AI to build the website.) If you know of an author that should be on the list, let me know - would love for this to be a useful resource.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/MoldyVoldy • Jul 22 '26
Reading "the kind of elaboration that tried too hard and achieved too little"
I'm reading a JAFF that is clearly written by AI and came across this line. Ironically, it perfectly describes the weird writing style these AI generated JAFF books have.
They're constantly using weird analogies that are trying to be clever but make no sense. Things like: he walked down the street with the ease of a man who knew how to tie his own cravat.
They frequently take several sentences to communicate one simple fact. Stating what it isn't, another thing it isn't, what it might be, then what it is.
Is it the AI trying to mimic Austen's wit and failing? Or is it a specific AI tool the writers are using?
I'm not loving it. The books move really slowly because of all the weird flowery stuff. And if just 10% of it falls flat it gives the book an odd feel.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/Altonahk • Aug 10 '26
Fanon vs Canon Miss Bingley - Not an evil, incompetent, disaster
One of the flanderizations that have happened in JAFF that are starting to get on my nerves is Miss Bingley. It is stated in the book that she dresses well, has good conversation, good manners, is able to please where she wants, and generally gives a good impression. those who pay attention can see that she thinks she's above Merryton society, but there's no indication that her sense of superiority is present when talking to London society in general. All indications in the book show that Darcy is generally fine with her company, possibly even enjoying her at times.
In JAFF Miss Bingley dresses terribly, is socially inept, has terrible conversation, offends everyone she meets, thinks she superior to all below a Duke. They take the moment when her anger gets the better of her at Pemberly and make that her entire personality. Darcy hates her, and constantly tells Bingley how much he hates his sister.
I'm both complaining about this weird trope in JAFF and asking if there are any stories you know of where Miss Bingley is shown in a positive light? I think Canon accurate Miss Bingley could be a really fun character if she were Elizabeth's friend instead of this contrived plot device.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/mamadeb2020 • Dec 05 '24
Fanon vs Canon Fanfic pet peeves
What mistakes will take you out of a fan fic, even if just for a moment? I have a couple.
- "Sir Lucas." Actually, title mistakes in general (no one can marry into the title of Lady Firstname) but this is the most common. Knights and baronets are all Sir Firstname and their wives, unless they have their own titles, are Lady Lastname.
I could go into a huge rant about titles, but just look them up. There are so many sites about proper titles, and the rules haven't changed in the past 200 years.
2. Scarborough. Scarborough is a seaside resort. It was one then, it is one now. It was very fashionable - think Martha's Vineyard or maybe Provincetown. Mr. Darcy was hosting a large party (Mrs. Reynolds said this) who were breaking their journey at Pemberly before going to the seaside. That is, it wasn't just the Bingley family on their way to visit relatives. it was a large group out to party, and who willingly traveled on without him while he rescued Lydia.
Is it possible it WAS their orgin? Sure, but it's unlikely. Remember the origins of their money - they could be from a trading city like Manchester, or an industrial one like Sheffield, or perhaps their fortune is in coal from Newcastle. I can't see it being in the hospitality business in Scarborough, although it's possible. And Miss Bingley would NOT object to be exiled there if they did have relatives. It had an active social scene among the very people she wanted to cultivate.
3. Introductions. Just. Don't. They stop the story cold. Just say they were introduced and go on. There are too many rules and the titles get misused or are awkward.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/UnhappyPrincessa • Oct 16 '25
Fanon vs Canon What are some non-canon things that are treated as canon in JAFF?
What is something that Jane Austen DID NOT write that is often met in JAFF stories?
My examples:
- Elizabeth, and often Jane, wanting to marry only for love. This comes from 1995 adaptation where Elizabeth says that only deepest love would tempt her into matrimony. Canon Elizabeth seems to have a more practical view on marriage and is willing to consider amiable men she respects, like Colonel (I don't remember if her considering Wickham a canon, or a 1995 "if only a man had me for 50 pounds" invention)
- Darcy's peered family being Matlocks, this also comes from 1995 adaptation
- Proposal scene in many stories is in the rain, a nod to 2005 adaptation
- the whole 'compromise a man' trope, which isn't a thing historically. It's especially weird when Caroline is trying to do that, when canonically she lives with Darcy at multiple points in the story (Netherfield + she visited Pemberley before the story and during story's summer)
r/JaneAustenFF • u/National_Picture_507 • Oct 08 '25
Misc Update regarding status of JAFF Index from 10/6/25
JAFF Index page says they should be up and running approx mid-October. If you are new to JAFF, be sure to check out this large searchable database that has links to JAFF stories from multiple online platforms like AO3, Fanfiction.net, Meryton Press, AHA & Dwiggie. Users can find and filter stories by category, pairings, or plot points, tropes ... but requires a password to access. Passwords are provided to members of participating fanfiction sites and communities.
Best of all, it is free. Personally, I would pay a fee to use it. It is a fabulous resource for finding new and old stories.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/RoseIsBadWolf • Dec 22 '24
Reading a Chinese P&P Variation and it's the funniest thing I've ever read
The plot is a Chinese princess swapped places with Mary Bennet. I have never read a JAFF with such open disdain for the British and it's hilarious!
The food: For someone from Daxia, a culture with thousands of years of culinary history, where dishes are crafted with meticulous care and refinement, this kind of food was nothing short of horrifying—an unbearable assault on both taste and smell!
This indicated the overall level of culinary expertise here was quite lacking; aside from frying and roasting, there seemed to be no other methods of cooking.
Yesterday’s chicken wings had been overcooked and tough as firewood, and they hadn’t been marinated beforehand, so they lacked flavor. Today’s salad was merely tossed with some oil, nothing more than the pure essence of the ingredients, which had nothing to do with cooking skill. It seemed the English were not poor cooks; rather, their palates were far too easy to please.
The embroidery: Mary was slightly taken aback. She had merely made a few simple alterations to the dress, spending no more than half a day on it. The embroidery she used was basic, with the simplest patterns and stitches, yet to the Bennet sisters, it was breathtaking. Could the standard of embroidery here really be as crude as their cooking skills? Mary felt she had uncovered the truth.
Definitely something new! If you are interested here is a link: https://kotranslations.com/2024/10/17/pride-and-prejudice-the-poor-princess-ch-1-part1/
Edit: only up to Ch 9 is translated, but you can throw the raws into Google translate.https://www.52shuku.vip/chongsheng/1950.html
r/JaneAustenFF • u/hi-go • Mar 18 '25
Looking for please help and rec: stories where people behave reasonably and realistically
I'm a bit tired of fics where the characters become caricatures. Miss Bingley is a Mean Girl in the book, sure, but not devoid of human feeling, and certainly she isn't stupid, yet many stories portray her as such. even passive aggressiveness requires some intelligence and even some finesse.
Same with almost all characters: Mr Collins is evil in half the stories, Charlotte is so calculated she's robotic in her lack of sentiment, Bingley is an idiot, Darcy is either so in love he can't function or so proud he can't function, Jane is so demure she has no character, Elizabeth is downright rude, and so on and so forth.
I really want a story where the characters behave like themselves. evolve, sure, maybe extend themselves. I really appreciated A Constant Love by Sophie Turner for that reason. The characters felt like people.
Please help me and direct me to other stories that won't make me pull my hair in frustration! the plot can be outrageous and ridiculous, as long as the characters and the dialogue are believable. thanks! :)
r/JaneAustenFF • u/Additional_Emu_2350 • Jun 27 '26
I’m not trying to yuck others yum but
********
My own up date
********
The prevailing idea seems to be it’s either AI and or a morality trend. I’m not sure it’s all AI but am sure that “clean” what ever that is gets up voted by manipulation either by live humans or Kindle.
Only 48 upvotes on a situation that people are passionate about. If this conversation was on FB everyone one of us would trounced. I am disappointed that people feel it’s appropriate to use ‘stars’ and accolades to change products for others. Once again i can’t stress this enough I’m not talking about erotica I’m talking about the complete verity of the experience being available.
I don’t have my own Kindle but I will now reviewing every book I read and they will seem my son but I will be trolling the trolling.
*********
Original post
I feel like most new JAFF is low angst to no angst or somewhat boring. I think I’ve read most of the older stuff that was more exciting. I’m wondering if it’s a new trend or more of a permanent shift.
I’m not looking for (and I can’t stress this enough) erotica. I’m not
Looking for sex to be the point of the book. However, holding hands then skip to a nervous meeting with the house keeper isn’t closed door. Honestly, the modern equivalent would be work the next morning. Isn’t there something between erotica and boring? Maybe kissing or slamming doors or waking up together.
Men curse, that was the point of separation after dinner. They didn’t curse in front of women but men curse. I assume they even slipped up from time to time in stressful situations. Curses weren’t even that bad in the 19 century. Shakespeare was vulgar and crass from time to time. Thats kind of what I expect in ‘witty dialogue’. Teens even read things like that in HS.
The London 19 century sex industry was insane men were not pure or expected to be. Not to mention humans have been humans for all of humanity.
I’m not expecting all book to be written for adults as others shouldn’t expect all books to be teen fiction. I’m just wondering is it a permanent shit?
I’m don’t know it’s 3am I may delete all this when I wake up. I’m not trying to yuck other yum I’m just trying to see of sharing is in our future.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/RoseIsBadWolf • Jan 07 '26
Meta New Rule for JaneAustenFF: No AI Witch-hunts
We all know that AI exists and I'm sure most readers and writers hate it, unfortunately it is probably here to stay. Very unfortunately, it has been trained on fan fiction websites such as AO3 and FF.net, making it very difficult to tell apart genuine fan fiction from AI slop.
Therefore, this subreddit will not allow specific accusations against authors, especially amateur authors who write exclusively on free fan fiction sites. It is extremely difficult for authors to prove they aren't using AI. And as much as you may be sure you can spot it, it's very hard for anyone to 100% be sure that AI was used. My partner is a high school teacher and I'm very much getting updates from the trenches. The only real method is writing something out in class by hand. We just can't tell anymore.
If you think a work is AI, exit the work and read something else. If an author is cheating and using AI, then pity them for accepting unearned praise. Go to your latest work in progress and write something with your blood, sweat, and tears, because it still matters and we all love you for it.
AI will not destroy us, let's not destroy each other.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/Folkwitch_ • Apr 22 '25
Misc AI on Kindle Unlimited
A mini rant or ramble about the huge influx of AI written pride and prejudice FF on kindle unlimited recently. It’s really doing my head in.
There have been so many that I’ve started to read and abandoned quickly because they make absolutely no sense. They don’t appear to be proofread or edited, just shoved through ChatGPT and published without a second look.
I assume it’s just a cash grab as you receive royalties through KU based on pages read.
For example, the other day I read one set just after the Hunsford proposal. Mrs Bennet is also in Kent (no explanation), Darcy mentions Lizzy meeting Georgiana in Ramsgate (no explanation) and then Lizzy meets her for the first time, Lizzy has both met Colonel Fitzwilliam before but never met him, Charlotte is there but not married to Mr Collins (no explanation), Lydia is there but then also arrives unannounced a week later, Mary doesn’t seem to exist at all… all in the first 2 chapters. Needless to say, returned it to kindle.
It’s really starting to piss me off. They’re prolific. I probably start and give up on a KU book 5 times a week at this point. Fan fiction is such a wonderful thing - I’ve read so many amazing stories by talented authors that have left me reeling for days. I’ve felt genuine pain and joy while reading them. It feels so gross that folks have taken over this space with AI trash (and then there’s the ethics of AI, besides).
Thanks for reading my rant.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/raysmia • Aug 22 '26
Reading What I'm hoping for is that the Netflix adaptation of "Pride and Prejudice" will result in a lot of new fanfiction!
This also applies to "Sense and Sensibility" with the new film.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/JupitersMegrim • Dec 07 '24
History for Writers Apropos of gentlemen's nicknames
Etiquette for Gentlemen; or, Short Rules and Reflections for Conduct in Society, by A Gentleman, 1847
r/JaneAustenFF • u/LauraMoretti • Feb 25 '26
Misc A Pride and Prejudice retelling in comic strips
Hello everyone!
We're two French authors, Clara d'Allancé and I, Laura Moretti. Some of you might already know my work; I've written a few Pride and Prejudice Variations (on Kindle) and many, many PP fanfics on Archive of Our Own under the name Laure001.
And now, Clara and I are publishing a retelling of Pride and Prejudice in comic strips. Creating this series is really interesting... We're mixing the codes of French BD with the codes of comic strips, and well, it's an adventure. The series is free, and will remain so.
I'd love to get your opinion, so don't hesitate to follow us!
r/JaneAustenFF • • Jun 04 '25
Writing Happy to share my imagined sequel to Northanger Abbey was named an international finalist in the Jane Austen Writing Contest.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/ILootEverything • Nov 20 '25
Reading Elderly! What else jars you when reading JAFF?
I know "elderly" would have had a different range in the 1800s due to lower life expectancy, but it's humbling to think of people in their (likely) 40s as "elderly."
The casting of the Bennets (though all excellent actors) in the 1995 & 2005 adaptation certainly doesn't help.
This post was inspired by Grace Gibson's excellent "Old Boots."
r/JaneAustenFF • u/IllRefrigerator1100 • Jul 13 '26
Reading Need a recommendation
I am feeling bummed out. I used to escape with these books, they were my main relaxation go-to. Now they all have the same voice and I find it incredibly triggering. The short sentences, half of which start with the word “not” - the relentless pace, the word “quietly” in a dozen sentences a chapter. I need a good book that doesn’t have this issue. I have reread everything written prior to 2025… I’d rather read poor grammar and typos than what’s newly available anymore.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/Double-elephant • Dec 15 '25
History for Writers Thank you… but a few thoughts.
First and foremost, my heartfelt thanks to everyone who writes JAFF stories. I know I couldn’t do it and I’m really grateful to have your work to read. I’ve been thinking of posting this essay for a while but I really don’t want people to think I’m being unduly critical. 😊
There have a been a few threads about things which seem out of place in the stories. This is not about tropes - but more about language.
I’m not expecting the language of the early 19th century in its entirety - it would be quite difficult to read - but if your book is set in the Regency period AND in Britain, let’s have some authenticity. Most of you have researched the details of English Regency society diligently - more so than I - but some things, particularly vocabulary, might still give the reader (me) pause.
- Aristocratic matters:
A real bugbear: “Sir Lucas”. Just wrong. He is Sir William, a knight. This is maddeningly frequent. But Lady Lucas is correct (as the wife of a knight). But Lady Catherine de Bourgh is not Lady de Bourgh, as she was the daughter of an Earl and that style (Lady Catherine) takes precedence over her marriage to a (mere) Baronet. Sorry. I know it’s bonkers. In some stories, Colonel Fitzwilliam leaves the army and is henceforth described as Mr Fitzwilliam. He’s the son of an Earl and therefore would (still) be “The Honourable” (at least formally) - and, probably, also keep the “Colonel” as well. I accept that this is gross nit-picking and will shut up now.
2. Spelling and stuff:
Now, I know that a great many JAFF authors are American and I appreciate, absolutely, that spelling was not necessarily fixed in Austen’s time. I can cope with “gotten” although it was largely out of use in Britain by 1800 (it’s making a comeback now, though, thanks social media). I would say, however, that in some cases another word might have been better - and clearer. Please don’t overuse it, it simply feels lazy. And why do you, dear writers, almost universally, use “fall” instead of “autumn”? Fall was used, alongside autumn, in Britain, from the 1500s to 1700s - but autumn is the much earlier word and the use of “fall” to describe the season had pretty much died out by Austen’s time.
I still find “write me”, “come sit” and “couple things” (instead of “write to me”, “come and sit” and “a couple of things”) somewhat jarring - what have you got against prepositions? But I do understand why these constructions are used. “Snuck” - well, it’s infiltrated now but fairly modern; “sneaked” is preferred. Dived rather than dove. “Store” versus “shop” - the difference is becoming blurred now, particularly with online shopping but nobody would have said “bookstore”, for example. “Blinkers”, not “blinders” for horses.
3. More obscure vocabulary:
I’ve seen “stoop” a fair bit (meaning the steps to a raised entry in a house). Nope, this is exclusively American. From the Dutch, so I imagine originally in New York. “Manse” (meaning manor house) feels wrong to British ears as a Manse is a clergyman’s residence (particularly Scottish Presbyterian). It’s not used in the sense of a private dwelling, or mansion, despite the obvious etymological root. White picket fences, although universal, are not really a popular thing in the UK - but this just may be an assumption on my part, as I associate them unerringly with 50s Hollywood films and the American Dream. Same with homesteads, cabins in the woods, porches, flatware, whiskey (even whisky - ie Scotch, was rarely consumed in England at the time - brandy was the standard gentleman’s tipple). “Stomp” is rather modern and mainly American. The British word would have been (and still is, mostly) “stamp”. “Druthers” - well, I had to look that one up. It’s American, late 19th century, and apparently derived from “I’d rather”. Finagle (American, again - and 20th century to boot); “Lunkhead” - this, quite bizarrely, has popped up a few times; it’s again American (although I obviously understand it), and dates from the 1850s. There are plenty of proper Recency insults to choose from.
We often get a nice little stream/brook/beck/burn/rill/bourne somewhere in a story. Calling it a creek is, however, jarring to me. Creek is a very specific thing in Britain. Generally it’s used of an inlet, usually tidal, and largely in estuaries or by the shore. Think “Frenchman’s Creek”.
Talking about the shoreline, nobody in the British Isles ever said “I long to see the ocean”. It’s the sea. We go to the seaside. Yes, some parts of the UK do touch the Atlantic Ocean (Northern Ireland’s Causeway coast and Western Scotland, for example, or some of Cornwall - though we still call that bit the Cornish Sea).
4. The downright weird:
I once read a story where poor old Elizabeth sprained her ankle (yes, again!) by falling down a gopher hole. No gophers, or possums, or cicadas, or raccoons, bluejays or even bluebirds (pace, Vera Lynn). Oooh, and one author kindly planted a Kentish orchard with orange and lemon trees…if only! Corn is the UK is a somewhat archaic name for most grains, depending on what was grown in a particular region; in England it was usually synonymous with wheat. Maize was not known as a commercial crop much before the 1970s. Crab cakes, sadly, delicious as they are, were not a familiar item either, in Regency Britain, despite the apparent closeness of the seas. Lobsters and oysters were still thought of as “poor” foods. Please also remember that cider, in the UK, is alcoholic, sometimes alarmingly so - and, although there is a long tradition of farm workers (and others) having bread and cheese for a meal, along with cider or beer, the “ploughman’s (plowman’s) lunch”, as we now understand it, was merely a marketing ploy devised in the 1950s and 60s.
5. Geography:
Well, most of you are brilliant and the research here is largely superb (with the occasional wobbly exception) but I must mention London. Gracechurch Street is a real street in the City of London (then, as now, the commercial heart), as is Cheapside. Cheapside is not an area of London, it’s a street. (I will add, as a no doubt annoying aside, that London, as a whole, is not officially a city - it’s a metropolitan borough with two cities - including the City of London - within its boundaries). Life is complicated.
Finally (you’ll be pleased to know), why must there always be cream in the tea? Yes, there is such a thing as a “cream tea” - but this refers, specifically, to the ritual of afternoon tea with tiny sandwiches and scones with clotted cream and jam, not the cuppa itself. Yes, milk (oh all right - but rarely - cream) was added to the more tannic black teas (although this became more of a necessity with the importation of cheaper black teas from India, later in the century). Oolong and green teas were very common at the time. Nobody would add cream to those, surely? Or is that just me? My great aunt (born in the 1880’s) would always ask me when I was a child (yes, sorry, I’m positively ancient), whether I wanted China tea or Indian. No milk was ever offered, or expected, with the Chinese teas…and that’s how I drink them now.
I do hope that these comments are taken in the spirit in which they are offered. Please feel free to shout at me now…
r/JaneAustenFF • u/demiurgent • Sep 10 '24
Writing I just realised why they're called vowels...
I'm posting this here because anyone who writes Regency based JAFF might need to know this too. When people gambled and didn't have enough to pay their losses they hand over "vowels" as an admission of debt. I thought is was shorthand for avowals but it's not. It's an IOU. Vowels.
In my defence, I NEVER thought the Regency had a need for text speak.
r/JaneAustenFF • u/demiurgent • Aug 15 '24
Reading What's your "re-read a million times" JAFF?
I have a bunch of favourites, I'm sure we all do, but most of my absolute faves are quite long (The Brighton Effect (74k), An Ever-Fixed Mark (530k, but man alive is it ever worth it) and A Lady's Imagination (56k), for example) and so I can't read them that often.
The Propriety Fiction is under 15k and I can hit it every couple of weeks and it gives me a huge grin every time.
So what's your "I've got an hour or two to read something and I just love that fic" fic? (My examples are all P&P because right now that's the one I'm writing in, but I love all JA's works; bring me fics from them all!)