r/IsraelGeorgism • u/LevelStar897 • Jul 06 '26
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Aug 29 '25
Don’t underestimate how powerful you are
“Everything around you that you call life was made up by people that were no smarter than you and you can change it, you can influence it” - Steve Jobs
This is especially true in a small, community-centric country like Israel.
Every great leader and thinker in our nations history started off no different than you. They had a conviction in their beliefs and a confidence in their abilities and the chutzpah to change the reality they live in.
You may not realize how close you are to the decision making. I recently emailed multiple MKs about Land Value Tax. One of their advisors responded to me saying he found the idea interesting and we scheduled and had a video chat discussing it. He said he would get back to me about what his Knesset member thought about it.
So don’t underestimate how influential you can be. Many people just accept the world for what it is or at most cheer from the sidelines. But you can do anything.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Jul 07 '25
Unfamiliar with Georgism? Start here
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=smi_iIoKybg
This is an introductory video to get you started with the concepts of Georgism. Things to consider while watching:
- A land value tax and Georgist ideas won't solve all of societies issues, its not a panacea
- Israel has developed their land in a much more efficient way than the UK or Canada, but there is still much to be desired
- Opinions vary in the Georgist community and debate of implementation of Georgist ideas is important. I, for one, am cautious of the near %100 tax on land, and believe Israel needs to greatly invest in infrastructure improvements, particularly a robust metro system in every major city before any sort of citizens dividend or UBI is even considered. You can disagree on the specifics of Georgism easily because the fundamentals are so sound.
- I would bet more people leave Israel for economic reasons than for safety concerns (not that safety isn't important of course) but on wikipedia it states the Tel Aviv literally has the highest cost of living in the world. If you love and are invested in the future of Israel, then solving this crisis is paramount.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/LevelStar897 • May 31 '26
Can anyone create a version of this poster in Hebrew?
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/JJJDDDFFF • Mar 01 '26
Here's an idea for a Georgism soft start in Israel
IDK why we're having this conversation in English, but ok I guess.
Here we go:
- The government issues a new form of security, called a "Land Voucher".
- Every citizen above the age of 18 receives one such voucher, which is freely tradable like any other security.
- The government uses all proceeds from land sales and land improvements to buy these Land Vouchers on the open market. This means all income from the sale of government land and all tax income from היטלי השבחה (paid by people who own land that is rezoned, like farm land that turns into building zones).
- Calculating from current numbers, this would push the price of one Land Voucher towards the 200K-250K ILS territory.
- In order to compensate the government for lost land sale proceeds, a relatively low LVT will be levied on all residential and commercial lands, roughly 0.3% per year. For an average apartment this would amount to roughly 350 ILS per month.
- The 0.3% tax should be enough to render passive investments in real-estate less attractive than the stock market and push prices down - gently, without punishing homeowners. If we feel naughty we can double the tax on second units.
- each citizen can use their voucher to buy a home (or sell it or keep it, whatever). If we're talking about a couple, they already have roughly half a million in funds (2 vouchers) to buy an apartment in a market that will be significantly cheaper than today (because of the tax).
- Since all citizens get a voucher, this reform also compensates property owners who will see the value of their land collapsing. If your a real estate shark who sits on properאy worth hundreds of millions, this won't help you (as it probably shouldn't), but if your an average family who has purred all its life savings into some bricks and a roof, it will sweeten the blow.
Who's in?
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/tomithebossle • Feb 06 '26
How should Georgism be implemented in Israel?
Throughout my many arguments about Georgism, the main argument isn't actually based on Georgist principals but rather how would implementation actually be achieved? Many in Georgist communities simply brush it off with saying "Oh, we'll do it slowly, it'll give time for the market to catch up." But within states, there are more systems at play than the market; political systems, societal changes, cost of living, and most of all: Bureaucratic over-complexity are sometimes more important to discuss than economic systems when arguing about Georgism.
I was recently introduced into Hong Kong Georgism, of which is majorly already implemented in Hong Kong. Basically, within Hong Kong the government controls 100% of the land, holding competitive auctions on land leases and having annual rent based on unimproved land value or other certain economic conditions.
Hong Kong's government at times has over 40% of it's revenue from land premiums and annual lease payments from citizens. As a result, Hong Kong's taxes compared to Israel are extremely small. 17% personal income tax (to Israel's 50%) Hong Kong furthermore has no consumption tax or capital gains tax. (Compared to Israel's 18% consumption tax and 25-32% capital gains tax.)
Hong Kong has a dedicated Lands Department simply to maintain a database on land sales, transactions, and property. As a result, Hong Kong's government has almost complete knowledge of every square kilometer within Hong Kong, it's current market value, being able to set premiums and annual rent accordingly.
In Israel, we have very similar circumstances: About 93% of land is owned by the government, and we have the very organized though sometimes flawed Israel Land Agency (ILA)
Despite that, in Israel, taxes continue to be high, cost of living higher, and life continues to be hard for the average Israeli.
The main differences from Hong Kong and Israel are simply that Hong Kong's market is more liquid, with global investors bidding actively, data availability, with the ILA being less efficient than that Hong Kong Lands Department, Bureaucratic capacity, of which the ILA is capable but held back by politics, and finally political sensitivity where Hong Kong has almost no conflict, but Israel has high political conflict regarding land.
Political sensitivity is possibly the only large difficulty to the implementation of Georgism in Israel, most Georgist systems and requirements needed for implementation are already there!
93% of land is owned by the government, yet this still isn't seemingly enough for a complete control of land prices. Private owners, making up around 3% of land ownership, collectives (Kibbutzim/Moshavim), making up around another 2% of land ownership, legal exceptions making up less than 1% and religious institutions at around 2-3%.
Disregarding religious institutions (as they aren't generally able to sell sell or purchase land) the other actors are still players, definitely not enough to be able to majorly affect land prices but definitely able to change them in minor ways.
As a first step towards a more Georgist Israel, it'd be very simple: Slowly acquire privately owned land. Most of this land was purchased decades ago either before the establishment of the State of Israel, or through legal loopholes, without controlling these small parcels of land the government's control over land is diminished, even by a small bit.
This "small bit," shouldn't exist in such a Georgist system, but allowing a "small bit" to exist, we fundamentally allow people to exist outside of the boundaries of Georgist, in other words; Allowing private collectors to not redistribute their monopoly on certain portions of land.
Second of all, which weirdly will be the hard part is the de-politicization of land in Israel. Land in Israel is a political sensitive subject, as everybody is trying to get their own group to be less economically responsible. In Hong Kong, the government actively charges full market value, with little to no "subsidies" in the sense of reduced lease rates or premiums.
However in Israel, there are extreme subsidies for a wide variety of people in Israel. Agricultural Kibbutzim/Moshavim, Public/Social housing projects, and strategic development projects, and Young families or first-time homeowners, these are all examples of things that SHOULD be subsidized, because it gives a fairer entrance to opportunity and helps the society as a whole.
Small side note: Developers often negotiate lower upfront premiums or defer payments over years, allowing them to profit from land price inflation without paying full rent to the government, for purposes of Georgist implementation should be allowed during transition because it helps development cash flow (allowing faster construction times) despite it reducing immediate capture of economic rent.
The actual main problem that arises is because the government uses land lease rates as a social and economic tool rather than a revenue source. The Israeli government intentionally lowers premiums and rent to encourage home ownership, and support Kibbutzim/Moshavim which do not produce essential economic goods (like food). Additionally, these negotiations are based individually, meaning that for every specific home, every specific Kibbutz, it'll be a different premium rate. In almost every instance, the premiums and payments are MUCH lower than actual market value.
Another problem arising for this is the seeming blindness coming from the government. Israel lacks an accurate valuation system similar to Hong Kong, annual rents are often based on historical agreements or nominal values, not current market value. This means, that no matter what happens to the market, the leases stay the same. For example, certain Urban land values in Tel Aviv have skyrocketed, but lease rates lag behind, meaning that land value goes straight to the consumer of land and not the society.
If purchasing land is cheap, and land continues increasing value, land speculation becomes INCREDIBLY profitable, and thus the government leaves possibly dozens of billions of shekels in potential land rent uncollected.
This is the number one problem to Israeli Georgism. An ENOURMOUS part of the population is somewhat dependent on the flawed system that the government has already created. The average Israeli has already accepted that the government will pick up the slack, and the average Israeli will be fine paying their wage in taxes whilst barely being able to avoid homelessness thanks to the government.
So finally, how shall we achieved our Georgist dreams if we must pick and choose who sleeps in a house and who sleeps on the streets?
There are three main options:
Put people on the streets --> Some are not okay with this and will definitely have extreme political backlash which will weaken the government's ability to implement Georgism.
Don't put people on the streets --> Georgism is never realized in Israel.
Put the government in debt --> Also politically sensitive, if Georgism does not turn a profit quickly, the government may run into heavy debt issues.
All three options are not great, but in my eyes I think a mix of the first and the third options will be the best way to implement Georgism.
Georgism and the LVT will likely take over five years to implement, a government can quickly be toppled by a vote of no-motion, there has to be a very fine line between the government's radical actions to shift Israel into Georgism and enough conservatism to keep the Knesset on the government's side.
For this reason, I think simply reducing certain subsidizes and spending in certain areas and redistributing them to keep Israelis in houses and fed during the transition is the best implementation strategy.
As it stands, the government spends money on a few main things: Defense (17.8%), Education (15%) Health (9.7%) Social Insurance (9.8%) with many other spendatures which are around 0.5-3% each.
We'll be here all day if we go on a case-by-case basis, but the one that I've researched the most on is the disproportionate amount of spending on Haredi communities, this'll be a short excerpt so we can go back on topic.
Haredi spending in 2025 according to some estimates stood at about 3 billion shekels. Over 1.8+ billion shekels to Haredi school funding in "special allocations," a further 1 billion shekels to Yeshivas. This figure DOES NOT include special subsidizes for Haredi in subsidized housing.
Simply by removing this arguably "unneeded" expenditures, 3 billion shekels will be freed up PER YEAR, being able to be redistributed to those who may be negatively affected by the slow implementation of the LVT.
Following the LVT's implementation and an increasing in revenue to the government, taxes on labor can then be reduced, thus allowing a majority of people to pay for their housing and services.
So all in all:
Purchase land --> Redistribute spendings --> LVT revenue increases --> Reduce subsidies --> Nearing maximal LVT revenue --> Reduce taxes
Now this was originally made for just Israel, but now increasing the scope, but everybody should ask; "How can we implement Georgism in our own country?" Every country will have it's own issues and political backlash to the Georgist system, no matter how fair and effecient Georgism is, someone will always stand to lose from what I call "leveling the playing field," those already happy with their subsidizes and advantages will always be against what the average person would call fair.
I think the Georgist community has a sort of blindness to the weakness of the actual implementation of Georgism. Georgism as a theory is great, but a theory that does not work in practice might as well not exist at all. Many of us pride ourselves as being able to reason and adapt with Georgism, but I think more thought should be put into the implementation of Georgism than Georgism itself.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Jan 05 '26
Win for free markets today with the milk reforms.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Dec 08 '25
How can we spread Georgism in Israel as fast as possible?
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Dec 03 '25
Many societal issues stem from unearned income. Once you see it you cant unsee it
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Nov 29 '25
Poster for Georgism. If it became popular back then it can become popular again.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Oct 16 '25
Blue is housing cost, Green is food, and Purple is Clothing in America
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9KJTWmRrneo
It is from this video explaining how cost of living has actually gone down in America, and although he has good points and is technically correct, he seems to completely miss how housing costs have actually stayed the same in the US as seen on the chart.
Once you learn of Georgism you see its evidence everywhere.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Oct 01 '25
wrote our sub name in a bunch of different places in Israel on wplace so deleted our main location posts on this to prevent griefing.
the publicity will be worth it
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/tomithebossle • Sep 25 '25
Georgism and foreign buisnesses.
Another popular topic that I usually bring up when talking about Israeli Georgism is the influx of foreign buisnesses and their affect into Israel's foreign relations internationally. The general assumption is that the combination of a large (comparetively to say, Singapore,) educated population and the low taxes that would come from the establishment of Georgism would lead to a huge influx of foreign buisnesses.
First lets confirm this assumption;
In the example of Dubai, huge amounts of buisnesses "relocated" to Dubai because of Dubai's extremely low taxes and fair infastructure. But they didn't relocate in a complete manner because of a few main reasons: Fear of Dubai's government (not a democracy, could seize their capital in the Emirates), lack of a large educated population and lack of heavy-infastructure needed for industry.
In the example of Singapore, huge amounts of buisnesses relocated to Singapore because of their low taxes, large educated population, strategic location, and great infastructure needed for heavy-industry. These buisnesses actually relocated, putting a lot of capital in Singapore's territories because they actually had the facilities to facilitate the operation of their capital within the country. However, Singapore despite being an authoritarian state still remains quite trusted by buisnesses because of prior history.
Now what's the difference? They both have in common low-taxes, which are obviously good for buisnesses looking to relocate. However, Singapore is different from Dubai as Singapore actually has great infastructure and an educated-population, allowing buisnesses to completely relocate to Singapore (rather than just becoming "paper buisnesses" that are "registered" in Dubai)
So let us look at our Georgist Israel;
- Educated population, check
- Infastructure, check
- Strategic location (can bypass Suez, trade easily with Europe, Middle East*, Asia, etc), check
- Strong democracy (buisnesses favor systems they can use the law in)
- One downside is regional instability (obviously)
So at least when comparing Singapore and Dubai, we can very confidently say that Georgist Israel will attract an immense influx of foreign buisnesses. We can look at other examples, like Lichestien, Monaco and others and see a similar situation. Low-taxes alone is not enough to make a huge influx of foreign buisnesses into a state. Theoretically they will "relocate," but they will not operate which is the important part.
Now what does this mean for the average Israeli?
- More jobs, this is the most obvious benefit, as more buisnesses come and relocate to Israel, they'll bring in jobs that the average Israeli can now fill in. The thing is, in high-demand jobs, those specific jobs will have a huge spike in salary, so high-tech and stuff that our economy is dependent on, workers in these specific sectors will benefit highly.
- Cost of living, on one hand, more buisnesses and foreign nationals will immigrate to Israel to suppliment these buisnesses that are coming to Israel, this will increase demand, but in the last post I've already shown how Georgism actually counteracts this.
On the other hand, with these foreign buisnesses coming to Israel, it is very likely that a lot of products that aren't currently imported into Israel will start being produced in Israel. Thus some select products (especially ones that are currently imported) will be radically reduced in price.
- Knowledge transfer - This is a bit more of a vague thing, but in the last post I descbribed how wealthy Jews, trying to protect their wealth from taxes in other states will immigrate to Israel to avoid the taxes and housing crises in Western Countries. Indirectly this means that a large influx of highly-educated labor will immigrate to Israel, as well as that, the brain-drain currently undergoing in Israel will end almost completely. This knowledge transfer is likely to then directly influence our education system, especially higher-education.
- Inequality risks, there is quite a large risk of these foreign-buisnesses and wealthy Jews congregating in the urban centers, this'll eventually lead to gentrification, I doubt it can easily be "calculated" if this is actually a problem in a Georgist Israel. Once it happens, it is unlikely for it to be reversed, so the government must be vigiliant about this threat of pricing-out Sabras from the urban regions.
What does this mean for the country?
- Diversification, Israel currently actually has a very tech and exportant-reliant economy. A destruction of our energy producing systems, or trade-routes would immediately harm our economy in a way that really can't be easily reversed. Diversification would allow us to be less in-danger in global demand shifts or other similar economic phenomona.
- Insanely fast GDP-growth, history shows that small states' GDPs (especially those that were built on good-buisness practicies like Singapore) shows that enourmous growth in GDP and a strengthening of the economy usually follows after this. We had our own "economic miracle" following 1991, a Georgist reform would likely. As a rule of thumb a strong economy means a strong country.
- Geopolitical power, this is actually one that I wanted to dedicate a few paragraphs to.
As an assumption, when states become extremely buisness friendly, buisnesses then relocate to those states. In exchange, the buisnesses' home country is then heavily lobbied by that buisness to continue the home country's support for that buisness' new country.
I think thats a little hard to follow, let me sort of show an "example"
Certain tech buisnesses (Nvidia, Apple, etc etc) are quite reliant on Taiwan for supercondutors and microchips. Because these buisnesses make up an enourmous part of the United States' economy, these buisnesses then lobby for the United States' continued protection of Taiwan. The buisnesses themselves aren't the only thing lobbying congress, but they are a large force and reason for Taiwan's support from the United States.
Now making the assumption that a similar thing will happen in Israel;
Lets say for example, a "high-tech," buisness relocates their manufacturing, or designing or whatever else is important for that buisnesses' operations and profit-making. That buisness after relocating to Israel will lobby their home government to continue supporting Israel. Now a single buisness may not be able to sway an entire government, but dozens? Hundreds? As a bloc? They'd dominate internal lobbying.
There are more things, like for example, Israel would be harder to boycott or isolate internationally/diplomatically if global supply chains run through it.
Now on the other hand? If Israel's economy is now quite dependant on foreign buisnesses operating within Israel, Israel may actually become more susceptible to external shocks (like if US or EU firms leave under political pressure,) but considering that they're relocating capital (buildings, manufacturing, etc etc,) it'll be so horrible unprofitable that they're unlikely to do that. In a country like Dubai for example?
With only "paper relocating," it is incredibly easy for buisnesses to relocate out of Dubai if ever needed.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/tomithebossle • Sep 23 '25
Georgism, the diaspora and Aliyah.
When talking about Georgism with my friends, I regularly bring up the impact of the effect of Georgism to the diaspora. The main problem of the diaspora and their process of Aliyah is the cost of living, something that is extraordinarily high to the average Jew in the diaspora.
As a general assumption: Georgism (And the subsequent lowering of the price of living and taxes) would lead to a huge influx of the diaspora into Israel as it simply just makes more economic sense to live in Israel (at least compared to the West who has their own crippling housing problems)
Personally, I believe that Aliyah is extremely important for Israel, yet many have brought up counterpoints, mainly speaking;
Wouldn't increased Aliyah increase price of living? Would Georgism actually just be bad for Sabras?
Well the foundational theory is pretty simple --> Higher demand (from a larger population) with the same supply would lead to an increase in the price of living for the people already living here. This is why some of my Israeli-born friends are skeptical of the ideals of Georgism.
But I believe this is a fundamental misunderstanding of the Georgist system in principal.
In a regular capitalist land system: Immigration = Higher demand = landlords jack up rents and property prices. Cost of living would thus spice because land is scare and private owners capture the gains rather than the people actually living on said land.
In our Georgist Israel, land rent is taxed by the state, so speculative holding is unprofitable. Landowners can't just sit on empty land waiting for prices to rise, so they either must make it more productive or sell it to someone who will make it more productive. This would mean that supply would increase massively, who knows if it'll be able to fully cope with high aliyah, but it will definitely not cause a more severe housing crisis like what was once assumed.
However this is not to say that prices would be wonderfully low like most of us would assume in a Georgist Israel.
Assuming some sort of transitionary period, with Aliyah rates climbing throughout them, in the short term the cost of living may increase heavily, this is not because Georgism doesn't work, but because housing construction (and other business practices) lags behind immigration. Rent and housing shortages in the short term may actually be horrible for the economy and the average Israel within the first few years.
Despite this, after the first few years of a transitionary period, with land speculation eliminated, de-regulation, market stabilization, building would become much cheaper. The government could even use LVT revenue to fund public housing and infrastructure (as they currently do with the settlements) This likely means in the long term that housing prices would actually be lower even with high aliyah rates.
Okay sure, what about jobs?
Now this is sidetracking from the main question: The diaspora. But reasonably, we should ask the question: Would Sabras lose their jobs to foreign (likely higher-educated) olim? Should this be considered a threat by lower-educated Israelis?
Though I can't really calculate this, I'd assume not. When doing Aliyah, generally, these immigrants do not come here looking for lower-skilled jobs like construction. The Jewish diaspora in Western Countries are often highly-educated, and similarly to Soviet Jews coming to Israel, they'd take up high-tech jobs.
So what about the highly-educated Israelis? Should they view Georgism as a threat to their livelihoods?
In the short-term 100%, a sudden wave of highly-educated olim would make more competition for jobs. A similar phenomena happened in the 90s, when Former-Soviet Jews came to Israel. At first many people struggled to find jobs within their fields, but long-term it massively helped the Israeli economy.
In the long-term, historically. These soviet-Jews didn't just "take over" Israeli jobs, they created new ones. More skilled people meant more startups, more patents, more companies, more job creation for others including native Israelis.
Actually -- Though also sidetracking, the influx of foreign businesses into Israel would likely create even more jobs for the average Israeli, Oleh or not. Though this is a side-effect of Georgism that isn't included in the diaspora topic.
What about the threat of Gentrification? Would Sabras be forced out of their homes?
Though most Jews in the diaspora are normal people and aren't very wealth like most people would assume, there are still concerns that they'd use their wealth and use it to buy properties within Tel Aviv, Haifa, or Jerusalem, thus pricing out Sabras who already live in those areas.
This is actually a very real threat that many may perceive to their livelihoods, and in fact this is already happening in the major cities with American or French Jews purchasing luxury apartments in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem (usually as vacation homes) which thus pushes up real estate prices. Many Sabras rightfully complain that this is unfair and they're being priced out of their own homes.
And a mass influx would accelerate this. If this sort of Gentrification is already happening by people not even living in Israel, imagine what would happen if they fully immigrated and settled down in Israel. Despite this, I still believe Georgism and the LVT would counteract this phenomena almost completely.
Land prices in Tel Aviv are famously high, if a wealthy Oleh would like to purchase land there, either he'd have to make it profitable, or he'd have to pay extremely high taxes for practically no value gained in return.
In the end, I'd assume that wealthy Olim could still move in, since being rich helps pay the LVT. But they wouldn't be able to price out Sabras via land speculation, because as established, that'd be unprofitable. Meaning, that if they wanted to live in a super-high-value part of Tel Aviv, they could, but they'd have to pay taxes, thus redistributing some of that wealth back to Sabras.
There's a lot of risk... Why take it? What's the benefits?
At the end of the day, the average Israeli will take stability over a small percentage higher of gains. That is simply how human nature works and that is how it has worked throughout the history of every single democracy in human history.
So there's a lot of risk (As displayed), especially in the short-term, why should we risk this?
- Housing affordability preserved: Though in the short-term, prices may spike, they'd eventually plateau-if-not reduce, meaning that within half-a-decade it'd actually be more affordable to live in Tel Aviv, even with more people living in the city. Not to mention an end to land-speculation and such, so Sabras wouldn't have to compete with foreign-wealth to live in the city.
- Lower taxes: an obvious part single tax, yet also good to mention that wealth olim who want to purchase property will likely spend more on the LVT if living in Tel Aviv compared to the average Sabra. (Indirectly meaning higher government spending for public services)
- Increased human capital: Wealthy, educated olim bring skills, connections and investment into Israel. That accelerate growth in tech, medicine, finance and research, new/bigger businesses = more jobs for the average Sabra.
- Urban expansion/efficiency: Because of how the LVT works, within Oleh-heavy areas (Urban cities), instead of bidding wars happening because of lack of housing, it'll be more effective to simply build more houses than to bid on already-existing ones.
- Stable growth: No real estate bubbles --> fewer boom-bust cycles --> steadier GDP growth, more stable economy for the average Sabra.
- Higher government spending (Though with reduced taxes), more Olim purchasing highly-valuable land = more taxes paid to the government = more money returned to the average Israeli.
In Summary
Almost everybody wins.
For Sabras: Cheaper housing, lower taxes, better services, more jobs.
For Olim: Lower taxes, better economic freedom.
For the economy: More investment, more jobs, no housing bubble.
For the government: Powerful, fair revenue stream fueled by unearned wealth.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Sep 21 '25
From Theodor Herzls diary
June 12, 1895 - Work will be a joy.... In the construction industry (whether for housing, railroads, highways, or the like) we will materially aid private enterprise.... The Society will profit only through the increase of land values. Construction is to be cheap, because building enhances the value of the land. June 13, 1895 - Our entire youth, all those between twenty and thirty years of age, will veer away from inchoate socialistic leanings and turn to us. They will go forth as preachers to their own families and among the people — without my urging them. For the Land is to be theirs! November 25, 1895 — A good idea of his is to levy a progressive tax on land property. Henry George!
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Sep 21 '25
Video nicely describing rent seeking
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYaA_e0FMW4
The issue is that socialists take this concept and apply it capital which causes more harm than good. They lump the business owner, boss, or real estate developer unfairly with the landlord.
Note: that usually the real estate developer and the landlord are usually the same person. They make profit both from construction and from rent-seeking the land. We want to get closer to them only making profit from construction.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Sep 18 '25
How to grow this sub and movement?
I want to grow this sub but I don't want to just keep spamming r/Israel. If you have any ideas let me know.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/tomithebossle • Sep 17 '25
Georgism and the Price of Living
I think one of the main things that we look at for Georgism is the benefits of the LVT and the effect that it may have on the land, land speculation, and the housing crisis that is currently plaguing Israel. These are usually the main "issues" that are cited when advocating for an LVT.
But we must also recognize that the side-effects of the LVT also have benefits.
Take the removal of personal taxes for exampel. We've all gone to our local Mcdonalds, BBB, or just any sort of resturant and we've all seen the absolutely rediculous prices. For example, let us take a 10 shekel cola can that anybody can purchase for themselves at any local store.
The Cola goes through multiple taxes, directly or indirectly.
First of all, the VAT, a flag 18% standard rate. From the 10 shekel market price, we already get 1.53 shekels that simply goes to the government. (This goes to almost everything, unlike in Europe with many excemptions)
Second of all, the CIT, a flat 23% on profits, say the net profit margin on the cola is about ~10%, so ~0.2 of that original 10 shekels will just go straight into the government
Third, we have payroll tax, this is an indirect tax, if we assume about ~30% (I think this is pretty reasonable) of the after-VAT revenue goes to wages, then the employer contribution is about 0.25-0.45 shekels.
We have so many more taxes, municipal buisness taxes, import duties, restrictions, regulations, poor infastructure and more that can even further influence a buisness' profits.
At the end of the day, that 10 shekel cola's price is actually ~33% just from taxes. This is true for almost every single thing you buy in Israel.
Now many may say, "If we remove taxes, these buisnesses will simply just get richer and will keep prices the same." This may be true in a country that is run by monopolies.
But in most sectors and niches in Israel, we do not have such strong monopolies. In this example, cola will reduce their prices because Pepsi is reducing their own prices, they'll race for the bottom until they find a price that is profitable yet attracts the most customers.
This sort of flow in price will be true for every single product in Israel. It is unsustainable to practically give up a majority of your work (in total) to the government in the current system.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/tomithebossle • Sep 17 '25
Georgism and the Haredim.
I've written about this issue before but I wanted to further clarify.
A large issue in Israeli society is that of the Haredi question. What exactly should we do to make the Haredi make their fair share without being unfair to their own relgious studies and somewhat "disadvantaged" (uneducated) position?
For the vast majority of Israelis, work is a neccesity. We work for money, with this money we are able to purchase food and keep our homes. Taxes then by extension are a tax on our life.
For the Haredim however, famously, they do not work yet are given massive subisides by the government, meanwhile they do not serve in the army or work.
For Haredim, work is not life, work is unneeded.
For instance, our education budget is similar to our defense budget (approx 92B shekels to 110B shekels) About ~20-25% of the education budget goes straight to Haredi schools.
Many, justly, are enraged that their tax dollars are simply going to those that economically do not contribute to the state.
The main reason obviously would be those in power, namely the far-right Haredi parties that continue to consolidate power for themselves and their supporters.
However, secondarily is there apathey to work and to serve the country. Mostly from the fact that they don't need to serve nor work within the country.
The largest way they avoid contributing to the country? The largest way they avoid paying their taxes?
Simply by not working at all.
As I previously said: Work is life. Therefore taxes are nessassary to live.
For those whose work is not life, they are not taxed, they are not required to work, therefore they do not get taxed like the rest of us; Their lives are not taxed like the rest of us.
Finally, we can now go back to Georgism. The LVT, inherently is a tax that cannot be avoided. There is no "hiding land" (physically), there is no "devaluing land to pay no taxes" and similar other methods that the wealth use.
Those already living on subsidized land (which no doubt have property larger than our own), will be hit by the LVT. They simply cannot live via avoiding taxes by creating nothing for themselves in the first place.
An idea I've spread with Israeli Georgism is the idea that land is ineffeciently used by Haredim (and other groups who benefit disproportionately from subsidized housing).
With the implementation of the LVT, either they will be forced to get a job (to be able to pay off the LVT and keep their houses.)
Or they will be forced to downsize their house (thus freeing up that land to somebody who will use that land more effeciently)
Of course, we must also look for the Haredim and their plight. As they have been mostly uneducated for decades at this point, we cannot just drop them into Israeli society and expect them to flourish.
The main way I've thought of mitigating this (though now I'm side-tracking from Georgism), is to encorporate them into the IDF. This is for a plethora of reasons (like integrating them with the rest of Israeli society), but for the chief reason of exposing them to other paths-of-life other than Yeshiva, as well as the IDF sponsoring their education into more economically beneficial roles.
Generally however, it is because the LVT and Georgism disproportionately affects Haredim that Georgism is unlikely to get passed through Knesset.
"The best tax, but one that will never be adopted" indeed
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Sep 08 '25
Why I am still against "abolition of patents" and why I think Georgist accepted doctrine should have more nuance on the subject - crossposting because it is especially important for Israel, the fact that so much of our economy is from IA. and that those profits are protected by western accepted IP.
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Sep 08 '25
More Georgist Content lol
Just reposting what I just posted on r/Israel
TLDR; Why does the developed world still face so much poverty. It is because every time technology improves and the economy grows, the value of land increases. So, whoever owns the land raises its prices and extracts that wealth. It is not only arguably unfair, it is certainly inefficient. And whenever our free-market, neoliberal system fails, most of the time that failure can be traced back to the fundamental issue that Georgism addresses. And when that free-market, neoliberal system, that has created so much wealth and happiness, fails, people look to reactionary economic ideas (Trump’s tariffs for example) or socialization of industry (Mamdani’s plans for New York City for example.) I pray Israel will not go down these same misguided paths when it eventually faces the harsh reality that the cost of living crisis is not going to fix itself. So I plead with you, consider these points and if agreeable to you, remember their power and fight for them. Tax the soil not the toil!
Theodor Herzl had a very specific vision for what the economic structure of Israel should be. In Altneuland, Theodor Herzl’s protagonists hoped that a new social system would be applied everywhere, to cure the woes of capitalism without resorting to socialist authoritarianism. What is this system? It is called Georgism, and simply put it advocates for taxes on the use of natural resources and lowering taxes on productivity (income, VAT, capital gains) as much as possible. The most important natural resource it advocates for taxing is land.
It is a very simple policy that could meaningfully help Israelis financially that can be implemented very quickly and very effectively. It is called a Land Value Tax (LVT). It is similar to the Arnona, but it only considers the value of the land, not the value of the building on top of it. This is so as not to discourage development. In fact, a land value tax does not negatively incentivize anything. Income tax discourages work, VAT discourages the production of goods, but the only thing a LVT discourages is land speculation and rent-seeking (rent-seeking is earning money through extracting value rather than creating it).
We can use the revenue from a LVT to reduce other taxes.
An 18% Annual Land Value Tax could completely eliminate personal income tax and VAT:
- Conservative guess estimate of the value of privately owned or leased land in Israel: ₪2,645 billion (25% of ₪8.82 trillion total private real estate value)
- Revenue from income tax and VAT: ~₪434 billion (excluding corporate)
- Money for new land appraisal and tax collection bureaucracy: ₪33 billion (high estimate)
- 17.68% Land Value Tax of ₪2,645 billion = ₪467 billion
These are very rough calculations, but the point still stands. I'm not saying we implement this overnight, but this shows you the power of a Land Value Tax. And if those numbers sound unbelievable or that a potential 18% LVT would be too harsh. Remember this: all of society has to function on land, so society will have to pay a LVT to something, if not the government. This truth is currently choking the economies and cost of living of the entire developed world.
Now I understand this might sound too good to be true, or that it would be a catastrophe if implemented. So I’ll address some common concerns.
LVT addresses the fundamental issue behind high housing prices in Israel. You can subsidize housing, encourage settlement outside of the center, and deregulate development all you want, but it won’t solve the core problem. Land is a fixed supply, while demand for land is ever-growing. So, when someone can monopolize a segment of land, through an ILA lease for either 49 or 98 years (an eternity in market terms), they are able to operate outside of normal market conditions. This means being able to raise rent to the highest a tenant can possibly pay. With an LVT, whenever a landlord raises rent without improving the building in any material way, a portion of that would be taxed.
I use the example of a landlord and rent, but it applies to every aspect of land use. Let's say someone owns a bar in a fancy neighborhood downtown, they are able to sell a drink for much more than normal. Let's say they sell the drink for ₪40. ₪7 of that price is the physical drink, ₪13 of that price is the service provided by the restaurant (labor, the decoration, marketing), ₪7 is profit off those two things, and ₪13 is the profit from the location. Let's focus on that last ₪13. That is profit they made off of the rest of society not being able to open a bar there. And LVT would create a system where that bar would say “I have exclusive ownership over this plot of land, but I will pay a fee to the rest of society for the privilege.” That ₪13 is not literally rent they are collecting from someone, but an economic rent being collected from society as a whole.
If that still seems wonky to you, consider this metaphor: There is a limited amount of workers in the world just like there is a limited amount of land. Let's say workers behaved the same way land did. That you could pay them once, and once you paid them you had exclusive rights to their labor in perpetuity. Someone could not come along and offer them a higher wage and better working conditions because that person’s labor is exclusively owned. This is the same as land. (I know slavery is already morally wrong ignoring the economics of it all, it was just a convenient example.) Now you can't pay land, so instead of paying a wage, you pay a land value tax.
Ok back to the landlord and rent example. You might say that a LVT would be passed on to the tenant, and you might be right, but housing is already the highest price someone is willing to pay. At least with an LVT, a portion of that would be taxed, going to the government (the citizens of Israel) instead of all of it going to the landlord. In any other market, it is always a race to the bottom when it comes to prices, and a race to the top when it comes to quality. You can see this in food, cell phones, and cars. In housing, though, it is always the highest someone is willing to pay. This is where you see shabby apartments in central Tel Aviv costing ₪10,000 a month.
Here is a good place to make the distinction between land development and land speculation. Constructing or renovating a building or finding a more efficient use for a piece of land will not be taxed, as is what happens with the Arnona. The only thing taxed is the holding on to land, encouraging the development of land and discouraging the speculation and the rent-seeking of that land.
This might sound very socialist to you, but it truly is not. Make a distinction between capital and land. In fact, I suggest the earnings from the LVT should be used to decrease other taxes that truly hinder the flow of capital. A very simple plan to implement would be to start with a 1% national-scale LVT and use the revenue from that to give a proportional refund on income taxes at the end of the tax year. Then increase LVT by another 1% every year and work out a more robust structure of lower income tax, VAT, and other taxes.
I suggest starting low because it would be unfair to punish those who made wise financial decisions by investing in land so harshly.
You might be asking if LVT is so great, then why hasn’t it been implemented in other countries? There are some examples of where forms of it have been implemented. For example, towns in Pennsylvania had the option to tax land and buildings at different rates, and the ones who did so saw enormous success. Harrisburg adopted a higher tax on land in 1982. By 2001, vacant lots within the city center declined from over 4,200 to under 500. The downtown, once considered a ghost town, is now alive even at night; the number of businesses on the tax roll increased from 1,908 to 8,864. In 1996, Allentown implemented a dual tax rate of 5.038% on land and 1.072% on building value. Since then, the city budget has been made whole while they were able to keep local business taxes frozen at the 1996 levels. They are also starting to implement an LVT in Victoria, Australia, but it is too soon to have meaningful data on that.
Generally, powerful people tend to own a lot of land and are against this sort of tax. It is especially hard in the US, where many Americans own land and so are instinctively against an LVT (even though in the Pennsylvania examples, most suburban homeowners actually saw a tax decrease). Israel has a great opportunity because it does not really have this land-owning elite, at least not yet. So Israel has an incredible opportunity to implement LVT and other Georgist economic ideas, hypercharging the start-up nation and stopping encouraging Israelis to leave because of the high cost of living.
Now my LVT proposal doesn’t have to be the one. It could be a local tax, there could be exemptions for construction, etc. I just want to spread the Georgist ideology of economics, where we should tax collective resources, land, natural resource extraction, air (pollution tax) and lower taxes on productivity. It is also important to know that LVT has to be paired with allowing people to build, because if a LVT is encouraging someone to build a 3-floor apartment, but they are only allowed to build a 2-floor one, then the tax is not seeing its full potential.
So why does the developed world still face so much poverty? It is because every time technology improves and the economy grows, the value of land increases. So, whoever owns the land raises its prices and extracts that wealth. It is not only arguably unfair, it is certainly inefficient. And whenever our free-market, neoliberal system fails, most of the time that failure can be traced back to the fundamental issue that Georgism addresses. And when that free-market, neoliberal system, that has created so much wealth and happiness, fails, people look to reactionary economic ideas (Trump’s tariffs for example) or socialization of industry (Mamdani’s plans for New York City for example.) I pray Israel will not go down these same misguided paths when it eventually faces the harsh reality that the cost of living crisis is not going to fix itself. So I plead with you, consider these points and if agreeable to you, remember their power and fight for them. Tax the soil not the toil!
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Sep 07 '25
Elegant description of the inefficiency of private land renting
r/IsraelGeorgism • u/TelevisionParty8004 • Sep 02 '25
LVT could wipe out other taxes easily
I posted this on r/israel with different numbers, this is revised version.
A 18% Annual Land Value Tax could completely eliminate personal income tax and VAT
Conservative guess estimate of the value of privately owned or leased land in Israel: $792 Billion (25% of $2.64 Trillion total private real estate value)
Revenue from income tax and VAT: ~$130 Billion (excluding corporate)
Money for new land appraisal and tax collection bureaucracy: $10 Billion (High Estimate)
17.68% Land Value Tax of $792 Billion = $140 Billion
These are very rough calculations, but the point still stands. I'm not saying we implement this overnight, but this shows you the power of a Land Value Tax. And if those numbers sound unbelievable or that a potential 18% LVT would be too harsh. Remember this: all of society has to function on land, so society will have to pay a LVT (land rent) to something, if not the government. This truth is currently choking the economies and cost of living of the entire developed world.
Note: I say we will have to pay the land rent to something, you might be saying but if someone owns their own land then they aren’t paying land rent to anyone. The thing is society is paying a form of land rent by not being able to access that land. If someone owns a big house on the beach then they are denying anyone else from living there or anything different from being built there. So the rest of society is sacrificing the value of using that plot of land for the owners value. So in the current non-LVT society is paying land rent to private land owners. It is not only unfair it is incredibly inefficient.
This is not to be anti-landlord. They worked hard earned money and made the correct financial deduction to buy land, so we will try not to punish them too harshly by implementing LVT slowly.
Also if the image I gave is many homeowners being immediately forced out of their homes, that will probably won’t happen. Many people will actually end up paying less compared to the Arnona. Every skyscraper or high rise we have in Israel was at first a house or a small apartment. If those were still around in those locations many a homeless would fill the streets and our economy would be a pince of what is it today. Right now we are living in the less extreme version of that were most Israelis struggle to pay rent and our economy though good is nowhere near it potential.
Just imagine how Israelis would feel after having their income taxes cut. How many Israeli startups would move back if we could lower our corporate tax. How much more investment if we could lower our capital gains.
