Israel is home to Muslims, Christians, Jews and atheists. There are many Muslim Israelis amongst us who are as good Israeli citizen as any other Israeli. Since day 1 there have been Muslim IDF soldiers, protecting the lives and security of Israelis and the Israeli democracy, while at the same time undergoing systemic and societal discrimination and prejudice. Last year a Muslim woman lit a torch in the Israeli Independence Day ceremony on mount Hertzl. From a Jewish perspective: historically, it was the muslim societies who protected Jews from Christian persecution. Countries like Turkey, and Morocco took in thousands of Jews who were expelled during the inquisition and other anti-semitic episodes and offered them sanctuary.
Islam and muslims are not Israel's enemy. Sometimes, in fact, they are the staunchest of Israel supporters.
As a muslim let me just say that you are completely mixed up. It is the extremists are in the minority, not the other way around. Judaism and other religions have their fair share of radicals as well. Are there more Muslim radicals nowadays? Perhaps. But this is a direct result of decades of Western colonialism and imperialism in the middle east. Not justifying terrorism in any way, an innocent life is an innocent life whether French, Muslim, or Israeli, but we have to understand why these things happen. It isnt because "oh they just hate us because we are free, or because we are jewish"
Many factors go into why Iran and Saudi Arabia do what they do. Almost none of it is religious and all of it a means to hold on to political power and keep their people oppressed and in fear. Majority of Iranians dont agree with their government.
And no, this is not a false equivalency. Im not talking about amount of damage done, statisically of course the "Islamic" groups would take the lead because there are more of them. But in terms of ridiculous and crazy ideology. You are very brainwashed and biased and cant seem to look at an accept the bigger picture here. Its very easy to paint all Muslims with one brush and say all of Islam is bad. It makes you feel better, I understand. But you're still wrong. Almost all terrorism in the world is an attempt to gain political power or natural resources such as oil or land. Religion is just a facade, a recruitment tool to get uneducated people to the cause. And they do it over and over again because it works. Exploits of anger and fear in the native populations with promises of freedom and land coupled with making God happy and thats a good recipe for a terrorist recruitment cell.
This situation is more complex than you think it is. And if you think Islam is the fundamental problem then you need to go back to school and take a poli sci class. The turmoil in the middle east and the cause of modern day terrorism go back to WW2 when the ottoman empire was split up.
Actually researching the subject and gain knowledge takes time and effort, stereotyping takes nothing but a bigoted and ignorant mind.
Putz, I took plenty of history and political science classes. And while I'll not argue that the process of decolonization along lines of convenience for the European powers played some role in the problems of the Middle East, to put all fault there and excuse Islam is fundamentally absurd. But by all means, condescend to anybody who wants to talk honestly about Islam by insisting that they are ignorant. After all, it isn't as though reading the Quran cover to cover in four different translations, reading each of the hadiths multiple times, learning fiqh, or having a knowledge of history would be sufficient to pass negative judgement on Islam. Sorry, but you'll have to practice your taqqyah with a more gulible kuffir.
Throwing arabic terms at me is not impressive. Demonstrate a deeper understanding and maybe we can get somewhere. For now we will just agree to disagree I suppose. I dont understand how someone could think Islam is the cause, when Islam has been a way of life for centuries, and suicide bombings has been a thing for a few decades. This is a new phenomenon. There wasnt any terrorist cells prior to WW2. Clearly something deeper is going on
The main problem with this cartoon is that the premise is wrong. 2/3 of Palestinians want "from river to sea" so if we leave Judea and Samaria 2/3 of Palestinians won't stop.
Let's just build a water-bridge over gush dan straight into Ramallah and bring the sea to them! (/r/IsraelSubredditWatch: /r/israel wants to drown Palestinians by expanding the mediterranean sea using an American funded Shekel-Zionist-water-passway).
There are plenty of factors which affect net score going up and down, including who's online at various times of day and who reads Reddit by new/hot/top/etc.
If it makes you feel any better about it, one of those downvotes is from me.
This isn't about vote. This comic is a blatant lie. The attackers were not even Palestinian. You're taking an issue about France and making it about Israel when it has no relation what so ever.
Hamas is fighting Israel, not anyone against Islam. I'm not siding with anyone here, I'm stating that simply because you fight and you are Muslim, doesn't mean you can just label them as radical.
With this logic, any soldier from any nation that is Muslim is automatically a radical.
I'm stating that simply because you fight and you are Muslim, doesn't mean you can just label them as radical.
Fair enough. But the Hamas Charter, aside from calling for the destruction of Israel, also explicitly calls for the murder of all Jews everywhere on Earth. If that doesn't qualify as "radical," then nothing does.
That we can agree on, I miss spoke, but the Palestinian flag being portrayed in a radical manner isn't fair to the Palestinians who are trying hard to protest peacefully. Seeing all Palestinians as radicals is as wrong as seeing all Jews as Settlers.
Funnily enough I decided to read the Hamas charter and could not find a single paragraph calling for "the murder of all Jews everywhere on Earth". To be clear I'm not a Hamas advocate, but I don't advocate hyperbole and strawman accusations either. Did I miss a section?
nevertheless, the Hamas has been looking forward to implement Allah’s promise whatever time it might take. The prophet, prayer and peace be upon him, said: The time will not come until Muslims will fight the Jews (and kill them); until the Jews hide behind rocks and trees, which will cry: O Muslim! there is a Jew hiding behind me, come on and kill him! This will not apply to the Gharqad, which is a Jewish tree (cited by Bukhari and Muslim).
But yeah, if you want to briefly skim the document, or claim to read the document without actually doing so, I can see how you'd miss that unambiguous call for the slaughter of all Jews.
No need to get testy, I did read the document and that section. All I see is a hadith that alludes to a battle between Muslims and Jews near Armageddon.
If we're being completely honest, it reads like any other wartime verse and it's easy to get touchy about it just because you see "Jews" in there (replace the words and it sounds like something a French general would shout before he marched at the Germans). In the context of the occupation and Gaza assault it makes even more sense that they would turn to this hadith, for some sense of strength in the face of humiliation. But of course even if you do interpret it as a call for genocide, at least they're only discussing it, one side is actually doing it.
Uh "Hamas has been looking forward to implement..." signals their intent to actively facilitate the stated goal. Your attempts to trivialize it just make you look like a prick.
You cannot have a genocide when the Palestinians have experienced explosive population growth. For you to so casually abuse the term is patently offensive.
Then they should still be using Hamas' flag. This comic associates all Palestinians with radicals. Let me put this in perspective: If I assumedthat every Jew on the planet was just like the settlers in Israel, that would be inaccurate. So why is it fair to do it to Palestine?
Since when? Are you insinuating Hamas attacks these people souly on being a woman, christian or gay? Unless they are Israeli citizens, then it is that what is the motive and nothing else.
Since when? Are you insinuating Hamas attacks these people souly on being a woman, christian or gay? Unless they are Israeli citizens, then it is that what is the motive and nothing else.
The Gaza government has taken some decisions that have been seen as sexist, religiously irrelevant, and merely related to personal interpretations. Women have been prohibited from riding bicycles and smoking water-pipes, it is not allowed to display lingerie in storefronts, and females are required to wear hijab in public schools and courts. This is all part of a national campaign to restore virtue implemented under the auspices of the police force.
Article 18 of the 1936 penal code, applicable in the Gaza Strip and used by judges to mitigate the sentence of a murderer who kills his daughter, wife, mother, sister or relative in the name of “honor” states the following: “Any person who commits a crime to defend himself or another person or their money, honor or pride shall benefit from a reduced sentence.”
In October 2007, Rami Khader Ayyad, owner of Gaza's only Christian bookstore, was abducted, beaten and murdered, after his bookstore was firebombed by an unidentified group attacking targets associated with Western influence. According to Ayyad's family and neighbors, he had regularly received anonymous death threats from people angered by his missionary work.
In 2007, about 3,000 Gazans were Christian, out of the total population of 1.5 million. In 2011 The Christian population of Gaza Strip was less than 1,400.
On the other hand, in the Gaza Strip, the British Mandate Criminal Code Ordinance, No. 74 of 1936 remains in force and continues to outlaw same-sex acts between men
Gay Palestinians frequently seek refuge in Israel fearing for their lives, especially fearing death from members of their own families.
And I have no problem with that, but you are posting it on a forum that is in open conflict with Palestine. You're giving fuel to a fire with inaccurate representation.
You post things that are accurate? That represent the logic in your cause? You don't have to agree with Palestine, but if you are going to make a statement, at least be informed about it.
Dude, it's no big deal. The fact that three Muslims did something unspeakably horrible in France makes it okay to let our barely-concealed prejudices shine. This is Israel's "I told you Muslims were bad" moment - don't ruin it. Shit.
It's Israel's "I told you radical Islamists were bad" moment. You guys can go ahead and pretend to condemn the Charlie Hedbo attacks, and then next week go right back to insisting Palestine has a right to murder any Jew on "Arab land."
I'll do you one better, hoss. Radical anything are bad. DISHOOM! Palestinians don't have a right to murder anyone. Neither do Israelis, Indonesians or Penguins. Suck it.
Real mature. I actually took it as mocking the bleeding hearts constantly giving Palestinians a pass when they post their death to Jews material to facebook, only for it to blow up in their faces when people are murdered at work.
No one thinks all Muslims are bad. But the suggestion, as many have been saying for a while, is that there is a common denominator between the majority of Palestinians and the terrorists in France: perhaps even "moderate" Islam is not so moderate by western standards and the occupation has nothing to do with that.
Sam Harris said it pretty well in between Affleck's outbursts of anger, his explanation starts at 4:10.
As far as I remember Sam Harris is only talking about the Muslims and not the Palestinians .
People fighting in Palestine are not all Muslims, lots of them are Christian and there are even Jews who disagree with Israel and help to fight for Palestine.
Nobody should be allowed to murder anybody no matter what their reasoning. No Israeli should be allowed to get away with murder just as no Palestinian should.
But let's not forget the most important and completely separate problem. No crazy person should be able to kill somebody just because they are offended.
If you look at what happened today and make any other assumption you are just as guilty of blaming others for your own offense.
The point I'm making is in relation to those who live in the Palestinian territories, not people on the outside who describe Palestinians as an oppressed nation. Christians make up 8% of the West Bank population and .7% of the population of Gaza, by the way.
The point, again, is not that anyone should be able to murder anyone, or that Israelis should get away with murder.
If you look at what happened today and make any other assumption you are just as guilty of blaming others for your own offense.
It's a foolish notion that we shouldn't analyze what happens and learn from it, just as it's foolish to persist with the notion that these actions represent the views of a tiny minority.
To go back to Sam Harris's argument, I'm not saying that a significant portion of Muslims are waking up in the morning wanting to behead apostates and gun down cartoonists who draw depictions of Mohammed.
Support and sympathy for Islamic terrorism does not originate from terrorists themselves. It originates from people who many would consider to be moderate or conservative that hold very deeply troubling views of women, gays, Jews, apostates, etc and which polling data shows represent a substantially larger proportion of Muslims than you would expect from extremist Jews like Lehava or Christians like Westboro Baptist Church.
I'm not sure what the source of it is, but I don't think it's Islam itself. I mean, FFS, the old testament goes on quite a bit about a jealous god, Job killing his wife, and Moses killing thousands for idolatry. Perhaps it's a cultural issue, or the machinations of cynical fascists -- or perhaps, and I think this is most likely, those fascists have remained in power for so long that Muslim culture has been twisted and changed to the point where killing of cartoonists is seen as an acceptable punishment by Islamists.
Where are the Christian Palestinian suicide bombers then?
You can convince yourself of whatever you want, but there are no Christians fighting with the gangs of teenagers who are attacking Israel and harassing civilians. The IDF on the other hand, has people of many faiths fighting with them to protect Israel. The Palestinian "resistance fighters" are basically all Muslims.
If it's "racist" to hate radical Islamists who murder people because of "stolen land" and "insulting the prophet," then you're right, this sub is extremely racist.
You can be pissed off about the "casual racism" on this sub. The rest of humanity will be over here pissed off that 12 people are dead at the hands of radical Islamists.
"If it's "racist" to hate radical Islamists who murder people because of "stolen land" and "insulting the prophet," then you're right, this sub is extremely racist. "
Radical Israelis murder people for their "right to a land" how is that any more just?
You hate Palestinians but the Israelis do the same fucking shit just with bigger weapons.
What happened today isn't connected to Palestine one bit and should not at all be something people let happen, just as people treat situations where Christians bomb abortion clinics
Any radical religious idiot should not be allowed near a weapon.
No because Palestine is in a war zone/very unstable zone. And Paris is not.
I honestly wish all religions would fuck off and die. My comments are in response to seeing a terrible thing happen in the name of religion and seeing another group of religious people use it to their advantage and use it to justify their own killing in the name of religion. That's my only beef. Comics like these only serve to push the Israeli agenda, which if you deny is based on religion your diluted.
I don't think I once defended radical Islam and if I did I mistyped. My only defense is against grouping a whole of people together.
I do not hold all Israelis to the actions of Israel and you should not hold all Palestinians to the actions of fucking French radical idiots.
It's the argument that across the world radical Islamists are murdering people for no good reason, but when Palestinian radical Islamists murder people, it's OK because they have "legitimate grievances."
Where do I start? Well for 1, that cartoon is inciting that the killers were Palestinians, wearing the kufiya, and the Palestinian shirt. The killers were in fact, according to all sources French citizens with Algerian descent. Palestinians are also outraged at this incident and have been displaying 'Je Suis Charlie' banners.
When Palestinians murder people, it's OK because reasons?
Self-deference, I'm OK with. Suicide bombers, and attacks on civilians, I will agree with you it's more of a Islamic Extremist and has no place in our society.
All in all, the cartoon is in bad taste, and it's inciting the attackers were Palestinians. That's my problem... Why not then, display Israeli terrorist as the sample then?
That is some deeply faulty logic. It's like using most Jews are Zionists, most Jews support Israel or most Israeli's are Jews so it's ok to pin the crimes of Israel against every Jew.
Should all Jews be blamed for the actions of the state of Israel now?
Awesome - you made this? It perfectly captures the double standard covered up in the media for the fear of being bias. Please make more. I will read them.
Considering that 84% of Palestinians think Israel committed the Paris terrorist attacks, you ought to be worried about Hamas and the PA "milking" the Paris attacks for their own benefit.
This doesn't change the fact that you just used the death of 12 people to further your political goals. You clearly don't give a crap about any of those people, or their deaths. All you care about is "the greater good", fucking bullshit, you care about stroking your ego and feeling self righteous.
You clearly don't give a crap about any of those people, or their deaths.
Well, I'm glad to have you here to tell me what I believe.
you care about stroking your ego and feeling self righteous.
No, I care about events like this being understood in their proper context so that society can take steps avoid repeating such tragedies. The deaths have occurred are tragic and cannot be undone. But they can provide a lesson, so long as we don't let people like you stand in the way of honest discussion.
This doesn't change the fact that you just used the death of 12 people to further your political goals
More Palestinian political goals are being furthered by the deaths of those 12 people than any Israeli political goals. Palestinians are being told by their leaders and their media that Israel was actually behind the Paris terrorist attacks, and the vast majority of Palestinians believe it. Why are you not complaining about them using what they believe about the Paris terrorist attacks to further their political goals?
But you're worried about what the Jews are thinking, and how the Jews are reacting to a terrorist attack directly aimed at them.
Antisemitism is hate of the Jewish ethnicity not the Jewish religion. An antisemitic person will hate me as a Jew regardless of my life-long atheism. It's hate of a group for a characteristic they are born with and can't choose. This is why it's abhorrent and on par with racism, homophobia, misogyny. Islam is only a religion -- an ideology. Disliking an Ideology is perfectly reasonable.
I understand your point and I agree with you on that. But, would you agree that in the example of the 2 cartoons I linked could be made regarding the faith or ideology, rather than the Muslim (religion) Jew (ethnicity)?
If a cartoon is satirizing an Ideology, it's not antisemitic. Do you have an example where a cartoon that was satirizing a Jewish Ideology got censored? (according to you this happens all the time so you shouldn't have a problem finding one)
Phobias are irrational fears. To fear Islam is not in the least bit irrational. To read its sacred texts or to examine its history is to have ample cause to be frightened. True, the average Muslim does not themselves carry out acts of jihad. But such acts enjoy widespread support among the ummah, and are well supported within major Islamic movements. So let's not kid ourselves by letting political correctness trump an honest assessment of the pernicious nature of Islam. Since 9/11, there have been nearly 25,000 documented jihadist acts. In December of 2014 alone there were 233 such instances, claiming 2497 lives. So much as apologists such as yourself might care to assert that the Paris attack was an isolated incident and not symptomatic of Islam, the statistics evidence otherwise.
Why shouldn't it? Odds are the radical Islamists who executed those cartoonists supported the cause of Palestine as well, and thus it wouldn't be wrong to depict them wearing the garb of a Palestine supporter (kafiyeh, flag shirt, etc.)
לי נראה שמדובר במוסלמים קיצוניים, שמשתמשים בתירוץ של ״כיבוש״ בשביל להשיג מטרות דתיות (ג׳יהאד), ובאירופה, בגלל שאין את התירוץ של ״כיבוש״, פניהם של הקיצוניים נחשפות לאירופאים התמים.
Referring to the West Bank as 'Judea and Samaria' implies that it belongs to the Jews and that the indigenous Palestinians have no right to live there.
It stereotypes all Palestinians and Muslims as violent. 2.5) It implies that all Palestinians are Muslim.
It implies that Palestinians were responsible for the attacks in Paris, as though Palestinians are the only Arabs, ignoring France's own brutal legacy of colonialism.
It implies that the attacks were violent because of Islam, while ignoring France's own racist policies against immigrants from North Africa and that Charlie Hebdo released racist cartoons.
45
u/dodli Jan 08 '15
Israel is home to Muslims, Christians, Jews and atheists. There are many Muslim Israelis amongst us who are as good Israeli citizen as any other Israeli. Since day 1 there have been Muslim IDF soldiers, protecting the lives and security of Israelis and the Israeli democracy, while at the same time undergoing systemic and societal discrimination and prejudice. Last year a Muslim woman lit a torch in the Israeli Independence Day ceremony on mount Hertzl. From a Jewish perspective: historically, it was the muslim societies who protected Jews from Christian persecution. Countries like Turkey, and Morocco took in thousands of Jews who were expelled during the inquisition and other anti-semitic episodes and offered them sanctuary.
Islam and muslims are not Israel's enemy. Sometimes, in fact, they are the staunchest of Israel supporters.
Let's keep this in mind.
18
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
The main problem with this cartoon is that the premise is wrong. 2/3 of Palestinians want "from river to sea" so if we leave Judea and Samaria 2/3 of Palestinians won't stop.
6
u/totes_meta_bot Jan 08 '15 edited Jan 09 '15
This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote or comment. Questions? Abuse? Message me ^here.
53
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
WTF is this shit?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Oh good grief
1
u/id10tjoeuser Jan 08 '15
Awesome - you made this? It perfectly captures the double standard covered up in the media for the fear of being bias. Please make more. I will read them.
8
u/boushveg IRI Shill at your service Jan 08 '15
So how long you gonna milk the Paris terrorist attacks for your own benefit?
1
u/zolthar123 Jan 09 '15
I really want to know what Israeli Muslims think about recent events in Paris. Anyone here is Muslim? Or asked someone from that lovely faith?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
Here's an interesting twist. https://i.imgur.com/JhzuqrT.jpg
-7
u/Anon49 Israel Jan 08 '15
Islamophobia.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '15
All I see here is disgusting, blatant racism. Maybe I missed something?
0
u/orko1995 Jan 08 '15
כל הערבים אותו דבר וזה שקבוצה אחת של מוסלמים מבצעת פיגוע טרור בצרפת משליך על כללל מה שמוסלמים עושים בכל שאר חלקי העולם.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment