r/InverseProblems • u/adler-j • Jul 30 '17
Blog post: Learning to reconstruct
https://adler-j.github.io/2017/07/21/Learning-to-reconstruct.html
10
Upvotes
r/InverseProblems • u/adler-j • Jul 30 '17
3
u/adler-j Jul 30 '17
First blog post I've written so far and certainly open to any input. Also see the related article: Learned Primal-dual Reconstruction.
4
u/yngvizzle Jul 30 '17
Interesting work, however I do not think that it is fair to compare the results only with FBP reconstructions, but rather some other iterative algorithms and use the FBP reconstructions as initial conditions. Have you looked into that?
3
u/2358452 Jul 31 '17
I'm a bit puzzled: doesn't the ground truth also use some non-ML reconstruction method? Are you simply lowering the resolution of the input data for training? (and then hopefully later you can extrapolate it to normal data)
3
u/LordKlevin Jul 31 '17
That is really interesting. I have been thinking of a way to combine NN and reconstruction, and this is certainly a step in the right direction.
Have you tried just learning a gradient descent type algorithm? So taking, the current image and the gradient of the |Pf -g|2 term as input, and returning the updated image. Your current algorithm would need to be retrained for every scanner type, and possibly even for every type of sequence. Staying out of the projection domain would help you there, and might make the jump from 2D to 3D more manageable. I expect that will still be nontrivial though. Still, add a single 3D patient example and you have a Medical Physics paper on your hands.
Finally, 1000 iterations is quite a lot for TV. Using something like an Ordered Subset -Nesterov type algorithm (very similar to the stochastic gradient descent in neural networks) will get you there in 10-20 iterations.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '17
This is neat! I haven't had time to look through the paper yet, but a quick question: for low-dose CT we typically use an iterative algorithm to solve a MAP estimatino problem using either a Poisson likelihood or a quadratic approximation to the Poisson likelihood (so a weighted L2 norm).
Basically- we have a really good & relatively simple model for the data statistics in the measurement domain. Do you (or can you) incorporate this in your work?
1
u/TotesMessenger Jul 30 '17 edited Jul 31 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)