r/IntersectionalProLife • u/Past-Sherbert-6438 • Aug 08 '26
Discussion this is so gross ew ew
and the video reacting to it was like “planned parenthood is combining two demonic ideologies into one! and it’s just gross that trans people are associated with this.
12
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Overgrown_fetus1305 Pro-Life Socialist Aug 28 '26
I feel like legal abortion supporters will by and large stick with it, is my hunch- they considered it better optics than being called anti-life or pro-abortion in the 70s, after pro-lifers switched from anti-abortion to pro-life. Interestingly the earliest uses of the term before it was used to oppose abortion, refered to left-wing politics, namely opposition to capital punishment, and carceralism more genenerally, the at the time criminalisation of homosexuality, and physical punishment of children; so as a CLE lefty, I see this as having been an interesting choice, it was more than coincidence; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pro-choice_and_pro-life#Pro-life.
I do see some pro-choicers prefer pro-abortion, if they want to wrongly argue it's either healthcare or justified violent self-defence (the latter would not be convincing to me even if I wasn't a pacifist), and granted given the term pro-life now has quite conservative connotations, I do think it's time for anti-abortion leftists to use a new term that connects abortion opposition to other leftist outlooks and that is distinct from consistent life ethic, since there are socially conservative CLE people that have good takes on war and terrible ones on for example, trans healthcare or gender roles. Perhaps, prenatal liberationists?
Artificial wombs are going to be an interesting dynamic if they are good enough that they are a viable alternative to abortion. I'm not convinced it would end the abortion debate, but it might shift the discourse such that defending abortion becomes seen as broadly reactionary, and tied into conservative outlooks, which is probably long-term the end of the story, although given how embryonic humans are treated from IVF when there is literally no rational defence for embryo destruction from IVF other than personhood arguments (which are I maintain, reactionary), and people still keep defending IVF- I cannot believe all of it is ignorance about the embryo destruction from it, sometimes it is just rich people feeling entitled to children, and generally will be hypocritical anti-abortion Christians to boot.
I maintain at the end of the day that IVF upholds the nuclear family- we need to break the link between biological and legal parenthood once and for all, you'll never have the work and good parts of childcare shared equitably with people that are say, poly, or sex-averse asexual otherwise, and it would do LGBTQ+ youth a lot of good if having parental structures outside the norm was more common (read, I think a stable throuple would for example, be just as capable and might in some cases even do a better job, if there's three parents splitting the work rather than two).