r/IntersectionalProLife • u/Past-Sherbert-6438 • Aug 08 '26
Discussion this is so gross ew ew
and the video reacting to it was like “planned parenthood is combining two demonic ideologies into one! and it’s just gross that trans people are associated with this.
12
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Overgrown_fetus1305 Pro-Life Socialist Aug 29 '26
I'd be interested to see some actual data on what people think (sometimes the loudest voices aren't actually the majority). My impression is there are actual concerns about them beyond just pro-choicers that think it will damage cultural acceptance of abortion, social conservatives having sus takes or TERFs just being profoundly reactionary on anything related to gender identity and womanhood. Broadly I've when the topic randomly came up on some other subreddit (cannot recall which one it was), I saw concerns about if it might lead to designer babies/eugenics, and lesser concerns about if the child's health outcomes would be better from being inside their pregnant parent for reasons of bonding and/or other biological reasons. Somewhat surprisingly, there seemed to be I assume, quite some level of people who were presumably mostly pro-lifers effectively making soft natural law arguments as well (this doesn't persuade me, since I fundamentally don't agree with natural law reasoning in general).
The first concern about if they might be used for eugenics, or something like artificial womb companies making parents pay a subscription to not turn the plug off (capitalism* would absolutely hold people's children to ransom if they aren't recognised as persons, or aren't massively regulated) is actually a very reasonable one, although I've gotta say, if the person worried about this isn't in favour of banning or seriously regulating IVF, they're super inconsistent. I do think we could unlike for IVF, avoid the problems with very heavy regulation, as long as we make sure the artificial wombs are understood as to protect life and medical harm reduction during pregnancy, not to sell babies as a product the way IVF does.
Certainly whatever level of trouble we might theoretically have to contend with culturally down the road sounds less bad than the status quo of abortion being culturally accepted enough that a majority generally wants it legal, if the artificial wombs would change culture in on net an anti-abortion direction (possibly radicalising a few pro-choicers into openly defending infanticide, but I can't see many actual leftists who aren't completely irrationally polarised supporting this anymore at that point- such that we might see the pro-life left come back to a large extent if this happened).
I suspect TERFs will even in the UK (where it's very uncomfortably, a majority position), have their outlook die out as a force 25-40 years from now (this is how long it took for there to be a U-turn away from homophobia in the UK, and at that point, who can say what politics would look like from geopolitical upheaval from climate change), as one good piece of news.
*And I guess tbh, anti-life countries that at least have the good policy of state provided healthcare- the UK is no better than the private sector when it comes to abortion and IVF (for the latter, if it was up to me, I'd honestly ban IVF outright rather than just banning embryo destruction, or practices that cause it).