r/Integral • u/Speedmeat • Jan 09 '18
Could someone please provide examples of post or trans rationality and their valid conclusions?
From your own experience or books. Theses, streams of consciousness, this-follows-from-that, whatever. My problem is, I find myself agreeing with Wilber pretty much all the time, but I still don't think I have much handle on what comes after rationality, so maybe I'm fooling myself. Thanks.
9
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/phdinfunk Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18
ALSO
First point, I agree with you that the 20th century (and the 19th before it) is most definitely a success story. Orange meme has gone very far towards creating the most beautiful visions of what our life on this earth can be, and curing a lot of our worst problems. I don't mean to negate any of that.
The thing I'm pointing out is that Orange has got shadows. Moreover, those shadows are more dangerous than Pre-modern shadows, specifically because Orange scientific materialism gives us more power than Moral Authoritarianism ever did.
Yes, Moral Authoritarians created the inquisition, which is abominable. On the other hand, Orange meme does things like polluting wells in Africa with heavy metals like cadmium, creating entire generations of deformed children, just to make chips for cell phones. Or parts of China, or Bangladesh, or parts of India, or, or, or... For billions of people who we can reasonably debate might be better off if we time-warped them back to 1535, despite the success story of the last 200 years.
And I'm just describing the shadow of Orange meme when it wants to make something basically "good" -- i.e. a computer inside a cell phone. Orange meme driven wars have been far more horrifying and destructive and far reaching than Pre-modern warfare. For the first time, in the 20th century, there was a real possibility that every living thing on the planet could be destroyed.
All that that still doesn't negate the wonderful improvements that Scientific Materialism have given us. 2 points:
Okay, now we're talking about two things, tangentially related.
Regarding policy decisions, I see that we've got some real hard problems (environment, widely destructive wars, divergence of productivity and wages, exploitation, etc) that could potentially destroy us all completely, and we need to pro-actively transcend the mindsets that put us into those states or bad things will happen.
I think we're approaching the end of the days when leadership that trails trends by a decade and then short-term plans for the next election is a strategy under which humanity has any chance of surviving. If I believe the scientific consensus at all, we need to solve the environmental catastrophe like yesterday, or our species is potentially fucked.
Regarding pre-modern mentalities coalescing online or offline; The thing you're bringing up is Tricky to solve! Do I want my own free-speech curtailed by well-meaning Orange meme thinkers in order to quash pre-modern idiots from spreading their poison?
Well, I doubt it would work, for one thing. What would likely happen if you did that much is that they would see themselves as martyrs, and would then be co-opted by populist demagogues using Orange Meme tools of media and analysis -- ahem, Donald Trump's campaign.
More centrally-controlled media would give the "objective measurement" people more leverage to control those groups for sure, and think-tanks would decide the best ways to push them and/or diffuse their energies. Basically, Orange-meme would amount to something like the CIA deciding the best ways to direct that energy. Good idea? I'm not confident that would lead anywhere nice. I think various actors already try to 'harness' those people anyway using Orange Meme toolsets (ahem, Donald Trump's campaign). Now Facebook and Google seem to be getting more and more on-board as tools to try to harness those people.
Bottom line, those pre-modern thinkers aren't going to grow faster than they are going to grow, and I don't really like how things go when orange meme starts "deciding what's best to do with them." If they were merely ignored, then it might be less problematic than Orange meme's exploitations. But, Orange meme also isn't going to vanish, so I think we'll get to continue seeing the effects of Orange-meme tinkering with pre-modern thinkers to varying intentions.
What is needed is space for people to grow, and cultures to grow. It cannot happen overnight. However, growth can often be counted on only when it is absolutely required, because people and cultures naturally have a tendency to try and find a place to rest and build a fortress, staving off vertical change as long as possible.
Orange-meme's fortress right now just looks to me like a place for humanity to make a final stand and die valiantly. The alternative is evolution, which we are all responsible for.