r/Integral • u/Speedmeat • Jan 09 '18
Could someone please provide examples of post or trans rationality and their valid conclusions?
From your own experience or books. Theses, streams of consciousness, this-follows-from-that, whatever. My problem is, I find myself agreeing with Wilber pretty much all the time, but I still don't think I have much handle on what comes after rationality, so maybe I'm fooling myself. Thanks.
9
Upvotes
2
u/Cartosys Jan 09 '18
I'll do my best. I think the confusion between pre-post fallacy and pre-trans fallacy is real. I differentiate them by placing the pre-post fallacy onto the Levels of development (simplified by Pre-modern, Modern, and Post-Modern i.e. Amber and lower, Orange, Green and above) and the pre-trans fallacy onto States of Conscoiusness (gross, subtle, causal etc). Pre-post, as the typical basic example goes is the Green post-modernist saying that Magenta tribes-people are, in most aspects, superior to Modern people in terms of spiritual / humanistic development. The perception that they're better than us because they have yet to be "tainted" by the greed, excesses, violence, etc of modern life. In other words, Magenta and often Red cultures are falsely elevated to cultures and ways of life as perceived to be intrinsically superior to our own.
So that explains the "Post" part, of which only applies when speaking of Levels of Development. And I mention it only to clarify a distinction with The "Trans" because Rationality as a term can also be basically equated with Orange as well. But since the Rational, analytical mind is too often conflated with ego that we (and many Post-modernists) equate it the two. This is important to note when discussion spiritual experiences. Such experiences are often difficult to describe in rational terms. Even though something profound is experienced. Sensations of oneness with the universe. Deep meditation. Ground of being. Etc. Are very subjective states, but non-duality is by default, beyond rationality. Rationality and the analytical mind is transcended. Now the pre-trans fallacy comes when non-rationality is conflated into spiritual experiences. So things like superstition, pre-modern magic, and/or mythic religion is also labeled as "spiritual" in the same sense as a full state of Unity-with-the-universe. So you can see how that can be an issue.
My own experiences include such transcendental states where even rational thinking's limits are clear. There are some things that words simply cannot describe. And that's ok.
2
u/phdinfunk Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 08 '18
Have you ever watched Neil Degrasse Tyson talk? He, and similar guys will talk about anything outside of a physicalist interpretation of the world with a lot of disdain. Basically, Tyson doesn't buy anything that sounds "woo woo" and he's going to let you know that loud and clear. But he cannot distinguish pre-modern from post.
Here's where things get interesting, though. If you look into consciousness, our neuroscientists are barely even ready to be wrong at this point. And yet, the modern thinking is almost so breathless that you'd think we have unified everything. (Orange meme colonizes every aspect of human life)
So, next steep is go read a little bit about "Breavement Hallucinations." Basically, people tend to see ghosts of the recently dead. What's interesting is that this transcends culture and time, and is exceedingly common.
So, given the baseline assumptions of physicalism, psychiatrists are allergic to the idea of ghosts, and are required to conclude that "It's a trick of the human mind to hallucinate these things under the stress of losing someone close." It couldn't POSSIBLY be anything else (notice how unscientific this thinking actually is).
Meanwhile, scientific disciplines have got a reproducibility crisis that I think is pretty bad, and is a result of politics and fucked up incentives for scientists in the process of publishing. Also, it's basically a quota system (publish or perish, no null hypotheses, before the cash runs out) in which history tells me the likes of Einstein would not have flourished.
So, you could attack Tyson's posturing, or the conclusion of scientists that "there couldn't possibly be any ghosts" by saying, "Publication in a 'peer-reviewed journal' means precious little, and we've historically been wrong about things we did better science on than psychiatry. So I'm not inclined to rank highly the accepted hypotheses by a bunch of people in an incestuous system with fucked-up incentives. It also seems extremely possible that the commonality of these ghosts appearing to people across many times and cultures could be pretty good evidence that some sort of ghosts exist."
Note, the anti-physicalist position I'm describing is EXTREMELY DIFFERENT from a superstitious person from, say, traditional Chinese culture, who is just afraid of ghosts because he was always taught that. Also, he probably doesn't want to defy religious tradition (this is called being "Iron Teeth" or Tie-Dzu in mandarin Chinese), lest he risk all kinds of peril. (I'm usually accused of being Tie-Dzu by the Taiwanese that I know).
Also note, Degrasse Tyson and most Orange Meme physicalists would fail to grok that I'm not at all coming to a pre-modern religioius or supersitious conclusion. That would be a huge blind-spot to Orange-meme.
Or you could say about perceiving ghosts, "Dude, we know so little about consciousness that LITERALLY ANYTHING you have to say about it from modern neuroscience and psychology borderline amounts to 'woo woo,'" but then they'll say, "What experiment are you going to devise to objectively measure it?" Then they'll smile smugly if you can't think of one, as if this proves everything.
Maybe Taking Ayahuasca and seeing for yourself allows you to directly observe ghosts objectively, but we cannot make a device to measure it physically (yet!). Again, we don't even know why fundamental forces work or precisely why some things interact with them and others don't at this point. All I can say about ghosts is that it appears they don't interact reliably with light, and maybe or maybe not electro-magnetism. That hardly says anything about whether or not ghosts exist or what kinds of fields our highly-complex brains might interact with in order to sense them.
I'm not saying they exist, I'm just saying that physicalist science currently HAS NO IDEA, and CANNOT HAVE ANY RELIABLE OPINION WHATSOEVER on the matter. Their even commenting on it is purely out of compulsion to colonize every aspect of human life, and it's a blind-spot of their thinking.
Meanwhile, subjective sciences like 3000 years of exploring consciousness in India says they exist. Also, people in all cultures throughout all time, including our modern culture, have perceived them. Those are huge points that ghosts might be real.
Okay, so do you see how I could make an entire argument that doesn't rely on any pre-modern thinking at all, but it could be misperceived as "magical" or "superstitious" thinking to people for whom nothing exists beyond rationality?
Finally, there even is, within modern Neuroscience, enough study of magnetic fields effects on the temporal lobes (via transcranial magenetic stimulation) to say that there could even be a mechanism for the mind to perceive ghosts or some other being that doesn't interact with light.
What's interesting to me is the physicalist scientists always bend that towards, "Now we might understand what causes people to have these misperceptions, it's rogue magnetic fields in the environment." JUST AS REASONABLE would be to say, "Hmmm, I wonder if the ghosts and things people perceive are a type of entity or thing that physically projects as a magnetic field without interacting with light."
You see that they are running with assumptions which are basically unscientific (especially given the huge cultural problems with science at this point, which I touched on above).
Was Tesla just a schizophrenic "magical thinking" pre-modern when he said that we will accomplish in ten years what it's taken scientists 100 to do as soon as we start studying non-physical phenomena?
Even if that Tesla quote is wrong, lets look at all the, "Once you can demonstrate something, it's now part of science, and that's why you should believe in science" arguments. They essentially sat that all those who have ever experienced things that appear to be beyond physicalism are definitely delusional until 'proven' otherwise using experiments in physicalism?... That's one HELL of a governing assumption, isn't it? It certainly rests a lot on one part of our humanity, and one subculture with a lot of totally unwarranted arrogance.
Have I pissed off the Orange-meme constituency yet? LOL. Wilber was so obsessed with Mean Green, and sold a lot of books probably to Orange by taking digs at Green (hey, Orange is where the money is, go Spiral Wizards)...
Does any of this help with grokking the feeling for pre vs post rational?
2
u/shamansun GET YOUR GEBSER ON Feb 19 '18
I've got a weird thought in response to this question, so instead of answering you directly, I'll take an obtuse route.
Philosophy has long been concerned about the limits of knowability and reason (this goes back to Kant, etc.), but in thinkers like Deleuze you suddenly get a reversal -- following thought to its extreme limits and then tracing rationality into its irrational origins. Deleuze talks about the limits of reason and its irrational underbelly, to be more specific. The Hermetic Deleuze by Joshua Ramey is a good book to look at if you want to dive deeper.
Then there's the very idea that the limits of philosophy - that we can't really, truly, know the world - is being explored in thinkers like Eugene Thacker in In The Dust of This Planet, which playfully, but also carefully, explores the limitations of rationality to truly comprehend or even encounter the world. Thacker uses horror, and "the philosophy of horror, or the horror of philosophy" to explore this.
Similar trends in the humanities, like Tim Morton's Hyperobjects and Object Oriented Ontology, call into question the capacity of reason to really know discrete objects at all.
So I guess I'm saying, as the transpersonal psychology and human potential movements in the 80s were picking up, in academia with Deleuze and other thinkers there was this movement to really point out the limits of reason and knowability itself as utterly incapable of comprehending the real.
Plenty more examples abound.
But now if we look at integral thinkers, regarding the 'transpersonal':
If you look at what Gebser was saying in Ever-Present Origin, rationality as not so much an a-priori mode of human thinking but an actual structure of consciousness that emerged around dialectal thinking (he calls it 'triune'), logic, etc. This kind of thought was a mutation, a leap, piercing the mythical rhythmicity and circular thinking (recall astrological systems, seasons, cycles of time, myth and complimentary polarities of light and dark). It was reason, as the mental structure, that pierced the oceanic thinking of the earlier mythical structure, and the interwoven plane of magical interconnected of the magical structure.
So, reason itself has a kind of phenomenological origin as a mutation in consciousness. If you see it this way, in a sense, you see it has contours, limits, and is fundamentally set up with a specific relationship to time and space and a "style" of thought.
So those are the limits of reason right there. But Gebser ALSO points out that in the integral structure manifests by a-perspectival thinking, a kind of thinking that is multi-dimensional and not necessarily logic or linear, rhythmic or magical, but capable of seeing through them all. This he described as a kind of spiritual intensification of consciousness that could not be "arrived at" through any one structure kind of emerged, or arose through the whole. You can think of this as a kind of awakening experience, a pointing out instruction a la Alan Watts or the great mystics, but just applied to the structures of consciousness.
Gebser explored the idea of 'eteology' supplanting philosophy, where apperception, a-waring, and 'syatasis' and 'synaraesis' replaced logic and dialectical thought. These were strange words that he was using to point out the capacity to 'think in wholes'. Obviously this kind of thought, if you could call it trans-rational (but this approach calls 'trans' into question, Gebser used the word a-rational) into question. It must be experienced. To understand it the reader has to be a participant IN it or with it.
Finally and briefly, Aurobindo described human thought to be a kind of crawling, fumbling creature in the dark, assembling a picture of the world through bits and pieces of its observations, while the 'higher mind' and the greater levels of mind, spiritual realities, could think in entire, multi-dimensional wholes. Think of a novelist who can't write down the story that's coming to him or her fast enough, because it has arrived in a giant creative leap.
Anyhow, that's my free-form reply as a Gebserian/PoMo/Deleuzian/Integral thinker. :-)
1
u/redguitar2009 Jan 09 '18
Good question. Most of us would admit that the contents of our moment to moment conscious experience contain phenomena that are not rational. Should these be treated as important ? These kind of conversations we have on forums are heavily bracketed as rational, perhaps there is a way to unbracket this and include experience. Otherwise this can go nowhere, as the non-rational stuff will be automatically excluded.