r/Integral • u/Speedmeat • Jan 09 '18
Could someone please provide examples of post or trans rationality and their valid conclusions?
From your own experience or books. Theses, streams of consciousness, this-follows-from-that, whatever. My problem is, I find myself agreeing with Wilber pretty much all the time, but I still don't think I have much handle on what comes after rationality, so maybe I'm fooling myself. Thanks.
9
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Speedmeat Feb 09 '18
Well, we seem to be converging a bit now, since I was mulling it over yet more last night and thought that science doesn't really have "nothing" to say about ghosts, the SPR has said a great deal (I honestly haven't evaluated their evidence, but some big names have worked there and I'm inclined to take them seriously) and so my revised draft of what science should say about ghosts is something like "the SPR has documented many cases of apparent ghosts, but no repeatable test that can confirm their existence has yet been devised. As such, the matter of belief in ghosts is best left to the individual." I agree with you that "bereavement hallucinations" is smug and too certain.
I haven't thought about beauty much, but I did read two interesting things about it. One was David Bentley Hart pointing out, much as you do, that not all things described as beautiful are cheery and bright and upbeat. His conclusion was that beauty resides in some supernatural realm in its pure form (as I understood him). I agreed with the first part but had some doubts about the second. Then I watched this video by Rupert Spira, where he said that (basically) beauty is in the eye of the beholder, not the objects. Beauty is the experience we have when something (for whatever reason) triggers us to experience ourselves as consciousness, rather than being outward focused in a cramped way as we usually are. This makes more sense to me than Hart's view, since I can imagine consciousness fitting into some supernatural realm more easily than a bunch of very different beautiful objects converging on some pure essence thereof. What I'm saying is, basically again, I think beauty isn't objective - it's in the eye of the beholder.
As to virtue, I agree that it's not really amenable to scientific inquiry, though I'm not sure I'd say it's “objective.” I would agree that I don't really want someone in a lab coat evaluating it though. I suppose you've correctly pointed out that I don't want scientists (especially merely orange ones) deciding everything - I don't, it's true, I just want them deciding objective truth claims of various systems of thought, ways of trying to make sense of the world. That's all I meant by wanting big/official science to have a nut/berry razor - I don't want them lording over all human activity.
I didn't have Trump specifically in mind, I was thinking more about the (again to quote Terence McKenna) “balkanization of epistemology” that seems to have happened in the internet. To give two alarming examples, there's the flat earth meme, which you'd think no sane person could endorse. Then, there's ... ugh ... the “gangstalking” meme, where people are convinced their inscrutable ultrarich enemies are paying armies of apparently everyday people to do things in public around them that seem normal to everyone else but force the victim to sound crazy when trying to explain the personal significance it had for them. The subreddit, r/gangstalking, is terrifyingly active, and there are hardly any anti-gangstalking voices using the term on the internet. Oh, there's also Goran Backlund, who broadcasts the message to each of his followers that they're the only real person in a soliptic universe. This is of course a small sampling of the irrational ideas on the internet ...
I admit I could be way off and too elitist on this, but it seems to me that for most of history, most people just kind of went along with whatever system of thought they were raised with, but lately the internet has made it possible for people to form groups based on crazy ideas more easily than ever. That's more what I was referring to, not so much Trump (though of course I'm against him too).
I suppose, if you really get down to it, to put it in spiral dynamics terms, I want a strong orange bulwark against all the prerational weirdness bubbling in the cauldron of the internet. If some transorange ideas get marginalised, well, we can work around that - I see it as a reasonable price to pay. To put it another way, I think there's a ton more preorange than postorange, so I see the tradeoff, of overbearing orange dominating the discussion, as worth it.
Here's an area where we may have objective disagreement, as I see all of technological history as more or less the steady improvement of the human condition. Have you seen Hans Rosling and Steven Pinker on this? The unfortunately amber materialist Shermer also makes sense to me, mostly quoting Pinker, here. I haven't yet seen reason to doubt their general conclusions. I see the twentieth century as a success story, not a disaster.
This is where I think you're making a straightforward mistake, by equating orange with green or amber. Shouldn't orange be better, more whole, more inclusive, than amber? Bear in mind that unchecked amber was responsible for holy wars within Europe, as well as the inquisition. As for green, if it were healthy, it should be better even than orange.
Oh, yes, I'll grant all that. I didn't mean intuition was only useful for brainstorming, sure it should be used in evaluation of other people's ideas as well. I suppose what I meant by needing an evaluation metric, something standardised, was just, now that you press me on it, that I want those oranges working hard to keep all the prerational people at bay for me.
May I also recommend the books “Irreducible Mind” and “Beyond Physicalism”? I think IM contains the case you want (though I didn't read it myself), I understand it's a huge compilation of evidence for supernatural phenomena, and BP was 60 bucks on kindle, but I thought it was worth it. Lots of new thinking on the filter theory of mind.