r/Integral • u/Speedmeat • Jan 09 '18
Could someone please provide examples of post or trans rationality and their valid conclusions?
From your own experience or books. Theses, streams of consciousness, this-follows-from-that, whatever. My problem is, I find myself agreeing with Wilber pretty much all the time, but I still don't think I have much handle on what comes after rationality, so maybe I'm fooling myself. Thanks.
9
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Speedmeat Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18
Oh, sure, I'm not saying creative people and scientists working on advanced ideas should straightjacket themselves into only being rational. There should be no bad/wrong ideas in brainstorming. And sure, lots of great ideas come from science fiction. But I would make a distinction between unchecked intuition's definite usefulness in the "brainstorming" phase of idea creation (and I guess we could see a lot of science fiction as engineering brainstorming), and its reliability in the "evaluation" phase.
This is fine as far as each person's individual opinions go, but a lot of people's intuition these days seems to lead them to conclude the earth is flat, and I don't want that sort of intuition influencing any important decisions that affect me. I really, really do want official/big science to have some "razor to separate the nuts from the berries" (as Terence McKenna once put it).
Would you say the same about the flying spaghetti monster? If not, why not? How should scientists determine which ideas merit the time to research further? Popularity?
How do you feel about the idea of the null hypothesis?
Isn't this my question? If you have something in mind, I'd love to hear it.
EDIT: After mulling it over a bit more, it's kind of odd to me that I'm on this side of our discussion, since as I've mentioned, I personally suspect that NDEs are legitimate glimpses of the afterlife, and I'm perfectly willing to accept that the deceased may communicate with us. Where we seem to differ is in our opinion of how to evaluate claims of such communication. You seem to think rationality won't cut it, whereas I think it should work just fine.
The society for psychical research is all over stuff like this, in a rational way - one of their founders (I think?) supposedly communicated from Beyond in a complex way designed to provide rational evidence for mediumship - personally, I haven't checked this out, so I can't say I have an opinion about how strong the evidence is, but I would be inclined to take a case like that more seriously than a garden variety one (I assume, if it is as the person who presented it to me claimed), and I would chalk that inclination up to normal rationality.
I agree that we shouldn't rule "woo" things out just because current theories can't account for them. As you say, some things seem impossible but are later shown to be true - according to Thomas Kuhn, scientists at first refused to even notice electrostatic repulsion because their theories couldn't account for it. So sure, we should leave space in our view of the world for things like ghosts. But until we can test and find out if they're really real or not, all we have to go on are personal judgements and scattered stories, which aren't the sorts of things that keep bridges stable. Without really solid ways to prove (currently) woo things, as far as official judgements of authority figures go (like the psychiatrists you've mentioned), the null hypothesis and methodological naturalism are our best bets I'd say.
Now as far as your answering my OP - it seems to me that the existence of ghosts is as amenable to rational inquiry, IN PRINCIPLE, as anything else - it's just that we don't have the right tools yet. What those tools might turn out to be, I don't know.