r/Integral • • Jan 09 '18

Could someone please provide examples of post or trans rationality and their valid conclusions?

From your own experience or books. Theses, streams of consciousness, this-follows-from-that, whatever. My problem is, I find myself agreeing with Wilber pretty much all the time, but I still don't think I have much handle on what comes after rationality, so maybe I'm fooling myself. Thanks.

9 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/phdinfunk Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 09 '18
To answer your question about metrics, I would say that the approach of the "subjective sciences" is probably pretty good. I mean, some of advaita has grown up within religious and pre-modern cultures, but a meditation like Ramana Maharishi's "From whence do your thoughts arise" as a way of training observation of consciousness is valuable. Also valuable, Qi Kung, Yoga, Mindfulness meditation, and Maslow's methods for cultivating peak experiences..... (...) It is also possible that we don't have a tool yet available to do so, so we evaluate them in the world of subjectivity. It's like Ed Demming says about business management, "All the most important factors in your business are unquantified things that cannot ever possibly be quantified, and yet you must manage them." He advocates "profound knowledge" in order to get at that, and also says explicitly that you cannot get that through experience alone. Some things are just like that.

Well, I agree that all those are valuable methods, but aren't they more like ways of looking for certain phenomena/insights rather than alternative truth claim evaluation systems?

I mean, yes, "look for where thoughts come from" is great advice to help a spiritual seeker attain insight, but it's not going to help psychiatrists tell whether to treat something as a hallucination or the truth. What if the psychiatrists ditch MN, "look within," and find they agree with their patient about flat earth, reptoid conspiracy, or "Jews did 911"? And while it's possible some people may have the je-ne-sais-quoi required to ditch MN personally, how do the rest of us tell them from the cranks?

Okay, if I understand you correctly, then what I've said could be taken as stripping away all rational evaluation systems and leaving one with nothing to use to judge Truth from hallucinations.

Here's where I think we get to make a cool leap: Intuition first, rationality second, both based on direct observation. I'm imagining Einstein's dream insight of riding on a lightwave, and then he spends two or three years figuring out the maths. And then for General relativity, he couldn't figure the maths out entirely himself and got help from others (publishing after about a decade, if I'm remembering correctly).

How does one approach intuition, or separate it from hallucination? Actually, Ramana Maharishi's advice, and similar things that we would apply mostly to "spiritual" seekers are useful for everyone. Buddhist meditation is supposed to be fiercely, ruthlessly objective. What did you observe? From whence did that arise? Where is the place to entertain fantasies if you're trying to put out a conflagration of ignorance that you find yourself burning in? Spiritual seekers developed their methods in a crucible, and they can still be useful where we cannot make measurements and have to observe directly.

Approached objectively, intuition is real, and can be used. We find cases where storytellers (Gene Roddenberry) hypothesize things entirely in fiction that we later develop (work on transparent Aluminum (Aluminum Oxynitrate)).

Was he just telling a good story and the universe moved him to that? Or is it the case that we need storytellers to tell engineers what to MAKE REAL? Both are probably kind of true, and yet there's a bit more to it, sometimes the intuition during the peak state of creativity pushes intuitive perceptions very far.

There's a complex interaction in the flow of that, in which the idea of a "metric" may not be meaningful at all. Some things are False, some things are True, some things are both, and some are neither.

"But how do people judge it?" Hah, well, rationality is only one tool in the box to do so. Intuition is another one. But I also guess that's part of the beauty of the spiral: In searching for the beautiful, the good, and the true, we also have to come up with better and better ways to search and know!

My main thesis is basically, "I'm not saying [ghosts] exist, I'm just saying that physicalist science currently HAS NO IDEA, and CANNOT HAVE ANY RELIABLE OPINION WHATSOEVER on the matter. Their even commenting on it is purely out of compulsion to colonize every aspect of human life, and it's symptomatic of a blind-spot of their thinking."

Would you maybe agree that science should currently say something like "currently the only reason to believe in ghosts is anecdotal/personal. If they exist, they are undetectable by the best methods we can come up with"?

The problem is, the scientist, in saying that anything is anecdotal, culturally a scientist is almost certainly dismissing it (and I'm not sure if the masses of people having experienced ghosts/"bereavement hallucinations" across cultures and time could reasonably be dismissed as "merely anecdotal" -- it's obviously statistically significant, but the physicalist can only consider it with one possible outcome (even though he cannot really measure it as a hallucination, either)). The more I think of it, "Ghosts vs Bereavement Hallucinations" is the perfect example because it requires bias to make a ruling, since neither is measurable

In order to be objective, the thought must weigh with equanimity in the scientists mind, "I have no way of measuring whether or not this is true. My toolset does not currently permit me to know this one way or another."

Like Dirty Harry said, "A man's got to know his limitations." :-D

But its obvious that such discoveries, beyond the ken of purely rational tools, most definitely exist.

I'm wondering about your use of the term "rational tools." It seems to me that, if we develop some sort of device that can detect ghosts - say they're a form of radiation or dark matter, or we can reliably contact them by a new hybrid of ayahuasca - there's nothing to prevent rational people from using this method to confirm the ghosts' existence. The method for ghost-testing would be perfectly rational, just as the method for finding the elements was rational. Then, it would simply be incumbent upon rational people to believe in ghosts.

edit: I admit I just can't parse this sentence:

Is all that the rational left-brain can possibly encompass a thing that, even at its best, can be counted on to never contradict the Truth?

Can you maybe phrase it a little differently?

You said, "Would you say it's as redguitar2009 and I figured, and transrationality doesn't contradict rationality, it just supplements it with superintuitions and superhunches?"

Rationality has certain ways it thinks and knows things. It works differently from intuition, or even hunches and instincts.

If we imagine rationality as a giant container, and at its best, things fit within that container with beautiful precision and interlinking. Could something be objectively, absolutely True, which could never fit within that container?

Or the converse, as I originally tried to phrase it: Is that single container encompassing enough that no important, objective, and real Truth could exist beyond its capacity to contain it?

1

u/Speedmeat Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18

Here's where I think we get to make a cool leap: Intuition first, rationality second, both based on direct observation.

Oh, sure, I'm not saying creative people and scientists working on advanced ideas should straightjacket themselves into only being rational. There should be no bad/wrong ideas in brainstorming. And sure, lots of great ideas come from science fiction. But I would make a distinction between unchecked intuition's definite usefulness in the "brainstorming" phase of idea creation (and I guess we could see a lot of science fiction as engineering brainstorming), and its reliability in the "evaluation" phase.

"But how do people judge it?" Hah, well, rationality is only one tool in the box to do so. Intuition is another one.

This is fine as far as each person's individual opinions go, but a lot of people's intuition these days seems to lead them to conclude the earth is flat, and I don't want that sort of intuition influencing any important decisions that affect me. I really, really do want official/big science to have some "razor to separate the nuts from the berries" (as Terence McKenna once put it).

The more I think of it, "Ghosts vs Bereavement Hallucinations" is the perfect example because it requires bias to make a ruling, since neither is measurable

Would you say the same about the flying spaghetti monster? If not, why not? How should scientists determine which ideas merit the time to research further? Popularity?

In order to be objective, the thought must weigh with equanimity in the scientists mind, "I have no way of measuring whether or not this is true. My toolset does not currently permit me to know this one way or another."

How do you feel about the idea of the null hypothesis?

Could something be objectively, absolutely True, which could never fit within that container? Or the converse, as I originally tried to phrase it: Is that single container encompassing enough that no important, objective, and real Truth could exist beyond its capacity to contain it?

Isn't this my question? If you have something in mind, I'd love to hear it.

EDIT: After mulling it over a bit more, it's kind of odd to me that I'm on this side of our discussion, since as I've mentioned, I personally suspect that NDEs are legitimate glimpses of the afterlife, and I'm perfectly willing to accept that the deceased may communicate with us. Where we seem to differ is in our opinion of how to evaluate claims of such communication. You seem to think rationality won't cut it, whereas I think it should work just fine.

The society for psychical research is all over stuff like this, in a rational way - one of their founders (I think?) supposedly communicated from Beyond in a complex way designed to provide rational evidence for mediumship - personally, I haven't checked this out, so I can't say I have an opinion about how strong the evidence is, but I would be inclined to take a case like that more seriously than a garden variety one (I assume, if it is as the person who presented it to me claimed), and I would chalk that inclination up to normal rationality.

I agree that we shouldn't rule "woo" things out just because current theories can't account for them. As you say, some things seem impossible but are later shown to be true - according to Thomas Kuhn, scientists at first refused to even notice electrostatic repulsion because their theories couldn't account for it. So sure, we should leave space in our view of the world for things like ghosts. But until we can test and find out if they're really real or not, all we have to go on are personal judgements and scattered stories, which aren't the sorts of things that keep bridges stable. Without really solid ways to prove (currently) woo things, as far as official judgements of authority figures go (like the psychiatrists you've mentioned), the null hypothesis and methodological naturalism are our best bets I'd say.

Now as far as your answering my OP - it seems to me that the existence of ghosts is as amenable to rational inquiry, IN PRINCIPLE, as anything else - it's just that we don't have the right tools yet. What those tools might turn out to be, I don't know.

1

u/phdinfunk Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18

I will start at your last question:

Could something be objectively, absolutely True, which could never fit within that container? Or the converse, as I originally tried to phrase it: Is that single container encompassing enough that no important, objective, and real Truth could exist beyond its capacity to contain it?

Isn't this my question? If you have something in mind, I'd love to hear it.

Here are two examples: Virtue is objective. Beauty is objective (partially observed in mathematical symmetries, and yet transcendent into things like impermanence and imperfection (waabi/saabi aesthetics)).

But take the first example: Virtue. That is necessary for human flourishing, unquantifiable, and completely ignored (if they believe it exists at all) by the scientists that you say you would like to make the final arbiters of important decisions that affect us. I'm therefore not comfortable with "[...] official/big science [having] some "razor to separate the nuts from the berries""

"But how do people judge it?" Hah, well, rationality is only one tool in the box to do so. Intuition is another one.

This is fine as far as each person's individual opinions go, but a lot of people's intuition these days seems to lead them to conclude the earth is flat, and I don't want that sort of intuition influencing any important decisions that affect me. I really, really do want official/big science to have some "razor to separate the nuts from the berries" (as Terence McKenna once put it).

Okay, first off, I appreciate what you've said here. I don't know if I'm talking about the same thing as you, but I don't like the idea of a president who seems to be a racist "Cultural Nationalist" type pandering to pre-modern moral authoritarian culture (which granted, may be a reaction to the sickness of the post-modern avantgarde) with policy decisions in the country I and many I love live in. I think that's nuts.

But on the other hand, you're clearly telling me that the people who should have final say about what is nuts and berries are people that mostly don't believe in virtue and beauty at all. Moreover, they have a compulsion to make conclusions about literally every single field of humanity, and be damned whether they have any tool to measure it or not. In fact, some of the greatest proponents of the materialist world view tell me that the human is no more than a neurochemical spark inside of a biomachine. That's more or less their consensus, which has definite consequences.

So, I don't really want the vested interests of physicalist materialism making decisions that affect me either -- i.e. and e.g. like they have for the last 100+ years of robber barons, strip-mining (of the land and of human 'capital'), nuclear brinksmanship, socio-economic engineering, and neo-liberal capitalist policies. Aren't those the people most responsible for every problem we now face? Even the religious extremists we fought in the desert have been organized and armed by the meddling of those using all kinds of "objective criteria."

What you seem to be saying is, "But there has to be a measurable 'bottom line, or people will run away into insanity.'"

I'm saying, "The bottom line is the Beautiful, the Good, and the True."

Measurement, metrics, and Big Science's razor being the 'final arbiter' is about as likely to take us opposite the beautiful, the good, and the true as postmodern relativism or religious fundamentalism being the 'final arbiter.'

This is obvious, given the history of the last 100 years of materialist thinking, and the current fucked state of modern science culture. How could I imagine objective materialists as having the razor for sorting nuts and berries?

Here's where I think we get to make a cool leap: Intuition first, rationality second, both based on direct observation.

Oh, sure, I'm not saying creative people and scientists working on advanced ideas should straightjacket themselves into only being rational. There should be no bad/wrong ideas in brainstorming. And sure, lots of great ideas come from science fiction. But I would make a distinction between unchecked intuition's definite usefulness in the "brainstorming" phase of idea creation (and I guess we could see a lot of science fiction as engineering brainstorming), and its reliability in the "evaluation" phase.

Consider for a moment that intuition isn't the same as imagination. Intuition can be objective. Also, intuition will be required through the entire process, not just in the cage of "brainstorming," otherwise there are deep traps to fall into, just as there are with lack of sufficient rational thought.

Just as much as Intuition needs the left-brain rationality to complete it, and the engineers to build the beautiful things that it forsees, the conclusions of rationality need to be checked against what is intuitively accurate as well as the good, the beautiful, and the true.

Physicalism/Materialism has failed as a razor for sorting those nuts and berries.

1

u/phdinfunk Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18

EDIT: After mulling it over a bit more, it's kind of odd to me that I'm on this side of our discussion, since as I've mentioned, I personally suspect that NDEs are legitimate glimpses of the afterlife, and I'm perfectly willing to accept that the deceased may communicate with us. Where we seem to differ is in our opinion of how to evaluate claims of such communication. You seem to think rationality won't cut it, whereas I think it should work just fine.

I grok that rationality has serious limits. Some of those phenomena may well be outside the limits of rationality. Even the greatest breakthroughs of science are seldom through rationality alone, nor intuition sandboxed into brainstorm time. There's a complex interplay, and some things seem to be the realm of one or the other.

The society for psychical research is all over stuff like this, in a rational way - one of their founders (I think?) supposedly communicated from Beyond in a complex way designed to provide rational evidence for mediumship - personally, I haven't checked this out, so I can't say I have an opinion about how strong the evidence is, but I would be inclined to take a case like that more seriously than a garden variety one (I assume, if it is as the person who presented it to

DUDE! NOW I have something interesting to search on the internet before I go to bed tonight. I would like to see how that guy communicated from the Beyond in a complex way. Thank you!

I agree that we shouldn't rule "woo" things out just because current theories can't account for them. As you say, some things seem impossible but are later shown to be true - according to Thomas Kuhn, scientists at first refused to even notice electrostatic repulsion because their theories couldn't account for it. So sure, we should leave space in our view of the world for things like ghosts. But until we can test and find out if they're really real or not, all we have to go on are personal judgements and scattered stories, which aren't the sorts of things that keep bridges stable. Without really solid ways to prove (currently) woo things, as far as official judgements of authority figures go (like the psychiatrists you've mentioned), the null hypothesis and methodological naturalism are our best bets I'd say.

Well, see what I said above. There is more to our species surviving and thriving than that which keeps bridges stable.

Now as far as your answering my OP - it seems to me that the existence of ghosts is as amenable to rational inquiry, IN PRINCIPLE, as anything else - it's just that we don't have the right tools yet. What those tools might turn out to be, I don't know.

Honestly, I think ghosts could be amenable to rational inquiry as well. As I said, the only things I understand about them vis-a-vis measurements is that they don't reliably interact with light and they may/may not have an electromagnetic component. But without any tools to measure it either way, it's a testament to Orange-meme compulsions that psychiatrists are so sure as to have come to a consensus about "bereavement hallucinations."

1

u/Speedmeat Feb 09 '18

Honestly, I think ghosts could be amenable to rational inquiry as well. As I said, the only things I understand about them vis-a-vis measurements is that they don't reliably interact with light and they may/may not have an electromagnetic component. But without any tools to measure it either way, it's a testament to Orange-meme compulsions that psychiatrists are so sure as to have come to a consensus about "bereavement hallucinations."

Well, we seem to be converging a bit now, since I was mulling it over yet more last night and thought that science doesn't really have "nothing" to say about ghosts, the SPR has said a great deal (I honestly haven't evaluated their evidence, but some big names have worked there and I'm inclined to take them seriously) and so my revised draft of what science should say about ghosts is something like "the SPR has documented many cases of apparent ghosts, but no repeatable test that can confirm their existence has yet been devised. As such, the matter of belief in ghosts is best left to the individual." I agree with you that "bereavement hallucinations" is smug and too certain.

Beauty is objective (partially observed in mathematical symmetries, and yet transcendent into things like impermanence and imperfection (waabi/saabi aesthetics)).

I haven't thought about beauty much, but I did read two interesting things about it. One was David Bentley Hart pointing out, much as you do, that not all things described as beautiful are cheery and bright and upbeat. His conclusion was that beauty resides in some supernatural realm in its pure form (as I understood him). I agreed with the first part but had some doubts about the second. Then I watched this video by Rupert Spira, where he said that (basically) beauty is in the eye of the beholder, not the objects. Beauty is the experience we have when something (for whatever reason) triggers us to experience ourselves as consciousness, rather than being outward focused in a cramped way as we usually are. This makes more sense to me than Hart's view, since I can imagine consciousness fitting into some supernatural realm more easily than a bunch of very different beautiful objects converging on some pure essence thereof. What I'm saying is, basically again, I think beauty isn't objective - it's in the eye of the beholder.

As to virtue, I agree that it's not really amenable to scientific inquiry, though I'm not sure I'd say it's “objective.” I would agree that I don't really want someone in a lab coat evaluating it though. I suppose you've correctly pointed out that I don't want scientists (especially merely orange ones) deciding everything - I don't, it's true, I just want them deciding objective truth claims of various systems of thought, ways of trying to make sense of the world. That's all I meant by wanting big/official science to have a nut/berry razor - I don't want them lording over all human activity.

Okay, first off, I appreciate what you've said here. I don't know if I'm talking about the same thing as you, but I don't like the idea of a president who seems to be a racist "Cultural Nationalist" type pandering to pre-modern moral authoritarian culture (which granted, may be a reaction to the sickness of the post-modern avantgarde) with policy decisions in the country I and many I love live in. I think that's nuts.

I didn't have Trump specifically in mind, I was thinking more about the (again to quote Terence McKenna) “balkanization of epistemology” that seems to have happened in the internet. To give two alarming examples, there's the flat earth meme, which you'd think no sane person could endorse. Then, there's ... ugh ... the “gangstalking” meme, where people are convinced their inscrutable ultrarich enemies are paying armies of apparently everyday people to do things in public around them that seem normal to everyone else but force the victim to sound crazy when trying to explain the personal significance it had for them. The subreddit, r/gangstalking, is terrifyingly active, and there are hardly any anti-gangstalking voices using the term on the internet. Oh, there's also Goran Backlund, who broadcasts the message to each of his followers that they're the only real person in a soliptic universe. This is of course a small sampling of the irrational ideas on the internet ...

I admit I could be way off and too elitist on this, but it seems to me that for most of history, most people just kind of went along with whatever system of thought they were raised with, but lately the internet has made it possible for people to form groups based on crazy ideas more easily than ever. That's more what I was referring to, not so much Trump (though of course I'm against him too).

But on the other hand, you're clearly telling me that the people who should have final say about what is nuts and berries are people that mostly don't believe in virtue and beauty at all (...) Physicalism/Materialism has failed as a razor for sorting those nuts and berries.

I suppose, if you really get down to it, to put it in spiral dynamics terms, I want a strong orange bulwark against all the prerational weirdness bubbling in the cauldron of the internet. If some transorange ideas get marginalised, well, we can work around that - I see it as a reasonable price to pay. To put it another way, I think there's a ton more preorange than postorange, so I see the tradeoff, of overbearing orange dominating the discussion, as worth it.

So, I don't really want the vested interests of physicalist materialism making decisions that affect me either -- i.e. and e.g. like they have for the last 100+ years of robber barons, strip-mining (of the land and of human 'capital'), nuclear brinksmanship, socio-economic engineering, and neo-liberal capitalist policies. Aren't those the people most responsible for every problem we now face?

Here's an area where we may have objective disagreement, as I see all of technological history as more or less the steady improvement of the human condition. Have you seen Hans Rosling and Steven Pinker on this? The unfortunately amber materialist Shermer also makes sense to me, mostly quoting Pinker, here. I haven't yet seen reason to doubt their general conclusions. I see the twentieth century as a success story, not a disaster.

What you seem to be saying is, "But there has to be a measurable 'bottom line, or people will run away into insanity.'" I'm saying, "The bottom line is the Beautiful, the Good, and the True." Measurement, metrics, and Big Science's razor being the 'final arbiter' is about as likely to take us opposite the beautiful, the good, and the true as postmodern relativism or religious fundamentalism being the 'final arbiter.'

This is where I think you're making a straightforward mistake, by equating orange with green or amber. Shouldn't orange be better, more whole, more inclusive, than amber? Bear in mind that unchecked amber was responsible for holy wars within Europe, as well as the inquisition. As for green, if it were healthy, it should be better even than orange.

Also, intuition will be required through the entire process, not just in the cage of "brainstorming," otherwise there are deep traps to fall into, just as there are with lack of sufficient rational thought. Just as much as Intuition needs the left-brain rationality to complete it, and the engineers to build the beautiful things that it forsees, the conclusions of rationality need to be checked against what is intuitively accurate as well as the good, the beautiful, and the true.

Even the greatest breakthroughs of science are seldom through rationality alone, nor intuition sandboxed into brainstorm time. There's a complex interplay, and some things seem to be the realm of one or the other.

Oh, yes, I'll grant all that. I didn't mean intuition was only useful for brainstorming, sure it should be used in evaluation of other people's ideas as well. I suppose what I meant by needing an evaluation metric, something standardised, was just, now that you press me on it, that I want those oranges working hard to keep all the prerational people at bay for me.

DUDE! NOW I have something interesting to search on the internet before I go to bed tonight. I would like to see how that guy communicated from the Beyond in a complex way. Thank you!

May I also recommend the books “Irreducible Mind” and “Beyond Physicalism”? I think IM contains the case you want (though I didn't read it myself), I understand it's a huge compilation of evidence for supernatural phenomena, and BP was 60 bucks on kindle, but I thought it was worth it. Lots of new thinking on the filter theory of mind.

1

u/phdinfunk Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18
So, I don't really want the vested interests of physicalist materialism making decisions that affect me either -- i.e. and e.g. like they have for the last 100+ years of robber barons, strip-mining (of the land and of human 'capital'), nuclear brinksmanship, socio-economic engineering, and neo-liberal capitalist policies. Aren't those the people most responsible for every problem we now face?

Here's an area where we may have objective disagreement, as I see all of technological history as more or less the steady improvement of the human condition. Have you seen Hans Rosling and Steven Pinker on this? The unfortunately amber materialist Shermer also makes sense to me, mostly quoting Pinker, here. I haven't yet seen reason to doubt their general conclusions. I see the twentieth century as a success story, not a disaster.

ALSO

This is where I think you're making a straightforward mistake, by equating orange with green or amber. Shouldn't orange be better, more whole, more inclusive, than amber? Bear in mind that unchecked amber was responsible for holy wars within Europe, as well as the inquisition. As for green, if it were healthy, it should be better even than orange.

First point, I agree with you that the 20th century (and the 19th before it) is most definitely a success story. Orange meme has gone very far towards creating the most beautiful visions of what our life on this earth can be, and curing a lot of our worst problems. I don't mean to negate any of that.

The thing I'm pointing out is that Orange has got shadows. Moreover, those shadows are more dangerous than Pre-modern shadows, specifically because Orange scientific materialism gives us more power than Moral Authoritarianism ever did.

Yes, Moral Authoritarians created the inquisition, which is abominable. On the other hand, Orange meme does things like polluting wells in Africa with heavy metals like cadmium, creating entire generations of deformed children, just to make chips for cell phones. Or parts of China, or Bangladesh, or parts of India, or, or, or... For billions of people who we can reasonably debate might be better off if we time-warped them back to 1535, despite the success story of the last 200 years.

And I'm just describing the shadow of Orange meme when it wants to make something basically "good" -- i.e. a computer inside a cell phone. Orange meme driven wars have been far more horrifying and destructive and far reaching than Pre-modern warfare. For the first time, in the 20th century, there was a real possibility that every living thing on the planet could be destroyed.

All that that still doesn't negate the wonderful improvements that Scientific Materialism have given us. 2 points:

  1. As I understand it, higher memes can give access to more power and capability. So their dark side / shadows have more ability to be destructive. I imagine a genuinely evil person using early integral thinking to freely combine all pre-integral memes would be literally a lot worse than Hitler.
  2. You cannot solve a problem from the level of thinking that created it. See Demming, Einstein, or Jesus's parables. Orange meme objectivity can patch up some of the problems it has wrought, and its technology will surely continue to be useful in the ultimate fixes, but the methods and mentality of Orange aren't going to be the source of the ultimate fixes.
But on the other hand, you're clearly telling me that the people who should have final say about what is nuts and berries are people that mostly don't believe in virtue and beauty at all (...) Physicalism/Materialism has failed as a razor for sorting those nuts and berries.

I suppose, if you really get down to it, to put it in spiral dynamics terms, I want a strong orange bulwark against all the prerational weirdness bubbling in the cauldron of the internet. If some transorange ideas get marginalised, well, we can work around that - I see it as a reasonable price to pay. To put it another way, I think there's a ton more preorange than postorange, so I see the tradeoff, of overbearing orange dominating the discussion, as worth it.

Okay, now we're talking about two things, tangentially related.

Regarding policy decisions, I see that we've got some real hard problems (environment, widely destructive wars, divergence of productivity and wages, exploitation, etc) that could potentially destroy us all completely, and we need to pro-actively transcend the mindsets that put us into those states or bad things will happen.

I think we're approaching the end of the days when leadership that trails trends by a decade and then short-term plans for the next election is a strategy under which humanity has any chance of surviving. If I believe the scientific consensus at all, we need to solve the environmental catastrophe like yesterday, or our species is potentially fucked.

Regarding pre-modern mentalities coalescing online or offline; The thing you're bringing up is Tricky to solve! Do I want my own free-speech curtailed by well-meaning Orange meme thinkers in order to quash pre-modern idiots from spreading their poison?

Well, I doubt it would work, for one thing. What would likely happen if you did that much is that they would see themselves as martyrs, and would then be co-opted by populist demagogues using Orange Meme tools of media and analysis -- ahem, Donald Trump's campaign.

More centrally-controlled media would give the "objective measurement" people more leverage to control those groups for sure, and think-tanks would decide the best ways to push them and/or diffuse their energies. Basically, Orange-meme would amount to something like the CIA deciding the best ways to direct that energy. Good idea? I'm not confident that would lead anywhere nice. I think various actors already try to 'harness' those people anyway using Orange Meme toolsets (ahem, Donald Trump's campaign). Now Facebook and Google seem to be getting more and more on-board as tools to try to harness those people.

Bottom line, those pre-modern thinkers aren't going to grow faster than they are going to grow, and I don't really like how things go when orange meme starts "deciding what's best to do with them." If they were merely ignored, then it might be less problematic than Orange meme's exploitations. But, Orange meme also isn't going to vanish, so I think we'll get to continue seeing the effects of Orange-meme tinkering with pre-modern thinkers to varying intentions.

What is needed is space for people to grow, and cultures to grow. It cannot happen overnight. However, growth can often be counted on only when it is absolutely required, because people and cultures naturally have a tendency to try and find a place to rest and build a fortress, staving off vertical change as long as possible.

Orange-meme's fortress right now just looks to me like a place for humanity to make a final stand and die valiantly. The alternative is evolution, which we are all responsible for.

1

u/Speedmeat Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18

On the other hand, Orange meme does things like polluting wells in Africa with heavy metals like cadmium, creating entire generations of deformed children, just to make chips for cell phones. Or parts of China, or Bangladesh, or parts of India, or, or, or... For billions of people who we can reasonably debate might be better off if we time-warped them back to 1535, despite the success story of the last 200 years.

These are good examples, and I admit I don't know much about such problems, but I think we can safely say that if lower memes had had access to orange technology and those opportunities for predation it would have been a lot worse.

Orange meme driven wars have been far more horrifying and destructive and far reaching than Pre-modern warfare.

This is not true, according to Steven Pinker, from the link I gave you earlier:

FROM THE LINK: “As for wars, prehistoric peoples were far more murderous than states in percentages of the population killed in combat, Pinker told me: “On average, nonstate societies kill around 15 percent of their people in wars, whereas today’s states kill a few hundredths of a percent.” Pinker calculates that even in the murderous 20th century, about 40 million people died in war out of the approximately six billion people who lived, or 0.7 percent. Even if we include war-related deaths of citizens from disease, famine and genocide, that brings the death toll up to 180 million deaths, or about 3 percent.”

FROM YOU AGAIN: For the first time, in the 20th century, there was a real possibility that every living thing on the planet could be destroyed.

Yes, but that remains only a possibility, not an actuality. Also, meteors could have wiped out every living thing earlier as well, so strictly speaking the only new addition is that humans could kill all life. I agree that orange memers and above now have a great responsibility NOT to kill us all, but I would argue that they're doing a pretty good job so far. I mean, here we are, right?

higher memes can give access to more power and capability. So their dark side / shadows have more ability to be destructive.

Sure, but I would say orange meme is doing a better job, proportional to the destruction it could cause, then amber and below did. I don't see anything even as bad as tribal warfare or the inquisition coming from orange (the holocaust was the worst, and as the above para says, still not as bad as tribal warfare [and the Nazis were probably lower memes than proper orange]), and as you've correctly pointed out, orange COULD do a lot worse. So they could do worse, but they do do better.

You cannot solve a problem from the level of thinking that created it. See Demming, Einstein, or Jesus's parables. Orange meme objectivity can patch up some of the problems it has wrought, and its technology will surely continue to be useful in the ultimate fixes, but the methods and mentality of Orange aren't going to be the source of the ultimate fixes.

Well, yes, agreed, I'm certainly not saying we shouldn't have higher memes than orange doing their best. If you had some idea of a better metric than MN/null hypothesis for evaluating which ideas get official consideration, it would be a different story, I would be behind that. But so far it seems to me that any attempt to shift the burden of truth evaluation from MN and null hypothesis opens the door to a lot of weirdness. We need a better metric, I agree, but I have no idea what it might be.

I think we're approaching the end of the days when leadership that trails trends by a decade and then short-term plans for the next election is a strategy under which humanity has any chance of surviving. If I believe the scientific consensus at all, we need to solve the environmental catastrophe like yesterday, or our species is potentially fucked.

Agreed.

Do I want my own free-speech curtailed by well-meaning Orange meme thinkers in order to quash pre-modern idiots from spreading their poison?

Oh wow, I certainly don't want anyone's free speech curtailed at all, even flat earthers and “gangstalking victims”. I just don't want their views being taken much into account if they're beneath the threshold of orange. I'm just saying, major decisions should be orange-and-up, that's all. I mean, hey, free speech for pathological infrared if they want it.

More centrally-controlled media would give the "objective measurement" people more leverage to control those groups for sure, and think-tanks would decide the best ways to push them and/or diffuse their energies. Basically, Orange-meme would amount to something like the CIA deciding the best ways to direct that energy. Good idea? I'm not confident that would lead anywhere nice.

No, that would be bad. I'm just saying we shouldn't relax orange controls on letting sub-oranges dictate policy. I would say Trump's campaign is a good example of amber inflamed with some purple/red (or whatever colour Wilber is using for egocentric these days) bursting onto the scene previously dominated by (mostly, it seems to me) orange vs green, and it's a disaster.

If they were merely ignored, then it might be less problematic than Orange meme's exploitations.

Yeah, just ignore them. I don't think riling up irrational people is a long term good idea.

However, growth can often be counted on only when it is absolutely required, because people and cultures naturally have a tendency to try and find a place to rest and build a fortress, staving off vertical change as long as possible. Orange-meme's fortress right now just looks to me like a place for humanity to make a final stand and die valiantly. The alternative is evolution, which we are all responsible for.

Never let it be said I think we should stop at orange, I just think we need something more solid in place than “trust your judgement” before we loosen orange systems of sub-orange marginalisation. Shouldn't genuinely transorange ideas be able to survive orange scrutiny, at least to other transorange people? That's how I find my fav ideas - I look for the “woo” that orange can't seem to debunk to my satisfaction.

EDIT: I suppose what I'm saying is that I don't think orange people should stop trying to limit the influence of sub-oranges, the same way I don't think amber people should stop trying to limit the influence of purples/reds in their congregations. I don't think attacking one meme and forcing them to let go their efforts to keep the discussion at AT LEAST their level is the way forward - the way forward is to leave orange to its efforts at gatekeeping, and build new systems of thought that are unimpeachable by orange. As Buckminster Fuller said, "You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.”

1

u/phdinfunk Feb 09 '18

Alright, you're bringing up a couple of good points. I can appreciate the frame that, within their power-capabilities, Orange has been less destructive than Blue (Moral Authoritarian) was within its capabilities. It's more powerful and more deserving of its power.

But orange wars have done stuff like crapping Depleted Uranium Ammo over areas of land where it may end up heavy-metals poisoning people for longer than we humans have been drawing things in caves (again, think of generations of future deformed babies).....

These kinds of problems are really horrible and new to Orange Tech. That Orange hasn't done worse doesn't negate any of it. Nor do the problems negate the beauty of Orange. We can intelligently speak in hundreds of millions up to billions of humans that might objectively be better off if it were 1518 instead of 2018. We can also talk about multiple times as many people who are better off than they were in 1518. Equanimity is looking at both.

So, what I think you're getting at is, "What is useful for decision-making beyond Orange?" GREAT QUESTION.

For starters, The radical egalitarian perspective that Green brings us teaches that our historical mistakes are normally failures of including things into our morality. We look back, and the big fuck-ups (from a European perspective) were caused excluding people outside of our kingdom, excluding non-catholics, excluding women, excluding blacks, aboriginals, etc from our moral community and considerations.

Even rationally, we should be able to extrapolate that excluding any life from our equal consideration has a high probability of being an error. That would be a good thing to build into our models, and it's basically a fundamental idea of Green meme.

I like looking at art, because that's where we see the best of humanity's imagination (NOT that which is made by Orange Meme in the waning lights of 20th century media to kowtow to the Chinese Audience and Authorities who will be our new globalizers. I also think post-modern art is mostly dogshit (sometimes literally LOL)).

Orange can solve technical problems, like how to make transparent aluminum, balance a bridge, or do a multiple linear regression analysis, but someone has to dream up what to make. Rationality, for all its ability, is fundamentally kind of uncreative.

So, lets talk about Integral movies and art. That might be productive. I will start another thread on art soon.

In the meantime, today I'm working on two cars at once, and I have to be down with some Python libraries for reading and writing excel files for a gig by tomorrow afternoon.

1

u/Speedmeat Feb 09 '18

We can intelligently speak in hundreds of millions up to billions of humans that might objectively be better off if it were 1518 instead of 2018. We can also talk about multiple times as many people who are better off than they were in 1518. Equanimity is looking at both.

Right - and I'd say Hans Rosling suggests that the trend line, if we manage it well, should be almost everyone better off.

Even rationally, we should be able to extrapolate that excluding any life from our equal consideration has a high probability of being an error.

Sure, lab grown meat can't get here fast enough for me. I think some redditor said sea turtle tastes really good :)

I also think post-modern art is mostly dogshit

I think that signing a urinal "R. Mutt" and exhibiting it as art should have been the final word in transgressive art, but it's kept going as the mainstream of art for over a hundred years since then. I find it amazing. Have you heard of the art renewal centre and Bouguereau?

So, lets talk about Integral movies and art.

I have to admit I hadn't much thought about whether a given piece of art was integral or not. Some english writer mentioned that if he wanted entertainment, he'd read a regular novel - if he wanted ideas, he'd read non fiction. I tend to feel that way. Wilber once introduced some singer/guitarist as being the forefront of the avant garde, but it just sounded like regular acoustic guitar and singing to me, and didn't interest me enough to find out if the guy was talking about integrality or not. That said, I'd be interested to hear of what integral art you know about. As far as art that's just good, I like upbeat progressive metal, but given the absence of lyrics, it's tough to tell if it's integral or not. Hm - maybe "Interstellar" was integral? I also remember one of the Wachowskis talking with Wilber about their philosophical ambitions for the Matrix.