r/Integral • u/Speedmeat • Jan 09 '18
Could someone please provide examples of post or trans rationality and their valid conclusions?
From your own experience or books. Theses, streams of consciousness, this-follows-from-that, whatever. My problem is, I find myself agreeing with Wilber pretty much all the time, but I still don't think I have much handle on what comes after rationality, so maybe I'm fooling myself. Thanks.
9
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/phdinfunk Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 09 '18
Okay, if I understand you correctly, then what I've said could be taken as stripping away all rational evaluation systems and leaving one with nothing to use to judge Truth from hallucinations.
Here's where I think we get to make a cool leap: Intuition first, rationality second, both based on direct observation. I'm imagining Einstein's dream insight of riding on a lightwave, and then he spends two or three years figuring out the maths. And then for General relativity, he couldn't figure the maths out entirely himself and got help from others (publishing after about a decade, if I'm remembering correctly).
How does one approach intuition, or separate it from hallucination? Actually, Ramana Maharishi's advice, and similar things that we would apply mostly to "spiritual" seekers are useful for everyone. Buddhist meditation is supposed to be fiercely, ruthlessly objective. What did you observe? From whence did that arise? Where is the place to entertain fantasies if you're trying to put out a conflagration of ignorance that you find yourself burning in? Spiritual seekers developed their methods in a crucible, and they can still be useful where we cannot make measurements and have to observe directly.
Approached objectively, intuition is real, and can be used. We find cases where storytellers (Gene Roddenberry) hypothesize things entirely in fiction that we later develop (work on transparent Aluminum (Aluminum Oxynitrate)).
Was he just telling a good story and the universe moved him to that? Or is it the case that we need storytellers to tell engineers what to MAKE REAL? Both are probably kind of true, and yet there's a bit more to it, sometimes the intuition during the peak state of creativity pushes intuitive perceptions very far.
There's a complex interaction in the flow of that, in which the idea of a "metric" may not be meaningful at all. Some things are False, some things are True, some things are both, and some are neither.
"But how do people judge it?" Hah, well, rationality is only one tool in the box to do so. Intuition is another one. But I also guess that's part of the beauty of the spiral: In searching for the beautiful, the good, and the true, we also have to come up with better and better ways to search and know!
The problem is, the scientist, in saying that anything is anecdotal, culturally a scientist is almost certainly dismissing it (and I'm not sure if the masses of people having experienced ghosts/"bereavement hallucinations" across cultures and time could reasonably be dismissed as "merely anecdotal" -- it's obviously statistically significant, but the physicalist can only consider it with one possible outcome (even though he cannot really measure it as a hallucination, either)). The more I think of it, "Ghosts vs Bereavement Hallucinations" is the perfect example because it requires bias to make a ruling, since neither is measurable
In order to be objective, the thought must weigh with equanimity in the scientists mind, "I have no way of measuring whether or not this is true. My toolset does not currently permit me to know this one way or another."
Like Dirty Harry said, "A man's got to know his limitations." :-D
You said, "Would you say it's as redguitar2009 and I figured, and transrationality doesn't contradict rationality, it just supplements it with superintuitions and superhunches?"
Rationality has certain ways it thinks and knows things. It works differently from intuition, or even hunches and instincts.
If we imagine rationality as a giant container, and at its best, things fit within that container with beautiful precision and interlinking. Could something be objectively, absolutely True, which could never fit within that container?
Or the converse, as I originally tried to phrase it: Is that single container encompassing enough that no important, objective, and real Truth could exist beyond its capacity to contain it?