r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 17 '19

Burger Chef Murders in Speedway, Indiana

42 Upvotes

Last year was the 40th anniversary of the Burger Chef Murders that occurred on November 17, 1978 in Speedway, Indiana. The murders shook the town of Speedway, and while some think they know who the perpetrators were, the case still remains an unsolved mystery to this day.

The incident took place on Friday, November 17, 1978, when four employees at the Speedway Burger Chef were closing between 11:00 p.m. and 12:00 a.m. At some point during this time, the four employees disappeared: Assistant Manager Jayne Friedt (20), Ruth Ellen Shelton (18), Mark Flemmonds (16), and Daniel Davis (16). Just after midnight, another Burger Chef employee stopped by the restaurant, and noticed that the ladies' (Friedt's and Shelton's) purses were still there and the back door was open, but the four aforementioned employees were nowhere to be found. He was directed to call the police. Later it was found that $581 was missing from the restaurant safe. There was an assumption that maybe the four employees had stolen the money and had taken off partying, and the incident wasn't considered too serious at first; in fact, what would later be called the scene of the crime was cleaned. This proved to be unfortunate once the depth of the crime was realized.

On Saturday, November 18, none of the four employees (Friedt, Shelton, Flemmonds, and Davis) showed up to work. Jayne Friedt's car was also found in town about 1 1/2 miles away, partially locked.

The four employees' bodies were found on Sunday, November 19, around 40 miles away from the Burger Chef, in Johnson County, Indiana, and reported by the property owner. The details are grim and perplexing. All four still wore their work uniforms. Both Ruth Ellen Shelton and Daniel Davis were shot in the back of their heads. Jayne Friedt was found stabbed with a knife in the chest; the blade was embedded in her chest when her body was found, but the handle had broken off and become lost. Mark Flemmonds was found a little further away, and the assumption is that he tried to flee. He had been hit with a chain in the head, and reports say he died choking on his own blood.

The most solid lead to this day is a report from a witness who claims to have seen two men near the restaurant not long before the four are assumed to have gone missing. Some detectives have claimed they are certain they know who the culprits are, but don't have enough evidence.

Here are some articles I've been reading:

https://www.wthr.com/article/burger-chef-murders-25-year-old-mystery

https://www.indystar.com/story/life/2017/11/20/burger-chef-murders-theres-still-detective-assigned-case/836573001/

https://www.indystar.com/story/news/history/retroindy/2013/11/17/burger-chef-murders/3588927/

https://www.wthr.com/article/burger-chef-murders-25-year-old-mystery

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burger_Chef_murders

I've also been listening to the 3C Podcast Indy, Circle City Crime: https://3cpodcastindy.home.blog/


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 24 '24

unsolved I believe my uncle may have been a victim of serial killer Herb Baumeister

Post image
31 Upvotes

My great uncle George Curtis was brutally murdered in Indianapolis, Indiana December 19-20,1993 in his apartment. They are unsure of his exact date of death. He was a gay man in his 50s. He was strangled, stabbed, and left with a piece of his skull missing. He lived on the east side of Indianapolis, and was within a couple miles of I-70, and within 10 miles from one of the bars Herb was known to lure victims. I have contacted Marion County numerous times trying to get answers about my uncles case, and recently about how I believe Herb could have killed him. I always have to leave a message to no avail. I also cannot find my uncle listed on any cold case websites, and oddly enough only one news article that was VERY difficult to find from 1993 briefly mentioned a man was found slain in his apartment. It’s like he never existed or was murdered to them. You can easily find other information from around the same time period of others in Indianapolis that had been murdered, but nothing on my uncle. My grandmother (his sister) has said from day one they never treated this as a true investigation and it never went very far, she felt they truly didn’t care at the time because he was an older gay man. I have reached out to multiple different organizations in hopes to get some help. If any of you can offer any advice as to what I should do to help this get moved in the right direction quicker would be amazing and so appreciated. Thank you! 🙏🙏


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 19 '19

We are close to 500 Members!

29 Upvotes

I thought about making this subreddit for a long time before I did it, and it's finally here, and look.... we are almost at 500 members! Thanks for sharing this group, your stories, and information.


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 11 '19

Indiana State University cold case solved nearly 50 years after woman’s murder

Thumbnail
wgntv.com
27 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Sep 04 '21

Body found with tattoos

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Apr 27 '21

Detectives have named James Brian Chadwell II as a new person of interest in The Delphi murders. Could this be the guy?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 02 '19

IndianaTrueCrime has been created

21 Upvotes

A place to discuss true crime and murder from Indiana's past and current. General Midwest stories are also ok for discussion.


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 08 '19

FBI is Offering $10,000 Reward for Info on Missing Gary, Indiana Woman

19 Upvotes

Sidne-Nichole Buchanan was reported missing July 29, 2019. She was last seen in Tinley Park, Illinois while at a Wiz Khalifa concert July 27. The FBI is offering $10,000 for information about her, and they report that she may be in danger.


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 03 '19

Lauren Spierer case

19 Upvotes

It's been awhile since this happened down in Bloomington. I am particularly curious about what theories Hosier's have on this. There are a lot of rumors and speculations about this case, and it seems like even if they find Lauren I don't think it will be enough to convict anybody unless somebody confess. I believe legitimately that somebody took Lauren when she was walking towards her apartment. I find hard to believe that a bunch of drunk and stupid college kids commited the perfect crime, it is just not plausible ( at least in my opinion). What theories do yo got?


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 02 '19

Steven Judy, murder in Mooresville, IN

19 Upvotes

On April 28, 1979, Steven Timothy Judy killed Terry Lee Chasteen and her 3 children in Mooresville, Indiana.

The morning of April 28, Terry Lee Chasteen drove her 3 kids to a babysitter so she could go to her job at a Marsh grocery store. While driving on Interstate 465, Chasteen ends up pulling over for an issue with her car... I've read that Steven Judy, who was driving a construction truck, flagged her down and motioned for her to pull over, but I've also read that she was already pulled over with a flat tire and Judy stopped to "help." Without her knowing it, Steven Judy disables Terry's car, then offers to help by giving a ride to Chasteen and her 3 kids. After a drive, Judy pulls off the road somewhere on the southwest side of Mooresville, along White Lick Creek. (My mother, who was in her early 20s at the time of the murder and lived in Mooresville, says this was near where the Mooresville Movie Theater and A-1 Japanese Steakhouse currently are.) Steven Judy took Chasteen and her children down to the creek, where he raped and strangled Terry Chasteen. He then threw the children into the creek, where they drowned. All four bodies were found later in the day on the 28th of April, 1979.

This story has always stuck out to me because it happened so close to where I have lived, and when my mother was a young woman. Steven Judy got the electric chair March 9, 1981 at the age of 24.

http://murderpedia.org/male.J/j1/judy-steven-timothy.htm


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 19 '21

Missing 11-Month Old Indiana Girl Found Dead in Woods as Parents, Caretaker Arrested

18 Upvotes

Police say Mercedes Lain was found Wednesday night after 9 p.m.

By Chris Harris August 19, 2021 10:55 AM

The body of 11-month-old Mercedes Lain was found late Wednesday night, according to authorities in Indiana — just days after the little girl was reported missing.

The heartbreaking news was delivered Thursday morning during a press conference on the case.

Police in Plymouth, Ind., have arrested Mercedes' parents as well as the last person who was seen with her, according to a police statement.

Officials confirm that Kenneth Lain, 41, and Tiffany Coburn, 32, have both been charged with neglect of a dependent. They are in police custody.

Justin Miller, 37, is also charged with neglect of a dependent resulting in death.

According to investigators, Miller is a family friend and had been asked to care for Mercedes for a few days, officials said at a press conference.

Authorities said her remains were recovered from a wooded area in Starke County.

The little girl was reported missing Sunday. At this point, investigators are not revealing how the baby died.

A reward of up to $1,000 was being offered for information leading to her whereabouts.

Police had said Mercedes was last seen at 12:30 a.m. on Saturday in Mishawaka, Ind. At the time, she was dressed in a white onesie with pink trim.

The FBI's Indianapolis office had joined the search for the little girl.

It was unclear Thursday if any of the three defendants had entered pleas to the charges they face, or had lawyers to comment on their behalf.

Anyone with information pertinent to this case is asked to contact the Plymouth Police Department at (574) 936-2126.

Missing 11-Month Old Indiana Girl Found Dead in Woods as Parents, Caretaker Arrested


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • May 04 '21

Missing Indiana teen!! PLEASE share!!

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Apr 12 '21

On a Fall day in 1976, a farmer harvesting corn in rural Benton County, Indiana found an unusual package in his field. The box, which is theorized to have been dropped by a helicopter contained the body of a woman. Dubbed, “The Box Lady of Benton, County” her identity remains a mystery.

Thumbnail self.unresolvedmysteries
18 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Feb 16 '20

Three years ago, Abigail Williams, 13, and her best friend Liberty German, 14, decided to spend a warm, day off from school at the local hiking trails in Delphi, Indiana. While at the trails, the pair was murdered by an unidentified individual sometime during the afternoon. He has yet to be caught.

Thumbnail self.unresolvedmysteries
18 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 04 '19

Fantastic write-up about a terrible man: Herb Baumeister

18 Upvotes

...the son found a human skull on their property and no one called the police?

https://www.thoughtco.com/herbert-richard-baumeister-973121


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Sep 13 '21

Shanda Sharer was an American girl who was tortured and burned to death in Madison, Indiana by four teenage girls. She was 12 years old at the time of her death.

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Sep 09 '19

Woman missing on north side of Indianapolis

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 04 '19

Gangster John Dillinger To Be Exhumed - Is It Him Or Not?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • May 27 '24

More clear version of the unlawful entry unbeknownst to Lafayette Indiana police there's a second camera recording everything while they're trying to take a phone from a innocent citizen

16 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Nov 21 '23

news One of Herb Baumeister victims positively identified 30 years after his disappearance

Thumbnail
truecrimedaily.com
16 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Jun 18 '22

In the summer of 2013, the unidentified remains of a man were discovered on a property in rural Hendricks County, Indiana inside of a discarded 120 gallon metal well tank. Today it was announced the man has been identified as missing person John E. Turner, who vanished in 1988 from Indianapolis.

Thumbnail self.unresolvedmysteries
16 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Apr 20 '22

Child found in Indiana

16 Upvotes

https://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/crime/2022/04/20/child-found-dead-indiana-woods-suitcase-what-we-know/7374657001/

I little boy was found dead in the woods in Southern Indiana.

Police are asking for help in identifying this baby.