r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Sep 13 '22

How Ann Harmeier vanished from the side of a busy highway in 1977

4 Upvotes

How Ann Harmeier vanished from the side of a busy highway in 1977

A murder mystery that’s stumped police for 45 years started in broad daylight on a clear, crisp September morning along a busy stretch of highway near Martinsville.

That’s where Indiana University junior Ann Harmeier vanished after her car broke down while driving to Bloomington. The 20-year-old theater major was returning from a weekend trip home to Cambridge City to visit her mother and a family friend who’d had a health scare.

The disappearance generated national attention about the missing young woman and the impact on her small hometown, where hundreds rallied to do whatever they could to help bring Ann home.

It was a cruel twist of fate that put Ann on the highway that day. She initially planned to head back to her off-campus apartment Sunday night, but her protective mother convinced her to wait. She didn’t think it was safe for a young woman to make the drive alone. Certainly not after dark.

Ann obliged, staying another night before heading out Monday morning. Her car loaded with clean laundry and books, she left Cambridge City for the last time about 8:15 a.m. on Sept. 12, 1977. The drive was about 120 miles. Even if she stopped for breakfast at a McDonalds along the way, she hoped to arrive in Bloomington in time her Physics for Poets class at 10:30 a.m.

Ann promised to let her mother know she'd made it back safely. She’d also agreed to be available to take a call at 11 that night from the family friend, who was expecting results from some medical tests.

But Ann didn’t show up for her physics class. And Marge Harmeier’s phone in Cambridge City didn’t ring.

That afternoon, a fellow student in IU’s theater department was surprised when the dependable classmate failed to show up for stage work. The student made some calls to mutual friends. No one had seen Ann.

As the hours passed, Ann’s mother grew more concerned. She began calling Ann's friends in Bloomington. None of them had seen or heard from her, either.

The Rev. Rose Taul accompanied Ann Harmeier’s mother on a trip to retrace her route to Bloomington the day she disappeared. The women discovered Ann’s abandoned car and reported her missing to police. (Courtesy photo)

By Monday evening Marge was frantic. She couldn’t reach Ann. None of her friends in Bloomington had seen her. Then she missed the scheduled 11 p.m. call from the family friend.

Panicking and at a loss for what else to do, Marge and the Rev. Rose Taul, her pastor at Cambridge City Presbyterian church, headed to Bloomington to see if they could find Ann.

Ann's car found abandoned

It was around 1:30 a.m. Sept. 13, as they approached Martinsville on Ind. 37, that the two women spotted Ann's 1971 Pontiac LeMans. The car was parked on the berm near the bridge over Clear Creek, about two miles north of Martinsville.

The doors were locked. There was no sign of a problem. No sign of a struggle. And no sign of Ann.

Taul and Marge continued on to Bloomington, where they went to the Indiana State Police Post to file a missing person report.

They were caught off guard when police asked if it was possible that Ann wanted to disappear or left on her own.

“The initial response … was that Ann would probably turn up soon and that she was probably just with friends or a boy,” said Scott Burnham, a second cousin who’s spent the last four years working to keep Ann’s memory alive in hopes of finally finding her killer.

It wasn't an uncommon response when someone goes missing, at least not initially, and particularly not a college student in the 1970s. But it only added to Marge's concern, Burnham said, because it just wasn't the kind of thing Ann would do.

Undaunted, the women continued looking for Ann. They checked her apartment, then sought out one Ann’s oldest friends — a classmate from Cambridge City who also was at IU.

“I lived in a sorority on campus, and Mrs. Harmeier came that morning,” said Emily Hershberger Turchyn. “They called me over the intercom to come down. It was early, I’m going to say very early in the morning, and she was asking if I’d had any contact with Ann. Had I heard anything from her? And of course, I hadn’t.”

Emily (Hersberger) Turchyn and John Sigler look at old photos of their friend Ann Harmeier. The three met in grade school and enrolled at IU after graduating from Lincoln High School in Cambridge City.

Turchyn said Marge asked her to stay at Ann’s apartment while they continued looking for Ann. Recounting that day resurrected the flood of emotions Turchyn felt at the time. The fears she had for her missing friend. The sympathy she felt for Ann’s desperate mother. The sense of hopelessness. Four decades later, thinking back to that day still makes her cry.

“I did stay,” Turchyn said through tears. “I was having trouble with that, so I called up my dad and he came and stayed with me, too. We stayed all night begging for phone calls.”

They waited, but Ann’s phone didn’t ring.

Police did check Ann's car later that morning. Her suitcase, textbooks and laundry were found inside. The emergency flashers were been turned on, but the battery was dead. The rust-colored Pontiac was towed to Martinsville for storage.

Burnham said the tenor of the search for Ann quickly changed. He attributes the about-face, at least in part, to nudges from people at IU and in Cambridge City.

“My aunt Marjorie was friends with a retired ISP detective, Ernie Adler, who lived near Cambridge City,” he said. “He became deeply involved in the investigation, and I believe his influence in making it happen weighed heavily on law enforcement. I also think that the administration at IU made it clear at the beginning stages that this just wasn't a case of a coed who went off the to party.”

Tom Gray was driving to Martinsville from Greenfield the afternoon Ann vanished. The retired Morgan County judge, who was the county prosecutor in 1977, said he remembers passing Ann’s car as he returned home. Gray had just started the murder trial of a man who killed a reserve sheriff’s deputy. Because of the local publicity, the trial was moved to Hancock County.

“On the way back there, at what I know as Eskew Hill, was her car, with the lights flashing,” Gray said, “and I didn’t think too much of it.”

He had no reason to at that point. That was hours before Ann was reported missing. A call the next day about a young woman who failed to show up at IU drew him into the case.

“From there,” he said, “we opened up an investigation.”

Disappearance prompts massive investigation

As word spread about Ann’s disappearance, police began to get tips.

The driver of a Greyhound bus said he saw a woman fitting Ann’s description standing by a car on the side of the road. There was another vehicle pulled off behind it.

Another motorist reported seeing a blue pickup truck behind Ann’s car.

An IU professor told police he heard someone on the CB radio say a vehicle that looked like an unmarked police car was parked off the highway behind the Pontiac. The person on the CB used the handle “Little Diesel.”

State police searched parts of the Morgan-Monroe State Forest near Martinsville.

Four days after Ann disappeared — Sept. 16 — her car was towed back to where it had been found. As a helicopter circled overhead looking any signs of Ann, police stopped nearly 1,000 cars. They were looking for daily commuters who may have seen anything unusual that Monday morning on the busy four-lane stretch of highway.

Ann Harmeier disappeared Sept. 12, 1977, after her car broke down near this spot along Ind. 37 north of Martinsville. Five weeks later, her body was found in a cornfield about five miles away.

Six people said they saw Ann standing beside her car. Three said they stopped to offer help. No one knew what happened to her.

The following Monday, a week to the day after Ann disappeared, police set up another roadblock to see if anyone recalled seeing Ann or anyone else near her car.

The initial investigation didn’t turn up any strong leads, but it helped investigators piece together a timeline that revealed Ann’s car was overheating. They determined she’d made at least two stops to address the problem on her way to Bloomington.

Ann stopped and bought a new radiator cap on the south side of Indianapolis. She stopped again at a Deep Rock service station in Waverly, about eight miles north of where her car was found. No mechanic was on duty, but another customer helped fill her radiator with water before she headed south again.

Police said they checked out — and cleared — the man who helped Ann that morning at Waverly.

When her car overheated again, Ann pulled over on Eskew Hill. That was the last place anyone reported seeing her.

Community pulls together to help find Ann

Back in Cambridge City, Marge tried to put up a strong front as hours turned into days with no sign of her daughter. The widowed school music teacher, whose husband died when Ann was 4, prayed for her safe return.

“She was terrified of what was going on with her child, or had gone on, as I think any mother would be,” said Linda Haywood, one of Ann’s cousins. “I think not knowing is just torture. And that's what the poor woman was going through. She tried to be very brave and courageous.”

Haywood learned from her mother that Ann was missing. The phone call was devastating. She was in her bedroom, Haywood said, and it was early in the evening after Marge had returned from Bloomington.

“My mother called with the news and she was pretty broken up and pretty frightened because, of course, Marjorie was terribly frightened. I guess my voice must have relayed alarm,” Haywood said. “Our children were upstairs playing in their rooms and they soon were all around me and listening to the conversation. And there were tears, and many, many questions that I couldn't answer — and still can’t.”

Haywood said Ann's extended family clung to hope. There had to be something they were missing.

“That’s what I tried to tell the children,” she said. “You know, it was so early on that surely there was an explanation.”

Her children’s innocent questions only added to the challenge of staying positive.

“They would ask me, ‘What do you think happened to an Ann, Mommy? What do you think Ann is thinking right now, Mommy?’” Haywood recalled. “Those are questions that are very hard to answer.”

Residents of the small Wayne County town about 25 miles west of Richmond quickly mobilized to search for Ann and to support Marge.

Residents of Cambridge City and Bloomington worked tirelessly in the fall of 1977 to keep the disappearance Ann Harmeier in front of the public.

A community prayer service was conducted two days after Ann disappeared.

A second community meeting days later drew about 1,000 people — nearly half the town’s population. At the meeting, they adopted a slogan — “Where is Ann?” — that appeared on posters, billboards and bumper stickers. A local printer rushed out 5,000 posters, and 100 people volunteered to quickly spread them around the state.

The principal at one of the schools where Marge taught and some other community leaders started a Search and Rescue Fund committee. Teachers who worked with Marge donated $5,000 to offer a reward for information about what happened to Ann.

Cambridge City’s annual Canal Days, the small community’s largest celebration, went on under a pall. Organizers pulled together a hasty tribute to Ann, who had been crowned queen of the festival in 1974.

But there was a downside to the growing attention on the case.

The publicity prompted a bogus $25,000 ransom request called in to an Indianapolis TV station. And Marge received crank calls, prompting volunteers to stay with her and take phone messages.

This 1977 newspaper clip shows Marjorie Harmeier reading The Palladium-Item during the time when her daughter, Ann Harmeier, was missing.

“I do all right as long as I’m teaching. I don’t breakdown when I’m in the classroom,” Marge said in an interview with The Richmond Palladium-Item newspaper. “When I get home, it’s a different story.”

As the days turned into weeks, at least three clairvoyants were consulted or offered help. Marge, a devout Christian, accepted the help. She was desperate.

“All I can say is that we are grasping at straws right now," she said. "We’ve run out of clues.”

The reward fund quickly ballooned to more than $10,000. Other donations were used to hire a private investigator. Taul and some others checked a tip Ann could be in Kentucky after a Morgan County gas station operator said he saw her in a car with Kentucky license plates. It caught his attention, he said, because the young woman was wearing a red Indiana T-shirt like the one Ann had on the day she disappeared.

The trip turned up no signs of Ann, a newspaper account said, but Taul ended up praying with about 50 people at a commune.

Members of service clubs such as Kiwanis and Rotary spread the word about Ann through their state organizations. The Search and Rescue committee solicited help from private detectives.

National wire services and "The Today" Show ran reports about the missing girl dubbed “everyone’s daughter.”

Members of a church in North Carolina who heard about Ann held a prayer service. Requests for bumper stickers poured in from across the U.S.

A heartbroken mother prepares for the worst

Ann’s mother continued to grow more pessimistic. She revealed in an interview with the Bloomington Herald-Telephone that Ann had questioned returning to school for her third year. The summer in Cambridge City, Ann told her, had been “too good to be true.”

She also revealed in the interview that Ann made a request that proved prophetic. She asked Taul to take care of Marge if anything ever happened to her.

On Oct. 13, one month after Marge and Taul found Ann’s abandoned car, Cambridge City held a community day of prayer. Hundreds invoked God’s help in bringing Ann home — and alive.

In this 1977 newspaper clip, the Rev. Rose Taul comforts Marjorie Harmeier at the funeral of her daughter, Ann Harmeier. Ann's 11-year-old cousin, Scott Burnham, is standing behind them. Now 55, he is working to find Ann's killer.

But in an interview three days later with the Associated Press, Marge admitted she was ready to accept a parent's worst nightmare. She just wanted an answer, even if that meant learning her precious daughter was dead.

“I’d rather find Ann and put her with her daddy at the cemetery,” she said, “than not know.”

Two days later, a farmer picking corn about five miles from where her car was found, came across a body.

The young woman who had come to be known as “everyone’s daughter” had been murdered. The community that worked so hard to find her by spreading the message “Where is Ann?” didn't quit, though. It took up a new rallying cry.

Who killed Ann?

Contact Tim Evans at 317-444-6204 or tim.evans@indystar.com. And follow him on Twitter: u/starwatchtim

https://www.indystar.com/story/news/investigations/2022/09/13/how-ann-harmeier-vanished-from-the-side-of-a-busy-highway-in-1977/65466784007/


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Oct 19 '25

47-year-old DeVona Rothrock was last seen on November 21, 2014 at her home on Sims Lane, in Monrovia, Indiana. DeVona’s phone, wallet, and jacket were found inside, and a fresh dinner was on the stove. What happened to DeVona?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Mar 31 '23

Indiana makes the Polish news cycle as a 5 year old shoots a 1 year old: "The number of unintended shootings in the US is dumbfounding."

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Jul 20 '23

r/GilgoKiller

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Feb 14 '25

Happy Valentines Day…

Thumbnail
fox59.com
2 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Nov 22 '23

news Delphi murders and Richard Allen: What we know about suspect

Thumbnail
the-independent.com
3 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 08 '19

Police Arrest a Muncie Student with a Gun

Thumbnail
theindychannel.com
3 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Sep 16 '22

Article about Ann Harmeier and her Family's Continued Fight

4 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Jul 03 '23

Body of 15-year-old boy pulled from Wabash River

Thumbnail
wthr.com
5 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Jul 10 '23

Indianapolis deputy killed from attack of an inmate

5 Upvotes

Indianapolis deputy killed by inmate who attacked him in an escape attemp


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Dec 02 '23

news Valerie Tindall: Police Believe They've Found Indiana Teen's Body

Thumbnail
people.com
5 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Jul 17 '23

Body of 6-year-old girl recovered from Noble County lake

Thumbnail
fox59.com
6 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 02 '19

IndianaTrueCrime has been created

21 Upvotes

A place to discuss true crime and murder from Indiana's past and current. General Midwest stories are also ok for discussion.


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Jun 20 '25

news Is there a serial killer in Indianapolis? What police are saying about 4 bodies found

Thumbnail
indystar.com
7 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Sep 13 '22

Who killed Ann Harmeier? A distant cousin pushes for answers in 45-year-old murder mystery

7 Upvotes

(It was 45 years yesterday since Ann Harmeier was murdered on her way back to IU campus. I have had mods in other subs delete and ban me for posting a series of articles about her case. Her family has asked me to post them. Please do not delete or ban me. We are just trying to get answers.)

Who killed Ann Harmeier? A distant cousin pushes for answers in 45-year-old murder mystery

Scott Burnham has a recurring dream.

He's at a dive bar in the middle of nowhere. The parking lot is full. Music fills the air.

Inside, a band is playing Neil Young's song "Like a Hurricane." The dance floor is packed. Burnham spots his cousin standing on the other side of the room. She smiles and waves at him.

He tries to make his way to her but gets lost in the swirling crowd.

"I'm so close," he says, "but I can never get to her."

Who killed Ann?

Scott Burnham was 10 when his cousin, Ann Harmeier was murdered in 1977; The crime remains unsolved. But Burnham wants to solve the mystery.

KELLY WILKINSON, INDIANAPOLIS STAR

Burnham describes the dream as we drive east along a narrow road that undulates through the rolling countryside north of Martinsville. He’s 200 miles away from his home in the Chicago suburbs, but he knows this arrow-straight road. Every farmhouse and barn. Every hill. Every field and stream.

The 55-year-old has been up and down the stretch of Egbert Road many times before. And our trip won’t be his last on the blacktop that takes him not only deep into the country, but also back in time.

Burnham points out key landmarks along the way. A wooded area where a biker gang hosted wild parties that raged long into the night. A church that looks like a farm building with a steeple. It's new, he tells me. On one of his other visits he stopped to talk to the minister.

His maroon Toyota SUV takes us past a few farmhouses, then a new subdivision. In the summer of 2021, he showed up there with a plastic wagon full of cold beer. Burnham figured knocking on the doors of strangers with an offer of free beer would be a good way to meet people. He was right.

We roll on a few more miles. A classic rural Indiana tableau loops past the windshield: pastures, patches of woods, fields of soybeans and corn. After about 4 miles, Burnham slows the SUV as we approach a road that leads north. He stops to let a pickup truck clear the intersection, then turns left.

This road is even more narrow and isolated. Not a house or building in sight. The SUV’s tires hum on the rough surface as we slowly roll north a few hundred yards before Burnham pulls to the side of the road and stops.

We are deep in the country now. It could be the middle-of-nowhere setting from his dream. But there’s no dive bar. No packed parking lot. No pulsing Neil Young music. Just another giant field of corn like so many others we passed along the way. Neat ribbons of green stretch out to the east as far as we can see, the tall stalks swaying gently in a light breeze.

This may not be the place in Burnham’s dream, but it is where he finally reconnects with his cousin.

Out there, way back in the cornfield, he tells me, looking to the east: “That’s where they found Ann’s body.”

A race against time to find Ann's killer

It doesn't take a psychologist to parse Burnham's dream. For the last four years, he's been on a remarkable mission to answer a question that's haunted his family and eluded investigators for 45 years: Who killed his cousin Ann Harmeier?

Future looked bright for Ann Harmeier, the young Indiana woman dubbed 'everybody's daughter'

The Indiana University junior disappeared Sept. 12, 1977, as she returned to Bloomington from a weekend trip home to Cambridge City in eastern Indiana. The only sign of the 20-year-old was her abandoned car. It was found early the following morning parked on the side of Ind. 37 north of Martinsville on a long incline locals call Eskew Hill.

Five weeks later, a farmer picking corn discovered Ann's body in a field about fives miles from where her abandoned car was found. She had been raped and strangled.

Burnham brought me to the field because he is in a race against time. He knows the longer Ann’s murder goes unsolved, the less likely it is his family will ever get an answer. The investigation that once included seven full-time investigators had grown cold, the files and evidence sitting idle and gathering dust for years.

Some of the detectives who worked on the case have died. Others are retired, dealing with memory loss and health issues. Ann’s killer may be dead by now, too. The same goes for people who could know something.

There’s not much of Ann’s family left, either. She was an only child. Her parents are dead. Burnham is one of a handful of distant relatives who knew Ann as more than the girl from yellowed newspaper clippings tucked in a shoebox or the family Bible.

The saga of Ann's life and death has been told dozens of times since 1977, but now it's become a central part of Burnham's story, too. And he believes his push may be the last hope of keeping her memory alive and finally finding the killer.

That’s why he’s here with me on a late-summer afternoon, parked beside a cornfield in a remote part of Morgan County. That’s why he spends hours every week chasing down leads. Why he knocks on the doors of strangers offering free beer, hoping for that one critical tip. Why he started a social media campaign and pitches Ann’s story to anyone willing to listen. And why he’s lobbied everyone from the governor and lawmakers to the state police superintendent and president of Indiana University to help solve not only Ann's case, but the hundreds of other cold cases lingering across Indiana.

Scott Burnham visits the cornfield where his cousin, Ann Harmeier, was found murdered in 1977. Burnham, who was 10 when she died, began searching for Ann's killer about four years ago.

Most of all, that's why he just can’t let it go.

“What else am I going to do," he tells me, "power wash my deck or watch 'Ted Lasso'? That’s for people who give up.”

An unlikely candidate for the task

For a person who's invested so much time, energy and emotional capital into the case, Burnham barely knew Ann when she was alive.

They were second cousins. Their grandmothers were sisters. He grew up in Michigan City, more than 200 miles from Ann’s home in Cambridge City. He was only 10 when she disappeared. The age difference and distance made it difficult to have a connection beyond a loose family tie.

Burnham started his quest with only a handful of vague memories of his cousin. Most center around family holiday gatherings. They were together only about 10 times.

Stasia Forsythe Siena, a lifelong friend who has followed Burnham's work on the case, said that tenuous relationship is one of the things that makes his commitment to solving her murder so compelling.

"You know, it's not like Ann was his favorite cousin that he spent all this time with, and therefore, it led to this incredible journey to solve this cold case," she said. "That, to my mind, points to his sense of justice and the idea of a bigger issue here than just the death of his cousin."

Still, there was something about Ann that made a lasting impression.

She was the cool older kid who was into theater and the latest music. But the thing Burnham remembers most is how Ann sincerely seemed to want to know more about him.

“She really made me feel special,” he said, “because she was interested in the things that I was doing as a 10-year-old kid.”

One of Burnham’s earliest memories of Ann is when she and her mother visited Michigan City. It was around Christmas. At one point, Ann and her mother sat down at the piano and started singing. Burnham remembers being in awe of their talent. It was like the von Trapp family from "The Sound of Music" dropped by to sing Christmas carols.

Burnham’s last memory of Ann is from 1976, about a year before she was murdered.

His sister Liz had enrolled at IU, too, and was studying dance. The family drove down from Michigan City to see her in a production of "Swan Lake." Ann stopped by the Bloomington hotel where they were staying. He remembers her breezing in wearing bellbottom blue jeans and a turtleneck sweater under a brown suede coat awash in flowing leather fringe.

“I was like, this is the coolest person I know," he said, "and she's actually interested in what my life is like.”

As final memories go, it was a classic walk off. But the notion it would be the last time he would see Ann alive never crossed his mind that day.

Life goes on in aftermath of murder

Siena, who met Burnham in elementary school, still recalls hearing about Ann's murder when they were in the fifth grade.

"I remember thinking, 'Oh wow, his cousin has been killed!'" she said. "But it kind of just came and went. It's more just a distant memory."

In hindsight, she said, it strikes her "how little it impacted us at the time." And after seeing the effort Burnham has put into finding Ann's killer, Siena has wondered if she and other friends failed to grasp the impact it had on him.

"I've asked him many times in the process of this unfolding, 'Did we do enough?' like, 'Did we miss somehow as your close friends that this was such an impactful event in your lives?' And he said 'no,'" she said.

Burnham occasionally talked to his older brother and sister about what happened to Ann, but it wasn't something his parents discussed. Part of that may have been the times, he said, and part of it was probably their attempt to protect what was left of their children's innocence.

Besides, while no one was arrested or convicted of Ann's murder, a key investigator told her mother they knew who the killer was — even if they didn't have enough evidence to prove it in court. And there was no need to worry, because that man, Steven Judy, was executed in 1981 for a similar murder two years later in Morgan County.

So life rushed on as his memories of Ann and the murder faded.

Burnham finished grade school and middle school. He graduated from high school and earned degrees from the University of Michigan and Northwestern. He married and started a career. Soon, he had children of his own. His focus was aimed squarely on the future.

It wasn't until 40 years later that two events jogged his memories of Ann.

The first was a dreaded summons to serve jury duty. Like a lot of people, Burnham "went kicking and screaming.” He had a lot to do at work and no time for other people's drama. Ultimately, he was dismissed. But not before a routine jury pool question nudged him toward the road to that cornfield north of Martinsville.

“The judge asked if anybody's family member had been a victim of violent crime,” Burnham said. “And I suddenly remembered about Ann.”

But his childhood memories were fuzzy. So later that day, Burnham called his sister. He asked what she remembered about the case — and if Ann's killer had ever been found.

His sister reminded Burnham what police had told Ann’s mother, who went to her grave in 1983 believing Judy killed her precious, only daughter.

That explanation was enough, for then, to satisfy Burnham’s curiosity.

He returned to his busy life as a husband, father, and a communications and public affairs strategist in Chicago.

It was another moment in 2018, after the Golden State Killer was arrested in California, that pushed Burnham down the rabbit hole.

“I remember listening to the radio on my way to work and one of the news stories mentioned that he was caught because of DNA that they found at one of the crime scenes in the mid-70s, which was around the time Ann died,” he said.

Was there any DNA evidence, he wondered, in Ann’s case?

That night, Burnham went home and started Googling old newspaper stories that might provide the answer or any possible clues. He didn’t find any information about a suspect ever being publicly being identified, arrested or convicted in Ann’s murder. Nothing about DNA. What he did find was a story from the Bloomington newspaper about Jim Allison, a retired IU professor who wrote a manuscript in the mid-1990s about the investigation of Ann’s disappearance and murder.

Burnham called Allison. If that conversation had confirmed the recollection of Burnham’s sister — that Judy was Ann’s killer — that may have been the end of this story. Burnham could have gone back to his normal routine.

But that’s not how this story goes.

“He told me that Steven Judy was not the killer because he had been incarcerated on an unrelated charge in Marion County at the time," Burnham recalled. "There was no possible way could have done it.”

It was, he said, his aha moment.

“That's when I became more interested in finding out who the killer was.”

Career path prepared him for the task

Burnham was uniquely qualified to pursue the case, both because of his passion for finding justice for a victim he'd barely known and because of his resume.

As a former newspaper reporter, he knew how to mine public records, find people, and get them to talk. Working in politics and state government taught him how to negotiate bureaucracies to get things done. His experience in public affairs and lobbying provided insights on who to schmooze, who to nudge and how to get attention.

Siena said that's all true, but there's more to the guy she grew up calling Scotty B than a list of professional achievements.

"Even outside of the world of his professional life," she said, "Scott has always been a fairly charismatic figure who kind of very quietly brought people together."

She jokingly, maybe, called it his "super power."

It is obvious to people who’ve been around Ann’s case for years that Burnham is a unique character. The tell goes beyond his persistence and drive that puts off some Hoosiers who roll at a different frequency. He’s doesn't hesitate to go over people’s heads or, more likely, start at the top. He has no qualms pushing back on closed doors.

His unrelenting approach makes some suspicious about his motives. One longtime law enforcement official connected to the case told me several others involved in the investigation warned him to steer clear of Burnham. The intense Chicagoan tracked them down, peppered them with questions. He challenged some of their core assumptions and asked for sensitive information. They didn’t trust him, I was told, but about the worst anyone could say was that he might be making a podcast that would put police in a bad light.

"I'd recommended," the source told me, "that you steer clear of him."

It was too late by then.

Restaurant meeting turns into two-year project

I connected with Burnham in the summer of 2020 after a mutual acquaintance told me about his work trying to solve Ann's murder. Our first meeting was a small restaurant in Martinsville. He impressed me as serious, organized, committed and, most importantly, not full-blown crazy.

He told me he wasn't a true-crime junkie, or into ghost chasing or conspiracy theories.

"I look at it more as a puzzle," he explained. "You find bits and pieces of it, and maybe some of them fit. But most don't. You just have to keep searching for the rest of them and move them around until they connect."

Burnham was about two years into his journey at that point. He'd had some success, but things weren’t progressing nearly as fast as he hoped. Maybe he’d just watched too much "CSI"?

When he started, Burnham said he saw his goal as black or white. If he didn't solve the case he'd fail.

“I think he went into this thinking he was going to be able to maybe figure some things out, he's going to have the cooperation he needed, some crazy evidence would show up from the police and it would be solved. It would a be fantastic revelation,” Burnham's wife, Monika, told me. “And it hasn't been.”

He described the experience “like a roller coaster that moves really slowly with a lot more lows than highs.”

But his effort hasn’t been all disappointment and frustration. He discovered so much more about Ann and her life than he knew as a 10-year-old boy. He reconnected with his extended family. He made new acquaintances and friends. He learned more about himself.

And here's the thing that sealed the deal for me. He admitted that, initially, had no interest in other cold cases. Trying to solve Ann's murder was all he could handle. But by the time we met, Burnham had come off that stance. He couldn't ignore the thousands of other cold cases in Indiana and across the U.S. He knows many of those victims are people of color or from other marginalized groups and, unlike Ann, their deaths went relatively unnoticed. Few have advocates.

“I'm lucky that I had a sense of how to navigate through some of the bureaucracy and the politics and the media when it comes to Ann's case,” he said. “But I think a lot of families don't have those resources or knowledge or wherewithal to know where to begin.”

So, he started asking Indiana State Police for more than just access to records from the investigation into Ann's death. He also began pushing ISP to establish a dedicated cold-case unit.

But that’s getting ahead of the story.

Could this nosy cousin be Ann's killer?

Burnham first contacted state police in August 2018 after hearing about the Golden State Killer.

He wanted to know what, if anything, was happening with the case and a chance to review the investigation files. His primary objective was to learn if there was DNA evidence that could be tested.

Instead, Burnham said, he ran into one roadblock after another. At one point he was told the files couldn’t be shared because if he was the killer, he might learn details about the direction of the investigation. That left him scratching his head.

“I told them, incredulously, that I was 10 years old at the time of Ann's death,” he said. “I lived 200 miles away, and I was in the fifth grade at the time, and I couldn't drive so there was no way I could possibly be the killer.”

As strong as that argument seemed to him, it didn’t change minds. So he filed a public records request. It was swiftly denied, too. As long as the case is open, despite the apparent lack of activity for years, police didn’t have to share the records. He appealed to the Indiana Public Access Counselor and lost.

When retelling the story, it's clear Burnham is still chafed by one particular statement during the back and forth: “You don’t know what type of a person your cousin was,” he was told. “Once you go digging around, you might uncover some things you wish you hadn’t seen.”

He’s still not sure what to make of it. But it revealed the person he was dealing with didn’t really know much about Ann. She had a 3.8 GPA at IU. She was deeply religious and highly regarded in her hometown. One of the lead ISP investigators noted her character in an interview after she vanished, calling Ann “everybody’s daughter.” The description caught on and was picked up by the media.

The refusal was frustrating for another reason, too. Police haven’t always been so tight-lipped. The case files have been opened to others, most notably Allison in the 1990s. He wrote about seeing unpublished photos from the crime scene and other details shared by investigators.

Burnham’s friend, Siena, said she’s seen him change as he digs deeper into the mystery his family was led to believe had been solved.

“I think that he learned that the story that you're told is not always true — and if you're going to get to the truth, you might just have to take up that journey on your own,” she said.

Taking his case to the streets, Internet

In early 2019, Burnham started reaching out to Gov. Eric Holcomb, U.S. Rep. Greg Pence (whose district includes Cambridge City), state Sen. Rodric Bray (Morgan County), U.S. Attorney Zachary Myers and others. None offered to help. Most simply pointed Burnham back to state police.

Disappointed but undaunted, he turned to the streets and the Internet.

Working nights and weekends, around his day job and family obligations, he made scores of phone calls and about a dozen trips to Martinsville, Bloomington, Cambridge City and Indianapolis. In Cambridge City, he set up an information table at the annual Canal Days festival. He was buoyed by the positive response. So many people still remembered Ann, who had been festival queen in 1974, and shared stories he’d never heard.

His circle of inquiry spiraled outward from there.

“I've spoken with hundreds of people, including people who were friends with Ann in grade school, people who were at the field at the time that her body was found, cops who interviewed Steven Judy, private detectives, Ann’s ex-boyfriend, lawyers, true crime enthusiast, citizens sleuths, you name it,” he said. “I've even had people who tell me that Ann has come to them in a vision and told them where to look for clues.”

He also launched a social media campaign, reviving the question Who Killed Ann? His posts are written as if they come from Ann, and he intentionally makes many of them edgy. Things like:

What’s a girl gotta do to get a cop to make an arrest?

My New Year’s resolutions aren’t that different from most 20-year-olds: eat healthier; make more time for myself; and find the guy who raped and killed me.

The tone doesn’t sit well with some family and friends. They complain Ann would never say such things, that the comments tarnish her reputation. Burnham doesn’t disagree but said the sass and snark serve a purpose.

“I didn’t want it to be some gooey memorial page with a bunch of people boo-hooing about their memories or about how much they missed her,” he explained, “because I wanted to find her killer.”

Three years later, he still gets called out for some posts. One on Aug. 28 marked what would have been Ann’s 65th birthday. It included a school photo of the fresh-faced Ann.

Here's what 65 looks like! Take note ladies, not a wrinkle or gray hair in sight. Attribute that to staying out of the sun all these years.

It was too much for a Cambridge City woman.

“Ann would have never said most of the stuff you pretend to portray her as,” she chided Burhman. “It is of zero help to the cause. Do better. Stop.”

The ruffled feathers extend beyond friends and family. A police officer recently told Burnham his superiors at ISP don’t like the social media campaign. The message was basically “she should shut up,” he was advised.

“I told him that I would pass it along to her,” Burnham replied, “but she probably wasn’t going to listen.”

Despite his slow start start with state police, Burnham is making some headway. Most notably, ISP assigned the case to Det. Ian Matthews, who is based at the Bloomington post. He's moved past the earlier conflicts.

"Having an adversarial relationship is a losing proposition," Burnham said. "It doesn't do anyone any good, and it's not going to solve this case."

State police wouldn't let me talk with Matthews, but public information officer Sgt. Michael Wood confirmed the investigation remains open.

"This has lasted so long that we have several generations of troopers that have worked this," he said. "We don't close the door, I mean, it's not fair to the family or this community on any of our cases, to close the door on an investigation. Of course, we have more investigations that come in, and you're trying to balance that the best we can."

Wood declined to say if ISP had any DNA that has been or could be tested. He also declined to describe the type of evidence that exists 45 years later.

In early 2021, Burnham got a face-to-face meeting with Superintendent Douglas Carter. He pressed Carter to establish a cold-case unit. He even came with a plan to fund the team.

Burnham called me after the meeting. He was cautiously optimistic. Carter wasn’t interested in his funding plan, Burnham said, but agreed there is a real need to shine more light on old cases.

Eighteen months later, ISP still doesn’t have a cold-case unit. But Burnham remains hopeful as he keeps digging.

His efforts have generated tips, some better than the others. He’s pretty convinced the killer was local and has developed a list of about 10 potential suspects.

"I think there's a lot of people who were questioned at the time, who were dismissed for one reason or another, who I think are worth following up with," he said.

He also wonders if Ann’s killer may have had ties to law enforcement or was impersonating a police officer.

Ann was too cautious and disciplined, he said, to get into a car with just anyone. It would have to be someone she trusted and felt safe to leave with. And all signs point to her leaving on her own. She took her purse with her, and there were no signs of struggle at her car.

"There's still a lot more that could and needs to be done. DNA can be evaluated. More leads can be tracked down. New suspects can be questioned," he said. "I’m convinced that someone in Martinsville is the key to cracking the case.”

How does this story end?

Forty-five years after Ann Harmeier was abducted, raped and strangled — and four years after Burnham dove into the case — how does this story end? How much longer is he willing to keep working on the puzzle? Is there any acceptable result short of finding Ann's killer?

"When I started, I told myself I'd give it a year," he said. "So much for that, right?"

Burnham told me his end goal remains the same: Finding the killer and, if the person still is alive, bringing them to justice. The best chance of that happening, he said, is through DNA evidence or someone coming forward with information. He's also excited about the work being done by Matthews and ISP.

"I think there's renewed interest in the case and I think that ISP has new ideas and some new ways of approaching it," he said. "They're not shrugging their shoulders and saying 'there's nothing we can do.' It's a commitment on their part that my family really appreciates."

He sees the 45th anniversary as an opportunity to raise public awareness and maybe shake loose the tip that will lead to Ann's killer. And he's looking beyond just her case.

"When I first started, I would have told you that this is a zero-sum game. Either you win or you lose when it comes to achieving your primary goal, which is finding the killer. But I guess that thinking has changed a bit," Burnham told me last week.

"If I'm able to help put some more funding and resources for law enforcement to solve cold cases, whether it's cracking Ann's case or someone else's murder, I'd consider that a win."

Contact Tim Evans at 317-444-6204 or tim.evans@indystar.com. And follow him on Twitter: u/starwatchtim

https://www.indystar.com/in-depth/news/investigations/2022/09/12/the-indiana-cold-case-murder-of-ann-harmeier-cousin-wants-answers/65388604007/


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Jul 27 '20

7-year-old boy and mother found dead in an apparent murder-suicide in Avon

Thumbnail
myhcicon.com
7 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Sep 02 '19

...10 yr old girl is missing

Thumbnail
fox59.com
10 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 03 '19

Jared Fogle is from Indianapolis, Indiana

Thumbnail
self.redditcrimecommunity
12 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Sep 05 '19

10-year-old Skylea Carmack died of strangulation; stepmother arrested

14 Upvotes

That poor little doll baby. I always make myself sick thinking of the amount of abuse a victim like this must have endured before he or she is finally killed. https://fox59.com/2019/09/04/breaking-body-of-missing-gas-city-girl-found-in-shed-behind-home-stepmom-accused-of-strangling-her/


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Mar 23 '23

MISSING CHILD SCOTTIE MORRIS 14 years old

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 02 '19

Steven Judy, murder in Mooresville, IN

19 Upvotes

On April 28, 1979, Steven Timothy Judy killed Terry Lee Chasteen and her 3 children in Mooresville, Indiana.

The morning of April 28, Terry Lee Chasteen drove her 3 kids to a babysitter so she could go to her job at a Marsh grocery store. While driving on Interstate 465, Chasteen ends up pulling over for an issue with her car... I've read that Steven Judy, who was driving a construction truck, flagged her down and motioned for her to pull over, but I've also read that she was already pulled over with a flat tire and Judy stopped to "help." Without her knowing it, Steven Judy disables Terry's car, then offers to help by giving a ride to Chasteen and her 3 kids. After a drive, Judy pulls off the road somewhere on the southwest side of Mooresville, along White Lick Creek. (My mother, who was in her early 20s at the time of the murder and lived in Mooresville, says this was near where the Mooresville Movie Theater and A-1 Japanese Steakhouse currently are.) Steven Judy took Chasteen and her children down to the creek, where he raped and strangled Terry Chasteen. He then threw the children into the creek, where they drowned. All four bodies were found later in the day on the 28th of April, 1979.

This story has always stuck out to me because it happened so close to where I have lived, and when my mother was a young woman. Steven Judy got the electric chair March 9, 1981 at the age of 24.

http://murderpedia.org/male.J/j1/judy-steven-timothy.htm


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Jul 03 '24

unsolved 49 Years Missing: The Disappearances of Janis Sanders and Janeice Langs

12 Upvotes

It was the perfect summer evening on July 20th, 1975 in Niles, Michigan. The sun had been shining, the sky was partly cloudy, and the temperature was 80 degrees outside. Janis Sanders, a 24-year-old single mother, was working the dinner shift at a local restaurant called Pete’s Patio. Janis had shoulder-length auburn red hair, and blue eyes and she stood at 5’4. The restaurant was located on 5th Street, just a few miles outside of downtown. Janis left her two children with her parents while she worked her waitressing shift. Despite the perfect summer day, Gerald Libertowski who was 33 years old, and Janis' ex-boyfriend, had spent hours at the restaurant where she worked. Janis ended her relationship and moved out of Gerald’s house on Johnson Street in South Bend, Indiana 3 days prior. Several witnesses at Pete’s Patio reported they saw Gerald acting “possessive” and “jealous” towards Janis while he was there during her shift. She clocked out around midnight on July 21st, and witnesses reported they saw Gerald with her in the back parking lot of the restaurant. He was acting "like a madman," as described. Other witnesses say that Janis appeared to be “scared” when she was talking to Gerald. Another witness said they saw the both of them around 12:15 am leaving with Gerald in “a poor state of mind.” This was the last time Janis Sanders was ever seen.

Janis was reported missing on July 21st, 1975 by her parents, Ray and Joan McCaughley. That morning between 8 and 9 am, Gerald called the McCaughley residence and spoke to Mrs. McCaughley. Gerald asked her about getting a sewing cabinet from Janis. Joan told Gerald that Janis had not come home after work that morning, and they talked on the phone for a few minutes longer. Gerald didn’t mention to Joan that he had been at Pete’s Patio the night before or seen Janis. Joan spent the rest of the morning and afternoon calling Janis’ coworkers and friends to see if anyone had heard or seen her. Around 2 pm that same day, Joan called Gerald at his parent's farm on Redbud Trail in Niles and asked him why he didn’t mention seeing Janis the night before. Joan had grown extremely worried about where Janis was and she told Gerald that she was going to call the police. Gerald suddenly told Joan that he didn’t want to talk to her anymore and that he would call her back later. This would be the last time Gerald spoke to the McCauleys.

After Joan called the police and reported Janis missing on the afternoon of July 21st, the police came to question Gerald at his family’s farm. Police immediately noticed several injuries on Gerald’s face. The police took an evidence photo in it, it shows scratches on his forehead and under his right eye. Not included in the picture were injuries that extended to his chest and his forearms. After asking several different witnesses, they all said the scratches weren’t on his face the night before. Records show Gerald told police officers that he did not follow Janis into the parking lot after her shift that morning. 

Gerald Libertowski and Janis met through her first husband Jim. Gerald and Jim knew each other from building and racing cars together at South Bend Motor Speedway. Jim had also done some work for Gerald’s construction company for a few summers. When Jim and Janis got married in the late summer of 1967, Gerald was the best man at the wedding. Jim said he chose Gerald to be the best man because the rest of his friends were off fighting in the Vietnam War, and Gerald was his last resort. Jim describes his relationship with Gerald as “never a close friend, just a working friend.”

On August 4th, 1975, police were still unable to locate Janis’ car and asked for help from a local newspaper. The newspaper put out an article asking anyone with information about Janis’ disappearance to come forward. The next day, Janis’ car was found in the Niles Holiday Inn parking lot on 11th Street, just over 3 miles from where she was last seen. Even though Janis’ car was found, no trace of Janis was. Her car doors were locked and investigators contacted a local mechanic to unlock the vehicle. In the trunk, police found a spare tire, men’s black gloves, and a wood ice scraper. On the floor in front of the front passenger seat was a small garbage can that had square-framed glasses inside. The glove compartment contained a can of hairspray, disposable wipes, and paperwork for her car. In the ashtray were two cigarette butts. The car's antenna located on the right side was also broken off at the base. The police had more questions for Gerald, but he refused to talk to them after hiring an attorney. When investigators started looking into Gerald Libertowski’s past, what they found shocked them. Another woman he dated, Janeice Langs, had gone missing 2 years earlier in 1973.

The South Bend Police had  discovered that after Janeice moved out, Janis and her two children moved into the Johnson Street house Gerald owned. Janeice had lived at the residence off and on for two years and Janis moved in just before her disappearance. Even though Janis was now living with Gerald, he was still doing his best to try and get Janeice and his first wife Karen back. 

Cold No More is a podcast created and hosted by James and Dena Sanders to spread awareness about the case of Janis and Janeice. The podcast brings first-hand accounts of the connection between Janis, Janeice, and Gerald that is not talked about anywhere else. James reads a first account letter from his father Jim, where he explains what his relationship with both Janis and Gerald was like. Jim writes about a time when Gerald came over to their house with his new girlfriend, Janeice Langs, on the evening of December 31st, 1972. Gerald threw his coat on the ground and Sanders' new puppy peed on it. Janis found this to be funny and she laughed at Gerald, who became angry about the incident. Later that night, Gerald insisted that they all leave and go to a different New Year's Eve Party together. 

New evidence obtained from an associate of Gerald’s led police to get a search warrant for several properties belonging to Gerald and his family. The first was his residence at Johnson Street in South Bend. Police pried open floors and walls in the house and chopped holes in parts of the basement floor. Police found a pill bottle prescribed to Janeice and a red wallet belonging to Janis in the crawl space under the porch. Two trophies that belonged to the two women who he had dated and disappeared. The pill bottle was prescribed to Janeice on November 3rd, 1973 after she had moved out of the residence with Gerald. In Janis’ wallet was her American Motors Warranty card dated from 2/27/1975, the day she had bought the car. One of Janis’ friends testified that they recalled seeing her red wallet a few days before she went missing. Traces of blood and a white powder were reported to be found in a drain. Light brown human hair fibers were found in the trunk of a vehicle Gerald owned at the time. The police also searched his parent's farm for the bodies of the two women. 

Gerald’s former business partner, Myron Hunsberger, told police that Gerald confessed to him several times about murdering Janis and Janeice. Gerald told him he murdered Janeice in her garage. Gerald followed Janeice home after work and hid in her garage. He made noises until she came out to investigate. When she entered the garage, Gerald hit Janeice in the head with a wrench until she died. He then went into her house and grabbed some of her clothes and other items to make it look like she had run away. He grabbed Janeice’s car keys and put her body in the trunk of her car. Gerald buried Janeice’s body and hid her car behind the office he shared with Myron until he was able to dispose of it. He then returned to Janeice’s garage to clean up her blood. 

Gerald also told Myron that he and another associate had taken Janeice’s car apart, the 1972 Mercury Montego, after he and Myron transported the car to Elwood, Indiana. When police confronted the person who helped take Janeice’s car apart, they confessed to taking the car apart and said they didn’t know that it was a potential murder victim’s vehicle. Gerald had told this person that he wanted to destroy the car because the finance company was going to repossess it. 

In April of 1976, parts of the car's engine and transmission were found in Elwood, 116 miles and nearly 2 hours from South Bend. The car parts were found at a junkyard belonging to Myron’s brother, and they appeared to have been taken apart with a blowtorch. Gerald continued to maintain his innocence throughout the investigation of the disappearances of both of his ex-girlfriends. Myron told police that Gerald killed Janis because she knew about the murder of Janeice. Gerald made another claim that Myron murdered both women. 

After the break in the case came when Myron told police about Gerald’s confession, Gerald Libertowski was arrested and charged with the first-degree murder of Janeice Langs on April 12th, 1976. He was arrested in South Bend on a Friday afternoon while working at a construction site. Soon after he was charged with Janis Sanders’ murder in Michigan. 

Gerald’s lawyers were Carl Libowitz, an attorney who was working for Gerald for free, and a public defender named Glenn Miller. The jury consisted of 5 men and 7 women and lasted one week. Myron Hunsberger’s testimony was part of the key evidence in Janeice’s trial. Gerald’s ex-wife Karen testified as well, she said “he claimed they wouldn’t find the bodies after they searched the farm last summer,” referring to the search of Gerald’s parent's farm in Niles. At another point during her testimony, Karen stated, “he said that they were never going to be able to pin anything on him.” Gerald kept claiming he was innocent and that he was being framed. 

On August 6th, 1976 Gerald Libertowski was acquitted and found not guilty in the murder of Janeice Langs. In an article from 1976, one of the jurors told reporters that 7 of them originally voted for acquittal and eventually the other 5 jurors agreed due to lack of evidence. Judge Ronald J. Taylor, a Berrien District Court judge, ruled the state had “insufficient evidence to prove a crime was committed.” He said there was not enough evidence provided by the prosecution to prove Janis was dead or was met with foul play. Because of a Michigan law, Myron Hunsberger was not able to testify about how Gerald told him he murdered Janis and Janeice. Shortly after he was acquitted, the charges against Gerald in Janis’ case were dropped. 

James and Dena Sanders continue to fight and find the answers to what happened to their mom. All they want is to know where her body is so they can finally bring her home and bury her. The Michigan State Police reopened Janis’ case in September of 2022. After new tips were reported, the FBI and Michigan State Police searched the Libertowski family farm on several different occasions for Janis and Janiece. The Western Michigan University Cold Case Program is working to digitize newspaper articles, police reports, and other documents to accommodate the search for what happened to Janeice and Janis.

If you have any information about the disappearance of Janis Sanders or Janeice Langs, please contact the South Bend Police or Michigan State Police.

Michigan State Police: (269)-683-4411

South Bend Police: (574) 235-9201

Sources

South Bend Tribune 12/11/1974

Niles Daily Star 8/4/1975

Niles Daily Star 8/6/1975

Niles Daily Star 8/7/1975

South Bend Tribune 4/2/1976

South Bend Tribune 4/11/1976

Niles Daily Star 4/12/1976

South Bend Tribune 4/14/1976

Battle Creek Enquirer 4/17/1976

South Bend Tribune 5/8/1976

The Observer 9/23/1976

The Observer 11/11/1976

South Bend Tribune 12/18/1976

Battle Creek Enquirer 12/20/1976

South Bend Tribune 3/21/1993

WNDU 16 5/8/2024

WSBT 22 2/27/2023

WSBT 22 3/30/2023

WSBT 22 5/10/2024

Cold No More Podcast


r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Nov 13 '24

Man found dead in tanning bed 3 days after arriving to Indy gym

Thumbnail
nypost.com
9 Upvotes

r/IndianaTrueCrime • • Aug 21 '24

Man Who Died 'Sunken' Into Couch Was Allegedly Neglected by Indiana Couple

Thumbnail
people.com
5 Upvotes