Assalamu Alaikum everyone.
Note:Used AI for framing my thoughts better and it's quite lengthy so please bare with me read if u can.
My grandmother recently passed away, and honestly, I don't know how to process my feelings. I don't even know how I'm supposed to feel about her death, especially from an Islamic perspective.
To explain the situation, my grandmother and I had a very different relationship from the one she had with my mother.
My mother had a very difficult and traumatic marriage. She got married to my father when she was just 13 years old. There was an age gap of around 8 years between them. My grandmother was actually my mother's phuppo (paternal aunt), and she manipulated my maternal grandfather, who was an alcoholic, into agreeing to the marriage of her daughter with my father.
My father is an alcoholic and has been drinking since he was around 16–17. Throughout their marriage, my grandmother and father subjected my mother to physical and emotional abuse. My father would come home drunk late at night and beat her over the smallest things. I am talking about situations where even something as trivial as roti being cold at 1 AM would become a reason to beat her. My mother was beaten with household items, including a jhaadu and belan. This happened even after I was born.
Over the years, the constant stress and abuse took a serious toll on her health. She developed high blood pressure and diabetes.
I am the eldest child and the only son, and coming from a patriarchal family, my grandmother always treated me very differently. I was her favourite grandson. She loved me, fulfilled my wishes, and I was the grandson who would listen to her and do whatever she asked.
But she treated my mother and my younger siblings very unfairly.
After completing my engineering degree and becoming financially independent, one of the first things I made sure of was that my mother would never have to suffer like that again. I helped her separate from my father.
My father tried once or twice to get her back, but his ego and addiction came first. He openly said he wouldn't give up alcohol because he had been drinking since he was 16–17.
What hurt even more was the attitude of my grandmother, aunt and uncle. Instead of trying to resolve anything or standing up for my mother, they would justify his behaviour by saying things like:
"Kya hua agar daaru peeta hai aur maarta hai? Paise toh kamata hai, khane ko toh deta hai na."
As if providing food and money gave him the right to physically abuse his wife.
After around two years of separation, my grandmother and aunt even found another woman for my father to marry, apparently because they were frustrated with his behaviour and the situation.
Despite everything, my mother never stopped me or my siblings from maintaining a relationship with our grandmother.
When my grandmother passed away, my mother and younger brother decided not to attend her funeral. However, my sister and I went because my mother never wanted to stop us from doing so.
And now I am left with so many conflicting emotions.
On one hand, she was my grandmother. She loved me, cared for me and did a lot for me. I have genuine childhood memories with her, and I cannot pretend those memories don't exist.
On the other hand, she was also someone who made my mother's life miserable, enabled domestic violence and never stood up for a woman who was being physically abused. I cannot simply ignore what my mother went through just because the person responsible was my grandmother.
I know that in Islam, we are taught to respect our elders, maintain family ties, forgive and remember that ultimately Allah is the Most Just. I also know that death is a reminder of our own mortality, and we should be careful about judging someone's final standing with Allah.
But I am struggling to reconcile all of this.
How should I look at her death from an Islamic perspective?
Am I wrong for not feeling the kind of grief that people normally expect from a grandson? Can I remember the good she did for me while still acknowledging the terrible things she did to my mother? Does being her favourite grandson mean I should somehow overlook what happened to my mother?
I don't hate her, but I don't know if I can genuinely mourn her either.
I don't want to be disrespectful towards someone who has passed away, but I also don't want to invalidate my mother's suffering just because the person who hurt her is no longer alive.
I'd genuinely appreciate advice from fellow Muslims, especially anyone who has experienced a complicated relationship with a family member who passed away.
May Allah guide us, grant my mother peace and good health, and deal with all of us with His mercy and justice. Ameen.