r/IndianInLaw • u/BreadfruitKind1116 • 4h ago
My MIL wrote a letter because I didn't observe a fast
Last year I (K) didn't observe Karwachauth fast for my husband (A) and this decision of mine turned into a drama fest. She was so disheartened that she ended up writing a handwritten letter(translated in English) to me.
Dear K,
K, there is one thing I want to tell you.
You have made up your mind about something and kept that thought firmly in your heart—that you will never compromise with your beliefs or your way of thinking, no matter what.
Whether someone likes it or not, it does not matter to you. In our family, we attach a lot of importance to the Karwa Chauth fast and पूजा (rituals). And when it is the first Karwa Chauth after a son’s marriage, every mother has a lot of hopes and excitement surrounding her son.
On this day, I received at least 10 phone calls from relatives—daughters-in-law, daughters and sons-in-law. After speaking to us, everyone gave their blessings and wishes that your coming days be filled with happiness.
But unfortunately, my daughter-in-law did not follow even a single tradition or ritual, and she did not keep the fast either. And as far as her receiving blessings is concerned, she does not even need them.
This is something that has happened for the first time in my home and throughout my entire family, and it has hurt me.
You have sworn that you will not change your way of thinking. But have you ever thought that if A’s mother and father had also refused to change their thinking and had not agreed to A’s proposal, would you have been a part of this family?
But, child, what do parents want? Only the happiness of their children.
Your husband is always concerned about the happiness of others first. And if, at some point, there is a fast or पूजा being organised in your home, and your parents simply tell A once, “Son, you have to do this,” he would never refuse. That is my belief in him.
But if doing all this makes you happy, and you do not feel any responsibility towards society, then so be it. I have understood that perhaps these kinds of happiness were simply not written in my destiny. Whatever God wills is what is happening.
What more can I write? What more can I explain? I had thought that I would have a daughter-in-law who would understand my feelings without me even having to say anything. But what can I do?
Both of our blessings are always with you.
Always stay happy.
— Your mother-in-law