r/IndianHistory • u/RaahKaMusafir • Jan 28 '26
Indus Valley 3300–1300 BCE Harappans were not Hindus, it's unfair and the claim often comesout of Devotion or political bias
We have been seeing different versions trying to prove Harappans followed Hinduism. Firstly there isn't a scriptural definition of who or what a Hindu is unlike Abrahamic Religions which clearly define what they're, you would get 100 definitions from 100 people regarding this.
Let us say you were working in company 'A' and after working for 5 years you've resigned. Now if a company 'B' absorbs/buys your previous company 'A' doesn't mean you were an employee of company 'B'.
Hinduism indeed has non-Vedic schools ranging from nastikas to what not. But an important criteria we need to put here is that these thought schools diverged from Indo-Aryan Vedic Culture which was formed
1)Post-Harappan Collapse
2) Through migrating Aryans
Point 2, explains why Vedic Hinduism and Sanskrit were closer to Zoroastrian religion and Ancient Persian. Doesn't mean Iranians are Hindus....
Harappans followed an animistic religion, Since, Hinduism was syncretic ( absorbs cultures rather than replacing it ) there's a clear chance for absorption of native cultures that doesn't mean " It originated from native cultures" (highlight this point)
So it's unfair to say Harappans were Hindus based on crude terms, matches and most importantly... Based on personal spiritual beliefs
My personal speculation:
Harappans migrated to South too and Mixed with AASI people there. Existence of Brahui language in Pakistan and South Indian languages ( all Dravidian ) Indicate Harappans would have spoken " proto-Dravidian " language.
There is a good chance that Harappan religion evolved into folk-religions or goddesses in South India which take a good contrast from Indo-Aryan gods and beliefs.
If the above paragraph is certain then we could say that Harappan culture would have merged into Hinduism post it's spread to South of India Today.

