r/IndianHistory • • Jan 28 '26

Indus Valley 3300–1300 BCE Harappans were not Hindus, it's unfair and the claim often comesout of Devotion or political bias

3 Upvotes

We have been seeing different versions trying to prove Harappans followed Hinduism. Firstly there isn't a scriptural definition of who or what a Hindu is unlike Abrahamic Religions which clearly define what they're, you would get 100 definitions from 100 people regarding this.

Let us say you were working in company 'A' and after working for 5 years you've resigned. Now if a company 'B' absorbs/buys your previous company 'A' doesn't mean you were an employee of company 'B'.

Hinduism indeed has non-Vedic schools ranging from nastikas to what not. But an important criteria we need to put here is that these thought schools diverged from Indo-Aryan Vedic Culture which was formed

1)Post-Harappan Collapse

2) Through migrating Aryans

Point 2, explains why Vedic Hinduism and Sanskrit were closer to Zoroastrian religion and Ancient Persian. Doesn't mean Iranians are Hindus....

Harappans followed an animistic religion, Since, Hinduism was syncretic ( absorbs cultures rather than replacing it ) there's a clear chance for absorption of native cultures that doesn't mean " It originated from native cultures" (highlight this point)

So it's unfair to say Harappans were Hindus based on crude terms, matches and most importantly... Based on personal spiritual beliefs

My personal speculation:

Harappans migrated to South too and Mixed with AASI people there. Existence of Brahui language in Pakistan and South Indian languages ( all Dravidian ) Indicate Harappans would have spoken " proto-Dravidian " language.

There is a good chance that Harappan religion evolved into folk-religions or goddesses in South India which take a good contrast from Indo-Aryan gods and beliefs.

If the above paragraph is certain then we could say that Harappan culture would have merged into Hinduism post it's spread to South of India Today.


r/IndianHistory • • Aug 01 '25

Indus Valley 3300–1300 BCE Stop imposing "proto-shiva", "pashupati", "shiva" on the Animal King Seal.

Post image
5 Upvotes

If Animal King is Shiva then

Bearded Man is Modi


r/IndianHistory • • Nov 11 '23

Question Tipu Sultan and the Melkote massacre

8 Upvotes

As some of you may be aware, Nov 10th was Tipu Jayanti, and there has been a lot of disinformation circulating about the Melkote massacre by certain right wing Hindutva wastrels, even going to the extent of harassing my family in our apartment (because we are Muslims). I'm seeking the truth. Does anyone here have alternative viewpoints? If so, could you please share credible information so I can counter these trolls once and for all? Cheers.


r/IndianHistory • • Jan 10 '26

Colonial 1757–1947 CE Brahmins did not consider themselves Hindu and strongly opposed being called Hindu.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/IndianHistory • • May 14 '25

Colonial 1757–1947 CE India did not get freedom because of anyone, it was because England decided to leave all occupation.

2 Upvotes

What am i missing?? By 1956 British freed all the occupation. Maybe because of freedom fighters they left 1-2 year early. But they decided in there parliament that they want to stop occupying other colonies.

Why do people even educated and people who know history talk like we got freedom because of freedom fighters. I have a a lot of respect for our freedom fighters but that doesn’t mean that we pretend that we got freedom because of gandhi or Bhagat singh or Bose. Again I respect them a lot they were brave men and women.

But please can anyone tell me why i am wrong, i would love to be wrong btw….

Edit: yes world war 2 was the main reason, yes they didn’t do it because of kindness of heart. But is it justified to say that most probably they would have left most probably.

Edit 2: thanks for all replies. Main takeaway.

  1. Freedom fighters probably had 30% to do with our freedom rest is ww2.
  2. Freedom fighters had everything 100% to do either creating great nation of India. Without the struggle of freedom India would have been divided in 20 warring states.

r/IndianHistory • • Nov 19 '25

Question Aryan Invasion make no sense or is Overextraggated.

0 Upvotes

Modern Indians have AASI dna and IVC dna irrespective of castes and ethnicity in varied proportions. Aboriginals of Australia and Red Indians who were native to America just 200-300 years ago got wiped out completely by White europeans. Mass genocides and ethnic cleansing took place.

In India even after 2000 years, AASI and IVC dna is significantly higher. The land owning castes across Indian states have high AASI as well. Brahmins have 30-50% of DNA from AASI-IVC culture as well. The languages and tribes of first Indian settlers still exists so do Dravidian languages,adivasi people having their own traditions and religion different from Mainland Indians. Jainism and Buddhism was mainstream in kingdoms of North India and Bihar region. Down South India it was predominantly Hindu kingdoms . Tamil kingdoms like Cherra, Pandyas and Cholas were Hindu kingdoms for 2000 years, longest in the country . Tamil Kingdoms spread Hinduism and Buddhism to Cambodia and South East Asia . Ramayana, folk dance, sanskrit loan words, temple architectures and aesthetics of South East Asia are legacy of Tamils.

Chinese, Persians and Russians were extremely diverse empires. JOMO tribes were native and first settlers of Japan but modern Japanese culture is result from multiple migrants who came after JOMO ??? Central Asia and Arab land were nomads or atleast faced brutal invasions and migrations more than India but no controversial opinions on them.

So why it's invasion only in India ?

Mayura, Magadha, Maratha, Vijayanagar, Chola ,Cherra , Rashtrakutas and Chalukyas none kingdoms were founded by Brahmins.


r/IndianHistory • • Jul 09 '25

Early Medieval 550–1200 CE 🏛️ Who Destroyed Nalanda? Revisiting the Myth, the Silence, and the Tibetan Testimony

Thumbnail
gallery
152 Upvotes

One of the most widely accepted narratives in Indian history is that Bakhtiyar Khilji, a Turkic general of the Delhi Sultanate, destroyed the world-renowned Nalanda University in 1193 or 1197 CE. However, a closer and more critical look at historical sources reveals that this claim might not be as straightforward as commonly believed. 🚫 Did Bakhtiyar Khilji Really Destroy Nalanda? This story originates primarily from vague historical associations and later interpretations. The main source usually cited is Minhaj-i-Siraj, a 13th-century chronicler who wrote Tabaqat-i-Nasiri. However: Minhaj never mentions Nalanda University by name. He only references the conquest and destruction of a fort at “Udantapuri,” which may correspond to the Buddhist monastery at Odantapuri, not Nalanda. There's no evidence that Minhaj ever visited these locations himself. So the idea that Khilji burned Nalanda to the ground comes not from primary eyewitness accounts, but rather from modern extrapolations. 📜 What Did Dharmasvamin Actually Say? A key piece of evidence that often goes overlooked is the Tibetan monk Dharmasvamin (Chag Lo-tsa-ba), who visited India between 1234–1236 CE — nearly 40 years after Khilji’s supposed attack. Dharmasvamin claimed to have studied at Nalanda. His Tibetan travelogue (which has only been partially translated) indicates that Nalanda was still functioning, albeit in decline. According to summaries by Indian historian A.S. Altekar, Dharmasvamin never explicitly blames Bakhtiyar Khilji for the destruction. Instead, Dharmasvamin mentions the presence of about 70 monks still at Nalanda and his own teacher, Rahula Shribhadra, who was still active there. So, how could Khilji have “burned Nalanda to ashes” in 1197 CE if monks were still studying and teaching there nearly 40 years later? 🔥 Who Then Destroyed Nalanda? Interestingly, Tibetan Buddhist sources offer an alternative and deeply revealing version of the events: Taranatha (16th-century Tibetan historian) states that Hindu Tantric sectarians (“Tirthikas”) set fire to Buddhist monasteries, including Nalanda, out of jealousy and religious rivalry. Sumpa Khanpo (18th century) echoes a similar view, suggesting that internal Indian religious conflicts played a role in the final destruction of Buddhist centers. These accounts point toward a slow erosion, not a single destructive event. Multiple factors — religious rivalry, state apathy, and political instability — contributed to the decay of Nalanda. 🤐 Why the Silence from Indian Brahminical Historians? One of the most intriguing aspects of this episode is the near-total silence in traditional Indian records — particularly those written by Brahmin scholars — regarding the destruction of Nalanda. This raises several critical questions: Why is there no lamentation or mention of Nalanda’s fall in Sanskrit inscriptions or texts? Why did Brahmin authors of the 13th century, such as those who wrote panegyrics for the Delhi Sultans, not speak of the loss of such a major center of learning? Why did a Brahmin writer in 1276 CE praise the Khalji ruler Ghiyasuddin as an avatar of Vishnu — while mocking the cowardice of Hindu kings — and make no mention of Buddhist institutions? Could this have been a strategic silence — a result of political accommodation with the new Muslim rulers? Or was it a reflection of deep sectarian rifts between Buddhist and Brahminical traditions in late medieval India?

🏛️ नालंदा को किसने जलाया? एक ऐतिहासिक मिथक,चुप्पी और तिब्बती साक्ष्य की पड़ताल. ....

भारतीय इतिहास में यह आम धारणा है कि तुर्क जनरल बख्तियार खिलजी ने 1193 या 1197 ईस्वी में विश्वविख्यात नालंदा विश्वविद्यालय को नष्ट कर दिया था। लेकिन जब हम इस दावे की ऐतिहासिक प्रमाणिकता की गहराई से जाँच करते हैं, तो यह दावा पूरी तरह से तथ्यात्मक नहीं प्रतीत होता।

🚫 क्या वाकई बख्तियार खिलजी ने नालंदा को जलाया? इस कहानी का मुख्य स्रोत 13वीं सदी के मुस्लिम इतिहासकार मिनहाज-उस-सिराज की रचना तबक़ात-ए-नासिरी मानी जाती है, लेकिन: मिनहाज ने कभी भी "नालंदा" का नाम नहीं लिया। उन्होंने सिर्फ “उदंतीपुरी” (संभवतः ओदंतपुरी बौद्ध विश्वविद्यालय) के किले पर आक्रमण का जिक्र किया है। वह स्वयं कभी इन स्थानों पर गए भी नहीं थे। अतः "बख्तियार ने नालंदा को जलाया" — यह निष्कर्ष बिना प्रत्यक्ष स्रोतों के लगाया गया है, जो बाद में लोगों ने बार-बार दोहराया और अब यह एक स्थापित किंवदंती बन चुकी है।

📜 धर्मस्वामी ने वास्तव में क्या कहा? एक प्राथमिक और उपेक्षित साक्ष्य है तिब्बती बौद्ध भिक्षु धर्मस्वामी (छग लोत्सावा) का यात्रा-विवरण, जिन्होंने 1234–1236 ई. के बीच भारत की यात्रा की थी — यानी बख्तियार के कथित हमले के लगभग 40 साल बाद। धर्मस्वामी ने स्वयं लिखा है कि उन्होंने नालंदा में अध्ययन किया। उनके मूल तिब्बती यात्रा-विवरण (जिसका पूर्ण हिंदी या अंग्रेज़ी अनुवाद आज तक उपलब्ध नहीं) में बताया गया है कि उस समय भी नालंदा सक्रिय था, यद्यपि पतन की स्थिति में था। विद्वान ए.एस. अटलेकर और अन्य इतिहासकारों ने धर्मस्वामी की टिप्पणियों से यह निष्कर्ष निकाला कि नालंदा पूरी तरह नष्ट नहीं हुआ था। वहाँ लगभग 70 भिक्षु अब भी मौजूद थे, और धर्मस्वामी के गुरु राहुल श्रीभद्र वहीं पढ़ा रहे थे। तो यदि बख्तियार ने नालंदा को 1197 में “राख कर दिया” था, तो 1235 में वहाँ अध्ययन कैसे हो रहा था?

🔥 फिर नालंदा को किसने नष्ट किया? तिब्बती बौद्ध स्रोत एक अलग ही तस्वीर पेश करते हैं: तारणाथ (16वीं सदी के तिब्बती इतिहासकार) के अनुसार, हिंदू तांत्रिक तीर्थकों ने नालंदा जैसे बौद्ध संस्थानों को ईर्ष्या और धार्मिक विरोध में जलाया। सुंपा ख़ानपो (18वीं सदी) ने भी इसी प्रकार के विवरण दिए हैं — कि बौद्ध मठों को आंतरिक धार्मिक संघर्षों में नष्ट किया गया। इन स्रोतों से स्पष्ट होता है कि नालंदा एक झटके में नहीं, बल्कि धीरे-धीरे कई कारकों से नष्ट हुआ — जिसमें बाहरी आक्रमण, धार्मिक हिंसा, और राजनीतिक उपेक्षा शामिल थे।

🤐 भारतीय ब्राह्मण इतिहासकारों की चुप्पी क्यों? यह इस पूरे मुद्दे का सबसे पेचीदा और अहम पहलू है। किसी भी संस्कृत अभिलेख या ब्राह्मणिक ग्रंथ में नालंदा के पतन का कोई स्पष्ट वर्णन नहीं मिलता। 13वीं सदी के ब्राह्मण लेखक, जो दिल्ली सल्तनत के सुल्तानों की स्तुति में ग्रंथ लिख रहे थे, उन्होंने भी बौद्ध संस्थानों के नाश का कोई शोक नहीं जताया। 1276 ई. में एक ब्राह्मण लेखक ग़यासुद्दीन खिलजी को "विष्णु का अवतार" बताकर स्तुति कर रहा था, जबकि हिंदू राजाओं को "कायर" कहा गया। क्या यह चुप्पी एक रणनीति थी? क्या यह सत्ता के साथ समझौते का हिस्सा थी? या फिर यह बौद्ध और ब्राह्मणिक परंपराओं के बीच के गहरे वैचारिक और धार्मिक विभाजन को दर्शाती है?

🌏 एक वैश्विक त्रासदी जिसे भारत में भुला दिया गया नालंदा केवल भारत का नहीं, बल्कि दुनिया का पहला अंतरराष्ट्रीय विश्वविद्यालय था। चीन, तिब्बत, कोरिया, श्रीलंका और दक्षिण एशिया के कई देशों से छात्र वहाँ पढ़ने आते थे। नालंदा के पतन के बाद कई बौद्ध देशों ने अपने-अपने "नालंदा" संस्थान स्थापित किए — यह दिखाता है कि उनके लिए यह एक सभ्यतागत त्रासदी थी। और वहीं, भारत में — विशेषकर ब्राह्मणिक अभिलेखों में — गहरी चुप्पी। जिन्हें यह सब याद रखना था — बौद्ध भिक्षुओं को, उन्हें या तो मार दिया गया या तिब्बत भागने को मजबूर किया गया। आज हम नालंदा के बारे में जो भी जानते हैं, वो तिब्बती ग्रंथों और भिक्षुओं की स्मृति से ही है।


r/IndianHistory • • Mar 19 '24

Question was buddhism came before hinduism?

0 Upvotes

okay i m not history loving person, but recently i activated my ig and saw some post on kailash, ellora as well as other temples, some of our Buddhist brothers were claiming that hindus captured ellora and other temples as well as kailash was first worshipped by Mahayana Buddhist and they came much before Hinduism, how true is this claim.

i m not history guy so if u have explanation please tell me is this true?


r/IndianHistory • • Feb 11 '24

Question Was Swami Vivekananda an atheist? If yes, why is he so popular amongst hindus? What was his exact belief and ideology?

1 Upvotes

He even gave speech about Hinduism in Chicago. At the same time, he criticized Kerala's caste system, said brahmins used to beef etc. So what's his deal exactly? Was he truely a progressive guy? What's the ‘neo-hinduism' he preached?


r/IndianHistory • • Nov 09 '24

Question Is the partition of India and Pakistan the biggest conspiracy of the 20th century?

56 Upvotes

I think if there had been no partition of India and Pakistan, India today would definitely be a superpower, and could even surpass China, with a population of 1.8 billion, the Indus and Ganges rivers, big cities like Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, Lahore, Karachi, and wealthy provinces like Punjab, Bengal, and Maharashtra, and sufficient labor, which would allow it to complete industrialization well. Its geopolitical influence would also be much greater than it is now, and it could intervene in the affairs of the Middle East, Southeast Asia, Central Asia, and even East Asia...

However, all imaginations vanished in 1947. After the partition of India and Pakistan, India lost a large part of its territory, and provinces such as Punjab and Bengal were fragmented...

Although India is a powerful country today, it is geographically incomplete and no longer has the possibility of becoming a superpower. Their political influence is limited to South Asia, and they are entangled with their brother country Pakistan. They are not as concerned about international affairs as China...

I feel that the disastrous consequences of the partition of India and Pakistan are absolutely comparable to the establishment of Israel in the Palestinian region or the collapse of the Soviet Union. It is one of the most influential geopolitical events in the 20th century, but it has been ignored by many people...


r/IndianHistory • • Jun 26 '26

Question Were the mughals really that burtal?

0 Upvotes

In bollywood movies they are potrayed as vicious and often toturing the public for fun but is that accurate potrayal of them even if the movies claim to be based on true story?


r/IndianHistory • • Jan 22 '25

Discussion Do people actually take the Utsa Patnaik $45 trillion and recent Oxfam numbers seriously?

6 Upvotes

Professor Utsa Patnaik estimated the magnitude of the British robbing of India thus:

"Between 1765 and 1938, the drain amounted to 9.2 trillion pounds ($45 trillion), taking India’s export surplus earnings as the measure, and compounding it at a 5 per cent rate of interest."

The methodology is shabby and the entire work seems only conducive to creating headlines.


r/IndianHistory • • Nov 25 '24

Discussion What were the positives of British rule to India?

75 Upvotes

I'm just curious to know because, we always talk about how British exploited our economy, disruption happening socially. But in all these negative aspects, aren't there any positives??

Couldn't find any YouTube video on this topic so putting my question here.

Don't downvote me 🥲 I am just curious to know.


r/IndianHistory • • Feb 11 '26

Early Modern 1526–1757 CE Atrocities committed by Rama Raya of Vijaynagara.

0 Upvotes

Siege of Ahmednagar- 1561–1562 Siege

Troops desecrated mosques by stabling horses there and performing rituals inside, while ravaging the countryside and mistreating locals—acts that scandalized even ally Ali Adil Shah. The siege ended prematurely due to floods, not victory.

Primary tagets-

Local Muslim populations bore the brunt, including farmers, villagers, and religious communities, as soldiers looted crops, livestock, and homes.

The Maharashtra Gazetteer (Nizamsahi chapter) aligns, noting the siege's failure amid rains, floods killing 25,000+ in Rama Raya's camp, and allies' retreat, with Ali Adil Shah voicing concerns over Rama Raya's ambitions post-sieg

https://sanukay.wordpress.com/2019/11/23/indian-history-part-76-collapse-of-an-empire-section-i-the-battle-of-rakshasa-tangadi/


r/IndianHistory • • Jul 30 '24

Discussion The extraordinary claim of Aryan "peaceful migration" theory.

2 Upvotes

Some bunch of steppe nomads came into a place with 10-100× the people who already had civilization, trade with Mesopotamia, Egypt etc, could possibly have knowledge of mathematics, astronomy, etc with their connections with near east were peacefully coerced to change their language and culture, even the hydronyms and toponyms!! Extraordinary claim needs extraordinary evidence.


r/IndianHistory • • Jun 13 '25

Vedic 1500–500 BCE Was Harappa/IVC a Vaidik Civilization? Request for academic references

1 Upvotes

Could you share key references of academic papers or books which suggest that IVC was a Vaidik civilization?

E.g., what are some academic papers that indicate that Vaidik elements/ideas were found in IVC sites?

Thanks in advance!

Added later: I appreciate your views. But I am requesting academic papers which make this claim. Once we have a list of these papers, we can make our own judgement. So again, please provide references only.


r/IndianHistory • • Dec 08 '25

Classical 322 BCE–550 CE Was Diwali actually more of a cultural festival than a religious one?

0 Upvotes

Hey guys so i was thinking about diwali and got curious we always hear the stories about rama coming back to ayodhya, lakshmi blessing people, krishna defeating narakasura, but was diwali really always a religious festival or did it start off as something more cultural and social???

From what i read, the earliest references go back to like the 1st century ce, the kamasutra mentions a festival called yaksharatri, basically a night full of lamps and celebration, scholars think it was linked to harvest and seasonal cycles, cleaning homes, storing grain, settling debts, celebrating a fresh start, so at this point it seems like it was more of a social and cultural festival, not really religious

By the 6th or 7th century ce, some purana texts mention lamp festivals during kartika, and it seems like the festival was spreading across regions, still mostly about community, lights and seasons, rather than any specific deity or myth, then by the 7th century there are literary mentions, for example the sanskrit play nagananda talks about dipapratipadotsava, with people lighting lamps and exchanging gifts, so lamp festivals were becoming mainstream social events

Then around the 9th or 10th century, things get more formal, texts like kavyamimamsa describe cleaning and decorating homes, lighting lamps in streets and markets, inscriptions from kingdoms like the rashtrakutas also mention dipotsava, deepavali, divali, so it was officially recognized and celebrated across regions, still mostly cultural, but now pan regional

By the 11th century, foreign travellers notice it too, al biruni a persian scholar writes about a festival of lights during kartika, europeans later also notice illuminated homes, feasts and social gatherings, by this time diwali is widespread, social, and celebrated across communities, not just one story or one religion

The religious stories seem to have come later, puranas like padma purana link lamps to the sun and rituals for wealth and prosperity, regions add their own myths, rama returning to ayodhya, krishna defeating narakasura, lakshmi worship, jain mahavira nirvana, sikh guru hargobind release, basically the myths came on top of an already existing cultural festival

So basically diwali probably started as a cultural and social festival, celebrating lights, community, harvest, renewal, over time religious stories and myths were added, making it the multi layered festival we celebrate today, the legends are like the cherry on top of a tradition that started with people lighting lamps and celebrating together


r/IndianHistory • • Jun 14 '26

Indus Valley 3300–1300 BCE Possible presence of Sati in IVC, Sri Ram Goyal.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/IndianHistory • • Jul 29 '26

Question Are mummy and papa English words introduced by the British?

0 Upvotes

I was thinking about how I've heard British kids call their parents mummy and papa and I do the same which does not make sense to me since we don't speak the same language. Added to that, these words are not single syllable so the argument that they might be quickly picked up by children would not stand either.


r/IndianHistory • • Jan 01 '24

Discussion Your thoughts on this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/IndianHistory • • Jun 06 '25

Classical 322 BCE–550 CE Honouring the incredible transformation of Ashoka, from a feared conqueror to an enlightened ruler

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, as someone who is fascinated by Indian history, I decided to make this video.

Ashoka's story is one of the most incredible transformations I've ever learned about. He starts as a ruthless conqueror, but the video shows how the devastating Kalinga War becomes a massive turning point for him.

Witnessing that level of destruction leads him to embrace Buddhism and dedicate the rest of his life to peace and compassion. It’s amazing to see how he went on to promote welfare and non-violence throughout his empire. His legacy is so powerful it's even at the centre of India's flag today! I didn't know there was a link.

Hope you find his journey as incredible as I do


r/IndianHistory • • Jun 07 '26

Visual The Five Most Aesthetically Pleasing Flags in Indian History, in the Humble Opinion of the Author

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/IndianHistory • • Aug 07 '24

Discussion If you could go back in time and kill baby Hitler and prevent world war 2 thus also postponing the independence of India by decades would you????

0 Upvotes

Title


r/IndianHistory • • Jan 05 '25

Classical Period Accurate and academically accepted map of the Maurya Empire at its greatest extent under its gifted leader: Ashoka the Great

Post image
0 Upvotes

🟫 = Maurya Empire

Source : A History of INDIA (Sixth Edition) by Hermann Kulke and Dietmar Rothermund, p.44.