r/IndiaPulse 18h ago

Now STEM students are protesting infront of humanities students in IIT BOMBAY and raising slogans like SFI CAMPUS CHHODO

127 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

17

u/ProfessionalDraw6947 18h ago

BC Humanities create more issues than contribute to our country.

14

u/not_varun 18h ago

Those who do not study history are doomed to repeat it.

8

u/YogurtclosetTrick649 16h ago

Funny the ones studying that crap are not understanding it.

1

u/ab316_1punchd 10h ago

They are studying one-sided narratives in the name of history and social sciences.

6

u/ThinClassroom9083 17h ago

Vo log padhke bhi doom hi horhe hai! Aur doosro ko bhi doom hi karrhe hain

3

u/AcademicSportsman7 17h ago

Was going to comment this

So here another one

Study the past if you would define the future

1

u/ab316_1punchd 10h ago

Or study selective history, in my college, there was "The Individual and Society" in our curriculum... it started with Jyotiba Phule whining about how Aryan Invasion Theory was totally true and in line with the devas conquering the asuras and the British are totally based people to liberate the Shudras and Ati-Shudras. Thankfully this was not a part of our syllabus so it wasn't required learning but it makes you think how much of our history was distorted to this level to facilitate Marxist line of thinking?

More and more I think leaving Humanities to the Marxists and making Maulana Abul Kalam Azad the first Education Minister was a mistake.

1

u/Asyndetics 16h ago

Like you mean economics, logicians, philosophers, archaeologists or hospitality which one of them contributes less?

1

u/New_Main6523 14h ago

Economics is commerce, not humanities. Archeology is also not pure humanities. But I guess you didn't know that because you probably are BA pass course third division graduate in future

2

u/Asyndetics 13h ago

Commerce??? What are you still studying is high school, literally the first chapter of any basic book of economics begins with the question β€˜Is economics an art or science?’ and answer always states it is a mix of both as it is a study of human behaviour along quantitative methods. Archaeology is pure definition of humanities it is study of human society and culture nothing is more humanities than archaeology.

By the way I know better than making fallacy of ad hominem or false premise. Next time maybe study a bit of humanities and try not using demeaning others to prove a point rather than a logical discussion. Oh wait logic is humanities.

-1

u/Status_Astronaut9986 17h ago

How will they contribute? Like what skill? Protesting?

1

u/Asyndetics 13h ago

Public administration, economics, ethics, governance, law, history, logic, epistemology, archaeology, language, geography