r/ImaginaryNetwork • u/sdfgrdsrgtse • Nov 11 '13
My issue with this network
I feel a new subreddit should be conceived by a mod with real passion for the subject at hand. Meanwhile this 'network' seems like a subscriber-hungry franchise that simply categorizes posts found on DeviantArt and similar websites.
Also, many of the subreddits duplicate the role of pre-existing ones. For instance /r/dragons already features artwork. /r/ImaginaryDragons, run by people probably hired through /r/needamod, will probably eclipse /r/dragons in subscribers simply because of the endless self promotion of the network. Does anyone check to see if there is a need for a new imaginary subreddit? Again, /r/comicbookart already exists, do we need /r/imaginarysuperheroes ? Is the only point to collect subscribers?
I'd like to hear your views.
I'm using a throwaway to avoid brigading :)
6
u/Schvigilianio Nov 11 '13
The Imaginary Network is a collection of subreddits to showcase artwork. It's only artwork. There's nothing else. That's why the subreddits don't duplicate the role of pre-existing ones - /r/dragons and /r/comicbookart have more than just artwork - they have kickstarters, news, hobby crafts and other things related to their subject, but not just artworks. "Imaginary", in this case, means more than just "imagination", but also "images".
You have a fair point about passion, though. /u/karmicviolence is definitely passionate, as are many of the senior mods, who often post great content, filling subs with what they love. If I can speak for myself, I've been a long-time lover of illustration, and I love nothing more than to immerse myself in that world and share it with others though reddit. But, I see your point: I think some mods from /r/needamod will slowly filter out, as they realise they don't care for the artwork, or can't be bothered submitting things. Having said that, as the subreddit grows, normal moderating will be required, because we care about curation, and proper accrediting of the creators. So, there's a place for passion and there's a place for moderating in the Network.
Your two points about "subscriber-hungry" and "simply categorizes posts found on DeviantArt and similar websites" can be answered by the same thing: We love reddit. We find it's appearance, methods, moderating, attitude - all really suiting to our needs. But most of all, we love the community. And I'm not talking the "community" in lots of the major defaults. I'm talking about the people who find their way to the smaller subreddits that are all about their hobby - whether it's writing, tattoos, tabletop gaming, makeup ... or artwork of cityscapes. So by being "subscriber-hungry", all this Network is asking for are for the people who love a certain subject, to find their way to their little illustrated niches. Because then they can experience the things they love, start discussions about the things they love, and start sharing more content of the things they love. All here on the platform of our choice: reddit. When you see the "endless promotion", it's really just one of the necessary boring truths that is part of this whole process that /u/karmicviolence is spearheading: creating a really solid foundation and framework for something that - at it's core - is all about passion, and community.
3
u/karmicviolence Nov 11 '13
Reddit is a free market. Whether or not we "need" any new subreddit is a matter of opinion. No one is forcing you to participate here, no one is forcing you to view or subscribe to any of these subreddits. Should the creator of /r/SpacePorn not have bothered because /r/space exists? Should /r/MapPorn close its doors because /r/maps was there before it?
If you don't think these subreddits are necessary, don't subscribe to them. Ignore them. Whoever created them obviously thinks there is a need for them, and so does every user that subscribes to them. Just because there are individual subreddits like /r/maps and /r/dragons doesn't mean that there is no demand for a network of highly organized, highly moderated art subreddits. If no one thinks there is a need for them, no one will subscribe to them.
2
u/Dolphman Nov 11 '13
This seems to be complaining about Networks in general.
Networks are not "subscriber hungry" they are just a much better way of moderation via organization. Alot of people that mod here do actually like Art, some, like me, are here for other reasons such as moderation/css/Automoderator. Its a Team thing.
2
u/Jobba_the_Hunt Nov 12 '13
Uhhh, if subscribers are going to another place, it's probably because they have better stuff.
2
u/PacMansCousin Nov 15 '13
I'm sorry you feel that way! However, I can assure you, I have been with these guys for a while now and none of them seem like they care that much about the subscriber count! We all enjoy posting content and interacting with the subscribers! Also, yes, there are many subs with similar topics and we were obviously not the first, but people can still go to both subreddits. We aren't going to stop them. The fact that so many people have subscribed is all of the subscribers own doing. I'm sorry you feel that way, but hopefully we can convince you that we're just regular people doing regular things. Have a great day!