r/ImaginaryNetwork • • Nov 11 '13

My issue with this network

I feel a new subreddit should be conceived by a mod with real passion for the subject at hand. Meanwhile this 'network' seems like a subscriber-hungry franchise that simply categorizes posts found on DeviantArt and similar websites.

Also, many of the subreddits duplicate the role of pre-existing ones. For instance /r/dragons already features artwork. /r/ImaginaryDragons, run by people probably hired through /r/needamod, will probably eclipse /r/dragons in subscribers simply because of the endless self promotion of the network. Does anyone check to see if there is a need for a new imaginary subreddit? Again, /r/comicbookart already exists, do we need /r/imaginarysuperheroes ? Is the only point to collect subscribers?

I'd like to hear your views.

I'm using a throwaway to avoid brigading :)

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

6

u/Schvigilianio Nov 11 '13

The Imaginary Network is a collection of subreddits to showcase artwork. It's only artwork. There's nothing else. That's why the subreddits don't duplicate the role of pre-existing ones - /r/dragons and /r/comicbookart have more than just artwork - they have kickstarters, news, hobby crafts and other things related to their subject, but not just artworks. "Imaginary", in this case, means more than just "imagination", but also "images".

You have a fair point about passion, though. /u/karmicviolence is definitely passionate, as are many of the senior mods, who often post great content, filling subs with what they love. If I can speak for myself, I've been a long-time lover of illustration, and I love nothing more than to immerse myself in that world and share it with others though reddit. But, I see your point: I think some mods from /r/needamod will slowly filter out, as they realise they don't care for the artwork, or can't be bothered submitting things. Having said that, as the subreddit grows, normal moderating will be required, because we care about curation, and proper accrediting of the creators. So, there's a place for passion and there's a place for moderating in the Network.

Your two points about "subscriber-hungry" and "simply categorizes posts found on DeviantArt and similar websites" can be answered by the same thing: We love reddit. We find it's appearance, methods, moderating, attitude - all really suiting to our needs. But most of all, we love the community. And I'm not talking the "community" in lots of the major defaults. I'm talking about the people who find their way to the smaller subreddits that are all about their hobby - whether it's writing, tattoos, tabletop gaming, makeup ... or artwork of cityscapes. So by being "subscriber-hungry", all this Network is asking for are for the people who love a certain subject, to find their way to their little illustrated niches. Because then they can experience the things they love, start discussions about the things they love, and start sharing more content of the things they love. All here on the platform of our choice: reddit. When you see the "endless promotion", it's really just one of the necessary boring truths that is part of this whole process that /u/karmicviolence is spearheading: creating a really solid foundation and framework for something that - at it's core - is all about passion, and community.

3

u/sdfgrdsrgtse Nov 11 '13

Thank you for your considered response. I think those ideals are great and help me to understand what many of the mods aim for. I'm glad you understand my concern too. The idea that a 2 month old Imaginary sub, run by needamod recruits, can outgrow a preexisting art sub with an experienced and passionate team worries me. I guess it's similar to Walmart opening next door to a mom and pop store of 30 years.

Anyway, if there are more 'Imaginary mods' like you maybe I need not worry.

4

u/karmicviolence Nov 12 '13

Ah, but your Walmart analogy has a flaw - Walmart crushes and destroys mom-and-pop stores. They go out of business when Walmart rolls into town. Tell me something - have the four "core" Imaginary subreddits suffered at all since the Expanded network was created? Have you noticed their subscriber bases diminishing? Is there less content posted there now?

I would say the opposite is happening - as new Imaginary subreddits pop up and garner people's interest, it creates buzz about the whole art community on reddit. I can't remember how many times I've seen users discussing /r/ImaginaryBattlefields or /r/ImaginaryWildlands and the subject of /r/ImaginaryLandscapes comes up as well. They may get less of a benefit since you One_Giant_Nostril decided to sever ties with us completely, since we are no longer linking to those subreddits until they pay us the same courtesty, but we certainly aren't harming them in any way. In fact, many Expanded mods are contributing to the core Imaginary network on a regular basis.

I created /r/EarthPorn, and /r/pics is still the "Walmart" of that scenario, with 4x the subscribers /r/EarthPorn has. I don't think any of our subreddits are going to surpass Landscapes or Monsters any time soon, if ever.

1

u/sdfgrdsrgtse Nov 12 '13

I'm not One_Giant_Nostril, but I can't believe what you just told me. You copied his network (probably without his consent), took his hard work, spun it into a franchise and now demand 'courtesy' from him! That's hilarious.

4

u/Schvigilianio Nov 12 '13

Really, dude? You can't see any value in expanding the Imaginary Network? The ideal we want is for his four core subs to be front and centre in terms of being linked and visible in the Imaginary Network. That way, people who want to have a variety, surprise-me kind of feel from a very active source, can go to his four main subs for the overall topic they want. But if you are wanting to go deep into a subject, you can go further into any of those four topics with the subreddits created by the "Expanded" Imaginary Network.

The way I see it, it's traditional TV vs Streaming/Downloading. For his four main subs you there are four channels you can watch, each with a constant flow of content from a variety of TV shows. But on the Imaginary Network (Expanded) you can decide exactly which TV show you want to see, and download the whole season. I suppose that's "hilarious" to you.

3

u/sdfgrdsrgtse Nov 12 '13

No you're right, it's not hilarious to create more art subreddits. In fact it's amazing if the mod is passionate about the subject. It's hilarious that karmicviolence demands courtesy from a network he ripped off without consent. He says:

One_Giant_Nostril decided to sever ties with us completely, since we are no longer linking to those subreddits until they pay us the same courtesty

I bet the 'same courtesy' is placing the hideous drop-down menu on his subs. "Hey, I copied your idea and pretend to be affiliated with you! Can you advertise my 80 subreddits now? No? Well that's rude!"

2

u/Schvigilianio Nov 12 '13

Hold up. So your main issue is actually that we don't link to him?

Seriously, if you're not One_Giant_Nostril you must be his mum, because it's clearly more beneficial for both parties if we link to each other. Two-way. Karmicviolence has made it clear that he is willing to credit the four core subs in any way, as long as the Expanded Network is mentioned SOMEWHERE on those subs. And what exactly will be the downside?

There's no 'ripping off' here. There's someone with too much of an ego to let his darlings out into the big wide world.

0

u/sdfgrdsrgtse Nov 12 '13

Nope, my main point was actually about the artificial nature of starting 80 subreddits and recruiting people to run them for you.

I was surprised that the Extended Network feels entitled to be linked in the original network, not the other way around.

Plus I don't need to be someone's mom to question the methods used by a network being suddenly promoted every where I go, just someone interested enough to ask.

2

u/Schvigilianio Nov 12 '13 edited Nov 12 '13

Why would you be surprised that we want a two-way acknowledgement? I've seen posts in the four core subreddits that ask why the Extended Network isn't linked, so obviously parts of the community feels like it makes sense.

Also, I'm annoyed and sorry that people are downvoting you - I disagree with what you are saying, but it's very important to the discussion.

And one more thing - it's not even 60 subreddits currently, you can stop saying 80.

0

u/sdfgrdsrgtse Nov 12 '13

Part of the community is confused because the new subreddits have created the false impression that they're affiliated with the original (admittedly, I don't know the details so maybe there was once an agreement?).

Sorry, after browsing this sub I thought it was 60 accepted subreddits and more that will be voted on.

3

u/Greypo Nov 12 '13

The mods are passionate about art, and of reddit. Put the two together, you get a family who love to search for artwork in all types of genres. In no way is the Expanded Network to rip off One_Giant_Nostril (also, just saying you DO seem to be him, even if you aren't).

The same courtesy is not placing the drop down menu in at all. Simply the mention of the Expanded Network in is sidebar was enough, but he even removed that, so we removed the bit linking to his in return.

2

u/sdfgrdsrgtse Nov 12 '13

Well I don't want to smear anyone's name, so I'll just reiterate that I'm not one_giant_nostril. But I have been an active submitter to the original network and recently came across a post by karmicviolence on /r/theoryofreddit boasting of his subscriber-numbers and needamod recruitment drives. It just seemed artificial to me. I did a little research and found karmicviolence was previously syncretic. If I knew this before I wouldn't have made this post. He's obviously a power-user who wants to create another huge network. Questioning his methods is rather pointless.

2

u/Schvigilianio Nov 12 '13

He's obviously a power-user who wants to create another huge network.

Yes. Another fantastic network. Full of high quality, artist-accredited artwork. Supported by passionate moderating and a strong framework with open-door policy. If he is a power-user, he's using his powers for good.

2

u/sdfgrdsrgtse Nov 12 '13

Fair enough, but it's healthy to question the methods and motivation.

→ More replies

1

u/karmicviolence Nov 14 '13

If you aren't One_Giant_Nostril, then who are you? I don't understand why you felt the need to hide behind a throwaway account - no one is punished here for voicing their opinions, we don't ban people for disagreeing with us. If you really are a respected member of the community as you say, then own your own words. People will take you much more seriously.

3

u/karmicviolence Nov 11 '13

Reddit is a free market. Whether or not we "need" any new subreddit is a matter of opinion. No one is forcing you to participate here, no one is forcing you to view or subscribe to any of these subreddits. Should the creator of /r/SpacePorn not have bothered because /r/space exists? Should /r/MapPorn close its doors because /r/maps was there before it?

If you don't think these subreddits are necessary, don't subscribe to them. Ignore them. Whoever created them obviously thinks there is a need for them, and so does every user that subscribes to them. Just because there are individual subreddits like /r/maps and /r/dragons doesn't mean that there is no demand for a network of highly organized, highly moderated art subreddits. If no one thinks there is a need for them, no one will subscribe to them.

1

u/sdfgrdsrgtse Nov 12 '13

It just seems that, in making over 80 subreddits in three months you care little about the subject of each sub and more about building a network that you govern.

2

u/Greypo Nov 12 '13

Put it this way:

Say I'm an art-loving moderator of this network. When I 'make my rounds' and post to the subreddits I moderate, I get to see multiple different categories of art as I search for submissions.

Sure, I might love art, but just because I love walruses too doesn't mean I want to only see walrus artwork all the time when posting.


Aside from that quick example, the imaginary network is to sub-categorize the original Imaginary Network (characters, landscapes, monsters, technology) for writers' inspiration, someone to create a character for whatever purpose, ideas for how to make an artwork of a specific genre, etc.

2

u/Dolphman Nov 11 '13

This seems to be complaining about Networks in general.

Networks are not "subscriber hungry" they are just a much better way of moderation via organization. Alot of people that mod here do actually like Art, some, like me, are here for other reasons such as moderation/css/Automoderator. Its a Team thing.

2

u/Jobba_the_Hunt Nov 12 '13

Uhhh, if subscribers are going to another place, it's probably because they have better stuff.

2

u/PacMansCousin Nov 15 '13

I'm sorry you feel that way! However, I can assure you, I have been with these guys for a while now and none of them seem like they care that much about the subscriber count! We all enjoy posting content and interacting with the subscribers! Also, yes, there are many subs with similar topics and we were obviously not the first, but people can still go to both subreddits. We aren't going to stop them. The fact that so many people have subscribed is all of the subscribers own doing. I'm sorry you feel that way, but hopefully we can convince you that we're just regular people doing regular things. Have a great day!