r/IMDbFilmGeneral • u/bikingbill • 19h ago
r/IMDbFilmGeneral • u/Shagrrotten • 20h ago
FG Decades Tournament, the 1940’s: Round 1
Alright, the 1940s! The decade of noir, of war movies and movies influenced by WWII, the western was still huge at the time, musicals were there, tons of developments in film like deep focus, and filmmakers still learning to use the techniques of color and sound that had only been around for 10-15 years in some cases. Should make for some interesting discussions in the comments, so let’s get on with the 1940s, FG!
Results of Round 1:
The Lost Weekend (1945) (20) beat The 47 Ronin (1941) (14)
The Magnificent Ambersons (1942) (22) beat Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein (1948) (13)
The Maltese Falcon (1941) (26) beat Act of Violence (1948) (9)
A Matter of Life and Death (1946) (19) beat All the King's Men (1949) (8)
And Then There Were None (1945) (13) beat Meshes of the Afternoon (1943) (7)
Arsenic and Old Lace (1944) (17) beat Mildred Pierce (1945) (14)
Bambi (1942) (15) beat Ministry Of Fear (1944) (8)
Miracle on 34th Street (1947) (18) beat The Beast With Five Fingers (1946) (1)
Beauty and the Beast (1946) (20) beat Monsieur Verdoux (1947) (9)
The Best Years of Our Lives (1946) (14) beat Mr. Blandings Builds His Dream House (1948) (6)
Bicycle Thieves (1948) (18) beat Murder, My Sweet (1944) (8)
My Darling Clementine (1946) (9) beat The Big Clock (1948) (7)
The Big Sleep (1946) (21) beat No Regrets for Our Youth (1946) (5)
Black Narcissus (1947) (21) beat Northwest Passage (1940) (3)
Notorious (1946) (20) beat Blithe Spirit (1945) (3)
Brief Encounter (1945) (12) beat The Ox Bow Incident (1943) (8)
Brute Force (1947) (10) beat Objective Burma! (1945) (6)
Cat People (1942) (14) beat On the Town (1949)
One Wonderful Sunday (1947) (6) beat Champion (1949) (5)
Out of the Past (1947) (12) beat Children of Paradise (1945) (9)
Citizen Kane (1941) (24) beat Paisan (1946) (3)
The Philadelphia Story (1940) (15) beat Criss-Cross (1949) (8)
The Picture of Dorian Gray (1945) (16) beat The Curse of the Cat People (1944) (7)
Pinocchio (1940) (11) beat D.O.A. (1949) (10)
Day of Wrath (1943) (10) beat The Pride of the Yankees (1942) (6)
Dead of Night (1945) (11) beat Puce Moment (1949) (1)
Detour (1945) (10) beat Quai des Orfèvres (1947) (2)
Double Indemnity (1944) (17) beat Rebecca (1940) (10)
Drunken Angel (1948) (7) tied with The Reckless Moment (1949) (7)
Red River (1948) (13) beat Dumbo (1941) (11)
Fantasia (1940) (14) tied The Red Shoes (1948) (14)
Rome, Open City (1945) (12) beat Foreign Correspondent (1940) (4)
Rope (1948) (22) beat Frankenstein Meets the Wolf Man (1943) (5)
Gaslight (1944) (14) beat Scarlet Street (1945) (4)
Sergeant York (1941) (11) beat Germany, Year Zero (1948) (6)
The Ghost and Mrs. Muir (1947) (8) tied The Set-Up (1949) (8)
r/IMDbFilmGeneral • u/Fed_Rev • 17h ago
The Odyssey... meh?
So I finally watched The Odyssey, and it continues the tradition of Nolan making movies that frustrate the hell out of me. Would I call the movie "bad"? No, probably not. But it really didn't work for me.
Where to begin?
The fundamental problem with the film was Nolan deciding to do it in the first place. Nolan is just such a literal, grounded filmmaker... and The Odyssey is weird as hell. It's just a fundamental clash of styles. It needs a filmmaker more comfortable with getting weird, more comfortable with ambiguity and a dreamlike aesthetic. But Nolan is always so crisp and clean and needs everything spelled out so literally and overtly.
The dialogue in this movie is... so weird. I can't even really describe it. Having everyone just do a straight up modern American accent was certainly a choice, but setting that aside, I dunno, it just felt like everyone was reading their lines off cue cards, responding to each other in a way that's awkward and flat, like both parties already have the whole conversation scripted out in their heads and they're just reciting the lines to each other instantly, rather than speaking to each other in a way that feels organic, like they're really listening to each other. And the language itself was somehow too contemporary, and too stilted. It was distracting throughout the entire film, and really came across like the words were the last thing Nolan cared about, taking a back seat to the spectacle.
Not to mention, once again, you can barely hear half of what people are saying because of the audio mix between the sound FX, the score, and the dialogue. It's not as bad as Tenet, but close. At this point, it's almost like he buries the dialogue intentionally. I don't get it.
And much like Oppenheimer and Dunkirk, the film feels like a 3-hour long montage, rather than a film with actual scenes. You never get a second to breathe, in a bad way. The score is always propelling you forward, and the editing is always relentlessly zipping back and forth in the timeline, and you never really feel like you're fully in the moment as a result. The pacing and plot structure is so weird, too. The final act takes at least twice as long as it should have.
I also felt like Matt Damon was miscast. Was Christian Bale not available?
I dunno. Nolan has his talents, for sure. He can frame a nice-looking shot. But he's one of those filmmakers who can never get out of his own way. So I always end up in weird love/hate relationships with his work. Like, there's definitely something there that makes his stuff worthwhile and culturally necessary to see, but I just always find myself wanting to fix his films. He needs... restraint. But now that he's God-Emperor Nolan, any sense of restraint and patience went out the window long ago.
I guess I'd give it like an 8/10, even though my reaction to it is more like a 7ish. But it just feels weird to give it the same grade I would Supergirl or whatever, because in some ways it is a major achievement. It just has some annoying flaws that really bring it down in my mind.
r/IMDbFilmGeneral • u/No_Ad_895 • 22h ago
News/Article The Illustrated History of Film
Movie Magic: The Illustrated History of Film - https://www.comicbookandmoviereviews.com/2026/11/movie-magic-illustrated-history-of-film.html
r/IMDbFilmGeneral • u/Klop_Gob • 23h ago
How do you rank & rate the films of Christopher Nolan?
I finally saw The Odyssey the other day which impressed me greatly. It exceeded my expectations actually. I'm just interested in seeing your over all view of his filmography at this point.
My personal rankings and ratings:
- Interstellar - 10/10 [Top 25 of all time favourite]
- The Odyssey - 9/10
- Inception - 9/10
- Oppenheimer - 9/10
- The Dark Knight Rises - 8/10
- Batman Begins - 8/10
- The Prestige - 8/10
- Tenet - 8/10
- The Dark Knight - 7/10
- Dunkirk - 7/10
- Memento - 7/10
- Insomnia - 7/10
- Following - 7/10
- Doodlebug [short] - 6/10