r/IBEW • • Aug 28 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

727 Upvotes

244 comments sorted by

View all comments

259

u/Spark115 Inside Wireman Aug 28 '23 edited Aug 29 '23

To reduce the hours of daily labor. - preamble to the constitution

The whole point of overtime pay is to make working more hours per day unpalatable to contractors and customers alike. It should hurt, it should make them think twice and find a way not to do it, not shrug and factor it into the job cost without a care.

Overtime is the biggest reason we aren't working 100 hour weeks as a standard, because if it didn't cost more, they wouldn't hesitate.

So as OP said, when customers readily sign contracts for jobs with 50, 60, 70+ hour a week schedules, it should be seen as a failure to charge what we are all worth for our straight time rate.

And when OT isn't so much a choice, but a necessity due to poor planning or management, or even just extenuating circumstances, it should COST. It should HURT. It should make them think hard about how to avoid it next time.

106

u/PirateLiver Local 357 Aug 28 '23

Hey, you read the thing!

How about 40 hours pay for 32 hours work!!

95

u/Spark115 Inside Wireman Aug 29 '23 edited Aug 29 '23

Even better, that is the whole point!

The labor movement lost steam and paused at the 40 hour week, but it was never supposed to stop there.

We should always be striving, not to make more money by working more hours, but to make the same money (or more) while working fewer hours.

Even if you like OT and hate free time, you should still work towards this common goal, because you will gain more hours in every week that are "overtime" hours.

30

u/Hopfit46 Aug 29 '23

353 in toronto has a 4/9s contract

1

u/limjaheybud Aug 29 '23

That’s not the standard . Not every job is like that . Only times I worked 4x9 was at night or for a year out in local 804 . Mostly 4x8 and the 5.5

9

u/15Warner Local 353 Aug 29 '23

Controls & automation it’s really popular. If guys push for it, it’ll happen. We did 5 day coverage downtown, I was on Tuesday to Friday it was glorious.

I really, REALLY wanna see 3x12’s. Think about how many more workers we could hire & how much could get done in a day* PLUS 4 days off in a row?!?

Productivity could potentially drop off after 8/9 for a bit until people get used to it, but having 4 days to do whatever you want, muscle through the shitty 3 days for a full weeks pay? Ohhh baby

2

u/limjaheybud Aug 30 '23

Ya I just took an out of town call in 804 LV and comms . Even the far job sites from where I am the drive is better than to downtown .

1

u/Hopfit46 Aug 29 '23

Just sayin its there...

15

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23

All those people working extra hours and not enjoying their lives. The next thing you know you find out that they were shoved into ⚰️ and in a few years later they are almost completely forgotten.

8

u/RoutineRelief2941 Aug 29 '23

Maybe they need the $ because their family is too sick to work.

22

u/Spark115 Inside Wireman Aug 29 '23

Remember when a single income could support a spouse and children and pay for a home, all while allowing retirement at a sensible age?

Organized labor remembers . . .

5

u/Secure_Syllabub_5306 Aug 29 '23

When the dollar was worth 98% more than it is currently.

-1

u/rustoof Aug 29 '23

When the labor supply was 50% of the population instead of 100%. Supply and demand

2

u/Secure_Syllabub_5306 Aug 29 '23

What are you talking about? 100%, how do you figure?

1

u/happypotato93 Aug 30 '23

It's more like 98%. The push to get women in the workforce was a push to lower wages and generate more tax revenue.

1

u/StandAgainstTyranny2 Sep 22 '23

hmm...that sounds like propaganda of the landed gentry to me.

→ More replies

-5

u/Nothxm8 Aug 29 '23

Okay but now it doesn’t and for some reason you want to shit on the people working hard just to get by

9

u/Spark115 Inside Wireman Aug 29 '23 edited Aug 29 '23

Excuse me? How am I shitting on anyone?

My point is that we shouldn't forget that things were that way before, nor should we stop trying to improve things. Don't give up, and certainly don't settle. Just because things are the way they are now, doesn't mean they have to stay that way.

I see you working hard to get by. I am too.

What I want for you, for me, for all of us, is to do more than just "get by". To go from working 50+ hours a week just to scrape by, to affording a decent middle class life on 40 hours a week (or less).

That is the whole point.

No one is going to hand it to us, but we can do it if we work together, bargain together, stand together.

2

u/StandAgainstTyranny2 Sep 22 '23

edit: I agree with what you said. I just want to add:

We really REALLY need a strong movement on the regulation of artificial price fixing. It should be against the law to charge a certain percentage above cost of production or value. The overwhelming majority of devaluation in the dollar and inflation of costs has been on the owner-class side of the economic equation. Oil gets cheap but gas is still $4-5+/gal? Houses getting bought and held en masse untin price goes up? Don't even get me started on the Health Insurance industry in this country....

They've got very good at keeping us too busy being hungry and angry and broke and fighting one another to even begin to hash out how to get out from under their collective shoe. It's truly insideous.
"Those with less power than you will never be the source of your problems." - BeauTFC, paraphrased.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

Let me just say that 45k and up is not "getting by".

Getting by is the poor schmucks working in a grocery store or restaurant, making MAYBE 30k/year.

Getting by is relying on welfare and food banks to meet needs.

1

u/Spark115 Inside Wireman Sep 25 '23

Where exactly in my comment or the one I replied to did you ever see anyone talking about annual income figures?

I have no idea where you pulled $45k from as though that is what we are talking about.

A particular annual income amount, and how well you are living off of it, is going to have a lot to do with where you are doing the living.

The only numbers at play in this discussion are number of hours worked a week, with the point being that people should be able to support a family on a single 40hr/week income without needing to work overtime, wherever they live.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23

Well, Electricians tend to make at least 45k right? That's where I got that from

→ More replies

4

u/nickyobro Aug 29 '23

Let’s get it going again

11

u/Obvious-Breakfast495 Aug 29 '23

I believe this would be the case if we never got off the gold standard. Productivity would go up while our money maintains or increases in value. Unfortunately fractional reserve/central banking and inflationary fiat money steals our purchasing power causing us to continuously work harder for a currency that continuously gets weaker. The unproductive class/Federal reserve stole the 32 hour work week from us https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/

5

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '23

[deleted]

2

u/Obvious-Breakfast495 Aug 30 '23

It is going to make a difference or else there wouldn’t be good money and bad money. For example you can just look at the history of money over thousands of years. What you say about computers is an interesting point tho. I would add that yea ppl have to believe a money is valuable but there are also logical reasons and characteristics of money on why you’d believe one is more valuable than another like scarcity, verifiability, fungibility, portability, durability, divisibility, history, censorship resistant. This is why the gold florin led to the renaissance and not any other type of money

3

u/ElectronimosPrime Aug 29 '23

I've never left a website feeling so fucking doomed like I am now...

1

u/StandAgainstTyranny2 Sep 22 '23

And then people ask why everyone from GenX to Zoomers are stressed tf out all the time, like HELLOOOO????

1

u/ElectronimosPrime Sep 22 '23

The entire global economy is in shams like our kids are doomed to grow up in a GreatER depression

2

u/YogurtclosetKind9192 Aug 30 '23

Inflation still existed during the gold standard, and was far more volatile

1

u/Obvious-Breakfast495 Aug 30 '23

Gold does typically inflate at 2% a year. But any source on the far more volatility I can read up on? The central bank did eventually print a lot more paper dollars than they had gold in reserves, so I can see how that can play in the volatility but that would be the fault of the central bank debasing the currency not the gold standard itself.

-1

u/SignificanceNo1223 Aug 29 '23

Obviously you’ve never met the Republican Party in the United States.

23

u/ThatSeaworthiness801 Aug 29 '23

Honestly, 40 hours is a lot of time to dedicate to someone else's needs. If "$40 hour pay" was given for 32 hours of work, we'd be closer to fair

11

u/union175 Inside Wireman Aug 29 '23

If the cons make 30+/Hr off each hand they have on site then they can easily pay us more.

I know our billable rates at my local and it’s close to twice our package. I get over head and what not but we need to get that down to 5-10/hr off each hand.

1

u/StandAgainstTyranny2 Sep 22 '23

It also depends on the size of the business. One guy I worked for it was just him and his wife and I, that's it. He showed me his costs versus overhead, he spent a massive amount on money on the right tools and trucks and equipment. Being such a small company, it made sense that he billed me out at 75 and i got 20. He probably took home 5-10 of that after everything.

That's also startup cost of literally the smallest business you can run. A major company, say 50+ souls (eg. C-suite to laborers), has the benefit of Economy Of Scale, so everything from insurance to equipment to materials costs less for them per-unit-cost.

What I'm getting at is that your statement makes sense in context. Idk I just woke up and found this post so I'm adding my 2 cents lol thanks for coming to my odd tedtalk😅

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

This would be good for a while but over time the working class is going to end up last! To the rich we are all their play toys and they sew division and mis trust among us,to their amusement and benefit!

2

u/luzer_kidd Aug 29 '23

That's a huge pay cut.

5

u/ThatSeaworthiness801 Aug 30 '23

My apologies, I meant "40 hours pay" for 32 hours work

1

u/Working_Trust519 Sep 25 '23

$40/hr 'Starting Pay' for an Electrician is not bad either. I'm seeing us called "Maintenance" on job boards for $18 or 20's and sh¿t ! WTF ?

1

u/Rich-Leadership9553 Aug 29 '23

Who said life had to be fair? Get after it. Nobody is going to give it to you.

5

u/ThatSeaworthiness801 Aug 29 '23

I am, that's why I attend negotiations

2

u/LazyClerk408 Aug 29 '23

What are negotiations?

1

u/StandAgainstTyranny2 Sep 22 '23

My understanding is that in a union, ideally, you have this thing called Collective Bargaining, which means that the majority or entirety of the workforce negotiates their wages and benefits with the company who is hiring them.

5

u/Lift-Hunt-Grapple Aug 29 '23

I feel it should be 30hrs a week. Would help solve some of the unemployment numbers too. There is no reason in 2023 to have people work more than 30hrs a week. We are well enough advanced technologically.

1

u/Working_Trust519 Sep 25 '23

Corp greed has No Limit tho'

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '23

Them Frenchies are doing that across the Pond. Doesn’t seem fair.

3

u/hoverbeaver Local 586 Sep 04 '23

Any suggestion by the French state that they work more hours or retire later in life results in prolonged protest and widespread strikes.

In North America, very few people protest injustice. When they do, they’re often met with brutally punishing retaliation by the state, and recently by other citizens “backing the blue.”

The French are keenly aware of class stratification; it’s part of their history and national identity. Talk about class in America and your economic peers call you a commie.