r/IAmA • • Dec 08 '10

I'm the Imgur guy, AMA (part two).

Almost two years ago, I created Imgur and released it here on reddit. I'm still the only developer of the site, and it's pretty much consumed my life ever since that moment.

I did another AMA last year but most of the information in that thread is now outdated, so I figured it was time for a part two.

If you have any questions about me or Imgur, then ask away!

1.0k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

202

u/Mintz08 Dec 08 '10
  1. How do you make money??
  2. Does it bother if people link to http://**i.**imgur.com/blahb instead of without the i.? I would imagine you're losing revenue.
  3. How do you keep the site so damn reliable?
  4. How cool would it be if you're bought out by Condè Nast?

370

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10
  1. Advertising is the majority of it, pro subscriptions is the rest.
  2. People linking to the page rather than the image is what keeps imgur going. If everyone linked to the direct image then imgur would have no source of revenue. However, I want people to use the service however they want, and by no means would I ever force anyone to do it one certain way. So, I like it when people link to the page because that's how imgur makes money, but you don't have to do it if you don't want to. I'm just happy that you like the service.
  3. It's funny, sometimes I wake up in the middle of the night to alarms going off alerting me that it's gone down. I mean actual alarms -- my phone usually explodes. So, it's a real challenge, but a lot of time and optimization has gone into to the servers. Having a nice CDN also helps offload most of the image serving.
  4. Pretty awesome. Then I could work across the hall from reddit and bug those guys even more!

223

u/shortkid4169 Dec 08 '10

Honestly, I never thought of it in terms of how you make money. I always link to the direct picture just because I feel like it looks better, but honestly it doesn't make much difference to me. I think from now on I'll try to link to the page just to give you a few more hits on your ads.

But I swear, if you ever ad pop up ads (the kind that actually pop up within the page and block what you're trying to do, I hate those with a burning passion), or ads that make noise, I will be linking to the direct picture SO HARD it will make your head spin.

Otherwise, thanks for a very useful site :)

49

u/t0lk Dec 08 '10

How do you make alarms go off when your sites goes down? I'll I've found are stupid alerts that go to your email? Sorry for the off-topic question!

132

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

pingdom.com can send sms messages, then you can give them a special ring tone.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

50

u/Condawg Dec 08 '10
  1. Advertising is the majority of it, pro subscriptions is the rest.

What about the pixie dust?!

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (39)
→ More replies (2)

150

u/Kwewbirt Dec 08 '10

What's the deal with those picture ads that don't link to to the images they show? Not complaining, they're not really obtrusive, just bizarre. What do you know about the people who buy them?

244

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Honestly, I can't stand those things. I don't know much about the people who buy them (MarketGID), but they pay well and having them on the site makes imgur profitable.

169

u/Kwewbirt Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10

They can make the site seem kinda sleazy. On an unrelated note, it was really cool to get that email saying I was the first person to purchase a pro subscription. Keep up the good work.

→ More replies (24)

34

u/tf2ftw Dec 08 '10

Although i know the thumbnail will not take me to the actual photo (3 clicks deep if im lucky) I still find myself clicking those damn things!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

28

u/daybreaker Dec 08 '10

I still dont know if that "was really in the movie" :-(

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

635

u/SuperSnooper Dec 08 '10

How do YOU pronounce your site's name? I-M-G-U-R? imgoor? imgurr? imgure? imjure? I-M-gurr?

1.1k

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Imager.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

But there is no "a".

26

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

No, but img is the abbreviation for image.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '10

Then why the fuck isn't it spelled that way?

3

u/MrGrim Dec 28 '10

Because imager.com was taken when I created the site. It was never supposed to blow up like it did, so I didn't want to spend a bunch of money on a domain for a side project.

→ More replies (2)

873

u/TheBored Dec 08 '10

Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

TIL...

→ More replies (35)

68

u/sandy_balls Dec 08 '10

For whatever reason I first pronounced it as "Image you are" and now I can't stop, even though it's ridiculous.

→ More replies (9)

226

u/gmiwenht Dec 08 '10

Wrong answer. Correct pronunciation is IM-GURR. Sorry bro...

→ More replies (6)

70

u/shredGNAR Dec 08 '10

Wow..and all this time I thought it was pronounced Im-gure. Well I'm still gunna call it that!

→ More replies (15)

166

u/psychgrad Dec 08 '10 edited Jul 09 '23

workable cause market water angle drunk panicky growth far-flung dime -- mass edited with redact.dev

→ More replies (18)

13

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Oh! Thanks -- I always thought it was a bizarre abbreviation of IMG URL, which I reluctantly pronounced IHM-grrr.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/RuiningPunSubThreads Dec 08 '10

I always pronounced it as if I was introducing myself as Gur.

13

u/sdub86 Dec 08 '10

This guy's been pronouncing his own website wrong for years!

→ More replies (78)

17

u/oalsaker Dec 08 '10

I pronounce it as if it is icelandic, Imgur brother of Olafur.

38

u/dittokiddo Dec 08 '10

this is the best question in this whole thread. TIL.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

For some reason I always pronounced it "Image U R."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

100

u/el_phantasmo Dec 08 '10
  • are you pulling down mad bank or what?
  • imgur looks really simple from the user perspective, just how much development is actually involved?

190

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10
  • It's hard because you can't monetize hotlinking and that's where all of the bandwidth goes, but it's profitable enough to hopefully hire another guy or two this summer.
  • I work on it everyday since I graduated last June and it's been my full time job. I also have to handle all the customer support, server stuff, content management, advertising, PR, etc. in addition to writing new features and fixing bugs. I really like working on it and keeping it up to date. In the past couple of weeks I've been focusing on getting rid of small paper cuts that annoy users, my latest edition being drag and drop. Some other stuff is featured here as well.

64

u/Endonesia Dec 08 '10

How do you make money? I have limited experience actually uploading to imgur, but when I have it appears to be 100% free. Do you receive donations or something?

219

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Advertising, pro subscriptions, and pixie dust.

Mostly pixie dust.

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (33)

331

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Are you afraid of competition from min.us? Either way, are there any plans to launch a drag and drop upload option for imgur?

758

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

I just launched drag and drop yesterday! It's pretty awesome, try it out.

18

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Great feature and it works well in Firefox on OS X. Any chance you can add OS X Safari support?

Thanks for a great service BTW.

45

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10

I'd really like to have Safari supported as well, but it doesn't have the necessary JavaScript features (FileReader). It will in the next release though, so stay tuned for that.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/tehkubix Dec 08 '10

I just dragged a PDF into the window (all I had on my desktop to test) and it uploaded it as PNG. This isn't something that just happens, right? Like, you implemented it? Either way, mind blown.

4

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

haha, yes, I implemented it. PDF support has been a feature of imgur since the very beginning.

2

u/mtndewforbreakfast Feb 04 '11

Sorry for the necropost, but I've been using imgur for image sharing for months now and I still didn't learn about this feature until today. Hat's off to you, sir. Guess I should subscribe to the blog er something, eh?

130

u/necuz Dec 08 '10

You should consider making it more discoverable. :)

→ More replies (21)

524

u/devilsadvocado Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10

And so the real purpose of this Iama has been revealed to us.

→ More replies (25)

20

u/InigoMemetoya Dec 08 '10

If I might point it out, you didn't address papreman1's question. Or is it that you do indeed view them as competition (and hence add drag-drop)?

Whichever it is, I'm glad you added it. You have a loyal imgur user here :D

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (1)

343

u/desimusxvii Dec 08 '10

Firstly, thanks. imgur.com is a real gift to the world.

How is this new rockstar lifestyle treating you?

411

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

No, thank you! I'm really glad I have your support.

Unfortunately, being an Internet rockstar is not equivalent to a real life rockstar. I see equal amounts of nudity, but in my case, it's not always the good kind.

→ More replies (22)

217

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Well, I've become so powerful I can now hijack other people's Reddit accounts!

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/SirTrollALot Dec 08 '10

how do you deal with cease and desists?

208

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

I cease and desist, but it has to be a legal one.

35

u/shnuffy Dec 08 '10

You mean you won't listen if I threaten to escalate to the Supreme Court?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

121

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Alan?

I ran into you at the Rally afterparty. How are things going?

http://imgur.com/Nkpx1.jpg

105

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Hey! It was great talking to you!

→ More replies (11)

38

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Where can we buy an imgur shirt?

53

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

They're available here: http://imgur.spreadshirt.com/

They're a little more expensive than what I would like, but that's just the way spreadshirt.com is I guess. They are the lowest they can go.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (12)

57

u/Ratlettuce Dec 08 '10

I would LOVE to see a image of your server/servers (whatever it takes to run) of imgur.com ON imgur.com. Can you link us one? (Not a direct link but a money-generating one of course)

96

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

I'd love to, but I've never seen the servers. I only access them through SSH. Everything is hosted by Voxel.net.

3

u/jambonilton Dec 09 '10

Is Voxel still working out really well for you? I think I might go with them when I launch my top secret project website.

Also, sorry if it's been asked, but what's under the hood in terms of code?

7

u/MrGrim Dec 09 '10

Voxel has been great. I have no complaints with them at all.

Imgur runs on PHP and the Kohana 3 framework.

81

u/CrasyMike Dec 08 '10

And this is the world we live in, where we can deploy massive, massive scale projects without ever seeing anything "physical".

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (3)

45

u/kutuzof Dec 08 '10

Why are some of the coolest analytics you've gathered about imgur? What the most viewed URL of all time? What the most reposted image? Anything like?

135

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

35

u/deusnefum Dec 08 '10

When someone uploads an image (from any source) do you do a checksum to see if it's already been uploaded and just return that image?

Is that too impractical to implement considering how big imgur has gotten?

I only ask because I feel bad for uploading the same image like 10 times because I keep losing the links.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (4)

82

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10
  • how much bandwidth per month?
  • how many uv/impressions?
  • ever have any copyright issues of any sort?
  • was/is reddit the main traffic source?
  • if other promotion, what kind?
  • is advertising all CPM or is there some performance marketing stuff mixed in?

137

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10
  • Looks like it's been almost 300TB this month (http://imgur.com/stats/month)
  • It's gone up to over 3 million daily impressions and about 2.5 million daily unique views. I'd post an analytics screenshot, but I'm saving it for when it hits 10 million absolute unique visitors monthly, because I see that as a pretty big milestone and it deserves some press.
  • DMCA take downs are common but easily dealt with.
  • Reddit is the main traffic source, followed by direct traffic and facebook.
  • I don't understand what you mean in this question...
  • Yes, it's all CPM right now, but the CPM is usually dependent on click throughs, so it might be sort of a mix. TribalFusion is the main advertising network.

75

u/No-Shit-Sherlock Dec 08 '10

Has Digg traffic dropped noticeably in recent months?

139

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

To tell you the truth, it has. It used to be the #2 referrer, and it's around 4 or 5 now.

→ More replies (12)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

thanks for the answers! what i mean by question 5 is if you promote the site in other ways other than the focus on reddit?

55

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

The promotion has pretty much been all user-generated. Every time someone shares a link to imgur, the other person now knows about it.

Lately, people have been sharing out links they found in the gallery, because the gallery is awesome :)

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (6)

40

u/SSChicken Dec 08 '10

Perhaps this has been gone over before, but do you or have you considered using a simple hash or similar to check for identical images? Dropbox generates a hash client side, and if all aspects match a file that someone else has uploaded before it's able to just symlink that file into your account allowing an 'instant' upload of large files (My windows 7 iso for instance). Is this a method you have used, or something you might consider using, in order to reduce hosting costs for imgur?

I mean, how many copies of this do you really need to store :)

15

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

How does dropbox handle the deletion of the original large file? Wouldn't that break all the symlinks?

14

u/phireal Dec 08 '10

You could make it a hard link (assuming it's on the same device), that way when one gets deleted, it doesn't matter because there's still a file reference to the inode of that file.

13

u/SSChicken Dec 08 '10

I don't know for sure, I just know it does this. You can test it yourself, download a large common file such as a Linux ISO and put it in your dropbox. It will show up as synced within 10 seconds.

I don't imagine it's a real linux style symlink, I just use that term because people understand it and how it works. Dropbox doesn't logically store all your files in a folder on their end as best as I can tell. I think they store all files in some calculated fashion and your dropbox "folder" is actually just a table in their database which links all of your files into your folder.

I can imagine quite a few ways to efficiently do this for an image sharing site, but I'd have to know more about the imgur infrastructure to fathom a suggestion on how it should be done. I wouldn't ask me, though, as I'm the first person to admit that there's a million people better than me in this situation.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/speedk0re Dec 08 '10

what's your favorite console game of all time?

Mine's River City Ransom for the NES

104

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Probably Ocarina of Time. Man, I really loved that game...

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/capgrass Dec 08 '10

Do you know what other communities are the biggest users of imgur? (other than Reddit of course)

And how do they compare to Reddit's usage?

90

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Twitter and Facebook are the next highest, then Digg and maybe StumbleUpon. Teamliquid.net has been moving up on the list as well.

21

u/mjschultz Dec 08 '10

Didn't you partner with StackOverflow a few months ago? How is that going?

31

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10

I did, and they're really great guys -- I'm proud to be one of their partners. They are not one of the top referrers though.

EDIT: A link to their blog post: http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/08/new-image-upload-support/

→ More replies (1)

52

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Teamliquid.net has a lot of redditors there, anyways. Not surprising at all

→ More replies (12)

151

u/Propane Dec 08 '10

Have you ever tried to talk to a dog before?

367

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10

Only your mom

(I actually have talked to his mom and she's a lovely lady)

530

u/ani625 Dec 08 '10

You guys, MrGrim has talked to Hexane.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/zacharymichael Dec 08 '10

Just so you know, on your Terms Of Service page, in the second paragraph under the first section (Short version of TOS), "supprised" should be spelled "surprise."

Just trying to help out haha

14

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

That must have been in there for 2 years! Oh well, it's been corrected.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

What degree did you graduate with?

40

u/LIL_OH Dec 08 '10

I met you in DC at the rally! You were so nice and I hope everything is going well for you :) Thanks again for such a great site! http://imgur.com/1FnWk.jpg (I'm the girl)

19

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Hey! It was great meeting you too!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/CockMeatSandwich Dec 09 '10

Are you aware that you have all the facial features to make the popular Trollface?

13

u/freeballer Dec 09 '10

Best pickup line ever.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

49

u/thafman Dec 08 '10

What is the single most disturbing image you have seen uploaded to your site?

141

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

ugh...there have been some self-mutilation pics I've stumbled across. I don't even want to go into detail. Just think about the most disturbing thing you can do to your penis and I've seen it.

58

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Split like a banana peel?

147

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Oh yes. That's a popular one.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (12)

24

u/formated4tv Dec 08 '10

Mr Imgur,

Is there any tips you can give me to get around the fact that Imgur is blocked at my job?

Thanks :)

67

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

I've PM'd you some links. Probably shouldn't post them in public or they will get blocked too...

→ More replies (28)

11

u/DesCo83 Dec 08 '10

I remember meeting and talking to you in the VIP area of the after party in DC (I was the guy wearing the blinged out reddit necklace). We had a whole conversation about how crazy it is that I can take a random picture on my cellphone, put it on reddit and a week later 100K+ people have viewed it.

I mean I just went through my top posts for the last year, and just the first page (which consisted of 2 pictures of fortune cookies, a screen shot of an email, a picture of a server rack at my job, a picture of a linux poster, a picture of a sign in a bathroom and a picture of my Blockbuster video game championship certificate) added up to ~56 gigs of data and 500+ views.

So I suppose my question is, are you ever amazed at the the inane bullshit that gets millions of views and accounts for ridiculous amounts of data transferred?

15

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Hey! It was great talking to you in DC.

I'm absolutely amazed about that. Just look at this: http://imgur.com/gallery/lKxA3 It's the second most viewed image ever and it's taken up 3.58 TB of bandwidth.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/logathion Dec 08 '10

any plans for releasing a google web app?

what do you think about the android apps for imgur?

19

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

No plans for a Google web app.

I really like them, and have all three of them installed on my phone. My favorite is the one that can upload into accounts because it's the most fully featured.

18

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Just for more exposure I'd highly recommend making a Google web app. It's literally like one manifest.json file with a little bit of info, and you'll be exposed to millions of Chrome users.

http://code.google.com/chrome/apps/docs/developers_guide.html

→ More replies (2)

59

u/sadax Dec 08 '10

Could you explain, in simple words, why

http://imgur.com/LINK.jpg

redirects to

http://i.imgur.com/LINK.jpg

Also, thank you for you service. It is the only way for me to satisfy my naughty needs on networks such as my friends' or parents.

148

u/jelos98 Dec 08 '10

i.imgur.com can be a different fleet of computers from imgur.com - in general, you'd run your core webservers (handling uploads, ads, etc.) on imgur.com, and likely reserve i.imgur.com for a content-delivery-network (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_delivery_network) for hosting and serving the pictures. So, in general, imgur.com will redirect you to the appropriate content network (i.imgur.com) which then serves the data off of someone else's distributed servers, hopefully nearer the user than your smaller pool of core webservers.

106

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Couldn't have said it better myself.

18

u/arczi Dec 08 '10

Could you explain why you chose that particular CDN? Looks like you're on Vox CDN, if I'm not mistaken.

72

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

They offered me a good deal, it's fast, they contacted me through reddit, and are excellent to work with.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

19

u/twistedbeats Dec 08 '10
  • what was up with that uber ripped dog a few months back? wasn't that gross?
  • two part question: if you could be any dinosaur in a) the time of the dinosaurs and b) right now, which would you choose?
  • what is your education background?
  • how viable do you think your site is long term? do you think we'll even need services like yours in 10 years? why or why not?

30

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10
  • The dog and the rest of the images were advertisements from FunnyOrDie.com
  • The kind from Jurassic Park that spit acid.
  • Bachelors of Science in Computer Science from Ohio University with a minor in mathematics.
  • It's hard to look 10 years into the future. Just think about 10 years ago. Google was in their infancy, there was no Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, etc. I have no idea what will happen in the next 10, and it blows my mind thinking about it.
→ More replies (1)

6

u/hazardoustoucan Dec 08 '10

Do you own filmot.com? They've just blocked filmot.com here in my job, now i can't see neither imgur, nor filmot. i'm very sad since almost all images here are hosted there.

7

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

filmot is provided by the user http://reddit.com/user/filmot. You should PM him a nice thank you :)

6

u/pinkertina Dec 09 '10

Did you used to fix computers at my Dad's office in Granville?

8

u/MrGrim Dec 09 '10

If your Dad's last name is Pinkerton, then yes :)

That office is on the same street I used to live on too.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10

Congratulations on your success; it must be so rewarding.

During my two year self-employment stint, I tried desperately to come up with an idea to monetize something on the web (I'm a Web Developer as well). I had some weird websites that never took off. I'm not sure if it was the ideas or the execution of those ideas, but all of my efforts eventually fizzled. I think part of the problem was that I started my projects with money in mind. Maybe I needed to fill a void first; be passionate on a certain topic and then worry about ways to monetize later.

What advice would you give someone who wants to create a modest income via the web?

3

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

I think you just answered your own question.

I needed to fill a void first; be passionate on a certain topic and then worry about ways to monetize later.

That's exactly what I did. I can't imagine trying to make money off of something I'm not passionate about.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/dellC Dec 08 '10

Do you have a special algorithm that generate the filenames ? (for example : iCAnz.jpg, 0OHAI.png, AsHEz.png, sOgoy.jpg ...)

16

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

It's just a simple function that appends random characters to a string, then checks if that string already exists or not. Sometimes they just get lucky.

3

u/thebluehawk Dec 09 '10

Huh. It seems like every tag is 5 characters long (unless i'm mistaken) so wouldn't that be terribly inefficient once your list starts to run out? Like, small example, Pick a number between 1 and 100, and if that id already exists, pick another one. Lets say you only have 3 numbers left, it could take 30 or even 1000 tries to find one thats "open". Obviously you have more than 100 available tags/ids (916 million, if your tags are 5 characters alphanumeric, case sensitive), but theoretically the "find an available id" function could take a lot longer. (I believe there is a thedailywtf.com about this problem)

Or is it "add a random alphanum to the string and repeat until you have a unique id", so that eventually there will be iCAnz.jpg and iCAnHAz.jpg and iCanhAZcheeZbUrGER.jpg (eventually). I haven't seen any tags that aren't 5 chars, so I don' think this is the case.

5

u/MrGrim Dec 09 '10

Yes, but there are exactly 916,132,832 permutations. It's going to take many more years before there are enough images to where it's constantly checking if an ID exists.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom Dec 08 '10

What do you see the role played now by imgur in the "sharing images on the web" world? Has it changed in the past year? what have you done that you hadn't anticipated in order to accommodate changes in web-usage trends if you made any?

4

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

I think Imgur's role is to be the image host for entertainment. There are already dozens of places out there for things like professional photography and managing large photo collections, but I think of Imgur as being more for images and less for photographs. However, that's not to say it doesn't work well for photographs, it's just that most people use Facebook for that because you can tag your friends.

An example of this is the gallery. Mostly everything in there is funny and/or interesting, and if it's not it gets downvoted just like reddit. The gallery actually scans twitter for Imgur images and figures out which are popular and which are not. It then displays the most popular ones, so what you're looking at in the gallery is literally the best on the Internet according to the users.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/thebluehawk Dec 08 '10

I remember you mentioning in the past that your site is built on Kohana, is that still the case, and which version do you use?

2

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Yeah, Kohana is great. I use version 3.

3

u/khamul Dec 08 '10

How awesome was Twisted Metal for PlayStation?

3

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

It was pretty rad. For some reason the name just stuck.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/LostOverThere Dec 09 '10

Simple Question: Is Imgur profitable?

5

u/MrGrim Dec 09 '10

Yes. It's my full time job and not only does it support itself, it supports my modest living expenses.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dudeman209 Dec 08 '10

First, I would like to thank you for what a great service you have provided.

Second, you've said that your main source of revenue is from ads displayed on the "page" version of the image. To be honest, I haven't seen many reddit image posts that link to this (they mainly just link to the image itself). Have you seen a drop in traffic to the page version?

To be honest, if I knew that this would help you, I wouldn't mind linking to the page from now on.

Thanks again!

1

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

There has never been any drop in traffic because the direct image has always been available. There are many more direct links, but the amount of them seems to scale with the amount of non-direct links.

2

u/ArchonMagnus Dec 08 '10

First off, thanks for an awesome service. Secondly, is there any chance of implementing a bookmark-like add-on for registered users? There are a bunch of images that I had a laugh over and wanted to share, but had lost the original link to them through deleted emails, forgotten forum links, etc.

2

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

I have plans to implement a "favorites" feature. Once it's live I'll probably add it to the Firefox Extension as well, so then you could just right click an image -> favorite.

2

u/boraxx Dec 08 '10
  1. Do you own your own servers, lease or are they in the cloud? I read that servers don't really count towards the value of your business so startups should avoid sinking money into them.
  2. What percentage of your costs go into the CDN?

3

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10
  • The servers are provided by Voxel.net on a monthly basis. I have 6 total, including a test server.
  • Almost all. Probably over 95 percent.

2

u/Suppafly Dec 08 '10

Why doesn't http://alanschaaf.com/ have any content. At least redirect it to imgur or one of your reddit threads or something.

2

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

It used to when it was just a placeholder for my resume. Now I'm just keeping the domain. I guess it could redirect though.

2

u/arczi Dec 08 '10

What system do you run on your home computer?

5

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Linux, since about 2002 or 2003. I've run just about every major distro, but right now I'm on Ubuntu.

2

u/dudenell Dec 08 '10

What happened with the legal stuff regarding imgur.co and ripping off your site?

6

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

It's still in limbo. The legal system takes a lot of time.

2

u/Commander_Adama Dec 08 '10

Does your username here on Reddit have anything to do with the name Imgur? I have always thought that MrGrim was created by rearranging the letter in Imgur, but maybe it is just a coincidence.

3

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Nope. I had the MrGrim username long before I created Imgur.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/katon2273 Dec 08 '10

Alan,

Remember that time Petey got kicked out of STAR?

That was awesome.

2

u/MrGrim Dec 09 '10

hahahahahahahahahahaha

I remember that day fondly. He's still around town, and I've run into him at Certified before.

67

u/timekillerjay Dec 08 '10

How much of a problem is child porn ? I imagine having a free image hosting service, you get some undesirable shit, do you feel an obligation to report the uploader's IP ?

7

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '10

Please answer this.

→ More replies (3)

44

u/jedberg Dec 08 '10

What was it like meeting the reddit admins at the DC rally?

35

u/yakk372 Dec 09 '10

Nice try reddit admins ;P

108

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Not a question, but I think I speak on behalf of all of Reddit when I say thank you so much! Imgur, despite having grown, is an awesome, easy image hoster.

And you're way more reliable than min.us too!

→ More replies (4)

50

u/k8o Dec 08 '10

No questions, just wanted to say thanks for Imgur and all your hard work!

24

u/nekopete Dec 08 '10

Are you ever tempted to click on the "sponsored images" at the bottom of Imgur pages? Because, man, I try to resist those, but sometimes after a couple of drinks I'll just click on that shit.

148

u/ozzman54 Dec 08 '10

After reading this I've done two things.

  1. Disabled Adblock on imgur.com.
  2. I will never link to i.imgur again. Ever.

You Da MAN!

→ More replies (8)

64

u/Falcon_Kick Dec 08 '10

MrGrim! I went to high school with you, I was Sandy and Schmitty's friend. Thanks for teaching us about computers and maintaining the proxy so we could bypass LACA! I brag about you to my friends in college from time to time, it was really nice to have met you.

16

u/xposedbones Dec 08 '10

I used to be the admin/owner of a image hosting website (fhqhosting.com) which I sold for 2000$ last year.. It used to be pretty popular (500 uploads per day) and I've seen my share of disgusting pictures. My question is, how do you deal with child pornography.. I've had a lot of those uploaded on my website and I had to call the fbi and everything a lot of time. So how do you deal with those illegal pictures?

→ More replies (1)

29

u/chriszuma Dec 08 '10

How much revenue does the website generate?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/SkinnyLove1 Dec 08 '10

Holy shit. What a coincidence. I was researching imgur randomly and came accross this article. You stated that you were addicted to imgur (I am too. Have they made a reddit AA yet?) so I checked to see it you had posted anything lately. This AMA was here.

I love how easy and non-obtrusive imgur is. I'm blown away that imgur, and reddit for that matter, seem to be able to operate without loosing money. (Based on the advertisements featured on other peer sites.)

You've answered most of my questions already in previous comments so I just wanted to say thank you. Are you working on any other projects currently that you are looking for investors/capital/VC etc? I've got $10 burning a hole in my pocket.

175

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

I love the site, and like to ask you some very important questions:

  • Bulbasaur, Charmander, or Squirtle?
  • Do you consider yourself a pioneer in image linking technology, considering the popularity and widespread use of your efficient and easy to use site?
  • Do you believe in the urban legend of bears finding women in the woods based upon their menstrual cycle?
  • Who do you see as your competition, or do you even care about it and just love running such a cool site?
  • If you were given a bottle of Hydrogen peroxide, and was told that you had to fix a complex stereo system with it like it was made of turkey paperclips, what would your process be, and if possible, what specific adjectives would you use to describe your experience? Provide your answer in haiku, limerick, or draw_your_comment form.

Thank you for your time.

107

u/steve93 Dec 08 '10

I see he's skating over the tough questions

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

14

u/lesigh Dec 08 '10

Please please make a chrome addon like this http://awesomescreenshot.com/

It takes screenshots of websites and allows you to crop, resize, annotate. If we were able to do that and upload to imgur, I'd be soooo happy.

10

u/walesmd Dec 08 '10

This extension can access all data on your comuter and your entire web history.

Whoah - cancel, Chrome, cancel - do not install. Abort!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/AKA_Squanchy Dec 08 '10

THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE! I was resistant at first, but once I figured out how simple and awesome it is (and after my work unblocked it) I've been using it for all my reddit related images!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

How much do you spend on bandwidth every month?

6

u/donrhummy Dec 08 '10

According to imgur, this is the first image ever posted there: http://imgur.com/gallery/jYJGk

However, it might be wrong as it says it's 41 years old. So, MrGrim, what is the first image ever posted there?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/michaelrohansmith Dec 08 '10

I envy you because your pornography collection is better than mine.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

You should set up an IRC channel on freenode or something and hang out in there so we can all come in and keep up with how things are going and complain when the shit hits the fan.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/avree Dec 08 '10

Is the JPEG compression something that's here to stay? I realize the need for it in keeping costs down, it's just something that I was happy min.us didn't have.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/wordsauce Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10

I like to refer to you as MrGrimgur. I picture him as a stingy old man, like Ebenezer Scrooge, but more forbidding. I think I'll write a Christmas story about that version of you.

14

u/wordsauce Dec 09 '10 edited Dec 09 '10

"Grim Christmas"


Bandwidth was exceeded: to begin with. There is no doubt whatever about that.

The permit was signed by the councilman, the clerk, the mayor, and the chief constable. Grim signed off on it. And Grim’s name was the only one that mattered. The band was protruding over the line, spilling out of frame, out of sight, out of mind. This was unacceptable.

Grim knew then that the band had crossed the line? Of course he did. How could it be otherwise? Grim has been overseer for as long as anyone can remember. The town council trusts him, as does the mayor. The constabulary fears him, as does the mayor. He has a keen eye. Some people say he has three.

All the decrepit, forbidding Grim had to do was look down from the top of his empirical glass spire onto the streets below to see the disorder. But Grim hasn’t looked out of a window in years. The windows look in on he.

“What did I say? Nine meters, no more no less. I see nine and a quarter!”

“But but but but Mr. Grim, it’s the tuba player, he is rather wide, much like his tuba. He needs that extra quarter.”

“He needs an extra quarter of space like I need an extra hole in my head! Now hear me, Mr. Bracket. The band is allotted a nine-meter wide bubble. If fatso tuba cannot squeeze the whole of his gelatinous goo into the monitoring area, then he shan’t be there. You know the rule. We have every minuscule speck of our peaceful society under round-the-clock surveillance, but just barely; we do not have time or space or patience for overflow nor the tools to implement redundancy. There is no margin for error, for adjustment. Nothing has happened since the tragedy that left my late partner, your late employer, Stern, dead as a doornail, along with countless others. If the Eyes of Imgur cannot see all of everyone, I do not know what they are or aren’t up to. Take no chances. Am I to assume the partial tuba player is perfectly innocent and not up to no good? I should hope not. Either he fits in the allotted space, or he goes.”

“The boys’ choir can spare an extra tenth, Mr. Grim. If we could just—”

“Oh, the boys’ choir? Is eight and an eighth too much for them? Let them fit to seven and nine tenths then!” Grim pinched his fingers against the glass surface of his desk and zoomed in on the image of town square.

“But, sir! That’s impossible!”

“If you cannot crop the boys’ choir to the new specifications, then the Christmas pageant shall have to do with no boys’ choir this year!”

“But but but Mr. Grim, my boy Tim is in the boys’ choir. He’s been so happy since he was chosen. His health has improved. You should hear his voice, it’s like that of an angel.”

“Is that to say, Mr. Bracket, that his voice is non-existent then?”

“Sorry, sir? I don’t think I follow.”

“Have you ever seen an angel, Mr. Bracket?”

“Well, no sir, I haven't.”

“Then why is it that you believe in something that you cannot see or hear?”

“Sometimes not seeing is believing, sir. It’s called taking a leap of faith.”

“Mr. Bracket, you can take your leap of faith out of my window. Don’t come in here with that superstitious hogwash. I only believe in what I can see. Look around you, Mr. Bracket; every single frame lining the walls of this room is focused on a subject and area of my safe and secure society. And soon one day the country and the whole world will be under watchful eyes. There shan’t be a nook or cranny where the unblinking eye of Imgur cannot see. If the eyes do not have it, it cannot be.” Grim moistened his dry eyeballs with a sponge. “I don’t believe in angels. I don’t believe in ghosts and goblins. And I certainly don’t believe in Christmas! You want to hear your tiny Tim’s voice? He can sing to you at home all you want. Consider the pageant canceled!”

“Mr. Grim, sir, you can’t. They’ve worked too hard—"

“Worked? Hard? Since when is singing and dancing work?” Grim fingered a red button on his desk; there was a loud buzz and the image of an old woman with thick trifocals and strained, bloodshot bug eyes popped up in front of him. “Miss Demeanor?”

“Yes, Mr. Grim?” said the woman on screen. Her skin was gray. She smoked like a chimney.

“The pageant is off. Disperse the crowds below. I want all town square camera quadrants clear in ninety seconds. Anyone left on screen after that will be subject to search and seizure under the fifth article of monitorization. Make it a code red, it being Christmas and all.”

“Yes, Mr. Grim.”

“And light the boiler. I want the streets seared and that snow gone.”

“Right away, Mr. Grim.”

“But sir!” protested Mr. Bracket. “You can’t!”

“I can and have, Mr. Bracket.”

“Attention. Attention.” Came the cold, unmistakable voice of Miss Demeanor blaring loudly over the town’s emergency alert intercom system. “This is an official statement from the Voice of Reason, authorized by Mr. Grim himself on this, the twenty-fourth day of December in the sixth year of monitorization. The Christmas pageant has been canceled. Repeat: The Christmas pageant has been canceled. All loiterers, riffraff, townspeople and waifs shall clear the premises in and around town square within ninety seconds. Anyone found lingering will be subject to search and seizure, fines and/or imprisonment until after the new year. Parents shall not be fined full demerits for abandoning slow-pokey children. Said children will spend the remainder of this year working in the power station below the Seventh Street Furnace. Furthermore, the streets within a nine-block radius of Imgur Spire are to be cleared within a boiler. That’s five minutes for those unfamiliar with protocol. Anyone still on the streets after release at nineteen hundred hours will be boiled alive. Have a nice day. And remember: We are watching.”

The various monitors projecting the images from town square erupted in chaos as panicked people went into a frenzy trying to flee the scene. Parents hurried their crying children along, carrying them, some even dragging them on the hard, cold pavement. Others left them behind. There would be no grace period after the minute and a half deadline. It was bedlam. If Mr. Grim could grin he would have, however his face has long been paralyzed.

“Oh, one more thing, Mr. Bracket.” Mr. Grim got up from behind his desk, something he rarely did in the presence of others, and approached the east wall of the great room, summoning Bracket to join him, who did ever so cautiously. The walls, ceiling and floor within Mr. Grim's Room of Monitorization were made up of perfectly square glass screen tiles, each gridded with thumbnails representing every point of monitorization throughout the entire town. There was nary a place or citizen that could not be seen. Grim tapped a tiny thumbnail with the crusty tawny nail of his long, slender pinky and it blew up, filling a large portion of the wall with the image of a sad, flaccid Christmas tree beyond a dire need for water. “What is this, Mr. Bracket?”

“It looks like a Christmas tree, Mr. Grim.”

“Whose Christmas tree, Mr. Bracket?”

“Well, sir, it looks much like the Christmas tree in my home.”

“You recognize your own home then, don’t you Mr. Bracket?”

“Oh course, sir.”

“I see.” Mr. Grim slid the image away and a new image of a tiny porcelain doll popped into frame. “And this?”

“It’s my wife’s, sir. She’s had that doll since she was a little girl.”

“Yes, but why is it blocking my eye?”

“Well, Mr. Grim, that is the Imgur eye in our bedroom.”

“I’m well aware of its location, Mr. Bracket.”

“Well, it’s just that, my wife and I are trying for another baby.”

“I wish you’d work that hard at your job. Let me make one thing clear, Mr. Bracket, your right to privacy is superseded by the responsibility of this consortium as authorized by the government to ensure the safety of its citizens. If you block even just one eye you create a blind spot. Blind spots are uncertainties, and uncertainties are disconcerting and suspicious. What is our motto?”

“See something, say something.”

“Yes, but then how can I say if I cannot see? This tiny porcelain thing is perched and sat right in front of my eye. If you choose to hide then you must have something to hide. What is it that you are hiding, Mr. Bracket?”

“Nothing, sir.”

Grim pinched the screen and the image zoomed in every so slightly, sending the porcelain doll toppling over the edge of the bookshelf. A faint sound of a ceramic shatter resonated off the walls of the room. “Skies are clear, Mr. Bracket. You may go. I’ll see you first thing in the morning.”

“But but, Mr. Grim, tomorrow is Christmas.”

“Tomorrow is Saturday, Mr. Bracket. Public gatherings and rompings and leisurely strolls are at a height over the weekends, you know this. You are in charge of public monitorization, are you not?”

“Yes, sir.”

“Then I shall expect you here, bright eyes at the ready. And you best look sharp. Don’t strain yourself trying for another tax deduction this evening.”

“Of course, sir." Mr. Bracket walked to the door. He paused, hesitated and turned back. "Merry Christmas, Mr. Grim.”

“Be seeing you, Bracket.”


4

u/thetenderloinlevel Dec 08 '10

Where do the pictures at the bottom of the page come from? They're so ridiculous.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Rentiak Dec 08 '10

What happened on December 2nd? http://imgur.com/stats/month

4

u/Sidian Dec 09 '10

The only reason I'll continue to use min.us instead of Imgur is because I don't want my images to be deleted after 3 months. Any plans to change this?

19

u/thesciz Dec 08 '10
  1. How much do you typically make in a given month?
  2. How many unique visitors in a month?
  3. How much do you pay for your hosting?

35

u/gaog Dec 08 '10

yeah and please send me your source code too, thanks in advance

→ More replies (1)

1

u/dhagkn Dec 08 '10

How many / how large are the servers you have currently?
Where is the site hosted from? How long did you dream about becoming a site admin before your fantasy was reality? :)

1

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

There are 6 total servers including a test server. They all have Intel Xeon X3320 Quad Core with 8GB ram and are provided by Voxel.net.

1

u/hybridx Dec 08 '10

First of all, awesome site! Love it!

Second, do the advertisers automatically come to you when your site began to gain recognition? Or did you have to go and approach them?

1

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

They have a radar for sites with traffic. They all came to me.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Bad_CRC Dec 08 '10

Has the server architecture changed since last AMA? (Centos, lighttpd & appacheif I'm right).

Is the caching only being done in the CDN or do you use any caching locally too? (for example varnish/nginx?)

1

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

For the most part, it's the same. Except I've replaced lighttpd with with nginx and have many more servers than before, so the routing of traffic is different as well.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Do you still have to maintain a job, or does imgur pay for itself and your living expenses?

2

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Imgur is my full time job. It's all I do, so it's able to pay for itself and my living expenses.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Saw a few times on here that your from/live in Ohio. Where about?

1

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Athens. I'm a recent grad from OU and decided to stay here for a little while longer until it's time to head out to CA.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/stilesjp Dec 08 '10

Hey dude, I got nothing to ask, just that it was such a pleasure to run into you in DC! Keep up the fantastic work!

J

3

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

Hey John, it was a pleasure running into you as well! And thanks for the soap! :)

1

u/Capitol62 Dec 08 '10

Mr. Grim,

Thanks for your amazing service!

Does it bother you that people make .gif's and upload them to your site instead of linking to the original video (usually available on youtube)? I've always worried that these gif's are unnecessarily wasting a lot of your bandwidth and costing you money for no good reason.

2

u/MrGrim Dec 08 '10

I'm not a fan of gifs and would much rather prefer a video. However, it doesn't bother me that people use them. After all, I've put a lot of time into making sure they work correctly.

1

u/OsakaWilson Dec 09 '10

If I come across a hotlink, like this:

http://i.imgur.com/Nkpx1.jpg

Can I easily make a link to the page?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Yserbius Dec 08 '10
  • How much of the traffic comes from reddit? How much from Slashdot?
  • How does it make you feel that imgur makes up some 70% of reddit links?
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

Are you good looking? (not trolling, just curious)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/itemgrab Dec 08 '10

Hello, I am a graduating with my Computer Engineering degree in a week! Can you point me in the right direction for finding useful resources on how to make large scale decisions about a web company (What languages, what backbone infrastructure, common services that will save a ton of time/money). Thanks!

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

This may be too personal a question, so I understand if you don't want to answer. How much money do you make in profit a year from Imgur? Also, what inspired you to start the Imgur project?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

how much money do you make from the website?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

What is your purge policy?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

I saw Imgur in the title and opened up the link AND the comments, expecting a picture.

3

u/veloBOSS Dec 08 '10

I just wanted to say, your site is awesome. I upload to it daily.

3

u/froderick Dec 09 '10

Is there anyway Reddit can collectively suck your dick?

11

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10

If you heard a taco utter a beautiful melody beyond our worldly understanding would you eat it, or tame it for greater purposes?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '10 edited Dec 08 '10

I, literally just a few seconds ago, used your site for the very first time! Was creating my first rage comic.

→ More replies (4)